Employment law

Dyer v Five Forty Aviation Limited [2026] KEELRC 14820 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E547 of 2022
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the claimant/Decree Holder’s Notice of Motion dated 15th June 2026, brought under section 3 of the Employment & Labour Relations Court Act and Order 22 Rule 48(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. It seeks the following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the Notice of Motion, the supporting Affidavit, the Grounds of Opposition, the Replying Affidavit and the written submissions, the main issues for determination are:-

Paragraph 10 →

Reasoning passage

Having considered the above provisions of the law, I find no difficulties in finding that a decree of the court can be executed through attachment of a judgment debtor’s property, whether held in his name or in the name of another person provided the property belongs to the judgment debtor and he has the power of disposal. Such property includes shares held by the judgment debtor in another company.

Paragraph 17 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the decree-holder’s motion was incompetent because it sought execution concerning Three Forty Investments Limited, a non-party; and whether prohibitory and inhibition orders should issue against shares held by Donald Earle Smith and property…

Material facts

Stirling Dyer obtained judgment against Five Forty Aviation Limited for unlawful termination and unpaid salary, allowances and terminal dues. A decree was issued on 21 September 2023 and costs were certified at Kshs. 2,552,755.47. The corporate veil was later…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 29th October 2026)

CAUSE NO. E547 OF 2022

STIRLING DYER ………………..………..…………………………....CLAIMANT

VERSUS

FIVE FORTY AVIATION LIMITED ….…………………………..RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. This ruling relates to the claimant/Decree Holder’s Notice of Motion dated 15th June 2026, brought under section 3 of the Employment & Labour Relations Court Act and Order 22 Rule 48(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. It seeks the following orders: -

a) That a Prohibitory Order do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment-Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director one DONALD EARLE SMITH, any person acting on his instructions, behalf or under his control including agents, servants, nominees, related entities and proxy companies from selling, transferring, charging, pledging, assigning, alienating, diluting or otherwise dealing with any and/or all shares, shareholding rights, voting rights and beneficial interests held directly or indirectly by the 2nd Judgment-Debtor/Respondent in THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED registered under Company Number C.82309.

b) That an Order of Inhibition do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment-Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director one DONALD EARLE SMITH from transferring, charging, leasing or in any other way dealing with all that property known as L.R No. 1159 Title No. I.R 87135 belonging to THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED.

c) That a Prohibitory Order do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment-Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director from dealing with the shares in THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED.

d) That an Order of Inhibition do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment-Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director from dealing with the property known as L.R No. 1159 Title No. I.R 87135.

e) That a Vesting Order do issue under Section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act, vesting the said shares in the Decree-Holder/Applicant or such Court appointed officer, nominee or receiver as the Court may direct.

f) That the Registrar of Companies be directed to register the transfer of the said shares in accordance with the Vesting Order.

g) That the Court be pleased to grant a date for the settlement of terms for realization, including valuation and sale of the attached shares and the immovable property.

h) That the costs of this Application be borne by the Judgment-Debtor/Director.

2. The Motion is supported by the claimant’s Affidavit sworn on 15th June 2026 and it is opposed by the respondent through Grounds of Opposition dated 20th July 2026 and a Replying Affidavit sworn on 20th July 2026 by Donald Earl Smith. The Application was disposed of by written submissions.

Facts

3. The Decree-Holder/Applicant instituted a suit against the Judgment-Debtor/Respondent for unlawful termination and failure to pay salaries, allowances and other terminal dues and a Judgment was entered in his favour on 21st September 2023 by Ocharo, J. A Decree was issued on 21st September 2023 and a Certificate of Costs was issued on 1st February 2024 in the sum of Kshs. 2,552,755.47.

4. On 20th May 2025, Keli, J allowed the Decree-Holder's Application to lift the corporate veil and held the Director, Donald Earle Smith, personally liable to satisfy the Decree. Subsequently, warrants of arrest were issued and the Director was arrested and presented before Court on 22nd July 2025.

5. On 22nd July 2025, the Court adopted a Consent Order whereby the Director committed to pay Kshs. 200,000 towards the decretal sum and Kshs. 100,000 towards legal fees on or before 30th July 2025. He was then released on a personal bond of Kshs. 10,000,000. On 8th October 2025, the Court issued fresh warrants of arrest and ordered the Judgment Debtor to be committed to civil jail for 30 days.

6. On 15th June 2026, the Decree-Holder/Applicant filed the instant Notice of Motion. The Applicant avers that the decretal sum remains unsatisfied to the tune of Kshs. 17,804,000.00 and USD 298,139.20, and legal fees of Kshs. 1,516,437.80. He states that the Director is a dual citizen of the UK and Kenya and a flight risk.

7. The Applicant further states that the Director is the controlling shareholder and director of THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, which is the registered proprietor of L.R No. 1159 Title No. I.R 87135. He alleges that the company is a proxy and nominee vehicle used by the Director to hold assets and evade execution. The Applicant seeks preservatory orders and a Vesting Order to attach the shares and the subject property.

8. The Director opposed that request contending that it was an abuse of the process of the Court as it seeks orders against a property belonging to THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, a third party. He states that the company has a separate legal personality and no basis has been laid to lift its corporate veil.

9. The Director further avers that the Applicant failed to make full and frank disclosure. He deposes that he has made substantial payments, completing the legal costs of Kshs. 1,852,755.00 and paying Kshs. 550,000.00 towards the decree. He states that negotiations are ongoing and that the Application is speculative and unsupported by evidence. He asserts that the orders sought violate Articles 40 and 50 of the Constitution by condemning a non-party without a hearing.

Analysis and Determination

10. Having considered the Notice of Motion, the supporting Affidavit, the Grounds of Opposition, the Replying Affidavit and the written submissions, the main issues for determination are:-

a) Whether the Application is incompetent and improperly grounded against the property of a third party.

b) Whether the Applicant should be granted orders sought.

Whether the application is incompetent and improper

11. The respondent’s Director argues that the Application is misconceived as it seeks execution against THREE FORTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, which is not a party to the suit. The claimant contends that the application is provided for by the law.

12. The Applicant seeks to attach shares and property registered in the name of the respondent’s Director in another company called Three Forty Investments Limited, on the assertion that the company is a proxy or nominee vehicle.

13. The law applicable to attachment of property in execution of a Court decree is copied below. Section 44 of the Civil Procedure Act is the primary law and it provides that:

“(1) All property belonging to a judgment debtor, including property over which or over the profits of the which he has a disposal power which he may exercise for his own benefit, whether that property is held in his name or in the name of another but on his behalf, shall be liable to attachment and sale in execution of a decree;”

14. Order 22 Rule 40 (1) (a)(i) of the Civil Procedure Rules then provides:

“(1) In the case of –

(a) a share in the capital of a corporation; or

(b) other movable property not in the possession of the judgment-debtor,

for the attachment of which specific provision is not made by the these Rules the attachment shall be made by a written order prohibiting –

(i) in the case of the share, the person in whose name the share may be standing from transferring the same or receiving any dividend thereon: or

(ii) …”

15. Order 22 Rule 41 provides that: -

“where the property to be attached consists of the share or interest of the judgment-debtor in movable property belonging to him and another as co-owner, the attachment shall be made by a notice to the judgment-debtor prohibiting him from transferring the share or interest or charging it in any way.”

16. Further Order 22 Rule 48 then provides that: -

(1) where the property to be attached is immovable, the attachment shall be made by an order prohibiting the judgment debtor from transferring or charging the property in any way, and all persons from taking any benefit from such transfer or charge, and the attachment shall be complete and effective upon registration of a copy of the prohibitory order or inhibition against the title to the property.

(2) A copy of the order shall be affixed on a conspicuous part of the property.”

17. Having considered the above provisions of the law, I find no difficulties in finding that a decree of the court can be executed through attachment of a judgment debtor’s property, whether held in his name or in the name of another person provided the property belongs to the judgment debtor and he has the power of disposal. Such property includes shares held by the judgment debtor in another company.

18. In this case the court pierced the corporate veil and held the judgment debtor’s Director (Mr. Donald Earle Smith) personally liable to settle the decree. The director has partially paid the decretal sum but there is still a huge balance left outstanding. He has further admitted that he holds shares in another Company called Three Forty Investment Limited. According to the records of the said company filed, Mr. Smith holds 99% of the shares in Three Forty Investment Company and that is what the Claimant/Decree holder seeks to attach in execution of his judgment.

19. Applying the facts of the case to the various provisions of law cited above, I find and hold the application before the court for attachment of Mr. Smith’s shares in Three Forty Investment Limited is competent and properly before the court. The law cited above does not require that the company be given a hearing before attachment of the Judgment debtor’s shares.

Whether the orders sought by the motion should be granted

20. The Applicant relies on Order 22 Rule 41 of the Civil Procedure Rules for the Prohibitory Order and Order 22 Rule 48 for the Inhibition Order. The Applicant also relies on the case of Samuel Njeru Daniel -VS- James Njeru Nthiga & 2 Others [2017] KEELC 3312 (KLR), where the Court considered the basis of issuing an Inhibition Order, and held that the purpose of such an order is to preserve the property pending execution.

21. Having considered the facts of the case, I have no doubt that the Applicant has a valid and unsatisfied Decree against the Respondent’s Director Mr. Donald E. Smith and he has a legal right to execute the same by attachment of his shares in Three Forty Investment Company.

22. In Eagle Vet. Tech Co. Limited v Anthony Obidulu [2019] KEHC 5791 (KLR), the Court, relying on Order 22 Rule 40 (1) and (2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, held that a share in the capital. Kasango, J held:

“7. Order 22 Rule 40(1) and (2) provide that a share in the capital of a corporation can be attached in satisfaction of a judgment. Such attachment takes the form of a written prohibition order prohibiting a person who owns the shares from transferring the same or receiving dividends thereof.”

23. The claimant/decree holder has demonstrated that the respondent’s Director, Mr. Donald Earle Smith has shares in Three Forty Investment Limited, and he has failed to settle the decretal sum herein. Therefore, I find that the Claimant is entitled to the prohibitory and inhibition orders sought in his motion. However, the rest of the orders sought shall be considered once the said shares are secured.

Conclusion

24. In view of the foregoing matters, I find that the Application dated 15th June 2026 has of merits and make the following orders:

(a) That a Prohibitory Order do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director one Donald Earle Smith, any person acting on his instructions, behalf or under his control including agents, servants, nominees, related entities and proxy companies from selling, transferring, charging, pledging, assigning, alienating, diluting or otherwise dealing with any and/or all shares, shareholding rights, voting rights and beneficial interests held directly or indirectly by the 2nd Judgment Debtor/Respondent in Three Forty Investments Limited registered under Company Number C.82309.

(b) That an Order of Inhibition do issue restraining the 2nd Judgment Debtor/Respondent and/or its Director one Donald Earle Smith from transferring, charging, leasing or in any other way dealing with all that property known as L.R. No. 1159 Title No. I.R. 87135 belonging to Three Forty Investments Limited.

(c) Costs to the Claimant/Applicant.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Gomba for Claimant

No appearance for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder