Employment law

Degu v Workstyle Serviced Offices Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14798 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E585 of 2024
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The parties to the action had a fixed term employment contract whose term ran from 1st March 2022 to 28th February 2024. As evidenced by the contract, the Respondent hired the Claimant as Chief Executive Officer (CEO) in order for him to assist it (the Respondent) to expand its office space business in Kenya and beyond.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

The Respondent, as a body corporate, acts through its directors. In law, directors of a company have ostensible authority to make decisions which are binding on it (see Makate v Vodacom (Pty) Ltd (CCT52/15) [2016] ZACC 13; 2016 (6) BCLR 709 (CC); 2016 (4) SA 121 (CC) (26 April 2016)). As such, I find that the Respondent’s director had ostensible authority to make the offer to the Claimant, through its email of 15th April 2024, to pay…

Paragraph 49 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Claimant satisfied the contractual conditions for back pay under clause 5(b); whether he proved unfair labour practices; and whether the Respondent could obtain injunctive relief and damages under its counterclaim after the non-compete period…

Material facts

The parties’ fixed-term CEO contract ran from 1 March 2022 to 28 February 2024. It provided USD 1,000 monthly until the Claimant attained 250 occupied desks monthly, then USD 4,000, with additional benefits and the uplift payable when cash flow permitted and…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO E585 OF 2024

EBENEZER KASSAHUN DEGU…………………………….......CLAIMANT

VERSUS

WORKSTYLE SERVICED OFFICES LIMITED……...……RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Background

1. The parties to the action had a fixed term employment contract whose term ran from 1st March 2022 to 28th February 2024. As evidenced by the contract, the Respondent hired the Claimant as Chief Executive Officer (CEO) in order for him to assist it (the Respondent) to expand its office space business in Kenya and beyond.

2. Clause 5 of the contract provided that the Claimant was to be paid USD 1000 per month until he attained a minimum office occupancy rate of 250 desks per month. After this, his salary was to rise to USD 4000 per month.

3. In addition, the Claimant was to receive the following other benefits:-

a) Payment & processing support for a Kenyan work Visa;

b) Private health insurance;

c) Tax filing support; and

d) Return flight to Addis Ababa every three (3) months.

4. However, clause 5 (b) (v) of the contract provided that the above additional benefits (including the salary rise from USD 1000 to USD 4000) were to be paid to the Claimant with the approval of the Respondent’s directors once its cash flow permitted.

5. The Claimant contends that the Respondent paid him USD 1000 per month until in January 2023. However, he avers that the salary was increased to USD 4000 from February 2023 until March 2024.

6. The Claimant contends that in December 2023, he informed the Respondent that he wasn’t going to extend his contract beyond its sunset date of 28th February 2024. He contends that soon after he made this communication, the Respondent begun treating him unfairly. For instance, he alleges that the Respondent: cancelled some meetings he was meant to chair; removed him from its ORND system; reassigned his parking slot; refused to pay his back pay emoluments; and begun using other employees to insubordinate him.

7. The Claimant contends that at the close of his contract, the Respondent owed him USD 32,500 in back pay. He avers that these payments comprise the difference in his emoluments as set out in clause 5 (a) & (b) of the contract.

8. The Claimant asserts that he is entitled to be paid the amount because he met the conditions for the payment by exceeding the 250 desk space occupancy threshold and ensuring that the Respondent’s cash flow improved from February 2023. He for example contends that the Respondent’s operating incomes between February 2023 and September 2023 oscillated between Ksh. 900,000.00 and Ksh. 1,000,000.00.

9. The Claimant alleges that during negotiations between the parties regarding payment of the back pay, the Respondent offered to pay him USD 15000 which was approximately 50% of his entitlements. However, he contends that he requested that he be paid at least 75% of what was due to him, an offer which he says the Respondent did not react to. Hence the decision to institute these proceedings.

10. The Claimant thus prays for the following reliefs:-

a) Enforcement of clause 5(b) of the contract of employment dated 1st March 2022 with the consequence that judgment be entered in his favour for USD 32,500 to be exchanged in the Kenya Shilling denomination under the prevailing exchange rate.

b) Compensation for unfair labour practices.

c) General and exemplary damages on an aggravated scale for breach of contract.

d) Costs of the suit.

e) Interest on the amount to be awarded at court rates.

11. The Respondent has opposed the claim. Whilst admitting that the parties had an employment relationship, it (the Respondent) denies that it owes the Claimant any unpaid benefits under the contract.

12. The Respondent contends that the Claimant was expected under the contract to, inter alia, budget and manage the profitability and cash flows of its business in order to ensure growth of revenue. It further avers that the Claimant was expected to: manage its operational costs to appropriate levels; open at least five (5) locations in Nairobi; lead lease negotiations; undertake fund raising of debts, equity and grants; and undertake procurement and project management of contractors and vendors. In addition, it avers that the Claimant was to oversee the opening of two (2) new hubs in Lagos or Johannesburg or Cairo.

13. The Respondent avers that before the parties executed the contract between them, the Claimant proposed several key performance indicators which it accepted. It contends that these indicators were critical in setting the fixed and performance based compensation which was to be paid to the Claimant.

14. The Respondent contends that the Claimant was to receive salary of USD 1000 until he attained a sales threshold of 250 desks per month. Upon attainment of the threshold, it contends that the Claimant’s salary was to be increased to USD 4000. However, it avers that this variation in the Claimant’s terms was conditional on its cash flow permitting and the directors approving the payout.

15. The Respondent avers that pursuant to the contract between the parties, the Claimant was indeed paid USD 1000 per month between 1st March 2022 and 31st January 2023 since he had not attained the monthly office occupancy threshold of 250 desks. However, it avers that the amount was increased to USD 4000 from 1st February 2023 up to 29th February 2024 when the contract between them came to a close.

16. The Respondent avers that although the Claimant was paid USD 4000 from February 2023, some of the payments were based on misleading data which he supplied to give the impression that he had attained the 250 desk occupancy threshold when he in fact had not. The Respondent avers that the Claimant sometimes inflated the desk occupancy data by including information relating to non-paying clients. As such, it accuses him of fraudulently obtaining some of the payments.

17. The Respondent further contends that despite the Claimant’s assurances that he was capable of delivering on the agreed performance indicators, he failed to do so. For instance, it contends that he did not meet the cash flow projections which had been agreed on.

18. The Respondent asserts that because of the Claimant’s actions, it suffered loss of more than USD 13000 in bad debts. It contends that despite repeated requests to the Claimant to assist in recovering the debts, he was unwilling to do so.

19. The Respondent contends that it paid the Claimant fully for the months he attained the 250 desk occupancy threshold. As such, it denies that it owes him the money he claims.

20. The Respondent avers that the Claimant’s claim is founded on cash flow projections which did not translate into actual cash receipts. It contends that the Claimant is not entitled to rely on the projections to anchor the claim for payment.

21. The Respondent admits that the Claimant informed it of his intention not to renew his contract beyond February 2024. However, it denies that it subjected him to frustrations or unfair labour practices as he claims.

22. The Respondent acknowledges that the parties held meetings to discuss their separation. However, it contends that the discussions were conducted on without prejudice basis and did not yield any concrete agreements.

23. The Respondent has also filed a counter-claim. It avers that the contract between the parties had a confidentiality clause which prohibited the Claimant from disclosing information relating to its business either during the term of or after termination of the contract. It also avers that the contract had a non-compete clause which barred the Claimant from: taking up employment with the Respondent’s competitors or running the same business as the Respondent’s; requesting for business from any customer with similar business to the Respondent’s; soliciting for business which is similar to the Respondent’s; and enticing the Respondent’s employees to leave employment and join him or the Respondent’s competitor within one (1) year of termination of the contract between the parties.

24. The Respondent avers that the Claimant breached these provisions in the contract by taking up employment and sharing confidential information with KOFISI Africa within the non-compete period. As such, it contends that it has suffered loss and damage.

25. Consequently, the Respondent prays for:-

a) An order of injunction to restrain the Claimant from indirectly or directly owning, operating, consulting or taking up employment with serviced offices or co-working space businesses in Kenya or any country outside Kenya where the Respondent has serviced offices or co-working business within the contracted non-compete clause under the contract of employment.

b) An order of injunction to restrain the Claimant from requesting any customers of any business being conducted by the Respondent to curtail or cancel the business with the Respondent.

c) An order of injunction to restrain the Claimant from soliciting, canvassing or accepting any business or transaction for any other person, firm or corporation or business similar to the business of the Respondent from any past or existing customers of the Respondent.

d) An order of injunction to restrain the Claimant from inducing or attempting to influence any employee of the Respondent to terminate employment with the Respondent or to enter into employment or other business relationship with any other person, firm or corporation or acting or conducting himself in a manner which is contrary to the best interest of the Respondent.

e) Damages for breach of contract.

f) Costs of the counter-claim.

g) Interest on the damages sought and costs of the counter-claim at court rates.

26. The Claimant filed a response to the Statement of Defense and a Defense to Counter Claim. He reiterates the contents of his claim and denies that he breached the contract between the parties.

27. The Claimant further states that his compensation under the contract was anchored on fixed term remuneration and performance based remuneration. He relies on clause 5 of the contract to anchor his contention.

28. The Claimant alleges that the only condition which the contract set for him to be paid USD 4000 per month was the attainment of the 250 desk occupancy threshold. He denies that the contract required him to meet any other targets.

29. The Claimant denies that the data he provided regarding attainment of the desk occupancy threshold was falsified. As such, he denies the accusations of fraud against him.

30. The Claimant suggests that his role under the contract was limited to causing sale of office space. He denies that the contract required him to ensure that the clients he engaged paid for the space.

31. The Claimant acknowledges the presence of the confidentiality and non-compete clauses in the contract. However, he denies that he breached the clauses. It is his case that he adhered to the aforesaid terms as expected under the contract.

32. Both parties testified in court. They adopted their witness statements, produced their respective exhibits and were cross examined on their evidence. Thereafter, they filed their respective written submissions which the court has considered whilst writing this judgment.

Analysis and Determination

33. The position in law is that parties are bound by the terms of their contract and or agreement. Unless a contract is vitiated by fraud, mistake, coercion or undue influence, the court’s function is to give effect to the intention of the parties as expressed in the contract by enforcing its (the contract’s) terms (see Langat v Co-operative Bank of Kenya Ltd [2017] KECA 152 (KLR)).

34. The court has no right to re-write a contract between parties. It cannot introduce new terms to the contract. Neither can it construe the contract in a manner that is inconsistent with what the parties intended.

35. In the contract that gave rise to the instant litigation, the parties agreed that the Claimant was to be paid the difference in the entitlements between clause 5 (a) and 5 (b) in the contract subject to three conditions being satisfied:-

a) The Claimant attaining sales of 250 desk spaces in a month.

b) The Respondent’s cash flow improving.

c) The directors of the Respondent giving their approval for the payout.

36. In effect, payment of the difference between clause 5 (a) and 5 (b) was, by agreement of the parties, to be conditional on the three pre-conditions being met. As such, the court can only order payment of the amount claimed by the Claimant if there is evidence to demonstrate that the three conditions were satisfied. Any other order would be tantamount to the court re-writing the contract between the parties, a matter which the law does not countenance.

37. There is no doubt that the Claimant attained the threshold of 250 spaces per month. This is fortified by the fact the Respondent increased his monthly salary from USD 1000 to USD 4000. It is noteworthy that the shift in the Claimant’s pay from USD 1000 to USD 4000 was conditional on his attaining sales of 250 spaces per month.

38. Although the Respondent alleged that the data which the Claimant relied on to contend that he had attained the 250 desk space threshold was fraudulent, it (the Respondent) did not present cogent material to support this claim. As such and having regard to the evidence on record, the court is convinced, on a balance of probabilities, that the Claimant indeed satisfied the above threshold.

39. On cash flow, it is the Claimant’s case that the Respondent’s cash flow had significantly improved to justify payment of the amount he claims in the Memorandum of Claim. On the other hand, the Respondent contends that the Claimant has not tabled cogent evidence to support this assertion.

40. The Claimant has presented data to anchor his contention that the Respondent’s cash flow had improved. He contends that he accessed the data from the Respondent whilst he was still in its (the Respondent’s) employment.

41. Conversely, the Respondent avers that the data relied on by the Claimant has not been authenticated since it does not bear the signature of the author. The Respondent avers that absent such authentication, it is not possible to rely on the impugned information to arrive at the conclusion that its (the Respondent’s) cash flow had improved to warrant the Claimant’s claim for payment.

42. The court takes note of the fact that Respondent is ordinarily the one which is expected to be in possession of the data relating to its (the Respondent’s) cash flow trends. Consequently, the data is in law, presumed to be within the Respondent’s special knowledge (see section 112 of the Evidence Act).

43. The foregoing being the case, if there is a dispute regarding the status of the Respondent’s cash flow, it is the Respondent and not the Claimant to table evidence to resolve the controversy (see section 112 of the Evidence Act). As the court record shows, the Respondent did not present evidence to support its contention that its cash flow had not improved as asserted by the Claimant. All it (the Respondent) did was to make a bare denial that its cash flow had improved.

44. Importantly, the evidence on record shows that the parties were engaged in some negotiations to try and resolve the dispute. During the negotiations, the Respondent made an offer to pay the Claimant some amount over and above what it had been paying him under clause 5 (a) of their contract to cover the difference of payment which is contemplated under clause 5 (b) of the contract. The Respondent could not have made this offer if its cash flow had not improved. In the premises and having regard to the aforesaid evidence, the court is convinced on a balance of preponderances that the Respondent’s cash flow had indeed improved as asserted by the Claimant.

45. The other condition which was to be satisfied relates to the approval of payments by the Respondent. Even if the Claimant demonstrates that he had satisfied the first two conditions for payment, he still required the Respondent’s directors’ approval of the payout for it (the payout) to be effected.

46. The Claimant’s case is that the Respondent’s directors approved the payout. He relies on email correspondence between him and one of the Respondent’s directors to anchor his contention.

47. Conversely, the Respondent denies that its directors gave approval for the payout. Further, it contends that the email correspondence which the Claimant relies on to anchor his case was issued after the employment contract between the parties had come to a close. As such, it (the Respondent) asserts that the email cannot be relied on as proof of the director’s concurrence for the payout.

48. The Respondent contends that, in any event, the offer to pay the Claimant USD 15000 was made on a without prejudice basis and merely as an enticement to him (the Claimant) to assist it (the Respondent) to recover some outstanding debts. It further (perhaps in the alternative) alleges that the offer was merely intended to amicably close the dispute between the parties. As such, it contends that he is not entitled to claim the amount.

49. The Respondent, as a body corporate, acts through its directors. In law, directors of a company have ostensible authority to make decisions which are binding on it (see Makate v Vodacom (Pty) Ltd (CCT52/15) [2016] ZACC 13; 2016 (6) BCLR 709 (CC); 2016 (4) SA 121 (CC) (26 April 2016)). As such, I find that the Respondent’s director had ostensible authority to make the offer to the Claimant, through its email of 15th April 2024, to pay him USD 15000.

50. The Respondent asserts that the offer was made on a without prejudice basis. However, there is nothing in the email of 15th April 2024 to support this contention.

51. It would appear that the Respondent’s contention is founded on the contents of its email of 18th June 2024 to the Claimant. However, in the court’s ruling on the issue in the proceedings of 24th September 2025, it (the court) rejected this argument pointing out that the ‘’without prejudice’’ principle cannot be invoked retroactively to cover discussions which, prima facie, were not held on without prejudice basis.

52. The court has also considered the Respondent’s assertion that the offer to pay the Claimant USD 15000 was merely meant to entice him to assist it to pursue some outstanding debts and to amicably close the dispute between the parties. However, the email containing the offer does not suggest that it (the offer) was made for purposes of enticing the Claimant to assist the Respondent to recover its debts. As such, the contention by the Respondent in this regard is not persuasive and is declined.

53. The court notes that all that clause 5 (b) (v) of the contract between the parties required in order for the Claimant to be paid the impugned amount was the concurrence of the Respondent’s directors. There was no requirement that the concurrence be granted during the currency of the Claimant’s contract of service. As such, it does not matter that the concurrence was granted after the Claimant had ceased employment.

54. From the email correspondence on record, it is apparent that the Respondent’s director’s tacit approval for a payout to the Claimant was limited to USD 15,000. There was no approval for payment of a sum which is in excess of the aforesaid sum.

55. As pointed out earlier, the court cannot enforce a contract outside the terms which the parties to the contract had agreed on. As such, this court cannot compel the Respondent to pay the Claimant an amount which is in excess of what was approved by its (the Respondent’s) directors in terms of clause 5 (b) (v) of the contract between them. If the court was to order otherwise, that will be contrary to the terms of the contract between the parties. In effect, the court will have re-written the contract between the parties.

56. As stated earlier, whilst the Respondent’s director made a tacit approval for some payment to the Claimant, this was limited to USD 15,000. As such, the court can only enforce payment of the payout to the extent of the approval by the director, that is to say USD 15,000. In the premises, the court enters judgment for the Claimant against the Respondent but limited to USD 15,000 as sanctioned by the Respondent’s director in terms of clause 5 (b) (v) of the contract between the parties.

57. The Claimant alleges that the Claimant subjected him to unfair labour practices by: removing him from the ORND platform; cancelling some meetings which he was to have chaired; allowing other employees to insubordinate him; and giving out his parking space. As such, he prays for compensation for breach of his right to fair labour practices.

58. However, during cross-examination, the Claimant conceded that he was removed from the ORND platform after his contract had been terminated. He further conceded that the available records show that his parking slot was re-allocated after the contract between the parties was terminated. He also conceded that he had no evidence to back the contention that the Respondent permitted other members of staff to insubordinate him.

59. Having regard to the foregoing, the court finds that the Claimant has not presented cogent evidence to back the claim of unfair labour practices. As such, it (the court) declines to award damages for breach of the right to fair labour practices.

60. The Respondent has filed a counter-claim seeking the various orders which were set out earlier in the judgment. The counter-claim is anchored on the confidentiality and non-competition clauses in the agreement dated 1st March 2022.

61. A perusal of the non-compete clause shows that the non-compete agreement between the parties had a lifespan of one (1) year from the date of termination of the contract between them. The agreement was not to remain in force for a period that is in excess of one (1) year after closure of the contract.

62. According to the evidence on record, the contract between the parties lapsed on 28th February 2024. As such, the non-compete clause could only be enforced until 28th February 2025. The Respondent cannot seek to enforce it beyond this date. As such, the prayers in the counter-claim for orders of injunction to restrain the Claimant from acting in contravention of the requirements of the clause cannot issue, the validity period for the clause having lapsed.

63. The Respondent has further prayed for damages against the Claimant for breach of his obligations under the contract. It avers that the Claimant: breached the non-compete and confidentiality clauses in the agreement and acted dishonestly by including non-paying clients in his data in order to beef up the desk occupancy numbers for the months of December 2023 and January 2024. As such, it contends that he breached the terms of his contract for which it seeks damages.

64. The general position in law is that the relief of general damages is not available for breach of contract. As such, a party seeking damages for breach of contract must not only specify the nature of injuries he has suffered but also quantify and prove the resultant loss (Nyamweya v Asakania [2025] KEHC 1702 (KLR)).

65. The Respondent has not quantified and specifically proved the loss it alleges to have suffered as a result of the alleged breach of contract by the Claimant. In the premises, the court is not entitled to grant an order for damages in its favour.

66. Having regard to the foregoing, the court is left with little choice but to dismiss the counter-claim.

67. It is noteworthy that the Claimant had similarly prayed for general and exemplary damages for breach of contract. However, the court declines to grant this prayer for similar reasons advanced above, that is to say, the relief of general and exemplary damages is not available for breach of contract.

68. The amount awarded to the Claimant is subject to the applicable statutory deductions at the time the contract between the parties was closed.

69. The Claimant is awarded interest on the amount awarded at court rates from the date of this decision.

70. The Claimant is granted costs of the suit.

Summary of Findings and Award

71. After evaluating the pleadings, evidence and submissions by the parties against the applicable law, the court makes the following findings and attendant orders:-

a) The court finds that the Claimant has demonstrated that he satisfied the conditions in the employment contract to warrant the payout of USD 15000.

b) As such, it (the court) enters judgment in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent for the sum of USD 15000.

c) The court finds that the Claimant has not presented cogent evidence to back his claim for breach of his right to fair labour practices.

d) As such, it (the court) declines to award damages for breach of the right to fair labour practices.

e) The court finds that the non-compete clause in the contract between the parties had a lifespan of one (1) year post employment. As such, it lapsed on 28th February 2025.

f) That being the case, the orders of injunction which the Respondent seeks through the counter-claim based on the aforesaid clause cannot issue as they have been overtaken by events.

g) As such, the prayers for injunction in the counter-claim all fail.

h) The court notes that both the Claimant and Respondent have sought damages for breach of contract. However, the law does not recognize general damages as one of the reliefs which are available for breach of contract.

i) As such, the prayer by both the Claimant and the Respondent in this respect is declined.

j) The Claimant is awarded interest on the award at court rates from the date of this decision.

k) The award to the Claimant is subject to the statutory deductions which were in force at the time the contract between the parties was closed.

l) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Claimant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder