Employment law

Carolyn K Muumbo & Co Advocates v Onchwari [2026] KEELRC 14828 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Miscellaneous Application E004 of 2025
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court is a Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026 brought by the Respondent/client under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order (ARO), Article 50 and 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution, Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010, Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Procedure Rules and Section 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. The Application seeks the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the Chamber Summons Application dated 30th March 2026, the rival Affidavits and written submissions filed by both parties and is clear that the Advocate – Client Bill of Costs dated 9th January 2025 was taxed in the absence of the Client. The main issues for determination are as follows:-

Paragraph 10 →

Decision / orders

I have found that the Respondent/Client was duly served with the Bill of Costs and subsequent notices and ignored them. I have also found that he made the instant application after an inordinate delay which he did not satisfactorily explain. Accordingly, I dismiss the Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026 with costs.

Paragraph 28 →

Reasoning passage

Having considered the competing affidavits on the issue of service, I find that the Process Server's Affidavits of Service dated 24th January 2025 and 20th February 2025 remain unshaken in the absence of cross-examination. The Respondent/Client's mere denials are insufficient to rebut the presumption in favour of the Process Server. I therefore find that the Respondent/Client was duly served with the pleadings and notices herein.

Paragraph 23 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 29th October, 2026)

MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. E004 OF 2025

CAROLYN K. MUUMBO & CO. ADVOCATES …… APPLICANT/ADVOCATE

-VERSUS-

ENOCH NYAKUNDI ONCHWARI..............................RESPONDENT/CLIENT

RULING

Introduction

1. Before this Court is a Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026 brought by the Respondent/client under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order (ARO), Article 50 and 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution, Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010, Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Procedure Rules and Section 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. The Application seeks the following orders:-

a) That, at the first instance and pending the hearing and determination of this Application, this Honourable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the Certificate of taxation issued herein pursuant to the Ruling delivered on 6th March 2025.

b) That, this Honourable Court be pleased to enlarge time for filing a Reference under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order against the decision of the Taxing Officer delivered on 6th March 2025 and the resultant Certificate of Taxation dated 17th April 2025.

c) That, upon enlargement of time, this Honourable Court be pleased to admit the Applicant's Reference (this Application) herein for determination.

d) That, this Honorable Court be pleased to set aside the Certificate of Taxation dated 17th April 2025, and remit the Bill of costs dated 9th January 2025 for taxation de novo with full participation of both parties.

e) That, the cost of this application be provided for.

2. The application is supported by the Client’s Affidavit sworn by on 30th March 2026 and it is opposed by the Advocate vide her Replying Affidavit sworn by her on 28th May 2026 plus an Affidavit sworn on the even date by James Mbuvi, a process server. Thereafter the application was disposed of by written submissions. The Client’s submissions made reference to his Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 27th April 2026 but there is no such affidavit both in the court file or uploaded on the e-filing portal.

Facts

3. On 9th January 2025, the Applicant/Advocate (Carolyn K. Muumbo & Co. Advocates) filed an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs against the Respondent/Client (Enoch Nyakundi Onchwari) for legal fees arising from representation in Nairobi Employment and Labour Relations Cause No. 2036 of 2017, Enoch Nyakundi Onchwari -vs- The National Authority for the Campaign Against Alcohol and Drug Abuse (NACADA).

4. The Advocate contends that the Respondent/Client was personally served with the Bill of Costs dated 9th January 2025 and the Taxation/Hearing Notice dated 14th January 2025 on 23rd January 2025. She relied on the Affidavit of Service dated 24th February 2025 filed in Court on 6th February 2025 as proof of service.

5. She further contended that the Respondent/Client was served with the Mention Notice dated 19th February 2025 on 20th February 2025, as evidenced by the Affidavit of Service dated 20th February 2025 and filed on 28th February 2025. All the said Affidavits of Service were sworn by James Mbuvi, a licensed Court Process Server, who averred that he personally served the Respondent/Client with the said documents outside Kencom House on the respective dates, but refused to sign to acknowledge receipt.

6. The Respondent/Client denies ever being served with the said documents and contends that he was not at Kencom House or anywhere within Nairobi Central Business District either 23rd January 2025 or 20th February 2025 or any other stated dates. Therefore he contends that the Affidavits of Service by the process server are false and that the Applicant/Advocate deliberately misled the Court to enable her to tax the Bill of Costs ex-parte.

7. On 6th March 2025, the Taxing Master delivered the impugned Ruling on the Bill of Costs, taxing the same at Kshs.1,125,762.60 and a Certificate of Taxation was subsequently issued on 17th April 2025. The Respondent/Client states that he only became aware of the taxation months later when the Certificate of Costs was annexed to the Applicant/Advocate's Replying Affidavit dated 29th May 2025 filed in Disciplinary Tribunal Case No. 96 of 2024, which the Respondent/Client had lodged against the Applicant/Advocate. The said Replying Affidavit was served on 3rd June 2025 upon his advocates then, M/s Abidha & Co. Advocates.

8. On 26th November 2025, the Respondent/Client filed a Notice of Motion Application seeking to set aside the ex-parte taxation. The said application was struck out on 12th March 2026 for failing to comply with the provisions of Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order. Subsequently he filed the present Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026.

9. The Applicant/Advocate opposes the application on grounds that the Respondent/Client was duly served with all pleadings; that there has been inordinate delay in bringing the application; and that the application does not meet the requirements of Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order as it fails to set out the items of taxation objected to.

Issues for determination and analysis

10. I have considered the Chamber Summons Application dated 30th March 2026, the rival Affidavits and written submissions filed by both parties and is clear that the Advocate – Client Bill of Costs dated 9th January 2025 was taxed in the absence of the Client. The main issues for determination are as follows:-

a) Whether the court should enlarge the time for filing a reference to challenge the ruling of the Taxing Officer delivered on 6th May 2025 and the Certificate of Taxation dated 22nd May 2025

b) Whether the court should order stay of execution of the impugned certificate of taxation pending hearing and determination of the intended reference.

Enlarge the time for filing a reference

11. The law on enlargement of time to file reference is set out in Paragraph of the ARO which copied hereunder: -

“11. Objection to decision on taxation and appeal to Court of Appeal.

1. Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects.

2. The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a Judge by chamber summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection.

3. Any person aggrieved by the decision of the Judge upon any objection referred to such judge under subsection (2) may, with the leave of the judge but not otherwise, appeal to the Court of Appeal

4. The High Court shall have power in its discretion by order to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) or subparagraph (2) for the taking of any step; application for such an order may be made by chamber summons upon giving to every other interested party not less than three clear days’ notice in writing or as the Court may direct, and may be so made notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired.”

12. A reference against the decision of the Taxing Officer is an appeal to a Judge and the Supreme Court has laid down the principles to be considered by the court when faced with an application for enlargement of time for lodging an appeal. In Nicholas Kiplos Arap Korir Salat v. IEBC & 7 others (2014) eKLR the Court held that: -

i. “Extension of time is not a right of a party. It is an equitable remedy that is only available to a deserving party at the discretion of the Court;

ii. A party who seeks for extension of time has the burden of laying a basis to the satisfaction of the court

iii. Whether the court should exercise the discretion to extend time, is a consideration to be made on a case to case basis;

iv. Whether there is a reasonable reason for the delay. The delay should be explained to the satisfaction of the Court;

v. Whether there will be any prejudice suffered by the respondents if the extension is granted;

vi. Whether the application has been brought without undue delay; and

vii. Whether in certain cases, like election petitions, public interest should be a consideration for extending time.”

13. In the instant case, the main ground upon which the enlargement of time is sought is that the Respondent/Client was never served with the Bill of Costs, Taxation Notice, Mention Notice, or Ruling Notice, and that the Applicant/Advocate filed false affidavits of service upon which the Court relied on to tax the Bill of Costs in his absence. The Applicant/Advocate on the other hand contends that service was properly done and relies on the Affidavits of Service dated 14th March 2025 and 24th April 2025 sworn by James Mbuvi.

14. I have perused the Affidavit of Service dated 24th February 2025 and 20th February 2025 annexed to the Applicant/Advocate's Replying Affidavit and marked as "C.K.M. 1" and “C.K.M.1”(also annexed to James Mbuvi's Affidavit and marked as "J.M. 1" and “J.M. 1”). The Process Server deposed that on 23rd January 2025, he served the Respondent/Client with the Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 9th January 2025, and the Taxation Notice dated 14th January 2025, outside Kencom House along Moi Avenue, Nairobi. He further deposed that the Respondent/Client refused to sign and acknowledge receipt of the said documents.

15. I have also perused the Affidavit of Service dated 20th February 2025 annexed as "C.K.M. 2" (also annexed as "J.M. 2"). The Process Server deposed that on 23rd February 2025, he served the Respondent/Client with a Mention Notice dated 19th February 2025, again outside Kencom House along Moi Avenue, Nairobi and the Respondent/Client refused to sign and acknowledge receipt.

16. The Process Server, James Mbuvi, in his Affidavit sworn on 28th May 2026, confirms that he personally served the Respondent/Client on both occasions. He deposed that he is well familiar with the Respondent/Client because he had met him on several occasions in the offices of Carolyn K. Muumbo & Co. Advocates where he works, and the Respondent/Client used to call him through his telephone number in the years 2021, 2022 and 2023.

17. The Respondent/Client has not denied knowing the Process Server but he denies that he was at Kencom House on the alleged dates of service. He has also not denied that the telephone number 0722527392 used by the process server to contact him belongs to him.

18. On the issue of service, the Court of Appeal in the case of Shadrack Arap Baiywo -vs- Bodi Bach, [1987] KECA 69(KLR) cited and applied in Miruka -vs- Abok & another [1990] KLR 544, stated as follows:

"There is a qualified presumption in favour of the process server recognized in MB Automobile -vs- Kampala Bus Service [1966] EA 480 at p 484 as having been the view taken by the Indian courts in construing similar legislation. On Chitaley and Annaji Rao; The Code of Civil Procedure Volume II page 1670, the learned commentators say:

“3. Presumption as to service –There is a presumption of service as stated in the process server's report, and the burden lies on the party questioning it, to show that the return is incorrect. But an affidavit of the process server is admissible in evidence and in the absence of contest it would normally be considered sufficient evidence of the regularity of the proceedings. But if the fact of service is denied, it is desirable that the process server should be put into the witness box and opportunity of cross examination given to those who deny the service."

19. In the case of Dickson Daniel Karaba -vs- John Ngata Kariuki & 2 others [2010] KECA 470(KLR), the Court of Appeal stated:

"In view of all that evidence, it cannot be doubted that the process server was at the location of the office of the 1st respondent at the time he swore he was, the only issue being whether or not he met the 1st respondent there and served him. That issue in our view would have been cleared through cross examination of the process server who was available for that purpose but the 1st respondent’s advocates declined to cross examine him. We think in the circumstances of this case they did so at the risk of leaving unchallenged the process server’s disposition and there was no firm basis for disbelieving his evidence.

It is our view therefore that there was no firm basis for rejecting the affidavit of the process server …”

20. In Raphael Ngure Wangunyu v John Gacheru Ndehi & Edward Ndehi Kamau [2022] KEHC 12007 (KLR), the High Court at Kiambu relied on above decision to hold that: -

“Raphael needed to be reminded that there is a presumption in favour of the process server. Raphael needed to shift that presumption and that would have been done if he successfully discounted the evidence of the process server by cross examining him.”

21. In Jacinta Muthini Kavisi -vs- Mark Macharia, [2013] KEELRC 145(KLR)Cause Number 90 of 2012, Industrial Court at Nairobi, the Court found that the Process Server had properly established contact with the Respondent through his telephone number for purposes of effecting service and dismissed the application. The Court noted that:

“The Court is satisfied that the claimant served the respondent at various times and places indicated in the affidavits of service. The Respondent did not deem it necessary to cross examine the process server on any of the numerous affidavits of service, or the affidavit sworn in reply to the application by the process server.”

22. The legal principle emerging from the above decisions is that, the only way to discount the evidence of the Process Server is through cross-examination. In the present case, the process server filed several Affidavits of service deposing that he knew the respondent prior to serving him and how he contacted him through telephone number 0722527392. As noted above, the respondent has not denied that the said number belongs to him. He also did not provide any evidence to prove that he was not in Nairobi Central Business District on 23rd January 2025 and 20th February 2025 when the process server alleged to have met him personally and served him. The Process Server swore an affidavit in opposition to the Chamber Summons and confirmed his readiness to avail himself to court if required to clarify the contents of the disputed Affidavits of Service but Respondent/Client shied away from that opportunity.

23. Having considered the competing affidavits on the issue of service, I find that the Process Server's Affidavits of Service dated 24th January 2025 and 20th February 2025 remain unshaken in the absence of cross-examination. The Respondent/Client's mere denials are insufficient to rebut the presumption in favour of the Process Server. I therefore find that the Respondent/Client was duly served with the pleadings and notices herein.

24. On whether the Application was made without undue delay, the Respondent/Client in Paragraph 4 of his Supporting Affidavit sworn on 30th March 2026 states that he only became aware of the Certificate of Taxation when it was annexed in the Applicant/Advocate's Response filed at the Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal, months after the delivery of the impugned taxation ruling. The Applicant/Advocate in her Replying Affidavit sworn on 28th May 2026 at Paragraph 19 states that the Replying Affidavit containing the Certificate of Taxation was served upon the then Advocates for the Respondent/Client, M/s Abidha & Co. Advocates, on 3rd June 2025, as evidenced by the Receiving Stamp on the face of the said Replying Affidavit.

25. The Respondent/Client never took any steps towards challenging the Certificate of Costs from 3rd June 2025 and waited for a period of over Five (5) months to file the Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025, which was struck out on 12th March 2026 for being incompetent. He then filed the instant Application on 23rd April 2026, more than one year after the Ruling on Taxation was delivered by the Taxing Master on 6th March 2025.

26. In Cecilia Wanja Waweru -vs- Jackson Wainaina Muiruri & Another [2024] KECA 492 (KLR), the Court held that a delay of 40 days in taking action after knowledge of a fact was considered to be inordinate. The Court stated:

"There is no set rule as to what constitutes inordinate delay. Whether or not a party is guilty of inordinate delay depends on the circumstances of the case. We are of the considered view that the learned judge in considering the application should have looked at the appellant’s conduct from the time the appeal was filed up to the date the application for reinstatement was filed."

27. In the instant case, I find that the Respondent/Client has not satisfactorily explained the inordinate delay in bringing this Application. The Respondent/Client has not explained why he and/or his Advocates on record, M/s Abidha & Co. Advocates, waited for over Five (5) months after becoming aware of the Certificate of Taxation on 3rd June 2025, to take any action. The delay in filing the initial incompetent motion and the instant Application is therefore inordinate and unsatisfactorily explained.

Conclusion

28. I have found that the Respondent/Client was duly served with the Bill of Costs and subsequent notices and ignored them. I have also found that he made the instant application after an inordinate delay which he did not satisfactorily explain. Accordingly, I dismiss the Chamber Summons dated 30th March 2026 with costs.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Opini for Applicant/Claimant

Muumbo for Respondent/Client

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder