Employment law

Akera v Navigators Africa Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14808 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E594 of 2024
Judgment date
29 October 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant was employed by the respondent as an Administrative Assistant/Receptionist from January 2015 until May 2023 when her services were terminated by the respondent. Subsequently, she brought this suit vide a Statement of Claim dated 30th July 2024 alleging unlawful redundancy and sought the following reliefs:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

After the hearing, both sides filed written submissions to fortify their respective cases. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, there is no doubt that the claimant was employed by the respondent from January 2015 to May 2023 when her services were terminated by the respondent. The main issues for determination are:

Paragraph 23 →

Decision / orders

I have found that the claimant has proved that her employment contract was unfairly terminated by the respondent. However, in view of the binding clearance certificate signed by the parties herein after the termination on 6th September 2023, the claimant is estopped from making the claims sought in this suit. Consequently, I dismiss the suit but with no costs since the claimant was not estopped from suing the employer for the court to…

Paragraph 48 →

Reasoning passage

Section 45(2)(b) of the Act further provides that a reason for termination is fair if it relates to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility. In this case, there is evidence to prove that the claimant’s performance was not satisfactory and that was caused by lack of capacity, late reporting and lack of attention to details. In the circumstances of the case, I find that the reason for the termination was valid and fair.

Paragraph 35 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 29th October 2026)

CAUSE NO. E594 OF 2024

ALICE WASONGA AKERA …..………..………………………..…....CLAIMANT

VERSUS

THE NAVIGATORS AFRICA LIMITED..………………………….RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. The Claimant was employed by the respondent as an Administrative Assistant/Receptionist from January 2015 until May 2023 when her services were terminated by the respondent. Subsequently, she brought this suit vide a Statement of Claim dated 30th July 2024 alleging unlawful redundancy and sought the following reliefs:

(a) A declaration that the Claimant was unlawfully dismissed.

(b) A declaration that the Claimant was unfairly terminated.

(c) A declaration that the Claimant was entitled to housing allowance arising for the employment.

(d) An equivalent of one (1) month’s salary in lieu of the notice period = Kshs.137,295.

(e) Damages for unlawful and unfair termination (137,295 x 12 months) = Kshs.1,647,540.

(f) Unpaid severance pay (8) years/8 months’ salary (137,295/2 x 8 = Kshs.549,180.

(g) Unpaid housing allowance for the 104 months (104 x [137,295 x 15/100] = Kshs.2,141,802.

(h) Unspent leave of 168 days amounting to Kshs.772,380.

(i) Certificate of service.

(j) Interests in payments set out in (d), (e), (f), (g) and (h) above.

(k) Costs of the suit.

2. The respondent filed a Response to the Claim dated 23rd August 2024 admitting that it employed the claimant until May 2023 when it terminated her employment for challenges related to her capacity and work performance. It denied the alleged redundancy. It averred that the claimant was accorded a fair hearing before the termination and he raised no objection. It further averred that the claimant was paid all her terminal dues after the termination and she voluntarily signed a clearance certificate. It averred that a certificate of service was prepared and it has been ready for collection. Therefore, it prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.

Evidence

3. The Claimant testified as CW1. She adopted her statement dated 30th July 2024 as her evidence in chief and produced 13 documents as exhibits. In brief, her case was that she joined the respondent in the position of PMMI/Administrative Assistant/Receptionist in January 2015 and her starting salary was Kshs.76,500 per month exclusive of housing allowance.

4. She further stated that her contract was renewed and appraised several times due to her diligent performance. Her salary was also increased after every evaluation. In the semi-annual review of her performance on 31st March 2022, the respondent’s Chief Regional Operations Officer, Mr. Robert Michael Grainger confirmed her exemplary performance and competence. The Chief Regional Operations Officer also scored her very well in the end of year review for the period July to December 2022. As a result of the said performance, she was given a salary adjustment and a job description vide letter dated 1st January 2023. Her salary was increased to Kshs.137,295 per month.

5. On 23rd May 2023, Mr. Robert Michael Grainger told her to proceed on compulsory leave from 24th May 2023 to the end of the month. As at that time, she had 168 accrued leave days from 1st June 2023, the compulsory leave was extended for three months upto 31st August 2023. On 6th September 2023, she was given a cheque of Kshs.180,026 and was compelled to sign a standard for that stated that the said cheque was her full and final settlement.

6. She contended that she was not allowed to take 21 leave days a year and she was not compensated for the unspent leave days. She prayed for 41.5 leave days plus the other reliefs sought in her claim. She also stated that she was never paid house allowance for the 8.8 years of service to the respondent. She contended that she was dismissed vide the letter dated 23rd May 2023 which stated that her services were no longer required.

7. On cross examination, she stated that she was employed in January 2015 and confirmed in April 2015. She maintained that she was given an appointment letter without copy of the Human Resource Policy Manual. She contended that she saw the Human Resource Manual when it was served on her Advocate in this suit.

8. She admitted that her appointment letter mentioned contribution of severance allowance of ½ her salary and the employer remitted the same regularly to the Sacco. She contended that she was claiming severance pay for 8.8 years equal to Kshs.549,180 but confirmed that she had access to the same from the Sacco after the termination. She confirmed that she was paid Kshs.180,025.65 as a top up of the severance pay. She denied that the employer paid over one Million as her severance pay.

9. As regards the termination, she contended that it was done without prior notice. She contended that the contract provided for a procedure for termination but it was not followed. She contended that she had just reported back from leave when the Board called her and told her that her services were no longer required. She admitted that was offered three months’ salary in lieu of notice but maintained that the termination was unfair as she was not given prior notice.

10. As regards the claim for leave, she admitted that there was a policy not to carry forward more than 10 leave days. She contended that from 2015, she was carrying forward less than 10 days every year. However, she admitted that she could not accumulate the days carried forward to more than 10 days.

11. In re-examination, she clarified that the severance pay mentioned in the appointment letter had nothing to do with the redundancy herein. She contended that the severance pay in the appointment letter was a benefit paid to all employees. She contended that she was discussed in her absence and was never given a chance to be heard on the issues discussed in her absence. She maintained that she never received the Human Resource Manual during her employment by the respondent.

12. The respondent’s Regional Director, Mr. Kosia Edward Mupanda testified as RW1. He adopted his statement dated 26th August 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced 14 documents as exhibits for the respondent. In brief, his testimony was that the claimant was employed by the respondent from 15th January 2015 and her contract was read and interpreted together with the respondent’s Human Resource Policy and Procedure Manual which was applicable to all the employees of the respondent. He contended that the Manual provided that the house allowance was consolidated in the salary.

13. He stated that over the time, it became clear that the claimant had serious challenges in capacity and work performance. The respondent tried to assign her different job descriptions to try align her to her strong areas but it proved futile. Her shortcomings in the semi-annual and annual performance review were brought to her attention vide report of July 2022 and various emails of 20th February 2023, 1st May 2023 and 8th May 2023.

14. He contended that the claimant lacked diligence, attention to details, poor time management, inefficient in undertaking administrative protocols in completion, submission and filing of documents which meant that she was incompetent and did not match the requirements and standards expected in the position she was holding. As a result, the respondent was compelled to call for a meeting to discuss the concerns which had already been communicated to her and responded to all of them. In the end, the respondent made a decision to terminate her services based on her work performance.

15. He contended that the termination was lawful because the claimant was given opportunity to defend herself. RW1 contended that the claimant’s poor performance was due to lack of academic qualification. He further contended that the claimant was not denied notice since she was paid three months’ salary in lieu of notice in June, July and August 2023. He denied the claim for compensation for unfair termination.

16. He denied the claim for severance pay contending that the respondent deposited the same into a Sacco account for 8 years according to her contract of service and the unremitted sum was paid to her after the termination. He further denied the claim for house allowance contending that the Human Resource Manual clearly provided that her salary was consolidated. He further denied the claim for 168 leave days and relied on the leave records produced as exhibits.

17. Finally, he contended that the claimant voluntarily signed a clearance certificate acknowledging full and final payment of her dues and wondered why the change of heart after one year. He further averred that a certificate of service for the claimant was prepared and it is awaiting collection by the claimant.

18. On cross examination, he contended that the claimant’s certificate of service dated 1st June 2023 is one of the exhibits filed by the respondent herein. He reiterated that severance pay was deposited in the Navigator’s Sacco to be paid at the end of the contract. He contended that the employer also contributed pension on top of the severance pay.

19. He admitted that the first contract never stated that claimant’s salary was consolidated and that her payslip on page 29 only provided for a gross pay of Kshs.134,514.85 made up of basic salary plus bonus and no mention of house allowance.

20. He admitted that the claimant’s payslip for August 2023 indicated severance pay of Kshs.254,399.50 but clarified that it was the balance after the monthly remittances to the Sacco for the 8.5 years served. The money in the Sacco was deposited in her name and it was earning interest. He contended that he had filed the computation of the claimant’s severance pay. He contended that page 32 is the clearance certificate indicating Kshs.180,026 as full and final settlement and discharge of all claims against the respondent.

21. He confirmed that the letter dated 23rd May 2023 was the termination letter and the reason was non-performance. It stated that her giftings were not matching with the position. He denied that the claimant was told that her services were no longer required. He contended that the claimant was struggling because of lack of professional qualification since she had only a high school certificate. For eight years of her service, she never presented any other certificate.

22. Finally, he stated that the claimant was given a paid leave during the three months’ notice period plus 6 days’ leave pending as at 24th May 2023.

23. After the hearing, both sides filed written submissions to fortify their respective cases. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, there is no doubt that the claimant was employed by the respondent from January 2015 to May 2023 when her services were terminated by the respondent. The main issues for determination are:

(a) Whether termination was through redundancy or by notice.

(b) Whether the termination was unfair.

(c) Whether the claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Redundancy or termination by notice

24. The Claimant alleged that the respondent terminated her services on account of redundancy vide the letter dated 23rd May 2023. She testified that the respondent told her that her services were no longer required. However, the respondent denied the alleged redundancy and averred that it terminated the claimant’s services on account of her non-performance. It maintained that the claimant lacked the necessary capacity to satisfactorily perform her duties.

25. The termination of claimant’s employment was communicated vide the letter dated 23rd May 2023 which is copied below:

“May 23, 2023

Dear Akera,

To summarize our meeting let me start by thanking you or your service to this ministry over these past 8.5 years. Helping our staff fulfill their calling and mazimize their contribution to the kingdom is very important to us. We have seen your heart to make an impact in the kingdom in the way you welcome people and make them feel at home. You never fail to greet new people with a warm smile and laughter. Hospitality and serving people in that space is something you are good at. We highly commend you for that and we want to help you mazimize your gifting in that area.

Like any other growing ministry and organization, we have sought to align our staff needs with our strategic direction in the light of our Faith Direction objectives. It is with that intention that we have worked hard to find a role that matches your gifting. Over the last 24 months we have modified your job description three times toward that end, but it has become clear that the demands of the office don’t match your gifting. We would like to see you in a place where your contribution can match your gifting. In view of that, we have concluded that it would be best for you to transition to a role that fits your gifting and the contribution you can bring so we are releasing you to be free to focus on that. Your last day will be May 24th. You will have the remainder of the month off as paid leave which will be credited toward our remaining leave days. Any remaining days will be included in your severance pay.

In lieu of notice and to help you pursue another position we will give you there months paid leave starting June 1st and ending August 31st while we prepare your severance package. Our desire is to help you transition well to a role that fits your gifting and the contribution you can bring. We trust this will give you time to explore new opportunities, update your resume, engage in interviews, or enroll in professional training.

Kind regards,

Signed

Michael Grainger

Chief Regional Operations Office

The Navigators Africa

Signed

Edward Mupada

Regional Director

The Navigators Africa”

26. I have carefully considered the above letter and there is no redundancy or lay off mentioned anywhere. However, it is clear that the termination was grounded on the reason that the claimant was no match for the role she was employed to perform despite modification to her job description. It is clear that the claimant was offered three months’ salary in lieu of notice meaning that the employer exercised the right to terminate the contract by notice. RW1 was categorical that the termination was not on account of redundancy and I agree with that position as the letter indicated a different reason.

Unfair termination

27. Having found that the termination was not on account of redundancy, the next question is whether or not termination was unfair. Section 45(1) and (2) of the Employment Act provides that:

“(2)A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove—

(a) that the reason for the termination is valid;

(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason—

(i) related to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility; or

(ii) based on the operational requirements of the employer; and

that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure.”

28. The above law has its roots from the International Labour Organization convention 158 on termination of employment specifically Article 4 and 7 which I have copied below:

“Article 4 – the employment of a worker shall not be terminated unless there is a valid reason for such termination connected with the capacity or conduct or the operational requirement requirements of the undertaking, establishment or service.

Article 7 – The employment of a worker shall not be terminated for reason related to the worker’s conduct or performance before he is provided an opportunity to defend himself against the allegations made, unless the employer cannot be expected to provide this opportunity.”

29. The key factors to consider in determining whether a termination falls within the four walls of the law are substantial fairness and procedural fairness. The former refers to the validity of the reason or reasons upon which the termination is grounded while the latter entails the steps followed before making the decision to terminate including the fair opportunities availed to the employee to defend himself/herself.

Reason for the termination

30. The reason cited herein is incompetent and poor performance. RW1 stated that the claimant only held a high school certificate and never built her capacity for the 8 years of her service. He produced records of claimant’s performance review for the year 2022 done by the Chief Operations Officer Mr. Michael Robert Grainger. The claimant acknowledged areas of gaps in her reporting time and capacity and promised to improve.

31. In the review report dated 20th April 2022, the reviewer commended the claimant for her great improvement in skills, work ethics and attitude. In the review report of 7th September 2022, the reviewer’s comments were that the claimant had made a lot of improvement in delivery of out puts.

32. However, her review report dated 13th December 2022 the same reviewer Mr. Grainger’s comments were that she was not at her best when given tasks that involve a lot of details or problem solving, or when left in charge of a project. He further noted the claimant’s job description would be adjusted to fit her.

33. The above evidence corroborates the respondent’s case that the claimant had capacity and performance challenges. It is also evident that the claimant was given an opportunity to improve. She admitted in her review reports that she had a friendly team of colleagues and a supervisor who provided the necessary support. She further admitted that the respondent provided all the relevant tools and facilities to enable her do her duties.

34. It is trite law that an employer is entitled to terminate the services of an employee who persist in underperformance after being given the necessary support and opportunity to improve. Section 44(4)(c) of the Employment Act entitles our employer to dismiss an employee if;

“(c) an employee willfully neglects to perform work which it was his duty to perform, or if he carelessly and improperly performs any work which from its nature it was his duty, under his contract, to have performed carefully and properly.”

35. Section 45(2)(b) of the Act further provides that a reason for termination is fair if it relates to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility. In this case, there is evidence to prove that the claimant’s performance was not satisfactory and that was caused by lack of capacity, late reporting and lack of attention to details. In the circumstances of the case, I find that the reason for the termination was valid and fair.

Procedure followed

36. Section 41 of the Employment Act provides that:

“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.

(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”

37. The above procedure is mandatory but in this case, it was not followed. There is no evidence that the employer served the claimant with show cause letter and then invited the claimant to a disciplinary hearing in the company of a fellow employee of a choice. In the case of Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Company Ltd [2013] KEELRC 920 (KLR), Justice Stephen Radido elucidated the ingredients of procedural fairness as follows:-

"63. And what does section 41 of the Act require. The first observation is that the responsibility established is upon the shoulders of the employer. In a claim for unfair termination or wrongful dismissal on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity, the employer is duty bound to comply with the requirements of section 41.

64. The ingredients of procedural fairness as I understand it within the Kenyan situation is that the employer should inform the employee as to what charges the employer is contemplating using to dismiss the employee. This gives a concomitant statutory right to be informed to the employee.

65. Secondly, it would follow naturally that if an employee has a right to be informed of the charges he has a right to a proper opportunity to prepare and to be heard and to present a defence/state his case in person, writing or through a representative or shop floor union representative if possible.

66. Thirdly if it is a case of summary dismissal, there is an obligation on the employer to hear and consider any representations by the employee before making the decision to dismiss or give other sanction."

38. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR the Court of Appeal held as follows:-

“Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass muster:

(i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee;

(ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination;

(iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination is made;

(iv) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee.”

39. As earlier noted, the respondent purported to terminate the contract by paying three months’ salary in lieu of notice. However, that payment cannot take away the employer’s obligation to follow fair procedure before terminating the employment contract. In the case of Kenfreight EA Limited Vs Benson K. Nguti [2016] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that: -

“It is considered unfair to terminate contract of service if the employer fails to demonstrate that the reason for the termination is valid and fair, that reason related to the employee’s conduct, capacity and compatibility or is based on the operational requirements of the employer. The employer must also prove that the termination was in accordance with fair procedure…

Apart from issuing proper Notice according to the contract (or payment in lieu of Notice as provided), an employer is duty-bound to explain to an employee in the presence of another employee or union official, in a language the employee understands, the reason or reasons for which the employer is considering termination of the contract. In addition, an employee is entitled to be heard and his representations, if any, considered by an employer before the decision to terminate his contract of service.”

40. In the instant case, the payment of the salary in lieu of notice could not sanitize the unfair termination as the employer failed to follow the mandatory procedure set out under section 41 of the Employment Act. Consequently, I hold that the termination of the claimant’s employment contract was unfair within the meaning of section 45 of the Act.

Reliefs

41. In view of the foregoing conclusion, I find that the claimant is entitled to declaration that her employment was unfairly terminated by the respondent. She is also entitled to a certificate of service which according to RW1, has been lying in the office since 1st June 2023 waiting for her to collect.

42. As regards the monetary claim, the respondent produced a document titled Clearance Certificate signed by the claimant and the respondent’s Chief Regional Operations Officer Mr. Grainger on 6th September 2023. The document stated:

“The Navigator Africa

CLEARANCE CERTIFICATE

I Alice Wasonga do acknowledge receipt of cheque No. 6413 for Kshs.180,026, being full and final settlement and discharge of all claims made or capable of being made by me or my personal representative, in respect of my employment with the navigators Africa and I do further acknowledge that I have no unsettled claims against the organization arising out of my said employment or howsoever arising.

I have at the same time of execution of this clearance certificate returned all documents, instruments, property, and other such items as these of The Navigators Africa, which I have been using in the course of my duties with The Navigators Africa.

SIGNED BY:

Signed Date: 06/09/2023

Employee (Name)

Signed Date: 06/09/2023

Chief Regional Operations Officer

EMPLOYEES’ CONTACT ADDRESS (after discharge):

Name: Akera Alice Wasonga

Address: P. O. Box: N/A Town: N/A Code: N/A

Contacts: Phone: 0722473402

Email Address: akerawasonga@gmail.com,

43. By the said document the claimant acknowledged the payment of Kshs.180,026 as full and final settlement of all her claims against the respondent in respect of her employment by the it, and further waived and discharged it from any further claims arising from the said employment relationship. By signing the document, the respondent also acknowledged that the claimant had returned all documents, instruments, property and other items of the employer that she had been using in the course of her duties.

44. In the case of Thomas De La Rue (K) Limited Vs David Opondo Omutelema [2013] KECA 491 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that:

“We would agree with the trial court that a discharge voucher per se cannot absolve an employer from statutory obligation and that it cannot preclude the Industrial Court from enquiring into the fairness of a termination. That is however, as far as we are prepared to go. The Court has in each and every case, to make a determination, if the issue is raised, whether the discharge voucher was freely and willingly executed when the employee was seized of all the relevant information and knowledge.”

45. In the case of Coastal Bottlers Vs Kimathi Mithika (2018) eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that: -

“A Discharge Voucher is a binding contract and it constituted a full discharge and the Court should not entertain the suit filed after execution of the discharge.”

46. In this case, the claimant never denied signing the said settlement agreement. She never adduced any evidence to prove that she never understood the import of the document she was signing or that she was coerced to sign it. She never pleaded fraud or any other vitiating factors. Consequently, I find and hold that she signed the clearance certificate voluntarily while fully aware of its details and meaning.

47. Having found that the execution of the said clearance certificate was voluntarily done, I am satisfied that it resulted to a binding contract between the parties herein and the suit violates the well-established doctrine of estoppel in contract law. In common parlance, the doctrine of estoppel is an equitable principle that prevents a person from going back on a promise or contradicting a previous statement if another person has reasonably relied on it and would suffer a loss as result. In this case, the court will not allow the claimant to breach her own undertaking.

Conclusion

48. I have found that the claimant has proved that her employment contract was unfairly terminated by the respondent. However, in view of the binding clearance certificate signed by the parties herein after the termination on 6th September 2023, the claimant is estopped from making the claims sought in this suit. Consequently, I dismiss the suit but with no costs since the claimant was not estopped from suing the employer for the court to inquire into the issue of unfair termination.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Sadia for Claimant

No appearance for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder