REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E260 OF 2026.
GARY EUGENE ADRIAAN……….……….............CLAIMANT/APPLICANT
VERSUS
BASCON CONSTRUCTION (K) LIMITED…………….….1ST RESPONDENT
CALVIN FASIAL BASSA……………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
HENRY DOLLA MIEN……………………………………..3RD RESPONDENT
RULING
1. This ruling relates to the Claimant/Applicant’s Motion dated 11th March, 2026, brought pursuant to Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21 Laws of Kenya), Order 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Section 12 (1)(a) and (3)(i) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. The Claimant/Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -
i. THAT an interim preservation order be and is hereby issued restraining the 1st to 3rd Respondents, their servants, agents and/or all those acting under their instructions from selling, transferring, moving their assets outside the Jurisdiction of the Court and/or adversely dealing with the assets pending the hearing and determination of this Application inter partes and the substantive suit.
ii. THAT an order be and is hereby issued that the Respondents deposit the sum of USD 499,435.87, being the monthly remuneration and benefits due and owing since 1st July, 2022 to the Applicant, with the Court pending the hearing and determination of the main suit;
iii. THAT costs of and incidental to the application be provided for.
2. The motion is supported by grounds on the face and the affidavit of Gary Eugene Adriaan, the Claimant/Applicant herein, sworn on 11th March, 2026.
3. The Applicant contends that the 2nd and 3rd Respondents are likely to dissipate the 1st Respondent’s assets to frustrate enforcement of any judgment in his favour. He further states that the Respondents’ failure to honour their contractual obligations and reimburse work related expenses has exposed him to substantial debts and threats to his liberty.
4. It is his position that as a foreign national, he relocated to Kenya in reliance on the Respondents’ assurances of employment and reimbursement of work related expenses.
5. The Applicant states that he was employed by the Respondents as Country Manager under a written contract dated 1st July, 2022, which was renewed on 1st July, 2025, and which remains in force. He avers that he faithfully performed his duties and incurred legitimate business related expenses, but has to date not received any contractual remuneration or reimbursement since his employment commenced.
6. He avers that despite repeated demands, the Respondents have failed to settle his outstanding salary and accumulated work related expenses from 1st July, 2022 to date.
7. The Applicant further avers that, in 2025, a creditor confronted him over the Respondents’ unpaid rental arrears for the period 2022–2025, resulting in his arrest and the withholding of his and his wife’s passports.
8. He contends that he personally settled the arrears to secure the release of the passports and withdrawal of the complaint, and that the Respondents’ continued failure to pay his remuneration and reimbursements has plunged him into mounting debts, financial hardship and emotional distress.
9. The Applicant urges the Court to intervene by preserving the Respondent company’s assets and prevent the frustration of his claim, asserting that the company’s assets are under the effective control of a foreign national and may be dissipated, rendering any eventual judgment unenforceable.
10. The Respondents opposed the Motion vide grounds of opposition dated 21st May, 2026 and a replying affidavit sworn by CALVIN FASIAL BASSA, the 2nd Respondent, on 21st May, 2026.
11. The Respondents deny that there is any factual basis for the alleged risk of asset dissipation, asserting that the 1st Respondent is a project-based entity awaiting capital injection and holds no liquid assets capable of being transferred outside the court’s jurisdiction.
12. The Respondents state that the Applicant is fully aware that the company's operations are dependent on external funding, having been a participant in discussions regarding investors and bank instruments.
13. They further argue that the preservation order sought herein is prejudicial because it impedes efforts to secure funding necessary to meet the company’s outstanding obligations.
14. The Respondents contend that the Applicant’s engagement as Country Manager, and subsequently Regional Manager, was conditional upon the 1st Respondent securing project funding. They maintain that payment of the substantial remuneration envisaged under the funding dependent business model was contingent on successful financing, which has not materialized.
15. The Respondents further contend that the Applicant was a senior executive who was actively involved in investor relations and project financing, and that he established the Bascon Senior Management WhatsApp group to coordinate those efforts. They rely on the Applicant’s communications urging the company to expedite investor engagement as evidence that he knew his remuneration depended on the availability of capital and was not an unconditional monthly obligation.
16. The Respondents deny any scheme to defraud the Applicant, asserting that no evidence has been presented to support the allegation. They state that they secured a USD 5 million Standby Letter of Credit (SBLC) from Pacific Corp to finance the project, but later discovered, upon verification with Asia Nexus Investment Bank, that the instrument was illegitimate and had not been issued by the bank. They maintain that this external fraud caused the funding delays and that the Respondents, like the Applicant, were victims of the alleged scam.
17. The Respondents contend that the Applicant’s allegations of fraud are false, unparticularized and unsupported by evidence, arguing that he has not identified any specific misrepresentation, its falsity or an intention to deceive. They assert that the Applicant actively participated in preparing documents, engaging investors, and negotiating funding, which makes his allegations contradictory.
18. While expressing regret over the Applicant’s arrest on 18th February, 2025, they maintain that it arose from a landlord tenant dispute over rental arrears at Cycads Suites and was not a criminal act by the Respondents.
19. The Respondents assert that they actively engaged the landlord to resolve the rental dispute and negotiated the release of the Applicant’s passports. They further oppose lifting the corporate veil to impose personal liability on the 2nd and 3rd Respondents, maintaining that they acted solely in their capacities as directors and that no personal or fraudulent conduct has been demonstrated to justify such action.
20. The Respondents also challenge the joinder of the 3rd Respondent, Henry Dolla Mien, contending that he was not involved in the company’s operational management or internal communications, as evidenced by his exclusion from the senior management WhatsApp group and the company’s organizational structure.
21. The Respondents maintain that they acted in good faith by paying for the Applicant’s initial travel, work permits and relocation costs, and that he made no formal, properly documented demands for reimbursement before instituting these proceedings and has failed to demonstrate that the claimed expenses were authorized, necessary, incurred for legitimate company purposes and adequately documented. They further dispute the USD 499,435.87 claim as grossly exaggerated and deny liability for interest and general damages.
22. The Respondents contend that the dispute herein is commercial rather than one involving fraud or deliberate wrongdoing, arguing that the Applicant knowingly participated in a funding-dependent business model and assumed its associated risks.
23. They further deny that an employer-employee relationship was established within the meaning of the Employment Act and assert that the alleged employment contracts were, in some instances, signed by persons who are not parties to the suit.
24. The Respondents finally maintain that the Applicant’s claims are misconceived and lack a factual and legal basis, hence their opposition to the application dated 11th March, 2026.
25. Parties' submissions on the motion have been duly considered.
Analysis and Determination
26. Two issues arise for my determination: -
i. Whether the Applicant has established sufficient basis for preservation of the 1st Respondent’s assets; and
ii. Whether the Court should order the deposit of the disputed sum before the substantive claim is determined.
27. The principles on the grant of interlocutory injunctions were set out in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co Ltd [1973] EA 358, where the Court held that an applicant must establish a prima facie case with a probability of success, demonstrate that irreparable injury would be suffered if the injunction is not granted, and, where the Court is in doubt, the Applicant must show that the balance of convenience tilts in favours of the grant of the injunction.
28. The Court of Appeal clarified what constitutes a prima facie case in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 others [2003] KECA 175 (KLR), holding that it must be a case in which, on the material presented, a tribunal properly directing itself would conclude that a right has apparently been infringed by the opposite party, calling for an explanation or rebuttal.
29. The Applicant has sought to rely on his written employment contracts dated 1st July, 2022 and 1st July, 2025, to support his position that he has worked as the Country Manager of the 1st Respondent’s company without receiving his contractual remuneration and reimbursement of work related expenses.
30. The Respondents, on their part, dispute the nature and terms of the relationship, maintaining that the Applicant’s remuneration was dependent on the successful procurement of project financing. They also question the validity of the alleged employment relationship and further point to the involvement of persons who were not parties to the suit in executing some contractual documents.
31. The parties’ foregoing competing positions raise substantive questions on the existence and the terms of the employment relationship, the conditions governing remuneration of the Applicant, and the extent of the Respondents’ liability for the claimed expenses.
32. The Claimant/Applicant has placed before this Court written contracts of employment between himself and the 1st Respondent. Nevertheless, at this interlocutory stage, the Court cannot conclusively determine the contractual dispute or the Applicant’s entitlement to USD 499,435.87. In my view, these matters require evaluation of the contracts, the parties’ communications, the funding conditions raised by the Respondents, and the supporting financial records at the hearing of the main suit.
33. On the asset preservation, the Applicant does not merely seek to restrain interference with a specific asset, but he instead seeks to prevent the Respondents from transferring or otherwise dealing with their assets on the apprehension that a future judgment may be rendered unenforceable. Such relief, in my view, amounts to a freezing or Mareva injunction, intended to prevent the dissipation of assets and the frustration of a judgment.
34. In UBA Kenya Bank Limited v Sylvia Mututi Magotsi [2015] KEELRC 289 (KLR), the court outlined the threshold for the grant of a freezing order as follows: -
“………... Before granting a freezing injunction, the Court will usually require to be satisfied that: -
i. The Claimant has ‘a good arguable case’ based on a pre-existing cause of action
ii. The Claim is one over which the Court has jurisdiction.
iii. The Defendant appears to have assets within the jurisdiction.
iv. There is real risk that those assets will be removed from the jurisdiction or otherwise dissipated if the injunction is not granted.
v. The balance of convenience is in favour of granting the injunction
vi. The Court can also order disclosure of documents or the administration of requests for further information to assist the Claimant in ascertaining the location of the Defendant’s assets.”
35. . These requirements are distinct from the ordinary principles governing interlocutory injunctions. The requirement of a real risk of dissipation is particularly important. A freezing order is not granted merely because a claimant fears that a judgment debt may go unpaid. There must be material from which the Court can reasonably infer a genuine risk that assets will be removed or dissipated to frustrate enforcement.
36. The Applicant’s position is that the 2nd and 3rd Respondents exercise effective control over the 1st Respondent’s assets and may transfer them beyond the Court’s jurisdiction. However, the material presented herein identifies no particular asset that has been sold, transferred, concealed, or placed beyond reach, nor does the application disclose a specific transaction or other concrete step indicating imminent dissipation. Further, the Respondents’ denial that the company has any liquid assets available for transfer has not been controverted.
37. The Applicant’s alleged non-payment of remuneration over an extended period, the accumulation of debts and the rental dispute are no doubt serious matters, and which may support his claim for monetary relief, but they do not, without more, establish that the Respondents are about to dissipate assets to defeat this suit.
38. In the circumstances of this case, the Court is not satisfied on the material placed before it that a real risk of dissipation has been demonstrated. Without such evidence, a blanket order restraining the Respondents from dealing with their assets would, in my view, be disproportionate, especially given the Respondents’ contention that the order would impede their efforts to secure the financing required to revive the project and meet their outstanding obligations.
39. The prayer for an order compelling the Respondents to deposit USD 499,435.87 in Court is, in essence, a mandatory interlocutory order requiring the Respondents to provide security for the entire amount claimed before the claim has been tried.
40. This request is not merely an order preserving an identified asset, but one that would impose an immediate financial obligation corresponding to the very sum in dispute.
41. The applicable threshold for a mandatory injunction at the interlocutory stage is higher than that for a prohibitory injunction. In Nation Media Group & 2 others v John Harun Mwau [2014] KECA 308 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed that such an order requires special circumstances and a clear case warranting intervention before trial, and the Court must have a high degree of assurance that the order is justified.
42. The amount claimed herein is highly disputed, and the parties further disagree on whether the Applicant’s remuneration was payable unconditionally or whether it was dependent on the procurement of project financing. They also dispute the validity and effect of the contracts, the authorization and documentation of the expenses claimed, and the Respondents’ liability for the alleged arrears.
43. These matters cannot for these reasons be properly resolved through this interlocutory application without prejudging the substantive suit.
44. The Court cannot also make any final finding on the existence of an employment relationship, the validity of the contracts, or the personal liability of the 2nd and 3rd Respondents at this stage so as to avoid making premature findings on disputed matters that properly belong to the substantive hearing.
45. In conclusion, I find and hold that the Applicant has not demonstrated a real risk that the Respondents are about to dissipate or remove assets to frustrate enforcement of a future judgment, and the prayer for preservation of the Respondents’ assets therefore fails.
46. The prayer for the Respondent to deposit USD 499,435.87 also fails on the basis that liability and quantum remain disputed and the exceptional circumstances necessary to justify such a mandatory interlocutory order have not been satisfied.
47. Accordingly, the Notice of Motion dated 11th March, 2026 is devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed with costs in the cause.
48. It is hereby so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Mathenge h/b for Mr. Okore for the Claimant/Applicant
Mr. Ayisi present for the Respondents
Ms. Esther S - C/A