Background
By an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 4th October, 2022 the Claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 4th October, 2022 the Claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →In conclusion the Claimant’s claim succeeds with costs as follows:
Paragraph 18 →The said accusations were serious in nature and needed to be proved within the threshold set by civil law. This court finds that the Respondent failed to discharge its burden of justifying the reasons for summarily dismissing the Claimant as required by section 43 of the Act hence it amounted to unfair termination under section 45 of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 20 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E121 OF 2022
ELENA WAIRIMA WAMUTITU……..……....................... CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
OLOOLAISER WATER &
SEWERAGE COMPANY LIMITED………………………. RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. By an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 4th October, 2022 the Claimant pleaded inter alia: -
a. She was employed by the Respondent in April 2013 as a Finance and Administration Manager. Her appointment was confirmed in a letter dated 12th March 2014.
b. She served the Respondent diligently without any issues being raised about her work performance. She worked closely with the Respondent's Board of Directors for over five years.
c. By a letter dated 10th August 2018 the Claimant was sent on suspension for 30 days for allegations which the Claimant avers lacked sound basis. She was nevertheless placed on full salary. She prepared a handing over report dated 13th August 2018.
d. By a letter of 20th September 2018, the suspension was extended but at half salary. In January 2019, she was then issued with a letter dated 14th January 2019 asking her to collect an audit report by 21st January,2019 at 9:00 am, study the same in the Respondent's Boardroom and return it by 3:00 pm the same day.
e. Further, she was to appear before the Board of Directors on 22nd January 2019 for what was termed as "a hearing" on the matters raised against her and then she was to thereafter respond.
f. The Board was to then allegedly convene on 25th January 2019 to deliberate on matters raised against the Claimant. By a letter dated 19th February 2019, the Respondent purported to issue a show cause letter to the Claimant after she had appeared before the board on 22nd January 2019, 29th January 2019, 31st January 2019 and 4th February 2019.
g. That she gave a detailed and factually cogent response to the Respondent in a 14 page letter of 1st March 2019 where she formidably countered each allegation against her. However, the Respondent was hellbent on terminating her services. This was confirmed in a letter of 5th March 2019 received on 12th March 2019 terminating the Claimant's services by way of summary dismissal. The Respondent though its Board glossed over the Claimant's responses, some which laid blame on the steps of the Board of Directors itself and part due to systemic challenges within the Respondent itself.
h. She averred that the termination letter even contained fresh accusations that were not in the show cause letter. Pursuant to clause 14.4.5.4 of the Respondent's Human Resources Policies and Procedures Manual, she submitted a detailed appeal in a letter of 2nd April 2019.
i. That the Appeal letter was totally ignored by the Respondent who clearly demonstrated that it was not after any interest to establish the truth but was in a hurry to release the Claimant by whatever means, however unlawful. That this can be demonstrated by the fact that even before the period for appeal had been exhausted, the Respondent had already made an advertisement seeking to recruit a replacement for the Claimant.
j. She averred that she gave satisfactory explanations to the Respondent's Board for all accusations made against her including even the new allegation contained in the letter of summary dismissal. Thus the Respondent did not have a valid, fair and just reason for summarily dismissing the Claimant in the circumstances. That documents will demonstrate that some of the allegations against her were so easily countered that it defies good reason and judgement as to why they formed the reasons for her termination.
k. That further, by introducing new allegations in the termination letter, failing to read and understand the Claimant's explanations and by failing to consider the Appeal, the Respondent violated the provisions of Section 41 of the Employment Act which requires procedural fairness before disciplinary action and also violated its own Human Resources manual.
l. That in the course of the disciplinary proceedings, she was denied crucial documents that would have added in her defence. The Respondent violated its own Human Resources Manual by failing to follow the procedures in the whole of Clause 14 (14.1 to 14.4.5.4).
m. That her employment lacked both substantive and procedural fairness and was both wrongful and unfair and hence unlawful. It also violates Article 47(1) of the Constitution which requires Fair Administrative Action, the same as read with Sections 4(1), (2) and (3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
n. That the Respondent failed to reimburse her per diem allowances for inter alia travel and accommodation during diverse official engagements. The amount adds up to Kshs 280,000/= and which she prays for.
o. That she had due to workload not taken her annual leave for the year 2018 (30 days) and for 2019 (5 days). She was entitled by her contract and HR Manual to 30 days leave per year. She claims for pay in lieu of leave calculated as Kshs 151,300 +26 working days X 35 days of leave to give Kshs 203,673/=.
p. The Respondent further failed to clear the Claimant so as to facilitate processing of her pension benefits by the pension administrator. A demand for this purpose was ignored. The Respondent engaged in unfair labour practices by ignoring the Claimant's appeal and by failing to pay her terminal dues. This violates Article 41(1), Section 41 of the Constitution. Further, the Respondent visited upon the Claimant with adverse consequences of inter alia termination of employment yet the deficiencies the Claimant was accused of were attributable to systemic issues in the Respondent's operational policies and systems. This is equally an unfair labour practice.
2. The Claimant in the upshot prayed for the following against the Respondent: -
a. A declaration that the Claimant's termination was unfair, wrongful and hence unlawful.
b. The Respondent be ordered to clear the Claimant from its employment.
c. The Respondent be ordered to issue the Claimant with a Certificate of Service.
d. The Respondent be ordered to forward necessary documents to the pension fund administrator to enable processing of the Claimant's pension dues.
e. One month pay in lieu of notice Kshs 151,300.
f. Pay in lieu of leave Kshs 203,673.
g. Reimbursement of allowances Kshs 280,000.
h. Half salary balance from 20th September, 2018 up to 5th March 2019 being date of termination Kshs 364,173.
i. Compensation (12 months' gross salary): Kshs 1,815,600.
j. General damages for unfair labour practices and violation of the right to Fair Administrative Action Kshs 3,000,000.
k. Costs and Interests.
3. The Respondent filed its statement of defense dated 31st March,2022 which was filed before Claimant amended her claim and it did not file an amended response and averred among others: -
a. The Claimant failed to provide the application letter for the post she applied for when seeking employment with the Respondent. When asked to provide the same, the response given by the Claimant did not display deliberations and approval of the Board of Directors authorizing that the Claimant be confirmed to senior management post. This was in contravention to the Human Resources Manual Clause 3.2.1 wherein it states that Heads of Department and Senior Managers will be recruited by the Board.
b. That the Claimant did not serve the Respondent diligently as alleged. Details of the Claimant's misdemeanors shall be laid out during the pendency of this suit. That she was sent on paid leave which leave was extended but on half salary basis. That she was handed an audit report to review and return on the same day.
c. That the Claimant was asked to appear before the board of directors on 22nd January 2019 for a hearing on the matters raised against her after which she was to respond.
d. The Claimant did not show that she made any effort to recover the un-surrendered imprests withdrawn on diverse dates by the Claimant and the cashier which the latter had not fully surrendered and there was no evidence of re-banking the fund and further the Claimant in her capacity and the Finance and Administration Manager to recover the imprest or show any administrative and disciplinary action the Claimant took against the cashier towards curbing the recurrence.
e. Further, the Claimant did not show any effort to recover address the issue of charge of payments made to various suppliers for bulk water supply rendered to the company, pipes without complete supporting documents and exposing the company to financial misappropriation as the payments made were in contravention to the company's financial and procedure manual clause 4.4.
f. That further to this, the Claimant's account wherein she stated that the non-remittance of pension contribution was affected by the drought situation was false and not acceptable. Non-remittance of pension contribution (statutory deductions) exposes the company to litigation and surcharges.
g. That it did issue the Claimant with a summary dismissal notice vide a letter dated 5th March 2019. It did not gloss over the Claimant's responses. Were this true, it would not have given such a detailed response. It considered the Claimant's representations and the investigation report and found that the Claimant's general conduct and work performance warranted the summary dismissal on account of gross misconduct as guided by the Employment Act Section 44 (c) and (e).
h. That in deciding to summarily dismiss the Claimant it considered an audit report done in December 2018 and the outcome of subsequent investigation meetings held by the Board of Directors, three of which the Claimant attended. This in the Respondent's humble view, was thorough enough.
i. That the summary dismissal of the Claimant herein fell within the ambit of the Employment Act specifically Section 41(1) and 41(2), 43, 44 (3) and (4).
4. The Respondent therefore prayed that the Claimant’s claim to be dismissed with costs.
5. The Claimant had filed a reply to the statement of defense dated 14th April, 2022 where she reiterated her averments in now the amended statement of claim.
EVIDENCE
6. The Claimant’s case was heard by this court on 28th October, 2025, where the Claimant herein CW1testified as follows: -
a. She adopted her witness statement and bundle of documents filed with the claim as her evidence in chief and stated that she responded to the show cause letter. Her response was before the court.
b. She stated that she was not asked to give a copy of job application letter. That she was not given job interview notes to keep. That she was not aware she was to be interviewed by the Board of Directors.
c. She stated that she was issued with confirmation letter. Her accusations were unprocedural procurement of VAT consultant. That the consultant was approved by the Managing Director which appointment was for three years.
d. CW1 stated that she was not part of procurement committee. That the consumer deposit account was money paid when applying for water supply. That she was accused of allowing the deposit to be made in the revenue account. That every month they did analysis and removed the money to the correct account.
e. She stated that the Respondent was struggling financially hence they could not remit statutory deductions on time. That she did not steal any money. That new issues were added to the termination letter. That she appealed the termination and she responded to the issues raised in the termination letter. That the board approved use of consumer deposits to pay expenditure.
f. She stated that on payment to Nairobi Iron Mongers without proper documents that this was not true as there was recommendation for award to Nairobi Iron Mongers. That Nairobi Iron Mongers issued ETR.
g. She stated that her appeal was never responded to and there was advertisement of her vacancy. That she was not paid her terminal dues and she attended some functional training on behalf of the Respondent but she was never paid her D&A.
h. She stated that the minutes do not accurately reflect what transpired during the disciplinary hearing as she never said she would supply her application letter.
i. In cross-examination she reiterated that she was not asked to provide her letter of appointment.
7. The Respondent’s case on the other hand was heard by this court on 28th October, 2025 and on 19th March, 2026 where Jedidah Soila herein RW1 the acting Human Resource of the Respondent testified among others as follows:
a. She adopted her witness statement dated 13.11.2024 and documents filed in response to the claim as her evidence in chief.
b. In cross-examination RW1 stated that job application is submitted by a potential employee and the employee is supposed to keep the same in the employees’ personal file. That there was no requirement that an employee should keep a copy of job application letter. There was confirmation letter.
c. She stated that she knew Faith Lekato who was her predecessor and she did not handle/participate in the disciplinary proceedings concerning the Claimant. She joined the Respondent in 2021 July but in a different department, That her training was on HR. That the Claimant worked from April 2013 to March 2019.
d. She stated that the Claimant interacted and made presentations to the Board. On the master’s certificate she stated that she could not see the seal clearly and she could not comment on it as she had not received verification of the master’s certificate from UON.
e. That the degree was on MBA. That the suspension letter required the Claimant to step aside for 30 days. That the letter refers to a letter from County Government of Kajiado which letter was not before the court.
f. That the termination letter refers to consumer deposits and she was not aware the board had approved consumer deposits for payment of expenses. That the extract of minutes of the board showed approval for borrowing consumer deposits to pay staff standby allowances. That the minutes were signed by the chair and MD of the Respondent. That there was the resolution to transfer from deposits account to company expenditure account.
g. She stated that the transfer was to pay salaries. That it was signed by the chair and the MD. These documents were not annexed by the Respondent. That she was not a member of the Board and she could not rule out there were other similar resolutions. That she was an accounting expert.
h. She stated that the Claimant was employed as a financial expert and the money taken from consumer deposit was a loan hence refundable to consumers. That there was no approval for clarification. That the money was not a loan although she was not a financial expert.
i. She stated that from the extract of audited accounts customer deposits was classified as trade and creditors. That the issue of consumer deposits was in the show cause letter. That the issue of misadvising the board was not in the show cause letter.
j. On the unsurrendered imprests she stated that the amount was not specified in the termination letter or the Respondent’s bundle of documents. The money was to be surrendered to the cashier. That the Claimant was not accused of putting the money in her own use. The cashier was not a witness in this case.
k. On the issue of payment to suppliers without supporting documents she stated that she confirmed that the Claimant did according to the audit for the period. On payment voucher to Nairobi Iron Mongers she stated that there was an approval certificate which was signed although she was not sure it was the MD who signed the certificate.
l. On the tender evaluation report she stated that Nairobi Iron Mongers were recommended for the award of the contract. That the delivery note to the Nairobi Iron Mongers the two documents were not clear. That the dates were not clear for the proforma invoice from the Nairobi Iron Mongers as well as the award to it.
m. She stated that as per the termination letter the Claimant was accused of unathorised use of VAT refunds despite resolution by the Board to stop she stated that she disputed the resolution was made after issuance of postdated cheques. That the resolution stopping using VAT refunds is not filed before the court. That the VAT was refunded to the expenditure account.
n. On appointment of VAT expert she stated that it was approved by the MD for a period of 2 years. On the failure to remit pension dues as per termination letter she stated that there was no bank statement produced to show there was money and she failed to remit.
o. On the appeal against the dismissal she stated that she was not sure the appeal was responded to. That the termination letter was signed by the chair of the board the same board appeal was to be made. That the board and the board committee were defined differently.
p. She stated that the Claimant’s position was advertised before her appeal was responded to on 18/3/2019 which was before the 30 days of appeal had lapsed. She was not certain if the Claimant was paid her per diem claim or if she exhausted all her leave. That she was not sure if the Claimant’s request to clear was responded to.
q. In re-examination she stated that she did not take part in disciplinary proceedings and the record of the disciplinary proceedings was with the Respondent. That the disciplinary panel was by Board of Directors.
r. She stated that she was not sure if the academic qualifications of the Claimant were in dispute. That as per termination letter the confirmation of approval by the BOD was not there. That there was no confirmation of promotion to senior manager level. That there was no approval by the Board of utilization of consumer deposits. That cashier works under finance manager.
s. She stated that payments were done without supporting documents. That she was not sure the Respondent received the appeal letter. That advertisement was made to fill the vacancy after dismissal of the Claimant.
CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS
8. The Claimant’s advocates Macharia, Burugu & Co. Advocates filed written submissions dated 19th June, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
a. On the issue of whether there was valid, fair and just grounds to dismiss the Claimant counsel submitted that the grounds which the Claimant was required to answer are in a show cause letter dated 19th February 2019. That the Claimant’s detailed response is at pages 8 to 21 of the Initial Trial Bundle. That the Respondent did not consider the Claimant’s responses before resorting to dismissal. The allegations against the Claimant were stated to emanate from a letter from the County Government of Kajiado pursuant to an audit of the Respondent’s books. This letter from the County Government of Kajiado was made reference to in the suspension letter. Surprisingly, the letter from County Government of Kajiado was not availed to court by the Respondent.
b. It was submitted that the first allegation against the Claimant was that she failed to provide her job application letter when requested by the Board during the disciplinary proceedings. There is documentation emanating from the Respondent itself which confirms that she underwent recruitment, was appointed, confirmed in employment and served the Respondent openly for over five years. The Respondent therefore did not demonstrate the inexistence of a recruitment process or the illegitimacy of the Claimant's appointment.
c. It was the Claimant’s submission that more importantly, the Respondent failed to establish how the inability to produce a personal copy of a recruitment document several years after employment constituted misconduct. An application letter, once submitted, becomes part of the employer's recruitment records.
d. That the Respondent did not identify any contractual, statutory or policy obligation requiring the Claimant to preserve and produce such a document many years later after her appointment. Nor was there any allegation that the Claimant plucked out, concealed or destroyed the document, or that her employment was procured through misrepresentation or that the Claimant (who was a Master’s degree holder) was unqualified. The Claimant did not “recruit herself” and she was not privy to any requirements for the Board to interview her. That was a matter purely within the Respondent’s purview.
e. It was submitted that the Respondent merely established the absence of a document. It did not establish misconduct. The law requires proof of culpable conduct on the part of the employee, not proof that an employer is unable to locate a historical record. The allegation therefore could not constitute a valid or fair reason for disciplinary action, let alone summary dismissal.
f. Counsel submitted that the second allegation concerned the payment of consumer deposits into the revenue account and utilization of funds from the consumer deposits account. The Respondent's treatment of this issue throughout the disciplinary process reveals a fundamental failure to distinguish between a systemic operational challenge confronting the organisation and misconduct attributable to an individual employee.
g. That the Claimant consistently explained that the Respondent was experiencing significant cash flow constraints arising from, among other factors, revenue collection challenges, delayed remittances and inefficiencies associated with the collection of consumer deposits and new connection fees through agents who deposited these monies to the revenue account. The Claimant explained this issue clearly and in detail. It was against that backdrop that consumer deposits were utilized with Board approval to meet pressing operational obligations, including the payment of staff salaries to avoid unrest.
h. It was the Claimant’s submissions that she further explained that consumer deposits and new connection fees were reconciled very month and the consumer deposits reflected as creditors in the Respondent's financial statements. Her explanation that deposits had been utilized for operational expenses during a period of financial difficulty while continuing to recognize and account for the deposits in its financial accounts was reasonable.
i. That the Respondent did not challenge that explanation. It did not call any accounting expert to challenge the Claimant's description of the treatment and representation of consumer deposits in the Respondent's accounts. It did not demonstrate or argue that any consumer deposits were lost, or that the Claimant derived any personal benefit from the transactions. More importantly, the Respondent's own witness conceded during cross-examination that the Board had approved utilization of consumer deposits and that such transfers were utilized for inter alia staff allowance and salaries. This was corroborated by board resolutions.
j. It was submitted that once it is accepted that the utilization of consumer deposits was Board-approved and against the backdrop of systemic financial challenges affecting the Respondent, the allegation ceases to be one of unilateral misconduct by the Claimant and becomes a question of institutional decision-making. The Respondent therefore did not establish misconduct on the Claimant’s part. The allegation therefore falls far short of establishing a valid or fair reason for disciplinary action and cannot sustain the decision.
k. It was submitted that the third allegation concerned an audit query relating to alleged unsurrendered imprest. Significantly, the Respondent did not allege that the Claimant received the impugned funds, failed to surrender them herself, misappropriated them or derived any personal benefit therefrom. Rather, the complaint was that the cashier Michael Shirosio had allegedly failed to surrender the imprest and that the Claimant, as Finance and Administration Manager, had failed to take administrative or disciplinary action against him.
l. It was submitted that the allegation was based on mere assumptions that were never proved. The Respondent never demonstrated that any portion of the alleged unsurrendered imprest was attributable to the Claimant or that she personally failed to account for funds entrusted to her. Instead, the allegation proceeded on the basis of a global audit query without establishing the Claimant's individual responsibility for the same.
m. It was the Claimant’s submissions that her response was that the issue of imprest arose during the finalisation of the 2017/2018 financial statements, that she had summoned the cashier regarding the matter and that follow-up was ongoing. She further explained that before the matter could be concluded she was suspended from employment in August 2018 and was therefore removed from the workplace and deprived of the practical ability to continue pursuing the issue. The Respondent never rebutted that explanation.
n. It was submitted that the petty cash was to be paid and reimbursed by the cashier Michael Shirosio. The Respondent neither analysed the constituent items making up the audit query nor demonstrated which of those items were attributable to Mr. Michael Shirosio and which, if any, were attributable to the Claimant.
o. That more tellingly, Mr. Michael Shirosio himself was never called as a witness. The court was therefore denied evidence from the very officer who allegedly received the funds, handled the cash account and was said to have failed to surrender the imprest. The Respondent's assumption that the Claimant was under a duty to institute disciplinary proceedings against the cashier is untenable. The Respondent did not demonstrate that an audit query had first been conclusively determined against Mr. Michael Shirosio, that responsibility had formally been fixed upon him, or that the Human Resource Manual vested disciplinary authority over the cashier in the Claimant.
p. Indeed, it is difficult to see how disciplinary action could properly be initiated before the underlying audit issue had itself been conclusively investigated and responsibility formally established. All in all, the responsibility of petty cash management lay with the cashier as can be seen in his job description.
q. It was submitted that in the final analysis, the Respondent only established the existence of an unresolved accounting query involving another officer. It did not establish that the Claimant, obstructed recovery efforts or wilfully failed to act. On the contrary, the evidence shows that the matter was under follow-up before the Claimant was suspended and removed from office. What remained was an audit and reconciliation issue. It was never transformed into proof of misconduct attributable to the Claimant and therefore could not constitute a valid or fair reason for her summary dismissal.
r. It was submitted that the fourth allegation concerned payments made to, among others, Nairobi Iron Mongers, allegedly without requisite supporting documents. This allegation is difficult to sustain because the Claimant’s bundle contains the very documentation which the Respondent alleged was missing. In relation to Nairobi Iron Mongers, the Respondent produced the payment voucher, the delivery note and local purchase order, the tender evaluation and recommendation report, the proforma invoice, another local purchase order and quotation evaluation report.
s. Counsel submitted that the Claimant further explained that by the time she was suspended, she had handed over the relevant dockets to the Acting Finance Manager, Ms. Regina Mutunga, and was no longer in custody of the subject files. The Respondent’s witness did not seriously dispute the above the documents in cross-examination. In those circumstances, the allegation collapses on the weight of the evidence. The Respondent did not prove that the Nairobi Iron Mongers payment was unsupported.
t. It was submitted that the fifth allegation concerned the utilization of funds received from Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) as VAT refunds. This was not a question of employee misconduct but an accounting and financial management issue requiring proper appreciation of the Respondent's financial position, the treatment of revenue and the proper classification of VAT refunds. Unfortunately, the Respondent approached the issue as a disciplinary matter without first disproving the detailed financial explanation consistently advanced by the Claimant.
u. It was the Claimant’s submissions that in her response to the show cause letter at paragraph 5 (i) to (v) and the table therein the Claimant explained that customer payments for water supply, sewerage removal and connection fees were initially received from customers and deposited into the Revenue account pursuant to the Respondent's operational framework as contained in section 9.7 of the Service Provision Agreement (SPA) which defined “customer” in clause 1 thereof.
v. That the money received in the revenue account was then transferred to the Expenditure account from where the VAT was paid to Kenya Revenue Authority. The money went back to the expenditure account as that was where it came from. She further explained that the VAT refunds did not constitute a new source of income but merely restored liquidity previously expended from the expenditure account. These expenditures had been approved within the Respondent's budgetary framework. She further explained that the corresponding expenditures were identifiable and fully accounted for.
w. Further it was submitted that the Claimant did not give a general explanation but provided a detailed reconciliation identifying the specific expenditures settled from the funds received on 30th April 2018, 3rd May 2018 and 22nd May 2018, together with the respective payees, payment vouchers, cheque dates and running balances.
x. That once such a reconciliation was furnished, the Respondent was required to demonstrate that it was inaccurate, misleading, unsupported or contrary to accepted accounting practice. It never undertook that exercise. Nowhere in the disciplinary process did the Respondent identify a single payment within the reconciliation that was fictitious, unauthorized, unsupported or made for the Claimant's personal benefit.
y. That equally important is the Claimant's explanation regarding the period after the Board directed that utilization of the VAT refunds should cease. The Respondent presented the matter as though the Claimant simply ignored a Board directive and continued spending the funds. That is not what the evidence shows. The Claimant explained that by the time the resolution was passed in April 2018, substantial post-dated cheques had already been issued to suppliers, service providers and statutory bodies in respect of pre-existing obligations. The expenditures in question had therefore already been committed and payment instruments issued before the refunds were received.
z. It was submitted that the Board appears to have equated disagreement with the Claimant's expert financial judgment with proof of misconduct. What remained was, at most, a technical accounting disagreement. It was never transformed into evidence of misconduct on the part of the Claimant. The allegation therefore falls far short of establishing a valid or fair reason for termination.
aa. It was submitted that the sixth allegation concerned the engagement and payment of the VAT consultant, Mui and Associates. The Claimant's response, both in the show cause proceedings and in her appeal, was that the consultant was engaged through a documented procurement process and that the consultant successfully recovered VAT refunds for the Respondent. The procurement documents relating to the engagement are contained in the Initial Trial Bundle, including the quotation, the evaluation and recommendation report and the letter of award. The Claimant further explained that the engagement had management approval and was not a unilateral decision on her part. The engagement underwent a full procurement process.
ab. The allegation of overpayment of the VAT consultant was addressed satisfactorily at paragraph 6 (i) of response to show cause and paragraph G.11 of the Appeal letter, the Claimant demonstrated how the consultant's payment had been calculated and explained that the amount complained of by the Board was arrived at by applying the agreed percentage (20%) to the VAT refunds amount recovered together with the applicable VAT (16% to get 733,555/=) on the consultant's fees. This tallied with the quotation. In those circumstances, the allegation remained an unresolved disagreement over figures rather than proof of misconduct on the part of the Claimant. In either event the Claimant’s calculations were correct.
ac. It was submitted that the seventh allegation concerned the alleged failure to remit statutory deductions. The Respondent assumes that because a statutory obligation remained outstanding, the Claimant must necessarily have been personally responsible for the default. The evidence does not support that conclusion.
ad. It was submitted that in her response to the show cause letter and subsequently in her appeal, the Claimant explained that the Respondent was experiencing significant cash-flow challenges which affected its ability to meet various financial obligations as they fell due. Those challenges were not peculiar to statutory deductions. They extended to a range of operational and financial commitments which the Respondent was struggling to satisfy at the material time. The issue was therefore not whether statutory deductions ought to have been remitted. The issue was whether the failure to remit arose from misconduct on the part of the Claimant or from the Respondent's broader financial position.
ae. That significantly, the Respondent never demonstrated that the Claimant had custody of the funds and deliberately withheld remittance, that she diverted the monies for unauthorized purpose, or that she acted contrary to a Board or management directive requiring immediate payment. Nor did the Respondent demonstrate that the Claimant possessed independent authority to generate funds for remittance in circumstances where the organisation was facing acknowledged liquidity constraints.
af. That in the absence of such evidence, the allegation amounts to an attempt to attribute an organisational financial problem to a single employee. The disciplinary process appears to have proceeded from the assumption that because the Claimant headed the finance department, every outstanding statutory obligation automatically became her personal misconduct. That the existence of an outstanding liability does not, without more, establish culpability on the part of an employee.
ag. It was submitted that in the final analysis, the Respondent only established that statutory deductions were outstanding. It did not establish that the outstanding remittances were caused by neglect of duty or any dishonest, wilful or improper conduct on the part of the Claimant. The allegation therefore could not constitute a valid or fair reason for summary dismissal.
ah. Counsel submitted that the foregoing were the allegations in the show cause letter. Of notable concern however is the introduction of an entirely new allegation but only in the letter of summary dismissal, which they called “allegation eight”. The allegation is that the Claimant misadvised the Board into approving financial statements which reflected money borrowed from consumer deposits as “creditors”. This allegation however did not form part of the show cause letter. The Claimant was consequently denied an opportunity to respond to the allegation before the decision to dismiss was made and she could only address it for the first time in paragraph C- 5 of her appeal.
ai. That for that reason alone, the allegation ought to carry little, if any, evidential weight as a ground for dismissal. The purpose of a show cause process is to notify an employee of the allegations being considered and afford the employee an opportunity to answer them before a decision is reached. An allegation introduced for the first time in the dismissal letter violates this purpose.
aj. That in any event, the allegation is unsupported by the evidence. At its core, it relates to the question of what is proper accounting treatment of borrowed consumer deposits within the Respondent's financial statements. That is a technical accounting issue requiring expert evidence. The Respondent did not call any expert to demonstrate that the accounting treatment adopted was incorrect.
ak. It was the Claimant’s submissions that her explanation in the appeal was that the consumer deposits had not been concealed, omitted or removed from the Respondent's books. Rather, the amounts remained reflected in the accounts as creditors. Equally absent was evidence of the alleged "misadvice". The allegation simply assumes that because the Board subsequently disagreed with the accounting treatment, the Claimant must have misadvised it. That assumption cannot substitute proof. Accordingly, that allegation could not constitute a valid basis for the dismissal.
al. Counsel submitted that arising from the foregoing, there was no valid, fair and just reason for dismissal and the dismissal was SUBSTANTIVELY UNFAIR.
am. On the issue of whether a fair procedure followed counsel submitted that although the Respondent relies on meetings held before the Board, those meetings appear to have been investigative rather than disciplinary in nature. They took place before the issuance of the show cause letter and before the allegations had been formally framed and communicated to the Claimant. In those circumstances, they cannot be equated to the disciplinary hearing contemplated under Section 41 of the Employment Act. A hearing should not precede the charges against an employee.
an. That once the show cause letter was issued and the Claimant furnished her detailed response, there is no evidence of a subsequent disciplinary hearing convened to consider that response before the decision to dismiss was made. The sequence reflected in the documents is therefore not the one contemplated in Section 41 of Employment Act as interpreted by numerous case law from this Court and the Court of Appeal.
ao. That the sequence was follows: preliminary meetings before the Board, followed by a show cause letter, followed by a written response and then a dismissal letter. The process moved directly from the show cause stage to dismissal without a clear Section 41 hearing in-between. The Court should also note that the Respondent did not produce any correspondence informing the Claimant of her right to be accompanied by a fellow employee or shop floor representative as required under Section 41.
ap. Counsel submitted that a disciplinary process needs not be pedantic or follow a mechanical path. However, a show cause letter which contains new allegations followed directly by a dismissal letter cannot be a fair process by any stretch. The procedural concerns are compounded by Clause 14.4.5.3 of the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual, which provides that disciplinary proceedings involving senior management staff are to be processed by a Board Committee, and Clause 14.4.5.4, which provides for an appeal to the Board.
aq. That the minutes produced by the Respondent refer to Board meetings rather than Board Committee meetings. The Respondent did not explain whether the preliminary meetings were meetings of the Board Committee or the Board itself. The distinction between the disciplinary and appellate structures and bodies therefore became blurred resulting to an unfair process.
ar. Further, although the Claimant appealed, the appeal was never considered. The Respondent instead advertised Claimant’s position before the window for appeal was exhausted. Taken together, these shortcomings demonstrate that the disciplinary outcome had crystallized before the disciplinary process had run its course. The conclusion therefore is that the hearing procedure followed was not fair and did not comply with Section 41 of the Employment Act and Respondent’s own procedure. In addition to being unfair under statute, it was also wrongful under common law for violation of the HR manual which forms part of the Claimant’s contract of employment.
as. On the issue of whether the Claimant’s right against unfair labour practices and fair Administrative Action were violated counsel submitted that the Respondent's conduct amounted not only to unfair termination but also to a violation of the Claimant’s rights under Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution and Section 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
at. It was submitted that the Respondent is not a private employer. In its own job advertisement, it describes itself as operating under the ownership of the County Government of Kajiado. Further, its financial statements were submitted to and audited by the Auditor General. The Respondent was therefore exercising public and administrative authority and was bound to exercise lawful administrative action.
au. That what emerges from the evidence is not merely a flawed disciplinary process but a sustained attempt to attribute systemic and institutional shortcomings to a single employee. Several of the allegations concerned long-standing accounting treatments, procurement processes, cash management practices, statutory remittances, operational weaknesses and governance decisions involving multiple officers, departments and, in some instances, the Board of Directors itself. Yet the disciplinary process proceeded on the premise that the Claimant alone should bear responsibility for those matters.
av. That for a public entity to subject a senior officer to serious allegations touching on financial integrity, stewardship of public resources and professional competence, while simultaneously failing to afford her the procedural safeguards guaranteed by law and attributing to her systemic shortcomings extending beyond her individual mandate, constitutes more than an ordinary unfair termination. It amounts to an unfair labour practice and an administrative process that fell below the standards required by Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution and Sections 4(1), 4(2) and 4(3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
aw. Reliance was placed on the case of Grace Gacheri Muriithi V Kenya Literature Bureau [2012] KEELRC 135 (KLR) on this assertion of employer deficiencies being met on employee.
ax. On the issue of remedies available to the Claimant counsel on compensation submitted that the Claimant was unfairly terminated hence entitled to compensation for unfair termination under section 49(1)(c ) of the Employment Act while considering the considerations given under section 49(4) of the Employment Act. The Claimant had served the Respondent for a period of six years where she rose to senior position of accounting for the Respondent’s finances, the manner of the Respondent’s termination on serious allegations which were never proved she was entitled to a maximum compensation.
ay. On notice pay she was entitled to one month’s salary in lieu of notice having being summarily dismissed without notice and as per her contract of employment and the Employment Act.
az. On pay in leu of leave the Claimant was entitled to the same since the Respondent as the custodian of employment records under section 74 of the Employment Act did not produce records hence the Claimant’s claim of accrued leave remains uncontroverted.
ba. On half salary balance it was submitted that the Claimant was suspended with half salary from 20th September, 2018 up to date of exit. That her gross salary was Kshs 151,300/ while during suspension she was paid Kshs 86,000/. That the shortfall salary was Kshs 65,300/. The total amount was Kshs 364,173/= That the Respondent withheld this portion of salary pending the outcome of the disciplinary process. Having failed to prove the allegations against the Claimant then it had no lawful basis to retain the withheld salary.
bb. Claimant also claimed reimbursement of per diem allowances of Kshs 280,000/ and produced documents to support the claim including approved vouchers issued by the Respondent and corresponding workshop and training invitations demonstrating the official assignments undertaken by the Claimant.
bc. The Claimant also claimed general damages for unfair labour practices and violation of the right to fair Administration action for violation of Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution as well as prayers a1 and a 3 for clearance to facilitate processing and release of her pension benefits. The Claimant sought for certificate of service to read from 30th April, 2013 to 5th March, 2019.
RESPONDENTS’ SUBMISSIONS
9. The Respondents’ Advocates Miller & Company Advocates filed written submissions dated 9th July, 2026 and submitted among others that:_
a. On the issue of whether there were valid and fair reasons for dismissal counsel relied on Section 43 and 45 of the Employment Act that an employer is required to prove the reasons for termination and that such reasons were valid and fair. That the Claimant occupied the senior position of Finance and Administration Manager and was entrusted with the stewardship of the Respondent's finances. Consequently, a higher degree of accountability and diligence was expected of her.
b. It was submitted that the evidence demonstrates numerous instances of negligence and dereliction of duty, including:
1. Failure to account for un-surrendered imprests and failure to recover public funds;
2. Failure to take administrative or disciplinary action against officers responsible for financial improprieties;
3. Processing and authorizing payments to suppliers without complete supporting documentation contrary to Clause 4.4 of the Respondent's Financial and Procedural Manual;
4. Failure to ensure remittance of pension contributions and other statutory deductions thereby exposing the Respondent to litigation and statutory penalties;
5. Failure to account for consumer deposits and VAT refunds in a manner satisfactory to the Board and auditors.
c. It was submitted that the Respondent's evidence establishes that the Claimant failed to demonstrate any efforts to recover un-surrendered imprests or to account for the funds withdrawn. She equally failed to provide evidence that the funds had been re-banked or otherwise properly accounted for. That the Claimant further failed to take administrative or disciplinary action against the cashier notwithstanding the repeated financial irregularities. As the head of the Finance Department, the Claimant cannot escape responsibility for the failures that occurred under her supervision.
d. It was submitted that the Respondent also demonstrated that payments were made to various suppliers without complete supporting documentation, thereby exposing the Respondent to financial loss and misappropriation. Such conduct was in direct contravention of the Respondent's Financial and Procedural Manual. That the Claimant's explanation concerning non-remittance of pension contributions and statutory deductions was rightly rejected by the Respondent as false and untenable. The failure to remit statutory deductions exposed the Respondent to statutory penalties and constituted serious neglect of duty.
e. Counsel submitted that the Claimant seeks to characterize these matters as systemic failures within the organization which is misplaced. The existence of organizational challenges does not absolve a senior manager from accountability for negligence, non-compliance with financial procedures and failure to discharge statutory obligations. The Court in numerous decisions has held that an employer is entitled to dismiss an employee whose conduct fundamentally erodes the trust and confidence necessary for the employment relationship, particularly where the employee occupies a fiduciary position involving financial management.
f. It was submitted that the cumulative effect of the Claimant's conduct justified the Respondent's conclusion that the Claimant had committed gross misconduct warranting summary dismissal under Section 44 (4) (c) and (e) of the Employment Act.
g. On the issue of whether the disciplinary process was fair counsel submitted that the Claimant was issued with a notice to show cause and was afforded an opportunity to respond to the allegations. The Respondent considered the Claimant's responses together with the audit report, the findings of investigations and the resolutions of the Board of Directors before arriving at the decision to summarily dismiss her.
h. That the Respondent further considered the investigation report prepared in December 2018 and the resolutions of the Board of Directors made during various meetings, three of which were attended by the Claimant. That the law does not prescribe a rigid formula for disciplinary hearings. What is required is that an employee be informed of the allegations and be afforded an opportunity to respond.
i. It was submitted that the evidence demonstrates that the Claimant was aware of the allegations, participated in the investigations, responded to the show cause letter and attended meetings convened by the Board. The requirements of Section 41 of the Employment Act were therefore substantially complied with. That the burden of proving unfair termination rests with the Claimant while the burden of justifying the grounds of termination rests with the Respondent. Reliance was placed on Section 47 (5) of the Employment Act and the case of lsindu v Lavington Security Guards Ltd (Civil Appeal 301 of 2015) (2017) KECA 225 (KLR). That the Claimant's assertion that the process was predetermined is unsupported by evidence and should therefore be rejected.
j. On the issue of whether the Claimant's rights under Articles 41 and 47 were violated counsel submitted that the Claimant has failed to establish any independent constitutional violation separate from the alleged unfair termination. That it was settled law that where the dispute falls squarely within the framework of the Employment Act, remedies should ordinarily be granted under the statute unless distinct constitutional violations are proved.
k. It was submitted that the Claimant did not demonstrate arbitrary, irrational or procedurally improper administrative action. The disciplinary process was undertaken following investigations into serious financial irregularities and in accordance with the Respondent's statutory and fiduciary obligations.
l. On the issue of whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought counsel submitted that having established that the dismissal was lawful and justified, the Claimant is not entitled to compensation for unfair termination, notice pay or constitutional damages. That the claims for accrued leave, half salary and per diem allowances are special damages that require strict proof. The Claimant bears the burden of proving the specific amounts claimed and that the same remain unpaid. That the prayer for maximum compensation under Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act is wholly undeserved considering the gravity of the misconduct established against the Claimant.
DETERMINATION
10. This court has reviewed and considered the pleadings, testimonies, submissions and authorities albeit long relied on by both parties and has I have come up with three main issues: -Aa. aa.
i. Whether Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.
ii. Whether the Respondent violated the Claimant’s rights.WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe
iii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful
1. It is not in dispute that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent vide employment letter dated 19th April, 2013 effective 30th April, 2013 and summarily dismissed vide the termination letter dated 5th March, 2019.
2. The ELRC and Courts above it have in most occasions held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court is guided by the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others.
3. On the substantive test the employer must give a fair and valid reasons as per section 43 of the Employment Act. The reasons for termination must be those the employer genuinely believed to exist which caused it terminate the employees services. Section 45 of the Employment Act is clear that where there is no valid and fair reasons such termination is unfair. Section 44 of the Employment Act, stipulates when summary dismissal can occur most specifically section 44(4) (c) and (e) provides where an employee wilfully neglects to perform any work which it was his duty to perform, or if he carelessly and improperly performs any work which from its nature it was his duty, under his contract, to have performed carefully and properly or employee fails to obey lawful commands of the employer.
4. In this case the Claimant was first suspended by letter dated 10th, August, 2018 citing gross misconduct while citing letter from the County government of Kajiado. Despite the said letter being the source of the woes for the Claimant the same letter was not produced by the Respondent before this court. The suspension on full salary was to take place up to 20th September, 2019 to pave way for investigations. The suspension was extended vide the letter dated 20th September, 2018 for five months up to 20th February, 2019 on half salary while investigations were undergoing.
5. The court notes that the suspension was quite long against the established principles and that suspension if too long could amount to constructive dismissal. The court will however procced to establish if the Respondent proved the reasons for termination. The Claimant was given a letter dated 14th January, 2019 before the suspension ended which alleged that audit by Auditors from the County Government of Kajiado had completed and notified the Claimant to collect the audit report on 21st January, 2019 to study it and return it the same day at 3.00pm and appear for board of directors hearing on 22nd January, 2019. That the Board would convene on 25th January, 2019 for further deliberations.
6. The Claimant was then issued with a show cause letter dated 19th February, 2019 which raised seven charges against her and was given 10 days to respond to the allegations. The Claimant gave a detailed response vide the letter dated 1st March, 2019 and the Respondent proceeded to terminate her services vide the letter dated 5th March, 2019 adding another eight charges on top of those given in the show cause letter.
7. On the first allegation of not providing her job application letter it was clear during hearing that it was not necessary for the Claimant to produce her application letter when it was the Respondent’s duty to keep such document in the Claimant’s job file. In addition, there was employment letter dated 19th April, 2013 issued by the Respondent and a confirmation of employment dated 12th March, 2014.
8. The Claimant could not know if she was to be interviewed by the board as that was within the purview of the Respondent. She did not employ herself but it was the Respondent who employed her and she worked as such for over five years without the Respondent illustrating if the Claimant misrepresented herself while she held a master degree. There was no challenge on her qualification as well.
9. On the second allegation of payment of consumer deposits into expenditure account, it was clear that the Respondent was undergoing financial constraints and there was a board approval dated 10th January, 2018 which allowed the transfer of consumer account to expenditure accounts and in any case, there was reconciliation every month where consumer deposits reflected as creditors in the financial statements. That the same was resolved in order to pay staff salaries to avoid staff unrest and the same was approved by the board.
10. On the third allegation on audit query relating to unsurrendered imprest, the Respondent blamed the Claimant for not taking disciplinary action against the cashier one Michael Shirosio who had failed to surrender the imprests. This court notes that from the job description of the said cashier it was his duty to manage petty cash vouchers and whereas the Claimant was the head of finance she should not take blame for inaction of an indolent employee. She explained that she could not take action on the said cashier since she was placed on long suspension and the issue arose during the finalisation of 2017/18 financial statements.
11. That the Audit query had not even constructively determined against the cashier for any action to be taken. During hearing it was clear the Respondent’s witness confirmed that no specified amounts were given by the Respondent as unsurrendered imprests. That the said cashier was never called as a witness by the Respondent.
12. On the forth allegation of payments to among others Nairobi Iron Mongers without the requisite supporting documents this court notes that there was the payment voucher, invoice, delivery note, local purchase order and the evaluation and recommendation for award of contract among others where the said Nairobi Iron Mongers was recommended for the award. The same was supported by the Respondent’s own documents. The Respondent’s witness confirmed that the said Nairobi Iron Mongers issued ETR receipt.
13. On the fifth allegations on utilization of funds from KRA as VAT refunds it was clear that the Claimant explained this issue from a financial position which was clear and payments done were before the board directed that utilization of the VAT refunds should cease. In any case the said resolution stopping using VAT refunds was not filed before the court as confirmed by the Respondent’s witness. The actions were necessitated by the Respondent’s financial constraints, and the Claimant did not utilise the funds for her own use but the same were accounted for. No accounting expert was called to clarify on this allegation.
14. On the sixth allegation on engagement and payment of VAT consultant Mui and Associates the same there is evaluation of the consultants, the said Mui Associates was recommended and the managing director issued the letter to the consultant of the contract for three years and they were to be paid 20% of the contract amount plus VAT. The procurement was documented and the consultant successfully recovered the VAT refunds for the Respondent. That the Claimant’s quotation tallying with the consultant fees paid.
15. On the seventh allegation on failure to remit statutory deductions it was clear that the Respondent was undergoing difficult financial turmoil and the deductions were not spared. The Respondent never illustrated that it gave any money for deductions and she never remitted used it for her own use or misappropriation on her part. That the Respondent’s witness confirmed that no bank statement was issued to show there was money and the Claimant failed to remit.
16. On the eighth allegation raised in the termination letter of misadvising the Board in to approving financial statements which reflected money borrowed from the consumer deposits as creditors this court notes that this allegation was not brought in the show cause letter denying the Claimant opportunity to respond to the same which it had to do through the appeal of the termination. The same required a technical expert on financial statements which the Respondent never did. The Claimant maintained that the consumer deposits were never concealed but remained as creditors. That there was no evidence of misadvice tabled by the Respondent.
17. From the above analysis it is clear the Respondent did not prove any of the reasons they summarily dismissed the Claimant for on account of gross misconduct despite working for it for around 6 years without any history of misconduct. That there were systemic issues in the Respondent operational policies and systems which could not be meted out on a specific employee such as the claimant herein.
18. The court is also guided by the case of Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated:
“There can be no doubt that the Act, which was enacted in 2007, places a heavy obligation on the employers in matters of summary dismissal (Emphasis mine) for breach of employment contract and unfair termination involving breach of statutory law. The employer must prove the reasons for terminating (section 43) – prove that the grounds are justified (section 47 (5), among other provisions. A mandatory and elaborate process is then set up under section 41 requiring notification and hearing before termination.”
19. The Respondent was bound by section 47(5) to justify the reasons to summarily dismiss the Claimant. The Respondent could not hide in the provisions of section 43(2) on the reasons it genuinely believed to exist which caused it to terminate the employment of the Claimant since the reasons in the first place were not justified nor valid. The reasonable test of an employer would apply if any reasonable employer would terminate in the circumstances.
20. The said accusations were serious in nature and needed to be proved within the threshold set by civil law. This court finds that the Respondent failed to discharge its burden of justifying the reasons for summarily dismissing the Claimant as required by section 43 of the Act hence it amounted to unfair termination under section 45 of the Employment Act.
21. On the procedural fairness as provided for under section 41 of the Employment Act this court notes that the same was never adhered to as the Respondent after the Claimant issued her response to the show cause letter they proceeded to terminate her services summarily on 5th March 2019 without according her a fair hearing under section 41 of the Employment Act. The hearings before were investigative in nature and the act of giving the Claimant the audit report on 21st January, 2019 to study it and return it the same day was in itself unfair since the period was too short.
22. In addition, the said meetings were not held as disciplinary committee as required by the Respondent’s own Procedure Manual clause 14.4.5.4 but as board of directors and the same were held before a show cause letter enumerating the charges was given to the Claimant. Further, the letter at no point did they notify the Claimant to attend with a colleague of her choice. A show cause letter marks the start of a disciplinary hearing as was held in the case of Vicky Kemunto Ocharo v Independent Policing Oversight Authority [2018] eKLR as follows;
The formal disciplinary procedure starts with a “show-cause letter”. The employee will be informed in writing by the supervisor of the nature of the complaint allegation. The employee will be required to submit his response within twenty -one (21) days.
23. This means therefore, the Claimant was terminated at the onset of disciplinary hearing without affording her a fair hearing which was against her right of fair trial and administrative hearing. In addition, the Respondent advertised her vacancy even before the 30 day period of appeal was exhausted on 18th March, 2019. The Claimant appealed on 2nd April, 2019, but the same was not addressed as confirmed during hearing. The Respondent seemed was hell bent to dismiss her from service hence the reason why they advertised position for recruitment even before the period for her right of appeal ended. In this respect, the court is guided by the case of Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Meru North Farmers Sacco Limited [2014] eKLR that: -
Section 41 of the Employment Act is couched in mandatory terms. Where an employer fails to follow these mandatory provisions, whatever outcome of the process is bound to be unfair as the affected employee has not been accorded a hearing in the presence of their union representative.
24. In conclusion this court finds and holds that the Claimant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally unfair and unlawful.
Whether the Respondent violated the Claimant’s rights.
25. The Claimant has claimed violation of her constitutional rights under the bill of rights. This court notes that the same violations need not just be specifically pleaded but strictly proved. the Claimant ought have proved the manner of the violation with precision. In any as much as the dismissal was unfair and her rights to fair hearing were interfered with the same in total amounted unfair termination and are adequately catered for under the Employment Act. This court is guided by the court in Mumo Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others (2013) eKLR that the Petition ought to be pleaded with precision as required in constitutional Petitions and held as follows: -
It is our finding that the petition before the High Court was not pleaded with precision as required in constitutional petitions. Having reviewed the petition and supporting affidavit, we have concluded that they did not provide adequate particulars of the claims relating to the alleged violations of the Constitution of Kenya and the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission Act, 2011. Accordingly, the petition did not meet the standard enunciated in the Anarita Karimi Njeru case (supra)
26. In the above regard, this court finds and holds that that the Claimant has not illustrated with precision how her rights under the constitution were violated which could not be adequately compensated for under the provisions of the Employment Act.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
11. Having found that the claimant’s service was unfairly terminated within the meaning of section 45 of the Act, she is entitled to compensation for unfair termination as per section 49 of the Act. The Claimant had worked for the Respondent for around six years and guided by Section 49(4) of the Employment Act and taking into the reasons and process of termination considered above, the court considers 11 months salary as adequate compensation for unfair termination in the circumstances.
12. The Claimant is also entitled to Notice pay of one month as per her employment contract and the section 36 of the Employment Act since she was terminated without notice.
13. On the prayer of leave pay this being a continuous injury the claim ought to be filed within 12 months after cessation of employment as per section 90 of the Employment Act. Reliance is placed on among other cases the court of Appeal in G4S Security Services (K) Limited v Joseph Kamau & 468 others [2018] eKLR the court held as follows:
Regarding ‘a continuing injury’, the proviso to Section 90 of the Employment Act requires that the claim be made within 12 months next after the cessation thereof. The learned Judge did not determine when the continuing injury ceased, for purposes of computing the twelve month period. In the absence of a defined period, the learned Judge erred in concluding that the claims had no limitation of time. Further, upon the claimant’s dismissal, any claim based on a continuing injury ought to have been filed within one year failing which it was time barred.
13. In this case the Claimant was terminated on March 2019 and the initial claim filed in February, 2022 which is past the limitation time. The same is disallowed.
14. On the accrued half salary during the time of suspension since this court has observed that the termination was unfair and the suspension was unlawfully long then the Claimant is entitled to the balance of her salary until she was summarily dismissed as prayed.
15. The prayer for general damages for unfair labour practices and violation of right to fair administrative action fails for reasons stated above.
16. On the reimbursement of per diem allowance, the Claimant illustrated that she attended the trainings on behalf of the Respondent but no evidence of payments for the same, she is then entitled to the same. There were workshops and training invitations and approved vouchers on the said allowances tabled in evidence.
17. The Respondent should issue the Claimant with certificate of service as per section 51 of the Employment Act.
18. In conclusion the Claimant’s claim succeeds with costs as follows:
a. 11 months compensation for unlawful termination………………Kshs 151,300 x11 = Kshs 1,664,300/=
b. Notice pay…….Kshs 151,300/=
c. Reimbursement of allowances ……Kshs 280,000/=
d. Half salary balance…..Kshs 364,173/=
e. Compensation for unfair labour practices and violation of the right to Fair Administrative action...Kshs NIL
f. Leave pay……NIL
TOTAL……KSHS 2,179,773/=
g. The award shall be subject to taxes and statutory deductions but shall attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until full payment.
h. The claimant shall further have costs of the suit.
i. Certificate of service
19. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October2026
Delivered virtually this 30th day of October.2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa