Employment law

Wambui v Hallmark Marketing Ltd & another [2026] KEELRC 14979 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Petition E097 of 2022
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

THAT this application be certified urgent and be heard on a priority basis.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the objection Motion was incompetent because the Notice of Objection was filed after the Motion; whether Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited proved it was distinct from Hallmark Marketing Limited, the judgment debtor; whether it proved a legal or…

Material facts

Following the petition judgment of 28 January 2026, which awarded Fidelis Wambui Kshs. 4,426,250 for constructive and unfair dismissal on account of pregnancy, execution issued for Kshs. 5,531,280. Mbeki Auctioneers proclaimed office furniture and four…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC PETITION NO. E097 OF 2022

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

FIDELIS WAMBUI PETITIONER/DECREE HOLDER

VERSUS

HALLMARK MARKETING LIMITED RESPONDENT/JUDGMENT DEBTOR

AND

HALLMARK ADVERTISING & MARKETING LIMITED OBJECTOR/APPLICANT

R U L I N G

This is an application by way of Notice of Motion dated 20th August, 2026 and filed by Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited (the Objector) on 21st August, 2026. It is brought under Order 22 Rules 51, 52, 53 and 54 and Order 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and all other enabling provisions of the law. It seeks the following orders of court:

1. THAT this application be certified urgent and be heard on a priority basis.

2. THAT pending the inter partes hearing of this application, there be a stay of execution of the decree herein insofar as the same is being executed against the Objector/Applicant and/or the property claimed by the Objector/Applicant.

3. THAT pending the hearing and determination of this application, the Respondent/Decree Holder and its agents, servants and/or Auctioneer be restrained from removing, selling, transferring or otherwise dealing with the property proclaimed against the Objector/Applicant.

4. THAT upon hearing the objection, the attachment of the Objector/Applicant’s property be raised and the proclamation and warrant of attachment against the Objector/Applicant’s property be lifted and/or set aside.

5. THAT the Objector/Applicant be declared to have a legal and/or equitable interest in the property described in the proclamation and the same be exempted from execution in satisfaction of the decree herein.

6. THAT the costs of the objection proceedings be borne by the Decree Holder.

The Motion is based on twelve grounds on its face and on the Supporting Affidavit of Philip Wekhomba sworn on 20th August 2026.

The grounds are that:

1. The Objector/Applicant was not a party to the suit giving rise to the decree herein.

2. The Objector/Applicant was never sued, served with summons to enter appearance or called upon to defend the suit.

3. The decree herein was issued against HALLMARK MARKETING LIMITED and not against the Objector/Applicant who are HALLMARK ADVERTISING & MARKETING LIMITED.

4. There is no judgment or decree against the Objector/Applicant.

5. The Objector/Applicant has nevertheless been served with a Proclamation Notice and Warrant of Attachment in purported execution of the decree.

6. The property proclaimed and/or attached belongs to the Objector/Applicant and/or the Objector/Applicant has a legal and/or equitable interest in the same.

7. The execution process against the Objector/Applicant’s property is therefore wrongful and ought not to be permitted to proceed.

8. The Objector/Applicant has filed a Notice of Objection pursuant to Order 22 Rule 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

9. Unless execution is stayed immediately, the Auctioneer may remove and/or sell the Objector/Applicant’s property before the objection is heard and determined.

10. Such sale would occasion the Objector/Applicant substantial loss and prejudice and would render the objection proceedings nugatory.

11. The Objector/Applicant has moved the Court promptly upon becoming aware of the impugned execution.

12. It is in the interests of justice that the attachment against the Objector/Applicant’s property be stayed and ultimately raised.

The Petition was determined by judgment delivered on 28th January, 2026. This court found that the Petitioner, Fidelis Wambui (the Decree Holder), was constructively and unfairly dismissed on account of her pregnancy. It awarded her a total of Kshs. 4,426,250.00 with interest at court rates from the date of judgment and the costs of the Petition. The Respondent was named in the Petition and in the judgment as Hallmark Marketing Limited.

A warrant of attachment of movable property was issued by the Deputy Registrar on 30th July 2026 and addressed to Mbeki Auctioneers. It is for Kshs. 5,531,280.00, being the decretal sum, interest, taxed costs, further costs and court collection fees. Mbeki Auctioneers issued a proclamation. Its schedule lists office furniture and equipment and four motor vehicles, registration numbers KCS 903L, KCA 677V, KDM 449Y and KAL 460W.

The Motion was filed during the court vacation under a certificate of urgency. The parties have since filed affidavits and written submissions, and the matter is ripe for determination.

The Objector’s case is in the Supporting Affidavit of Philip Wekhomba, who deposes that he is the Non Executive Director of the Objector. He states that the Respondent in the Petition is Hallmark Marketing Limited, that the Objector was never joined or served with any process, and that on or about 14th August, 2026 a proclamation notice and warrant of attachment issued by Mbeki Auctioneers were delivered to its office premises, annexed as PW1(a) and PW1(b).

At paragraph 11 he states that the office furniture belongs to Reynard Africa on lease terms, that motor vehicle KDM 449Y is under financing through NCBA Bank, that KCS 903L is under financing through Equity Bank, and that KAL 460W is owned by the premises landlord. He deposes that the property was never the Judgment Debtor’s, that the Objector has admitted no liability for the decretal sum, and that he has lodged a Notice of Objection under Order 22 Rule 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

In its submissions dated 28th September, 2026 the Objector adds that the Judgment Debtor does not exist, that the premises are occupied by a third company, Hallmark Retail Management Limited and that a CR-12 and agreements with third parties were produced with a Further Affidavit. It accepts that the burden of proof is on an objector, argues that it has discharged it, and relies on the presumption that the registered owner of a vehicle is its owner. On the preliminary objection, it says that the Notice of Objection has since been filed and served.

The Decree Holder opposes the Motion by a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 18th September, 2026 and filed on 22nd September, 2026 by a Replying Affidavit sworn on 18th September, 2026. The Preliminary Objection is that the objection proceedings are incompetent and invalid for want of compliance with Order 22 Rule 51(1), (2) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, which the Petitioner/ Decree holder observes require a Notice of Objection to be filed before objection proceedings are instituted. She prays that the Motion be struck out with costs. In her submissions she adds that the Objector filed its Notice of Objection on 22nd September, 2026 after the Motion, and that this does not cure the defect.

On the merits, she deposes that the Respondent and the Objector are one and the same entity, and that the Respondent was named Hallmark Marketing because that is the name on the letter of 15th April, 2021 that placed her on unpaid leave. The Respondent was served at its Kileleshwa offices, appointed P.K. Mtange & Company Advocates and defended the Petition. She points to documents in the Respondent’s own affidavits that bear the Objector’s name, to bank statements showing her salary paid in the Objector’s name, and to the Objector’s CR-12, exhibited as FW-6, which lists Philip Wekhomba Muchimuti as its director. She states that he is the Philip Muchimuti who appears in the Respondent’s correspondence.

She adds that the Respondent held settlement talks through counsel and, after judgment, lodged a Notice of Appeal and applied to the Court of Appeal for a stay of execution, and that she has instructed her advocates to apply to correct the name of the Respondent. On the property, she states that the Objector has shown no proprietary interest in vehicles KDM 449Y and KCS 903L and that no registered owner or financier has objected. In her submissions dated September, 2026 she asks the court, in the alternative, to correct the name of the Judgment Debtor to Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited.

The issues for determination therefore are;

1. Whether the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 18th September 2026 is merited, that is, whether the Motion is incompetent for want of a Notice of Objection filed before it.

2. Whether the Objector has shown that it is a person distinct from the Respondent against whom the decree was issued.

3. Whether the Objector has established a legal or equitable interest in the attached property.

4. What orders should issue, including as to costs.

On the 1st issue for determination, objection to attachment is governed by Order 22 Rule 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 do not have any standing rule on the subject. Rule 73(2) forwards the execution in this court’s decrees to the Civil Procedure Rules. Both parties have proceeded under Order 22, and does this court.

Rule 51(1) allows a person claiming a legal or equitable interest in attached property to give written notice of objection to the court, the parties and the decree holder at any time prior to payment out of the proceeds of sale of such property. Rule 51(2) requires the notice to be accompanied by an application supported by affidavit. Rule 51(3) requires service within seven days of filing.

The Decree Holder says the Motion came first and the Notice followed on 22nd September, 2026. The Objector does not say otherwise: its submissions say that the Notice has since been filed. Yet ground 8 of the Motion and paragraph 19 of the Supporting Affidavit state that the Notice had already been lodged. On the account before me, it had not. This statement should not have been made in the first place.

The Decree Holder relies on the authority of Gikunji & 3 others v Nyaga & 3 others; Wahome & 16 others (Objector) [2023] KEELC 16395 (KLR). The court there held that the notice of objection is the foundation of objection proceedings, that an application taken without one is mounted in a vacuum, and that the failure was not excused by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution. Counsel in that case conceded that no notice had been filed before the objection proceedings were commenced. The decision is persuasive and I have considered it with care.

On the facts before this court lead to a different view for three reasons. Firstly, Rule 51(1) allows notice at any time prior to payment out of the proceeds of sale, no party says that a sale has taken place, and the Notice was on the record before the Motion was determined. Secondly, the Decree Holder had the Motion before her when she swore her Replying Affidavit on 18th September, 2026 answered it in full and filed submissions on the merits. She has not said what prejudice the order of events caused her. Thirdly, striking out the Motion would achieve nothing beyond delay because the Objector could file a fresh application with the Notice before any sale and the same issues would return to this court.

Article 159(2)(d) does not excuse a party from the Rules, and the inaccurate statement that the Notice had been lodged is not condoned. But a defect of sequence which has caused no prejudice, and which was cured before any sale, does not on its own defeat an objection that can still be brought. The preliminary objection is therefore overruled, and the Objector’s lapse is a matter this court takes into account on costs.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the Objector has shown that it is a person distinct from the Respondent against whom the decree was issued. The Objector’s central contention is that it is a stranger to the decree. It says the decree is against Hallmark Marketing Limited, that it is Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited, and that the two are different companies. It is not in doubt that the Objector is a registered company. The question is whether the Respondent, sued as Hallmark Marketing Limited, is the Objector under a wrong name.

The Objector asserts that it is a distinct person, and so it must prove it. Section 107 of the Evidence Act, Chapter 80, Laws of Kenya puts the burden on the party who asserts a fact. The Supporting Affidavit does not speak to the incorporation of either company. The Objector’s submissions say that the Judgment Debtor does not exist but no search showing that is exhibited to the affidavit confirm against the Further Affidavit. The only CR-12 identifiable on the record is the Decree Holder’s, exhibited as FW-6 and dated 1st December, 2022.

The evidence points the other way. The pay reduction notice of 1st April, 2020 is on the letterhead of Hallmark Marketing, at Gatundu Close, Off Nyeri Road, Kileleshwa, with post office box 102364-00100, and is signed by Philip Muchimuti as Executive Director and Board Chairman. The letter of 13th July, 2020 on the letterhead of Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited gives the same address and post office box. The CR-12 of the Objector shows one director and shareholder, Philip Wekhomba Muchimuti, with the same post office box. The Objector’s deponent signs as Philip Wekhomba. He does not say that he is a different person from the Philip Muchimuti who signed the 2020 notice, and the Objector’s submissions do not answer the Decree Holder’s assertion that he is the same man.

The Respondent defended the Petition through counsel and filed a Replying Affidavit sworn by Heri Nyaki Gathuru on 25th July, 2022. Its annexures include the letter of 13th July, 2020 and the warning letter of 15th March, 2021 on the Objector’s letterhead, and emails whose signature block reads Hallmark Advertising & Marketing Limited. No one objected to the name of the Respondent at any stage. That deponent also speaks of the Non Executive Director of the company, and the Objector’s deponent describes himself as the Non Executive Director of the Objector.

The Decree Holder’s bank statements, exhibited as FW-5, carry entries narrated HALLMARK ADVERTISING AND and HALLMARK ADVERT MKTING, which she says are her salary. The correspondence between counsel in 2023, exhibited as FW-7, shows settlement talks. After judgment the Respondent lodged a Notice of Appeal and an application for stay in the Court of Appeal. The Objector has not denied these steps.

A company is a legal person separate from its directors and from other companies, and a decree against one company cannot be executed against the property of another. But a mistake in a party’s name is not the same as suing the wrong party. In Kenya Hotels and Allied Workers Union v Diani Sea Resort T/A Carslake Nominee Limited [2015] KEELRC 528 (KLR) the Industrial Court at Mombasa held that employees are not to be shut out because they have misnamed their employer, and that the consequence is an amendment of the record. The same reasoning applies at execution where, as here, the employer knew the claim and defended it.

On the material before me the Objector has not shown that it is a stranger to the decree. The weight of the evidence points the other way: the same address and post office box, the same controlling mind, correspondence under both names, a defence conducted without objection to the name and steps taken after judgment in the Respondent’s name.

This court does not decide that the two are one and the same company. That question calls for an application to correct the name, on notice, and none is before me. The Decree Holder says she will bring one. The request in her submissions is not a substitute for it and I make no order on it.

On the 3rd issue for determination, whatever the answer on the identity of the Objector, the Motion succeeds only if the Objector shows a legal or equitable interest in the attached property. Rule 51(1) speaks of a person claiming to be entitled to, or to have a legal or equitable interest in, the property attached. The Objector accepts that the burden is on it.

The Objector does not claim to own any of the property. Its affidavit says that the furniture belongs to Reynard Africa, that two vehicles are financed by banks and that the third belongs to the landlord. Each of those is an interest belonging to someone else. Reynard Africa, NCBA Bank, Equity Bank and the landlord have not objected, and none has sworn an affidavit.

On the furniture, the only document the Objector offers is a screenshot of an email from a person named Kelvin of Reynard Africa. It forwards quotations that are not attached and says that the firm did not quote for cleaning the seats. It does not say that Reynard Africa owns any furniture at the Objector’s premises or that any lease exists. No lease, invoice or letter from Reynard Africa has been produced.

Motor vehicle KDM 449Y is shown on its registration certificate as registered to NCBA Bank Kenya PLC and to Hallmark Retail Management Limited. The Objector is neither, and it does not explain its relationship to that company. The certificate dates from the vehicle’s registration in 2023 and is not a current search. Motor vehicle KCS 903L is shown in the NTSA copy of records as at 20th August, 2026 as registered to Philip Wekhomba Muchimuti, with a charge in favour of Equity Bank (Kenya) Limited. The affidavit does not disclose that it is registered in his own name and a vehicle registered to a director is not on that account the company’s property.

The NTSA copy of records for motor vehicle KAL 460W, also as at 20th August 2026, shows a 1994 vehicle with no owner’s name on the exhibited copy. The Objector says it belongs to the premises landlord, but it does not name the landlord or produce a lease. Motor vehicle KCA 677V appears only in the schedule of proclaimed property. Paragraph 11 of the Supporting Affidavit does not mention it and the submissions place it under financing by Equity Bank at one point and by NCBA Bank at another, without any document.

The Objector relies on the presumption that the registered owner of a vehicle is its owner. The presumption helps the person whose name is on the register, and on the records the Objector itself exhibited that is not the Objector. The Objector has therefore not shown a legal or equitable interest, in its own right, in any item of the attached property. A person who says that attached goods belong to someone else, and claims no interest of its own, is not an objector within Rule 51.

This ruling does not prejudice any person who is not before this court, such as a lessor of the furniture, a financing bank or a registered owner, who proves an interest in any of the property and objects in accordance with Order 22.

On the 4th issue for determination, prayers 1, 2 and 3 of the Motion were interlocutory and are spent with its determination. Prayers 4 and 5 fail for the reasons given above.

Costs are in the discretion of the Court under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, and ordinarily follow the event. The Objector has failed on every issue. Its Motion stated that a Notice of Objection had already been filed when it had not, and the Decree Holder, who has waited since the judgment of 28th January, 2026 to execute has had to answer it with a Preliminary Objection, a Replying Affidavit and submissions. I see no reason to depart from the general rule. The Objector shall bear the Decree Holder’s costs of the Motion.

I am therefore inclined to dismiss the Notice of Motion dated 20th August, 2026 and order as follows;

i) The Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 18th September, 2026 is overruled.

ii) The Notice of Motion dated 20th August, 2026 be and is hereby dismissed.

iii) Any interim orders issued in respect of the Notice of Motion be and are hereby discharged.

iv) The Decree Holder be and is hereby at liberty to proceed with execution of the decree in accordance with the law.

v) The Decree Holder’s request to correct the name of the Respondent is not before this court by way of application and this court does not make order on it.

vi) The Decree holder be and is hereby always at liberty to apply on (v) above.

vii) The costs of this application shall be borne by the Judgment Debtor and Objector.

Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mr. Amalemba instructed by Amalemba & Associates Advocates for the Petitioner/Decree Holder.

2. Mr. Nyangena instructed by Kerandi Manduku & Company Advocates for the Objector/Applicant.

3. Mr. Mtange instructed by P.K. Mtange & Company Advocates for the Respondent/Judgment Debtor.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder