Background
THAT the Appellant’s Record of Appeal dated 3rd February 2026, does not contain the Decree appealed from making it fatally defective and ripe for striking out.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
THAT the Appellant’s Record of Appeal dated 3rd February 2026, does not contain the Decree appealed from making it fatally defective and ripe for striking out.
Paragraph 1 →Whether the appeal record was fatally defective, or deprived the Employment and Labour Relations Court of jurisdiction, because it initially omitted the decree; whether the appellant could validly file a supplementary record containing the decree without…
Amos Kipkurui Tuwei appealed against the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Milimani judgment of 21 July 2025 in CMEL No. E1329 of 2022, which dismissed his suit with costs. His record of appeal, filed on 18 February 2026, contained pleadings, proceedings and the…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E269 OF 2025
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
AMOS KIPKURUI TUWEI………………………………………….……… APPELLANT
VERSUS
WINGUARDS SERVICES LIMITED …………………… RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
RULING
This is an application dated 7th April, 2026 and seeks the following orders of court;
1. THAT the Appellant’s Record of Appeal dated 3rd February 2026, does not contain the Decree appealed from making it fatally defective and ripe for striking out.
2. THAT it is trite law that a Record of Appeal must contain the decree appealed from and without it, this honourable court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the Appeal.
3. THAT service of the memorandum of appeal did not contain any case number and without adequate particulars, the respondent was denied a fair opportunity to peruse the record and prepare a defence.
4. THAT the mode of service of the Record of Appeal was improper and was intended to deny the Respondent the right to peruse the Record of Appeal and defend the same.
5. THAT the Respondent only became aware of the irregularities upon being given a hearing date before the Judge and after perusing the Public Kiosk.
6. THAT we urge this honourable court to dismiss the Appeal in its entirety for lack of the decree appealed from and improper service.
7. THAT the Respondent herein be awarded costs.
The Respondent did not draw or file any reply to the application. This court presumed that it sought to rely only on the written submissions and no more. This is permissible. The conduct of litigation is sizably, if not wholly, the responsibilities of the parties.
The application arises from an appeal against the judgment of the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Milimani delivered on 21st July, 2025 in CMEL No. E1329 of 2022, in which the trial court dismissed the Appellant’s suit and awarded costs to the Respondent. The Appellant filed a Memorandum of Appeal dated 5th August, 2025 and a Record of Appeal dated 3rd February, 2026, which was filed on 18th February, 2026. The record contains the pleadings, the proceedings and the judgment of the trial court. It does not contain a decree of court.
The application is supported by the affidavit of Caleb Otieno sworn on 7th April, 2026 and a further affidavit sworn on 17th April, 2026. The Appellant opposed it through a replying affidavit dated 10th April, 2026 and filed a Supplementary Record of Appeal dated the same day which, both parties agree, contains the decree. The parties filed rival written submissions, the Respondent’s dated 30th April, 2026 and the Appellant’s filed on 6th May, 2026.
The Respondent’s case is that a record of appeal without the decree appealed from is fatally defective and that this court has no jurisdiction to entertain such appeal. It relies on Rule 15(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 which requires a record of appeal comprising a certified copy of the pleadings, the proceedings, any documentary evidence relied on and the judgment, ruling, decision, order, decree or award appealed against. It also relies on the authority of Jomo Kenyatta Foundation v JA (a minor suing through his next friend and father JA) (Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2012), in which the High Court at Nyeri held that without the decree or order appealed from there is, in effect, no appeal.
The Respondent further contends that the Supplementary Record was filed without leave contrary to Rule 16, that Rule 19 allows only a respondent to supplement a record, and that it is prejudiced because the appeal had already proceeded to hearing. On service, it says that the physical record served on its advocates bore no case number and that no mention notices were served. It asks that the Record of Appeal and the Supplementary Record be struck out with costs.
The Appellant’s case is that the application rests on the Civil Procedure Act and Rules, which do not govern this court. He relies on Vincent Mwatsuma Nguma & 5 others v Kilifi Mariakani Water & Sewerage Co Ltd (KIMAWASCO) [2021] KEELRC 622 (KLR) and on Benedict Ojou Juma & 10 others v A. J. Pereira & Sons Limited [2016] eKLR, as cited. He reads the words “ruling, decision, order, decree or award” in Rule 15(1) as alternatives, so that a decree is not mandatory and says that Rule 15(4) allows the court to call for the trial court file.
The Appellant contends that Rule 19(3) allows an appellant to lodge a supplementary record at any time, that no prejudice has been shown, that parties are yet to file submissions on the appeal, and that the application does not seek to strike out the Supplementary Record. He takes no position on service, maintaining that it was properly done and that no particulars of any defect have been given. He prays that the application be dismissed with costs.
The court has considered the Notice of Motion, the affidavits and the rival submissions. The application is expressed to be brought under Order 42 rules 2 and 13 and Order 51 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules together with sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. Order 42 regulates appeals to the High Court. Appeals to this court are governed by the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, and court has found no provision in them that imports Order 42 into appeals before this court. A party may resort to the Civil Procedure Act and Rules in this court only where the ELRC Rules sanction it: This is the rationale in the authority of Vincent Mwatsuma Nguma & 5 others v Kilifi Mariakani Water & Sewerage Co Ltd (KIMAWASCO) [2021] KEELRC 622 (KLR.) The Appellant is right on that point. It does not follow that the application is a nullity. The complaint, that the record lacks a document, is squarely addressed by Rules 15, 16 and 19 which both parties argued, and Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution requires justice to be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities. I will therefore determine the application under the ELRC Rules.
Rule 15(1) provides that a memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied by a record of appeal comprising a certified copy of pleadings, the proceedings, any documentary evidence relied on, and the judgment, ruling, decision, order, decree or award appealed against. The last limb describes the decision under appeal in whatever form the forum below rendered it. The same formula appears in Rule 11(1) which lists what an intending appellant must request from the forum below. It describes the decision appealed against and is not a checklist of separate documents. Here, the decision appealed against is the judgment of the trial court, which the Memorandum of Appeal states is appealed against in whole. That judgment is in the record together with the pleadings and the proceedings. The Respondent’s reading, that the word “decree” makes a decree mandatory, is not fanciful and the preference goes to the Appellant’s.
The authority in Jomo Kenyatta Foundation does not assist the Respondent. This is because it was decided on section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 42 rules 1(2), 2 and 13(4) of the Civil Procedure Rules, which govern appeals from subordinate courts to the High Court and not appeals to this court. Even there, Order 42 rule 2 allowed the decree to be filed after the memorandum of appeal, and the appeal was struck out because there was no evidence that the decree had ever been applied for. The jurisdiction of this court comes from Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. It does not turn on whether a particular document is in the record.
The omission of a document goes to the completeness of the record. The Rules allow a record to be supplemented under Rules 16 and 19 and allow the court to call for and rely on the trial court file under Rule 15(4). In Frodak Kenya Limited v Makunda [2024] KEELRC 1689 (KLR) the court set aside an order striking out an appeal whose record lacked a certified decree and allowed the appellant to supplement it. The omission of the decree therefore did not render the appeal incompetent and, in any event, has been cured by the Supplementary Record.
Rule 16 provides that the appellant may, with leave of the court, file and serve a supplementary memorandum of appeal or a supplementary record of appeal. Rule 19(3) provides that an appellant may, at any time, lodge copies of a supplementary record of appeal and as soon as practicable thereafter, serve copies of it on every respondent. The two provisions do not sit easily together, and the Respondent’s answer that Rule 19 is for respondents overlooks sub-rule (3). It is not necessary to resolve the tension. Even if leave was required, the failure to seek it is a procedural lapse, the Rules do not say that a record filed without leave is a nullity and Rule 16 itself vests the power to grant leave in the court.
The Supplementary Record contains the very document the Respondent says was missing and was filed within days of the application. The Respondent says the appeal had already proceeded to hearing but identifies no step it took, or in any event lost the chance to take, because of the timing of the filing. It can hardly claim prejudice from receiving the decree it demanded. That the filing was an afterthought does not matter. The application is dated 7th April, 2026 and the Supplementary Record 10th April, 2026, and the application does not seek to strike it out. A prayer cannot be added through a further affidavit and submissions. To the extent that leave was required, this court grants it in the interest of justice, and the Supplementary Record be and is hereby deemed as properly on record.
The complaints on service, in prayers 3, 4 and 5, were not pressed in the Respondent’s submissions beyond background and an allegation of malice. The email exchange of 19th and 20th February, 2026 shows that the Appellant’s counsel sent the record to the Respondent’s counsel on 19th February, 2026, that by 20th February, 2026 the Respondent’s counsel had learnt the case number and followed it up on the public kiosk. Further, the Appellant’s counsel apologised for the oversight in not serving mention notices. No affidavit of service was filed, and one should have been so filed.
The Rules, however, prescribe no sanction of striking out or dismissal for want of mention notices. The Respondent does not say that the Memorandum of Appeal was served outside the twenty-one days allowed by Rule 13. It has appeared, filed its application, a further affidavit and submissions, and been fully heard. No prejudice has been shown, and dismissing an appeal in its entirety on that account would deny the Appellant a hearing on the merits. Prayers 3, 4, 5 and 6 therefore fail. This ruling is confined to the matters raised in the application and does not determine any other objection to the competence of the appeal, none having been raised before me.
Costs are in the discretion of the court under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. The application arose from a real omission in the Appellant’s record, which he cured within days, and the Respondent was not unreasonable in raising it. Each party shall bear its own costs.
I am therefore inclined to dismiss the application and order as follows;
i) The Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 7th April, 2026 be and is hereby dismissed.
ii) Leave is granted, to the extent that it was required, for the filing of the Supplementary Record of Appeal dated 10th April, 2026 which is properly on record and shall be read together with the Record of Appeal dated 3rd February, 2026.
iii) The appeal shall be mentioned on 2nd December, 2026 for directions on the filing of submissions and the hearing of the appeal, in the alternative, for compliances and directions of court.
iv) Each party shall bear its own costs of the application.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Wetaba instructed by Wetaba, Were & Associate Advocates for the Appellant.
2. Miss Mwangi holding brief for Miss Kathambi instructed by Kathambi Rwito & Co. Advocates for the Respondent.