REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E101 OF 2026
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
IN THE MATTER OF THE CONTRAVENTION & THREATENED CONTRAVENTION OF ARTICLES 2, 3, 10, 22, 23, 25, 27(1),(2),(4),(5), 41(1), 47(1),(2), 48, AND 50 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA IN SO FAR AS THE CONSTITUTION HAS BEEN, AND STANDS TO BE VIOLATED
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF THE CONTRAVENTION AND/OR VIOLATION OF FAIRTRADE’S HUMAN RESOURCE POLICY MANUAL AND WHISTLE-BLOWING POLICY
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF THE CHALLENGE OF UNLAWFUL, ILLEGAL, UNPROCEDURAL, AND UNCONSTITUTIONAL DISCIPLINARY PROCESS OR PLANNED DISCIPLINARY PROCESS AS AGAINST THE PETITIONER AND THE FAILING, IGNORING, NEGLECTING AND/OR REFUSING TO GRANT THE PETITIONER FAIRNESS
-BETWEEN-
ISAAC TONGOLA………….………………………………..………………………………………………………….PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
COMMERCE EQUITABLE AFRIQUE (CEA)
T/A FAIRTRADE AFRICA……………………………………………………..……………………………………RESPONDENT
Coram
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The Petitioner was an employee of the Respondent in the capacity of Executive Director (Chief Executive Officer) when he was faced with a disciplinary process over whistleblower allegations of misconduct. The employer issued him a letter of suspension pending investigations. He was issued with a show cause and responded. The employer later reinstated him on completion of the investigation, having considered the response. The employer then embarked on further proceedings related to the disciplinary process. The Petitioner was aggrieved by the subsequent steps post the reinstatement and filed this suit vide a Petition dated 25th March 2026, alleging unfair labour practice and violation of his right to a fair hearing, and sought the following relief:-
a) A declaration that the reinstatement of the Petitioner vide the letter of reinstatement dated 5th March 2026 was final and the Petitioner cannot be disciplined twice over the same offence.
b) An order revoking any decision of the Respondent emanating from any disciplinary process arising from the suspension cum notice to show cause, investigation and/or Notice to Show cause dated 13th February 2026.
c) An order revoking any advertisement or recruitment to the current employment position of the Petitioner.
d) An order of permanent injunction restraining the respondent either by themselves, employees, servants, partners, parent organization(s) and/or agents from terminating the employment of the Petitioner based on the suspension/Notice to show cause letter dated 13th February 2026.
e) The costs of this Petition be borne by the Respondent.
2. The Petition was filed alongside the Affidavit in Support of Petition sworn by the Petitioner on 25th March 2026, and the Petitioner’s List and Bundle of Documents of even date.
3. In response to the said Petition, the Respondent filed a Replying Affidavit sworn by HEND MOHAMED HELMY KASSAB on 23rd July 2026 with annexures thereto.
4. To counter the Respondent’s response, the Petitioner filed a Further Affidavit sworn by him on 1st September 2026, and another sworn by PETER DANKU-ELSENBROEK on the same date.
The Petitioner’s case in summary
5. The Petitioners’ case is that he was employed by the Respondent on a three (3) year contract in 2022 as the Executive Director (Chief Executive Officer), and this contract lapsed in 2025. The contract of employment was subsequently renewed for another five (5) year term up to 2030.
6. The Petitioner’s grievance is that on 13th February 2026 while the Petitioner was away in Agadir, Morocco on official duty, he was suspended by the Respondent’s Board of Directors vide Suspension Letter/Notice to Show Cause, and Notification, both dated 13th February 2026. The charge brought against him was that the investigation into the whistle-blowing allegations against him had been concluded. There was no further attachments or information on the charge within the Notice to Show cause, with the Petitioner only being supplied with further information on 17th February 2026 upon his request. While the Respondent stated in the Notice to Show Cause that they had already constituted a disciplinary committee, they had not accorded the Petitioner an opportunity to be heard and to submit his written responses to the unfounded and trumped-up allegations. Further, the Petitioner complains that he had already been blocked, prior to receiving the Suspension Letter/Notice to Show Cause, from accessing the Respondent company email on his work laptop and phone in total violation of the Respondent’s ICT Policy which provides that blocking occurs only for staff or board members who have been terminated or have left the employment of the Respondent company. The Petitioner takes issue with the simultaneous issuance of the Notice to Show Cause and the notification that the investigation into the allegations had been completed.
7. It is averred that during the suspension, the Petitioner was denied access to information relevant to the allegations levelled against him, despite submitting a request to the Respondent’s Board of Directors. After receiving his response, however, the Respondent’s Board resolved to immediately reinstate the Petitioner which they did vide the letter dated 5th March 2026 signed by the Chairperson. The Petitioner’s reinstatement was also confirmed by the Chairperson of the Case Management Committee for the investigation into the whistle-blowing allegations, a Board Member of the Respondent, in his email dated 11th April 2026.
8. The Petitioner avers that he is aware that the Board of Directors vide its Board resolution of 23rd March 2026 indicated its determination to terminate his contract of employment and engaged a third party to provide them with an opinion on the intended termination. According to the Petitioner, the engagement of a third party to provide opinion to the Respondent even after reinstating the Petitioner implies that the Respondent’s Board did not fairly review the Petitioner’s response, and there is an ulterior motive to find fault with the Petitioner. The Petitioner’s case is that due process, in line with the Respondent’s Human Resource Policy Manual, requires that no further investigation, disciplinary action, or vilification against the Petitioner could continue, because reinstating him after the suspension ordinarily concluded the matter. Further, although the Respondent’s Whistle-blowing Policy states that allegations by a whistle-blower can be investigated in line with the Respondent’s HR Policy, Clause 15.3.3 of the HR Policy requires that, for an investigation to be done, the person making the allegation must not be anonymous. It provides that “Anonymous grievances will not be investigated”. The Petitioner avers that neither the Respondent nor its Board of Directors knows the whistle-blower/complainant as stated in the board meeting on 5th March 2026, which invalidates the investigation and the allegations.
9. The Petitioner avers that the Respondent’s HR Policy Manual also requires that if it is necessary to extend the investigation period for allegations and grievances, the investigator or the person responsible for the investigation must first agree with the employee. In the alternative, the chairperson should agree with the employee on the extensions to the timelines and keep the employee up to date, at intervals to be agreed. The Petitioner complains that in his case, the investigation started almost out of time, and it was conducted beyond the maximum 45 days provided in the Respondent‘s Whistle-blowing Policy. Further, the need for extension beyond the 45 days was never or has never been brought to the attention of the Petitioner. The Petitioner states that he verbally sought feedback in December 2025 from the Chairperson of the Respondent’s Case Management Committee, to no avail.
10. Another grievance raised by the Petitioner is that a retrial of the Petitioner by the Respondent’s Board over the same issues that he was cleared of and reinstated contravenes the Respondent’s Human Resource Policy Manual which provides that investigations and/or disciplinary process must be consistent, prompt, impartial, reasonable and applied without any form of discrimination. The Petitioner states that the Respondent’s conduct demonstrates blatant unfairness, unreasonableness, and partiality. The Petitioner further relies on Clauses 1.4 and 4.1 of the HR Policy which provide that an employee should be suspended to pave way for investigations. On the contrary, the Respondent presented the Petitioner with a complete investigation report on 13th February 2026 and then afterwards handed a suspension letter upon the Petitioner. The Petitioner calls into question the purpose of the suspension, stating that a suspension is a punishment which can only be meted out after the accused employee has been afforded an opportunity to respond to the charges set out in the show-cause notice. Additionally, he states that under the HR Policy, the suspension process ought to comply with the principles of natural justice and must only last for a period of fourteen (14) working days maximum, during which period all deliberations must have been completed, a response from the accused employee obtained, and a decision reached by the Respondent.
11. The Petitioner views his suspension while on a work assignment in Morocco and the issuance of the suspension letter at night as evidence of the Respondent’s partiality, unfairness, and ulterior motives. The Respondent’s ulterior motives, malice and bias against the Petitioner are further demonstrated, according to the Petitioner, by the fact that one of the Respondent’s Board members actively conducted interviews to replace the Petitioner as an Executive Director/CEO of the Respondent before the outcome of a disciplinary process had been communicated, during the Petitioner’s suspension as noted in the Board meeting of 5th March 2026; and by the attempt by a section of the Respondent’s Board members on 4th March 2026 to pass a resolution in a meeting without quorum to re-engage the external investigator (IKM Advocates) over the allegations against him.
12. It is the Petitioner’s case that he is unlikely to get a fair hearing if the Respondent is permitted to conduct a retrial of his disciplinary case, especially as they appear hell-bent on circumventing their own decision of having reinstated or absolved the Petitioner from any blame.
13. The Petitioner pleads that his Constitutional right to access information was violated by the Respondent when they blocked the Petitioner’s access to his work phone, laptop, and email prior to his suspension and denied his request to access the same. He also states that his Constitutional rights to fair labour practice, fair administrative action and fair hearing were violated. According to him, an unconstitutional decision is not a law and confers no rights, imposes no duties, affords no protection, creates no office, and it is in legal contemplation as inoperative as though it had never been passed.
14. The Petitioner challenges the Respondent’s Replying Affidavit dated 23rd July 2026 on the premise that the deponent thereof is not authorized to swear the same as the Board Charter at Clause 7(a)(x) requires the Chairperson of the Respondent’s Board to represent the Respondent in formal matters.
15. The Petitioner’s witness, PETER DANKU, contends that in March 2026, the CEO of Fairtrade International, the Chairperson of Fairtrade International, and the Chairperson of Fairtrade International’s governance committee called, and wrote emails and WhatsApp messages to the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson of the Respondent’s Board, as well as the greater Board, to demand forceful termination of the petitioner’s contract, in a manner that pointed at collusion between the Respondent’s Board and its affiliate Fairtrade International. He confirms that on 24th March 2026, he cautioned the Respondent’s Board against re-engagement of the investigator (IKM), since the Respondent’s HR Policy provides that an investigation cannot be done when the identity of the complainant is not known. The witness also confirms that some members of the Case Management Committee had determined that the full whistleblowing allegations would not be shared with the petitioner, and that only a redacted version would be sent to him demonstrating, according to the witness, a deliberately and maliciously compromised and subjective investigatory process right from the outset, where the Petitioner had been found before obtaining all the facts.
Respondent’s case in brief
16. The Respondent admits that the Petitioner is their employee and was subjected to disciplinary proceedings. They explain that the Respondent’s Board of Directors received a Whistleblowing Report on 21st July 2025 that had been shared anonymously by email with Fairtrade Africa Board members, Fairtrade International Board members, and the Chief Executive Officers of various National Fairtrade Organisations within the Fairtrade system, during a period when Fair Trade Africa was on the cusp of preparing for the 6th Annual General Assembly and celebration of Fairtrade Africa 20 years existence (FTA@20) when it intended to lodge its new Strategic Plan for the period 2026 - 2028. Upon receipt of the Report, it is stated that Fair Trade Africa invoked its internal Whistleblowing Policy and held an initial Special Board meeting on 25th July 2025 to consider the matter. The Governance and Legal Lead was then invited to advise the Board on the next steps required under the Fair Trade Africa Whistleblowing Policy. As the matter progressed, the Fair Trade Africa Board, through the Governance and Legal Lead, was informed of a potential Board level leak, which was noted after the Petitioner began attempting to cover his tracks by requesting for documentation including procurement documentation and HR files from staff. The Board was requested to maintain confidentiality and uphold their fiduciary duties.
17. It is averred that after the 25th July 2025 meeting, the Fair Trade Africa Board members formed a Case Management Committee that consisted of the Chair of the Audit & Risk Committee, an Independent Member of the Nominations Committee, an Independent Member of the Governance Committee, an Independent Member of the Audit & Risk Committee, and an Independent Member of the Human Resource Committee. Due to potential conflicts of interest, the Petitioner and the then outgoing Board Chair, were excluded from the Case Management Committee and from all Board deliberations relating to the whistleblowing matter. The Fir Trade Africa HR Manager and Legal representatives, including both internal and external counsel, were also excluded from the CMC because they were likely to be required as witnesses, given that some of the matters raised in the report related to legal and human resource issues.
18. The mandate of the Case Management Committee as set by the Board was to conduct an urgent prima facie review of the case and advise the Board on whether the claims warranted a formal investigation, and whether it was appropriate to suspend the Petitioner while the allegations were being investigated. The Chair of the of the Audit & Risk Committee was appointed Chair of the Case Management Committee. The Respondent confirms that on 28th July 2025, the Board through the Case Management Committee Chair sent an email notification to the Petitioner and the outgoing Board Chair, informing them that a whistleblowing report against them had been received and the Board had triggered aspects of the Whistle Blowing Policy and constituted the Case Management Committee to look into the matter. In August 2025, the Case Management Committee held an inception meeting and upon evaluation of the matter determined that the issues raised should be investigated further. It requested the Board to allocate resources necessary for a thorough investigation, allowing the recruitment of an external investigator with expertise in Whistleblowing investigations, forensic investigations and employment and labour relations matters. The Case Management Committee’s requests were granted, with IKM Advocates being engaged as the external Lead Investigators on 20th August 2025.
19. The Respondent states that on 15th August 2025 before the investigations had commenced, a second Whistleblower had sent an email to the Fair Trade Africa Board, the first Whistleblower and the Fair Trade Africa System Members, defending the Petitioner against the first Report and leveling accusations against several staff members for wrongdoing. It also expressed that a harsh work environment had been created in which staff were allegedly monitored and blamed for the initial whistleblowing report concerning the Petitioner. On 19th August 2025, the first Whistleblower responded via email back to all Fair Trade Africa System partners, the Fair Trade Africa Board, the Fairtrade International Board and National Fairtrade Organisations CEOs, stating that the second Whistleblower was not him/her but that it was actually the Petitioner himself, highlighting the differentiation in the two emails sent.
20. The Respondent states that between September and October 2025, IKM Advocates, having been furnished with the necessary information and documents, investigated the matter through document reviews, email correspondence, selected staff interviews conducted both in person and virtually, including with the Petitioner, forensic document reviews, and further email clarifications and correspondence. They then prepared a final report arising from the investigation and shared it with the Case Management Committee in October 2025, indicating their findings and recommendations. The Board and the Case Management Committee held a joint meeting on 6th January 2026, at which the CMC presented its final report. The report indicated that some matters raised required the Petitioner's response through a show cause letter and the commencement of a disciplinary process.
21. Subsequently, on 16th February 2026, a show cause letter was served on the Petitioner, who was afforded an opportunity to respond to certain findings in the investigation report that required further clarification. The Petitioner was also placed on a 14-day suspension, commencing on the same day. The Respondent admits that the Petitioner responded to the show cause letter on 20th February 2026, vide three separate documents. They also admit that, despite receiving the Petitioner’s response, they could not convene within the 5-day suspension window to review the Petitioner's responses, as provided for in the Fair Trade Africa HR Policy, due to the volume of documentation and pre-planned commitments by Board members. The Board was further unable to meet to review the responses between 20th February 2026 and 2nd March 2026, as Board members are non-executive and have other work commitments. During the same period, discussions were also ongoing between the Board and IKM Advocates regarding engagement of the firm to assist in reviewing the Petitioner's responses. In the meantime, the Petitioner wrote to the Board indicating that an extension of the suspension period would be a breach of the HR Policy, which provided for only a 14-day suspension.
22. The Fair Trade Africa Board finally met on 5th March 2026 specifically to discuss the issue of the lapse in time, and resolved to lift the suspension and have the Petitioner resume his duties. The Petitioner was issued with a letter requesting him to resume his duties, but the Respondent clarifies that the letter expressly indicated that the Board would invite him at a later date to clarify his responses. The Respondent denies that the Petitioner was explicitly or implicitly informed that he had been cleared of the allegations against him, and instead states that it was made clear to him that the disciplinary process was ongoing. In accordance with the letter, it is stated that the Petitioner reported back to the office on 9th of March 2025.
23. It is the Respondent’s case that the suspension of the Petitioner from office was a human resource tool intended to permit investigation of the allegations of misconduct against him, rather than a disciplinary action. They point out that during the Petitioner's suspension, he remained an employee of the Respondent with all the rights and privileges attendant thereto. Further, they emphasize that the letter reinstating the Petitioner to his position did not absolve him of any wrongdoing as a scheduled hearing was being contemplated, and that contrary to his claims, a disciplinary hearing arising from the issues for which the Petitioner was suspended cannot amount to double jeopardy as he has not been absolved. The Respondent takes the view that the Petitioner has approached the Court to prevent a lawful disciplinary process brought against him, and urges the Court to refrain from usurping their day-to-day administrative mandate as an employer, including managing a disciplinary process arising from misconduct at the workplace.
DETERMINATION
24. Following directions by the court that parties should file written submissions, both parties complied.
Issues for determination
24. In his submissions dated 1st September 2026, the Petitioner identified the following issues for determination:
i. Whether the Petitioner’s predicament is a case of Double Jeopardy;
ii. Whether the attempt by the Respondent to subject the Petitioner to a second disciplinary process is procedurally fair, lawful and constitutional;
iii. iii. Who bears the cost of the Petition.
25. On their part, the Respondent identified the following issues for determination in their submissions dated 11th September 2026:
i. Whether the Petitioner has established a prima fade case to warrant conservatory orders.
ii. Whether the doctrine of double jeopardy applies in these circumstances.
iii. Whether this Honourable Court should interfere with an unconcluded internal disciplinary process.
iv. Whether the supporting affidavit of Mr. Peter Danku and the documents annexed thereto are properly before the Court.
v. Whether the Petitioner's allegations of bias, predetermination and constitutional prejudice are substantiated.
26. The Court, having perused the pleadings and submissions, was of the considered opinion that the issue for determination was whether there was a violation of the Petitioner's constitutional rights of fair labour practice and fair hearing.
The Law
27. Articles 41(1) and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya
Whether there was a violation of the Petitioner's constitutional rights of fair labour practice and fair hearing.
28. At the outset, the court (Justice Dr Gakeri) ordered that the status quo be maintained, meaning no further disciplinary proceedings pending hearing and determination of the suit. The parties opted to have the court proceed straight to the petition; thus, the pending application is deemed as determined under this judgment.
29. It is trite that any ambiguity in a document from the employer is to be construed in favour of the employee. ‘Contra proferentem (Latin: "against [the] offeror"),[1] also known as "interpretation against the draftsman", is a doctrine of contractual interpretation providing that, where a promise, agreement or term is ambiguous, the preferred meaning should be the one that works against the interests of the party who provided the wording.’(Wikipedia).
30. Vide letter dated 11th February 2026, the petitioner was issued with a notice to show cause dated 13th February 2026, which indicated investigations were being done pursuant to a whistleblower report issued on 21st July 2026. He was asked to show cause in 5 days why disciplinary action should not be taken against him.
31. The letter further stated, “pending the conclusion of the disciplinary process you will be suspended from your duties with pay and will not have access to the organization system during this period” (page 63 of petitioner’s document). He proceeded on suspension. The petitioner complied and sent to the employer a response dated 20th February 2026 (pages 65 – 98) and a further response of even date (99 – 106) of the petition.
32. The employer (Respondent) on the 5th March 2026 through its chairman, one Benjamin Francklin KOUAME, wrote to the petitioner as follows:
“05 March 2026
Mr. Isaac Tongola
Subject: Your response to the formal notice regarding the whistleblower case.
Sir,
Following your response concerning the whistleblower case, the Board of Directors would like to inform you that it has considered your response to the Notice to Show Cause.
In accordance with our Human Resources policy, the Board of Directors has deliberated and decided the following:
1. You are reinstated to your position as Executive Director, effective immediately.
2. However, due to the importance and sensitive nature of the matter, the FTA Board of Directors will invite you in the coming days to be heard to clarify your responses further.
3. Only the documents in our possession as part of your response will be analyzed for any further reference by the Board of Directors.
4. You must perform your duties in strict accordance with your job description, without discussion any issues related to the whistleblower's case with staff or any third parties.
The Board of Directors reserves the right to ensure compliance with the spirit and letter of this notice.
On behalf of the FTA Board of Directors,
Benjamin Francklin KOUAME
The Board Chairperson”
33. The petitioner acknowledged the letter by the respondent vide email of 8th March 2026 and thanked the board for reinstating him to his role as Executive Director of Fairtrade Africa. The petitioner expressed enthusiasm to continue working having been reinstated (page 143 of petitioner).
34. On 11th March 2026, one Jeremiah Mweene, FTA Audit and Risk Committee, wrote an email to IKM lawyers and indicated that, after receiving responses from the petitioner and the Board being unable to convene on the 5th March 2026, the Board resolved to reinstate him with a general letter and later to meet him to hear him and clarify his responses. (page 147 of the petition).
35. The petitioner produced a letter dated 23rd March 2026 from KOISAME, the Chairman, who called for a meeting of the board and referred to the ongoing disciplinary process concerning him. The letter was addressed to IKM Advocates and sought legal advice on whether the letter of 5th March 2026 amounted to clearance and had any legal implications for the ongoing disciplinary proceedings. Further, the respondent sought the law firm's opinion on whether, having received the response to the petition to the Notice to Show Cause, the Board ought to reinstate the petitioner or terminate his services (page 698 of the petition). It is this letter which prompted the petitioner to file the application for conservation orders which were issued as status quo on the 31st March 2026 by Justice Dr Gakeri.
36. The petitioner alleges he was cleared and reinstated thus the threat of further disciplinary process amounts to double jeopardy.
37. The response was vide replying affidavit of Ms HEND MOHAMED HELMY KASSAB vide affidavit dated 22nd July 2026. The facts and chronology of events by the parties is not in dispute. According to KASSAB, the letter of 5th March 2026 only lifted the suspension and did not indicate that a disciplinary process was ongoing.
38. The petitioner filed reply vide affidavit dated 1st September 2026 where he reiterated that the board meeting of 5th March 2026 made a resolution to reinstate him to his position as the Executive Director of the Respondent and confirmed in writing that the resolution was after it read his response to the show cause. It was misleading for Respondent to state it lifted suspension, yet the period for suspension of 14 days (under the policy had lapsed.
39. The petitioner further relied on the affidavit dated 1st September 2026 of Peter Oanku ELSEN BROEK, a director of the respondent, who, among others, stated that on 24th March 2026 he cautioned the board against re-engaging the law firm, as an investigation under the respondent's Human Resource policy cannot be conducted where the complainant's identity is unknown.
40. Clause 15.3.3 of the Human Resource policy is on investigations. Among others. It is stated “Anonymous grievances will not be investigated.” (page 219 of the petition).
41. According to PETER DANIKU, the board on 5th March 20216 resolved to reinstate the petitioner as CEO of the respondent with immediate effect, and that was the final resolution of the board.
42. The court finds that disciplinary process is a management prerogative. Secondly, suspension is a lawful process pending investigation. The Supreme Court held so in Petition No. E034 of2024 Between Hamisi Bweni Dzila-and- Kwale County Assembly Service Board And Others (JUDGMENT OF 25TH MAY 2025)held as follows-
‘Asked differently, was the appellant entitled to be heard before his suspension? We find in the negative.
[60] Suspension is a preliminary step that may or may not end up with removal. It, therefore, does not necessitate a full disciplinary hearing entailing presentation of evidence, and the hearing of the clerk on the allegations. The main purpose of a suspension is merely to pave the way for investigations. Upon conclusion of the inquiry, as we have already noted, there can be two outcomes: the allegations may be found to be without basis and at that point the clerk may be exonerated; or if sufficient evidence disclosing facts constituting grounds for removal under Section 22, is presented, the clerk may be removed.’
43. It is not in dispute that the petitioner was issued with a show cause after investigation and suspended with words –
”During the conclusion of the disciplinary process, you will be suspended from duties ….”.
44. Where there is ambiguity in the employer's communication, the court will interpret the employer's document against the employer, meaning in favour of the employee, applying the doctrine of Contra proferentem (defined above). It is obvious that there is ambiguity in the respondent's letter of 5th March 2026 to the petitioner.
45. The court is then invited to interpret the letter. The words of the reinstatement letter are –
“Following your response concerning the whistle blower’s case, the board … would like to inform you that it has considered your response to the notice to show cause.
In accordance with our Human Resources policy of the respondent, the Board of Directors has decided the following:
1. You are reinstated to your position as Executive Director, effective immediately.
2. However, due to the importance and sensitive nature of the matter, the FTA Board of Directors will invite you in the coming days to be heard to clarify your response further ….”.
46. The petitioner was further asked under the above letter to resume duty in accordance with the job description and not to discuss the whistleblower’s case with staff or third parties.
47. According to respondent Kassab, for the respondent they simply lifted the suspension. This is not what they stated in letter of 5th March. They used the word “reinstated” . Do the words "lift" and "reinstated " mean the same? Are the words interchangeable? The court is guided by the letter which suspended the petitioner from work. It stated the period of suspension was ‘pending conclusion of disciplinary process’. The disciplinary process is one under section 41 of the Employment Act.
48. The court then finds that by use of the words ‘reinstatement’, having stated they considered his response, meant the employer had cleared the petitioner of any wrongdoing. This position is attested to by the respondent's director, Peter, who was at the meeting and affirmed as much in his affidavit before the court.
49. The court further finds that clause 15.3.3 of the policy prohibits investigations into anonymous grievances. The Director, Peter, noted that this issue was considered on 5th March 2026 before reinstating the petitioner. As the show cause was based on an anonymous grievant, the entire proceedings were contrary to clause 15.3.3 of the respondent’s Human Resource policy; thus, illegal investigations were carried out. The court cannot allow an illegal disciplinary process to continue.
Trade Disposition
50. The court holds that the letter dated 5th March 2026 was a final communication regarding the outcome of the disciplinary process and fully reinstated the petitioner to office with immediate effect. Any purported further disciplinary process based on the same Notice to Show Cause of 13th February 2026 is illegal and amounts to double jeopardy and an unfair labour practice, contrary to Articles 50, 41, and 47 of the Constitution.
51. The court further holds that the investigation was in violation of clause 15.3.3 of the Respondent's Human Resource manual.
52. The court is pleased to issue a declaration that the reinstatement of the Petitioner vide the letter of reinstatement dated 5th March 2026 was final and the Petitioner cannot be disciplined twice over the same offence.
53. The court is pleased to issue an order revoking any decision of the Respondent emanating from any disciplinary process, arising from the suspension -cum-notice to show cause. investigation and/or Notice to Show cause dated or of 13th February 2026.
54. The court is pleased to issue an order revoking any advertisement or recruitment to the current employment position of the Petitioner.
55. The court is pleased to issue an order of permanent injunction restraining the Respondent, either by themselves, employees, servants, partners, parent organisation (s) and/or agents, from terminating the employment of the Petitioner based on the suspension/Notice to show cause letter dated 13th February 2026.
56. The costs of this Petition be borne by the Respondent taking into account the conduct of the Respondent.
57. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Petitioner- Sikuta
Respondent- Okello h/b Ouma