Employment law

Sygenta Pollen Ltd v Mbogo [2026] KEELRC 14962 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Appeal E112 of 2024
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to determine weather (sic) the Respondent’s alleged injuries were sustained in the course of work.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NO. E112 OF 2024

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

SYGENTA POLLEN LIMITED ……………………………………….…………… APPELLANT

VERSUS

MARY WANGECHI MBOGO …………………………………………………… RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal from the Judgment and Decree of Hon. P. Mutua, Senior Principal Magistrate, delivered on 6th March 2024 at Thika in Chief Magistrate’s Court Civil Case No. 105 of 2018: Mary Wangechi Mbogo v Sygenta Pollen Limited.)

JUDGMENT

This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 5th April, 2024 and lodged in court on the same day.

The trial court found the Appellant 100% liable for a back injury the Respondent sustained at work on 18th April, 2016. It awarded her general damages of Kshs. 2,000,000.00 costs inclusive of a doctor’s attendance fee of Kshs. 10,000.00 and interest at court rates. Special damages of Kshs. 4,000.00 were declined as unproved.

It comes out as follows;

1. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to determine weather (sic) the Respondent’s alleged injuries were sustained in the course of work.

2. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to determine whether the Respondent’s alleged injuries were sustained at the Appellant’s premises.

3. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to consider the provisions of Section 30 (1) of the Work Injury Benefits Act, Cap. 236 Laws of Kenya when awarding the general damages.

4. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to consider the Provisions of Section 37 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, Cap. 236 Laws of Kenya in awarding the general damages.

5. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to give a basis for awarding the Respondent damages of Kshs. 2,000,000/=.

6. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in the exercise of his discretion in awarding the Respondent an inordinately high amount of general damages.

7. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact by failing to consider the Appellant's submissions and in so doing arrived at an erroneous conclusion.

The Appellant prays for orders thus;

a) THAT the Judgment and Decree dated 6th March, 2024 issued in the Respondent's favour in Thika CMCC No. 105 of 2018 : Sygenta Pollen Limited-vs-Mary Wangechi Mbogo be set aside and all consequential proceedings and orders be set aside.

b) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to dismiss the Respondent's suit against the Appellant.

c) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to assess reasonable compensation for general damages guided by Sections 30 (1) and 37 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, Cap. 236 Laws of Kenya

d) THAT the costs of this Appeal be awarded to the Appellant.

The Respondent’s claim at trial was brought by a Plaint dated 30th January, 2018 and filed on 16th February, 2018. She pleaded that on or about 18th April, 2016, while harvesting flowers for the Appellant, she was forced to pull a heavy trolley so as to meet the target and was injured.

The injury pleaded was lumbar spondylosis most marked at L4/L5 with bilateral L4 nerve root contact and bilateral L5 nerve root compression. She sought general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenities, special damages of Kshs. 4,000.00 costs and interest.

The Appellant’s defence denied that she was its employee, denied the accident and the injury, and pleaded in the alternative that her illness was not an occupational disease. At paragraph 15 it admitted the jurisdiction of the trial court.

The Appellant then moved by a motion dated 29th May, 2018 to strike out the suit under sections 16 and 26 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, Chapter 236, Laws of Kenya. The motion was dismissed on 27th July, 2021 as premature. Leave to appeal that ruling out of time was refused by this court on 13th July, 2023 in ELRC Miscellaneous Application No. E110 of 2022.

At the hearing the Respondent testified as PW1 on 11th October, 2023 and called Dr. Cyprianus Okoth Okere as PW2 on 13th December, 2023. The Appellant called no witness and produced no document(s).

It is the Appellant’s case and submission that the Respondent did not prove that she was injured at its premises. It points out that no payslip for April, 2016 was filed, that the DOSH 1 form leaves blank the place of the accident, that no eyewitness was called and that there was no proof of her report to a supervisor.

The Appellant further submits that section 16 of the Work Injury Benefits Act ousts any remedy outside the Act, so that compensation ought to have been computed under sections 30 (1) and 37. On its computation, ninety six months’ earnings at the Kshs. 6,443.00 shown in the DOSH 1 form comes to Kshs. 618,528.00 which it asks this court to substitute. It also submits that the trial court gave no basis for the award. Its own authorities at trial carried awards of Kshs. 800,000.00 and Kshs. 900,000.00 for comparable back injuries, and inflation could not justify more than double those sums.

The Respondent’s case and submission is that her employment and injury were proved by the Appellant’s own documents, among them the payslips, the letter of 3rd January, 2017 calling her to the company clinic, and the DOSH 1 form the Appellant itself lodged. The Appellant having called no witness, her evidence stood uncontroverted.

She submits that hers was a common law claim in negligence which the Act did not take away. Again, the Appellant never paid her any compensation under the Act and that this court cannot on a first appeal convert her claim into one under the Act.

On quantum, she submits that the trial court gave its reasons at paragraph 16 of the judgment and that the award is proportionate to a 45% incapacity, higher than in either of the Appellant’s authorities. She also asks that the Appellant be ordered to pay auctioneer’s charges of Kshs. 308,219.00 arising from a proclamation of 24th April, 2024.

After a considered look and scrutiny of the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;

1. Whether the Work Injury Benefits Act ousted the Respondent’s suit or required her damages to be assessed under sections 30 (1) and 37 of that Act.

2. Whether the Respondent proved that she was injured at the Appellant’s premises in the course of her employment.

3. Whether the award of Kshs. 2,000,000.0 in general damages was unreasoned or inordinately high.

4. Whether the Respondent is entitled, in this appeal, to an order for auctioneer’s charges.

5. Who should bear the costs of the appeal.

This being a first appeal, this court is under a duty to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence on record and to draw its own conclusions, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses as was enunciated in the celebrated authority of Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others [1968] EA 123.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the Work Injury Benefits Act ousted the Respondent’s suit or required her damages to be assessed under sections 30 (1) and 37 of that Act. The Appellant’s position has shifted. It admitted jurisdiction in its defence, later sought to strike out the suit under section 16, and now asks not that the suit be struck out but that sections 30 (1) and 37 be applied to the award. Jurisdiction is a threshold matter and this court opens on it.

Section 16 bars an action by an employee against the employer for damages in respect of an occupational accident, save under the Act. The Supreme Court upheld that provision in Law Society of Kenya v Attorney General & another [2019] KESC 16 (KLR). Work injury claims go first to the Director, with an appeal to this court under section 52.

This court does not therefore accept the Respondent’s wider submission that an employee remains free to elect a common law suit over the Act. That is not the law after the Supreme Court’s decision. Her suit is saved on a narrower footing. At paragraph 85 of the same decision the Supreme Court recognised that claimants with cases pending in court had a legitimate expectation that those cases would be concluded under the judicial process which they had invoked.

To give effect to that decision, the Chief Justice issued Practice Directions under Gazette Notice No. 5476 of 28th April, 2023, directing that all claims for compensation for work related injuries and diseases filed after the commencement of WIBA and before the Supreme Court decision, in this court or in the Magistrates’ Courts, shall proceed until conclusion before those courts. The Supreme Court’s decision was delivered on 3rd December, 2019. The Respondent’s suit was filed on 16th February, 2018 and was still pending when the Practice Directions issued. The trial court was properly seized of it.

The trial court was bound to try the suit before it. That suit was pleaded in negligence and breach of duty of care and sought general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenities. Damages on such a claim are assessed at large, by reference to the injury and to comparable awards. Sections 30 (1) and 37 set the measure of compensation under the statutory scheme administered by the Director. They are not the measure of general damages in a suit that proceeds in court by reason of the saving. A party cannot ask that a pending suit be concluded in court and at the same time be treated as a claim before the Director.

Further, the Appellant never pleaded the Act in its defence. At trial it relied on section 10 of the Act only on proof of injury, and on quantum it proposed general damages of between Kshs. 800,000.00 and Kshs. 900,000.00 on two common law awards. The section 30 (1) computation was never placed before the trial court. The trial court cannot be faulted for not considering a computation that was never urged before him. Grounds 3 and 4 fail.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the Respondent proved that she was injured at the Appellant’s premises in the course of her employment. Grounds 1 and 2 raise issues on the trial court’s failure to determine whether the injury was sustained in the course of work and at the Appellant’s premises. That is not so. At paragraph 11 of the judgment the trial court found that the Respondent was an employee and was also injured in the course of such employment. The question is whether that finding is supported. The Respondent testified that she was forced to carry more than the trolley could accommodate, which is why she fell, that she was injured on the back, that she reported to her employer and that she was taken to hospital the same day.

Her documents bear the Respondent out. The Nazareth Hospital report of 18th January, 2017 shows she was admitted on 18th April, 2016, the date pleaded, and discharged on 26th April, 2016. She then attended physiotherapy until 3rd January, 2017. The MRI report of 27th June, 2016 carries the diagnosis pleaded. The most telling document is the Appellant’s own. On 9th December, 2016 its Health, Safety and Environment Lead lodged a notice of occupational accident in form DOSH 1. It describes the Respondent as permanent general staff with fourteen years’ service and records medical bills of Kshs. 155,508.00 and transport of Kshs. 21,000.00 both paid by the Appellant.

An employer does not notify the Director of an occupational accident, and meet the medical bills, for an injury it believes was sustained elsewhere. The same form is a complete answer to the defence that the Respondent was not an employee at all. The blanks in that form for the date, place and cause of the accident do not help the Appellant. The form is its own and completing it was its statutory duty. It cannot found an argument on its own omissions, more so when it called no witness to explain them. Nor does the absence of an April, 2016 payslip. The payslips on record for January, February and June to October, 2016 show the Respondent on the Appellant’s payroll as staff number 2567 both before and after the accident.

It is noted that the Respondent’s letter of 22nd November, 2016 to her union gives the date of injury as 11th March, 2016. She was not cross-examined on it and the Appellant has not relied on it. The hospital record of admission on 18th April, 2016 supports the date pleaded and the discrepancy does not displace the finding. She was not obliged to call an eyewitness. The standard is a balance of probabilities and her evidence, supported by the Appellant’s own records, met it. The averments in the defence remained mere allegations once the Appellant elected to call no evidence. Grounds 1 and 2 fail.

On the 3rd issue for determination, an appellate court will interfere with an award of damages only where the trial court took into account an irrelevant factor, left out a relevant one, or made an award so inordinately low or high that it must be a wholly erroneous estimate. This is the pronouncement in the authority of Kemfro Africa Limited t/a “Meru Express Services (1976)” & another v Lubia & another (No 2) [1985] KECA 137 (KLR).

The complaint that no basis was given is not borne out. At paragraphs 13 to 16 the trial court set out the injury, the treatment, the complaints at examination and the assessed incapacity. He rejected the Respondent’s proposal of Kshs. 10,000,000.00 because her authorities concerned more severe injuries.

He then held that the Appellant’s two authorities were the relevant ones and, guided by them, considered the actual injuries, inflation and the 45% incapacity. The reasons are brief but they are the right considerations. The Appellant’s submissions were not ignored, its authorities were the ones adopted. Ground 7 therefore fails

Is the sum inordinately high? In the Appellant’s first authority Kshs. 800,000.00 was awarded in 2018 for disc prolapse at L4/L5 and L5/S1 with 15% incapacity. In the second, Kshs. 900,000.00 was in 2019 held not to be excessive for a prolapsed disc at L4/L5 with about 30% incapacity.

The Respondent’s incapacity was assessed at 45%. PW2 testified that she will not fully recover, will continue to have backache and cannot do heavy work. She walks with crutches and wears a lumbar corset. She earned her living by manual labour. The Appellant cross-examined PW2 on his specialisation but neither had the Respondent examined by a doctor of its choice nor tendered a rival report. The 45% assessment stood unchallenged at trial and is not challenged in the grounds of appeal. An incapacity one and a half times that in the closer authority, assessed five years later, will attract a materially higher award. Kshs. 2,000,000.00 is on the higher side, but I am unable to say it is a wholly erroneous estimate. This court does not interfere merely because it might have awarded a different sum. Grounds 5 and 6 fail.

On the 4th issue for determination, the prayer for auctioneer’s charges of Kshs. 308,219.00 does not arise from the judgment appealed against. There is no cross-appeal and no material on those charges in the record. That is a matter for the court executing the decree.

On the 5th issue, costs. Costs are in the discretion of the court under section 12 (4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. In the exercise of that discretion this court propels a case of costs being awarded to the Respondent.

I therefore dismiss the appeal and order as follows;

(i) The Judgment and Decree of the trial court delivered on 6th March, 2024 in Thika CMCC No. 105 of 2018 is upheld and affirmed.

(ii) The orders of stay of execution issued in this appeal are discharged and the decretal sum deposited in court pursuant to the orders of 14th November, 2024 shall be released to the Respondent.

(iii) The Respondent’s prayer for auctioneer’s charges is declined, without prejudice to any application before the executing court.

(iv) The costs of the Appeal shall be borne by the Appellant.

Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mrs. Umba instructed by Madhani Advocates LLP for the Appellant.

2. Mr. Mshindi instructed by Kinuthia, Wandaka & Co. Advocates for the Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder