Background
THAT the Learned Magistrate misdirected herself on several matters of law.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
THAT the Learned Magistrate misdirected herself on several matters of law.
Paragraph 1 →Whether service pay was barred by section 35(6) of the Employment Act because the respondent was an NSSF member; whether the respondent’s monthly salary was Kshs. 70,000 or Kshs. 50,000 and house allowance was payable; whether leave pay and October 2019…
Stephen Irungu Mwangi alleged that Shiv Insurance Brokers Ltd employed him as an underwriter from September 2011 and that his salary rose to Kshs. 70,000. He said his salary stopped in September 2019 after fraud accusations and that he was dismissed without a…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E267 OF 2023
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
SHIV INSURANCE BROKERS LTD ……………………………………… APPELLANT
VERSUS
STEPHEN IRUNGU MWANGI ………………………………………… RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Hon. G. Omodho, PM delivered on 30th November, 2023 at Milimani in ELRC No. 2305 of 2019: Stephen Irungu Mwangi v Shiv Insurance Brokers Ltd.)
JUDGMENT
This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 20th December, 2023. It arises from the Judgment delivered on 30th November, 2023 in Milimani in ELRC No. 2305 of 2019.
The Respondent sued by a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th December, 2019. His case was that he was employed by the Appellant from September, 2011 as an underwriter, on a salary that rose to Kshs. 70,000.00. That his salary was stopped in September, 2019 after he was accused of fraud and that he was later dismissed without a hearing. He claimed salary arrears, notice pay, leave, public holidays, gratuity and house allowance.
The Appellant in an Amended Response dated 12th October, 2022 admitted the employment, but posited that it was from 14th December, 2016. They pleaded that the Respondent was involved in fraud, that his salary was stopped as a result and that he subsequently absconded from work. They denied that he was dismissed and filed no counterclaim. The matter was heard on 21st March, 2023 with one witness on each side and the parties thereon filed written submissions.
The trial court found that the Respondent had not shown that he was dismissed and that he absconded duty. It declined public holidays for want of proof and made no award of notice pay, observing that the Respondent, having abandoned his station. This means that he was the owing party to the Appellant. It allowed service pay at 50% of basic pay for seven years, house allowance, leave and salary for October, 2019 as claimed, with costs.
The record contains only pages 1, 3, 5 and 6 of the six-page trial judgment and no decree. This court has relied on the pages before it and neither party suggests that the missing pages have any bearing on this appeal.
The appeal comes out as follows;
1. THAT the Learned Magistrate misdirected herself on several matters of law.
2. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law in failing to properly consider the totality of the Appellant’s Amended Response to the Statement of Claim, its written submissions and authorities causing her to arrive at an erroneous conclusion contrary to the weight of and inconsistent with the evidence adduced by the Appellant.
3. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in the construction, interpretation and application of the Employment Act in general and section 35(6) of the Employment Act in particular.
4. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law in holding against the weight of evidence before her and awarding the Respondent 50% of basic pay for each year worked as service pay after the court correctly observed that the Respondent absconded work to evade the investigation process and was not terminated.
5. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in finding that the Appellant did not avail before the court approved leave during the service of the Respondent yet the Appellants produced in Court sufficient documentary evidence to support of the leave days taken by the Respondent.
6. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law by merely holding that on salary in lieu of notice, the Respondent having abandoned station owes the Appellant and coming to simplistic findings without taking into account that the Respondent owes the Appellant.
7. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law in finding that the Respondent is entitled to house allowance yet the gross salary included the house allowance.
8. THAT the Learned Magistrate erred in law in issuing prayers not sought in the Statement of Claim despite parties being bound by their pleadings.
9. THAT the judgment is narrow, simplistic, opportunistic and oppressive.
The Appellant prays for orders thus;
a) This Appeal be allowed.
b) The Judgment of the trial court dated 30th November, 2023 be varied and substituted with an entry of judgement dismissing the entire Statement of Claim dated 16th December, 2019.
c) Costs of this Appeal.
d) Any other or further relief as this Honourable Court may deem fit to grant.
It is the Appellant’s case and submission that the trial court misapplied the Employment Act, 2007 and awarded terminal dues is not supported by law or evidence after correctly finding that the Respondent absconded and had not proved dismissal. The submissions address grounds 1 to 4 together, then grounds 5, 6 and 7. Grounds 8 and 9 are not addressed. On service pay, the Appellant submits that section 35(6) of the Employment Act, 2007 excludes an NSSF member. That remittances were proved and that the award duplicated a social security benefit.
On leave, the Appellant submits that it produced documents showing leave taken, and that the Respondent never showed an application refused. On notice, it submits that an employee who absconds is not entitled to salary in lieu of notice under section 36 and that the trial court found that he owes the Appellant. On house allowance, it submits that the Respondent’s Kshs. 50,000.00 was a consolidated gross salary that included housing, and that he accepted it for years without complaint. It prays that the claim be dismissed entirely, with costs.
The Respondent’s case and submission is that the judgment is proper and should not be disturbed. On grounds 1 to 4, he submits that the NSSF point was not raised by the Appellant at trial, that the contributions were partly nil and, in 2011, totalled Kshs. 2,400, and that they cannot be equated with the payment guaranteed by the Act. He adds that section 35(6)(d) must be read with paragraph (c), because the word and ends paragraph (c).
On leave, the Respondent submits that the Appellant held the records and had to prove that leave was taken. On house allowance, he submits that nothing shows it was included in the salary or the agreement. He asks the court to look into the prayers not awarded, such as public holidays and prays that the appeal be dismissed with costs.
After a considered look at the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;
1. Whether the trial court erred in awarding service pay in the face of section 35(6) of the Employment Act.
2. What the Respondent’s monthly salary was, and whether the trial court erred in awarding house allowance.
3. Whether the trial court erred in awarding leave pay.
4. Whether the trial court awarded salary in lieu of notice, and whether its observation that the Respondent owes the Appellant can found any relief.
5. Whether salary for October 2019 was properly awarded, what becomes of the remaining grounds, and what orders should issue, including costs.
This being a first appeal, this court is under a duty to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence on record and to draw its own conclusions, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses testify, as established in the authority of Selle and Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123.
On the 1st issue for determination, section 35(5) of the Employment Act, 2007 entitles an employee whose contract of service has been terminated under section 35(1)(c) to service pay for every year worked. Section 35(6) provides that section 35 shall not apply where an employee is a member of, among others, the National Social Security Fund.
The Respondent says the Appellant never raised the point at trial. The record says otherwise. The Appellant’s trial submissions dated 17th July, 2023 invoked section 35(6)(d) at paragraph 13. The trial court’s judgment, in the pages before this court does not mention section 35(6) or give a reason for passing over it. In any event the point is one of law on facts the Respondent himself proved.
Membership of the NSSF is not in doubt. The Respondent produced his own NSSF statement for 1st February, 2005 to 30th September, 2019 and relied on it to prove employment. His August, 2019 salary voucher shows an NSSF deduction of Kshs. 1,080.00. The trial court itself recorded that remittances were made up to September, 2019.
The Respondent says the contributions were low, at times nil, and cannot be equated with service pay. Section 35(6)(d) turns on membership of the Fund, not on the adequacy of the contributions. In Kens Metal Limited v Shikanga [2022] KECA 561 (KLR) the Court of Appeal set aside service pay under section 35(6) on a payslip showing an NSSF deduction of Kshs. 200 and the employee’s evidence that he was a registered member. The Respondent is in no weaker position.
The copy of the NSSF statement in the record is largely illegible and this court does not rely on its figures. The Respondent did not plead or prove a period without contributions. He claimed 15 days’ pay for each of his seven years and the trial court awarded service pay for all seven. I do not consider whether service pay might be due for a year with no contribution, as none was pleaded, proved or found.
On the word “and” at the end of paragraph (c), the argument cannot stand. Read that way, an employee would have to belong to a registered pension scheme, a collective agreement scheme, an employer’s scheme and the NSSF all at once, and the exclusion would almost never apply. The paragraphs are alternatives, each a form of provision that takes the place of service pay and the authority of Kens Metal applied the exclusion on proof of NSSF membership alone.
The Respondent’s contract of 14th December, 2016 provides for no gratuity or service pay. NSSF members fall outside the realm of section 35 and with it section 35(5.) The award of service pay was an error of law and cannot stand. Grounds 3 and 4 succeed on this point and I find as such. I need not decide whether service pay would otherwise be payable to an employee who absconded.
On the 2nd issue for determination, the pages of the trial judgment before me make no finding on the Respondent’s salary. The court awarded house allowance and October, 2019 salary as claimed, so those awards proceed on the pleaded Kshs. 70,000.00. The Appellant says the salary was Kshs. 50,000.00 and the Respondent’s own submissions on this appeal proceed on that figure.
The Respondent pleaded Kshs. 70,000.00. In cross-examination he said that he signed vouchers of Kshs. 50,000.00 and Kshs. 20,000.00 but he produced no voucher for the Kshs. 20,000.00 no payslip and no bank record. The Appellant produced the contract of 14th December, 2016 which fixes a salary of Kshs. 46,000.00 and the voucher for August, 2019 showing basic and gross pay of Kshs. 50,000.00. The Respondent’s trial submissions denied that voucher, but he accepted in evidence that he signed one for Kshs. 50,000.00.
The burden of proving the higher figure lay on the Respondent and the only documentary evidence of his pay is the voucher he signed. I find that his last monthly salary was Kshs. 50,000.00 and that the trial court erred in proceeding on Kshs. 70,000.00. The Respondent’s claim applies his last salary to the whole period of service. That favours him, the Appellant has not challenged it. This is therefore adopted by court.
On house allowance, section 31(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 obliges an employer to provide reasonable housing or to pay a sufficient sum as rent in addition to salary. Section 31(2)(a) excludes an employee whose contract consolidates an element for rent into the basic salary. Section 26(1) makes Part V of the Act, which includes section 31, the basic minimum terms of a contract of service. The Appellant wishes to rely on the exclusion from payment of house allowance. This would not apply because the contract does not say that the salary is consolidated. Its salary clause fixes Kshs. 46,000.00 a month and says only that taxes will be deducted. The August, 2019 voucher lists basic pay of Kshs. 50,000.00 a dash against house allowance, and gross pay of Kshs. 50,000.00. A salary paid wholly as basic pay, with the housing line empty, is not a consolidated salary. The Appellant did not say that it housed the Respondent. The authority cited by the Appellant turned on a contract that provided for a consolidated salary. There is none here, and silence during employment does not extinguish a minimum entitlement under Part V. Ground 7 fails on liability.
The Respondent’s claim of Kshs. 882,000.00 equals Kshs. 10,500.00 for each of 84 months, which is 15% of Kshs. 70,000.00. The Appellant did not challenge the percentage or the number of months. At Kshs. 50,000.00, 15% is Kshs. 7,500.00 a month, and for 84 months that gives Kshs. 630,000.00. The award is reduced accordingly.
On the 3rd issue for determination, section 28(1)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 entitles an employee to not less than twenty-one working days of leave with full pay after every twelve consecutive months of service. Section 74(1)(f) requires the employer to keep a written record of each employee’s annual leave entitlement, days taken and days due.
The Appellant says it produced documents proving that the Respondent took his leave. The record shows otherwise. Its list of documents has eight items and none is a leave record. Its witness did not speak to leave taken, its trial submissions did not address leave, and its Amended Response did no more than deny the claim.
The trial court was right that no approved leave records were availed. The contract term that leave is at the company’s discretion, and may be encashed only at its discretion, cannot reduce the statutory minimum. The submission that the Respondent had to show a refused application reverses the scheme of the Act, which puts the record-keeping on the employer.
The Respondent claimed 21 days for each of seven years. The Appellant pleaded that service began in December, 2016 but its own witness said that the Respondent started in 2011 or 2012, and the trial court recorded that seven years of service was not disputed. The Appellant has taken no ground on the period of service or on any other part of the calculation and this court makes no finding on them.
At Kshs. 50,000.00 a month one day’s pay is Kshs. 1,666.67, so twenty-one days is Kshs. 35,000.00 and seven years gives Kshs. 245,000.00. Ground 5 fails on liability and the award is reduced to that sum.
On the 4th issue for determination, ground 6 and the Appellant’s submissions attack an award of salary in lieu of notice. There is none. The closing paragraph of the judgment allows the Respondent’s prayers on service pay, house allowance, leave and salary arrears for October, 2019. Notice pay is not among them. The court’s remark was that the Respondent, having abandoned his station, owed the Appellant on that head.
To the extent that the Appellant complains that the court did not account for what the Respondent owes it, it pleaded no counterclaim and no set-off, and its Amended Response sought only the dismissal of the suit. It produced an apology letter in the Respondent’s name speaking of repayment, which he denied writing, but no claim was brought on it. Parties are bound by their pleadings, as the Appellant itself says in ground 8, and it cannot obtain a money order in its own favour on this appeal.
Nothing in this judgment is a finding on the fraud allegations against the Respondent. They were not pleaded as a counterclaim or tried to a conclusion and the Appellant’s witness said the investigations are ongoing. Ground 6 fails.
On the 5th issue for determination, the Appellant does not argue against the award of salary for October, 2019. Its own Amended Response says the Respondent’s salary was stopped in September, 2019 its only salary voucher is for August, 2019 and it does not say that it paid him for October. There is no basis to disturb the award in principle. It was made on Kshs. 70,000.00 and on the salary found under the 2nd issue, it is Kshs. 50,000.00.
The Appellant’s broader submission is that, because the Respondent absconded, nothing is due to him. Absconding goes to whether there was a dismissal and to the remedies that follow from termination, such as notice and compensation and the trial court rightly awarded none. It does not erase wages for work done or the leave and housing entitlements that accrued as basic minimum terms under Part V while he was in employment. No contractual forfeiture was pleaded or argued.
Ground 8 raises issues of prayers not sought. The Memorandum of Claim pleaded each head awarded, with its figure at paragraph 9. Ground 8 therefore fails on this aspect. Grounds 1 and 9 are general and add nothing, and ground 2 is addressed under the 2nd issue. The Respondent invites the court to look into prayers not awarded, such as public holidays. He filed no cross-appeal and the finding that public holidays failed for want of proof. It is not before this court.
In summation, grounds 3 and 4 succeed, ground 2 succeeds in part as to the salary, and grounds 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 fail. On the pleaded salary of Kshs. 70,000.00 the trial court’s awards would have been Kshs. 245,000.00 for service pay, Kshs. 882,000.00 for house allowance, Kshs. 343,000.00 for leave and Kshs. 70,000.00 for October 2019 salary, Kshs. 1,540,000.00 in all. On the findings in this judgment the total is Kshs. 925,000.00.
The trial court awarded costs to the Respondent, no ground is taken against that order, and I leave it undisturbed. On this appeal success is divided. The Appellant has defeated the service pay award and reduced the others, but has not dismissed the claim. Under section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, each party shall bear its own costs of the appeal.
I am therefore inclined to partially allow the appeal and order as follows;
(i) The award of service pay in the judgment delivered on 30th November, 2023 in ELRC No. 2305 of 2019 is set aside.
(ii) The awards of house allowance, leave and salary for October, 2019 in that judgment are varied and substituted with awards computed on a monthly salary of Kshs. 50,000.00 as follows:
a) House allowance (84 months at Kshs. 7,500)………………………Kshs. 630,000.0
b) Annual leave (21 days for 7 years)…………………………….…Kshs. 245,000.00
c) Salary for October 2019……………………………………..……..Kshs. 50,000.00
Total of substituted award……………………………………….Kshs. 925,000.00
(iii) Save as set out above, the judgment and decree of the trial court, including its order for costs in that court, are undisturbed.
(iv) Each party shall bear its costs of this Appeal.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Steve Ogolla and Agasha instructed by Saroni & Stevens Advocates for the Appellant.
2. Mr. Kimwere instructed by Kimwere Josphat & Co. Advocates for the Respondent.