REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI MILIMANI LAW COURTS
JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E095 OF 2026
THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION FOR ORDERS OF CERTIORARI AND PROHIBITION
IN AND IN THE MATTER OF THE KENYA UNION OF WATER AND SEWERAGE EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTION (RULE 8(a), RULE 14, RULE 15 AND RULE 23)
BETWEEN
REPUBLIC………………………………………………………………………………….……………...……….APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
THE GENERAL SECRETARY,
KENYA UNION OF WATER AND SEWERAGE EMPLOYEES …………………….……..RESPONDENT
AND
KENYA UNION OF WATER & SEWERAGE EMPLOYEES………………….1ST INTERESTED PARTY
THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE (NEC), (KENYA UNION
OF WATER & SEWERAGE EMPLOYEES). ……………………..…………….…2ND INTERESTED PARTY
EX PARTE: NELSON OTHOO
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The Ex Parte Applicant is an employee of the 1st interested party, serving as National Industrial Relations Coordinator. The Ex Parte Applicant was issued a letter of show cause and suspension, dated 28th August 2026, by the General Secretary, the Respondent. The Ex Parte Applicant was also issued another letter of the same date, revoking the Respondent's salary review. Aggrieved by the Respondent's decisions, the Ex Parte Applicant approached the 2nd interested party, which, at its sitting on 29th August 2026, chaired by the Vice Chairman of the union, resolved to revoke the letter of show cause and suspension and to clear the Ex Parte Applicant of all allegations. The 2nd interested party restored the revoked salary review and appointed the Ex Parte Applicant as acting General Secretary of the union, the Respondent having earlier been suspended by the 2nd interested party. The Respondent did not comply with the resolutions of 29th August 2026. The Ex Parte Applicant filed judicial review proceedings vide a Notice of Motion dated 24th September 2025, seeking ORDERS -
a. AN ORDER OF CERTIORARI be issued to remove into this Honorable Court and quash the Respondent's decisions, directives, and letters dated 20th August 2026 which purported to indefinitely suspend the Applicant from his position and revoke his lawfully adjusted salary structure.
b. AN ORDER OF PROHIBITION be issued restraining the Respondent, whether by himself, his agents, or servants, from barring, locking out, withholding payroll access, or in any manner interfering with the Applicant's exercise of his constitutional and contractual duties as the National Industrial Relations Coordinator of the Union.
c. AN ORDER directing the Respondent to fully comply with the supreme directives of the National Executive Committee (NEC) issued on 29th August 2026 and 18th September 2026, and to grant the Applicant unhindered physical access to his office desk at the Union Head Office.
d. THAT the costs of this Application be borne by the Respondent personally.
2. Grounds of the judicial review application
(a) By virtue of Rule 8(a) of the Union Constitution, the National Executive Committee (NEC) is the supreme managing organ. The Respondent has no legal authority to overrule the NEC's express resolution quashing the Applicant's suspension.
(b) The Applicant single-handedly manages active, multi-million-shilling trade union suits including a Ksh 6.1 million garnishee hearing on 22nd September 2026. Locking him out directly subverts the administration of justice and risks catastrophic legal defaults for thousands of public water sector workers.
(c) The Respondent acted as an investigator, prosecutor, and judge by issuing a blank, open-ended suspension letter lacking explicit preferred charges, disciplinary timelines, or a basic right to be heard.
3. The application was further grounded on the Statutory Statement and the Verifying Affidavit of the Ex Parte Applicant, sworn on the 21st day of September 2026, and the Supporting Affidavit of the National Vice Chairperson, sworn on the 21st day of September 2026.
4. The ex parte applicant's Supporting Affidavit of the National Vice Chairperson, sworn on the 21st day of September 2026, was annexed as EB1, together with the minutes of the 2nd interested party dated 29th August 2026; and as EB2, a special NEC resolution dated 18th September 2020, in which it met and resolved to join these proceedings. The ex parte applicant further annexed a letter dated 21st August 2026 regarding his salary review by the respondent; a letter dated 28th August 2026 revoking the salary review on the allegation that it had been obtained by misinterpretation of facts by the ex parte applicant; and a further letter dated 28th August 2026, for show cause and suspension from office of the ex parte applicant by the respondent on the ground of inciting the removal of the respondent, vide a coup (sic) meeting called on 29th August 2026 (see minutes produced as EB-1) by the Chairman, whom the respondent said had no power to call the meeting. The minutes of the meeting were produced with a resolution clearing the ex parte applicant of all allegations, restoring his salary, and further appointing him as the acting secretary. Another affidavit was sworn by Bundi, the Vice Chairman, on 21st September 2021 in support of the application.
5. The application was opposed by the respondent, Elijah Awach, vide his reply affidavit dated 29th September 2026. Awach was the elected National General Secretary of the union in the national elections for the union, which took place on 17th April 2026 (E0A1 was a copy of the extract of the register by the Registrar of Unions as at 20th April 2026). Awach asserted that under section 2 of the Labour Relations Act he was the chief executive officer of the union and the authorised representative. That under rule 12(d) of the union constitution, he had the mandate to issue all notices of all conferences and to prepare the agenda of meetings. That it was not true that the National Executive Committee holds supremacy over all union officials and employees, as the executive power of the union vests in the General Secretary.
6. The respondent stated that he exercised his executive power and suspended the expelled applicant, awaiting disciplinary proceedings, for misconduct for an illegal coup against him and further revoked his salary review. The Respondent contended that the 2nd interested party had no power to issue a notice to show cause against him. The respondents stated that the meeting of the 2nd interested party on 29th August 2026 was illegal as it was not convened by the General Secretary. The Registrar of Trade Unions found the meeting illegal and rejected the restoration of Form Q arising from the subject meeting (EOA2 was a letter dated 9th September 2026 by the Registrar of Trade Unions). In essence, the resolution appointing the ex parte applicant as the acting Secretary General was rejected, and the parties were sent back to the drawing board. It is the ex parte applicant who forwarded the minutes, vide letter dated 29th August 2026, to remove the respondent (EOA3). The Deputy General Secretary, pursuant to the rejection of the changes vide letter dated 9th September 2026, issued the respondent a notice of special national executive meeting notice for disciplinary proceedings against him for 18th September 2026 and a charge sheet. The respondent further annexed a letter dated 28th September 2026 reporting a trade dispute to the Cabinet Secretary, Labour, on disciplinary proceedings of the expert applicant (EAO5).
7. Awach filed a further affidavit dated 29th September 2026 and produced the union constitution.
8. The ex parte applicant filed a supplementary affidavit dated 5th October 2026, in which he stated that the general secretary held only executive power and that his decisions were subject to the supervisory power of the interested party. He further stated that the 2nd interested party met after the registrar's letter rejecting the changes, and he produced a document dated 18th September 2026, being a resolution to ratify his re-appointment and joining these proceedings, signed by the vice chairman and one Jimmy Adhiambo, indicated as acting secretary of the meeting.
9. The 2nd interested party entered an appearance via Nyabena Alfred & Co, advocates, and filed a reply affidavit sworn by Jimmy Adhiambo, stating that they did not oppose the application and annexing the minutes of 29th August 2026 and the resolution of 18th September 2026 already proceeded by the applicant.
Determination
10. The parties submitted before the court.
11. The court discerned the issue for determination to be-
a) Whether the suspension from office of the ex parte applicant by the respondent was in accordance with the union constitution
b) Whether the respondent is properly in office
c) Whether the revocation of salary review by the respondent was lawful
d) Whether the ex parte applicant is entitled to the orders sought
The law
12. Section 10(5) of the Employment Act -
‘(5)Where any matter stipulated in subsection (1) changes, the employer shall, in consultation with the employee, revise the contract to reflect the change and notify the employee of the change in writing.’
13. Section 41 and section 45 of the Employment Act on procedural fairness
Whether the suspension from office of the ex parte applicant by the respondent was in accordance with the union constitution
14. The ex parte applicant is the national industrial relations coordinator of the union appointed under rule 15 of the union constitution by the National Executive Council. His remuneration is determined by the General Secretary(the respondent) subject to approval by the National Executive Council. Rule 14 states that the engaged employees may be dismissed at any time by majority vote of the National Executive Council. The letter of show cause and suspension was issued by the General Secretary. The ex parte applicant relied on rule 8 (a) and 23 of the union constitution to contend that the suspension was ultra vires. Rule 8(a) states that the NEC shall be responsible for the management of the affairs of the union and shall exercise control over the individual officials and employees of the union.
15. Rule 23(c) provides that no member shall be suspended unless given an opportunity to state his case personally or in writing before the 2nd interested party. The court noted that the ex parte applicant is employed and thus clause 23 does not apply to employees but to members. The relevant rule for employees is 14 on engagement and dismissal of employees.
16. The contract of service was not produced, which ought to have details on the terms of service. In view of the lacuna regarding the terms of service of the ex parte applicant, the court then relied on the law on the respondent's role. The Labour Relations Act is the North Star for unions. The preamble of the Act states-
‘An Act of Parliament to consolidate the law relating to trade unions and trade disputes, to provide for the registration, regulation, management and democratisation of trade unions and employers organisations or federations, to promote sound labour relations through the protection and promotion of freedom of association, the encouragement of effective collective bargaining and promotion of orderly and expeditious dispute settlement, conducive to social justice and economic development and for connected purposes.’
17. The Labour Relations Act provides for an authorised representative of the union in section 2 as follows-
‘ In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires—
"authorised representative" means—
(a)the general secretary of a trade union;
(b)an employer or the chief executive officer of an employer;
(c)the secretary of a group of employers;
(d)the chief executive or association secretary of an employers’ organisation; or
(e)any person appointed in writing by an authorised representative to perform the functions of the authorised representative;’’
18. There is no doubt in the court's mind that the respondent is the authorised representative of the 1st interested party, not the 2nd. I find neither the Act nor the Constitution envisages the ex parte applicant to perform the role of the respondent. There exists an elected deputy who acts in the absence of the respondent.
19. Section 8 of the Labour Relations Act provides the right of the union to have its own constitution, of which both parties produced before the court. It is provided-
‘Every trade union, employers’ organisation or federation has the right to—
(a)subject to the provisions of this Act—
(i)determine its own constitution and rules; ‘
20. Rule 15 of the union constitution provides for the appointment of the National Industrial Relations Coordinator, appointed by the National Executive Council and remuneration determined by the General Secretary, subject to approval by the National Executive Council. The ex parte applicant is allowed to attend the meetings of the National Executive Council at the discretion of the General Secretary.
21. Rule 12 (d) of the union constitution provides for the role of the National General Secretary, which includes calling for meetings. Ensuring compliance by the union with the provisions of the labour laws and performing the function of the chief executive officer of the union and is a full-time official of the union.
22. Rule 12(f) is provision for the assistant national general secretary who acts in the absence of the respondent. Both the respondent and his assistant are elected officials under section 34 of the Labour Relations Act and registered as such by the Registrar of Trade Unions.
23. Section 34 of the Labour Relations Act provides for election of union officials-
‘(1)The election of officials of a trade union, employers’ organisation or federation shall be conducted in accordance with their registered constitutions.’
24. The court finds it was misplaced for the 2nd interested party to appoint the ex parte applicant as acting general secretary in view of the foregoing provisions of the union constitution. I digress. This is to demonstrate that the ex parte applicant may have been misled on his role in the union to be beyond of that an employee appointed by the 2nd interested party under the union constitution and not at level of elected officials (under section 34 of the Labour Relations Act)
25. The court noted that the respondent, in exercise of his powers as the authorised representative of the 1st interested party, vide letter dated 28th September 2026, reported a trade dispute to the Ministry of Labour regarding the disciplinary proceedings of the ex parte applicant, invoking section 62 of the Labour Relations Act, which states-
‘62. Reporting of trade disputes to the Cabinet Secretary
(1)A trade dispute may be reported to the Cabinet Secretary in the prescribed form and manner—(a)by or on behalf of a trade union, employer or employers’ organisation that is a party to the dispute; and
(b)by the authorised representative of an employer, employers’ organisation or trade union on whose behalf the trade dispute is reported.’’(emphasis given)
26. I find it is premature to pronounce myself on the issue of disciplinary action against the ex parte applicant, having established that Rule 23 of the union constitution applies to suspension of members and not employees. The court finds that, having established that the respondent is acting as per the law , being one in charge of ensuring compliance with the employment laws (Rule 12(d) of the union constitution) in the disciplinary process, there is no basis to interfere with the show cause and suspension.
27. The court finds that the letter dated 28th August 2026 revoking the ex parte applicant’s salary review amounts to arbitrary variation of terms of contract of employment held by the Petitioner under section 10 (5)of the Employment Act –
‘5)Where any matter stipulated in subsection (1) changes, the employer shall, in consultation with the employee, revise the contract to reflect the change and notify the employee of the change in writing.’
28. The letter of 28th August 2026 purporting to vary terms of service is held as an illegality and is nullified.
29. The court finds that the purported change of officers to replace the respondent was rejected by the Registrar of Trade Unions vide letter dated 9th September 2026. The respondent is legally in office.
30. The court, as noted earlier, finds the dispute on employment of the ex parte applicant is properly before the Ministry in charge of Labour affairs. The respondents are not government, and thus orders of judicial review are not available to the ex parte applicant.
31. The court, pursuant to section 20 of the Employment and Labour Relations Act, is to determine matters without regard to technicalities, only nullifies the letter of revocation of review of salary dated 28th August 2026 as being in violation of section 10(5) of the Employment Act.
32. The dispute on show cause and suspension is held as premature. The respondent has authority to issue the show cause and suspension under the law, section 2 of the Employment Act as read together with rule 12 (d) of the union constitution. The dispute is before the Ministry of Labour under section 62 of the Labour Relations Act. The ex parte applicant ought to await the outcome of the process. If not satisfied, they ought to file a claim and not judicial review, as the employer is a private entity and his employment has no statutory underpinning. The breach of the respondent's contract of employment was not a public act or matter of public law but was a matter of contractual relationship between the parties. The same had no statutory underpinning.
33. The orders sought by way of judicial review are not available to the ex parte applicant. His claims are based on a private employment contract protected under the Employment Act. The trade dispute has already been reported under section 62 of the Labour Relations Act, and that process ought to be exhausted before the court intervenes in the disciplinary process. The petitioner ought to move the court with a claim if he is not satisfied with the conciliation process.
Disposal
34. Judgment is entered for the ex parte applicant against the respondent as follows-
A. The letter of 28th August 2026 revoking the salary of the ex parte applicant is held as an illegality and null and void. The salary review for 2026, vide letter dated 21st August 2026, is restored from the date of revocation. All other prayers are declined for reasons explained in the judgment.
B. I make no order as to costs as the parties are in an active employee-
employer relationship.
35. The file is marked as closed.
36. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
Jemimah Keli,
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Ex-Parte Applicant – Othoo
Respondent-Awach
1st interested party
2nd interested party Nyabena