Employment law

Republic v Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services & another; Tungu (Ex parte Applicant) [2026] KEELRC 14931 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Jr Cause E031 of 2026
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application succeeded against DOSH: mandamus issued compelling DOSH to hear and assess compensation for the alleged 5 April 2023 work accident. The application failed against the Interested Party/employer; no order was made against it. DOSH was ordered to pay the Ex Parte Applicant’s costs.

Supporting judgment passages

45. The court enters judgment for the ex parte applicant against the respondent as follows-

Paragraph 45 →

A. The court is pleased to issue an order of Mandamus compelling the respondent (DOSH) to hear and assess compensation payable to the ex parte applicant, with respect to the accident and injury alleged to have occurred on 05.04.2023 while the exparte applicant was on duty in the employment of the interested party.

Passage 130 →

B. Costs of the application payable to the ex parte applicant by the respondent.

Passage 131 →
Issue 1Whether the Ex Parte Applicant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Held. Yes, in part. The Applicant was entitled to have DOSH consider the alleged work-injury claim under WIBA, and mandamus issued compelling DOSH to hear and assess compensation. The claim for judicial-review relief against the Interested Party failed: assessment is DOSH’s statutory function, the employer had no obligation to pay before a demand, and the court would not compel the employer’s WIBA compliance in these proceedings. Costs were awarded against DOSH.

Ratio. Once DOSH has notice of an alleged workplace injury, it must make the inquiries necessary to decide the claim. An employer’s denial that the accident was work-related does not prevent that inquiry, and a settlement or discharge cannot relinquish WIBA benefits because such a provision is void. Mandamus may compel the statutory body to perform its legal duty, but cannot direct the manner of performance or substitute the court for DOSH’s statutory role.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the ex parte applicant is entitled to relief sought.

Passage 106 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

41. The court taking into account the foregoing and the respondent having not defended the claim finds the ex parte applicant whose employment with the interested party at the material time was not in dispute, and the accident having being alleged to have happened at work, though denied, is entitled to have his claim considered in accordance with WIBA by the respondent. The employer has no obligation to pay before a demand is made thus no case against it is made.

Paragraph 41 →

44. The court finds no merit in the judicial review proceedings against the interested party, as the duty to assess the claim of work-related injury rests with the respondent. The WIBA is comprehensive and self-enforcing statute with sanctions with respect to the process, and there is no basis for the court to issue any order against the employer regarding compliance unless the order is sought by the respondent. The respondent only summoned the parties on the 2nd June 2026 despite being seized of the claim much earlier as evidenced by its letter dated 28th October 2025 to the interested party.

Paragraph 44 →

A. The court is pleased to issue an order of Mandamus compelling the respondent (DOSH) to hear and assess compensation payable to the ex parte applicant, with respect to the accident and injury alleged to have occurred on 05.04.2023 while the exparte applicant was on duty in the employment of the interested party.

Passage 130 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

‘19. Compensation not to be alienated

Passage 115 →

‘(2)For the purposes of this section, an accident includes any injury reported by an employee, to his employer, if the employee when reporting the injury, alleges that it arose out of and in the course of his employment and irrespective of the fact that the employer is of the opinion that the alleged accident did not so arise out of and in the course of employment.

Passage 121 →

42. The respondent has a statutory mandate, and the court cannot usurp its role to compel the employer to comply with WIBA. The court under judicial review proceedings may compel a statutory body to do its duty vide an order of mandamus. In defining the scope of the Order of Mandamus, the Court of Appeal in Kenya National Examination Council v Republic; GGN & 9 others (Ex parte) [1997] KECA 58 (KLR) stated-

Paragraph 42 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

At all material times, the Ex-parte Applicant was an employee of the interested party stationed at its Buruburu Branch. He alleged an uncompensated work injury during his employment. The Ex Parte Applicant instituted judicial review proceedings against the Respondent, the Directorate of the Occupational Safety and Health Services, brought by a Notice of Motion dated 26th March 2026, and sought the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

In his submissions dated 22nd June 2026, the Ex-Parte Applicant identified the following issues for determination:-

Paragraph 23 →

Reasoning passage

The ex parte applicant has lodged a claim with the respondent. The interested party has informed the court it has received letter dated 2nd June 2026 from the respondent summoning it and the ex parte applicant to appear before it to provide information on the alleged accident. (LN-6 by the interested party was the summons). I find this step is in accordance with section 23 of WIBA to wit-

Paragraph 36 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the ex parte applicant was entitled to judicial-review relief, particularly mandamus compelling the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services (DOSH) to hear and assess his alleged work-injury compensation claim; and whether any relief could…

Material facts

Nicodemus Mutunga Tungu, an employee of Naivas Limited at its Buruburu Branch, alleged that unsupervised trolleys struck his groin on 5 April 2023 while on duty, causing permanent incapacity assessed at 45%. He stated that he reported the accident and that…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC JR CAUSE NO. E031 OF 2026

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

REPUBLIC......................................................................................................................................................APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

DIRECTOR OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY

AND HEALTH SERVICES…………………………………………….…………………………………………….RESPONDENT

-AND-

NAIVAS LIMITED……..................................................................................................................INTERESTED PARTY

EX-PARTE: NICODEMUS MUTUNGA TUNGU

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. At all material times, the Ex-parte Applicant was an employee of the interested party stationed at its Buruburu Branch. He alleged an uncompensated work injury during his employment. The Ex Parte Applicant instituted judicial review proceedings against the Respondent, the Directorate of the Occupational Safety and Health Services, brought by a Notice of Motion dated 26th March 2026, and sought the following orders:

a) An order of Mandamus do issue to compel the respondent (DOSH) to hear and assess compensation payable to the applicant with respect to the accident and injury that occurred on 05.04.2023 while the applicant was on duty in the employment of the interested party.

b) The interested party be compelled to provide all necessary documentation and information necessary to enable the respondent to carry out the assessment and award compensation.

c) Costs of the application be provided for.

2. The Notice of Motion was supported by the grounds set out therein, the Statutory Statement dated 26th March 2026, the Supporting Affidavit sworn by the Ex-Parte Applicant on even date, and the annexures thereto.

3. In response to the application, the Interested Party filed Grounds of Opposition dated 15th June 2026, and a Replying Affidavit sworn by LIVIA NJARUI on even date. (The court took note of the earlier Replying Affidavit sworn by the same Deponent on 22nd May 2026. The court presumed it was replaced with this)

4. To counter the Interested Party’s responses, the Ex-Parte Applicant filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 22nd June 2026.

The Applicant’s case in summary

5. The Applicant’s case is that he was injured on 5th April 2023 in the course of his work duties, while lawfully employed by the Interested Party as its fresh lead at the Buru Buru Branch. The Ex-Parte Applicant avers that the injury resulted from being hit in the groin by unsupervised trolleys. He was rushed to Alfa Care Medical Center for emergency treatment, and the doctor who treated him confirmed that his pelvic and groin regions were affected. The percentage of permanent incapacity/disability was assessed at 45%. The Ex-Parte Applicant indicates that, as a result of the accident, he suffered severe and permanent physical incapacity, rendering him wholly dependent on assistance in undertaking ordinary day-to-day activities. He has since been certified and formally registered as a person living with a disability in accordance with the applicable legal framework. Following the accident, the Ex-Parte Applicant contends that he reported the same to the Interested Party’s management, culminating in the execution, by the reporting manager, of an incident notification form detailing the occurrence of the accident.

6. The Ex-Parte Applicant’s grievance is that the Interested Party failed to notify or report the occupational accident to the Respondent in breach of the law, despite receiving a demand letter dated 6th January 2026 from the Ex-Parte Applicant requiring the Interested Party to report the accident to the DOSH. Instead, the Interested Party responded by letter dated 29th January 2026, denying that an occupational accident occurred.

7. After he pursued the matter with the Respondent, they wrote to the interested party, vide their letter dated 28th October 2025, directing them to report the occupational accident via the Directorate’s portal. However, despite various correspondence with the Respondent, no action has been taken. In the meantime, the Respondent has not responded to his manually lodged claim.

8. In rebuttal to the matters raised by the Interested Party, the Ex-Parte Applicant emphasises that the Interested Party cannot disown their incident notification form, signed and stamped by their branch manager, as they are estopped from doing so by Section 120 of the Evidence Act; that only a competent body is clothed with jurisdiction to impeach medical documents and correspondence adduced in evidence; that the Ex-Parte Applicant is not mandated by law to forfeit statutory protection merely because he had suffered earlier injuries; that, in the event of inordinate delay, Section 90 of the Employment Act requires that any claim arising from an employment contract or dispute must be filed in court within 3 years, which the Ex-Parte Applicant complied with; and that the provision of medical treatment, humanitarian assistance, welfare support or terminal dues by an employer does not operate as a waiver of an employee's statutory rights under the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007, unless there exists a lawful settlement, discharge, deed of release, compromise or compensation agreement recognised by law, which the Interested Party has not produced before the Court to demonstrate that the Ex-Parte waived, compromised or abandoned his statutory claim. The Ex-Parte Applicant also challenges the Interested Party’s affidavit for failing to comply with Sections 4 and 5 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act.

Interested Party’s case in brief

9. The Interested Party admits that the Ex-Parte Applicant was its employee, serving in an administrative and supervisory capacity as an Assistant Branch Manager/Fresh Lead, stationed at its Buruburu Branch.

10. They state that, by virtue of his position, the Ex Parte Applicant had administrative access to internal operational documentation, including petty cash requisitions and incident-related documentation, and was capable of independently initiating, processing and endorsing certain internal documents.

11. The Interested Party stresses that the alleged occupational accident was never reported to it through the established reporting channels and procedures set out in its internal operational protocols and the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007. It was therefore denied the opportunity to promptly investigate the alleged occurrence, preserve evidence, interview witnesses and make a contemporaneous assessment of the alleged incident. The Interested Party disowns the incident notification form produced by the Ex-Parte Applicant and expresses doubt regarding its authenticity, reliability and probative value, on the ground that it does not disclose the identity, designation or particulars of the person who allegedly filled in, endorsed or authorised it. It implies that the Ex-Parte Applicant may have generated, endorsed and/or processed it without authority, and states that he independently initiated and processed documentation which was subsequently forwarded to the Interested Party’s insurers without proper escalation or notification through the established internal reporting hierarchy.

12. The Interested Party points to material factual inconsistencies in the account of the alleged incident: the Interested Party's records and medical documentation indicate that, prior to the alleged accident, the Ex Parte Applicant had a documented history of recurring medical complications affecting the same pelvic, inguinal and urological regions for which he now seeks compensation; medical correspondence available to the Interested Party demonstrates that the Ex Parte Applicant had undergone multiple surgical procedures and suffered from recurring complications affecting the same anatomical area long before the alleged workplace incident; and correspondence exchanged with the Interested Party's insurers confirms that the area allegedly injured had been affected by longstanding medical conditions predating the alleged accident.

13. In any event, the Interested Party further contends that the alleged incident is said to have occurred within the customer parking area, which is outside the Ex-parte Applicant’s designated work area, at a time when the Ex-parte Applicant was supposed to be on leave and had neither formally resumed duty nor confirmed his return from leave to his supervisor. They further point out that the Ex-parte Applicant has not produced any independent witness to corroborate the occurrence of the alleged incident.

14. It is averred that, in good faith and without admission of liability, the Interested Party, through its internal medical support structures and insurer arrangements, expended in excess of Kenya Shillings Eight Hundred and Six Thousand (Kshs. 806,000/-), being the maximum applicable insurer medical limit, towards the Ex-Parte Applicant’s treatment and medical needs. It subsequently initiated discussions for a mutual separation from employment and, following the Ex-Parte Applicant’s request for separation from employment, voluntarily entered into a Mutual Separation Agreement dated 4th October 2023 with the Ex-Parte Applicant, under which he received separation dues amounting to Kenya Shillings Seven Hundred and Seventy One Thousand and Sixty Nine (Kshs. 771,069/-). The Mutual Separation Agreement was initiated and voluntarily executed by both the Ex-Parte Applicant and the Interested Party following the Ex-Parte Applicant's request for separation from employment.

15. The Interested Party relies on Clause 1.2 of the Agreement, which provides that the term "Statutory Employment Protection Claims" includes claims arising under the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007 and the Occupational Safety and Health Act 2007; and on Clause 2.1 of the Agreement, which provides that the dues paid to the Ex-Parte Applicant were in full and final settlement and discharge of all statutory employment claims arising from the employment relationship and its termination. They also refer to an express representation and warranty in the Agreement issued by the Ex-Parte Applicant that he had disclosed any personal injuries in relation to which a claim could reasonably be brought against the Interested Party, and that he had no future statutory employment claims against the Interested Party.

16. The Interested Party submits that, having knowingly and voluntarily executed the Mutual Separation Agreement and accepted the substantial financial benefits arising therefrom, the Ex-Parte Applicant is estopped from advancing claims against the Interested Party that fall within the scope of matters expressly compromised and settled by the Agreement.

17. In addition to the dues paid to the Ex-Parte Applicant, the Interested Party indicates that, as a demonstration of goodwill and concern for the welfare of its employees and the Ex-Parte Applicant’s colleagues, it coordinated and facilitated monetary contributions to assist the Ex-Parte Applicant with his medical expenses and personal needs during his period of illness and treatment. It states that the medical support, financial assistance and staff welfare contributions afforded to the Ex-Parte Applicant were extended purely on humanitarian and employee welfare grounds and did not amount to an admission that the alleged injuries arose out of and in the course of employment within the meaning of the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007.

18. The Interested Party explains that, alongside its insurers, it continued to interrogate the medical basis, causation and nature of the Ex-Parte Applicant’s condition owing to longstanding prior medical complications. They emphasise that the medical reports and procedures now relied upon by the Ex-Parte Applicant are themselves disputed and unreliable, since some of the subsequent procedures and medical interventions allegedly undertaken by the Ex-Parte Applicant were not conducted at facilities recognised, approved or accredited by the Interested Party or its insurance service providers. As such, they aver that serious questions arise as to the credibility, causation and attribution of the alleged injuries and/or subsequent medical complications.

19. The Interested Party denies that the Respondent, the Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Services, has declined, refused or failed to exercise its statutory mandate. It explains that it received a letter dated 2nd June 2026 from the Directorate, summoning both the Ex Parte Applicant and the Interested Party to appear before the Director of Work Injury Benefits Administration on 18th June 2026 to provide information and documentation relating to the alleged incident. According to the Interested Party, the summons demonstrates that the Respondent is actively seized of the complaint and is presently undertaking inquiries and investigations pursuant to Sections 23 and 24 of the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007.

20. The Interested Party argues that the present proceedings were brought after an inordinate and unexplained delay, the alleged incident having purportedly occurred on 5th April 2023, with the Ex-Parte Applicant issuing a demand letter only in January 2026. He instituted the instant proceedings on 26th March 2026, nearly three years after the alleged occurrence. The Interested Party is emphatic that the delay contravenes the statutory framework and timelines contemplated under Sections 26 and 27 of the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007 relating to notification and lodging of claims, and contends that no satisfactory explanation has been offered for the delay.

21. Finally, the Interested Party argues that the issues raised by the Ex Parte Applicant involve disputed questions of fact and merit that fall outside the scope of Judicial Review proceedings; and that the Ex Parte Applicant improperly seeks substantive Judicial Review orders against it, despite the Interested Party being a private corporate entity, not a public body exercising statutory or public functions, and therefore not susceptible to Judicial Review remedies such as Mandamus. It also contends that the Interested Party is not the statutory decision-maker under the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007 and bears no statutory duty capable of enforcement by way of an order of Mandamus. It therefore characterises the orders sought as legally incompetent and untenable.

DETERMINATION

22. Following directions by the court that it would determine the suit through written submissions, the parties filed their respective submissions.

23. In his submissions dated 22nd June 2026, the Ex-Parte Applicant identified the following issues for determination:-

i. Whether the Ex Parte Applicant has established a proper basis for the grant of judicial review remedies.

ii. Whether the Interested Party has rebutted the factual and legal issues raised by the Ex Parte Applicant.

iii. Whether the Interested Party's allegations concerning delay, welfare support, medical assistance and separation benefits are sufficient to defeat the application.

iv. Whether the Ex Parte Applicant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

24. On their part, the Interested Party distilled the following issues for determination in their submissions dated 26th June 2026:

i. Whether the application satisfies the threshold for the grant of an order of Mandamus.

ii. Whether the reliefs sought against the Interested Party are legally sustainable.

iii. Whether the Ex-Parte Applicant is entitled to the reliefs sought and costs.

25. The court upon perusal of the pleadings of the ex parte applicant and the interested party, the respondent having not entered appearance,, finds the issue for determination to be –

Whether the Ex Parte Applicant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

The law.

26. The preamble of the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA) reads-

‘An Act of Parliament to provide for compensation to employees for work related injuries and diseases contracted in the course of their employment and for connected purposes’’

27. Section 9 of WIBA commands the Employer to keep records as follows-

‘(1)An employer shall—

(a)keep a register or other record of the earnings and other prescribed particulars of all employees;

(b)at all reasonable times produce the register or record on demand to the Director for inspection; and

(c)retain the register, record or reproduction referred to in paragraph (1)(a) for a period of at least six years after the date of the last entry in that register or record’.

27. Section 10 of WIBA provides for the right to compensation for work injury and disease -

‘’10(1)An employee who is involved in an accident resulting in the employee’s disablement or death is subject to the provisions of this Act, and entitled to the benefits provided for under this Act.

(2)An employer is liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of this Act to an employee injured while at work.

(3)An employee is not entitled to compensation if an accident, not resulting in serious disablement or death, is caused by the deliberate and wilful misconduct of the employee.’’

28. Section 19 of WIBA provides that Compensation not to be alienated-

‘(1)Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary in any written law, compensation shall not be—(a)assigned or pledged;

(b)capable of attachment or any form of execution under a judgment or order of a court of law; or

(c)set off against any debt of the person entitled to the compensation.

(2)Any provision of an agreement in terms of which an employee assigns, purports to assign, relinquishes or purports to relinquish any right to benefits in accordance with this Act, shall be void.’

28. Section 21 of WIBA provides for issuance of Notice of accident by employee to employer-

‘Written or verbal notice of any accident provided for in section 22 which occurs during employment shall be given by or on behalf of the employee concerned to the employer and a copy of the written notice or a notice of the verbal notice shall be sent to the Director within twenty-four hours of its occurrence in the case of a fatal accident.’

29. Section 22 of WIBA provides for Notice of injury or accident by employer to Director-

‘(1)Subject to the provisions of this section, an employer shall report an accident to the Director in the prescribed manner within seven days after having received notice of an accident or having learned that an employee has been injured in an accident.

(2)For the purposes of this section, an accident includes any injury reported by an employee, to his employer, if the employee when reporting the injury, alleges that it arose out of and in the course of his employment and irrespective of the fact that the employer is of the opinion that the alleged accident did not so arise out of and in the course of employment.

(3)An employer shall, at the request of an employee or the dependant of an employee, furnish the employee, or dependants with a copy of the notice of the accident furnished by the employer to the Director in respect of a claim for compensation by such employee or dependant.

(4)An employer who fails to comply with subsection (1) commits an offence.(5)The provisions of this section do not prevent an employee from reporting an occupational accident or disease to the Director at any stage.’

30. Section 23 of WIBA provides for Inquiry by Director-

‘(1)After having received notice of an accident or having learned that an employee has been injured in an accident the Director shall make such inquiries as are necessary to decide upon any claim or liability in accordance with this Act.

(2)An inquiry made under subsection (1) may be conducted concurrently with any other investigation.

(3)An employer or employee shall, at the request of the Director, furnish such further particulars regarding the accident as the Director may require.

(4)A person who fails to comply with the provisions of subsection (3) commits an offence.’

31. Section 24 of WIBA provides for Particulars in support of a claim for compensation -

‘(1)An employee who is injured in an accident or his dependant, shall, when reporting the accident or thereafter at the request of the employer or Director, furnish such information and documents as may be prescribed or as the employer or Director may request.

(2)An employer shall, within seven days after having received a claim, medical report or other document or information concerning such claim, submit the claim, report, document or information to the Director.’’

32. Section 25 of WIBA provides for the Employee to submit to medical examination-

‘(1)An employee who claims compensation or to whom compensation has been paid or is payable, shall when required by the Director or the employer as the case may be, after reasonable notice, submit himself at the time and place mentioned in the notice to an examination by the medical practitioner designated by the Director or the employer with the approval of the Director.

(2)If, in the opinion of any medical practitioner, an employee is not capable of travelling to be examined by the designated medical practitioner, the employee shall inform the party requiring the examination thereof or cause him to be so informed, and the designated medical practitioner shall then examine the employee at a time and place as agreed upon.

(3)An employee shall be entitled at his own expense, to have a medical practitioner of his choice present at an examination by a designated medical practitioner.’

33. Section 26 of WIBA provides for claim for compensation-

‘(1)A claim for compensation in accordance with this Act shall be lodged by or on behalf of the claimant in the prescribed manner within twelve months after the date of the accident or, in the case of death, within twelve months after the date of death.

(2)If a claim for compensation is not lodged in accordance with subsection (1), the claim for compensation may not be considered under this Act, except where the accident concerned has been reported in accordance with section 21.

(3)If an employer fails to report an accident or to provide information requested by the Director as specified in the request, the Director may—

(a)conduct an investigation and recover the cost of the investigation from the employer as a debt due from the employer; or

(b)levy a penalty on the employer.

(4)An employer or insurer against whom a claim for compensation is lodged by the Director under this section, shall settle the claim within ninety days of the lodging of the claim.

(5)The Director shall, within thirty days of receipt of the money claimed under subsection (1), pay the money to the employee who made the claim or his dependants.

(6)An employer or an insurer who fails to pay the compensation claimed under this subsection commits an offence and shall on conviction be liable to a fine not exceeding five hundred thousand shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or to both.’

34. Section 51 of WIBA provides for objections and appeals against decisions of the Director-

‘(1)Any person aggrieved by a decision of the Director on any matter under this Act, may within sixty days of such decision, lodge an objection with the Director against such decision.

(2)The objection shall be in writing in the prescribed form accompanied by particulars containing a concise statement of the circumstances in which the objection is made and the relief or order which the objector claims, or the question which he desires to have determined.’

35. Section 52 of WIBA provides for Director’s reply to the objection and appeal to this court-

‘(1)The Director shall within fourteen days after the receipt of an objection in the prescribed form, give a written answer to the objection, varying or upholding his decision and giving reasons for the decision objected to, and shall within the same period send a copy of the statement to any other person affected by the decision.

(2)An objector may, within thirty days of the Director’s reply being received by him, appeal to the Industrial Court against such decision.’

Whether the ex parte applicant is entitled to relief sought.

36. The ex parte applicant has lodged a claim with the respondent. The interested party has informed the court it has received letter dated 2nd June 2026 from the respondent summoning it and the ex parte applicant to appear before it to provide information on the alleged accident. (LN-6 by the interested party was the summons). I find this step is in accordance with section 23 of WIBA to wit-

(1)After having received notice of an accident or having learned that an employee has been injured in an accident the Director shall make such inquiries as are necessary to decide upon any claim or liability in accordance with this Act.

(2)An inquiry made under subsection (1) may be conducted concurrently with any other investigation.

(3)An employer or employee shall, at the request of the Director, furnish such further particulars regarding the accident as the Director may require.

(4)A person who fails to comply with the provisions of subsection (3) commits an offence.’’

37. The ex parte applicant filed a supplementary affidavit dated 22nd June 2026 and did not deny the averment that the parties had been summoned by the respondent vide letter dated 2nd June 2026 on the accident (see paragraph 30 Livia Njarui for interested party replying affidavit dated 15th June 2026)

38. The respondent did not file a response to this suit.

39. The court read the averments on the settlement and discharge letter signed on mutual exit. I find that the discharge letter did not defeat the WIBA claim, applying section 19 of WIBA to wit-

‘19. Compensation not to be alienated

(1)Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary in any written law, compensation shall not be—(a)assigned or pledged;

(b)capable of attachment or any form of execution under a judgment or order of a court of law; or

(c)set off against any debt of the person entitled to the compensation.

(2)Any provision of an agreement in terms of which an employee assigns, purports to assign, relinquishes or purports to relinquish any right to benefits in accordance with this Act, shall be void.’

40. Further, the denial of the accident by the interested party as alleged does not preclude DOSH's inquiry. It is stated in section 22 of WIBA as follows-

‘(2)For the purposes of this section, an accident includes any injury reported by an employee, to his employer, if the employee when reporting the injury, alleges that it arose out of and in the course of his employment and irrespective of the fact that the employer is of the opinion that the alleged accident did not so arise out of and in the course of employment.

(3)An employer shall, at the request of an employee or the dependant of an employee, furnish the employee, or dependants with a copy of the notice of the accident furnished by the employer to the Director in respect of a claim for compensation by such employee or dependant.’’(emphasis given)

41. The court taking into account the foregoing and the respondent having not defended the claim finds the ex parte applicant whose employment with the interested party at the material time was not in dispute, and the accident having being alleged to have happened at work, though denied, is entitled to have his claim considered in accordance with WIBA by the respondent. The employer has no obligation to pay before a demand is made thus no case against it is made.

42. The respondent has a statutory mandate, and the court cannot usurp its role to compel the employer to comply with WIBA. The court under judicial review proceedings may compel a statutory body to do its duty vide an order of mandamus. In defining the scope of the Order of Mandamus, the Court of Appeal in Kenya National Examination Council v Republic; GGN & 9 others (Ex parte) [1997] KECA 58 (KLR) stated-

‘24.The next issue we must deal with is this: What is the scope and efficacy of an Order of Mandamus? Once again we turn to Halsbury’s Law of England, 4th Edition Volume 1 at page 111 from paragraph 89. That learned treatise says:-“The order must command no more than the party against whom the application is made is legally bound to perform. Where a general duty is imposed, a mandamus cannot require it to be done at once. Where a statute, which imposes a duty leaves discretion as to the mode of performing the duty in the hands of the party on whom the obligation is laid, a mandamus cannot command the duty in question to be carried out in a specific way.’

43. The respondent is bound to conduct and determine the claim of injury at the workplace by the worker. The ex parte applicant was a worker with a claim of work injury which he has brought to the attention of the respondent. The order of mandamus is due to be issued against the respondent.

Disposition

44. The court finds no merit in the judicial review proceedings against the interested party, as the duty to assess the claim of work-related injury rests with the respondent. The WIBA is comprehensive and self-enforcing statute with sanctions with respect to the process, and there is no basis for the court to issue any order against the employer regarding compliance unless the order is sought by the respondent. The respondent only summoned the parties on the 2nd June 2026 despite being seized of the claim much earlier as evidenced by its letter dated 28th October 2025 to the interested party.

45. The court enters judgment for the ex parte applicant against the respondent as follows-

A. The court is pleased to issue an order of Mandamus compelling the respondent (DOSH) to hear and assess compensation payable to the ex parte applicant, with respect to the accident and injury alleged to have occurred on 05.04.2023 while the exparte applicant was on duty in the employment of the interested party.

B. Costs of the application payable to the ex parte applicant by the respondent.

46. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Ex parte applicant- Kuria

Respondent- absent

interested party- Ms Kinyua

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder