Employment law

Nzwili v Zheng Hong (K) Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14868 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Appeal E105 of 2024
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Respondent through its application dated 20th August, 2026 sought among others order for stay of execution and that its application dated 25th September, 2025 be reinstated. The application further sought review of the judgment dated 17th September 2025.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NO. E105 OF 2024

DOMINIC MBITHI NZWILI.……..………………………..……CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

ZHENG HONG (K) LTD ……………..……………………… RESPONDENT

(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)

RULING

1. The Respondent through its application dated 20th August, 2026 sought among others order for stay of execution and that its application dated 25th September, 2025 be reinstated. The application further sought review of the judgment dated 17th September 2025.

2. The court on 22nd June, 2026 considered the Respondent’s application dated 25th September, 2025 and noted that the only ground the Applicant was seeking the review of the court’s judgment delivered on 17th September 2025 was that the court in determining the appeal did not consider submissions by the Respondent yet they were electronically filed.The court noted that the rules of this court on appeals require that concurrently with the filing of record of appeal and submissions the parties should also furnish the court with hard copies. That Authorities on the role of the first appellate court is to consider the evidence before the trial court, analyze it afresh and make its own conclusions sometimes agreeing with the findings of the trial court and sometimes not. The court also noted that submissions though necessary they do not significantly impact upon the settled principles upon which the 1st appellate court proceeds. In the circumstances the court directed the parties to reconsider the application dated 25th September 2025 in context of above and decide whether the proper approach by the Respondent was to appeal the decision of the court or seek review on the grounds set out on the application dated 25th September, 2025.

3. On 27th July 2026 the application dated 25th September 2025 was dismissed in absence of the counsel for the Respondent who averred that they were not let in in the virtual court platform. The same was reinstated by the application dated 27th July 2026 by Justice D.K Njagi Marete vide the court’s order dated 1st August, 2026.

4. The Respondent averred that soon after the reinstatement proceedings the Appellant commenced execution proceedings and sought warrants of Attachment and sale of the Decree dated 24th November 2025. That unless the execution was stayed the Respondent would suffer irreparable harm necessitating the Respondent’s application dated 20th August 2026.

5. On 26th August,2026 the Respondent was granted stay of the execution on a condition they deposit the decretal sum on or before 22nd September 2026 which was the date the matter was slated for mention. The Appellant was at liberty to respond to the same.

6. This court on 22nd September, 2026 noted that in order to bring this matter to close and save the court’s time the court albeit reluctantly agreed to review its judgment on condition that the Respondent’s submissions on the appeal be downloaded from the portal as claimed to have been filed by counsel and not subsequently thereafter. The court will therefore reconsider the matter and render this ruling on review of the Judgment.

7. The Respondent’s submissions have since been downloaded and placed in the court file. The Appellant did not file any response to the Application dated 20th August 2026 but they had filed their replying affidavit sworn on 21st November, 2025 in opposition to the review application dated 25th September, 2025 and averred as follows: -

a. A perusal of the judgment delivered herein at paragraph 4 of the said judgment, the Honourable Court expressly noted that it did not find the Respondent's submissions on record and further recorded that the Court had directed the parties to file physical copies of their submissions even if the same had been uploaded on the e-filing portal. On the face of the judgment the Court comprehensively analyzed the issues and evidence.

b. Consequently, the assertion that the judgment should be reviewed on this basis is baseless and misconceived. The Applicant invokes Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules as the basis for review yet fails to satisfy the mandatory criteria expressly set out therein. The rule provides that a court may review a decree or order upon discovery of new and important evidence not previously available despite due diligence, an error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason.

c. The Applicant has not demonstrated any newly discovered evidence, nor have they pointed out any error apparent on the face of the record. Their claim rests solely on a speculative narrative that submissions were allegedly not considered, yet this is unsupported by the record, the judgment, or any communication from the Court.

d. For an error to be apparent on the face of the record, it must be obvious, self-evident, and discernible without elaborate argument. The judgment herein contains no such error. The Applicant's assertion would require the Court to re-evaluate the proceedings, speculate on unrecorded assumptions, and essentially re-hear the matter none of which fall within the narrow review jurisdiction. It is clear that the Applicant is improperly attempting to use review as a substitute for an appeal.

e. The Applicant's Application is, at its core, an expression of dissatisfaction with the final decision rather than a demonstration of any valid ground for review. The law is settled that a party aggrieved by the reasoning or conclusions of the Court must pursue an appeal, not review. Allowing the Application would undermine the principle of finality in litigation.

f. Upon delivery of the judgment, the Honourable Court became functus officio, having fully exercised and exhausted its judicial mandate. The doctrine prohibits the Court from revisiting or altering its decision save for limited circumstances allowed by law. The Applicant's attempt to reopen issues conclusively adjudicated invites the Court to assume a jurisdiction it no longer possesses.

g. The Applicant's allegations imply that the Court failed to examine the record of appeal, an implication that is unfounded and legally untenable. The entire record of appeal was properly filed and available to the Court. To suggest otherwise is to question the competence and diligence of the Court, and such a claim cannot constitute a lawful basis for review.

h. The present Application is deliberately crafted as a delay tactic to deny the Appellant the fruits of his judgment. The Applicant opted for review rather than appeal to avoid the mandatory requirement to deposit the decretal sum as security. This conduct demonstrates an intention to frustrate execution while avoiding financial accountability.

i. The Application is frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process. It discloses no legitimate ground for review and is anchored on conjecture, mischaracterisation of the judgment, and speculative allegations. This Honourable Court should not countenance applications designed to obstruct execution or reopen matters already determined.

DETERMINATION

8. The court has considered the Application dated 20th August, 2026 and the one dated 25th September,2025 and observes that whereas the Respondent relies on Order 45 Rule 1 the right provision is now Section 16 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act which gives the Court power to review its judgements, awards, orders or decrees in accordance with the Rules. Furthermore, Rule 33 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2016 provides for review as follows: -

(1)A person who is aggrieved by a decree or an order from which an appeal is allowed but from which no appeal is preferred or from which no appeal is allowed, may within reasonable time, apply for a review of the judgment or ruling—

(b)

on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record;

(d)

for any other sufficient reason.

9. The Applicant relies on the ground of failure by court to consider its submissions to the appeal despite the same having being filed electronically as noted above by the court. Whereas on 28th April, 2025 the parties confirmed having filed and exchanged their submissions; the Respondent did not furnish the court with hard copies of the same as required. The Respondents submissions from the portal show the date of filing as 20th August 2025 whilst the Appeal was slated for judgment on 20th June, 2025. This therefore meant that by the time the court was preparing the judgment the Respondent’s submissions in question were not even properly filed until 20th August, 2025 yet the respondent claims they were filed on April, 2025.

10. At paragraph 4 of the impugned judgment the court noted that it did not find the Respondent’s submissions on record as directed by the court that parties file physical copies even if filed on the portal. In any case the court was sincere since the submissions were filed past the date the matter was scheduled for judgment in June, 2025. The time to file submissions had since lapsed by the time the respondent filed its submissions. The respondent is therefore not candid in accusing the court of not considering the submissions yet the same were not filed within time set by the court and long after the judgment date had passed.

11. Whereas submissions are necessary the same are not pleadings they are only persuasive to the court. In the case of Muthaiga Heights Management Plc v View Point Homes Limited & 3 others (Environment and Land Petition E029 of 2025) [2026] KEELC 5090 (KLR) (31 July 2026) (Judgment) it was held that:-

It is trite law that submissions are not pleadings and cannot form the basis of a preliminary objection that was not first raised in the pleadings or in the 1st Respondent's affidavit.

12. Similarly, in this case the court has perused the Respondent’s submissions, and they do not bring out any legal issue which was not brought about by the pleadings before the trial court. The Record of Appeal which forms the pleadings at the trial court was properly filed. The submissions do not override the pleadings already relied upon by the court to make its judgment. The court became functus officio upon the delivery of the judgment and could only be moved by review if the conditions for review were properly met.

13. In Zablon Mokua v Solomon M. Choti & 3 others [2016] eKLR while relying on court of Appeal decisions held that: - The Court of Appeal had the following to say in an application for review in the case of National Bank of Kenya Ltd vs Ndungu Njau.

“A review may be granted whenever the court considers that it is necessary to correct an apparent error or omission on the part of the court. The error or omission must be self-evident and should not require an elaborate argument to be established. It will not be a sufficient ground for review that another Judge could have taken a different view of the matter. Nor can it be a ground for review that the court proceeded on an incorrect exposition of the law and reached an erroneous conclusion of law. Misconstruing a statute or other provision of law cannot be a ground for review.

14. Upon looking at the Applicant’s ground for review, that the court did not consider its submissions which were filed late anyway; this court is unable to place the grounds therein under those stated in the above Rules. There is neither discovery of new and important matter or evidence, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record nor a sufficient reason given as to why this court should consider a review of the well-reasoned judgment dated 17th September 2025.

15. The court on 22nd June, 2026 gave the Respondent a choice to review the judgment or appeal and this court is of the view that if the Respondent was dissatisfied with the judgment of the court, the right forum would be to appeal to the Court of Appeal instead of applying for review simply on the basis that the court did not consider its submission in the judgment.

16. The upshot is that the Respondent’s Applications dated 25th September, 2025 and 20th August, 2026 are devoid of merit and are therefore dismissed with costs

17. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October 2026

Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder