Employment law

Mwita v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2026] KEELRC 14913 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 464 of 2012
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant filed application dated 9th October, 2025 brought under Section 12 and 20 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Rule 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Rules, 2016. The Application sought the following reliefs:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The singular issue for determination is whether the funds as deposited on the escrow account should be released to the Claimant. There is no dispute that the amount of Ksh. 11,105,639.65 was deposited as security for the decretal amount pending the hearing and determination of the Appeal. The Respondent lodged Civil Appeal No. 53 of 2017 from the judgment of this court and the said appeal was determined vide the judgment of the court…

Paragraph 12 →

Reasoning passage

This half interest given to the Respondent will compensate it for the reduced 12months’ compensation by the court of appeal to 4 months’ salary compensation. This way each party benefits from the same arrangement and in the same measure justice shall be served upon all the parties herein. The funds cannot continue staying in the escrow account ad infinitum. The court finds that the Claimant has made a case for the release of the…

Paragraph 20 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether funds of Kshs 11,105,639.65 held in joint fixed account No. 1004356884 as security pending appeal should be released to the Claimant, and if so, in what proportions between the parties.

Material facts

Following the trial judgment of 17 December 2015, the Respondent deposited Kshs 11,105,639.65 in a joint interest-earning NCBA Bank account pending its appeal. The Respondent had earlier paid the Claimant Kshs 2,888,550 on 11 February 2016 and Kshs…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 464 OF 2012

THOMAS NYANGI MWITA…………………………..……..APPELLANT

-VERSUS-

KENYA COMMERCIAL BANK LIMITED…… …………RESPONDENT

(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)

RULING

1. The Claimant filed application dated 9th October, 2025 brought under Section 12 and 20 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Rule 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Rules, 2016. The Application sought the following reliefs:

a) Spent

b) The Honourable Court be pleased to order that the monies held in the fixed account in the names of M/S J.A Guserwa & Co. Advocates and M/S Federation of Kenya Employers deposited in Account No. 1004356884 at the NCBA Bank, Upper hill Branch be released to the Claimant/Applicant.

c) This Honourable Court be pleased to order that the Claimant/Applicant be paid Ksh. 1,866,221/= comprising the principal sum together with accrued interest in the sum of Ksh. 2,569,155/= at the court rates for the period 17th December 2015 to date.

2. The Application was based on the grounds on the face of it and supported by the Affidavit of the Claimant who averred that: -

a. Judgment was delivered in the cause on 17th December 2015.

b. The Respondent was aggrieved by the Judgment and filed Civil Appeal No. 53 of 2017 to the Court of Appeal.

c. The parties agreed that pending the determination of the appeal, the decretal sum be deposited in a joint interest earning account.

d. Consequently, the amount of Ksh. 11,105,639.65/= was deposited in the joint interest earning account no. 1004356884 opened with NCBA Bank Upper hill Branch.

e. The Appeal was then heard and determined in favour of the Claimant vide the Judgment dated 27th September 2019.

f. The funds should now be released.

3. In reply the Respondent filed a Replying Affidavit sworn by Bonnie Okumu the Group General Counsel of the Respondent herein on 26th May 2026 opposing the Application materially as follows: -

a. Pursuant to orders granting stay of execution pending appeal part of the decretal sum constituting contested future earnings for 3 years of Ksh. 11,105,639.65/= was indeed deposited in a joint interest earning account. Between M/S J.A Guserwa & Company advocates and M/S Federation of Kenya Employers account number 1004356884 at the NCBA Bank Upper hill Branch.

b. That pending the hearing and determination of the appeal the Respondent settled and paid to the Claimant the sums awarded by the trial court as 12 months compensation, notice pay and costs.

c. That this fact was brought to the attention of the Court of Appeal and counsel on record of the Claimant confirmed receipt of payment of both the decretal sum and costs awarded.

d. The judgment of the court of appeal dated 27th September, 2019 allowed the appeal by reducing the decretal amount in favour of the Claimant in terms of compensation to 4 months, the 3 months’ notice pay was retained while it set aside future earnings constituting the major amount deposited.

e. As a result of the said reduction the amount already paid to the Claimant exceeds the amount upheld by the court of appeal and there is even an overpayment by the Respondent.

f. The release of the funds to the Applicant would amount to unjust enrichment.

g. The amount should be released to the Respondent and the Claimant be ordered to release the excess amounts together with interests.

APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS

4. The Applicant through its Advocates JA Guserwa & Co. Advocates filed its written submissions dated 11th August, 2026 and counsel submitted that the trial court found the Claimant was unfairly terminated and awarded him 3 years’ salary at Kshs 9,597,708/=, 12 months’ compensation for unfair termination at Kshs 3,139,296/= and notice pay at Kshs 799,824/= plus costs and interest.

5. That prior to filing the appeal by the Respondent at the court of Appeal the Respondent without any prompting decided to pay to the Claimant ex gratia payment of Kshs 2,88,550/= without any conditions or at all on 15th February, 2016. The Respondent appealed via Appeal No. 53 of 2017 and judgment was delivered where the Claimant was awarded 4 months compensation for unfair termination and the notice pay of three months as awarded by trial court.

6. Counsel submitted that before the appeal could be heard and determined the Respondents on their own volition and without any prompt requested the Applicant’s counsel to invest the decretal sum in a joint Escrow account with NCBA Bank which was done awaiting the finalization of the appeal.

7. It was submitted that upon the finalization of the appeal at the court of appeal the Applicant wrote to the Respondent seeking the release of his share of the invested funds which they were ready and willing to do so.

8. It was submitted that the Respondent declined to have the funds released Ksh. 4,435,376/= being the principal sum and interest on the ground that they had paid the Applicant some money prior to the determination of the appeal. Counsel urged the court to refer to court of appeal proceedings where the Respondent’s counsel told the court the moneys paid were made ex gratia and they never indicated it was subject to the Court’s judgment.

9. It was submitted that the placement of decretal sum in the Escrow account meant that once the appeal was determined the disbursements of the funds in the account would be determined. That a party cannot deny another party his benefits from a valid judgment premised on their misunderstanding and implementation of an ex gratia payment. That the Applicant is entitled to amounts set out by the Respondent in their letter of 29th January, 2026 of principal amount Kshs 1,866,221/= and interest Kshs 2,569,155/= total Kshs 4,435,378/

10. Reliance was placed on 3 authorities including Kellen Wangari Gitonga v Judith M. Matimbo C.A No. E076 of 2021 where money in Escrow account was released upon determination of appeal while submitting that the court should order release of the finds deposited on the escrow account.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

11. The Respondent does not appear to have filed any submissions on the instant application.

DETERMINATION

12. The singular issue for determination is whether the funds as deposited on the escrow account should be released to the Claimant. There is no dispute that the amount of Ksh. 11,105,639.65 was deposited as security for the decretal amount pending the hearing and determination of the Appeal. The Respondent lodged Civil Appeal No. 53 of 2017 from the judgment of this court and the said appeal was determined vide the judgment of the court of appeal dated 27th December 2019 where the claim for 3 years salary of Kshs 9,597,708/-was set aside, 3 months’ notice pay upheld and the 12 months’ compensation reduced to 4 months compensation.

13. In essence the Claimant would then be entitled to Kshs 1,866,221/= the amount claimed by the Applicant herein and the principal sum. This court notes that before the Respondent filed its appeal in 2016 February it made payments to the Claimant one made on 11th February, 2016 of Kshs 2,888,550.00/= and another made on 19th February, 2016 of Kshs 1,357,758.65/=. This amount was for the 12 months’ compensation for unfair termination, the notice pay and the costs all totaling to Kshs 4,246,305.65/=.

14. This court notes the Applicant disclosed only the first amount of Kshs 2,888,550 and not the other amount. Therefore, the amount paid by the Respondent was way above what the court of Appeal awarded of Kshs 1,866,221/=. This court therefore reverts to the court of appeal proceedings where at page 12 paragraph 3 counsel for the Respondent admitted that the payments made after the judgment were made ex gratia but not to compromise the appeal. Ex gratia means the payments were more like a gift to the Applicant and did not reduce the judgment sum.

15. The Respondent is then estopped from claiming that the payment made were way above what the court of appeal awarded if the same were ex gratia.

16. The gist of the case of the Respondent is that no money should be paid as the Claimant owes the Respondent no monies. If at all, according to the Respondent, it is the Claimant who owes the Respondent and the funds should be released to the Respondent instead.

17. To this court, the decretal amount was deposited on 26th January 2017 as per the confirmation from the bank attached to the supporting affidavit. The amount the Respondent alleges to have paid was paid prior to depositing the said decretal sum. The amount deposited was Kshs 11,105,639.65/= which was not the 3 years salary of Kshs 9,597,708/= but again less than the total decretal sum of Kshs 13,536,768/= plus costs and interests.

18. Since the initial payments were said to be ex gratia to serve justice between the parties this court will allow the difference of the amount deposited so that the Respondent retains all the amount for the 3 years salary’ plus interest then the Applicant gets the balance of Kshs 1,507,931.65/= plus half interest.

19. If the money in the joint account was the contested amount of the 3 years salary, the scenario would change where the Applicant would get nothing but due to the surplus of the decretal sum the parties will therefore share the interest of the extra sum equally to serve justice between the parties. The Respondent will therefore get his principal amount of Kshs 9,597,708/= with its interest then the half interest in the extra decretal sum of Kshs 1,507,931.65/=

20. This half interest given to the Respondent will compensate it for the reduced 12months’ compensation by the court of appeal to 4 months’ salary compensation. This way each party benefits from the same arrangement and in the same measure justice shall be served upon all the parties herein. The funds cannot continue staying in the escrow account ad infinitum. The court finds that the Claimant has made a case for the release of the portion of monies that is due to the Claimant as seen above.

21. In the upshot, the application dated 9th October 2025 is partially merited and allowed in the following terms:

a) The monies held in the fixed account in the names of M/S J.A Guserwa & Co. Advocates and M/S Federation of Kenya Employers deposited in Account No. 1004356884 at the NCBA Bank, Upper hill Branch be released forthwith.

b) The Claimant/Applicant be paid Ksh. 1,507,931.65/= comprising the extra principal sum over the 3 years’ salary together with half of accrued interest.

c) The Respondent shall be paid the balance of Kshs 9,597,708/= with its interest and half interest for the Kshs 1,507,931.65/=

22. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October 2026

Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder