Background
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 7th May, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable Tom Mark Orlando, PM delivered on 9th May, 2025 on grounds inter alia that: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 7th May, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable Tom Mark Orlando, PM delivered on 9th May, 2025 on grounds inter alia that: -
Paragraph 1 →This court has in a number of times pronounced itself on the issue of absconding of duties by an employee with recently in the case of Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited (Appeal E109 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR) (18 April 2024) (Judgment) holding as follows:-
Paragraph 18 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
APPEALS DIVISION
APPEAL NO. E178 OF 2025
PATRICK NDURI MWANGI …………………………………..APPELLANT
VERSUS
PLAINS & RIDGES COMPANY LIMITED ….…………. RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Honourable Tom Mark Orlando PM delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in CMELRC No. E414 of 2022 on 9th May, 2025)
JUDGMENT
(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)
1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 7th May, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable Tom Mark Orlando, PM delivered on 9th May, 2025 on grounds inter alia that: -
i. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law by failing to sufficiently consider thereby disregarding the evidence as filed and adduced by the Appellant in the matter or at all.
ii. The Learned Magistrate erred in failing to consider and appreciate the uncontroverted evidence contained in the Appellant's Statement of claim and submissions that shows that the Respondent's allegations with regard to the Claimant's termination were false.
iii. The Learned Magistrate failed to consider any of the submissions cited in support of the said Claim by the Appellant in its submissions dated 15.1.2025.
iv. The Learned Magistrate failed to consider any of the submissions cited by the Appellant in his submissions dated 15.1.2025 with regard to whether he was wrongfully terminated as well as granting the prayers as sought by the Appellant in his Memorandum of Claim.
v. The Learned Magistrate misdirected himself when he came to a finding that the Respondent was indeed both fairly terminated by the Respondent and thereafter proceeded to dismiss.
vi. THAT in all the circumstances of the case, the Learned Magistrate failed to do justice before him.
2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed with costs and judgment delivered and all consequential orders made by the Learned Magistrate in the trial court dismissing the Claim be set aside and the same be substituted with an Order allowing the claim as prayed.
3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.
APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS
4. The Appellant’s Advocates S.K Opiyo and Company Advocates filed written submissions dated 11th May, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. Counsel submitted on the role of this court as the first appellate court while relying on the case of Selle & Another V Associated Motors Boat Co. Ltd & Others (1968) EA 123. That the Appellant was employed in the month of June 2019 as a heavy Commercial Truck Driver at a then gross monthly salary of Kenya Shillings Thirty-Three Thousand Five Hundred (Kshs.33,500/=) payable at the end of each month as par the conditions therein contained. The Appellant had worked for the Respondent for approximately 1 year, 5 months.
ii. It was submitted that the Appellant served the Respondent with loyalty, devotion and diligence until on or about 13th November 2020 when without any reason whatsoever, the Respondent terminated his services. That the Appellant was neither issued with a notice and reasons behind his termination nor a letter informing him of his termination. That he was terminated without committing any known offence or even a due hearing outlining his offences.
iii. Counsel submitted that the Respondent alleged through its witness that the Appellant himself absconded from Employment and was not terminated. Firstly, no tangible and/or cogent evidence was adduced by the Respondent that would support this allegation. Secondly, the Respondent called one Wanjiru Mburu as its witness (DW1) who admitted that she was never present during the termination of the Appellant which was done by one Diana N. Mwangi. Despite the said Diana N. Mwangi being scheduled to appear as a witness, the Respondent chose to call an employee (DW1) who was neither present nor aware of the facts that led to the dismissal of the Appellant.
iv. It was submitted that the Appellant testified that he duly complied with his issued instructions which was to deliver the lorry to the Respondent’s yard which he did. The Respondent through its second witness Mrs. Jackline Wangui Ondara (DW2) confirmed as much. There was no evidence despite the allegation by DW1 that the Appellant did not follow express instructions regarding the dropping of office documents that indicate whether the Appellant was even issued with a Notice to Show Cause or put through the procedures of section 41 of the Employment Act.
v. That there was also no evidence that showed despite the allegation by DW1 that the Appellant absconded from duty, whether the Respondent ever tried to communicate with the Appellant in an attempt to bring him to order with regard to his employee obligations to the Respondent. Counsel relied on section 47(5) of the Employment which places the employer with a burden to justify the grounds of termination while the employee establishes an unfair termination occurred. That the onus of proving therefore that the Appellant termination is justified therefore rests with the Respondent. This was all the more critical as the Respondent clearly denied the Appellant’s assertions by raising that the Appellant absconded duty and left on his own volition.
vi. Reliance was placed on the case of Julius Kyallo Malonza VS Ruth Osolo T/a Eraeva Catering Services [2021] eKLR where Justice Jacob Gakeri held that an employer who relies on the defence that an employee absconded duty ought to adduce proof to that effect. He further cited Justice Nzioki Wa Makau in Boniface Francis Mwangi VS B.O.M Iyego Secondary School [2019] eKLR where the judge held that the employer must take initiative of contacting the absconding employee. Justice Gakeri also cited Abuodha J. in Simon Mbithi Mbane VS Inter Security Services Limited [2018] eKLR where the Judge observed that efforts to contact absconding employee must be demonstrated without success.
vii. Counsel submitted that from the Respondent’s evidence it is clear that it was aware of the Appellant’s phone number and knew where he was to be found and how he could be contacted. That the fact that the Respondent chose neither to contact the Appellant nor even ask the Appellant to present himself at his workstation using SMS service or WhatsApp clarifies the Appellant’s evidence and firms up the position that he was terminated.
viii. Counsel also relied on section 43 of the Employment Act on proof of reason for termination. That this section clearly obligates an employer to ensure that prior to termination of an employee’s employment contract, it is required to prove that the alleged reasons for termination of the employee exist and are valid. That there was no evidence tabled by the Respondent through its witnesses that would have showed that the Appellant was indeed guilty of absconding duty.
ix. Counsel submitted that the Respondent never accorded the Appellant the benefit of enjoying the aforesaid constitutionally and statutorily protected benefits in events leading up to his termination. That the said termination falls woefully short of the mandatory requirements as provided for under Sections 41 & 45 of the Employment Act. That with regard to the evidence of DW1 the same was shown to be fraught with lies and half-truths. That the evidence of the Respondent ought to be disregarded in its entirety on account of the lies as told.
x. Counsel submitted that there is no record of any investigations being conducted by the Respondent into any offence that may have warranted the Appellant’s termination in November 2020. That there is no record of whether the Appellant was given an opportunity to defend himself from any allegation that may have been levied against him including the one that he was allegedly guilty of absconding from duty hence his termination was unfair.
xi. It was submitted that in the absence of any tangible evidence, it becomes clear that the allegations levied against the Appellant as indicated by DW1 in her testimony were false and were extremely malafide made with the intention of denying the Appellant his just dues and further to justify the Respondent’s unlawful termination of the Appellant. That with regard to the process that led to the termination counsel reiterated that the provision of section 41 of the employment Act was not followed. That there was no complaint directed at the Appellant in relation to his performance as an employee of the Respondent.
xii. Further counsel submitted that there was no Notice to Show Cause delivered to the Appellant since from his testimony, he was terminated verbally and without any letter of termination. It defeated logic as to why no NTSC was sent by WhatsApp messaging service or even SMS which is at present an acceptable mode of communication.
xiii. Counsel submitted that the onus after admitting employment of the Appellant fell on the Respondent to provide details of disciplinary action taken against the Appellant and whether the same complied with terms of the Employment contract as provided for under Section 74 of the Employment Act which provides that employer is the custodian of employment records.
xiv. Further it was submitted by the Appellant that there was no hearing done in the presence of a co-employee of the Appellant’s choice prior to termination. It was therefore clear that the Appellant was never given an adequate opportunity to defend himself from whatever allegations that the Respondent may have possessed against him. That from the aforesaid, it was therefore clear that there was no disciplinary procedure undertaken against the Appellant that would have complied with both Sections 40 and 41 of the Employment Act.
xv. That RW1 and RW2 were not present on the days when the Claimant’s services were terminated by the Respondent hence they remained in no position to testify that compliance with the law was adhered to on the material day. Their evidence entirely constitutes hearsay which is inadmissible in matters evidence unless certain thresholds were met which clearly lacked in the instant case. Reliance was placed on Sections 62 & 63 of the Evidence Act on admissibility of oral evidence which must be direct. That the Respondent’s evidence more so the testimony of “DW1” failed the direct evidence rule and must therefore be disregarded in toto.
xvi. Counsel submitted that had the Respondent correctly regarded the Appellant as a term employee then if he had indeed refused to resume duty upon being recalled they ought to have taken him through the disciplinary process as required under Section 41 of the Employment Act, for absconding duty. That it is trite law that even absconding employees were entitled to be taken through the disciplinary process enshrined in law. That it was on record that the Respondent never issued the Appellant with a Show Cause letter, never afforded him a disciplinary hearing and never issued him with a termination letter.
xvii. Counsel urged the court to be guided by the case of Judith Atieno Owuor v Sameer Agriculture and Livestock Limited [2020] eKLR on this assertion of absconding employee to be entitled to fair procedure under section 41 of the Act. That an allegation into the employee absconding and/or a missed call is not enough evidence to demonstrate that the Respondent acted justly, equitably and fairly in its dealings with the Appellant as required under Section 45 (4) & (5) of the Employment Act. They ought to have issued with a notice to show cause and afforded him an opportunity to be heard before terminating him.
xviii. Counsel secondly submitted that from the evidence as submitted by the Appellant before the trial court, the Appellant was never paid his dues in full or at all. It was admitted that the Respondent paid the Appellant his salary for the month of November 2020 and aside from the aforesaid, it remained the Appellant’s submission that the Respondent never paid the Appellant any sum as his terminal benefits when they terminated the services of the Appellant hence entitled to his claims in the claim.
xix. Counsel submitted that Section 48 of the Labour Institutions Act provided that the minimum rates of remuneration established in a Wages Order constitute a term of employment of any employee to whom the Wages Order applies. That indeed as echoed by the aforesaid section, if the contract of employment provided for payments lower than the minimum rates as in this case, the minimum rates under the Wages Order substitute those inferior terms.
xx. That the Respondent never paid the Appellant wages at par to the wages outlined in the LEGAL NOTICE NO. 2 OF 2019 which was tacitly admitted by the Respondent’s witness (“DW1”) who even feigned ignorance to the wages as outlined in the aforesaid order despite allegedly being the Human Resource/Operations Manager of the Respondent.
xxi. On the issue of whether the Appellant was entitled to his terminal dues counsel submitted that on notice pay it is clear from the adduced evidence aforesaid that the Appellant was the one who was wrongfully terminated by the Respondent. That under this claim, the Appellant remained entitled to Notice pay of KShs. 35,222.00 being the statutory minimum wage as provided for by Legal Notice Number 2 of 8th January 2019 that was relevant at the time of his termination.
xxii. On unpaid pro rata leave balance for seventeen (17) months counsel submitted that on this head that it was clear that the Respondent never gave the Appellant his leave as provided for in law. The Appellant initially made his demands for leave before the Labour Officer within the limitation period in line with section 47 of the Employment Act. Despite the proceedings being concluded and an award being delivered, the Respondent refused to pay up, leading to the present proceedings before the Honourable Court. The fact that the Appellant never proceeded on leave was further evidenced by the Respondent’s attempts at claiming leave for a period that it itself was not properly licensed to do business and/or for a period when despite the Claimant’s presence, it did not allocate the Claimant any work while relying on section 28 of the Employment Act which provides for leave of at least 21 working days.
xxiii. That from the aforesaid, it was clear that leave is an entitlement and a right. The Respondent could not therefore purport to firstly claim that the Appellant owed it paid leave arrears in the absence of the Appellant’s leave application. Furthermore, there was no muster roll that even verified the Appellant’s absence on the Respondent’s material dates. That leave being a right and entitlement as aforesaid the Appellant is entitled to this claim calculated as Leave pay for the period he was in employment.
xxiv. On underpayment claims counsel submitted it was admitted that the Respondent paid the Appellant a monthly sum of Kshs 33,000/= per month at the commencement of employment up to Kshs 33,544/= and including the date of termination. Both wages fell short of the mandatory minimum wage as provided for by Law. In the year 2019 the prescribed wages as par LEGAL NOTICE NO. 2 OF 2019 were Kshs 35,221.5675 (rounded off to 35,222.00) made up of basic wage of Kshs 30,627.45 plus a house allowance (PAYABLE AS PAR THE GENERAL ORDER) of Kshs 4,594.1 calculated at 15% the basic wage. The Appellant was being paid by the Respondent a monthly sum of Kshs 33,000.00 which if we deduct leads to an underpayment of Kshs 2,222.00 per month which if we multiply by 17 (the months the Appellant was in the Respondent’s employ) will make it an underpayment of Kshs 37,774.00 for that period which the Claimant hereby claims.
xxv. On unpaid November Salary it was submitted that on this head, it is admitted by the Appellant that he was paid his salary for the month of November 2020. The Appellant therefore relinquishes his right to demand payment thereof.
xxvi. On Public Holidays for seventeen (17) months it was submitted that on this claim the Appellant worked during the public holidays for the said seventeen (17) months prior to his termination from the Respondent’s employ. That a Sum of Kshs 40,650.00 for the said holidays which was calculated at 15 days X 2 (the public holiday rate as par Regulation 7(1)(b) X a sum of Kshs 355 per day.
xxvii. On Unpaid off duty it was submitted that the Appellant never took his off days for the said seventeen (17) months prior to his termination from the Respondent’s employ. A claim for a sum of Kshs 205,960.00 for the said off days which was calculated at 76 days X 2 (the Off-day rate as par Regulation 7(1)(b) X a sum of Kshs 1355 per day was claimed.
xxviii. On 12 months’ Salary for wrongful termination it was submitted that the same being a discretionary remedy, if the Honourable Court is inclined to admit that the termination was unlawful and/or wrongful then the same can be awarded to a maximum sum as proposed in the Appellant’s memorandum of Claim.
xxix. On prayers 2,3,4,5 & 6 that from the testimony of the Appellant it is clear that the nature of his termination entitles him to claim the aforesaid which includes his certificate of service which the Respondent is required by Law to provide to each and every employee at the end of their employment tenure with them.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
5. The Respondent’s Advocates Waweru Kamau & Associates Advocates filed written submissions dated 19th June, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On the issue of whether the Hon. Magistrate considered the evidence tendered and submissions therein in dismissing the claim counsel submitted that from the onset of the Appellant's claim he was bound by Section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove the claim for unfair termination of employment as claimed. That this section is to be read together with section 107 of the Evidence Act that whoever alleges facts must proof the existence of the facts.
ii. It was submitted that the trial court greatly subjected the evidence tendered by the Appellant as seen in its judgment. That the Appellant unlawfully and unfairly terminated his contract of the employment and breached his obligation as an employee by absconding his duty.
iii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant never tendered any evidence of termination and/or any other form of written communication of termination of employment by his employer and as a show of bad faith, he failed to disclose to the Honourable Court that despite his dissertation he received the full monthly salary for November, 2020. The Appellant failed to revert the Respondent's case that he indeed absconded duty and was not terminated.
iv. Counsel submitted that the trial court was informed that Diana Mwangi who was the Respondent's HR had since left employment despite her having signed a detailed witness statement that was filed in court. DW1 M. Wanjiru Mburu took over from her and took the stand and gave evidence on her part by consent. Her evidence was the adopted statement of Diana Mwangi as her evidence in chief.
v. It was submitted that the Respondent's witness evidence (DWl) gave account that on 6th November, 2020 the Appellant after loading the truck at the Thika plant was in possession of the documents which he was to pass through the Head Office at Lusaka Road. However, when called on his whereabouts, by the HR Diana Mwangi, he unceremoniously disconnected the call and thereafter being called back became rude. The statement by Diana was admitted as evidence by DW1.
vi. It was further submitted by the Respondent that the Appellant took the truck to Embakasi yard and gave the Supervisor the truck keys and left. He never went back and never handed over the office documents which were in his possession for the work he had done. This averment was never refuted by the Appellant in evidence.
vii. Further it was submitted that DW1 evidence was corroborated by the evidence of Respondents' Witness (DW2) a supervisor that the Respondent on 6th November, 2020 the Appellant came straight to the office workshop and gave her the keys to the truck and told her that he had left. Further as a norm, she asked the Appellant if the truck had issue for their attention but the Appellant did not answer but left the workshop. This averment was also never refuted by the Appellant in his evidence.
viii. It was the Respondent's submissions that the Appellant was expected to pick up the truck on 8th November, 2020 for offloading at Mombasa Port but he never showed up and all attempts to reach him via call went unanswered, leaving the Respondent to delay the collection at Mombasa Port and had to source for another driver.
ix. Counsel submitted that the Appellant never tendered any evidence that he was terminated from service. However, on the Respondent's side, there was evidence from two witnesses that the Appellant was called but declined to return to work and elected to leave the Respondent's premises with a firm emphasis that he had left.
x. It was submitted that clearly the Appellant had made up his mind not to go back to work despite the calls to him by the Respondent to come back. That the Appellant's was also not corroborated by any other witness and as such the Respondent's evidence by the two witnesses painted a true and clear picture indeed the Appellant absconded duty. That indeed from evidence tendered by the Respondent's witnesses the Respondent demonstrated reasonable efforts to reach the Appellant and its clear he was not intent on returning back to work despite those calls.
xi. Counsel urged the court to be guided by the authority in Julius Kyalo Malonza-vs Ruth Osolo t/a Eraeva catering services (2011) eKLR where court upheld that employer had discharged its burden that employee had absconded duties. That the Respondent's witnesses further testified vide their adopted witness statements that the Appellant came to the Respondents' head office with two men who stated they were labour officers but when requested to bring an official letter from the Labour Office since they had no documentation to show that they were labour officers, never came back.
xii. It was submitted that further, the Respondent testified that the Appellant's letter dated 9th February 2021 and 21st February 2021 from the Industrial Relation Officers and Kenya Scientific Research International Technical and Institution Workers Union (KSRITAIWU)were not received at the Respondent's Office. No alleged Union Officer was called by the Appellant to corroborate, even to the bare minimum to demonstrate his subscription of membership to the said alleged union or the Respondent.
xiii. Counsel submitted that from the foregoing facts, the Appellant had not proved that he was terminated from employment but rather the evidence by the Respondent clearly demonstrated how he absconded duty and decided to terminate his own employment without notice as a result causing the Respondent to incur loss and the court should uphold this.
xiv. It was submitted that the court noted that the Appellant testified that he was told by Diana to go home but he never produced any document to prove that he had been terminated neither did he prove that he had reported to the management about the dispute. Further, the trial court rightly found that the letter by the labour officer and the prayers sought in the claim were not complaining about wrongful termination but was complaining about payment of terminal dues. The trial court noted if he was barred from entering the premises he would have gone to the labour office and union office would have written a letter to that effect. Hence in absence of any evidence and also corroborating evidence for wrongful termination, its indeed clear the Appellant absconded work.
xv. Counsel submitted that having established that the Appellant was not unlawfully terminated the claim for the sum Kshs. 781,014.105 as alleged terminal benefits were not warranted as upheld by the trial court. Counsel urged the court to uphold the trial court’s judgment in its entirety with the reasons as outlined below:-
a. The claim for one (1) month salary in lieu of Notice is not entitled to the Appellant as he was never terminated as proved but rather, he absconded/deserted his duty occasioning his own termination of employment without any leave notice or termination notice from the Respondent.
b. In furtherance to the above the Appellant worked for only six (6) days in the month of November 2020 when he deserted his employment yet his employer paid him full monthly salary for November 2020 but elected not to disclose to the Court. He is thus not entitled to this claim of payment for November, 2020 salary pay to which was also a loss to the Respondent.
c. The Appellant is not entitled to any alleged leave days as the total leave days taken were 111 (less) the leave days the Appellant could have earned within the period of contract being only 33 days making 78 days to be recovered from the claim.
d. The Appellant is not entitled to any claim to alleged salary underpayment as the alleged salaries paid and utilized in full by the Appellant were over and above the stipulated basic maximum for 16 months not 17 months as alleged. From the pay slips exhibited by the Respondent, from June, 2019 to 6th November, 2020 the Appellant's salaries paid were over and above the stipulated basic minimum as per the legal Notices.
e. The Appellant is not entitled to any payment alleged as public holiday as it did not arise during the Appellant's tenure for the period he worked before he absconded/ deserted his duty.
f. The Appellant is not entitled to any payment alleged as off duty as it did not arise during the Appellant's tenure for the period he worked.
g. As to the claim of 12 months' salary for wrongful termination, the Appellant is not entitled to the alleged Sum of at Kshs. 422,664/= as he was never terminated but rather absconded his duty and unlawfully terminated his contract.
DETERMINATION
6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by the both parties herein and proceeds to analyse them while appreciating the role of the court as the first appellate court which is to re-evaluate the evidence tendered at trial court and reach its own determination while placing reliance on the case of Court of Appeal for East Africa in Peters –vs- Sunday Post Limited [1958] EA 424 among other cases.
12. In this case, the judgment of the trial court was that the trial court dismissed the Appellant’s claim with each party bearing their own costs while finding that the Appellant did not discharge his burden that he was unfairly terminated and that he absconded duties. The Appellant appealed against the whole of the judgment fronting 6 grounds of appeal which this court will frame in to two main issues which are:-
i. Whether the trial court erred by finding that the Appellant did not discharge his burden that he was unfairly terminated but absconded duties
ii. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe Whether the trial Magistrate erred in not awarding the Appellant his terminal dues.
Whether the trial court erred by finding that the Appellant did not discharge his burden that he was unfairly terminated but absconded duties
13. It is not in dispute that the Appellant was employed by the Respondent as a heavy Commercial Truck driver on June, 2019 at a with his last salary being Kshs 33,544/= gross monthly salary and he worked up to November, 2020 when the parties took diverse positions on how employment ended. Whereas the Appellant alleged that on 13th November, 2020 he was terminated verbally by the Respondent when one Diana told him to go home without him committing any offence, without notice and due process. The Respondent on the other hand alleged that on 6th November, 2020 the Appellant failed to obey lawful instructions of the Respondent, returned the vehicle keys and walked out never to return hence he terminated his own services by absconding of duties. That he absconded duties and never illustrated if he was terminated by the Respondent. The trial court found that the Appellant absconded duties and did not prove that he was unfairly terminated by the Respondent.
14. The courts have always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court refers to the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others. This court is of the view that in as much as the Appellant had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove that termination occurred before the Respondent could be called upon to justify the grounds of termination. This court notes that since the Appellant alleged that his termination was done orally and the Respondent raised the defence of absconding of duties courts have held severally that in instances of absconding of duties an employee does not usually terminate his services.
15. The Respondent alleged that the Appellant deserted his own duties on 6th November, 2020 at his own volition and he was not terminated. Under Section 44(4) (a) of the Employment Act, absconding duty by an employee constitutes gross misconduct and renders an employee liable for summary dismissal. The Respondent relied on the defence of desertion that the Respondent had no intention of returning to the place of work.
16. The Respondent had a duty under section 43 and 47(5) of the Act to justify the grounds of termination and demonstrate the reasons were fair and valid which would lead to unfair termination under section 45 of the Act if there was no valid reasons and the procedure followed was unfair. In the case of Stanley Omwoyo Onchweri v Board of Management Nakuru YMCA Secondary School [2015] eKLR the court held that:-
17. Desertion can only take place where an employee leaves employment with the intention of not returning or formulating such intention not to return after leaving. Such intention may be demonstrated by showing absence of communication from the employee, duration of absence, impact of the absence and nature of employee’s duties.
18. This court has in a number of times pronounced itself on the issue of absconding of duties by an employee with recently in the case of Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited (Appeal E109 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR) (18 April 2024) (Judgment) holding as follows:-
17.First, an employee does not terminate his employment in a case of alleged abscondment. When faced with an employee who fails to attend work, the employer must issue notice to the employee to render an account over his misconduct. Where the employee persists and fails to abide by such directions, the employer is required to issue notice terminating employment or summary dismissal through the last known address of the employer.
18.Further, under Section 18(5) (b) of the Act, where the employer cannot trace the employee, notice must be issued to the Labour Officer and any terminal dues deposited in such office. Then, the employer has undertaken its legal duty to properly end employment.
19. In this particular case no notice was issued to the Appellant upon absconding duty or to the labour office and his terminal dues deposited therein. In addition, if the Appellant absconded duties the Respondent did not demonstrate that it commenced any disciplinary action against the Respondent under Section 41 of the Employment Act after he allegedly failed to report on duty.
20. In Joseph Nzioka v Smart Coatings Limited [2017] eKLR Nduma J. observed that
“Dismissal on account of absconding must be preceded by evidence showing that reasonable attempt was made to contact the employer concerned and that a show cause letter was issued to such employee calling upon such employee to show cause why his services should not be terminated on account of absconding duties.”
21. In this present case, the Respondent did not illustrate any efforts of contacting the Appellant to inform him that they were considering terminating his services due to absconding of duties. The Respondent only claimed that their calls went unanswered but never produced evidence of the call logs or either an SMS or WhatsApp message to the Appellant regarding the said subject of absconding of duties.
22. On the allegations of disobeying lawful instructions, the Respondent did not issue any show cause letter either on this allegation or that of absconding of duties as required. The court disagrees with the trial court that the Appellant did not on a balance of probabilities discharge its onus of establishing that he was unfairly terminated and finds that the Respondent did not discharge its burden of justifying the grounds of termination of the Appellant on account of absconding/deserting duty.
23. In addition, the Respondent did not issue any show cause letter to the Appellant or any hearing before termination hence it also failed on the procedural fairness under section 41. This court disagrees with the trial court finding and finds that the Appellant’s services were terminated unfairly by the Respondent.
Whether the trial Magistrate erred in not awarding the Respondent his terminal dues.
24. The trial court after finding that the Appellant was not unfairly terminated dismissed the whole claim. ELRC has however stated in most cases that there are claims payable even where the termination is not unfair like unpaid salary, leave and underpayments. This court after finding that the Appellant was unfairly terminated will award him the compensation for unfair termination as provided for under section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act. This court notes that the award of compensation is discretionary with a maximum of 12 months’ salary and the court should be guided by considerations set out under Section 49(4) of the Employment Act in awarding the compensation herein.
25. The court takes note of period of service of one year and four months and the nature of termination which was unfair and finds that three months’ salary is justified and reasonable compensation for unfair termination of the appellant’s service. The award of one-month salary pay in lieu of notice was also justified after finding the Appellant was unfairly terminated without notice as provided for under section 36 of the Employment Act.
26. On the right salary the Regulation of wages (General) (Amendment) Order 2018 provides for Kshs 30,627.45/= as basic pay exclusive of housing allowance for heavy commercial vehicles. When 15% as house allowance of the basic pay is added it gets to Kshs 4,594.1/= which totals to Kshs 35,222/= per month. The Appellant was paid for November 2020 which fact he admitted hence not entitled to this claim.
27. On the claim for leave pay, underpayments, public holiday and off days this court appreciates that it is continuing injury which the Claimant must file his suit within 12 months after cessation of employment as per section 90 of the Employment Act. This court notes that the employment relationship herein ended in November,2020 and the Claim was filed in February, 2022 which is outside the 12 months as required. These claims therefore fail due to limitation period. In among other cases the court of Appeal in G4S Security Services (K) Limited v Joseph Kamau & 468 others [2018] eKLR the court held as follows: -
Regarding ‘a continuing injury’, the proviso to Section 90 of the Employment Act requires that the claim be made within 12 months next after the cessation thereof. The learned Judge did not determine when the continuing injury ceased, for purposes of computing the twelve month period. In the absence of a defined period, the learned Judge erred in concluding that the claims had no limitation of time. Further, upon the claimant’s dismissal, any claim based on a continuing injury ought to have been filed within one year failing which it was time barred.
28. The certificate of service is a right under section 51 of the Employment Act and should be issued to the Appellant by the Respondent if not yet issued.
29. In the upshot the Appeal is merited and is hereby partially allowed with costs to the Appellant as follows: _
a. Three months compensation for unfair termination Kshs 35,222 x 3 = 105,666/=
b. Notice pay ….Kshs 35,222/=
c. Leave/underpayment/pubic holiday and Off days…..NIL
TOTAL Kshs 140,888/=
d. Certificate of service.
30. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October 2026
Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa