Employment law

Mutegi v Fine Aromas of Kenya Co. Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14869 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E316 of 2025
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling is in regards to the Supplementary Record of Appeal dated 9th February, 2026. The court on 25th February, 2026 directed parties to file brief submissions on the same while directing that it will dispense with the issue of the Supplementary Record of Appeal first through this ruling.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the extracts of the Respondent’s attendance register in the Supplementary Record of Appeal dated 9 February 2026 formed part of the trial-court record and could properly be included on appeal, or instead constituted inadmissible new evidence.

Material facts

Dennis Karani Mutegi appealed from the Ruiru Chief Magistrates Court. Fine Aromas of Kenya Co. Ltd filed a Supplementary Record of Appeal containing attendance-register extracts, asserting that they had been filed in the lower court, referred to during…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

APPEALS DIVISION

APPEAL NO. E316 OF 2025

DENNIS KARANI MUTEGI…………….……..…………….. APPELLANT

-VERSUS-

FINE AROMAS OF KENYA CO. LTD…..…………...…. RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal against the judgment and decree of Honourable Charles Mwaniki K. (PM) delivered on 5th September, 2025 at Ruiru Chief Magistrates Court in MCELRC NO. E038 of 2024.)

RULING

(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)

1. This ruling is in regards to the Supplementary Record of Appeal dated 9th February, 2026. The court on 25th February, 2026 directed parties to file brief submissions on the same while directing that it will dispense with the issue of the Supplementary Record of Appeal first through this ruling.

2. The Supplementary Record of Appeal seeks to bring the attendance register excerpts which the Respondent stated had been omitted by the Appellant in the record of Appeal. That the same attendance register excerpts were filed in the trial court and for this court to be properly seized of the complete record as it existed before the trial court the Respondent filed the supplementary record.

3. The Appellant objected to the inclusion of these documents on the contention that they were not filed before the lower court and that their admission would amount to the introduction of new evidence at the appellate stage.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

4. The Respondent’s Advocates Nyongesa Nafula & Company Advocates filed their submissions dated 23rd February,2026 and submitted among others that:

a. Counsel submitted that this court is thus invited to determine a straightforward but fundamental issue: Whether the attendance register excerpts contained in the Supplementary Record of Appeal formed part of the record before the trial court. It was submitted that it is a matter of fact that a supplementary list of documents was filed on 31st July 2024, a date fixed for pre-trial conference for the dispute between the Appellant and the Respondent.

b. That this fact is well-document on the Case Tracking System and this court shall witness it. That it is in fact, on the 31st July 2024 that the case was certified ready for hearing, and a hearing date of 19th September 2024 reserved. That it is also a matter of fact that these documents were subject to both cross-examination and re-examination of the parties at the lower court.

c. Counsel submitted that at page 206 of the Record of Appeal, the Appellant was referred to the Attendance register and asked whether his name appeared on the same. That if at all the Appellant had any reservations on the use of the said register, he would have objected to that. He did not. The Appellant answered questions referring him to the register and as such, the court is entitled to peruse the register being referred to in the said cross-examination.

d. It was further submitted that even assuming (without conceding), that there was a procedural concern, the Appellant did not object to the filing of the supplementary list of documents at the pre-trial stage, nor apply to strike it out. Having actively participated in proceedings where the document was relied upon, the Appellant cannot now turn around on appeal and challenge its inclusion. Simply put, the Appellant waived any right to object.

e. Counsel submitted that the doctrine of waiver was espoused by the courts in Standard Chartered Bank Kenya Limited v Taif Holdings Limited [1997] KEHC 46 (KLR) where the courts cited with authority the case of Charles Rickards Lts vs. Oppenheim (1950) 1KB 612 to submit that in order to constitute waiver there must be conduct which leads the other party reasonably to believe that the strict legal right will not be insisted upon. That the Appellant having slept on any alleged right to object cannot resurrect it at the Appellate stage.

f. Counsel submitted that an appeal is a re-evaluation of the material that was before the trial court. It is settled law that an appellate court must consider the entire record placed before the trial court. Reliance was placed on the case of Selle and another Vs Associated Motor Board Company and Others [1968) EA 123 on this assertion.

g. It was submitted that if a document was properly filed and remained on record, it must form part of the record on appeal. The Appellant cannot rewrite the procedural history at the appellate stage. That the omitted document is very pertinent in the determination of the appeal. Essentially, the Appellant's case hinges on the allegation that he worked as an employee from 2016.

h. Counsel submitted that the Respondent produced an attendance register listing employees who signed in. The Appellant's name does not appear therein. Thus, the document included in the supplementary Record of Appeal is not peripheral, as it goes to the very root of the employment relationship alleged. To exclude it would materially distort the evidentiary matrix before this court. Counsel urged this court to uphold its duty to render substantive justice.

i. It was submitted that Appellant’s objection is an attempt to suppress material evidence that was part of the trial record, which attempt raises a legitimate question on what prejudice arises from a document that was fully ventilated at trial and subjected to cross-examination. Reliance was placed on the case of Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v IEBC & 7 Others (2013) eKLR where the supreme court emphasized that procedural rules are handmaidens of justice not mistresses of justice. That to exclude properly filed, relied upon and tested in cross-examination would elevate technicality over substance.

APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS

5. The Appellant’s advocates Muthoni Ahago filed submissions dated 26th February,2026 and submitted among others that: -

i. Counsel submitted that Rule 15 (1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 (“the rules”) on the contents of a Record of Appeal provides that a memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied by a record of appeal comprising a certified copy of pleadings, the proceedings, any documentary evidence relied on, and the judgment, ruling, decision, order, decree or award appealed against.

ii. It was submitted that at the trial, the Respondent filed and served the Appellant’s Advocates with two (2) sets of documents that they intended to rely upon: The Respondent’s list and bundle of documents dated 22nd July, 2024 (“the first bundle”) and the supplementary list and bundle of documents dated 20th September, 2024 (“the supplementary bundle”).

iii. 3. The first bundle (at pages 113 to 161 of the Record of Appeal) comprised eleven (11) documents as follows – termination notice, a copy of the employment letter dated 5th April, 2023, warning letter dated 5th July, 2023, warning letter dated 3rd October, 2023, warning letter dated November, 2023, a copy of a supply invoice by the Claimant, a copy of the Respondent’s Occupational Health and Safety Policy Statement, a copy of the Respondent’s Environment Policy Statement, a copy of the Respondent’s Personnel Policy, a copy of the Respondent’s employment records for the year 2020 and copies of the Respondent’s job cards for the years 2021, 2022 and 2023

iv. That the supplementary bundle (at pages 162 to 166 of the Record of Appeal) comprised one (1) document a certified copy of NSSF Statements of the year 2023.That the Respondent’s Director testified on 21st January, 2025 and produced only the Respondent’s documents in the first bundle and in the supplementary bundle on that date as exhibits 1 to 12.

v. It was submitted that the supplementary record of appeal describes the document sought to be introduced on appeal as ‘Extracts of the Respondent’s attendance register’. That it is clear from the foregoing that the said document wasn’t part of the record at the trial court. As such, the Appellant’s Advocates did not get an opportunity to cross examine the Respondent’s witnesses on it. It would be extremely prejudicial to the Appellant if the said document were to be admitted on the court record at the appellate stage through a Supplementary Record of Appeal in the manner sought by the Respondent. Counsel urged the court to expunge it from the record and give the appeal a judgment date.

DETERMINATION

6. The court has considered the submissions by the both parties and the only issue for determination is whether the excerpts of the attendance register sought to be introduced by the supplementary record of appeal dated 9th February 2026 formed part of the trial court record or they are new evidence.

7. The Respondent alleged that the attendance register excerpts formed part of supplementary list of documents filed on or before 31st July, 2024 and that the same was referred during cross-examination and re-examination. That this is the same date the matter was listed down for hearing on 19th September, 2024. The Appellant on the other hand alleged that the supplementary list of documents dated 20th September, 2024 contained one document the NSSF statement foe 2023.

8. This court notes that at page 162 of the Record of Appeal the Respondent filed supplementary list of documents dated 20th September, 2024 and listed the NSSF statement for 2023. There was no supplementary list of documents dated or filed on 31st July, 2024 as alleged by the Respondent. The first set of documents was dated 22nd July, 2024 and the excerpts were not part of those documents. The matter was given a hearing date on 19th September, 2024 where the case was adjourned for the Appellant’s counsel to serve the Respondent’s counsel with its 2 supplementary list of documents.

9. The Respondent then filed its supplementary list of documents dated 20th September, 2024 a day after the date the matter was scheduled for hearing but still not the attendance registers excerpts. No leave was sought by the Respondent to file the supplementary list of documents despite pleadings having closed although the same was not vital since hearing was adjourned on 19th September, 2024 for the Appellant counsel to serve the supplementary lists of documents.

10. The excerpts of the attendance register were not listed therein. On page 206 of the Record of Appeal where the Respondent stated that the same were referred in cross-examination and re-examination this court notes that whereas the Appellant alleged that his name was in the Respondent’s attendance register none was filed by the Respondent at the trial court.

11. This therefore means that the said attendance register excerpts were not part of the trial court record to be part of this court’s record as per proper reading of Rule 15 (1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 which governs the contents of a Record of Appeal and provides that:-

A memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied by a record of appeal comprising a certified copy of pleadings, the proceedings, any documentary evidence relied on, and the judgment, ruling, decision, order, decree or award appealed against.

12. Whereas the Respondent could file a supplementary record of appeal if the documents were filed in the trial court but omitted or faint at the record of appeal this is not the case. The same never formed the record of the trial court and constitutes new evidence at the appellate stage. On the prejudice to be met on the Appellant this court notes that the same would be prejudicial to the Appellant where rules of natural justice demand a fair hearing. The Appellant will have no chance to respond/ cross-examine on the said new documents.

13. The court in the case of Ondong (Suing on His Own Behalf and on Behalf of the Estate of Willia Odhiambo Ondong - Deceased) v Kenyatta National Hospital (Civil Appeal E824 of 2021) [2026] KEHC 9067 (KLR) (Civ) (25 June 2026) (Judgment) held that:-

It would not be right to consider documents that were not part of the trial Court but which are introduced at the Appellate level. For this reason, the Court expunges pages 5 to 20 of the record of Appeal from the record.

14. The same position was reached in the case of Macharia v Kaloki & another (Suing as the Legal Representatives of the Estate Of Sammy Kaloki Matolo - Deceased) (Civil Appeal E153 of 2025) [2026] KEHC 13082 (KLR) (20 August 2026) (Judgment) where it was held as follows:-

Since the Appellant has conceded to the Respondents objection on the same, and seeing that the documents were not part of the record before the trial court, the same will be expunged and will not be taken into account in determining the present appeal: these are documents found at pages 29-45 of the Record of Appeal.

15. In the same spirit since the excerpts of attendance register were not part of the trial court record the same ought to be expunged from the record as they bring new evidence at appeal stage which is against the rules of natural justice.

16. In the upshot the Supplementary Record of Appeal dated 9th February, 2026 is expunged from the record.

It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi 30th day of October 2026

Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder