Background
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 24th March 2022. The claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 24th March 2022. The claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →In Conclusion the court finds the claim without merit and hereby dismisses the same with costs.
Paragraph 16 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E198 OF 2022
IRENE NYAMBURA MUCHIRI……..……................................ CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
PERNOD RICARD KENYA LIMITED………....………1ST RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 24th March 2022. The claimant pleaded inter alia: -
i. On or about the 3rd. of July 2016, the Respondent offered and the Claimant accepted employment with the Respondent Company in the position of Financial Controller earning a Basic salary of Kshs. 300,000/= per month exclusive of other allowances.
ii. The Claimant diligently, committedly and with due honesty served the Respondent throughout her employment term with the Respondent and was able, ready and willing to continue with such service right through her years of service.
iii. By a letter dated 1st of March 2021, the Respondent without notice and/or any justifiable cause whatsoever, terminated the Claimant’s services summarily from their employment following a claim of unsuccessful completion of the Claimant’s Performance Improvement plan (PIP).
iv. The Claimant’s employment was terminated without any prior notification and/or justification subjecting the Claimant to great trauma, anxiety and stress.
PARTICULARS OF MALICE
a) Failing to inform the Claimant of the reasons and/or justification for the termination and its extent.
b) Failing to follow the provisions of Section 44 of the Employment Act, 2007 as to termination and the basis for such an action.
c) Failing to apply the terms of the Company’s Human Resource Manual.
d) Failing to give the Claimant favourable and equal treatment with other employees.
e) Treating the Claimant unfairly and with contempt.
f) Exposing the Claimant to pecuniary embarrassment and economic harassment.
g) Victimizing the Claimant for proceeding on maternity leave.
i. The Respondent has treated the Claimant unfairly and discriminated against the Claimant.
PARTICULARS OF DISCRIMINATION
a) Discriminating against the Claimant by isolating her for alleged termination without any basis and/or justification.
b) Replacing the Claimant with another employee without considering the existence of the Claimant’s contract.
c) Singling out the Claimant in the alleged termination.
d) Appointing the Claimant’s replacement after unlawfully terminating her services.
e) Violating the Claimant’s constitutional right to fair hearing and Lawful expectation
ii. As a result of the matters aforesaid, the Claimant has suffered damage to her professional career and standing, mental stress and emotional anguish, loss and damage.
iii. As a result of the matters aforesaid, the Claimant has suffered great financial loss and damage as set out below.
PARTICULARS OF SPECIAL LOSS AND DAMAGE
(i) Pension dues for the month of March 2021 Kshs 27,951.08
(ii) Pension for 12 months Kshs. 335,412.96
(iii) 12 months compensation @ Kshs.373,728.65 x
12 months Kshs.4,484,743.80
TOTAL Kshs. 4,848,107.84
AND the Claimant claims damages.
iv. Despite demand and notice of intention to sue having been given, the Respondent has failed, neglected and/or refused to honour the Claimant’s claim.
v. There is no other suit pending in any other court between the Claimant and the Respondent.
vi. The cause of action herein arose within the Jurisdiction of this Honourable Court.
REASONS WHEREFORE the Claimants prays for Judgment against the Respondent for:-
a) Reinstatement of the Claimant to her previous position without loss of any benefits
b) A declaration that the claimant was discriminated against and suffered unlawful termination.
c) Damages for violation of the Claimant’s Constitutional rights
d) Exemplary damages.
e) Damages for discrimination
f) Damages for wrongful and unfair treatment
g) Payment of all the lawful termination dues set up at par. 9 above.
h) Cost of this suit with interest thereon
2. The Respondent filed a statement of response dated 3rd October, 2022 and averred among others that:-
a) The Respondent admits the contents of Paragraph 3 of the Statement of
Claim.
b) In response to Paragraph 4, the Respondent denies that the Claimant served the Respondent in the manner pleaded throughout her employment term and that she was able, ready and willing to do so through her years of service.
c) In further response to Paragraph 4, the Respondent avers that the Claimant's employment was terminated on the basis of poor performance of her duties. Before the said termination, the Respondent avers that the Claimant was afforded numerous opportunities and support to improve her performance. These included being placed on a Performance Improvement Plan ("PIP") which the Claimant disregarded and whose requirements she failed to satisfy.
d) In further response to Paragraph 4, the Respondent avers that through a letter dated 9th November 2020 and received by the Respondent on 13th November 2020, the Claimant expressed her unwillingness to continue working for the Respondent in response to being placed on the PIP on 26th October 2020.
e) In further response to Paragraph 5, the Respondent reiterates the contents of paragraph 5 and 6 above. The Respondent also avers that it issued a notice to show cause to the Claimant dated 22nd February 2021 which particularized the performance issues accompanied by evidence in support. The said letter invited the Claimant for a meeting on 25th February 2021 when the Claimant would have an opportunity to defend herself before a decision was made on whether to terminate her employment.
f) The Respondent avers that the Claimant had an opportunity to be heard through the meeting that was held on 25th February 2021, after which her employment was terminated through the letter dated 1st March 2021. Although the Respondent was entitled to summarily dismiss the Claimant on the ground of poor performance, the Respondent still paid her one month's salary in lieu of notice among her final dues.
g) In response to Paragraph 6, the Respondent reiterates that the Claimant
received prior notification of the start of the disciplinary process culminating in her termination. This was through the notice to show cause as well as the hearing conducted on the matter. Furthermore, the Respondent avers that the Claimant was well informed of the justification leading to her termination. The Notice to Show Cause letter, the Performance Improvement Plan and the process leading to the adoption of the Plan clearly shows that the Respondent had provided sufficient justification to the Claimant on the grounds leading to her termination. The Claimant's assertion that the Respondent subjected her to great trauma, anxiety and stress, including the particulars of malice, are therefore denied.
h) In Response to Paragraph 7, the Respondent denies the Claimant's allegations of discrimination and the particularization thereof. The Respondent reiterates the foregoing and avers that it treated the Claimant respectfully, fairly and non- discriminatorily during the term of her employment. The Claimant is put to strict proof thereof.
i) In response to Paragraph 8, the Respondent denies the entirety of the Claimant's averments. The Claimant is put to strict proof thereof.
j) In response to Paragraph 9, the Respondent denies any claims of special loss and damage suffered by the Claimant in view of the foregoing. As such, the Respondent avers that the Claimant is not entitled to damages as she was lawfully terminated and the claims for pension are also without any basis.
k) In response to Paragraph 10, the Respondent reiterates the foregoing as
the basis for rejecting the Claimant's demand.
l) Paragraphs 11 and 12 are admitted.
REASONS WHEREFORE the Respondent prays that the Claimant's claim be dismissed in its entirety with costs
EVIDENCE
3. Claimant’s case was heard on 4th December 2025 and the claimant testified among others that: -
i. She was employed on 3rd July 2016 as financial controller and worked until 1st March 2021. She adopted her witness statement dated 24th March 2022 and a supplementary dated 29th October 2025 as her evidence in chief. She also also relied on the bundle of documents filed with as evidence. According to her, she was terminated without notice and felt it was malicious. She adopted the particulars mainly contained in her statement of claim. She also relied on the particulars of discrimination. She further stated that she had suffered loss as a result of the termination and sought compensation as prayed in the claim.
ii. In cross-examination she stated that she was a professional and experienced accountant and that she appreciated the concept of accountability. She acknowledged that as per S-RBD dated 18th November 2025, her termination was on account of poor performance which arose after her maternity leave. She resumed work in October 2020 after maternity leave. At page 21 of RBD was performance review for 2018 to 2019 and that she evaluated herself and stated therein that there was room for improvement and provided details and further that her supervisor agreed there was room for improvement. The claimant further stated that at page 24 of RBD she acknowledged that she made numerous mistakes and this was for a year before she resumed from maternity leave.
iii. It was further her evidence that the respondent allowed flexible and reduced work arrangements for persons resuming from maternity leave and in her supplementary statement at paragraph 12-13 she stated that the mid-year review was positive. However, the stance changed drastically after resumption from maternity leave. The claimant however stated that at paragraph 12 of her statement she did not complain about the evaluation which was done only by her manager and that at page 25-32 RBD was a full year review from 1st July, 2019 to 30th June, 2020.
iv. The claimant further stated that at paragraph 6 of her witness statement she talked of exchange of text messages between herself and Mr. Craig. It referred to review of financial year 2020. This was what led to her being placed on PIP in November – December, 2020. At page 26 of the RBD the Manager reported that the objective had not been delivered to expected level. That is to say there was there was insufficient advance preparation for the internal audit and that her leadership attributes showed she was not sufficiently involved in the understanding of the business and further that she lacked strategy for improvement.
v. The claimant further conceded that at page 30 of the appraisal stated that consumers gave the view that she operated in isolation and did not understand internal customers. It was further her evidence that she resumed work and scheduled a meeting with Mr. Craig and after the meeting she was put on PIP.
vi. It was the claimant’s evidence that at page 17 of CBD, the PIP identified 5 issues and their consequences on the issue on business performance. She further conceded that at paragraph 13 of the witness statement she agreed with Madam Magama on mutual separation agreement and further that the email at page 45 of CBD was from Craig and also contained her letter in response to Mr. Craigs letter. It was dated 9th November 2020 and she stated that she was agreeable to mutual separation. At page 38 of CBD was an email from her sent after craigs letter and it stated that she did not disagree with the contents of the plan in that it was a duplication of her job description. It was not true that she was not meeting her job description and that she was asked to do things beyond her mandate.
vii. The claimant further stated that at page 35 of RBD she was invited to performance evaluation meeting for her to explain why she should not be put on PIP but stated that she disagreed with the evaluation and the intention to put her on PIP. At page 35 RBD reference was made to meeting of 3rd November 2020 which referred to placing her on PIP and further that the respondent was committed to providing her support during PIP.
viii. Concerning her performance, the claimant acknowledged that at page 39 of RBD five issues were raised and that they were same issues as was in the letter at page 17 of RBD. These were performance committee issues, general lack of productivity, VAT assessment from Kenya Revenue Authority received in October 2019. These she acknowledged were to be dealt with as soon as they were received and that she did not liaise with PWC on them. issues. At page 182 of CBD was an email from PWC to her dated 5th January 2021 and referred to a discussion with her. According to her, this was the earliest communication on the issue and was about eight months after the issue was raised by Kenya Revenue Authority. Regarding financial statements at page 38 of RBD, she stated that the signing of financial statements delayed and that she blamed her manager on the issue. The claimant further stated that at page 63 of the CBD was an email dated 9th January 2020 and at page 62 of CBD, Mr. Craig asked her to address his comments on the attached policy documents. She acknowledged that a Notice to Show Cause was issued to her but there were no reports to monitor her performance during PIP.
ix. Concerning her performance during PIP, the claimant stated that she had seen the 2nd supplementary list of documents dated 15th December4, 2026 and further stated that her performance was not monitored using the reports and that she was not involved in the preparation of the reports. She noted that at page 3 of the RBD, the column on comments, she was to share training materials with Mr. Craig and that he was her supervisor. The comments were filed by her and her feedback filed by Craig. She noted that at page 8 of the SRBD on overall comments, she completed 8 of the 16 points and it stated that she had not delivered on PIP by quite a distance. She was thereafeter issued with a Notice to show cause which was found at page 12 of RBD (trial bundle). She was invited for a disciplinary hearing and was informed of opportunity to explain and defend herself.
x. She stated in her supplementary statement (claimant’s) dated 23rd October, 2025 at paragraph 8 and 9 that her line manager sat in the disciplinary Committee and this was unfair. According to her, the committee should exercise highest degree of impartiality. Her line manager accused her of underperformance and that as an accountant there was a duty to uphold confidentiality, but when a situation involved public interest or concerned persons outside the organization it can be disclosed. It was not an accounting standard but a general principle. She however did not sign a confidentiality clause at P79 of RBD. She also admitted forwarding work email to her personal email address.
xi. In re-examination she stated that nothing stopped her from forwarding office email to her personal account. Concerning the SRBD she stated that she did not know who prepared the document. It is not signed. It was not shared with me. Between 2016 – 2019 I worked without any performance issues. End 2019 I received a letter accusing me of poor performance. It did not specify which ones I did not perform. The person accusing me of poor performance did not attend the disciplinary hearing. I was not given any targets during PIP. I was not told of any targets I did not meet. I went on maternity leave from May 2020 to October 2020. I was not supposed to be on PIP during this period. I was issued with PIP on the 1st day I resumed work. I was terminated based on instructions PIP.
xii. The respondent’s witness on the hand stated that he was Fredrick Souligrec and that he recorded a statement on 27th January, 2025 and that he relied on the same as his evidence in chief he also relied on the documents filed in support of the respondent’s case being exhibit 1 dated 14th March, 2025, exhibit 2 of 18th November 2025 and exhibit 3 of 16th December 2026 and that he produced all of them in evidence.
xiii. In re-examination he stated that he knew the claimant and that she came back to the respondent October 2020 but was not with the respondent when the claimant was employed. It was his evidence that there were issues with the claimant’s performance before he joined the respondent and that he read these in the respondent’s documents. He stated that the claimant was on maternity leave for 5 months and someone was reliving her. It was Kiptoo Andrew and he was performing well.
xiv. It was his evidence that the claimant was put on PIP for four weeks after she came back from maternity leave and that the CFO made the decision. Mr. Fredrick Souligrec further stated that the issues in the claimant’s appraisal were before proceeding on maternity leave and the rating was outstanding – 150%. He however stated that the claimant had gaps in her appraisal, but he was not the one rating the claimant. It was Craig who filled the rating. He stated that the ratings were not dated and signed and that he could not find the page with signature. Concerning PIP it was his evidence that it started in 1st quarter, 2020 and the claimant was put on PIP for two months and it was not successful. There was a list of areas the claimant failed. And concerning the Notice to show cause he stated that the claimant responded to the same. He further stated that Craig did not attend the disciplinary hearing. The decision to terminate was made by himself and the Human Resource Director.
xv. In reexamination he stated that at page 21 of RBD was goal achievement 2018 – 2019 dated 7th February 2018 evaluated by Craig. Details indicated an entry by Irene Muchiri claimant and at page 24 the claimant stated that she acknowledged making numerous mistakes but could only learn and strive to improve.
CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS
4. Counsel for the claimant Ms. Okondo submitted among others that:
a. The evidence adduced before this Honourable Court by the Claimant and the documents on record clearly speak to the fact that the Claimant was dismissed on mere allegations that were neither valid nor proven as demonstrated hereunder.
b. The Claimant was accused of underperforming which action led to her dismissal yet the said allegation could not be proved by any documentary evidence nor evidence by her supervisor who chose not to give evidence before the Honourable Court.
c. Concerning allegations of poor performance, at the hearing of the instant matter, the Claimant gave evidence to the effect that during her employment period, she was consistently rated favourably and met expectations as was evidenced by her performance appraisals between 2016-2019 having fully achieved expectations. The Respondent alleged through its witness that the Claimant had prior performance issues during the period of her employment and that her performance had been dismal as at the time of her termination from employment yet he was unable to produce evidence to show the Claimant's performance rating vis a vis the target they had set for her if at all.
d. The Respondent alleged that the Claimant was placed under Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) prior to her termination from employment yet it failed to produce any evidence before Court to indicate whether the Claimant was given any target of areas that needed Improvement/Expectation to meet nor any evaluation report to show the Claimant’s work performance.
e. The Claimant was issued with a Show Cause letter on 22nd of February 2021 to which she responded however, the termination letter issued to her on the 1st of March, 2021 by the Respondent did not inform her which issues or areas she had not addressed satisfactorily in the show cause letter but instead terminated her services without any proper valid reason and/or justification whatsoever.
f. The Respondent failed to comply with the legal requirements of the
Employment Act at Section 41(2) of the Employment Act, 2007 which stipulates that an employer shall before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under Section 44(3) or (4) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance and the person if any, chosen by the employee within sub-section (1) make. In this respect counsel submitted that the Claimant was not accorded a fair hearing or any hearing at all before her termination was effected as she was never subjected to any disciplinary hearing contrary to the provisions set out under Section 41 (2) of the Employment Act.
g. Concerning remedies sought, counsel submitted that the Claimant served the Respondent for over 5 years with a clean and exemplary record and was ready and willing to continue serving the Respondent were it not for the unjustified and malicious termination she was subjected to. Consequently, she was entitled to prayers as set out in her claim which were:-
i. Reinstatement of the Claimant to her previous position without loss of any benefits.
ii. A declaration that the claimant was discriminated against and suffered unlawful termination.
iii. Damages for violation of the Claimant’s Constitutional rights proposed at Kshs.
5 million.
iv. Exemplary damages - proposed at Kshs. 5 million
v. Damages for discrimination - proposed at Kshs. 2 Million
vi. Damages for wrongful and unfair treatment - 12 months’ salary.
vii. Payment of all the lawful termination dues .
viii. Cost of this suit with interest thereon.
h. In support of these prayers, counsel relied on among others the case of Oscar Juma v Telkom Kenya Limited & 2 Others ELRC Cause No. 916 of 2018
The Honourable Court found that the Claimant had suffered unfair and unlawful termination as the Respondent had no reasonable justification in terminating the Claimant’s services. The Court awarded the Claimant 10 months’ salary as compensation together with other terminal benefits and costs. In the case of Dr. Allan Pamba v The Kenya Hospital Association for and on behalf of The Nairobi Hospital & Another ELRC Cause No. E614 of 2020, the Honourable Court determined the case in favour of the Claimant following his unfair and unlawful termination while in his first year of employment. He was awarded the sum of Kshs. 204,000,000/= as damages for various heads he had claimed as set out in his pleadings.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
5. Counsel for the respondent, Mr. Mwangi on the other hand submitted among others that:
i. The Respondent had substantive justification for terminating the Claimant's employment and on this he was guided by the ELRC in Malindi, in the case of Galgalo Jarso Jillo v Agricultural Finance Corporation [2021] eKLR where the Court determined that:
"In terms of section 43 of the Employment Act, an employer will be deemed to have a substantive justification for terminating a contract of service if he/she genuinely believed that the matters that informed the decision to terminate existed at the time the decision was taken. In other words, it is not a requirement of the law that the substantive ground informing the decision to terminate must in fact be in existence. All that is required is for the employer to have a reasonable basis for genuinely believing that the ground exists even if it later turns out that it, in fact, did not. In my view, what the law is concerned with here is whether the circumstances surrounding the decision to terminate would justify a reasonable man on the street, standing in the same position as the employer, to reach a similar decision as him/her regarding the termination."
ii. Regarding the question of justifiable dismissal, counsel sought guidance on the Court of Appeal's sentiments in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR, where it was held that:
"It is improper for a court to expect that an employer would have to undertake a near forensic examination of the facts and seek proof beyond reasonable doubt as in a criminal trial before it can take appropriate action subject to the requirements of procedural fairness that are statutorily required. The standard of proof is on a balance of probability, not beyond reasonable doubt, and all the employer is required to prove are the reasons that it "genuinely believed to exist," causing it to terminate the employee's services. That is a partly subjective test. In the case of Bamburi Cement Limited vs. William Kilonzi [2016] eKLR this Court expressed itself on tire nature of proof required as follows: "The question that must be answered is whether the appellant's suspicion was based on reasonable and sufficient grounds. According to section 47(5) the burden of proving that the dismissal was wrongful rests on the employee, while the burden of justifying the grounds of wrongful dismissal rests on the employer. It is a shared burden, which strictly speaking amounts to the same thing..." {Emphasis added}
iii. Concerning the facts that led to the claimant’s dismissal, counsel stated that the Claimant alleges that her employment was terminated without any lawful cause for the following reasons:
a) She was consistently rated favourably and fully met expectations, as evidenced by her performance appraisals between 2016 and 2019;
b) There is no evidence demonstrating the targets set for her vis-a-vis the ratings she achieved;
c) She was placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) without being given any targets; and
d) No evaluation report was produced to demonstrate her performance.
iv. Counsel in refuting these allegations submitted that the allegations were without any merit and that at the commencement of the claimant’s employment, the letter of appointment was accompanied by a detailed job description. Among other responsibilities, her role entailed the management of the balance sheet, general ledger, treasury, and cash flow. In line with these responsibilities, her performance was periodically reviewed in accordance with Clause 7 of the Respondent's Human Resource Policy and Procedure Manual.
v. It was undisputed that, for the period 2nd July 2018 to 30th June 2019, the Claimant's performance was evaluated by her then Manager, Craig Van Der Zee. The evaluation process was two-phased: the Claimant first conducted a self-appraisal, followed by an appraisal by her manager. Contrary to her assertion that she consistently exceeded expectations, the evaluation for this period demonstrated otherwise.
a) At page 21 on "Enhanced Balance Sheet & Cash Flow Analysis", the Claimant's performance was rated at 80% by both by herself and her manager. The goal achievement under this task, in part reads, "timely preparation of monthly CICO model validating assumptions & y/e cash landing” In the Claimant's own words, she states "There is definitely room for improvement on this performance measure. From maintaining an updated CICO, to proper forecasting of inventory and in-depth analysis of the movements of the balance sheet month on months." In the Claimant's own view, her performance on this aspect was not expectational as she claimed. Her then Manager agreed with this assessment and confirmed that indeed there was "definitely a lot of room for improvement".
b) At the bottom of page 24, the Claimant, once more, in her own words stated that: "I acknowledge I made numerous mistakes and I can only learn and strive to improve on all aspects of my job". This admission underscores her awareness of deficiencies in her performance and formed the basis of her evaluation.
vi. The shortcomings in the Claimant's performance were similarly evident in her performance review for the period July 2019 to June 2020. At page 25-26, on "Enhanced Balance Sheet & Cashflow Analysis", the Claimant's performance was again rated at 80%. Her manager observed that "this objective had not been delivered" and further noted that "I did not see strong enough coordination across teams to understand business performance its impacts on cash, and I do not feel that this has been tightly controlled." Counsel submitted that the observation was consistent with the observations made in the 2018-2109 review. Further, in relation to internal audits, the Claimant's performance was rated at 80%. The observation by the Manager was that "we had a lot of advance warning for the audit but there was not sufficient advance preparation done which left a big rush in Dec, Jan & Feb meaning that points that should have been clean were not."At page 29, the Manager noted that "I feel that Irene is not sufficiently involved in the wider understanding of our business and how her work impacts on the business. She deals well with day-to-day tasks, but I am not seeing any strategy for driving improvements that are essential given the stage of maturity of our business."At page 30 on "Consumer Focus Cultivates Innovation- Tech Savvy", the Manager observed that the Claimant "had not understood her internal customers such as sales and marketing and hence has not driven much needed process improvements. Irene could benefit from excel training and seeking out new ways to improve the setup in our ERP system for things such as withholding VAT as an example.”
vii. According to counsel, these reviews were conducted in July 2020, following which the Claimant's Line Manager recommended that she be placed on a PIP. This recommendation was informed by her performance over two consecutive review periods. Contrary to her allegation that the PIP was imposed without lawful cause, the Respondent considered her performance from July 2018 to June 2020 and, in light of persistent shortcomings, reasonably placed her on the PIP.
viii. Counsel urged the court to note that the Claimant's performance issues did not arise during her maternity leave, as she suggested. The evidence demonstrated that these issues predated her maternity leave. Upon her return in October 2020, she was informed of the recommendation to place her on a PIP. According to counsel, the Claimant opposed these recommendations and expressed her opposition in her letter of 9th November 2020 (see page 45 of the Claimant's Trial Bundle) in which she proposed a mutual separation. This response indicated her resistance to both the performance concerns raised and the opportunity afforded to her to improve.
ix. By a letter dated 27th November 2020 (see page, 33 of the Respondent's Trial Bundle), the Claimant was invited to meet with the Respondent's Managing Director and to explain her disagreement with the performance appraisal, as well as to show cause why she should not be placed on a PIP. The Claimant attended the meeting on 30th November 2020 and made her representation. Upon consideration, it was agreed that there were notable areas requiring improvement. Consequently, the Respondent formally placed her on a two-month PIP by a letter dated 3rd December 2020(see page 35-39 of the Respondent's Trial Bundle). In the letter, the Claimant was informed of the specific areas that her performance was below expectation and required specific performance. This information was contained in the annex to the letter, which set out in great detail the specific issue, their impact on businesses and Performance Committee Feedback. In light of this, it was inaccurate and misleading for the Claimant to assert that her performance was exceptional.
x. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant's assertion that no clear goal or objectives were provided was therefore equally misleading. At all material times during the PIP, she was fully aware of her objective and targets. She held regular meetings with her Line Manager to review her progress. These evaluations were documented as follows in the Respondent's 2nd Supplementary Bundle:
a) In the evaluation dated 16th December 2020, the Claimant was informed that "there is lack of proper planning and initiative" and was graded at "needs improvement".
b) A further evaluation on 29th December 2020 recorded her performance status as "in progress", indicating that although objective had agreed upon, they had not yet been met. It was also noted that her follow-up on team management was weak, despite its importance to her PIP.
c) In the evaluation dated 22nd January 2021, it was observed that she lacked proactivity and required significant prompting from her Line Manager.
d) A final evaluation on 15th February 2021, revealed that, out of the 16 goals/ objectives, she had only achieved 8 of the goals. It was concluded that she failed to meet the requirements of the PIP by a considerable margin. A causal link was also identified between her lack of proactivity and failures in forecasting, delays in compliance with KRA audits, and deficiencies in internal audit submissions.
xi. Following the Claimant's failure to complete the PIP, the Claimant was issued with a Notice to Show Cause dated 22nd February 2021. The letter outlined the performance issues identified during the PIP and the feedback previously provided. She was invited to attend a meeting on 25th February 2021, with the option of being accompanied by a representative of her choice, to respond to the allegations of poor performance. In the case of Mukala v Ol Tukai Lodge Ltd [2013] KEIC 634 (KLR) court opined that
"it is imperative on the part of the employer to show what measures were in place to enable them assess the performance of each employee and further what measures they have taken to address poor performance once the policy or evaluation system has been applied".
In line with this finding, counsel submitted that the respondent had set out in detail how the Claimant's performance was evaluated and the steps taken by the Respondent to address it. Further in the case of Machira v Mugo Waweru and Associates [2012] KEIC 1 (KLR), the Court reasoned that "the shortcomings to the employee and give the employee an opportunity to improve over a reasonable length of time. In our view 2-3 months would be reasonable." Counsel therefore submitted that the Claimant was accorded sufficient time and support to enable her to improve her performance.
xii. It was therefore not correct that the Respondent handled the Claimant's performance management process in an unfair or discriminatory manner. The Claimant had not adduced any evidence to support such allegations. Accordingly, her termination was based on a fair and valid reason, in compliance with the Employment Act and the Respondent's internal policies.
xiii. As regards whether the procedure for termination was fair, counsel submitted that procedural requirements prior to terminating an employment were provided for in section 41 of the Employment Act. The Court of Appeal in Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR set out the elements that must be established for the procedure to be deemed fair as:
"...(i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee; (ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination; (iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination is made; and (iv) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee."
xiv. In addition to this process, it was imperative that where the reason for termination was poor performance, the employer must demonstrate that the employee had been properly supported prior to the decision to dismiss. In demonstrating that the Respondent terminated the Claimant's employment following fair process, counsel submitted that he relied on the holding in Alois Makau Maluvu v Cititrust Kenya Limited & another [2018] KEELRC 1285 (KLR) where the Court opined:
"Where poor performance is shown to be reason for termination, the employer is placed at a high level of proof as outlined in section 8 of the Employment Act, 2007. The employer must show that in arriving at the decision of noting the poor performance of an employee, they had put in-place an employment policy or practice on how to measure good performance as against poor performance
It is imperative on the part of the employer to show what measures were in place to enable them assess the performance of each employee and further, what measures they have taken to address poor performance once the policy or evaluation system has been put in place, it will not suffice to just say that one has been terminated for poor performance as the effort leading to this decision must be established." {Emphasis added}
xv. According to counsel, at all times, the process followed in terminating the Claimant's employment was as provided for in the Respondent's Human Resource Policy & Procedure Manual. Clause 7 of the Policy provided for performance appraisal which aimed to align the employees' goals and objectives with the organisation’s goals and objectives. The policy also provided for appraisal discussions where the employer as the appraiser was accountable for giving the employee constructive, timely and honest feedback.
xvi. The On the issue of discrimination, the claimant alleged she was discriminated against. In the case of Ol Pejeta Ranching Limited v David Wanjau Muhoro [2017] KECA 329 (KLR), the Court stated that discrimination could only occur when there was any distinction, exclusion, or preference made on any basis, which has the effect of nullifying or impairing equality or opportunity or treatment during the Claimant's employment. According to counsel, the Claimant failed to lead any evidence to show any distinction between her and the Respondent's other employees, including the Claimant. Counsel therefore urged the Court to take note that the Claimant did not raise any concerns regarding discrimination during the PIP periods. The allegation was clearly an afterthought, and the Court ought to dismiss it.
xvii. Concerning the question whether the claimant was entitled the reliefs sought, counsel submitted that reinstatement was a discretionary remedy, granted only in exceptional circumstances under section 49(4)(c) of the Employment Act and the Court's finding in Paul Ooko Okoth v Chemilil Sugar Co. Ltd [2016] KEELRC1437 (KLR). The courts have consistently held that reinstatement is not an automatic right. One of the key considerations in exercising this discretion is the practicability of reinstatement. We submit that the Claimant has not demonstrated any exceptional circumstance to warrant reinstatement. On the issue of violation of the claimant’s rights, counsel submitted that the Claimant had failed to demonstrate how the Respondent violated her constitution rights. Notably, she had not identified any specific provision of the Constitution alleged to have been breached. In any event, the Respondent had demonstrated that the termination was fair and that it did not violate the Claimant's right to fair labour practices as enshrined under Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.
xviii. Regarding allegation of discrimination and unfair termination, counsel submitted that the Respondent had sufficiently demonstrated that the Claimant was terminated on account of poor performance. The Respondent placed the Claimant under remedial measures intended to improve her performance, which unfortunately did not yield the desired results. Additionally, the Claimant was accorded due process prior to the termination of her employment. Counsel therefore urged the court to find that the termination was fair and lawful and to dismiss this claim with costs.
xix. In the alternative, counsel submitted that should the Court find otherwise section 49(1) of the Employment Act provided that where the termination of an employee was not justified, an award equivalent to the number of month's wages or salary not exceeding 12 months based on the gross monthly wages or salary can be awarded. Only where a party has proved unfair and unlawful termination, can the damages of 12 months' compensation accrue. In determining the appropriate remedy under section 49, the Court was required to consider, inter alia, the circumstances under which the termination occurred. As this Honourable Court will appreciate, the Claimant's termination arose from her own documented underperformance, notwithstanding the support extended to her, including placement on a PIP. To award the maximum compensation of twelve months' salary in such circumstances would amount to unjust enrichment.
xx. Concerning exemplary damages, counsel submitted that the Court of Appeal in the case of D K Njagi Marete v Teachers Service Commission [2020] eKLR the Court held that exemplary damages were only appropriate in two instances: oppressive, arbitrary and unconstitutional action by the servants of government, and conduct by a Defendant calculated to make a profit for himself which may well exceed the compensation payable to the plaintiff, and these classes should not be extended. In this regard, counsel submitted that the Claimant had not led any evidence to show the Respondent's actions were malicious or any in way motivated by bad faith. As such, she was not entitled to this claim.
DETERMINATION
6. The Court has elaborately and carefully considered the pleadings, oral evidence, supporting documents and submissions by counsel in the matter and takes the view that the main issues consideration in the determination of this claim before this court as the trial court are:-
a. Whether there existed lawful and fair reasons for terminating the claimant’s service
b. If not, whether the claimant was entitled to the prayers sought in the memorandum of claim?
According to the claimant, the respondent had no justifiable reasons for terminating her service. In her view the termination smacked of malice and discrimination in that the respondent: -
a. Failed to inform her of the reasons and/or justification for the termination and its extent.
b. Failed to follow the provisions of Section 44 of the Employment Act, 2007 as to termination and the basis for such an action.
c. Failed to apply the terms of the Company’s Human Resource Manual.
d. Failed to give the Claimant favourable and equal treatment with other employees.
e. Treated her unfairly and with contempt.
f. Victimized her for proceeding on maternity leave.
g. The claimant further averred that in terminating her service the Respondent acted in a discriminative manner by isolating her for alleged termination without any basis and/or justification, replacing her with another employee without considering the existence of her contract.
The respondent on the other hand contended that the Claimant's employment was terminated on the basis of poor performance of her duties and before the said termination, the Claimant was afforded numerous opportunities and support to improve her performance which included being placed on a Performance Improvement Plan ("PIP") which the Claimant disregarded and whose requirements she failed to satisfy.
7. Under section 43 of the Employment Act, in any claim arising out of termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of section 45(2) of the Act. Further, the reason or reasons for termination of a contract are the matters that the employer at the time of termination of the contract genuinely believed to exist, and which caused the employer to terminate the services of the employee. This Court has held in several cases that it is not within its jurisdiction to conduct a near forensic audit of the reasons for termination of service of an employee. In the often-quoted case of British Leyland UK Ltd v. Swift [1981] IRLR 91, Lord Dening stated as follows:-
Further in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority Vs Menginya Salim Murgani, Civil Appeal No. 108 of 2009 as cited in Republic Vs National Police Service Commission Exparte Daniel Chacha Chacha JR 36 of 2016 (2016) eKLR-“ Justice (Prof) Ojwang’ stated that: -
“…There is ample authority that decision making bodies other than courts and bodies whose procedures are laid down by statute are masters of their own procedures. Provided that they achieve the degree of fairness appropriate to their tasks. It is for them to decide how they will proceed”
8. The foregoing having been adumbrated to and considering the reasons proffered by the respondent for terminating the claimant’s service, the seeks to interrogate if the reasons met the threshold of the above cited caselaw. The respondent through its counsel Mr. Mwangi emphatically submitted that the allegations by the claimant were without any merit and that at the commencement of the claimant’s employment, the letter of appointment was accompanied by a detailed job description and among other responsibilities, her role entailed the management of the balance sheet, general ledger, treasury, and cash flow. In line with these responsibilities, the claimant’s performance was periodically reviewed in accordance with Clause 7 of the Respondent's Human Resource Policy and Procedure Manual. Counsel further contended that it was undisputed that, for the period 2nd July 2018 to 30th June 2019, the Claimant's performance was evaluated by her then Manager, Craig Van Der Zee. The evaluation process was two-phased: the Claimant first conducted a self-appraisal, followed by an appraisal by her manager and that contrary to her assertion that she consistently exceeded expectations, the evaluation for this period demonstrated otherwise.
9. According to counsel at page 21 on "Enhanced Balance Sheet & Cash Flow Analysis", the Claimant's performance was rated at 80% by both by herself and her manager. The goal achievement under this task, in part read, "timely preparation of monthly CICO model validating assumptions & y/e cash landing” In the Claimant's own words, she states "There is definitely room for improvement on this performance measure. From maintaining an updated CICO, to proper forecasting of inventory and in-depth analysis of the movements of the balance sheet month on months
10. Counsel further submitted that the shortcomings in the Claimant's performance were similarly evident in her performance review for the period July 2019 to June 2020. The Claimant's Line Manager consequently recommended that she be placed on a PIP. Counsel urged the court to note that the Claimant's performance issues did not arise during her maternity leave, as she suggested. The evidence demonstrated that these issues predated her maternity leave. Upon her return in October 2020, she was informed of the recommendation to place her on a PIP. According to counsel, the Claimant opposed these recommendations and expressed her opposition in her letter of 9th November 2020 found at page 45 of the Claimant's Trial Bundle in which she instead proposed a mutual separation.
11. Claimant’s Counsel Ms. Okondo submitted maintaining that among others that the evidence adduced before this Honourable Court by the Claimant and the documents on record clearly speak to the fact that the Claimant was dismissed on mere allegations that were neither valid nor proven as demonstrated hereunder. According to her, the Claimant was accused of underperforming which action led to her dismissal yet the said allegation could not be proved by any documentary evidence nor evidence by her supervisor who chose not to give evidence before the Honourable Court. Regarding allegations of poor performance counsel contended that the Claimant gave evidence to the effect that during her employment period, she was consistently rated favourably and met expectations as was evidenced by her performance appraisals between 2016-2019.
12. Regarding PIP counsel contended that the Respondent alleged through its witness that the Claimant had prior performance issues during the period of her employment and that her performance had been dismal as at the time of her termination from employment yet he was unable to produce evidence to show the Claimant's performance rating vis a vis the target they had set for her if at all and further that the Respondent failed to produce any evidence before Court to indicate whether the Claimant was given any target of areas that needed Improvement/Expectation to meet nor any evaluation report to show the Claimant’s work performance.
13. The Court has carefully considered the two opposing submissions and takes the view that the claimant’s counsel was not being candid when submitting that the respondent did not table before the court evidence of the claimant’s poor performance. Contrary to this submission, Counsel for the respondent Mr. Mwangi, in detail took the court through the bundle documents ably demonstrating concerns by the respondent over the claimant’s performance, her response when confronted with the issue and the decision to place her on PIP. Counsel further drew the courts attention to the targets set by the respondent during the PIP and the support to be provided during the period. Counsel for the claimant merely glossed over these serious issues and did not even consider it fit to file further submissions to challenge or clarify these glaring submissions by Mr. Mwangi backed by evidence on record.
14. From the foregoing, the court is persuaded that the respondent ably discharged the burden cast upon it in law to justify the reasons for terminating the claimant’s service. Concerning the process for termination, the court is satisfied from the evidence that the claimant was issued with a notice to show cause, taken through a disciplinary hearing which she attended and thereafter a decision was taken to terminate her service. The process of termination was therefore in accordance with the procedure prescribed under section 41 of the Employment Act.
15. Regarding allegations of discrimination, the court has carefully analysed the claimant’s evidence and submissions by counsel and is not persuaded that the claimant evidenced and demonstrated to the required threshold that in terminating her service, the respondent treated her differently and in a discriminative manner. This claim therefore fails.
16. In Conclusion the court finds the claim without merit and hereby dismisses the same with costs.
It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October 2026
Delivered virtually this30th day of October2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-Appeals Division