Background
The Claimant through his Memorandum of Claim dated 23rd January, 2020 pleaded inter alia as follows: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant through his Memorandum of Claim dated 23rd January, 2020 pleaded inter alia as follows: -
Paragraph 1 →On the issue of compensation, the Claimant prays under prayer (b) of his statement of claim dated 23rd January 2020 for an order for reinstatement. The question before the court the remedy is efficacious in the circumstances. The law is clear that reinstatement is a discretionary remedy and is only granted under very exceptional circumstances. The court of Appeal in Nanyuki Water & Sewage Company Limited v Benson Mwiti Ntiritu & 4…
Paragraph 108 →In conclusion, the Court hereby enters judgment in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;
Paragraph 120 →Despite the Claimant’s contention that the suspension came without prior disclosure, the court notes that, before his suspension, the Claimant had made statements to the Respondent on 22nd January 2019 and 23rd January 2019 concerning the matters that were then under investigation. In the circumstances, I find that the suspension did not come as a complete surprise to the Claimant.
Paragraph 96 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E77 OF 2020
DOUGLAS MIREGWA MOGAKA..……................................... CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
KENYA COOMERCIAL BANK………………..………….. RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The Claimant through his Memorandum of Claim dated 23rd January, 2020 pleaded inter alia as follows: -
a. That he was employed by the Respondent on or about 3rd December, 2007 as a Graduate Clerk and was subsequently confirmed to the position on 3rd December, 2008. That he served the Respondent diligently, rose through the ranks and was eventually appointed as an Assistant Manager, Personal Banking Services on 3rd March, 2014.
b. That on or about 25th January, 2019, the Claimant was suspended from employment and was thereafter summarily dismissed on 7th November, 2019. That the Claimant contended that the dismissal was harsh, devoid of natural justice, unlawful and unjustified.
c. That on or about 2nd May, 2019, the Respondent purported to serve him with a Notice to Show Cause letter whose basis and propriety he termed as unjustified. That the subsequent invitation to attend a disciplinary hearing was without particulars and was incapable of anchoring a fair process.
d. That the report upon which the Respondent based the allegations against him was never served upon him and therefore he was denied an opportunity to properly respond to the allegations and form the basis of a fair administrative process.
e. That the summary dismissal was imposed upon him without being afforded an opportunity to prepare a response to the allegations levelled against him, thereby infringing upon his right to be heard.
f. That the terms attendant to his employment were derived from his permanent contract of employment and there was no justification for his summary dismissal.
g. That at the time of his dismissal, he was aged 38 years and earning a monthly salary of Kshs. 143,219/=. That he had approximately 22 productive and active years remaining before attaining the retirement age of 60 years and had a reasonable expectation of continued career prospects within the banking sector.
h. That the Respondent's actions in suspending and subsequently summarily dismissing him were callous, arbitrary, high-handed, unfair, unjustified, unlawful and illegal.
i. That as a result of the said dismissal, he suffered loss of livelihood, opportunity costs, mental stress and anxiety, for which he sought special, general and exemplary damages.
2. The Claimant in the upshot prayed for the following against the Respondents: -
a. A declaration that the dismissal of the Claimant was wrongful, unfair, unlawful, irregular, null and void.
b. An order for reinstatement of the Claimant without loss of benefits and to purge the violations attendant to the unjustified summary dismissal.
c. An order directing the Respondent to pay the Claimant for the entire period he had been out of employment.
d. In the alternative, general and exemplary damages for unfair and unlawful dismissal.
e. Damages equivalent to the Claimant’s salary for 22 years at the rate of Kshs. 143,219/= per month from the date of the summary dismissal, pursuant to his legitimate expectation of a fair industrial relationship.
f. Compensation equivalent to twelve (12) months’ salary.
g. One month’s salary in lieu of notice.
h. A Certificate of Service.
i. Costs of the suit and interest.
j. Any other relief that the Court deemed reasonable in the circumstances.
3. The Respondent filed its memorandum of response dated 24th March, 2020 and averred inter alia as follows: -
i. That the Respondent admitted to the Claimant’s employment and the various levels of engagement he had with the Respondent as pleaded in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Memorandum of Claim.
ii. That the Claimant was suspended pursuant to the Respondent’s Group Disciplinary Handling Policy and was eventually dismissed on 7th November, 2019, which suspension and dismissal were justified and lawful in pursuit of the Respondent’s obligation to protect the interests of its clients.
iii. That the Claimant was issued with a Notice to Show Cause dated 2nd May, 2019 after he allegedly accessed customer accounts without lawful authority in breach of the Respondent’s Code of Conduct, service standards and secrecy bond.
iv. That vide a letter dated 11th October, 2019, the Claimant was invited to attend a disciplinary hearing on 17th October, 2019, the letter containing the particulars and reasons for the disciplinary process and informing him of his rights under Sections 41(1) and 41(2) of the Employment Act.
v. That the Claimant attended the disciplinary hearing on 17th October, 2019 at Kencom House, 7th Floor, Jiinue Conference Room, Human Resource Division, where he was given an opportunity to respond to the allegations, explain and defend himself.
vi. That the Respondent denied that the Claimant’s right to be heard was infringed and averred that he was informed of the reasons for the disciplinary action and afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond.
vii. That the termination of the Claimant’s employment was lawful and justified and arose from the Respondent’s loss of confidence and trust in him, which it could not allow to jeopardise its relationship with its customers, considering that its banking business was anchored on reputation and trust.
viii. That the Respondent denied that the dismissal was callous, arbitrary, high-handed, unfair, unlawful or illegal and further denied the Claimant’s alleged losses and damages, including opportunity cost, mental stress, anxiety and loss of livelihood.
ix. That the Claimant was not entitled to the reliefs sought and that his employment was lawfully and justly terminated by way of summary dismissal.
x. The Respondent prayed that the Claimant’s Claim be dismissed with costs.
EVIDENCE
4. The Claimant testified on 6th February, 2025 as CW1 and adopted his witness statement and the documents ex-1-7 filed together with the Claim as his evidence in chief. He testified that he was the Claimant and that the Respondent was his employer from 2007 until 2019, when his employment was terminated. He referred to the suspension letter at page 6 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents and testified that there were no specific allegations against him. According to him, it was not clear what was being investigated and the suspension was generalised.
5. He stated that he was suspended until 25th January, 2019, which was for around four months. According to him, the HR Staff Manual provided that suspension should not last for more than 21 days.
6. He testified on the letter dated 21st May, 2019 concerning access to accounts and stated that he responded to the allegations. He further testified that he received communication on 4th October, 2019 inviting him to attend a disciplinary hearing.
7. He stated that the particulars contained in the letter at page 3 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents did not reflect his earlier response. He further testified that the letter had an extra account and that the letter and the particulars did not correspond with his earlier response, as they were new allegations.
8. He testified that the telephone number stated in the allegations was not his. He further stated that there was no cash transaction on the alleged days and that no statements were produced.
9. He testified that the KYC process was done prior to the transactions.
10. He stated that he was assigned profile number KEI0184, which was associated with his name and profile, and that he accessed accounts in the course of his duties using the said profile. He testified that he was asked to show cause by the letter dated 21st May, 2019, appearing at page 6 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents, and that he responded to the same. He referred to his response at page 7 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents.
11. He further testified that the notice came back to him after his response. He referred to the letter at page 9 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents and testified that he saw the said letter. He also testified that he saw the memo dated 9th May, 2019.
12. He testified that there was a letter dated 11th July, 2019 addressed to the Director of BFID requesting urgent investigations. He stated that investigations were conducted and that he was subsequently charged with a criminal offence.
13. He testified that he had not attached the judgment of the trial court acquitting him of the criminal offence.He further testified that he was issued with a notice to attend a disciplinary hearing. According to him, the reasons stated in the notice were totally new and did not reflect his response to the allegations.
14. He stated that he was informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague of his choice. He testified that, prior to the hearing, he sought further information through the Branch Manager, although he had no evidence to show that he requested for more information.
15. He testified that minutes were taken during the disciplinary process but that he never signed the minutes and was not issued with a copy thereof. He further testified that he was not issued with the report of the investigations.
16. He testified that he was subsequently issued with the summary dismissal letter. According to him, the summary dismissal letter referenced different accounts. He further testified that he could not choose which accounts to access because he was in the front office and access was through everything. He reiterated that there was no cash transaction. He testified that the transactions did not occur at his branch, Industrial Area, and that the transactions took place at Upper Hill Branch.
17. In cross-examination, the Claimant testified that he was suspended until 25th January, 2019. He admitted that the suspension letter contained general reasons and that he was paid his salary during the period of suspension. He testified that, prior to the suspension, he recorded a statement with the Forensic Department. He confirmed that the statement at pages 68 to 73 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents was his statement.
18. He further admitted that he recorded another statement on 23rd January, 2019, appearing at pages 74 to 76 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents. He confirmed that he was assigned profile number KEI0184, which bore his name, and that he accessed accounts in the course of his duties using the said profile. He admitted that he was asked to show cause by the letter dated 21st May, 2019 and that he responded to the same.
19. He further admitted that he saw the memo dated 9th May, 2019 and the letter dated 11th July, 2019 addressed to the Director of BFID requesting investigations. He testified that investigations were conducted and that he was charged with a criminal offence. He admitted that he had not attached the judgment of the trial court acquitting him of the criminal offence. He further admitted that he was subsequently invited to attend a disciplinary hearing and that he was informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague of his choice.
20. He maintained that the reasons stated at the disciplinary hearing were totally new and did not resonate with what he had responded to. He admitted that he sought further information through the Branch Manager but had no evidence to show that he formally requested for such information.
21. He admitted that he was subsequently summarily dismissed and that he never appealed against the decision to dismiss him.
22. He further admitted that he had a letter of appointment with the Bank and that Clause 7 provided for termination of employment by summary dismissal.
23. He admitted that he cleared with the Respondent upon termination and signed the employee exit form.
24. He further admitted that he was advised on payment of his terminal dues and that his net pay was Kshs. 511,931.90, which amount he admitted was paid to him. Finally, he testified that he was not issued with a certificate of service.
25. In re-examination, the Claimant testified that he was acquitted on 30th July, 2024 and that the Bank was the complainant in the criminal case. That the disciplinary hearing was not proceeded with adequate notice. According to him, it was difficult to get a member of staff to accompany him in view of the lapse of time and the allegations against him.
26. He testified that he was required to respond prior to the disciplinary hearing. Finally, he testified that the summary dismissal letter did not give him the right to appeal, whereupon he closed his case.
Respondent’s evidence
27. The Respondent called Norma Kambito, who testified on 18th November, 2025 as RW1. She testified that she worked for the Respondent as the Manager, Industrial Area Branch. She confirmed that she had signed a witness statement dated 18th May, 2020, and adopted it together with her List and Bundle of Documents dated 25th March, 2020 and supplementary list of documents as her evidence in chief.
28. She testified that the Claimant was summarily dismissed after accessing customers’ accounts without permission and that, in the process, the Bank lost Kshs. 21 million. That the Claimant was issued with a notice to show cause, subsequently suspended and later invited for a disciplinary hearing, after which he was summarily dismissed. That the Claimant signed the exit form and was paid his terminal dues.
29. In cross-examination, RW1 referred to pages 4 and 9 of her witness statement and page 28 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents concerning the disciplinary handling policy. She testified that the disciplinary hearing commenced when there was a disciplinary handling policy in place. She stated that the policy kept being updated and that the earlier version of the policy was not before the Court. She nevertheless maintained that there was a policy in use and that the disciplinary hearing was procedural.
30. Referring to the internal memo to the Claimant at page 6 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents, RW1 testified that the memo was issued before the disciplinary hearing.
31. She testified that the Claimant was called upon to explain the issues raised in the memo as well as additional issues discovered during his suspension. That the issues raised during the disciplinary hearing had been communicated to the Claimant earlier. She also testified that the account number referred to was different and that there were several accounts, with the account in question being one of them.
32. That there was no show cause letter in respect of the other account numbers referred to. According to her, the show cause letter came first before the invitation to the disciplinary hearing. That the Claimant was a Personal Banker and that his duties included giving information relating to customers’ details. She testified that customer information was not allowed to be given over the telephone and that a customer was required to be physically present. She, however, stated that she did not have the relevant policy before the Court.
33. She testified that the loss occurred through transfers from KCB to other banks and that the applications or agreements relating to the transfers were purportedly made by the customers. She further testified that the transaction involving Kshs. 20 million was undertaken at Upper Hill and that a customer could transact from any branch. That the documents relating to the transactions were irregular and that the documents which triggered the transfers were not before the Court.
34. She testified that the Claimant was charged and prosecuted in a criminal case but was subsequently acquitted. That she could not confirm whether the Claimant was on duty throughout the material period. She nevertheless testified that the Claimant was accused of unauthorized access to customers’ accounts.
35. She further testified that the particulars of the Claimant’s job description were not before the Court. That the Claimant shared customer information with an unauthorized third party.
36. Referring to the summary dismissal letter, RW1 testified that it stated the policy which the Claimant was alleged to have breached.
37. She referred to the circular at page 27 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents concerning confidentiality of customer information. That the investigations and CCTV footage showed that there was no customer in front of the teller or the Claimant at the material time. She stated that the Claimant possibly gave the information over the telephone.
38. She further testified that she was not privy to what transpired during the disciplinary hearing and that she could not participate in the process due to a conflict of interest, as the Claimant was reporting to her. She testified that the disciplinary hearing was held on 17th October, 2019.
39. In re-examination, RW1 testified that the date appearing at page 4 of the Respondent’s Bundle of Documents was a typing error and that the Claimant acknowledged the date. She further testified that there were additional accounts and that there was correspondence exchanged between the Claimant and the Respondent. That she did not know who the accused person was in the criminal case.
40. She also testified that the circular containing the relevant policy was before the Court and that the details of the persons who initiated the transactions were contained in the forensic report.
CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS
41. The Claimant’s advocates Mose Nyambega and company Advocates filed written submissions dated 11th December, 2025 and on the issue of whether the Respondent had valid and fair reasons to terminate the Claimant’s employment, counsel submitted that under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, the Respondent bore the burden of proving the reasons for the termination and demonstrating that those reasons were valid, fair and founded on factual truth. Counsel relied on Kenfreight (EA) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] eKLR and Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR and submitted that both substantive and procedural fairness must be established and that even a properly conducted disciplinary process cannot validate a dismissal founded on unsubstantiated grounds.
42. Counsel submitted that the Respondent failed to satisfy the test of substantive fairness, as its case was riddled with contradictions, inconsistencies and unsupported allegations. It was submitted that the Claimant never acted outside the scope of his official mandate and that the Respondent failed to demonstrate any specific departure from that mandate.
43. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant was suspended on 25th January 2019 without any specific allegation or act of impropriety being disclosed to him. After a period of more than four months, the Respondent issued an Internal Memo dated 2nd May 2019 alleging that the Claimant had accessed Account No. 1110415605 without authority. The Claimant responded to the memo on the same date and, consequently, his response negated and extinguished the allegations contained therein. Thereafter, the Respondent never pursued or referred to those allegations and failed to produce evidence demonstrating that the Claimant's conduct had exposed it to any loss.
44. Counsel submitted that, after the suspension and the Internal Memo, the Respondent remained silent until July 2019, when it allegedly instigated the arrest and arraignment of the Claimant. While the Claimant was undergoing the criminal trial, from which he was subsequently acquitted, the Respondent introduced new allegations during the disciplinary process of 17th October 2019. Counsel maintained that the disciplinary process was therefore neither preceded by a proper notice to show cause nor founded on consistent allegations.
45. It was also submitted that the Respondent’s Internal Memo of 2nd May 2019 was specific to Account No. 1110415605, whereas the subsequent disciplinary letter dated 11th October 2019 abandoned that allegation and instead accused the Claimant of accessing two different accounts, namely Account Nos. 1139248111 and 1104581892. Counsel submitted that no explanation was offered for this shift in the allegations and that the notice to show cause and the invitation to the disciplinary hearing did not align. Relying on Mary Chemweno Kiptui v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited [2014] eKLR, counsel submitted that an employer cannot shift allegations or introduce inconsistent accusations without justification, as such conduct offends Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act.
46. Counsel also challenged the Respondent's attempt to link the Claimant to alleged illicit M-Pesa transactions. It was submitted that the Respondent alleged that the Claimant used Mobile No. 0722836374, while its own M-Pesa statement identified Mobile No. 0720380553 as belonging to him. Counsel submitted that the Respondent neither produced evidence from the telecommunications provider nor called any witness to establish a connection between the Claimant and the impugned number. Relying on NMC v Andrew Mugogo [2021] eKLR, counsel submitted that the contradictory documentary evidence destroyed any nexus between the Claimant and the alleged M-Pesa transactions.
47. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent's witness confirmed during cross-examination that the alleged fraudulent transaction occurred over the counter at KCB Upper Hill Branch, where the relevant officers were expected to have undertaken the requisite KYC procedures. However, the Respondent did not call any witness from that branch, including the operations manager, teller or any other officer present on the material date, to corroborate its allegations. It was also submitted that no CCTV footage, teller system logs or user-ID evidence was produced to establish that the Claimant processed or authorised any transaction from his station at KCB Industrial Area Branch. Reliance was placed on Nicholas Muasya Kyula v Farmchem Limited [2012] eKLR for the submission that failure to call material witnesses may render an employer unable to discharge the burden imposed under Section 43 of the Employment Act.
48. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent purported to rely on a forensic report authored by Alloys Ombui and prepared under the instructions of Faith Basiye, the alleged Head of Forensic Services. However, neither the author nor the person who instructed or supervised the investigation appeared before the disciplinary panel or testified before the Court. Counsel submitted that their absence denied the Claimant an opportunity to challenge the basis of the allegations and rendered the process casual, inadequate and incapable of satisfying the requirements of fair administrative action. Relying on Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei [2014] eKLR, counsel submitted that a forensic or investigative report cannot properly form the basis of termination where its maker is not availed for scrutiny.
49. Therefore, the shifting allegations, contradictory documentation, failure to call material witnesses, absence of forensic testimony and lack of objective evidence linking the Claimant to the alleged misconduct demonstrated that the Respondent failed to prove any valid, fair or substantiated reason for dismissal.
50. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant had been acquitted in the criminal proceedings arising from substantially the same allegations and maintained that, although the acquittal was not automatically binding in the employment proceedings, the Respondent was nevertheless required to independently prove the allegations against him. Counsel urged the Court to find that the summary dismissal was arbitrary, unfounded and substantively unfair.
51. On the issue of whether the disciplinary process met the mandatory procedural requirements, counsel submitted that Section 41 of the Employment Act is couched in mandatory terms and requires an employer to clearly and specifically explain the allegations to the employee, afford the employee an opportunity to be accompanied by a representative of his choice and allow him an opportunity to respond before disciplinary action is taken. Counsel relied on Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR and submitted that these safeguards constitute the minimum requirements of procedural fairness.
52. Counsel submitted that the Claimant's suspension was itself procedurally unfair because he was suspended without being informed of the specific allegations necessitating the suspension. Relying on Muthaiga Country Club v Kudheiha Workers [2017] eKLR, counsel submitted that an employee cannot be suspended in the dark without disclosure of the alleged wrongdoing.
53. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent failed to produce the minutes of the alleged disciplinary hearing held on 17th October 2019. It was submitted that minutes constitute the primary record demonstrating that the hearing took place, that the employee was heard and that the employer complied with the requirements of Section 41 of the Employment Act. Relying on Judith Atieno Owuor v The Bohra Primary School [2014] eKLR, counsel submitted that, in the absence of minutes, the Respondent's assertion that a fair hearing took place was unverifiable and unsustainable. Counsel therefore maintained that either no proper disciplinary hearing took place or, if one did, the process failed to meet the minimum procedural standards required by law.
54. Counsel also submitted that the Respondent failed to avail the author or supervisor of the forensic report relied upon to implicate the Claimant. Neither the forensic officers nor the Head of Forensic Services attended the disciplinary hearing of 17th October 2019. Counsel maintained that this denied the Claimant the opportunity to challenge, question and test the evidence against him, thereby violating his rights under Articles 47 and 50 of the Constitution. Reliance was placed on Rebecca Ann Maina & 2 Others v Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture & Technology [2014] eKLR for the submission that fairness requires an employee to be afforded a meaningful opportunity to engage with the evidence and the persons responsible for generating it.
55. Counsel further submitted that the dismissal letter dated 7th November 2019 did not provide for any right of appeal. It was argued that this was contrary to the requirements of natural justice and the considerations under Section 45(5)(c) of the Employment Act. Relying on Mary Chemweno Kiptui v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited [2014] eKLR, counsel submitted that the failure to provide an opportunity for appeal was a serious departure from fair procedure and demonstrated a predetermined intention to remove the Claimant without affording him an opportunity to challenge the findings against him.
56. Counsel further contended that the Respondent relied on a Group Disciplinary Handling Policy approved on 14th November 2019 and effective from 1st December 2019, despite the Claimant having been summarily dismissed on 7th November 2019. It was submitted that the policy was therefore not in force at the material time and could not lawfully be applied to the disciplinary process.
57. Counsel consequently submitted that the procedural defects were not minor or accidental but were systematic and fundamental. The Claimant was allegedly suspended without disclosure of the allegations, subjected to shifting accusations, denied the opportunity to confront the forensic evidence and its makers, and the Respondent failed to produce the minutes of the disciplinary hearing or provide an avenue for appeal. Counsel therefore urged the Court to find that the dismissal was procedurally unfair.
58. On the issue of whether the Claimant’s constitutional rights were violated, counsel submitted that the entire disciplinary process violated the Claimant's rights to fair labour practices, fair administrative action and a fair hearing under Articles 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution, as well as the non-derogable right under Article 25(c).
59. Counsel submitted that Article 41 guarantees every worker the right to fair labour practices and that this requires an employer to act fairly, transparently and in accordance with due process. It was submitted that the Respondent violated this right by allegedly fabricating and shifting allegations, relying on contradictory mobile numbers, withholding material evidence concerning the alleged transactions, failing to identify the branch, officers and persons involved in the transactions, and failing to provide the minutes of the disciplinary hearing. Reliance was placed on Banking, Insurance & Finance Union (Kenya) v Kenya Revenue Authority [2017] eKLR for the submission that arbitrary, oppressive or malicious disciplinary measures infringe an employee's constitutional right to fair labour practices.
60. Counsel further submitted that the disciplinary process failed to meet the standards of fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution. It was argued that the Claimant was suspended without prior disclosure of the allegations, was subjected to a process that was not preceded by a proper notice to show cause, was allegedly subjected to a hearing whose minutes were not produced, and was denied the opportunity to challenge the forensic evidence relied upon against him. Relying on Dry Associates Limited v Capital Markets Authority & Another [2012] eKLR, counsel submitted that administrative action must be transparent, rational, lawful and procedurally fair.
61. On the right to a fair hearing under Article 50(1), counsel submitted that the Claimant was not given timely and consistent notice of the allegations, was not furnished with all the evidence to be relied upon, was not provided with the record of the disciplinary proceedings and was denied an opportunity to question the forensic officers whose reports formed the basis of the allegations. Reliance was placed on Judicial Service Commission v Mbalu Mutava [2015] eKLR for the proposition that disciplinary proceedings must comply with the principles of natural justice, including the right to be heard and to challenge adverse evidence.
62. Counsel also submitted that Article 25(c), which protects the non-derogable right to a fair trial, was implicated by the Respondent's conduct. It was argued that by shifting the allegations against the Claimant and allegedly relying on a disciplinary policy that came into force after his dismissal, the Respondent denied him a fair opportunity to defend himself. Counsel therefore submitted that the cumulative effect of the Respondent's conduct amounted to a violation of the Claimant's constitutional rights under Articles 25(c), 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution.
63. On the issue of whether the Claimant was entitled to the reliefs sought, counsel submitted that, having demonstrated that the termination was both substantively and procedurally unfair, the Claimant was entitled to the remedies provided under Section 49 of the Employment Act, to be assessed in light of Sections 49(4) and 50 thereof.
64. Counsel submitted that the procedural improprieties were egregious and systemic. In particular, the Respondent allegedly conducted a hearing without producing minutes, relied on a Group Disciplinary Handling Policy which was either not in force or was not properly placed before the Court, denied the Claimant an opportunity to confront the evidence and question witnesses, relied on contradictory documentation and issued a dismissal letter that did not provide for an appeal. Counsel maintained that these defects went to the core of the disciplinary process and justified the fullest remedial relief available under the law.
65. Counsel further submitted that there was no substantive justification for the summary dismissal because the allegations were shifting, incoherent and factually contradictory. The Internal Memo of 2nd May 2019 referred to an entirely different account from those contained in the disciplinary letter of 11th October 2019. Further, the Respondent allegedly relied on a mobile number that was contradicted by its own M-Pesa records and on a forensic report whose authors neither attended the disciplinary hearing nor testified before the Court. Counsel submitted that, in those circumstances, the Respondent could not demonstrate that it acted on a reasonable belief founded on evidence linking the Claimant to misconduct.
66. Counsel also submitted that the Respondent's documentary evidence contained contradictions and errors, including inconsistent dates, reliance on forensic documents not supported by their authors, reliance on a disciplinary policy that was allegedly not in force at the material time, and the withholding of material evidence. It was contended that these matters demonstrated bad faith and an intention to manufacture or fabricate a case against the Claimant. Counsel relied on Banking, Insurance & Finance Union v Kenya Revenue Authority [2017] eKLR and submitted that oppressive and arbitrary employer conduct warrants the grant of appropriate and substantial remedies.
67. It was further submitted that there was no evidence that the Claimant contributed to the circumstances leading to his dismissal. Counsel submitted that the Claimant instead suffered significant hardship and reputational damage and remained prejudiced in his career as a banker. His career prospects were allegedly adversely affected by the summary dismissal and the manner in which the Respondent conducted the disciplinary process.
68. Counsel relied on Kenfreight (EA) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] eKLR and submitted that where an employer's conduct is blatantly unlawful, the dismissal is both substantively and procedurally unfair, and the employee did not contribute to the termination, the maximum compensation of twelve months' salary may be justified.
69. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent's witness was not involved in the internal disciplinary process and merely testified in her capacity as the Branch Manager at KCB Industrial Area Branch. It was argued that the persons who conducted the investigations and disciplinary process were not called as witnesses before the Court. Counsel maintained that the documents and witness statement subsequently produced by the Respondent could not cure the deficiencies in the internal disciplinary process.
70. Finally, counsel submitted that the Claimant had been acquitted in Milimani Chief Magistrates' Court Criminal Case Nos. 1198 of 2020 and 1624 of 2019, which allegedly arose from the same facts relied upon to dismiss him. While acknowledging that an acquittal is not automatically binding in employment proceedings, counsel submitted, relying on Meshack Kito v Kenya Ports Authority [2019] eKLR, that an acquittal on identical facts was persuasive evidence that the employer lacked a substantive basis for termination. Counsel maintained that the Respondent deliberately failed to call the functionaries who conducted the internal disciplinary process and that its witness could not cure the deficiencies arising from the introduction of new allegations which were not preceded by a proper notice to show cause. Counsel therefore urged the Court to find that the Claimant had proved his case and was entitled to the reliefs sought.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
71. The Respondent’s Advocates Waweru Gatonye & Associates Advocates filed written submissions dated 12th February, 2026 and on the issue of whether there were justifiable reasons for the summary dismissal, counsel submitted that Sections 41 and 44 of the Employment Act governed the procedure for termination and summary dismissal. Counsel submitted that an employer was entitled to summarily dismiss an employee who was guilty of gross misconduct and that Section 44(4) allowed for further grounds of misconduct to be provided for under an employer's policies and regulations.
72. That the Claimant was dismissed for gross misconduct arising from the alleged unauthorized access to customers’ accounts and disclosure of confidential customer information to third parties. That the Claimant’s contract of employment dated 20th January, 2016, under Clause 7(c), provided for summary dismissal in cases of misappropriation, dishonesty, gross misconduct, conduct likely to bring the Bank into disrepute, or serious breach of the contract, HR Policy or other Bank policies.
73. It was submitted that the relationship between a bank and its customers is founded on trust and that any unauthorized access to customers’ accounts exposed the Bank to financial and reputational risk. In support of this position, counsel relied on Turnbo Foam Mattresses Industries Limited v First Community Bank & 2 Others (Civil Appeal 62 of 2019) [2022] KEHC 16950 (KLR) and Co-operative Bank of Kenya Limited v Obure (Civil Appeal 61 of 2019) [2024] KEHC 5275 (KLR).
74. It was Counsel’s submission that the Claimant was suspended after preliminary investigations showed that he was allegedly involved in irregular access to customers’ accounts. According to counsel, the Bank’s forensic investigations showed that the Claimant’s credentials and workstation had been used to access a customer’s account without justification and that customer information was allegedly shared with a third party. That the Claimant had recorded statements with the Bank’s Forensic Department before his suspension and was therefore aware of the allegations being investigated.
75. Counsel further submitted that the alleged activities exposed the Bank to a financial loss of Kshs. 21,520,000 and USD 82,390 and involved activities affecting several branches. That the matter was serious enough to warrant investigations and was later referred to the Banking Fraud Investigations Department for further investigations.
76. Counsel relied on Stephen Ndolo v Nairobi City Water & Sewerage Company Limited (Civil Appeal No. 419 of 2019) and submitted that honesty is essential where an employee handles finances. That where an employee acts dishonestly in the discharge of such duties and the conduct results in a breakdown of the employment relationship, the employer is entitled to terminate the employment.
77. Counsel also submitted that although the Claimant testified that he had been acquitted in the criminal case, he did not plead the criminal proceedings in his Claim or produce the judgment of the criminal court. Counsel argued that the fact that the Claimant was charged and subjected to a criminal trial demonstrated that the allegations against him were not frivolous. Therefore, the reasons leading to the dismissal were valid and raised serious questions concerning the Claimant’s integrity as a senior employee of the Bank.
78. On the issue of whether the Respondent followed a fair procedure, counsel submitted that Section 41 of the Employment Act required the employer to explain the reasons for the contemplated termination to the employee, allow the employee to be accompanied by another employee or union representative of his choice, and hear and consider the employee’s representations before making a decision. Counsel submitted that the Claimant was made aware of the allegations against him at different stages. He had recorded statements with the Forensic Department on 22nd and 23rd January, 2019. He was thereafter suspended by the letter dated 25th January, 2019 and was subsequently issued with an internal memo dated 2nd May, 2019 requiring him to explain his access to account number 1110415605 and the alleged loss arising therefrom. Counsel submitted that the Claimant responded to the memo.
79. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant was later issued with the letter received on 11th October, 2019 setting out further allegations concerning accounts number 1139248111 and 1104581892, the alleged sharing of confidential customer information and the alleged M-Pesa transactions. The letter also raised the issue of the financial loss allegedly suffered by the Bank and required the Claimant to explain why disciplinary action should not be taken against him.
80. Counsel submitted that after receiving the Claimant’s responses, the Bank invited him to attend a disciplinary hearing on 17th October, 2019. The Claimant was informed of his right to be accompanied by a member of staff of his choice. Counsel submitted that the Claimant acknowledged receipt of the invitation and the charges and attended the disciplinary hearing, after which the disciplinary committee considered his response and decided to summarily dismiss him.
81. On the Claimant’s argument that his suspension was unfair, counsel submitted that the Claimant had already recorded statements with the Bank’s Forensic Department before the suspension and was therefore aware of the matters under investigation. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant was paid half of his basic salary during the suspension period. Counsel relied on Martin Omido Mmatta v Consolidated Bank Kenya Limited (ELRC Cause No. E840 of 2023) and submitted that an employer may impose an administrative suspension where operational interests require it, particularly where the employee holds a sensitive position with access to important information. Counsel argued that the Claimant’s suspension was necessary to allow investigations to proceed and to safeguard the Bank’s and its customers’ information.
82. Counsel also relied on Donald C. Avude v Kenya Forest Service [2015] eKLR and submitted that suspension may be used to allow an employer to conduct investigations where the continued presence of an employee may jeopardise those investigations. Counsel maintained that the Claimant’s suspension was lawful and justified in the circumstances.
83. On the issue of the forensic officers and the forensic report, counsel submitted that the Claimant’s complaint that the authors of the forensic report did not attend the disciplinary hearing or testify in Court should be rejected. Counsel argued that the Claimant did not raise that issue before the disciplinary committee and did not seek summons to have those persons called for cross-examination before the Court, as permitted under Rule 58 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024.
84. On the issue of the alleged violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights, counsel submitted that the constitutional claim was introduced for the first time in the Claimant’s submissions and had not been pleaded in the Memorandum of Claim. Counsel argued that the Claimant could not introduce a new cause of action through submissions.
85. Counsel relied on Martin Omido Mmatta v Consolidated Bank Kenya Limited, where the Court rejected a constitutional claim that had been introduced through submissions. Counsel also relied on Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] eKLR and submitted that a party alleging violation of constitutional rights must plead with reasonable precision the rights alleged to have been violated and the manner in which they were violated.
86. Counsel submitted that, in any event, the Claimant had been given an opportunity to explain himself both in writing and before the disciplinary committee. Therefore, the constitutional claim lacked merit and should be rejected.
87. Counsel further relied on Mutiso v South Eastern Kenya University (SEKU) (Cause E04 of 2021) [2024] KEELRC 647 (KLR) and submitted that where an employee is issued with a show cause letter, given an opportunity to respond and attends a disciplinary hearing, the requirements of Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act may be satisfied, depending on the circumstances of the case. Counsel urged the Court to find that the Claimant’s dismissal was both substantively and procedurally fair.
88. Counsel also relied on Wambua v Stanbic Bank Kenya Limited (Cause 1487 of 2018) [2023] KEELRC 491 (KLR) and referred to the test of substantive justification and procedural fairness under Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, as discussed in Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR. Counsel submitted that the Respondent had discharged its burden of proving both a valid reason and a fair procedure.
89. On the issue of the reliefs sought, counsel submitted that the Claimant had not proved that his dismissal was unlawful or unfair and was therefore not entitled to the remedies sought. Counsel further submitted that reinstatement would not be practical because the Claimant left the Bank in 2019, cleared with the Bank and received his terminal dues. Counsel referred to Section 49(4) of the Employment Act and submitted that reinstatement should only be granted where it is practicable and appropriate.
90. Counsel also submitted that the Claimant’s claim for general and exemplary damages, as well as salary for the period up to retirement, had no basis in law. It was submitted that the statutory remedy for unfair termination is provided under Section 49 of the Employment Act and that compensation is subject to the statutory limit of up to twelve months’ salary. Counsel argued that an award of salary up to retirement age would amount to unjust enrichment.
91. In conclusion, counsel submitted that the Respondent had valid reasons to summarily dismiss the Claimant and that the Claimant was accorded a fair hearing and urged the Court to dismiss the Claim with costs.
DETERMINATION
92. This court albeit the long pleadings by parties has reviewed and considered the pleadings, testimonies, submissions and authorities relied on by all parties and has I have come up with four main issues: -Aa. aa.
a. WhetherWhether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.
b. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWheWhether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Whether the Claimant’s summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.
93. The courts have always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court is guided by the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others.
94. On the substantive test the employer must give a fair and valid reason as per section 43 of the Employment Act. Section 45 of the Employment Act is clear that where there is no valid and fair reasons such termination is unfair. Section 44 of the Employment Act ,2007 stipulates when summary dismissal can occur in particular under Section 44(4) (c) of the Employment Act, warrants summary dismissal on grounds of gross misconduct and especially in a case where an employee commits or, on reasonable and sufficient grounds, is suspected of having committed a criminal offence against or to the substantial detriment of his employer or his employer's property.
95. It is not disputed that on 25th January 2019, the Claimant was suspended from employment pending preliminary investigations by the Respondent into allegations relating to his involvement in the impugned fraudulent transactions and the alleged unauthorised access to customer accounts.
96. Despite the Claimant’s contention that the suspension came without prior disclosure, the court notes that, before his suspension, the Claimant had made statements to the Respondent on 22nd January 2019 and 23rd January 2019 concerning the matters that were then under investigation. In the circumstances, I find that the suspension did not come as a complete surprise to the Claimant.
97. Subsequently, he was suspended and during the period of suspension, paid half of his basic salary and was also required to report to the Respondent every Friday until the end of the month. Thereafter, on 2nd May 2019, the Respondent issued an internal memo to the Claimant alleging that he had accessed account number 1110415605 without authority. The Claimant responded to the said memo through a letter dated 2nd May 2019, explaining his position in respect of the allegations made against him.
98. The matter subsequently proceeded to criminal investigations, and, on 22nd July 2019, the Claimant was arrested and arraigned in connection with the allegations against him. At this point in time, the court is unable to ascertain the outcome of the criminal proceedings as no judgment, order or other evidence was produced before it, therefore the court is not persuaded that the Claimant was acquitted of his charges.
99. On 11th October 2019 the Claimant received another letter from the Respondent, which the court considers sufficient as a Notice to Show Cause, informing the Claimant of detailed allegations he was facing, requiring him to provide clarifications in respect thereof as follows:
(i) Why the Clamant accessed customer's account number 1139248111and1104581892 without justifiable cause and shared the customer confidential information with a non-account holder detail of which were captured in a tabular form.
(ii) Why the Claimant received a sum total of Kshs. 10,000/= from one Mr. Mutembei of mobile 0720380553through Mpesa to the Claimant’s line 0722836374 on the 27t1t October, 2018 and on the 3rd October,2018.
(iii) Why the Claimant exposed and or facilitated exposure of the Bank to a financial loss of Kshs. 21,520and USD 82,390.00.
(iv) Why disciplinary action should not be taken against the Claimant for gross misconduct as described in a, b & c above and resultant exposure of the Bank to a financial loss of Kshs. 21,520and USD 82,390.00.
100. The Claimant was thereafter invited to attend a disciplinary hearing on 17th October 2019 and thereafter summarily dismissed from employment. The difficulty that I am having, is that no minutes of these disciplinary proceedings were produced before this Court and the Respondent does not explain why it did not record the proceedings in minutes.
101. The Respondent is aware that it has a statutory burden to prove lawful termination pursuant to section 43(1) of the Act which reads as follows:
“In any claim arising out of termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of section 45.”
102. The Respondent, also being aware of the procedural safeguards prescribed under Section 41 of the Employment Act, ought to have appreciated the importance of maintaining a record of the disciplinary proceedings particularly given that such proceedings may subsequently be subjected to scrutiny in litigation.
103. I am guided by the Court of Appeal in Agricultural Finance Corporation v Jillo (Civil Appeal E002 of 2023) [2025] KECA 2068 (KLR) (5 December 2025) (Judgment) where it was held as follows;
“For emphasis, it cannot be gainsaid that it is expected that the Disciplinary Committee should record the proceedings before it for evidential purposes. The rationale is simple; the disciplinary procedure is prone to exposure to litigation. The need for written minutes as evidence in such instances has been underscored by this Court. In the case of Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers vs. Kisii Bottlers Ltd (2020) KECA 209 (KLR), while agreeing with the findings of Marete J. that the respondent’s termination of employment was lawful for failure to seek leave of absence, the Court faulted the appellant for failing to produce evidence that it adhered to the mandatory prescribed procedure under section 41(1) of the Act. It held that:
“There was no evidence by the respondent that apart from the dismissal letter the grievant was given any explanation for the disciplinary action in the presence of another employee or a shop floor union representative, which is a mandatory requirement. Where that is not done, the termination of employment is deemed unfair; see section 45(2) of the Employment Act.”
104. Similarly, the court in Mini Bakeries (MSA) Limited vs. Ali Omar Faraj (2019) KECA 479 (KLR) had this to say on the importance of the minutes of a meeting in a disciplinary hearing:
“It is not that we prescribe that minutes for disciplinary hearing should take a certain format but that it ought to be clear from the minutes that a disciplinary hearing was conducted; that the allegations were tabled before the disciplinary committee and the employee was given an opportunity to respond to the same.”
105. Moreover, in Emojong vs. Henkel Chemicals (EA) (2025) KEELRC 259 (KLR) Wasilwa, J. p rendered herself thus:
“There is no indication that the process set out above was followed and without any minutes of what transpired and with the claimant expressing reservation of the entire process, I find the respondent did not establish the existence of valid reason for claimant’s dismissal nor is there evidence that the claimant was subjected to a fair disciplinary process.”
106. The Claimant's position was that he was not afforded a fair hearing, while the Respondent maintained that the disciplinary hearing conducted on 17th October 2019 was fair. Ordinarily, the minutes of the disciplinary proceedings would have assisted the Court in determining whether either of the parties' accounts was borne out by the record. The minutes could have shown, among other things, the persons who attended the hearing, the allegations that were placed before the Claimant, whether he was informed of his right to be accompanied, the response he gave to the allegations and whether he was afforded an opportunity to raise any issue, call for an adjournment or otherwise make his representations. They would also show whether the disciplinary panel considered his response before arriving at the decision to summarily dismiss him.
107. These facts could not be established to the required standard by oral testimony. Consequently, in the absence of minutes, the Court is left with no basis upon which to find that the requirements of procedural fairness were complied with. In the above regard, the court finds and holds that the Claimant’s summary dismissal was not procedurally fair.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Reinstatement
108. On the issue of compensation, the Claimant prays under prayer (b) of his statement of claim dated 23rd January 2020 for an order for reinstatement. The question before the court the remedy is efficacious in the circumstances. The law is clear that reinstatement is a discretionary remedy and is only granted under very exceptional circumstances. The court of Appeal in Nanyuki Water & Sewage Company Limited v Benson Mwiti Ntiritu & 4 others [2018] KECA 196 (KLR) stated as follows;
“Reinstatement is a lawful remedy which a trial court can grant as spelt out in section 12 (3) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. It must, however, accord with written law and the relevant provision is section 49 (4) of the Act which lists no less than 13 factors to be considered by the court before reinstatement is ordered, to wit:
a) . The wishes of the employee;
b) The circumstances in which the termination took place, including the extent, if any, to which the employee caused or contributed to the termination; and
c) The practicability of recommending reinstatement or re-engagement;
d) The common law principle that there should be no order for specific performance in a contract for service except in very exceptional circumstances;
e) The employee’s length of service with the employer;
f) The reasonable expectation of the employee as to the length of time for which his employment with that employer might have continued but for the termination;
g) The opportunities available to the employee for securing comparable or suitable employment with another employer;
h) The value of any severance payable by law;
i) The right to press claims or any unpaid wages, expenses or other claims owing to the employee;
j) Any expenses reasonably incurred by the employee as a consequence of the termination;
k) Any conduct of the employee which to any extent caused or contributed to the termination;
l) Any failure by the employee to reasonably mitigate the losses attributable to the unjustified termination; and
m) Any compensation, including ex gratia payment, in respect of termination of employment paid by the employer and received by the employee.”
109. It is clear from the facts of this case, that the confidence between the Claimant and Respondent had irretrievably broken down. The Claimant even alleges that the Respondent had him arrested and charged in criminal court. The Court does not therefore find an order for reinstatement convenient in the circumstances at would amount to imposing the Claimant upon an unwilling employer.
110. On the issue of seeking damages equivalent to the Claimant’s salary for the remaining 22 years of his anticipated employment, based on his alleged legitimate expectation of a fair industrial relationship, the court takes the view that the law is more or less clear that claims for anticipatory salaries or future salary earnings lack a statutory foundation under the current Employment Act, 2007. Employment is not a lifetime engagement and can terminate before the expected date of retirement for reasons such as death, resignation or gross misconduct. This is the rationale behind providing for a termination clause in most contracts of employment.
111. The Supreme court in the case of Ngokonyo & 2 others v Telkom Kenya Limited (Petition E009 of 2025) [2025] KESC 75 (KLR) (11 December 2025) (Judgment) held that;
“Based on the authorities reviewed and on our own analysis, we come to the following conclusion before we finally answer the framed question:
i. The designation of employment as “permanent and pensionable” does not guarantee tenure until retirement age. Such contracts remain terminable, subject to the law and terms of service.
ii. Retirement in public interest constitutes a form of involuntary termination of employment. The employer bears the burden of proving that it is not in the public interest to retain the employee and must ensure compliance with due process.
iii. Claims for anticipatory salaries or future salary earnings lack a statutory foundation under both the repealed Employment Act (Cap 226) and the current Employment Act, 2007.
iv. The general measure of damages does not extend to salaries for the unexpired period to retirement age. Remedies are generally confined to notice pay, payment in lieu of notice, and contractual terminal benefits.
v. Awards of arrears of salary and benefits may be made in exceptional cases where the termination is declared unlawful and a nullity, effectively treating the employee as if still in service.
vi. An employee has a duty to mitigate any loss that may arise from unlawful termination of employment.
112. I am bound by the foregoing decision and consequently, I find that the Claimant's prayer for damages equivalent to his salary for the remaining 22 years until his anticipated retirement cannot be sustained. The prayer is accordingly declined.
Damages for Constitutional violations
113. On this issue the Claimant has submitted at length that the Respondent violated his fundamental rights and freedoms under the Constitution during the process of terminating his employment. The Claimant cites in his submissions Article 41 on Fair Labour practices, Article 47 on Fair administrative action, Article 50 of Right to a Fair Hearing and seeks general and exemplary damages for unfair and unlawful dismissal. I agree with the Respondent that this was belatedly claimed in the Claimant’s submissions. A reading of the Claimant’s Statement of Claim shows that he did not plead the particulars of the alleged constitutional violations and therefore no award of damages is warranted. I am guided by the court in Mmatta vs Consolidated Bank Kenya Limited (Cause E840 of 2023) [2026] KEELRC 293 (KLR) (4th Februrary 2026) (judgement) quoting the case of Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] eKLR. held that: -
“We would, however, again stress that if a person is seeking redress from the High Court on a matter which involves a reference to the Constitution, it is important (if only to ensure that justice is done to his case) that he should set out with a reasonable degree of precision that of which he complains, the provisions said to be infringed, and the manner in which they are alleged to be infringed.”
114. Similarly, in Murithi v Insta Products (EPZ) Limited (Cause E004 of 2024) [2026] KEELRC 316 (KLR) (4 February 2026) (Judgment) the court held that;
“It is trite that any alleged or threatened violation of a constitutional right must be pleaded with a reasonable degree of precision. This principle was reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in Mumo Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others [2013] eKLR, which emphasized that precise pleadings allow the parties and the Court to identify the issues in dispute. It was further held that pleadings are fundamental to substantive justice, as they provide fair notice to the opposing party. For the foregoing reasons, the claim for constitutional violations cannot be sustained.”
115. Consequently, this prayer is declined.
Compensation
116. The Court having found that the Claimant was unfairly terminated proceeds to assess the appropriate remedies under Section 49 of the Employment Act. The Claimant prayed for 12 months. The takes into account that save for the procedural lapse in the process of terminating the claimant’s service, the reasons for termination were quite plausible hence the court considers an award of two months’ salary as reasonable in the circumstances.
One month’s salary in lieu of notice
117. On the prayer for one-month salary in lieu of notice, since the Claimant was never issued with a notice of termination of his service, he is entitled to the same.
118. The Claimant is further entitled to certificate of service by virtue of section 51 of the Act.
119. On the claim for costs, the court notes that the Respondent paid terminal dues of Kshs. 511,931.90 immediately upon termination of employment. Under section 45(5) of the Act, this being taken into account, each party should pay its costs.
120. In conclusion, the Court hereby enters judgment in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows;
(a) A declaration that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair for failure to carry out the same in accordance with a fair procedure as provided under section 45 of the Employment Act.
(b) The Claimant is awarded Kshs 286, 438/- equivalent to two months’ of his last gross salary as compensation for unfair termination.
(c) One month salary in lieu of notice. 143,219/-
(d) the total award amounts to Kshs. 429,657/-.
(e) The award shall be subject to taxes and statutory deductions but shall attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until full payment.
121. It is so ordered
Dated at Mombasa this 30th day of October2026
Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa