REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC PETITION NO. E196 OF 2021
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
JOHN OUMA MIDEGA………………………………………………………………PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
KENYA ENERGY GENERATING COMPANY LIMITED…………………….RESPONDENT
Coram
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
RULING
1. The applicant was N. Nyaswenta &Associates, Advocates seeking leave of the court to come on record post judgment. The law firm filed an application by way of Notice of Motion dated 10th July 2026 brought under Order 9 and Rule 9 (a) & (b) of the Civil Procedure Rules for ORDERS -
a. THAT Leave be granted to the firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates, Advocates to come on record for the Decree Holder herein, John Ouma Midega, in place of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates.
b. The costs of this application be provided for.
2. The Grounds of the application were as follows-
a) The decree Holder herein was Represented by N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates.
b) The decree Holder has discovered misinformation by Mohamed & Odhiambo Co. Advocates, who have declined to grant consent despite Notice of change, and has now decided that his case be handled by the Advocate who filed the Petition and handled the case to Judgment.
c) That the firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo has been duly Advised to cease acting and giving out any instructions on the matter.
d) That the Certificate of costs and the Bill of costs was filed by the firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates who carried out research on the case.
e) That Decree Holder has the Liberty of Choosing the Advocates who will represent him.
f) That this Application be heard on a priority basis and allowed.
g) The costs of this application be provided for.
3. The application was supported by the supporting affidavit of the Decree Holder, John Ouma Midega.
4. Midega averred that he had Appointed the firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates in place of Mohamed & Odhiambo Advocates. That the said firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates was his first Advocates in this matter and they handled the case well and obtained a judgment in his favour. That it was the said firm of Advocates who drafted and filed the Bill of costs the subject of the certificate of costs. That he had freely and willingly chosen the said firm of Advocates based on their long relationship to take over the conduct of the matter henceforth in place of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates.
5. Midega further contended that a certificate of costs was given in his favor. That there has been a breakdown of information and misinformation by the firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates, hence his personal decision to change to his First Advocates. That he wished to exercise his right to change Advocates as prayed and pray that this Application be allowed. That it was in interest of Justice that Orders herein be granted.
Response
6. The law firm on record opposed the change of advocates and filed replying affidavit sworn by JAMES ODHIAMBO advocate practicing under the name and style of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates which is the firm presently on record for John Ouma Midega, the Petitioner herein.
7. He contended that the present application is not an ordinary application for change of advocates. It has been brought at a very peculiar and telling stage of these proceedings, namely after the substantive work relating to the recovery of the Petitioner's costs has substantially been undertaken by their firm and when payment of the taxed costs is imminent.
8. He stated that the history of the matter is material in order to demonstrate the circumstances under which the present application has been brought. That following the award of costs in favour of John Ouma Midega in the main suit, the said John Ouma Midega initially instructed N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates to file and prosecute a Bill of Costs against the Respondent, Kenya Electricity Generating Company (KenGen). Thereafter, John Ouma Midega withdrew his instructions from N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates and appointed D. K. Githinji & Company Advocates to take over the matter and prosecute the Bill of Costs. D. K. Githinji & Company Advocates proceeded with the taxation proceedings, which culminated in the Bill of Costs being taxed at Kshs. 246,438/= [annexed and marked 'JO-1' is a copy of the ruling].
9. That John Ouma Midega was dissatisfied with the above taxation and again withdrew instructions from D. K. Githinji & Company Advocates. It was at that stage that John Ouma Midega instructed their firm, Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates, to challenge the ruling and/or certificate arising from the taxation which had awarded him Kshs. 246,438/=. That before withdrawing instructions from D. K. Githinji & Company Advocates and instructing our firm, Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates, the client fully settled legal fees due to D. K. Githinji & Company Advocates who subsequently consented to them coming on record [annexed and marked 'JO-2' is a copy of the consent].
10. That upon receiving the instructions, Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates took up the matter and undertook the necessary legal work to challenge the taxation. 12. THAT our efforts were successful and, vide a ruling delivered on 26th June 2025, the Court set aside the earlier taxation and ordered that the Bill of Costs be subjected to a fresh taxation [annexed and marked ‘JO-3' is a copy of the ruling].
11. That following the fresh taxation, the Taxing Officer, vide a ruling delivered on 25th September 2025, taxed the costs at Kshs. 3,838,605/= [annexed and marked 'JO-4' is a copy of the certificate of costs]. Thereafter, KenGen filed a Reference challenging the said taxation, and Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates Law firm continued to act for John Ouma Midega in defending his entitlement to the taxed cost. Vide a ruling delivered on 22nd April 2026, KenGen's Reference was dismissed, thereby upholding the taxation and leaving the sum of Kshs. 3,838,605/= due and payable to John Ouma Midega [annexed and marked 'JO-5' is a copy of the ruling].
12. The Advocate contended that even after the dismissal of the Reference, KenGen filed an application seeking stay of execution, to which our firm has responded and continues to represent John Ouma Midega. KenGen is seeking a stay pending filing of an appeal, whose time has lapsed, and therefore no competent appeal can be filed now. That they have argued as much in the Grounds of Opposition filed in response to the application for stay.
13. That having rendered a verdict on the Reference filed by KenGen and upheld the certificate of taxation, the court is now functus officio and is done with the substantive issues. The matter has therefore reached a stage where payment of the taxed costs is due, and it is at this precise point, after Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates firm has undertaken the substantial and successful legal work that resulted in the setting aside of the initial taxation of Kshs. 246,438/= and the subsequent taxation of Kshs. 3,838,605/=. Now John Ouma Midega has purported to instruct N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates to take over the matter. The timing and circumstances surrounding the proposed change raise a serious and legitimate concern that the intention is to remove Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates firm from the record immediately before receipt of the fruits of denied the legal work undertaken by it , thereby exposing it to the risk of being paid the agreed professional fees
14. That if the client wanted the firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates to represent him in the taxation process, he should have done so before the reference was determined and/or at the Court of Appeal if any competent appeal is filed, and not just when payment is about to be made. The scheme is clearly to deny them their rightly earned fees.
15. The Advocate contended that it was expressly agreed between the firm and John Ouma Midega that their professional fees for the work undertaken in relation to the work done in the subsequent proceedings would amount to Kshs.1,151,581/=. The amount included costs they incurred in terms of filing fees and related court fees which they catered for from their pockets as the client indicated that he was not able to pay. The amount stated was not agreed upon in writing but was settled on between them and the client after the Reference was dismissed and they were now awaiting payment. The said fees were to be recovered and/or settled from the monies payable by KenGen following the successful conclusion of the taxation proceedings. The firm accepted and acted upon the instructions on the basis of the said agreement and proceeded to undertake extensive legal work which directly resulted in the enhancement of the costs from Kshs. 246,438/= to Kshs. 3,838,605/=.
16. The Advocate urged that it would be manifestly unjust and inequitable to permit the client to remove their firm from the record at the point when the payment is about to arise to be received without first making provision for the professional fees from the services already rendered.
17. That to the best of his knowledge and experience, this is the first time and advocate is coming on record to receive payment and not to prosecute any issue. The intended change of advocates is particularly prejudicial because there are no substantive proceedings presently pending before this Court requiring a new advocate to undertake the legal work for which their firm was instructed, save for dealing with the pending application for stay of execution and matters incidental to the realization of the taxed costs. That if KenGen elects to file an appeal or any other substantive proceedings requiring representation in a different forum, the client remains at liberty, to appoint an advocate of his choice to represent him in such proceedings. However, the appointment of a new advocate merely to take over at the stage of receiving the payment arising from work substantially undertaken by the outgoing advocate should not be allowed to operate as a mechanism through which an advocate is deprived of fees rightfully earned.
18. That under Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules, where there is a change of advocate after judgment has been passed, or where a party decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, such change can only be effected upon an order of the Court upon an application with notice to all parties, or upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person.
19. That the requirement for the consent of the outgoing advocate or an order of the Court is not cosmetic, procedural surplusage or an empty technicality. The purpose of Order 9 Rule 9 is, among other things, to ensure that an advocate who has represented a litigant through proceedings up to and after judgment is not casually or strategically removed from the record in a manner calculated to defeat, prejudice or defeat the recovery of his or her fees. In considering an application under Order 9 Rule 9, the Court is required to exercise its discretion judicially and with due regard to the circumstances of the case, including the protection of an advocate's legitimate professional interest and entitlement to fees already earned.
20. That the present application should therefore not be treated as a routine request for substitution of advocates without examining the real consequences of the proposed change. The burning and central issue is that the client is attempting to disengage their firm after the work has been completed and immediately before the substantial payment arising from that work is made, without making any arrangement whatsoever for payment or security of their agreed fees of Kshs. 1,151,581/=.
21. That worse is that the client is retiring at the end of this year and he knows that recovering fees from him will not be an easy task. That unless this Honourable Court intervenes, the client may receive the entire amount payable by KenGen through the proposed incoming advocates and thereafter frustrate or delay payment of the fees lawfully due to their firm. It is evident by the client's conduct including his refusal to pick our calls or give a proposal on how he intends to settle our fees [annexed and marked 'JO-6' are correspondences confirming this position].
22. That the prejudice to their firm is immediate and substantial, whereas John Ouma Midega will suffer no prejudice if reasonable security is ordered for the agreed fees pending the resolution of any dispute regarding the same. That in the circumstances, the application dated 10th July 2026 ought to be dismissed, or alternatively allowed only upon conditions that adequately protect the firm's entitlement to its fees. Without prejudice to the foregoing, if this Honourable Court is inclined to permit N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates to come on record, the Advocate sought for the Court do so only on condition that John Ouma Midega deposits the sum of Kshs. 1,151,581/= in Court or in a joint interest- earning account in the names of the advocates for the parties and/or such other advocates or stakeholders as the Court may direct, pending the determination and settlement of our firm's fees. That alternatively, and if the Court considers a deposit in Court or a joint interest-earning account unnecessary, N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates should be permitted to come on record on the express condition that, upon payment of the taxed costs by KenGen, the sum of Kshs. 1,151,581/= shall be withheld and preserved by the said firm pending the determination and/or settlement of the professional fees payable to Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates. That such an order would fairly balance that rights of the parties. That it is in the interests of justice, fairness and the proper administration of justice that a client should not be allowed to benefit from the full fruits of an advocate's labour while taking deliberate steps to place those fruits beyond the reach of the advocate before the issue of fees is resolved.
23. The Decree Holder responded to the law firm vide undated supplement affidavit as follows-That the said firm of N. Nyaswenta & Associates Advocates were his first Advocates in this matter and they handled the case well and obtained a Judgement in his favor and further prepared a Bill of Costs that was merely copied and adopted by D. K. Githinji & Co. Advocates. That it's the said firm of Advocates who drafted the Bill of costs the subject of the certificate of costs and gave him a copy that he took to D. K. Githinji Advocate. That the Conduct of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates is wanting and they are crying over a matter that does not belong to them. That there is no Agreement between him and Mohamed & Odhiambo Advocates to pay them 1,151,581/= at all, a clear demonstration of An Advocate who wants to reap from sweat by other Advocates and sprinkle lies to the court. That Instructions fees, Research and entirely the whole case was handled by N. Nyaswenta & Associates since filing In 2O21 and its them who are entitled should any payments be made which has not been done at all. He averred that he did not wish to be represented by t1,151,581/= by the firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company and had made a choice of Advocates who will represent him and who have the Knowledge of this matter from the onset. That the firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates should cease representing him in this matter as per his instructions and they cannot force themselves upon him at all. That he exercised his right to Change Advocates as prayed and pray that this Application be allowed as they do not want to leave the case on baseless grounds That he had made payments to them in terms of Legal fees, that they are not disclosing to the court and dictating distribution of Costs which have not been paid yet, the subject of an Appeal. That its in the interest of Justice that Orders herein be granted and his new Advocates proceed with the matter in his interest. That his interests were not being well taken care of by Mohamed & Odhiambo Advocates, hence the change.
Decision
24. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions and pleadings.
25. Issue for determination
Whether to grant leave to change of advocates
Whether the leave is to be conditional
26. The applicable law
Order 9 Rule 9 (a) & (bl of the Civil Procedure Act Cap 27 Laws of Kenya
‘9. Change to be effected by order of court or consent of parties [Order 9, rule 9]
When there is a change of advocate, or when a party decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, after judgment has been passed, such change or intention to act in person shall not be effected without an order of the court—(a)upon an application with notice to all the parties; or(b)upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person as the case may be.10. Procedure [Order 9, rule 10]
An application under rule 9 may be combined with other prayers provided the question of change of advocate or party intending to act in person shall be determined first.’
Decision
27. It is not in dispute that the applicant law firm initiated the case. Shortly thereafter the Decree Holder appointed the law firm of DK Githinji Advocates to represent him vide application dated 5th May 2024. On 12th November 2024, the petitioner filed notice to act in person. The petitioner further filed notice of appointment of advocates of Odhiambo Owino & Company Advocates vide notice of change of advocates dated 9th December 2024. Vide a notice of change dated 25th February 2026, the petitioner filed notice of change of advocates and appointed the instant law firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates. The instant application is now filed to change advocates to the initial law firm of N. Nyaswenta.
28. It is not in dispute that the certificate of taxation of Kshs. 3,838,605 dated 25th September 2026 was subject of a ruling dated 20th April 2026 when the instant law firm was in place. The reference was declined, meaning the certificate of costs held by the Decree Holder secured by Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates is valid.
29. The law firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates has raised many issues, and importantly for the court to appreciate the intention of Order 9, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules being to be to protect the interests of outgoing counsel. They relied on Ngitimbe Hudson Nyanumba v Thomas Ongondo [2018] KEELC 2886 (KLR), where the court stated-
'The idea/objective behind amending the Civil Procedure Rules to provide that where judgment had been entered any change of advocate was to be with the leave of the court was essentially for the protection of the advocates to safeguard their fees from their clients. The amendment was aimed at preventing mischief whereafter an advocate worked tirelessly for a client upto obtaining a judgment, the advocate is not debriefed by merely another advocate filing a notice of change or the client filing a notice to act in person so that execution of the decree is by another advocate who did not participate in the trial and/or by the client directly with the object of denying the advocate his fees or costs.'
30. I upheld the above decision and find that it is not a mere procedural step that the leave of the court is sought. At the same time, the court cannot impose the rejected counsel on the petitioner, who has the right to be represented by counsel of choice. The law firm is entitled to costs under the Advocate's client bill of costs, which can be taxed. The agreed legal fee is disputed by the petitioner, and there is no proof of the agreement. The outgoing law firm has a valid reason to raise concerns on security of their advocate-client fees.
31. The court finds that the only basis of the objection is fear of non-settlement by the client of advocate and client costs for the outgoing advocates. The court agreed with the proposal of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates to issue a conditional leave of change of advocates in favour of the new law firm which it hereby does as follows-
The law firm of N. Nyaswenta and Associates is granted leave to come on record post judgment on condition that within 14 days it gives a written undertaking to the law firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates to withhold the sum of Kshs. 1,151,581 for the benefit of the law firm of Mohamed & Odhiambo Company Advocates, out of the proceeds it may receive from the judgment debtor for the petitioner, pending the taxation of the advocate's client's bill of costs, or as may be agreed in writing between the outgoing advocate and the former client. All proceedings in the file to await the issuance of the professional undertaking. In default, the leave lapses. If no agreement on fees, the court noting the decree holder disputed the oral agreement on fees, the law firm ought to tax its advocate's client bill of costs for settlement under the professional undertaking.
32. Mention on 16th November, 2026 to confirm status on the legal representation of the judgment holder. Interim order of stay in place extended to that date.
33. I make no order as to costs in the application.
34. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Applicant: Musungu
Respondent - Njuguna