REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E425 OF 2025
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
KOMAL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED APPELLANT
VERSUS
JUSTUS MULWA RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the Judgment of Hon. R. L. Musiega, SRM, delivered on 13th December, 2024 at the Milimani Commercial Courts, Nairobi in CMCC No. 5832 of 2017: Justus Mulwa v Komal Construction Limited.)
JUDGMENT
This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 14th January, 2025. It arises out of a judgment delivered in the Chief Magistrate’s Court, Milimani in CMCC No. 5832 of 2017.
The grounds of appeal are;
1. When the parties agreed to produce as an exhibit the medical report by Dr Joab Bodo dated 21/2/2018, and the Honourable Court did not have sight of the report, the Court failed in its duty to serve wholesome justice when it proceeded to deliver judgment before directing the defendant to avail a copy of the medical report.
2. The Honourable Court erred in holding that the respondent suffered 2 fractured ribs when there were no primary medical documents for example treatment notes or x-ray films supporting that issue.
3. The Honourable Court erred in awarding an excessively high sum of general damages for pain and suffering that was disproportionate to the injuries and greatly at variance with awards made in comparable matters.
The orders sought in the Memorandum of Appeal are;
1. THAT this appeal be allowed in its entirety.
2. THAT the award by the trial Court of damages for pain and suffering be set aside and this Honourable Court be pleased to revise the award of the damages downwards.
3. THAT the appellant do have costs of this appeal and costs of the suit below.
The Respondent, then plaintiff, sued the Appellant, then defendant, by a plaint dated 10th August, 2017 for general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenities, special damages of Kshs. 3,000.00 and costs and interest.
The Respondent’s case and pleading is that he was employed by the Appellant as a mason, and that on or about 20th January, 2017 a scaffold on which he was working on the Appellant’s instructions collapsed and he fell. He blamed the Appellant for negligence and breach of duty. He pleaded fractured ribs (2) on the left side and blunt injuries to the chest.
The Appellant filed a defence dated 4th October, 2017. It did not admit that the Respondent was its employee and denied that the accident happened as alleged. In the alternative it blamed the Respondent’s own negligence. It put him to strict proof of his injuries and of special damages.
No witness testified at the trial. On 23rd October, 2024 the advocates recorded a consent which the trial court adopted. Liability was entered at 75% against the Appellant and 25% against the Respondent. The Respondent’s documents were produced as exhibits 1 to 6 without calling their makers. The defendant’s medical report was admitted. The parties were to file written submissions.
The proceedings record the ratio as 75:20%. That is an evident slip. The parties, the trial court and the decree all use 75:25. What remained was quantum.
The Respondent asked for Kshs. 800,000.00 relying on the medical report of Dr. G. K. Mwaura, and cited Esther Dorca Bochere v Zacharia Okemwa Manono & another and AM v Muhamud Kahiye. The Appellant relied on the medical report of Dr. Joab Bodo dated 21st February, 2018 which found a contusion or abrasion over the right chest wall and no rib fracture. It proposed Kshs. 100,000.00 for soft tissue injuries.
The trial court found that the Respondent had proved the injuries he complained of relying on Dr. Mwaura’s report and the Kenyatta National Hospital treatment documents. It said Dr. Bodo’s report was purportedly produced by consent, was never filed and that it was ‘unable to confirm the contents therein. It said it would attach significant weight to the initial treatment notes.
The trial court found the Respondent’s authorities more comparable. It awarded Kshs. 800,000.00 as general damages ‘subject to apportionment of liability’, Kshs. 3,000.00 as special damages with interest from the date of filing suit, and costs and interest. The decree records liability at 75%: 25% and repeats those awards.
The Appellant’s case is that the trial court adopted the consent admitting Dr. Bodo’s report and so erred in calling it purportedly produced by consent. It concedes that it did not file the report. It calls this pure human error’ and says its counsel wrongly believed the report was in the court file, as its submissions at page 30 of the Record of Appeal show. It relies on section 3 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and on the authority of Moses Karanja Kahochio & another v Joel Mburu Kanyuku & another [2020] KECA 865 (KLR), that courts exist to do justice and not merely to enforce discipline. It asks this Court to consider the report.
On the second ground the Appellant seeks to rely on the authority of Timsales Ltd v Wilson Libuywa [2008] eKLR for the proposition that a doctor’s report not supported by an initial treatment card does not prove the injury. It says no primary document shows a rib fracture. Of the four documents Dr. Mwaura used, the attendance card was never filed and the triage chart carries no final diagnosis.
It says only the first page of the radiological form was filed, and the radiographer’s report page is missing. It adds that an accident report the Respondent signed on 23rd January, 2017- page 23 says he was grazed at his right rib, while Dr. Mwaura reports fractures on the left. It asks that damages be assessed for soft tissue injury only.
On the third ground it says the trial court relied on authorities with far graver injuries. In the authority of Esther Dorca Bochere Onyancha v Zacharia Okemwa Manono & another [2008] KEHC 2013 (KLR) the plaintiff had burn-like wounds over most of the body, a deep ankle wound, scalp and facial wounds and multiple rib fractures, with two weeks in intensive care and about two months in a ward. The Respondent here went home the same day. They proposes Kshs. 100,000.00 citing Ogola v Ogangira & another [2026] KEHC 336 (KLR) and Shiabulo v Shikwati [2026] KEHC 1428 (KLR). Alternatively, if two rib fractures are found, it proposes Kshs. 400,000, citing Oduol v Gitaru [2024] KEHC 690 (KLR), Brinks Security Services Limited & another v Karuga [2024] KEHC 13492 (KLR) and Nyakundi & another v Isayi [2026] KEHC 1749 (KLR). It prays for costs.
The Respondent’s case is that this court should interfere only where the trial court acted on wrong principles, the award was extremely low or high, or the facts were disregarded, citing Gitobu Imanyara & 2 others v Attorney General [2016] eKLR. It is his case and submissions that none is shown and the appeal should be dismissed with costs.
The Respondent avers and states that his injuries were pleaded at page 4 of the Record of Appeal and confirmed by Dr. Mwaura, who examined him on 10th July, 2017, page 14. He says the initial Kenyatta National Hospital documents at pages 11 to 13, including the X-ray form, confirm fractured ribs. He says the Appellant cannot rely on one report prepared long after the incident. He urges that where reports conflict the initial treatment notes prevail, citing Matinda (Fruits) Bus Services Ltd v Agnes Chemngeno Tuiya [2021] eKLR. He also cites Mosoti & another v Ouko [2025] KEHC 17055 (KLR) and Easy Coach Limited v Joyce Moraa Asiago [2021] KEHC 3648 (KLR), where Kshs. 600,000.00 is said to have been awarded for almost comparable injuries.
The Respondent’s submissions also contain a section on future medical expenses, internal fixation, implant removal at Kshs. 200,000.00 and a page 85 of the Record of Appeal. No such claim was pleaded or awarded, the Record of Appeal ends at page 42, and the submissions are headed Appeal No. E435 of 2025. That section does not relate to this appeal and I disregard it.
This being a first appeal the court must reconsider and evaluate the evidence and draw its own conclusions, bearing in mind that it has not seen or heard the witnesses (Selle and Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123). Here no witness testified and the evidence was documentary, so this Court is as well placed as the trial court to weigh it.
General damages lie in the trial court’s discretion. This court will interfere where a wrong principle was applied, an irrelevant factor was considered or a relevant one omitted, or the award is so inordinately high or low as to be a wholly erroneous estimate (Mbogo and Another v Shah [1968] EA 93).
The issues for determination therefore are;
1. Whether the trial court erred in proceeding to judgment without Dr. Bodo’s report, and whether the report may be considered in this appeal.
2. Whether the Respondent proved that he sustained two fractured ribs, and what injuries he proved.
3. Whether the award of Kshs. 800,000 as general damages was inordinately high and what award should be substituted.
4. What orders should issue, including on costs.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in proceeding to judgment without Dr. Bodo’s report and whether the report may be considered in this appeal. The consent of 23rd October, 2024 was adopted by the trial court. It admitted the defendant’s medical report in evidence without calling its maker. The Respondent’s advocate agreed. The trial court was therefore wrong to call the report purportedly produced by consent. It had been admitted by the court’s order.
That error did not cause the report to be missing. The Appellant concedes that it never filed it. A party relying on a document admitted by consent must put it before the court. Its submissions of 4th November, 2024 treated the report as if it were on the file. At the mention on 27th November, 2024 its counsel asked only for a judgment date. In those circumstances the trial court did not fail in any duty by proceeding on the material before it. It could not weigh a document it had not seen and it said so. It was not bound to supply the Appellant’s evidence after both sides had closed with submissions. To that extent the first ground fails.
The matter does not end at that. This is because this appeal is a rehearing of the same. The report is at pages 24 and 25 of the Record of Appeal. It was admitted by consent. The Respondent does not dispute its authenticity, does not object to its being considered, and deals with it in his own submissions. He suffers no prejudice. This court therefore consider the report in this appeal as evidence admitted by consent in the trial court and I give it the weight it deserves. This is not fresh evidence. I find it unnecessary to decide the Appellant’s reliance on section 3 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the Respondent proved that he sustained two fractured ribs and what injuries he proved. The burden lay on the Respondent. Under sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act, he who asserts a fact must prove it. He pleaded two fractured ribs on the left side and the Appellant put him to strict proof. No witness testified, so his proof rests on documents alone.
The only document recording a rib fracture is Dr. Mwaura’s report of 10th July, 2017 at pages 14 and 15. It was written almost six months after the accident. It lists four documents used. It says ‘X-rays were done’ but not what they showed. The local examination is recorded as ‘Healed / pain’. No clinical finding of a fracture is recorded. The attendance card is not in the Record of Appeal and this court has not had the privilege of seeing it. The triage chart (page 11) records a chief complaint which, as I make it out, reads ‘STI 2° fall from height? Ribs #’, followed by a letter for the side that is not legible to any degree of confidence. A query at triage would be and is a suspicion, not a diagnosis.
The X-ray request form at page 12 records a fall from about seven feet with injuries to the chest and requests a chest radiograph. It is a request. The radiographer’s section is blank and the report page was not filed. The prescription at page 13 lists one medicine and states no diagnosis. None of the initial documents records a rib fracture. The Respondent says these pages ‘confirmed’ fractured ribs. They do not. He also urges that the initial treatment notes prevail where reports conflict, citing Matinda (Fruits) Bus Services Ltd v Agnes Chemngeno Tuiya [2021] eKLR. I accept the proposition. It is the principle the trial court said it applied. Applied here it works against him. Dr. Bodo saw the Respondent on 21st February, 2018 - pages 24 and 25. He recorded a contusion or abrasion over the right chest wall and a chest X-ray that did not reveal any rib fracture. The Respondent was given analgesics and allowed home. He had a superficial scar and had recovered with no permanent incapacity. He (Dr. Bodo) does not say where he got the X-ray result. It is nonetheless the only evidence of that result and it fits the initial documents. There is also an unexplained difference in side. The plaint and Dr. Mwaura place the fractures on the left. Dr. Bodo places the injury on the right.
The Appellant also relies on the accident report of 23rd January, 2017 (page 23). It was not among the documents admitted by consent and its makers were not called. I place no reliance on it. My conclusion stands without it. The authority of Timsales Ltd v Wilson Libuywa [2008] eKLR concerned whether the accident happened at all. Here the accident is common ground. Its reasoning still applies to the nature of an injury. A report written long after the event must be anchored in the contemporaneous hospital record. Dr. Mwaura’s fracture entry is not.
The trial court said it attached significant weight to the initial notes but did not say what they recorded. They record no fracture. It nevertheless accepted Dr. Mwaura’s report as proof of the pleaded injuries. That was a misapprehension of the evidence. It also had no sight of the only evidence of the X-ray result.
On the whole evidence, the Respondent proved that he fell from a height at work on 20th January, 2017 and sustained a blunt chest injury. He was treated and discharged the same day with analgesics. He still had chest pain on exertion in July 2017 and by February 2018 he had recovered with a superficial scar and no permanent incapacity. He did not prove two fractured ribs. The second ground succeeds.
The 3rd issue for determination is whether the award of Kshs. 800,000 as general damages was inordinately high and what award should be substituted. The award was premised on rib fractures, which were not proved. It was therefore made for an injury the Respondent did not prove. That alone justifies interference.
The comparators were also wrong. Comparable injuries attract comparable awards. The trial court preferred the Respondent’s authorities as ‘more comparable’. They were not. The plaintiff in Esther Dorca Bochere Onyancha v Zacharia Okemwa Manono & another [2008] KEHC 2013 (KLR) had burn-like wounds from head to toe, a deep ankle wound with loss of skin and deeper tissue, scalp and facial wounds and multiple rib fractures. She spent two weeks in intensive care and about two months in a ward.
The other provided authority, AM v Muhamud Kahiye, is described in Brinks Security Services Limited & another v Karuga [2024] KEHC 13492 (KLR). The injuries included multiple fractured ribs, extensive friction burns over the chest, abdomen and both legs and a lacerated liver. The Respondent’s was a blunt chest injury with same-day discharge. Treating those cases as comparable was an error of principle.
Even if two fractured ribs had been proved, Kshs. 800,000.00 could not stand. In Brinks, supra, delivered on 31st October, 2024 the High Court set aside Kshs. 800,000.00 and substituted Kshs. 450,000.00. The plaintiff there had two fractured ribs, a blunt head injury, lacerations to the scalp, forehead, cheek and eye, and bruises. His injuries were wider than the Respondent’s would have been on his case. The Respondent’s authorities, as he describes them, attracted Kshs. 600,000 for injuries he calls almost comparable. That is below the figure he defends. I have not been given those decisions and do not rely on them.
Let us now move on to an assessment damages for the injury proved. It was a blunt chest injury with a contusion or abrasion, a superficial scar, a fall of about seven feet, same-day discharge, exertional chest pain at six months and full recovery by thirteen months. The Appellant asks for Kshs. 100,000.00. Its own authorities do not support so low a figure.
In Ogola v Ogangira & another [2026] KEHC 336 (KLR) the High Court substituted Kshs. 150,000.00 for soft tissue injuries to the head, anterior chest wall and lower back, with one day in hospital. The Respondent’s injury is confined to one region but he had a scar and exertional pain for months. In this case Kshs. 150,000.00 is fair compensation for the injuries sustained. I substitute it for Kshs. 800,000.00. The third ground succeeds.
The 4th issue for determination is on the appropriate orders and costs.
The first ground fails as a ground of error, although Dr. Bodo’s report has been considered. The second and third grounds succeed. The appeal therefore succeeds in part.
The special damages of Kshs. 3,000.00 were not challenged. The Appellant’s second prayer is confined to damages for pain and suffering. This award is left undisturbed.
The consent on liability at 75% against the Appellant and 25% against the Respondent stands. The trial court awarded damages ‘subject to apportionment of liability’ and the decree states the ratio without computing the net sum. It applies to both awards. Seventy-five percent of Kshs. 150,000.00 is Kshs. 112,500.00. Seventy-five percent of Kshs. 3,000.00 is Kshs. 2,250.00 The total is Kshs. 114,750.00.
The substituted general damages shall carry interest at court rates from 13th December, 2024, the date of the trial court’s judgment. Interest on special damages from the date of filing suit stands.
Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act allows the court to make such orders as to costs as it considers just. The Appellant succeeded substantially on quantum. The first ground, however, arose from its own omission to file a report it had agreed to produce. Each party shall bear its own costs of the appeal. The Respondent remains the successful party in the suit and the trial court’s costs order stands.
In the result, I am therefore inclined to allow the appeal and order as follows:
i) The award of Kshs. 800,000.00 as general damages be and is hereby set aside and substituted with an award of Kshs. 150,000.00.
ii) The award of Kshs. 3,000.00 as special damages stands and is not disturbed.
iii) The consent on liability at 75% against the Appellant and 25% against the Respondent applies to both awards. The Respondent is accordingly entitled to;
General damages (75% of Kshs. 150,000) …..Kshs. 112,500.00
Special damages (75% of Kshs. 3,000) Kshs. 2,250.00
Total of award Kshs. 114,750.00
iv) The general damages shall carry interest at court rates from 13th December, 2024 until payment in full.
v) Interest on the special damages shall run at court rates from the date of filing suit, as ordered by the trial court.
vi) The order for costs of the suit in the trial court is not disturbed and the trial court shall issue an amended decree in the terms of these orders.
vii) Each party shall bear their costs of this appeal.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Kamau instructed by Evan Mbugua Advocate for the Appellant.
2. Mr. Kiptanui holding brief for Wachira instructed by Waiganjo Wachira & Co. Advocates for the Respondent.