Employment law

Kilonzo & 21 others v Teachers Service Commission (TSC) [2026] KEELRC 14959 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Constitutional Petition E172 of 2025
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Petition allowed in part. The Court declared ASAL and hard-to-staff teachers a marginalised group entitled to affirmative action; declared prolonged acting beyond six months, disguised as deployment pending promotion after three years, an unfair labour practice; ordered acting allowances effective from each petitioner’s appointment to the higher position under the 2018 Career Progression Guidelines, with budgetary measures; declined additional compensation for the violations; and awarded costs to the petitioners.

Supporting judgment passages

44. The court finds that declarations and orders on the acting allowance are sufficient to vindicate the petitioners' rights. The court declines to award compensation for the violations. The petition is allowed, with judgment entered in favour of the petitioners against the respondent as follows-

Paragraph 44 →

1. A Declaration is issued that all the teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff regions constitute a marginalized group within the meaning of Article 56 and are entitled to affirmative action measures.

Passage 154 →

4. The petitioners are awarded costs of the petition.

Passage 157 →
Issue 1Whether teachers serving in ASAL and hardship regions constitute a marginalized group entitled to constitutional protection and affirmative action.

Held. Decided for the petitioners. The Court held that teachers serving in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas can be categorised as marginalised and issued a declaration that they are a marginalised group within Article 56 and entitled to affirmative-action measures. It nevertheless found that their terms of service, hardship allowance and promotion-related affirmative action were already addressed in CBAs, and grievances concerning those terms should be pursued through their unions.

Ratio. ASAL and hard-to-staff teachers were not disputed to be marginalised. The Court treated the existing CBAs, negotiated by the representative unions and containing hardship and progressive-promotion provisions, as the governing framework for service-condition grievances.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

i. Whether teachers serving in ASAL and hardship regions constitute a marginalized group entitled to constitutional protection and affirmative action.

Passage 104 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

33. It is not denied from pleadings before the court that workers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas can be categorised as marginalised. My take on this issue is that it is already addressed in the CBAs. The employees of the respondent are under unions which have negotiated terms of service, including those of teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas and hardship allowance is in the CBA. It is not alleged it is not being paid. Any grievance on the terms of service should be raised by the union which represents these teachers in the negotiations of the CBA. e.g. clause 9 of the CBA on promotions provides for affirmative action for such teachers.

Paragraph 33 →

1. A Declaration is issued that all the teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff regions constitute a marginalized group within the meaning of Article 56 and are entitled to affirmative action measures.

Passage 154 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

31. It is the finding of the court that the issue of marginalisation of teachers working in ASAL and hard to staff areas had already been agreed in the existing collective bargaining agreements between the respondent and the 3 unions. The respondent produced 3 CBAs between it and KUPPET (The Kenya Union of Post-Primary Education Teachers), KNUT (The Kenya National Union of Teachers) and KUSNET (The Kenya Union of Special Needs Education Teachers) (annexure ‘LA-1’). The employees of the respondent are represented by unions that have negotiated terms of service, including those of teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas. Any grievance on the terms of service should be raised by the union which represents these teachers in the negotiations of the CBA. For example, clause 9 of the CBA on promotions provides for affirmative action for such teachers. I say so because the CBAs specifically address service in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas (listed in clause 9.5 of the KUPPET CBA and 9.4 of the KNUT CBA). Clauses 9.4 (KUPPET) and 9.3 (KNUT CBA with similar clauses reflected in the other 2 CBAs ) provide -

Paragraph 31 →

33. It is not denied from pleadings before the court that workers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas can be categorised as marginalised. My take on this issue is that it is already addressed in the CBAs. The employees of the respondent are under unions which have negotiated terms of service, including those of teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas and hardship allowance is in the CBA. It is not alleged it is not being paid. Any grievance on the terms of service should be raised by the union which represents these teachers in the negotiations of the CBA. e.g. clause 9 of the CBA on promotions provides for affirmative action for such teachers.

Paragraph 33 →
Issue 2Whether the Respondent's prolonged acting appointments are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional under Articles 41, 47, 232 and 237 of the Constitution.

Held. Decided for the petitioners in part. The Court declared that retaining petitioners in higher positions beyond six months under the guise of deployment, without additional compensation and while awaiting promotion after three years, was ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional as an unfair labour practice. It ordered the Respondent to remedy that practice by paying acting allowance, including to the petitioners from their respective dates of appointment to the higher positions under the 2018 Guidelines. The Court rejected automatic confirmation to substantive positions because promotion falls within the Respondent’s constitutional mandate.

Ratio. Deployment to perform higher-position duties without commensurate compensation is, in substance, acting; it amounts to unequal pay for equal work and an unjustified limitation of the right to fair labour practices. However, a court cannot direct automatic substantive confirmation because the Teachers Service Commission holds the constitutional function of promoting teachers.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

ii. Whether the Respondent's prolonged acting appointments are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional under Articles 41, 47, 232 and 237 of the Constitution.

Passage 105 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

34. The employer, in the reply in affidavit of Antonina Lentoijoni, denied that these officers were acting in the position and stated they had been deployed because they lacked qualifications to act in the position. I find this is a case of a rose by any other name smells like a rose. The court's attention was drawn to paragraphs 27(g, h, I and I) of the respondent’s affidavit, which admit that the petitioners were performing duties of a higher position without extra remuneration. The respondent justified the practice under paragraph 28 of its affidavit. I find this to be an unfair labour practice and amounting to underpayment where the petitioners are paid less than for work done. It is an unacceptable practice in a democratic and open society, and the limitation of the fair labour right for equal wages for work done is not justified. I did not find acting allowance in the CBAs. I declare Respondent's prolonged acting appointments in the guise of deployment to higher positions without extra compensation are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional.

Paragraph 34 →

3. A Declaration do issue that petitioners who have been subjected to acting appointments under guise of deployment for consideration of promotion after 3 years are entitled to appropriate compensation of acting allowances. The respondent is ordered to put in measures, including budgetary allocation, to pay the petitioners acting in higher positions under the guise of deployment, acting allowance effective from the dates of appointment to act in the higher positions under the Career Progression Guidelines. 2018.

Passage 156 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

35. The Court holds that the practice of deployment of teachers to work in higher positions without commensurate compensation, in human resources termed as acting allowance, is an unfair labour practice. The practice cannot be justified under Article 24 of the Constitution. The Respondent's conduct constitutes Unequal Pay for Equal Work, which is an unfair labour practice.

Paragraph 35 →

36. The Respondent is ordered to take immediate steps to remedy the unfair labour practice and, where it deploys a teacher to a higher position, pay compensation by way of an acting allowance.

Paragraph 36 →
Issue 3Whether the Respondent's promotion framework and Career Progression Guidelines result in direct and indirect discrimination contrary to Article 27.

Held. Decided against the petitioners. The Court found no evidence of the alleged direct discrimination and held that clause 9 of the CBA applies affirmative action to promotions of teachers in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas.

Ratio. A claim of discriminatory promotion required supporting evidence; the applicable CBA itself contained affirmative-action promotion provisions for the affected teachers.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

iii. Whether the Respondent's promotion framework and Career Progression Guidelines result in direct and indirect discrimination contrary to Article 27.

Passage 106 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

39. I find that under clause 9(CBA), affirmative action applies to the promotion of teachers in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas. There is no evidence before me of the alleged direct discrimination.

Paragraph 39 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

39. I find that under clause 9(CBA), affirmative action applies to the promotion of teachers in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas. There is no evidence before me of the alleged direct discrimination.

Paragraph 39 →
Issue 4Whether the Respondent has failed to implement meaningful affirmative action contrary to Articles 27(6), 27(7) and 56 of the Constitution.

Held. Decided against the petitioners. The Court found no evidence that the Respondent had failed to comply with the CBA, and noted that the unions representing the teachers had not raised a complaint through the Labour Relations Act mechanisms.

Ratio. In the absence of evidence of non-compliance with the negotiated CBA framework, and absent a union complaint through the applicable labour-relations mechanisms, the alleged failure to implement affirmative action was not established.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

iv. Whether the Respondent has failed to implement meaningful affirmative action contrary to Articles 27(6), 27(7) and 56 of the Constitution.

Passage 107 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

40. There is no evidence before the court of non-compliance with the CBA. The unions who represent the teachers have not complained under the mechanisms in the Labour Relations Act.

Paragraph 40 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

40. There is no evidence before the court of non-compliance with the CBA. The unions who represent the teachers have not complained under the mechanisms in the Labour Relations Act.

Paragraph 40 →
Issue 5Whether the conditions under which teachers serve in ASAL regions deny them equal opportunities for professional development and career growth.

Held. Decided against the petitioners. The Court found no basis for this finding. It held that the teachers’ contracts permitted service anywhere in Kenya and that the CBAs addressed their conditions of service, including hardship allowance; any service-condition grievance should be raised through the union for renegotiation or resolution under the labour-relations framework.

Ratio. The contractual mobility terms and CBA provisions governing ASAL service conditions meant that the asserted denial of equal professional-development and career-growth opportunities was not established on the evidence presented.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

v. Whether the conditions under which teachers serve in ASAL regions deny them equal opportunities for professional development and career growth.

Passage 108 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

41. I find no basis for such a finding. The teachers have contracts agreeing to serve in any part of the country. The CBA has addressed their conditions of service, including payment of a hardship allowance to the petitioners, and any grievance ought to be brought to the attention of the union for renegotiation of the CBA or resolution under the legal framework for the operation of the union provided under the LRA.

Paragraph 41 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

41. I find no basis for such a finding. The teachers have contracts agreeing to serve in any part of the country. The CBA has addressed their conditions of service, including payment of a hardship allowance to the petitioners, and any grievance ought to be brought to the attention of the union for renegotiation of the CBA or resolution under the legal framework for the operation of the union provided under the LRA.

Paragraph 41 →
Issue 6Whether the Petitioners' legitimate expectation has been violated

Held. Decided in substance for the petitioners only to the extent that the Court held their placement in higher positions was acting disguised as deployment to deny acting allowance, and therefore an unfair labour practice. The Court did not separately identify or apply the doctrinal elements of legitimate expectation.

Ratio. The necessary basis for relief was not a separately articulated legitimate-expectation rule, but the finding that higher duties performed without corresponding acting allowance constituted an unfair labour practice.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

vi. Whether the Petitioners' legitimate expectation has been violated

Passage 109 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

42. I held the placing of the petitioners in higher positions was acting disguised as deployment to deny the petitioners compensation in terms of acting allowance. That is unfair labour practice.

Paragraph 42 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

35. The Court holds that the practice of deployment of teachers to work in higher positions without commensurate compensation, in human resources termed as acting allowance, is an unfair labour practice. The practice cannot be justified under Article 24 of the Constitution. The Respondent's conduct constitutes Unequal Pay for Equal Work, which is an unfair labour practice.

Paragraph 35 →
Issue 7Whether this Honourable Court should invoke its supervisory jurisdiction and grant structural reliefs.

Held. Decided against granting structural relief. The Court found structural interdicts far-fetched after issuing declarations of violation, particularly because the teachers were represented by unions holding CBAs with the Respondent.

Ratio. The existence of representative unions and CBAs, together with the declarations already granted, made structural interdicts inappropriate.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

vii. Whether this Honourable Court should invoke its supervisory jurisdiction and grant structural reliefs.

Passage 110 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

43. The teachers are under various unions that hold CBAs with the respondent. I find it far-fetched to grant any structural interdicts after a declaration of the violations.

Paragraph 43 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

43. The teachers are under various unions that hold CBAs with the respondent. I find it far-fetched to grant any structural interdicts after a declaration of the violations.

Paragraph 43 →
Issue 8Remedies available

Held. The Court held that declarations and orders concerning acting allowance sufficiently vindicated the petitioners’ rights and declined separate compensation for the violations. It issued declarations of marginalisation and of unfair labour practice for prolonged disguised acting appointments; ordered measures and budgetary allocation to pay acting allowance from the dates of higher-position appointment under the 2018 Guidelines; and awarded the petitioners costs.

Ratio. Once declarations and prospective/payment orders on acting allowance adequately vindicated the rights, additional compensation for the violations was not warranted.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

viii. Remedies available

Passage 111 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

44. The court finds that declarations and orders on the acting allowance are sufficient to vindicate the petitioners' rights. The court declines to award compensation for the violations. The petition is allowed, with judgment entered in favour of the petitioners against the respondent as follows-

Paragraph 44 →

3. A Declaration do issue that petitioners who have been subjected to acting appointments under guise of deployment for consideration of promotion after 3 years are entitled to appropriate compensation of acting allowances. The respondent is ordered to put in measures, including budgetary allocation, to pay the petitioners acting in higher positions under the guise of deployment, acting allowance effective from the dates of appointment to act in the higher positions under the Career Progression Guidelines. 2018.

Passage 156 →

4. The petitioners are awarded costs of the petition.

Passage 157 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

44. The court finds that declarations and orders on the acting allowance are sufficient to vindicate the petitioners' rights. The court declines to award compensation for the violations. The petition is allowed, with judgment entered in favour of the petitioners against the respondent as follows-

Paragraph 44 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Petitioners are all teachers employed by the Respondent. They are alleged to be serving in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas. They allege unfair labour practices by the employer. They commenced this suit against the respondents vide a Petition filed on 2nd September 2025, seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

On the issue of failure to promote some teachers who have acted for more than 6 months and ought to be automatically promoted, the Respondent while admitting that it is clothed with the mandate to promote teachers under Article 237 (2) (d) of the Constitution, avers that it is nonetheless bound by Articles 10, 47 and 232 to apply the principle of fair competition and merit as the basis of appointment and promotion. Further, per…

Paragraph 21 →

Decision / orders

The court finds that declarations and orders on the acting allowance are sufficient to vindicate the petitioners' rights. The court declines to award compensation for the violations. The petition is allowed, with judgment entered in favour of the petitioners against the respondent as follows-

Paragraph 44 →

Reasoning passage

The employer, in the reply in affidavit of Antonina Lentoijoni, denied that these officers were acting in the position and stated they had been deployed because they lacked qualifications to act in the position. I find this is a case of a rose by any other name smells like a rose. The court's attention was drawn to paragraphs 27(g, h, I and I) of the respondent’s affidavit, which admit that the petitioners were performing duties of a…

Paragraph 34 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether ASAL and hard-to-staff teachers are a marginalised group entitled to affirmative action; whether deployments to higher duties without compensation were unlawful acting appointments; whether the promotion framework discriminated; whether affirmative…

Material facts

The petitioners, teachers employed by TSC and said to serve in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas, alleged that they performed principal or deputy-principal duties for prolonged periods—sometimes years—under “deployment” rather than acting appointments, without…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E172 OF 2025

IN THE JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE ARTICLES 3(1), 10, 12, 19, 21, 22(1) & (2)(c), 27(4),41(1), (3) 47, 53, 56(c), 159(1) AND 237 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

-AND-

IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION AND VIOLATION OF ARTICLES 1(1), 2(1-4), 3(1), 10, 21, 27(4), 41(1), (2) 47, 53, 56(c) AND 237 OF THE CONSTITUTION

-AND-

IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED VIOLATION OF SECTION 37(3) OF THE TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION ACT OF 2012, SECTION 34 OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION ACT, 2017 AND SECTION 5(7) OF THE EMPLOYMENT ACT, 2007 AND CODE OF CONDUCT AND ETHICS

FOR TEACHERS – REGULATION 151(2) AND 156(2)

-AND-

IN THE MATTER OF DETERMINING THE CONSTITUTIONAL AND LEGAL VALIDITY OF THE TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION REFUSAL TO PROMOTE TEACHERS IN ASAL AREAS WHO HAVE BEEN ACTING BEYOND THE STATUTORY LIMIT AND FAILURE TO IMPLEMENT

STRUCTURED AFFIRMATIVE ACTION POLICY WITHOUT JUSTIFICATION

-AND-

IN THE MATTER OF THE DOCTRINES OF LEGITIMATE EXPECTATION AND AFFIRMTIVE ACTION

-BETWEEN-

PATRICIA MBATHE KILONZO………………………………..……………………………………..….1ST PETITIONER

WILSON OKENYE OMWEBU…………………………………..………………...………………….….2ND PETITIONER

DOMINIC PYEKO DOYWAN…………………………………………………………………………….3RD PETITIONER

MOHAMED ADAN MOHAUD..…………………………………………………………….………….4TH PETITIONER

HALIMA G. ALI……………………..……………………………………………………………….………….5TH PETITIONER

JAMAL LUBA BORE…………………………………..…………..………………………………………….6TH PETITIONER

ANTONY BARASA MABONGA………………………………..……………………………………….7TH PETITIONER

KORIO ADOW BEDEL………………………….………………..………………………………………….8TH PETITIONER

KITWAI MWANGANGI………………..………………………..………………………………………….9TH PETITIONER

WILLY K KAPCHEPKOW………………………………………..………………………………………...10TH PETITIONER

ABDI MOHAMED AHMED……………………………………..……………………………………....11TH PETITIONER

SUSAN MUNYAMASYE MBULU..……………………………..……………………………………..12TH PETITIONER

MINGAINE GIBSON MUTWIRI…………………...…………..……………………………………...13TH PETITIONER

MICHAEL O.B ONYANGO………………..……………………..………………………………………14TH PETITIONER

SALIM WATICHO IJEMA………………………………………..………………………………………15TH PETITIONER

JOSEPHAT KAROKI WAINAINA………………….…………..……………………………………....16TH PETITIONER

MOHAMED KANYARE ABASS………………………………..….……………………………….…..17TH PETITIONER

FRANCIS NDAMBUKI KISYANG’A………………………………….……………………………….18TH PETITIONER

JACOB KILUKI……………………………………….……………..……………………………………….…19TH PETITIONER

JOSEPH M. KIDALI………………………………………………..……..………………………………….20TH PETITIONER

STEPHEN LTACHAWA OGOM………………………….……..……..……………………………….21ST PETITIONER

SAMUEL KIMANZI MBWAU………………….………………..……………………………….……..22ND PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION (TSC)…………………...……..…………………………...1ST RESPONDENT

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. The Petitioners are all teachers employed by the Respondent. They are alleged to be serving in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas. They allege unfair labour practices by the employer. They commenced this suit against the respondents vide a Petition filed on 2nd September 2025, seeking the following orders:-

a) A Declaration do issue that all the teachers serving in arid, semi-arid, and hardship regions constitute a marginalized group within the meaning of Article 56 and are entitled to affirmative action measures.

b) An Order directing the Teachers Service Commission to design and implement affirmative action programmes in recruitment, promotion, deployment, and professional development for teachers serving in arid, semi-arid, and hardship regions.

c) A Declaration do issue that promotional criteria or recruitment processes that disadvantage teachers serving in arid, semi-arid, and hardship regions without reasonable cause are unconstitutional and discriminatory under Article 27.

d) An Order do issue compelling the Teachers Service Commission to take into account the unique challenges of hardship postings in all staffing, transfer, and promotion decisions, as a form of affirmative action under Article 56.

e) A Declaration do issue that prolonged retention of teachers in acting appointments for a period exceeding Six (6) months is unconstitutional, unlawful, and contrary to Article 41, Article 47, Article 232, and Article 237 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

f) A declaration do issue that the actions and/or omissions of the Teachers Service Commission in failing to substantively fill positions within the statutory period prescribed under the Code of Regulations for Teachers (2015) amounts to a violation of the affected teachers’ rights to fair labour practices and fair administrative action.

g) An Order do issue compelling the Teachers Service Commission to forthwith regularize all acting appointments that have exceeded Six (6) months by confirming them to substantive appointments in compliance with the Constitution, the Teachers Service Commission Act, and the Code of Regulations for Teachers.

h) A Declaration do issue that teachers who have been subjected to acting appointments beyond the lawful period are entitled to appropriate compensation, including but not limited to acting allowances, loss of benefits, and any other remuneration accruing to the substantive position.

i) Costs of the petition

2. The Petition was filed with the Supporting Affidavit of the 1st Petitioner, sworn on 2nd September 2025, and the annexures thereto.

3. In response to the Petition, the Respondent filed a Replying Affidavit, sworn by ANTONINA LENTOIJONI on 8th April 2026, with annexures thereto.

4. To counter the Respondents’ responses, the Petitioners filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 10th May 2026.

The Petitioner’s case in summary

5. The Petitioners’ case is that the Respondent routinely appoints teachers and Institutional Administrators in acting capacities where substantive positions are vacant or the office holder is absent, but such appointment should not exceed six (6) months. If a teacher acts for a period exceeding six months the Respondent is obligated to fill the position substantively.

6. The Petitioners complain that, contrary to this well-established policy, the Respondent has habitually retained teachers and Institutional Administrators in acting appointments for indefinite and prolonged periods, in some cases exceeding five (5) years, without making substantive appointments. The affected teachers, who mainly perform administrative duties, remain in acting appointments for many years without substantive appointments, thereby subjecting them to professional stagnation, denial of rightful remuneration and benefits, and unfair labour practices in violation of Article 41 of the Constitution.

7. Another layer to the Petitioner’s complaint is that teachers serving in arid, semi-arid, and other hardship regions face systemic challenges, including but not limited to: severe teacher shortages; insecurity and isolation; harsh climatic conditions and poor infrastructure; and inadequate opportunities for promotion and career development. Teachers in these areas face structural marginalisation, being disadvantaged compared with their colleagues in more developed and accessible regions, as evidenced by the Respondent’s report dated 20th May 2025 to the Departmental Committee on Education. The Report states that a majority of the teachers in Asal regions serve in grades C2, C3, C4 and C5, rather than the required D grades for Principals and Deputy Principals. Head teachers and Deputy Head teachers in those regions are similarly under-graded, with some serving in C1, C2 or C3 instead of the requisite grades. The retention of these teachers, who act as Institutional Administrators in lower job groups, means that they are not guaranteed promotions and confirmation.

8. It is further averred that teachers in Asal areas who are deployed as Institutional Administrators do not receive acting allowances or special duty allowances despite carrying out full administrative duties. As a result, this mismatch has compromised succession management, school leadership and teacher motivation in these marginalised regions. There is also a deprivation of equal educational opportunities, undermining the teachers’ rights under Articles 43(1)(f) and 53(1)(b) of the Constitution.

9. To illustrate the prejudices they suffer, the Petitioners state that the Respondent published advertisements in December 2024 for teaching positions, with requirements that were fair, particularly for teachers in ASAL areas. However, after intense debate, the Respondent succumbed to pressure and revised the requirements for recruitment and promotion, setting out requirements that disadvantaged teachers in ASAL areas and forced them to remain in positions of uncertainty for unknown periods. The Petitioner takes the position that the Respondent, as an Independent Constitutional Commission with a full mandate to address teachers’ issues, should have asserted its authority and retained the original requirements, in an effort to entrench requirements that will place teachers in ASAL areas on a level playing field with teachers from other regions.

10. Other examples advanced by the Petitioners are that the Respondent selectively and discriminatorily implemented affirmative action by promoting some Principals in ASAL areas under affirmative action while leaving other Principals and Deputy Principals serving in the same hardship regions stagnant in lower grades, despite similar appointment criteria, responsibilities and hardship conditions. Further, before the introduction of the Career Progression Guidelines, deployment into administrative roles operated under the Scheme of Service framework, and the Job Group M threshold was not rigidly applied. The Respondent retrospectively introduced restrictive promotion thresholds under the Career Progression Guidelines, thereby trapping ASAL Deputy Principals and others in acting capacity in lower grades despite the continued performance of substantive administrative duties. The Petitioners rely on various Parliamentary Petitions filed by teachers serving in ASAL regions, including Tana River, Turkana, Garissa, Wajir, Marsabit, Mandera, Isiolo, Kitui, West Pokot, Baringo and Lamu, complaining about prolonged deployment into administrative roles, in some instances exceeding a decade, without substantive appointment, formal recognition or commensurate remuneration. According to the Petitioners, this demonstrates that this is a nationwide and systemic problem affecting hundreds of teachers across the country.

11. They point out that the deployment letters produced by the Petitioners identify specific teachers who have acted as administrators in 2012, 2016, 2017, 2019 and 2021 without substantive appointment. The Petitioners state that the Respondent has failed to rebut the specific periods of prolonged acting appointments pleaded in the Petition, and that such silence amounts to an admission that teachers have indeed remained in acting administrative capacities for unreasonable and excessive periods. They also admit that the Petitioners are performing substantive administrative duties, that the Respondent knowingly benefits from their labour, and that the Respondent deliberately delays substantive regularization while continuing to rely on the Petitioners operationally. The Petitioners supervise institutions, manage staff, administer discipline, oversee examinations, manage institutional operations, and perform the functions of Principals and Deputy Principals. Therefore, withholding substantive appointment and commensurate remuneration for years becomes irrational, discriminatory and exploitative.

12. The Respondent’s reliance on hardship allowance, mentorship programmes and teacher support initiatives is irrelevant and misleading because hardship allowance is paid to all teachers in designated hardship areas, is not compensation for higher administrative duties and cannot substitute substantive appointment or cure unequal remuneration, prolonged acting appointments and labour exploitation.

13. It is the Petitioners’ case that the Respondent’s conduct of retaining teachers in indefinite acting positions is a violation of their right to fair labour practices under Article 41; to fair administrative action under Article 47; a breach of the values of transparency, accountability, and meritocracy under Article 232; and an abdication of constitutional duties under Article 237. Additionally, the Respondent’s failure to adopt affirmative action measures for teachers serving in hardship areas contravenes Article 27(6) & (7) and Article 56 of the Constitution, which require the State to take proactive steps to redress historical and systemic disadvantages. According to the Petitioners, under Articles 27(6), (7) and 56, the following should be considered in formulating an affirmative action programme; attraction of teachers to ASALs through creating entry incentives, bonded scholarships, spousal/family posting priority and subject scarcity premiums; capability support by setting up specialized training; tele-mentoring & cluster learning and itinerant specialist teams: County-level rotating teams for STEM, SNE, and psychosocial support; retention improvement through provision of teacher housing kits, dynamic hardship allowance, leave & transfer guarantees and wellbeing support; creation of and fair advancement of programmes such as ASAL Performance Points (APPs), Acting-to-Substantive Track, Local Leadership Pipeline, Language & Culture Incentives; promotion of accountability & community Support through a transparent hardship index, deployment stability, community teaching assistants and attendance & transition grants.

Respondent’s case in brief

14. The Respondent challenges the jurisdiction of the Court to entertain the present suit on the premise that the Petitioner has failed to exhaust all the internal dispute resolution mechanisms and administrative remedies available to it contrary to Section 46 of the Teachers Service Commission Act and Regulation 156 of the Code of Regulations for Teachers, and is therefore in breach of the doctrine of exhaustion. Further, they aver that the Petition does not meet the threshold of constitutional pleadings test, as espoused in the cases of Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] eKLR and Mumo Matemu vs. Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance, Civil Appeal No. 290 of 2012, and categorize the present dispute as a contractual dispute which offends the principle of Constitutional Avoidance.

15. It is averred that the Respondent’s mandate under Article 237 of the Constitution is to register trained teachers; recruit and employ trained teachers; assign teachers in its service to teach in various public schools; promote and transfer teachers; exercise disciplinary control over teachers; and to terminate their employment. In exercise of its mandate, the Commission has published a Code of Regulations for Teachers in line with Section 47 (2) of the Teachers Service Commission Act. The Respondent further relies on Section 11 of the Act which requires it to facilitate career progression and professional development for teachers by, including, the appointment of institutional administrators and to formulate policies.

16. The Respondent explains that Part IV of the CORT provides for the criteria and procedure of promotion of teachers from one grade to another subject to availability of vacancies and budgetary allocations. They state that they have also formulated the Career Progression Guidelines 2018, to guide the career growth of teachers in the Commission’s employ, including the recruitment, retention, development, training and promotion of teachers to ensure they meet the set standards. The Respondent highlights Regulation 67 of the Code which grants the Commission the discretion to transfer teachers in its service as the circumstances may demand even where a teacher has not applied for a transfer; Clause 6 of the employees’ Letters of Appointment which proclaims that the Petitioners’ employment is subject to the provisions of the Code of Regulation for Teachers; and Clause 5 of the employees’ Letters of Appointment which provides that a condition for employment is readiness to serve anywhere in Kenya in any school in which the TSC considers the Petitioners are qualified to teach.

17. While acknowledging that teachers serving in hard-to-staff-areas operate under unique and challenging circumstances including harsh climatic conditions and historical marginalization, the Respondent contends that it has deliberately implemented affirmative action interventions to mitigate the challenges that they face, with a view to promoting equity, retention and access to fair career progression for teachers in ASAL areas. It admits that a significant number of Institutional Administrators serving in ASAL areas are yet to attain the requisite grades, qualification and experience for substantive appointment to administrative grades, but attributes this to historic staffing challenges in these areas. The Respondent states that it negotiated with its social partners to accord these teachers a special exemption to be allowed to serve in administrative grades even when they have not met the requisite qualifications for substantive appointment, instead of excluding them from administrative positions. It resolved to progressively promote teachers in ASAL areas every three years, while retaining them at their current stations until they obtain the requisite grades for substantive appointments. The Respondent emphasizes that this arrangement was part of their affirmative action interventions.

18. The Respondent insists that their actions are intentional, structured, deliberate, negotiated and policy-driven, and not discriminatory or arbitrary. They are grounded in Clause 9.3 of the 2021-2025 Collective Bargaining Agreement which provides that ''The Commission shall progressively promote teachers serving in ASAL hard-to-staff areas holding administrative positions until they attain grades commensurate with their respective positions." Per the same CBA, ASAL and hard-to-staff areas where teachers are eligible for affirmative action are: -

i. Baringo North, Tiaty East, Tiaty West, and Marigat sub-counties in Baringo County

ii. Garissa County

iii. Suba and Mbita Sub-counties in Homa Bay

iv. Isiolo County

v. Mashuuru, Loitoktok and Kaiiado West Sub-Counties in Kajiado County

vi. Magarini and Ganze Sub-Counties in Kilifi Counties

vii. Mumoni, Mutito North and Tseikuru Sub-Counties in Kitui Counties

viii. Kwale Countv

ix. Lamu County

x. Mandera County

xi. Marsabit County

xii. Narok North and Narok South Sub-Counties in Narok County

xiii. Samburu County

xiv. Taita Taveta County

xv. Tana River County

xvi. Turkana County

xvii. Wajir County

xviii. West Pokot County

19. Other affirmative action measures that the Respondent highlights are that vacancies for administrative positions in ASAL and hard to staff areas are preserved exclusively for local teachers so as to grant them opportunities to attain administrative grades, and enhance retention and community integration; are subjected to targeted recruitment strategies including re-employment on contract up to age sixty-five (65) years for willing retired teachers in counties such as Mandera, Wajir, Garissa and Lamu, and reduction of the minimum stay before eligibility for transfer, particularly in North Eastern counties, from five (5) years to three (3) years; are paid Hardship Allowance over and above other teachers posted in Non-ASAL areas. The teachers are also offered professional support and development, including, School based Teacher Support System (SBTSS) implemented in 130 sub-counties which provides pedagogical content knowledge and mastery of content in Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, English, and Science for Primary School through localized support, peer learning, and mentorship; Competency-Based Education (CBE) retooling of teachers; Remote Learning Methodologies such as livestreaming of lessons in Primary and Secondary schools; encouraging teachers to use platforms such as Microsoft Teams, Forms, PowerPoint, and LabXchange, and the development of structured SE lesson plans (Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, Evaluate) which foster interactive learning, enhance digital literacy among teachers, and prepares them for blended and technology-driven teaching models; Teacher Professional Development (TPD); and Integration of ICT in the teaching learning process, which teachers are trained in.

20. The Respondent states that in the 2024/2025 financial year, in promotion of the affirmative action principle, it waived the requirement for teachers to serve for a period of three years in one Job group for those serving in ASAL areas, ensuring that 5,291 teachers who had not served for at least three years in their grades were promoted. It contends that it has put in place administrative structures, policy directives, procedures and deliberate strategies and interventions to ensure that teachers especially those in ASAL and hard to staff areas are not only supported but also accorded fair opportunity to serve. They therefore deny the claims that the Petitioners are marginalized and discriminated against.

21. On the issue of failure to promote some teachers who have acted for more than 6 months and ought to be automatically promoted, the Respondent while admitting that it is clothed with the mandate to promote teachers under Article 237 (2) (d) of the Constitution, avers that it is nonetheless bound by Articles 10, 47 and 232 to apply the principle of fair competition and merit as the basis of appointment and promotion. Further, per Regulation 73 of the Code of Regulations for Teachers (CORD) and the Career Progression Guidelines (CPG), teachers are promoted subject to availability of budget/funds, existence of vacancies in the authorized establishment, merit and ability as reflected in the teacher's work performance, seniority and experience, annual performance records, and academic and professional qualification. As such, it is stated that all promotion vacancies are filled competitively, but the Respondent confirms that it has consistently invoked affirmative action principles in teacher promotions within the limits provided by law. The Commission denies the existence of any contractual agreement, policy or statutory provision which compels it to automatically promote teachers who have acted for six months.

22. It also denies that it has appointed any teacher in an acting capacity, clarifying that it has deployed them to perform duties. The Respondent takes the position that acting appointments are only applicable to a person who has met the qualifications and experience required to be substantively appointed to a higher post, which is not the case for the Petitioners and the majority of teachers in ASAL areas. It states that the temporary deployments of the Petitioners to perform administrative duties are occasioned by systemic and operational constraints, namely natural attrition, lack of funds and budgetary provisions appropriated by the National Assembly, and registration of new schools without corresponding budgetary provision for administrative grades. Despite the challenges, the Commission affirms that it has negotiated with the teacher Unions to effect accelerated promotion after every three years.

23. On infrastructure, equipment, learning facilities and mitigation of harsh climatic conditions, the Respondent contends that these matters fall under the mandate of the Ministry of Education and Boards of Management, not the Commission. It explains that its Constitutional mandate is limited to the management of teachers, including recruitment, deployment, promotion, and remuneration, within approved frameworks.

24. The Respondent discloses that it has commenced the review of the current Career Progression Guidelines so as to address the challenges affecting the teaching sub sector in General. It states that the Petitioners are represented on the Committee undertaking the review of the said Guidelines, and that any policy-related challenges will be addressed during the review.

25. The Respondent emphasizes that it has not discriminated against the teachers serving in the ASAL areas, instead it has: implemented structured affirmative action programmes anchored in law and negotiated CBAs; provided preferential access to administrative positions and promotions; applied flexible eligibility criteria to mitigate historical marginalization; ring-fenced opportunities to enhance retention and local participation; and progressively promoted teachers despite severe fiscal constraints. The challenges cited in the Petition arise from budgetary limitations, system expansion and inter-sectoral mandates, rather than deliberate exclusion or unequal treatment by the Commission.

26. The Respondent concludes that the prayers sought by the Petitioners are against public policy and interest in that the Petitioners are bound by the terms of their contracts of employment which the Court cannot re-write; and granting them the prayers will amount to usurpation of the Commission's constitutional, statutory and administrative mandate, and create a bad precedent in the public service.

DETERMINATION

27. Following directions by the court that parties should file written submissions, the Petitioner complied.

Issues for determination

28. On perusal of the issues raised by the parties, the pleadings and submissions, the opinion on the issues for determination was -

i. Whether teachers serving in ASAL and hardship regions constitute a marginalized group entitled to constitutional protection and affirmative action.

ii. Whether the Respondent's prolonged acting appointments are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional under Articles 41, 47, 232 and 237 of the Constitution.

iii. Whether the Respondent's promotion framework and Career Progression Guidelines result in direct and indirect discrimination contrary to Article 27.

iv. Whether the Respondent has failed to implement meaningful affirmative action contrary to Articles 27(6), 27(7) and 56 of the Constitution.

v. Whether the conditions under which teachers serve in ASAL regions deny them equal opportunities for professional development and career growth.

vi. Whether the Petitioners' legitimate expectation has been violated

vii. Whether this Honourable Court should invoke its supervisory jurisdiction and grant structural reliefs.

viii. Remedies available

The Law

29. Articles 27, 41, 47, 56, 232 and 237 of the Constitution.

Whether teachers serving in ASAL and hardship regions constitute a marginalized group entitled to constitutional protection and affirmative action.

30. Article 56 of the Constitution states-

‘56. Minorities and marginalised groups

The State shall put in place affirmative action programmes designed to ensure that minorities and marginalised groups—(a)participate and are represented in governance and other spheres of life;(b)are provided special opportunities in educational and economic fields;(c)are provided special opportunities for access to employment;(d)develop their cultural values, languages and practices; and(e)have reasonable access to water, health services and infrastructure.’

31. It is the finding of the court that the issue of marginalisation of teachers working in ASAL and hard to staff areas had already been agreed in the existing collective bargaining agreements between the respondent and the 3 unions. The respondent produced 3 CBAs between it and KUPPET (The Kenya Union of Post-Primary Education Teachers), KNUT (The Kenya National Union of Teachers) and KUSNET (The Kenya Union of Special Needs Education Teachers) (annexure ‘LA-1’). The employees of the respondent are represented by unions that have negotiated terms of service, including those of teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas. Any grievance on the terms of service should be raised by the union which represents these teachers in the negotiations of the CBA. For example, clause 9 of the CBA on promotions provides for affirmative action for such teachers. I say so because the CBAs specifically address service in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas (listed in clause 9.5 of the KUPPET CBA and 9.4 of the KNUT CBA). Clauses 9.4 (KUPPET) and 9.3 (KNUT CBA with similar clauses reflected in the other 2 CBAs ) provide -

‘Further, the employer shall endeavor to promote members serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas holding administrative positions progressively until they attain grades that are commensurate to their respective positions. Meanwhile, they shall be retained in their current stations/areas until attainment of the substantive grades.’

32. Further, the CBAs provide for hardship allowance in designated hardship areas under Appendix 6. The Constitution of Kenya, Article 260 interprets the words ‘ marginalised group; to mean-

‘a group of people who, because of laws or practices before, on, or after the effective date, were or are disadvantaged by discrimination on one or more of the grounds in Article 27(4);’

33. It is not denied from pleadings before the court that workers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas can be categorised as marginalised. My take on this issue is that it is already addressed in the CBAs. The employees of the respondent are under unions which have negotiated terms of service, including those of teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff areas and hardship allowance is in the CBA. It is not alleged it is not being paid. Any grievance on the terms of service should be raised by the union which represents these teachers in the negotiations of the CBA. e.g. clause 9 of the CBA on promotions provides for affirmative action for such teachers.

Whether the Respondent's prolonged acting appointments are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional-

34. The employer, in the reply in affidavit of Antonina Lentoijoni, denied that these officers were acting in the position and stated they had been deployed because they lacked qualifications to act in the position. I find this is a case of a rose by any other name smells like a rose. The court's attention was drawn to paragraphs 27(g, h, I and I) of the respondent’s affidavit, which admit that the petitioners were performing duties of a higher position without extra remuneration. The respondent justified the practice under paragraph 28 of its affidavit. I find this to be an unfair labour practice and amounting to underpayment where the petitioners are paid less than for work done. It is an unacceptable practice in a democratic and open society, and the limitation of the fair labour right for equal wages for work done is not justified. I did not find acting allowance in the CBAs. I declare Respondent's prolonged acting appointments in the guise of deployment to higher positions without extra compensation are ultra vires, unlawful and unconstitutional. I reject the invitation to declare that the teachers who acted in higher positions should be automatically confirmed. That would be in violation of the mandate of the respondent as stated in Article 237 –

‘237. Teachers Service Commission

1)There is established the Teachers Service Commission. (2)The functions of the Commission are—

(a)to register trained teachers;

(b)to recruit and employ registered teachers;

(c)to assign teachers employed by the Commission for service in any public school or institution

;(d)to promote and transfer teachers;

(e)to exercise disciplinary control over teachers; and

(f)to terminate the employment of teachers.

(3)The Commission shall—

(a)review the standards of education and training of persons entering the teaching service;

(b)review the demand for and the supply of teachers; and(c)advise the national government on matters relating to the teaching profession.’

35. The Court holds that the practice of deployment of teachers to work in higher positions without commensurate compensation, in human resources termed as acting allowance, is an unfair labour practice. The practice cannot be justified under Article 24 of the Constitution. The Respondent's conduct constitutes Unequal Pay for Equal Work, which is an unfair labour practice.

36. The Respondent is ordered to take immediate steps to remedy the unfair labour practice and, where it deploys a teacher to a higher position, pay compensation by way of an acting allowance.

Whether the Respondent has violated Articles 41, 47, 232 and 237 of the Constitution.

37. The court finds that the lack of compensation for the petitioners, who are alleged to have been deployed to higher positions without compensation, violates the right to fair labour practice under article 41 of the Constitution.

Whether the Respondent's conduct constitutes Unequal Pay for Equal Work.-

38. I return in the positive in view of my finding above.

Whether the Respondent's promotion framework and Career Progression Guidelines result in direct and indirect discrimination contrary to Article 27.

39. I find that under clause 9(CBA), affirmative action applies to the promotion of teachers in ASAL and hard-to-staff areas. There is no evidence before me of the alleged direct discrimination.

Whether the Respondent has failed to implement meaningful affirmative action contrary to Articles 27(6), 27(7) and 56 of the Constitution.

40. There is no evidence before the court of non-compliance with the CBA. The unions who represent the teachers have not complained under the mechanisms in the Labour Relations Act.

Whether the conditions under which teachers serve in ASAL regions deny them equal opportunities for professional development and career growth.

41. I find no basis for such a finding. The teachers have contracts agreeing to serve in any part of the country. The CBA has addressed their conditions of service, including payment of a hardship allowance to the petitioners, and any grievance ought to be brought to the attention of the union for renegotiation of the CBA or resolution under the legal framework for the operation of the union provided under the LRA.

Whether the Petitioners' legitimate expectation has been violated-

42. I held the placing of the petitioners in higher positions was acting disguised as deployment to deny the petitioners compensation in terms of acting allowance. That is unfair labour practice.

Whether this Honourable Court should invoke its supervisory jurisdiction and grant structural reliefs.

43. The teachers are under various unions that hold CBAs with the respondent. I find it far-fetched to grant any structural interdicts after a declaration of the violations.

Remedies /disposal

44. The court finds that declarations and orders on the acting allowance are sufficient to vindicate the petitioners' rights. The court declines to award compensation for the violations. The petition is allowed, with judgment entered in favour of the petitioners against the respondent as follows-

1. A Declaration is issued that all the teachers serving in ASAL and hard to staff regions constitute a marginalized group within the meaning of Article 56 and are entitled to affirmative action measures.

2. A Declaration is issued that prolonged retention of petitioners in acting appointments beyond 6 months under guise of deployment for consideration of promotion after 3 years amounts to unfair labour practice under Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

3. A Declaration do issue that petitioners who have been subjected to acting appointments under guise of deployment for consideration of promotion after 3 years are entitled to appropriate compensation of acting allowances. The respondent is ordered to put in measures, including budgetary allocation, to pay the petitioners acting in higher positions under the guise of deployment, acting allowance effective from the dates of appointment to act in the higher positions under the Career Progression Guidelines. 2018.

4. The petitioners are awarded costs of the petition.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Petitioners: Maboga

Respondent: Gekombe

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder