Background
The Petitioner, a medical doctor and former employee of the Respondent, whose services were terminated by redundancy, aggrieved with the separation process, commenced this suit by a Petition dated 7th February 2022 seeking:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Petitioner, a medical doctor and former employee of the Respondent, whose services were terminated by redundancy, aggrieved with the separation process, commenced this suit by a Petition dated 7th February 2022 seeking:-
Paragraph 1 →In his submissions dated 14th July 2026, the Petitioner identified the following issues for determination:-
Paragraph 28 →The petitioner contended the redundancy was not justified but relied on a draft structure. On the issue of whether or not the redundancy was justified, I find it is a business prerogative of the employer to declare redundancy. In the letter of 13th April 2021, the employer explained that the redundancy was due to a new business structure. In Kenya Airways Limited vs. Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 Others [2014] eKLR, the…
Paragraph 39 →The court considered whether Andrew Kekovole’s redundancy was unfair; whether he was entitled to ESOP benefits; whether his rights to equal pay, non-discrimination on ethnicity, and fair labour practices were violated; and whether he was entitled to the…
The Petitioner, a medical doctor employed from 27 September 2004, rose to Chief Operating Officer in January 2019 on a gross monthly salary of Kshs.720,000. In April 2021, Avenue Group restructured, splitting the COO role into General Manager Avenue Hospitals…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E022 OF 2022
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
IN THE MATTER OF VIOLATIONS OF ARTICLES 2, 3, 10, 20,21,27,35, 41, 43 &
47 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF BREACH OF SECTIONS 2 & 4 OF THE FAIR
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF BREACH OF SECTIONS 5(3), 10, 15, 26(2), 35, 40, 43, 45, &
49 OF THE EMPLOYMENT ACT, 2007
AND
IN THE MATTER OF UNLAWFUL & UNFAIR TERMINATION, UNFAIR LABOUR PRACTICES & UNFAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION
BETWEEN
ANDREW KEKOVOLE…………………………………………………………………...PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
AVENUE GROUP……………...………..……….……………………..……………..RESPONDENT
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The Petitioner, a medical doctor and former employee of the Respondent, whose services were terminated by redundancy, aggrieved with the separation process, commenced this suit by a Petition dated 7th February 2022 seeking:-
a) THAT a Declaration be issued that Redundancy termination letter dated 13th April issued by the Respondent to the Petitioner is unlawful on account of violation of Article27, 28, 41, and 47of the Constitution and Section 5(3) of the Employment Act.
b) THAT a Declaration be issued that the redundancy notice issued to the Petitioners on 13th April 2021 was unprocedural and unlawful contrary to Section 40(1)(b)(e)(g) of the Employment Act.
c) THAT a Declaration be issued that the Respondent infringed and violated the Petitioner's inalienable Constitutional rights not to be discriminated against on the basis of ethnicity, to equal treatment, to protection of his human dignity and equal protection of the law.
d) THAT a Declaration be issued that the unlawful acts of the Respondent in the unprocedural and unjustified termination of the Petitioners employment amount to Unfair Labour Practices and Unfair Administrative Action contrary to section 2 & 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
e) THAT a declaration be issued that the refusal by the Respondent to give equal pay for equal work and the ESOP was a form of modem slavery having deceitfully benefitted from the Petitioners labour and loyalty.
f) THAT the Respondent do pay the Petitioner:
i. Unfair and Wrongful termination (720,000 x 12) Ksh. 8,640,000/-
ii. Unpaid gratuity pay for 16 years (720,000 x 16) Ksh. 11,520,000/-
iii. Transfer of 1.25% ESOP Shares share of the 5 % of the total value of the Company into the Petitioners name as at 2021 USD 348,051/-
iv. Unpaid Club Membership (210,000 x 4) Ksh. 810,000/-
v. Unremitted deduction on Provident Fund Ksh. 1,480,469/-
vi. Unpaid Overtime days (72/30x 20,000) Ksh. 1,728,000/-
vii. Unpaid Acting Allowance Ksh. 2,290,000/-
viii. Unpaid Management Bonus 2017-2020 Ksh. 3,041,832/-
ix. Compensation for Wage Discrimination Ksh. 11,640,000/-
x. Compensation for unequal Medical Benefit Ksh.24,000,000/-
xi. Compensation for pay increase discrimination Ksh.1,820,550/-
xiii. Damages for 12 Months restrictive Covenant Ksh. 8,640,000/-
TOTAL AMOUNT Ksh. 128,572,426
g) General damages
h) Cost of Suit
i) Interest for (e) from the date of filing the petition until payment in full.
2. The Petition was filed alongside the Supporting Affidavit of the Petitioner sworn on 7th February 2022; list of documents dated 17th October 2022 with the bundle of documents attached; Witness Statement of Faith Waweru dated 10th October 2022; a Further Affidavit sworn on 24th February 2023; and list and bundle of documents dated 3rd October 2024.
3. In response to the said Petition, the Respondent filed a Replying Affidavit sworn by JAY MICHOMA on 1st December 2022; Witness Statement of JAY MICHOMA dated 20th February 2023; List of Documents dated 23rd February 2023 with the bundle attached; a second List and Copy of Documents dated 3rd October 2024; and a trial bundle of documents dated 8th May 2026.
4. To counter the Respondent’s averments, the Petitioner filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 16th May 2026.
Hearing and evidence
5. The petitioner's case was heard before Justice NDUMA NDERI (As he then was ) on 23rd March 2023 and on 29th June 2023, when the petitioner testified on oath and stated he relied on his supplementary affidavit as his evidence. The witness also produced his documents as exhibits. The petitioner was cross-examined by counsel for the respondent on the 24th February 2025 and re-examined.
6. The respondent’s case was part heard before Justice Nduma Nderi on the 15th October 2025, where one Jay Michoma is recorded to have testified as Human Resources Director (HRD). She produced the documents filed by the respondent under a list dated 23rd February 2023.
7. I took over the proceedings on the 10th June 2026 following the appointment of Justice Nduma Nderi the Court of Appeal. RW1 was cross-examined by counsel for the petitioner, Ms Morara h/b Madahana and re-examined on the same date.
The Petitioner’s case in summary
8. The Petitioner is a medical doctor who worked at Shalom Hospital and Avenue Group Hospitals in the positions of Outpatient Manager, Regional Branch Manager, General Manager and Chief Operating Officer. He was employed as a Medical Officer on permanent and pensionable terms by the Respondent by a Letter of Appointment dated 27th September 2004, at a monthly salary of Kshs. 95,0000/- with attendant benefits. The Petitioner states that he worked diligently and was awarded a merit increment of his salary on 5th December 2016 to Ksh. 461,725/-. He was later promoted to Regional Branch Manager from 15th March 2017, earning a monthly salary of Ksh.540,000/- with benefits, a position that elevated the Petitioner to the Respondent's Senior Management Team.
9. It is averred that the Respondent, in a bid to motivate its Senior Employees and grow its Revenue, granted members of the Senior Management Team (SMT) an Employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) through its Remuneration Committee giving the Petitioner an ownership interest in the Respondent, amounting to 1.25% of 5% of the Respondent's total shareholders' Equity reserved for the SMT ESOP scheme.
10. The Petitioner states that on or about 30th July 2018, having obtained Operations experience after serving the Respondent in the positions of Branch Manager, Acting Inpatient Manager of Kisumu Hospital and Regional Manager, he was appointed as the Acting Chief Operating Officer of the Respondent. He was given an additional acting allowance of Kshs. 100,000/- vide a letter dated 26th September 2018. On 15th January 2019, the Petitioner was promoted to the Respondent’s Chief Operating Officer earning a gross monthly salary of Ksh.720,000/- together with benefits, including Club membership at Capital Club Nairobi, Provident fund, Medical Benefits, ESOP at 1.25% of 5% of the net company value, bonuses and allowances.
11. The Petitioner states that his problems began around November 2020 when the Respondent’s then CEO, a South African National, effected brutal changes within the Respondent organization, through a systemic removal of women from managerial posts. Further, he effected demotions of qualified personnel especially the women on flimsy grounds, institutionalization of fear, undignified treatment of the staff, muzzling of any differing opinion, harassment of any person that did not obey illegal instructions or accept racial slurs, including threats of termination and redundancy, and the use of racial slurs such as “Africans are monkeys and gorillas, naturally corrupt and lazy”.
12. It is the Petitioner’s case that he himself was subjected to humiliation by the C.E.O by being excluded from meetings and decisions, but being expected to be aware of and implement the decisions. The C.E.O’s conduct caused such disaffection among the employees that it led to a virtual meeting of the Board on 21st January 2021 to address the issue. The Board, however, downplayed the employees’ grievances and excused the C.E.O's conduct as “unique culture and experience”, and stated that his behavior should be accommodated/tolerated. The Petitioner expressed his disagreement as the instructions issued by the Respondent’s C.E.O. endangered patients and were in some cases outright illegal. He was victimized from the date of the virtual meeting by being subjected to aggressive and continuous intimidation, bullying, verbal abuse and entrapments by the C.E.O.; while the employees working under him were also subjected to constructive dismissals, unprocedural redundancy and forced resignations. It is averred that due to workplace harassment, the Petitioner fell ill and took sick leave on 20th, 24th and 26th March 2021 in order to seek treatment. He appointed, in line with the C.E.O’s directions, one Faith Nyawira, his direct reportee, to act in his absence.
13. It is averred that during the Petitioner’s absence, a scheme was hatched to make sure that he was found at fault, in that Disciplinary Action/show cause letters were authored in his name against ones Faith Waweru, Nyawira Kinyua and Claire Kamau, and purportedly signed for him by the Chief Quality and Standards Officer. When he became aware of the letters, being cautious that they flouted the Respondent’s human resource procedures, the Petitioner reported the matter to the police, and informed the Respondent’s Human Resource Manager through a letter dated 30th March 2021 of the police report. He requested internal investigations and non-retaliation. On 12th April 2021, the Respondent's Human Resource Manager responded, assuring the Petitioner that they would not take retaliatory action against him. They, nonetheless, castigated the Petitioner and insinuated that he was incompetent, despite never subjecting him to any evaluation which had uncovered failings in his delivery of services. The Petitioner states that the letter additionally insinuated that the decisions to discipline the affected employees and the outcome of the disciplinary process were already predetermined following casual conversations between members of the Senior Management Team to which the Petitioner was complicit, a false allegation according to the Petitioner.
14. The Petitioner contends that he received communication on intended changes vide a letter dated 13th April 2021, whereby his position of COO was to be declared redundant by reason of having been divided into 2 portfolios namely, General Manager Avenue Hospital and General Manager Avenue Clinics. Despite being a member of the Executive team, the Petitioner states that he had not been informed of such changes in the Respondent organization. Vide a letter dated 22nd April 2021, he was informed that he had been terminated from employment on account of redundancy. The letter of termination referenced a meeting held by the Senior Management Team (SMT) on the13th April 2021 where the issue of the intended redundancy was purportedly discussed, but the Petitioner emphasizes that he was not aware, and neither did he attend any meetings held on 13th April 2021 or 20th April 2021.
15. The Petitioner’s case is that the purported redundancy was part of an orchestrated scheme to terminate him from employment, building up from the events particularized by the Petitioner. The Petitioner further complains that his redundancy contravened Sections 5(3), 40,42, 44 and 45 of the Employment Act, the Constitution and International Labour Laws as no reasons were advanced for justifying the organizational restructuring nor of the redundancy there being in place a strategic plan that was to run up to 2024; the reporting lines and the functions of the redundant Chief Operating Officer position are for all practical purposes the same as those of the General Manager Avenue Hospital; the redundancy notice expressed a need to reduce the workload of the Chief Operating Officer not the abolishment of the position; the Petitioner was not granted an opportunity to express interest in taking up the new positions; the notice of intention to declare redundancy was not served upon the Petitioner; the Petitioner was not given three months’ termination notice in accordance with Clause 16 of his Employment Contract dated 15th October 2019 which provided for such notice except in the event of non-performance; no notice was served upon the Labor Office; and the Petitioner was not given an exit package including three months’ notice pay, severance pay for the 16 years that he worked for the Respondent, and gratuity.
16. The Petitioner discloses that by virtue of his position as the C.O.O., he became aware of and came into possession of information that the Respondent had systematically practiced discrimination on the basis of tribe contrary to the principle of “equal pay for equal work” as set out in the law and the Constitution, by offering less pay to the Petitioner than his colleagues from the Gikuyu tribe. He states that his predecessor, a Kikuyu, on promotion to the post of COO in January 2017 was started on a salary of Ksh. 1,200,000/- unlike the petitioner who was kept on a monthly salary of Kshs. 720,000/-. He states that in fact, the Respondents C.E.O, C.O.O., C.F.0 (Chief Financial Officer) and CQ & SO (Chief Quality and Standards Officer) had widely divergent pay, with the Petitioner despite being second in command, receiving the least pay i.e Ksh.720, 000/-, compared to the CQ&SO who received Kshs. l, 000,000/- and the CFO Kshs. 900,000/-. Both of the higher paid officers were Kikuyu. Similarly, on promotion to the position of Regional Manager, the Petitioner was given a pay increment of 16.9% whereas his colleagues reporting to him i.e. Hospital Manager Avenue Hospital Parklands and Medical Service Manager Parklands received Kshs.700,000/- and Kshs. 874,847 respectively. They too were Kikuyu. The Petitioner additionally states that on promotion to position of Chief Operation Officer the Petitioner was given an increment of 180,000/-while his Kikuyu counterpart promoted from finance Officer to chief Finance Officer was given an increment of 300,000/-. The Petitioner observes that this discrimination on the basis of ethnicity was not unique to him but was widespread throughout the Respondent's establishment, and no justification was given for these discrepancies.
17. Other forms of discrimination that the Petitioner states that he faced were that he was denied his contractual paid for right to membership at a Private Members Club namely Capital Club Nairobi while his predecessors and peers from the Kikuyu ethnic group enjoyed due to their positions; the Petitioner was not assigned an office or a work laptop after being appointed as a C.O.O. unlike his predecessors; the Respondent restricted to a few employees the voluntary inclusion into the Provident Fund jointly contributed to by the Employer and Employee at 5% gross pay from 2014, thereby excluding the Petitioner without justification; the Petitioner excluded the Petitioner from provision for cost of living adjustments; the Petitioner was denied his graduated bonus payment pegged on the end of year audited accounts which he was entitled upon appointment as the Regional Branch Manager from 1st January 2017; the Petitioner was not paid acting allowances for acting as Branch Manager Eldoret Clinic between 28th April 2016 and 30th June 2016 (Kshs.100,000/-), In-patient Manager Avenue Kisumu Hospital between 1st February to 30th July 2018 (Kshs. 270,000/-), and Regional Manager for a period of Nineteen (19) months (Kshs. 1,920,00/-); being granted Medical Allowance of Kshs. 2 Million Shillings for the four years in which he was in Senior Management whilst positions similar to his within the Respondent's set up were attracting Kshs.10,000,000/= occasioning the Petitioner loss the totaling Ksh.24,000,000/-; and being denied leave pay for his 58 (Fifty-Eight) leave days amounting to Kshs. 1,392,000/-.
18. Another complaint that the Petitioner fronts is that as a beneficiary of the ESOP, the Petitioner was discriminated against by not being paid a total of USD 348,051 being his 1.25% share of the 5% of the total value of the Company from 2017 to 2020 whilst others who were terminated by the Respondent were paid, and by being denied documentation on ESOP. It is averred that the amount for 2015-2016 was paid in 2017 when a liquidity event occurred in 2016 when Evercare Group acquired the Respondent and through its Management Abraaj paid off the amount. The Petitioner's legitimate expectation that he would be paid his ESOP arose from the fact that during his tenure the Respondent saw its greatest growth of revenue and earnings without capital injections from the Share Holders and the Fund Managers.
19. The Petitioner contends that the Respondent’s conduct violated his Articles 10, 20(1) (2) and (4),27, 28 and 47 rights. They also contravened Section 5(3) of the Employment Act by discriminating against the Petitioner on grounds of ethnicity and conditions of employment; and the General Rule of the International Labour Convention domesticated as Kenyan Law by Articles 2(5) and (8) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
Respondent’s case in brief
20. The Respondent admits that the Petitioner was appointed as a Medical Officer by the Respondent vide letter of appointment dated 27th September 2004 on a permanent and pensionable basis and earning a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 95,000.00 in addition to other benefits. He was later, on 5th December 2016, awarded an increment in salary of Kshs. 461,725/- based on merit, and then on 1st March 2017, promoted to the position of Regional Manager at a monthly gross salary of Kshs. 540, 000.00 together with benefits. They agree with the Petitioner that he became a member of the Senior Management Team after this promotion. It is averred that subsequently, the Respondent promoted the Petitioner to the position of Acting Chief Operating Officer on 1st September 2018, and awarded him an additional monthly acting allowance of Ksh.100,000.00 above his salary and other benefits. On 1st January 2019, the Petitioner was confirmed as the Chief Operating Officer at a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 720,000.00 alongside other benefits.
21. It is stated that the events leading up to the Petitioner’s termination of employment took place during his tenure as the Respondent’s Chief Operating Officer. In 2020, the Respondent appointed one Dr. Andre Ackerman as the Chief Executive Officer (the C.E.O) to spearhead organizational reforms for the benefit of the Organization and its patients, which the Petitioner was well aware of. There were also ongoing conversations, which the Petitioner was aware of, concerning the conduct of three employees: Faith Waweru, Nyawira Kinyua and Claire Kamau, who had on more than one occasion failed to ensure that there was equality and safety within the organisation.
22. The Respondent contends that from 20th to 26th March 2021, the Petitioner took sick off days for the purpose of seeking treatment as he was unwell. This sick off coincided with the execution of management's decision, made in the presence of the Petitioner, to issue show cause notices and suspension letters to the three employees: Faith Waweru, Nyawira Kinyua and Claire Kamau. While it is admitted that the Petitioner complained in a letter dated 30th March 2021 that the show cause and suspension letters were issued in his name and a criminal complaint lodged at the Police Station by him, the Respondent states that they responded to the issues raised vide a letter dated 12th April 2021.
23. On 13th April 2021, in line with the overhaul of the Respondent's organizational structure, the Respondent informed the Petitioner that the position of the Chief Operating Officer, which the Petitioner held, had been collapsed into two portfolios: General Manager Avenue Hospitals, and General Manager Avenue Clinics, both positions reporting directly to the CEO. Further, the Petitioner was informed that the Management would engage him on the issue in order to discuss the way forward. Discussions were subsequently held on 20th April 2021 on the effect that the changes would have on the Petitioner’s position, and the payments that he was entitled to. Thereafter, through a letter dated 22nd April 2021, the Respondent was issued with one month's Notice of Redundancy to the Nairobi County Labour Office informing them of the redundancy. According to the Respondent, their communication with the Labour Office complied with Section 40(1)(b) of the Employment Act, 2007.
24. It is also averred that in accordance with Section 40 (l)(b) of the Employment Act 2007, the Respondent issued the Petitioner with one month's Notice of Termination of Employment on Account of Redundancy dated 22nd April 2021 informing him that his last day was 22nd May 2021. After receiving the Notice of Termination, the Petitioner requested via email a full computation of his terminal dues including Service Pay, Employment Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), Leave Days and Gratuity. The computation was provided by the Respondent through a letter dated 5th May 2022, whereby he was also informed that ESOP had not yet been implemented hence he was not entitled to any amount emanating from the same. The Respondent confirms that the terminal dues were eventually paid out to the Petitioner but he was not satisfied with the amount computed by the Respondent. The parties attempted negotiations but they failed.
25. The Respondent’s case is that they followed due lawful process in the termination of the Petitioner’s employment on account of redundancy as the position of COO held by the Petitioner was abolished in line with Section 2 of the Employment Act and was therefore legally justified; the Respondent issued a one month's notice of termination on account of redundancy to both the Labour Office and the Petitioner as per the dictates of Section 40 (1) (b) of the Employment Act, 2007; the Respondent paid the Petitioner his terminal dues including fifteen days' pay for each completed year of service as stipulated in Section 40(1)(g) of the Employment Act; the Petitioner was aware, as part of the Senior Management Team, that the organisation was undergoing structural changes which would impact several positions; and the Respondent effected the redundancy to align the business with market expectations, rather than to target women or any other category of employees as alleged.
26. The allegations that the Respondent discriminated against the Petitioner are denied, with the Respondent stating that the Petitioner was treated and paid fairly during the pendency of his employment, as he was remunerated fairly and in a manner commensurate with the work and position he held at the time; and was not discriminated against on the basis of ethnicity. The Respondent insists that they adhered at all times with Articles 10, 27, 41 and 47 of the Constitution as well as Sections 5(3) of the Employment Act
DETERMINATION
27. Following directions by the court that it would determine the Petition through written submissions, the Petitioner and Respondent filed their respective submissions.
Issues for determination
28. In his submissions dated 14th July 2026, the Petitioner identified the following issues for determination:-
i. Whether the Petitioner was unfairly terminated.
ii. Whether the petitioner is entitled for the unfair and wrongful termination damages.
iii. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the benefits denied him by the Respondent.
iv. Whether the Constitutional rights specifically of equal pay for equal work, non-discrimination on ethnic basis and labour rights were violated.
v. Whether general damages should be awarded.
29. Conversely, the Respondent filed submissions dated 27th July 2026, where they distilled three issues for determination, namely:
i. Whether the termination of the Petitioner’s employment by the Respondent on account of redundancy was substantively justified.
ii. Whether the Petitioner was accorded due process prior to termination of their contract by the Respondent.
iii. Whether the Petitioner was entitled to an Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP).
iv. Whether the Petitioner was discriminated against on any basis.
v. Who should bear the costs of this suit.
30. The court, having perused the proceedings, partly having heard the case, and perused the pleadings, was of the considered opinion that the issues for determination in the suit were as follows-
i. Whether the Petitioner was unfairly terminated from employment.
ii. Whether the Petitioner was entitled to an Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP).
iii. Whether the Constitutional rights specifically of equal pay for equal work, non-discrimination on ethnic basis and labour rights were violated.
iv. Whether the petitioner is entitled to relief sought
The law
31. Section 40 of the Employment Act provides for the redundancy process and mandatory conditions to be complied with by the employer -
‘40. Termination on account of redundancy
(1)An employer shall not terminate a contract of service on account of redundancy unless the employer complies with the following conditions—(a)where the employee is a member of a trade union, the employer notifies the union to which the employee is a member and the labour officer in charge of the area where the employee is employed of the reasons for, and the extent of, the intended redundancy not less than a month prior to the date of the intended date of termination on account of redundancy;
(b)where an employee is not a member of a trade union, the employer notifies the employee personally in writing and the labour officer;
(c)the employer has, in the selection of employees to be declared redundant had due regard to seniority in time and to the skill, ability and reliability of each employee of the particular class of employees affected by the redundancy;
(d)where there is in existence a collective agreement between an employer and a trade union setting out terminal benefits payable upon redundancy; the employer has not placed the employee at a disadvantage for being or not being a member of the trade union;
(e)the employer has where leave is due to an employee who is declared redundant, paid off the leave in cash;
(f)the employer has paid an employee declared redundant not less than one month's notice or one month's wages in lieu of notice; and
(g)the employer has paid to an employee declared redundant severance pay at the rate of not less than fifteen days pay for each completed year of service.’
Whether the Petitioner was unfairly terminated from employment.
32. The petitioner alleged that the termination was unfair because the restructuring was not justified, that he was the only one affected, that he was not consulted, and that there was no selection criteria.
Compliance with notices
33. The court noted the respondent issued the petitioner with notice of restructuring dated 13th April 2021 and received by the petitioner on 5th April 2021(R-exhb 8). The letter indicated the petitioner had been involved in the development of a new structure approved on 4th March 2021, that he had been informed that morning at a meeting of senior management team, that the position of COO held by the petitioner had been affected by being divided into 2 portfolios, namely, General Manager Avenue Hospital and General Manager Avenue Clinics and thus the position of COO had become redundant.
34. The respondent produced as its exhibit 9 notification of redundancy to the Nairobi Labour Office, and the same was received on 22nd April 2021. The notice indicated that the position of COO, among other positions, had been declared redundant. A similar notice was produced, addressed to the petitioner, of termination on account of redundancy. The letter referred to the prior letter of 13th April 2021, and discussions held with the petitioner on 20th April 2021(R-exhb 10).
35. In the email of 2nd April 2021, the petitioner responded to the notice of termination and asked for full computation of all sums due to him, inclusive of service pay,ESOP, Leave days and gratuity as provided in the law.
36. The court so far finds there was compliance with the notices as per section 40 of the Employment Act.
Consultation and selection criteria
37. The petitioner was not offered any of the 2 positions following the split of his position of COO. RW1 admitted as much and offered no reason why the respondent did not offer any of the positions to the petitioner, despite the petitioner having served as regional branch manager, where he acted as overseer of the clinics at the time. It was evident to the court that there was no meaningful consultation with the petitioner regarding redundancy and the possibility of being re-engaged in any of the 2 positions, for which his qualifications were not denied. The essence of consultation in redundancy was explained by the Court of Appeal in The German School Society & another v Ohany& another (Civil Appeal 325 & 342 of 2018 (Consolidated)) [2023] KECA 894 (KLR) where the Court of Appeal held at paragraphs 56, 57 and 60:-
"A notice to the employee/trade union/labour officer opens up the door for a consultative process with the key stakeholders. The Court of Appeal the German School case (Supra) held:
a) Consultation is implicit in the Employment Act under the principle of fair play,
b) Consultation gives an opportunity for other avenues to be considered to avert or to minimize the adverse effects of terminations;
c) Consultations are meant for the parties to put their heads together and is imperative under Kenyan law;
d) Consultations have to be a reality not a charade;
e) Opportunity must be given for the stakeholders to consider,
f) Stakeholders must have and keep an open mind to listen to suggestions, consider them properly and then only then decide what is to be done; and
g) Consultation must not be cosmetic.’
38. The process was flawed for lack of consultation with the petitioner as to whether he could be engaged in the 2 new roles created on declaring his position of COO redundant. The issue of selection did not apply as there was only one COO.
Validity of the reasons for the redundancy
39. The petitioner contended the redundancy was not justified but relied on a draft structure. On the issue of whether or not the redundancy was justified, I find it is a business prerogative of the employer to declare redundancy. In the letter of 13th April 2021, the employer explained that the redundancy was due to a new business structure. In Kenya Airways Limited vs. Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 Others [2014] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that as long as the employer genuinely believed that there was a redundancy situation, any termination was justified, and it was not for the court to substitute its business decision of what was reasonable. The Court has no supervisory role. I find the new business structure justified the redundancy.
Procedure
40. In the opinion of the Court, the computation complied with the payment under section 40 (exhb 12). The petitioner did not dispute the computation. He alleged he raised issues of other due payments; no evidence was produced to support the allegations. Documentary evidence is superior to mere averments. He needed the computation in writing; he received the computation in writing. Nothing could have been easier and more reasonable than challenging the computation in writing. The petitioner was not paid until he had to make a demand claim dated 27th August 2021(p- exhb AK22). The law does not envisage that an employee declared redundant would be required to wait until the last day of the notice period to be paid monies due under section 40. The respondent failed to comply with payment of dues as stated in the law(section 40 of the Employment Act), despite having computed the same as requested by the petitioner, vide iletter dated 5th May 2021. For the foregoing reasons, I find that the termination process was unlawful and unfair for lack of consultation and compliance with section 40 regarding the due payment.
Whether the Petitioner was entitled to an Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP).
41. The petitioner raised this issue and was cross-examined on it and he also cross-examined the respondent's counsel on it. When the petitioner requested the for computation, the request included ESOP. The respondent, vide letter dated 5th May 2021 informed the petitioner as follows-
‘ as you are aware the ESOP has not been implemented and therefore there is no amount you are entitled to.’
42. As indicated earlier, the petitioner never wrote back to challenge the employer on the computation and response on ESOP. To support the claim of ESOP, the petitioner relied on the minutes of the respondent's remuneration committee dated 2nd August 2012, in which the issue of ESOP was discussed and it was noted that an HR policy would be put in place (P-exb 24). He produced as exhibits 25 a notice of grant issued to Dr Dennis Ogolla and dated 10th May 2016. During the hearing, the petitioner admitted that on 28th February 2019, while he was a COO, he attended a meeting where it was indicated the ESOP was still pending alignment with ECO system. He told the court that by the time he left, the ESOP issue was still pending. The petitioner produced his employment contract, which has Schedule 1 on remuneration. On ESOP it was stated that he was entitled to-
‘ all other benefits and options normally applying to AVENUE Group Staff in the same category of employment.
This will include participation in the Executive Stock Option Plan to be introduced.
43. The petitioner relied on the document of 2016 before he became COO. The court finds that his own contract and testimony were to the effect that the promise of ESOP had not crystallised even at his exit. The court finds that the claim of ESOP had no merit.
Whether the Constitutional rights specifically of equal pay for equal work, non-discrimination on ethnic basis and labour rights were violated.
44. The petitioner pleaded discrimination based on tribe in paragraph 44 of petition. He made assertions of disparity in payments. He was the only COO and thus no comparison of term with similar employee. During the hearing and cross-examination of the RW1, she admitted the petitioner was 2nd in command and was paid less than a person below, being the chief quality standards officer. On the issue of predetermined termination on account of the letters issued by a colleague irregularly to his 3 colleagues, on perusal of the employer's response to him, I find that the employer appreciated that the same was issued on behalf of his office and had no issue against him. I was not persuaded that the letters had anything to do with the termination, taking into account the contents of the letter dated 13th April 2021, which referred to a new structure approved on 4th March 2021, yet his complaint on the said letter was on 30th March 2021. There is no causation proved.
45. The court finds that, unless the employment contract is before the court to prove the discrimination in terms of equal work equal pay, there are many variables which may lead to such a scenario, where an employee ranked lower, like years of service in the position, allowances due to the position, among others. The court has no benefit of the contract to make an informed decision. Mere allegation on wages cannot suffice to support a claim of discrimination on remuneration. I find that the petitioner did not prove his claim of discrimination on the balance of probabilities, thereby shifting the burden to the employer to prove non-discrimination or justify the differentiation, if any.
Whether the petitioner is entitled to relief sought
46. The court held that the termination process was unfair for non- compliance with the redundancy process. The petitioner was eventually paid the leave, the 15 days' severance pay, and one month's notice. However, due to a lack of consultation and non-compliance with payment requirements under the law, the termination is held to be in violation of fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution, as stated in Section 40 of the Employment Act as concerns termination of employment on the basis of redundancy.
47. The petitioner had served the respondent for 17 years, from 27th September 2004 to May 2021. The contract was terminated on redundancy, meaning he did not contribute to the termination. I award him compensation under section 12 of the ELRC, equivalent of 6 months' gross salary @720,000.
48. On provident fund, that is a claim against the fund and not the employer.
49. On claim of gratuity, the item is not under contract. (Page 185 of the petitioner’s bundle of documents is the employment clause on remuneration).
50. All other terminal claims related to the employment were not proved on a balance of probabilities.
Disposal
51. The court enters judgment for the petitioner for unfair labour practice in violation of Article 41 of the Constitution and section 40 of the Employment Act as follows-
a) THAT a Declaration is issued that the redundancy termination letter dated 22nd April 2021 issued by the Respondent to the Petitioner is unlawful on account of violation of Article 41 and 47 of the Constitution and Section 40 of the Employment Act.
b) THAT the Respondent do pay the Petitioner:-
i. Compensation for violation of right to fair labour rights under Article 41 of the Constitution as read with Section 40 of the Employment Act Ksh. 4,320,000/- equivalent of 6 months' gross salary with interest at court rate from the judgment date.
ii. Costs of the petition.
52. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED IN VIRTUALLY MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Petitioner: Ms Moraa
Respondent: Ochola