Employment law

KCA University v Kenya Private Universities Workers Union [2026] KEELRC 14936 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Petition E044 of 2022
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The applicant (union) alleged contempt of court against the petitioner(employer) of orders of the court in judgment delivered on the28th March 2025 in Notice of Motion application dated 15th April 2026 brought under Rule 73 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedural) Rules 2024 seeking for orders-

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

The application is dismissed with costs to the respondent/petitioner.

Paragraph 29 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC PETITION NO. E044 OF 2022

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

KCA UNIVERSITY …………………………………………………………………….. PETITIONER / RESPONDENT

VERSUS

KENYA PRIVATE UNIVERSITIES WORKERS UNION ……………… RESPONDENT / APPLICANT

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

RULING

1. The applicant (union) alleged contempt of court against the petitioner(employer) of orders of the court in judgment delivered on the28th March 2025 in Notice of Motion application dated 15th April 2026 brought under Rule 73 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedural) Rules 2024 seeking for orders-

i. THAT, the Honourable Court be pleased to issue an Order against the Petitioner's CEO (Vice Chancellor) Prof. Isalah I. C. Wakindiki to appear in Court to show cause why he should not be sentenced for Contempt of Court Orders.

ii. THAT, the costs of this Application be provided for by the Petitioner.

2. Grounds of the application

a) THAT, the Honourable Court delivered her Judgement in the matter on the 28th day of March 2025 and a DECREE in the same given on 3rd day of April 2025with clear Orders to allow the Respondent/Applicant to access her members and potential members at the Petitioner's premises. Here attached and marked Appendix PEO1are copies of the Judgement and Decree in the matter.

b) THAT, Judgement and decree were served upon the Petitioner after which the Respondent has written various letters requesting for permission for access which the Petitioner has declined in writing and at some point not responding. Here attached and marked App. PE02 are copies of the parties' letters to that effect.

c) THAT, Judgement and decree were served upon the Petitioner after which the Respondent has written various letters requesting for permission for access Here attached and marked App. PE03 are copies of the parties' letters to that effect.

d) THAT, Order number (2) as sought herein is provided for at Rule (70) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024.

e) THAT, Order number (1) as sought herein is provided for at Rule 73 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024.

3. The application was supported by an affidavit of Peter Emisembe Owiti, who stated he was the General Secretary of the union and that the annexed correspondence demonstrated the union sought access to the premises of the petitioner unsuccessfully. He stated that this was in contempt of the judgment of the court dated 28th March 2025 which granted them an order of access to recruit members.

4. The respondent opposed the application vide replying affidavit of Prof. Wakindiki sworn on 21st April 2026. The deponent denied the petitioner was in contempt of the court by stating –

5. THAT the Application is wholly misconceived, bad in law, an abuse of the process of this Honourable Court, and a deliberate attempt by the Respondent/Applicant to misrepresent, distort, and circumvent the clear terms of this Court's Judgment. It is brought in bad faith and ought to be dismissed with costs on an attorney-client basis (or such higher scale as this Court deems fit) to mark this Court's displeasure at the Respondent/Applicant's persistent contumacious conduct.

6. THAT the core of the Application is the false and misleading assertion that the Petitioner has willfully disobeyed the Judgment and Decree. This is a blatant misrepresentation. The Judgment of this Honourable Court (per Hon. Lady Justice Jemimah Wanza Keli) is expressly conditional and must be read and applied in its entirety. Paragraphs 49 and 50 of the Judgment (which the Respondent/Applicant conveniently ignores) state in clear and unambiguous terms: "49. The Respondent should comply with the letter by the Vice Chancellor of 8th February 2022 [sic - reference to the Petitioner's letter of 2nd December 2021] and submit the names of the registered officials of the union as requested and their identity documents and further on compliance the university should permit reasonable access which should be for 2 weeks and regulated by the employer as it deems fit since Section 56 of the Labour Relations Act provides for meetings outside working hours which means the recruitment could be over lunch hour..." "50(b). Order under prayer g, The Respondents to comply with Petitioner's letter of 2nd December 2021 and on compliance, the Petitioner to permit reasonable access..." (Emphasis added). The Decree mirrors this conditional order verbatim.

7. THAT the Petitioner's letter of 2nd December 2021 (which the Court expressly incorporated into its Order) required the Respondent/Applicant to:

(i) provide the names of its recognised union representatives;

(ii) furnish proof of their identity and credentials; and

(iii) conduct any meetings outside working hours to avoid disruption of the University's academic programmes.

8. The Respondent/Applicant has never complied with this precondition at any point since the Judgment was delivered. None of the letters annexed as PEO2 (dated 12th June 2025, 15th August 2025, 13th February 2026, and 24th March 2026) contain or attach any list of authorised officials or identity documents. The Respondent/Applicant simply issues peremptory demands for access without fulfilling the Court-mandated condition precedent.

9. THAT in direct response to the Respondent/Applicant's letter of 13th February 2026, the Petitioner promptly replied by letter dated 18th February 2026 (annexed by the Respondent/Applicant itself as PEO3). That letter explicitly reminded the Respondent/Applicant of the conditional nature of the Judgment, quoted the relevant paragraphs, and reiterated that the Petitioner has no obligation to grant access until the precondition is met. The Petitioner further warned the Respondent/Applicant against any attempt to trespass, in line with the declaratory relief granted in the Judgment (Order (a)) protecting the Petitioner's proprietary rights under Article 40 and the students' right to education under Article 43(1)(f) of the Constitution.

10. THAT there has therefore been no disobedience let alone willful disobedience by the Petitioner or by the deponent personally. The Petitioner remains ready and willing to grant the regulated 2-week access the moment the Respondent/Applicant complies with the Judgment. The Respondent/Applicant's persistent refusal to do so, while simultaneously rushing to this Court to seek personal punishment against me, constitutes a classic case of abuse of process and forum shopping to achieve by contempt what it could not achieve by compliance.

11. The applicant filed a supplementary affidavit of Petere Emisebe Owiti dated 19th June 20206 in reply and denied non-compliance with the condition in the judgment as averred by Prof. Wakindiki. The union annexed its letter dated 20th February 2022, where it attached an extract of the registered officials. It alleged this was in compliance with the Judgment of the Court.

Determination

12. The parties submitted on several issues under the application, and the court agreed that all were relevant, namely

(i) Whether the operative order of this Court is conditional and whether the condition precedent has been fulfilled by the Respondent/Applicant after the Judgment;

and if the condition was met, proceed to determine-

(ii) When, in law, a trade union’s right to conduct activities on an employer’s premises crystallises, and whether that right had accrued to the Applicant;

(iii) Whether the high threshold for a finding of contempt has been met;

(iv) Whether the Vice-Chancellor can properly be held personally liable; and

(v) Whether the Application is an abuse of process and ought to be dismissed with costs on a higher scale.

The law

13. Section 5 of the Judicature Act provides-

“5.  The High court and the Court of Appeal shall have the same power to punish for contempt of court as is for the time being possessed by the High Court of Justice in England and that power shall extend to upholding the authority and dignity of subordinate courts”.

14. The application is brought under rule 73 of ELRC (Procedural) Rules, 2024 which states-

‘73. Execution and warrants

(1) The Registrar shall issue an order in execution of a decree.

(2) Rules on execution or stay of execution of an order or decree of the Court shall be in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules.

(3) Where any written law provides for the enforcement of the decision of an administrative body by the Court, a party may, through a miscellaneous application, apply for the adoption of that decision by the Court.

(4) Notwithstanding subrule (3), an application for the enforcement of the decision of an administrative body shall only be made after the period allowed for appeal or review has lapsed, if any.’

Whether the operative order of this Court is conditional and whether the condition precedent has been fulfilled by the Respondent/Applicant after the Judgment;

The applicant’s submissions-

15. The judgment and decree of the court are clear, valid and binding - It is trite that once a competent court has issued an order, the order remains binding unless and until it is reviewed, varied, stayed or set aside on appeal. The judgment herein was delivered on 28th March 2025. The decree was subsequently issued on 3rd April 2025. There is no evidence before this Court that the judgment or decree has been stayed, reviewed, varied or set aside. The Respondent therefore has no legal basis upon which to suspend compliance with the orders according to its own interpretation of what the Court intended. The Court of Appeal in Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] KECA 945 (KLR) emphatically reaffirmed that the obligation to obey a court order is uncompromising. The Court held that a person who knows of a court order cannot choose whether to obey it based upon his own assessment of its validity or regularity. The same principle is captured in the well-established authority of Econet Wireless Kenya Ltd v Minister for Information & Communication of Kenya & Another [2005] 1 KLR 828, namely that the authority and dignity of courts must be upheld and that deliberate disobedience of court orders cannot be condoned.

16. The importance of this principle cannot be overstated in the present case. The Respondent is not an ordinary private party unaware of the proceedings. It was the petitioner in the original Petition. Its Vice Chancellor swore the Replying Affidavit in the present proceedings and expressly acknowledges knowledge of the judgment, decree and correspondence. Indeed, the Respondent's Replying Affidavit does not dispute the existence of the judgment. On the contrary, it quotes and relies upon paragraphs 49 and 50 of the judgment. The Respondent is therefore fully aware of the order it is accused of disobeying.

17. The question is consequently not whether there was an order. There plainly was. The question is whether the Respondent complied with it.

18. On the issue of the order being conditional the applicant fulfilled the condition - The principal defence advanced by the alleged contemnor is that the order of the Court was conditional. We concede that the order contained a condition. However, the Respondent's argument fails because the condition imposed by the Court had already been fulfilled by the Applicant. The Respondent relies heavily upon paragraph 49 of the judgment, which stated that the Applicant was required to submit the names of its registered officials and their identity documents, after which the University was to permit reasonable access. The Respondent then asserts that the Applicant never complied with that requirement. That assertion is contradicted by the documentary evidence. The Applicant had, as demonstrated by the documents annexed to the Supplementary Affidavit, already furnished the Respondent with the relevant list of its national officials and union representatives. The Applicant's letter dated 20th February 2022 expressly forwarded an extract from the Registrar of Trade Unions together with a list of the current union officials at the University. The extract identifies, among others, the General Secretary, National Chairman, Deputy Secretary General and other national officials. The Applicant's records further contain its communication concerning its shopfloor officials. The respondent has not disputed receipt or lack of knowledge of the said letter. The Respondent's defence therefore suffers from a fundamental flaw. Since the condition identified by the Respondent itself had been met, the obligation to permit reasonable access crystallised. The Respondent was thereafter obliged to regulate the access in accordance with the judgment—not to refuse it altogether.

The Respondent’s submissions

19. The order is expressly conditional – the condition has never been fulfilled post-judgment - The starting point is the actual language of the Judgment and Decree. Paragraph (b) of the Decree (mirroring paragraphs 49 and 50 of the Judgment) states: “Order under prayer g, The Respondents to comply with Petitioner’s letter of 2nd December 2021 and on compliance, the Petitioner to permit reasonable access which should be for 2 weeks and regulated by the employer as it deems fit since Section 56 of the Labour Relations Act provides for meetings outside working hours which means the recruitment could be over lunch hour.”

20. The words “and on compliance” create a classic condition precedent. Until the Respondent/Applicant complies with the Petitioner’s letter of 2nd December 2021 (by submitting the names of its registered officials and their identity documents), the Petitioner’s obligation to permit access does not arise at all. The Respondent/Applicant’s reliance on a letter dated 20th February 2022 (more than three years before the Judgment) is both legally and factually bankrupt. The Court was fully seized of the entire history of the dispute, including prior correspondence, when it delivered its Judgment. If the Court had considered the 2022 letter sufficient, it would never have imposed the condition in the terms that it did. The deliberate inclusion of the condition demonstrates that the Court was not satisfied that compliance had occurred.

21. Evidently, The Applicant’s own annexures (the letters of June 2025, August 2025, February 2026 and March 2026) do not enclose any list of officials or identity documents. The Petitioner’s letter of 18 February 2026 (annexed by the Applicant itself as PEO3) put the Applicant on clear notice of the outstanding condition, yet no compliance followed. This removes any possible suggestion that the University “moved the goalposts”. Post-judgment correspondence from the Respondent/Applicant did not attach any fresh or updated list of officials or identity documents. When the Petitioner, by its letter of 18th February 2026, expressly reminded the Respondent/Applicant of the condition and required compliance, the Respondent/Applicant still failed to supply the documents. Instead, it rushed to Court with this contempt application. A party cannot rely on stale, pre-judgment correspondence to claim fulfilment of a condition that the Court specifically imposed after reviewing the entire record. To hold otherwise would render the Court’s carefully crafted condition meaningless.

Decision

22. Section 5 of the Judicature Act provides-

“5.  The High court and the Court of Appeal shall have the same power to punish for contempt of court as is for the time being possessed by the High Court of Justice in England and that power shall extend to upholding the authority and dignity of subordinate courts”.

23. The Supreme Court in Mate & another v Wambora & another [2017] KESC 1 (KLR) set out a core essence of contempt of court as follows-

‘80. Be it restated that the court’s word is the people’s solemn edict calling for obedience; but it is precisely the sanctity of that word, that dictates utmost care, focus and assiduity, in the judge’s undertaking. The context is set out in the Judgment of Romer LJ in Hadkinson v Hadkinson [1952] 2 All ER 567:

“It is the plain and unqualified obligation of every person against, or in respect of, whom an order is made by a court of competent jurisdiction to obey it unless and until that order is discharged. The uncompromising nature of this obligation is shown by the fact that it extends even to cases where the person affected by an order believes it to be irregular or even void,’

24. The Order in the judgment of which the petitioner is accused of being in contempt read as follows-

‘a. A declaration that the respondent in seeking to forcibly enter into the premises of the petitioner without seeking permission is unlawful and amounts to trespass in violation of Article 40 and right to education under the Constitution.

b. Order under prayer g, The Respondents to comply with Petitioner's letter of 2nd December 2021 and on compliance, the Petitioner to permit reasonable access which should be for 2 weeks and regulated by the employer as it deems fit since Section 56 of the Labour Relations Act provides for meetings outside working hours which means the recruitment could be over lunch hour.’

25. The applicant contended he had complied with the condition in order (b)(above) of the Judgment under his supplementary affidavit dated 19th June 2026 where he attached a letter dated 20th February 2022 where he annexed an extract of the register of trade unions in office as at 31st January 2022. The court notes the letter was in place as at hearing of the case. It is disingenuous of the applicant to rely on the said letter in compliance with the judgment of the court dated 28th March 2025. The compliance ought to be post the judgment. The court could not have issued the order if not was not necessary. Court orders are not in vain. The applicant has not complied with the condition of the judgment in its favour.

26. In Mweru & others v National Land Commission & 2 others [2020] KEHC 9233 (KLR)  the court set out the test of determination of issue of contempt as follows-

‘The test for when disobedience of a civil order constitutes contempt has come to be stated as whether the breach was committed ‘deliberately and mala fide.’ A deliberate disregard is not enough, since the non-complier may genuinely, albeit mistakenly, believe he/she is entitled to act in the way claimed to constitute the contempt. In such a case good faith avoids the infraction. Even a refusal to comply that is objectively unreasonable may be bona fide (though unreasonableness could evidence lack of good faith).’

27. It is the finding of the court that the obligation by the petitioner did not crystallise for lack of compliance with the condition in the judgment. There is no evidence of disobedience for contempt, as per the foregoing jurisprudence, to be found. The court need not decide on the merit of the application as the obligation to grant access has not crystallized.

Disposal

28. The application is held to be premature, as the obligation to grant access has not crystallised. The Court holds that the applicant has not complied with the condition for access as stated in the judgment dated 28th March 2025, Order b.

29. The application is dismissed with costs to the respondent/petitioner.

30. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Applicant: Mosagwe h/b Meso

Respondent- Ouko Cliffton

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder