Employment law

Imperial College of Medical and Health Sciences v Chepkirui [2026] KEELRC 14988 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Appeal E258 of 2025
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact in failing to analyze that the Appellant were never served either physically or electronically with the Amended Memorandum of Claim, Summons to enter appearance or hearing notices and she relied on the impugned service alleged by the deponent of the Affidavit of Service dated 4th March, 2024 which was disputed by the Appellant herein thereby reached a wrong decision.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NO. E258 OF 2025

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

IMPERIAL COLLEGE OF MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES ……….… APPELLANT

VERSUS

ANNETTE LANGAT CHEPKIRUI ………………………………….………… RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal from the Ruling of Hon. D. Milimu, Senior Resident Magistrate, delivered on 4th August, 2025 at Thika in MCELRC No. E004 of 2024: Annette Lang’at Chepkirui v Imperial College of Medical and Health Sciences)

JUDGMENT

This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 7th August, 2025. It arises from a Ruling delivered on 4th August, 2025 in Thika MCELRC No. E004 of 2024 in which the trial court dismissed, with costs, the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 8th May, 2025.

That Motion sought to set aside the ex-parte judgment delivered on 28th October, 2024, the decree and the following execution and leave for the Appellant to defend the claim.

The Respondent had been employed by the Appellant as a trainer at its Thika campus from 7th July, 2022. Her employment was terminated by a letter dated 31st October, 2023, with effect from 1st November, 2023 on an allegation(s) of conflict of interest.

The Appellant did not enter appearance. The claim was heard ex-parte on 9th September, 2024. The trial court found the termination unfair and awarded one month’s salary in lieu of notice and twelve months’ gross salary as compensation. In all, the award totaled Kshs. 436,800.00 a certificate of service, costs and interest.

On 6th May, 2025, with the auctioneers and the police at its premises, the Appellant paid Kshs. 300,000.00 against a handwritten acknowledgment. The Motion was filed two days later. The Respondent’s case is that the attached goods were sold by public auction on 16th May, 2025.

The Record of Appeal was filed on 28th January, 2026 and a Supplementary Record of Appeal on 17th February, 2026. It comes out as thus;

1. The learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact in failing to analyze that the Appellant were never served either physically or electronically with the Amended Memorandum of Claim, Summons to enter appearance or hearing notices and she relied on the impugned service alleged by the deponent of the Affidavit of Service dated 4th March, 2024 which was disputed by the Appellant herein thereby reached a wrong decision.

2. The learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact in failing to analyze that the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, provide for service of court process (Summons to enter appearance). Rule 28 thereof provides for service on a Corporate body which may be effected on the Secretary, director and any other principal officer of the Corporate body, or where the process server is unable to find any of the said officers he may effect service by leaving the pleadings at a conspicuous place at the registered office of the Corporate body, sending the pleadings by the registered courier service to the registered office of the corporate body, leaving the pleadings at a conspicuous place where the corporate body carries out business, sending by registered post to the last known postal address of the corporate body if it does not have a registered office or postal address. The above were not followed neither were the futile efforts of service upon the said officers shown to the Court and the Affidavit of service dated 4th March, 2024 clearly shows that service of court process was ineffective as the alleged service was done on the receptionist of the Respondent and thus the trial magistrate by holding that the judgment was regular arrived at a wrong decision.

3. The learned magistrate erred in law and in fact in relying heavily on various Affidavits of service for mention and hearing notices that had been filed by the Respondent. However these do not comply with the requirements of the rules, there is no averment how the process server came to know that these were the last known email addresses of the Respondent and further they exhibit email print outs and not the read receipt reports which would essentially be proof of service by email and thus by failing to set aside the ex-parte Judgment the trial court reached at a wrong decision.

4. The learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact in failing to appreciate the veracity of the jurisprudence on the law as per Order 22 Rule 6 that provides that where the holder of a decree desires to execute it, he shall apply to the court which passed the decree in the format, provided that, where judgment in default of appearance or defense has been entered against a defendant, no execution by payment, attachment or eviction shall issue unless not less than ten days’ notice of the entry of judgment has been given to him either at his address for service or served on him personally and a copy of that notice shall be filed with the first application for execution, the Respondent applied for execution on 5th December, 2024 and the application did not comply with Order 22 Rule 6 as there was no indication that the Judgment debtor was ever served with the 10 days’ notice and thus the trial magistrate by failing to set aside the execution by ordering the lifting of the warrants of attachment arrived at a wrong decision.

5. The Learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in facts in reaching a conclusion that the delay in moving court by the Appellant was unexplained yet the Appellant had disputed service of the Summons to enter appearance, hearing notices and only became aware of these proceedings when they were ambushed by officials of Skigate Auctioneers on 5th May, 2025 and served with a proclamation of Attachment and the warrants thereof that there was a Decree emanating from proceedings against them and they are due for execution, whereby they swiftly approached the Honorable Court seeking the Orders in their Application to safeguard their interests and thus the learned magistrate proceeded to manifest bias against the Appellant’s case from the onset of the Ruling to her conclusion thereby causing the same to fall short of establishment principles of a legal Ruling.

6. The Learned trial Magistrate erred in law and in facts in finding that the Interlocutory judgment was regular in form and procedure and that the Appellant had not demonstrated any compelling error of law, procedural impropriety, or irregularity in the entry of the Judgment and decree despite the Appellant disputing Service and the legal implications involved thereby reached a wrong decision.

7. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in facts in disregarding that the Order 22 Rule 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 that permits the Court to stay execution only upon a clear showing of Sufficient cause a threshold she held had not been met by the Appellant despite the Appellant providing evidence to the contrary and thus she ended up making the wrong decision.

The Appellant prays for orders thus;

a) An Order setting aside the Ruling delivered on 4th August, 2025 and any subsequent orders thereto.

b) An Order for setting aside of the interlocutory Judgment endorsed by the trial court, the Judgment delivered on 28th October, 2024 and the subsequent decree extracted issued on 28th October, 2024 and all subsequent orders thereto issued by the trial court and the Appellant be allowed unconditional leave to defend the suit and be heard on merits before a different judicial officer at the lower court.

c) Costs of this Appeal be borne by the Respondent.

It is the Appellant’s case and submission that it was never served, physically or electronically, with the Amended Memorandum of Claim, the summons or any notice. It relies on the rule of this court on service on a corporate body, which requires service on the secretary, a director or other principal officer and allows other modes only where the process server cannot find any of them.

It submits that the Affidavit of Service sworn on 4th March, 2024 shows on its face that the documents were left with a receptionist, and that no effort to find any officer of the Appellant is disclosed. Service was therefore ineffective and the judgment irregular and material for setting aside as of right.

As to the mention and hearing notices, the Appellant submits that the affidavits of service do not say how the deponent knew the electronic mail addresses to be the Appellant’s and exhibits print-outs of messages sent rather than proof of receipt.

On execution, it submits that no notice of entry of judgment of at least ten days was given before execution issued, contrary to Order 22 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, so that the execution was unlawful. It asks that the appeal be allowed with costs.

The Respondent’s case and submission is that the appeal has been overtaken by events. The Appellant paid part of the decretal sum and committed itself to clear the balance; the goods were proclaimed, advertised and sold to a third party and the conditional stay granted by this court on 19th November, 2025 was complied with late, by a deposit made on 13th January, 2026.

On service, she submits that the process server explained how he served the Appellant and exhibited a gate pass issued at its premises. Leaving the documents at the front desk was service at a conspicuous place where the Appellant carries on business. She adds that the Principal of a college is its secretary, and points to a photograph of the Principal being served in the presence of a police officer.

She further submits further that the electronic mail addresses used are the Appellant’s published on its website, that its telephone numbers were served through WhatsApp and that the complaint about proof of receipt was never raised before the trial court. In finality, she submits that the judgment was regular, that the Motion came six months after it and only after proclamation, and that the court’s discretion does not exist to assist a party who has deliberately sought to obstruct the course of justice. She prays that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

After a considered look and scrutiny of the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal, the Supplementary Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;

1. Whether the appeal has been overtaken by events.

2. Whether the Appellant was properly served with summons to enter appearance, and whether the ex parte Judgment was therefore regular.

3. Whether the grounds on delay, bias, Order 22 Rule 6 and stay of execution have merit.

4. What orders should issue, including on costs.

This being a first appeal, this court is under a duty to re-evaluate the material that was before the trial court. The Motion was determined on affidavits and submissions, and no witness was heard. The decision was, however, discretionary, and this court will interfere only if the trial court misdirected itself in some matter and as a result arrived at a wrong decision, or was clearly wrong, as is in the authority of Mbogo & Another v Shah [1968] EA 93.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the appeal has been overtaken by events. On this, the Respondent relies on the payment of 6th May, 2025 and on the sale of the attached goods. The acknowledgment of 6th May, 2025 is a receipt written at the point of attachment, with the auctioneers and the police on the premises. It records a part payment and the release of some of the goods. It cites two case numbers and speaks of the case numbers above, and the record shows a second decree against the Appellant, in Thika MCELRC No. E007 of 2024 executed by the same auctioneers. This was not a consent and was not at all recorded in court. It contains no admission of service and no waiver of the right to challenge the judgment. The Motion followed two days later. A payment made to avert the removal of a college’s computers and desks is not acquiescence in the judgment.

Nor has the decree been satisfied. On the Respondent’s case a balance remains and execution has continued. A judgment still being enforced against a party cannot at the same time be beyond that party’s challenge.

The sale of the goods bore upon one prayer in the Motion, that for their release. It could not dispose of the prayer to set aside the judgment, and the trial court erred in treating it as overtaking the whole application. The late compliance with this court’s conditional stay goes to the stay, not the appeal. I therefore find that the appeal has not been overtaken by events. This answers the 1st issue for determination.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the Appellant was properly served with summons to enter appearance, and whether the ex parte Judgment was therefore regular. The law distinguishes a regular from an irregular default judgment. The trial court cited the authority of James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR) but reproduced only what the Court of Appeal said of a regular judgment. Of an irregular one, the court said:

“In an irregular judgment, on the other hand, judgment will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served or properly served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgment is set aside ex debito justitiae, as a matter of right”.

The court went on to hold that in such a case the intended defence and any delay are not considered, the party having been condemned without notice. The decisive question before the trial court was therefore whether the Appellant had been properly served with summons.

Service was said to have been effected on 29th February, 2024. Both counsel argued Rule 28 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 which came into operation in August, 2024. The Rules in force at the date of service were those of 2016 and the provision applicable is Rule 12. The two are, in the respects that matter in this case are the same.

Rule 12(1) provides that service on a corporate body may be effected on the secretary, director or any other principal officer. Only where the process server is unable to find any of those officers may he leave the pleadings at a conspicuous place at the registered office or where the body carries on business, or send them by registered courier or post. Any other method requires leave under Rule 12(2).

The Affidavit of Service of Joel Maina Mwangi sworn on 4th March, 2024 states that he went to the Appellant’s offices on 29th February, 2024 and introduced himself to the receptionist. She stamped his gate pass, received the summons and pleadings, kept copies, but declined to acknowledge receipt, having been authorised by the school Principal not to stamp any other document.

A process server’s return of service carries a presumption that service took place as stated, and the burden lies on the party questioning it to show that it is incorrect, as is in the authority of Shadrack Arap Baiywo v Bodi Bach [1987] KECA 69 (KLR). This court awards the return that weight. The stamped gate pass confirms the visit and the Appellant has not disowned it, or at all.

The presumption, however, goes to the facts stated. It does not turn those facts into compliance with the Rule. Taken at its highest, the return shows service on an unnamed receptionist. A receptionist is not the secretary, a director or a principal officer, and the process server does not say that he looked for any such officer or failed to find one or all of them. The condition on which the alternative modes depend was therefore never laid. On the process server’s own account, the Principal was near enough to instruct the receptionist on what to stamp, which makes the failure to serve him or to explain why he could not be served, all the more telling.

The Respondent’s Replying Affidavit says that the process server found the Principal and served him in the face of hostility. That is not what the process server swore, and his own account binds the Respondent. The photograph she relies on is dated 6th May, 2025 and shows the execution, not the service of summons in February, 2024. Again, the Affidavit of Service refers to a claim dated 13th February, 2024 while judgment was entered on the claim as amended. No affidavit on record says that the Amended Memorandum of Claim was among the documents served, which was the very complaint on the face of the Motion.

The electronic mail notices do not cure the position. These were notices of mention and hearing, not summons. The 2016 Rules made no provision for service by electronic mail and no leave was sought. Rule 11(6) called for evidence of acknowledgment of receipt, and the affidavits exhibit only print-outs of messages sent. This is not a new point; service was the whole foundation of the Motion.

The trial court therefore misdirected itself. It held that the return of service had not been challenged when the Motion was founded on a denial of service. It did not test the return against the Rule. It relied on the demand letter of 8th November, 2023 and the payment of the October salary, which predate the suit and say nothing about service of summons. I therefore find that the Appellant was not properly served with summons to enter appearance. The Judgment of 28th October, 2024 was irregular and ought to have been set aside as of right. This answers the 2nd issue for determination and grounds 1, 2, 3 and 6 again succeed.

The 3rd issue for determination is whether the grounds on delay, bias, Order 22 Rule 6 and stay of execution have merit. Delay does not arise where a judgment is irregular and ground 5 succeeds to that extent. I do not, however, accept that the Appellant first learnt of the matter on 5th May, 2025. The proclamation of 10th December, 2024 records that the auctioneers were denied entry, and police assistance was ordered on 20th March, 2025. The Appellant answered none of this.

The allegation of bias in the same ground has no basis on the record. A finding against a party is not evidence of bias.

Ground 4, on Order 22 Rule 6, which applies to execution by virtue of Rule 73(2) of the 2024 Rules, was never raised before the trial court, and a court cannot be faulted on a point not put to it. It fails, and in any event the execution falls with the decree. Ground 7 concerns an interim stay granted on 12th May, 2025 which was spent when the Motion was determined. It is not of any substance.

On the 4th issue for determination, the ruling, judgment, decree and the execution must be set aside and the Appellant awarded leave to defend. The trial Magistrate has twice pronounced on service and described the Appellant as either subverting justice or indolent. Though no bias is shown, the claim is better heard before another court of competent/similar jurisdiction.

The Appellant sought no refund of the Kshs. 300,000.00 or of the proceeds of sale, and none is ordered. Those sums must be accounted for and shall abide the outcome of the claim. In line with the Appellant’s own undertaking to provide security, any sum deposited under the order of 19th November, 2025 shall remain in court pending determination of the claim.

On costs, the Appellant has succeeded, but its own conduct after December, 2024 put the Respondent to the expense of an execution they were entitled to believe was regular. In the exercise of the discretion under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. In this case, this court makes a finding that each party shall bear their costs of this appeal.

I therefore allow the appeal and order as follows;

(i) The Ruling delivered on 4th August, 2025 in Thika MCELRC No. E004 of 2024 be and is hereby set aside and substituted with an order allowing the Notice of Motion dated 8th May, 2025 in terms of prayer (c) thereof.

(ii) The ex-parte Judgment delivered on 28th October, 2024, the decree and all consequential execution proceedings are set aside.

(iii) The Appellant shall file and serve its Memorandum of Response within thirty (30) days, in default of which the judgment of 28th October, 2024 and the decree shall stand reinstated.

(iv) The claim shall be heard and determined on its merits, on priority, before a Magistrate at Thika other than Hon. D. Milimu.

(v) The Respondent shall within thirty (30) days file in the trial court an account, supported by the auctioneers’ returns, of all sums received from the Appellant and realised from the sale of the attached goods, which sums shall abide the outcome of the claim.

(vi) Any sum deposited in court under the order of 19th November, 2025 shall remain so deposited pending the determination of the claim or further orders of the trial court.

(vii) Each party shall bear their costs of this appeal.

Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mr. Jessee Kariuki instructed by Jessee Kariuki & Company Advocates for the Appellant.

2. Miss Nandi instructed by Lucheli Musundi & Company Advocates for the Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder