REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT TIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
PETITION NO. E256 OF 2026
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLES,2,3,10,21,22,23, 27, 35, 47, 48, 50, 159, 162(2) (2) (a) 232, 234 and 258 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010
AND
IN THE MATTER OF VIOLATION OF ARTICLES 1, 10,35 AND OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010
AND
IN THE MATTER OF STATE CORPORATIONS ACT (CAP 446)
AND
IN THE MATTER OF GOVERNMENT OWNED ENTERPRISES ACT OF 2025,
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION ACT (NO. 4 OF 2013)
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT ACT (NO. 20 OF 2011)
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE MWONGOZO CODE OF GOVERNANCE FOR STATE CORPORATIONS
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA (PROTECTION OF RULES, 2013
RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS) PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE
BETWEEN
MESHACK GWARO…………………………………………………………………………………………………PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS,
NATIONAL OIL CORPORATION OF KENYA…………………………………………………..1ST RESPONDENT
NATIONAL OIL CORPORATION OF KENYA LIMITED……………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
THE CABINET SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF ENERGY & PETROLEUM………………………………………………………...3RD RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL……………………………………………………………………………4TH RESPONDENT
AND
DUNCUN WAZIRI……………………………………………………………………………………….INTERESTED PARTY
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
RULING
1. The 1st respondent, vide board resolution dated 31st August 2026, appointed their Corporation Secretary to represent it in the instant petition. The interested party, the acting CEO, further appointed the law firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP Advocates to act for the respondents vide letter of 1st September 2026, and they filed notice of change of advocate on the same date. The respondents, aggrieved with the move by the interested party filed a Notice of Motion dated 8th September 2026 brought Under Order 9 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Sections 7 and 34, sections 3A & 63 (e) of the Civil Procedure Act, and all other enabling provisions of laws for ORDERS:-
a. Spent
b. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to strike out the Memorandum of Appearance dated 1" September 2026, the Grounds of Opposition, the Notice of Motion, and all pleadings or documents filed by the firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP purporting to act for or represent the 1" Respondent (The Board of Directors) and the 2nd Respondent (National Oil Corporation of Kenya Limited).
c. THAT the firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP be barred and restrained from acting, appearing, or taking any steps in these proceedings on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
d. THAT the costs of this Application be borne by the interested party.
Grounds of application
2. Pursuant to a valid Board meeting held on 31st August 2026, the Board of Directors of the 2nd Respondent passed a formal Board Resolution appointing Robai Musilivi, the Company Secretary, to formally enter an appearance and represent the 1st and 2nd Respondents in this Petition. The law firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP does not possess any instructions, mandate, or authority from the Board of Directors to act or file any documents on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Respondents. In instructing M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP, the Interested Party acted in flagrant breach of Sections 11, 12, and 79 of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. He committed public corporate finances to private legal representation without budgeted allocation, procurement approvals, or Board sanction, rendering the expenditure illegal, unprocedural, and a waste of public funds. The Interested Party has acted in gross conflict of interest by retaining a single firm (M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP) to simultaneously represent his personal interest as a private litigant and the institutional interests of the Corporation, using public corporate resources unlawfully to defend his contested and expired personal tenure. Allowing an unauthorised firm of advocates to maintain pleadings on the record for public entities without corporate authorisation constitutes a critical irregularity, creates an operational impasse, and constitutes a direct abuse of the court process. It is in the wider interests of justice that the orders sought herein are granted.
3. The application was further supported by the Supporting Affidavit of ROBAI MUSILIVI sworn on the 8th September 2026, who annexed the resolution of the Board of Directors meeting held on the 31st August 2026 at 10.00 am(Annexure RM-01) reproduced as follows-
‘ΜΙΝ. 2.2/31/08/26: BOARD RESOLUTION
UPON consideration AND Review of the tenure of service of the acting Chief Executive Officer of National Oil Corporation of Kenya the Board HAS RESOLVED to:-
1. Instruct the Corporation Secretary to enter appearance and represent the Board of Directors, National Oil Corporation of Kenya and National Oil Corporation of Kenya in Case No. ELRCPET/E256/2026 Meshack Gwaro -vs- The Board of Directors, National Oil Corporation of Kenya and National Oil Corporation of Kenya Limited and two (2) others and request for extension of time to file a response to the application and petition.
IT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED THAT the above is a true extract from the Minutes of the Board of Directors meeting of the Company held on 31st August 2026 and that the resolution set forth was duly passed in accordance with the Memorandum and Articles of Association of the Company.’
4. The application was supported by a further affidavit of Albert Ojonyo dated 21st September 2026, the session chairperson of the 1st respondent, who averred as follows-
(1) THAT on 31 August 2026, the tenure of service of Mr. Duncan Waziri as the Ag. Chief Executive Officer of the National Oil Corporation of Kenya came to an end. (Annexed herewith and marked "RM-01" is a copy of his Appointment as Ag. Chief Executive Officer of the National Oil Corporation of Kenya Ltd.)
(2) THAT he was advised by advocate that the Office of the Attorney General, via a circular REF: AG/CONF/4/159/60 Vol. 1, dated 11th September 2026, reiterated the Conservatory court orders modified by the Court on 30th January 2026 in Gikenyi B & 6 others -vs- Council of Governors & 68 Others: Office of the Auditor-General & 2 others (Interested Parties), Petition No. E001 of 2026, which expressly provided, in relation to public bodies falling within the National Government and the Public Service Commission, that external counsel be engaged only with the express and formal approval of the Attorney General. ((Annexed herewith and marked "RM-03" is a true copy of the Attorney- General circular REF: AG/CONF/4/159/60 Vol. 1, dated 11th September 2026).
(3) THAT the Attorney-General in circular REF: AG/CONF/4/159/60 Vol. 1, dated 11th September 2026 provided that following the orders issued by the Court in Gikenyi B & 6 others -vs- Council of Governors & 68 Others; Office of the Auditor-General & 2 others (Interested Parties). Petition No. E001 of 2026, no ministry. State Department or State Corporation shall initiate, procure, instruct, renew, extend or continue the engagement of external counsel in circumstances requiring the approval of the Attorney General without first obtaining the requisite formal approval of the Attorney General.
(4)THAT hence the application dated 1st September 2026 seeking to lift the conservatory orders issued herein and all the pleadings by the said firm are irregular. misplaced, and null and void ab initio.
Response
5. The law firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP filed response to the application vide affidavit dated 9th September 2026 of Dr. Jotham Okome Arwa, an advocate of the High Court of Kenya, practicing as such under the firm, name and style of RACHIER & AMOLLO LLP and seized of this matter on behalf of the Petitioners/Applicants, as follows:
1) THAT he was the Advocate having conduct of this matter on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Respondents/Applicants as well as the Interested Party herein and, by virtue of his conduct thereof, he was conversant with the facts and circumstances giving rise to the present Application and competent to swear this Affidavit.
2) THAT it is true that Robbai had previously misled the board of directors of the 2nd Respondent into irregularly and illegally instructing her to represent the 1st & 2nd Respondent in these proceedings.
3) THAT under Order 9 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules, a party who had previously appointed an advocate to represent it in court has the power to appoint another advocate to take over the conduct of those proceedings on its behalf from the previous advocate by filing a Notice of Change of Advocates.
4) THAT where a Notice of Change of Advocates is filed, the previous advocate CEASES IMMEDIATELY to represent that party in court and loses the AUTHORITY to file any pleading in court on behalf of that party.
5) THAT the 2nd Respondent subsequently instructed Rachier and Amollo LLP to TAKE OVER the conduct of the proceedings from Ms. Robbai on behalf of the 1st & 2nd Respondent whereupon the said firm filed a Notice of Change of Advocates. Annexed hereto and marked “JOA – 01” is a copy of the Instructions Letter.
6) THAT it follows therefore that Ms. Robbai CEASED to be an advocate for the 1st and 2nd Respondents and also that Rachier and Amollo LLP are the ONLY Advocates who are presently on record LEGALLY for the 1st & 2nd Respondent.
7) THAT since Ms. Robbai is not on record officially for 1st and 2nd Respondent, she has no right or authority to file ANY PLEADING on behalf of the 1st & 2nd Respondents, and consequently that application should be dismissed.
8) THAT the board of directors of a Government Owned Enterprise does not have the power in law to appoint an advocate to represent the Enterprise in court.
9) THAT unlike the board of directors of other companies that derive their mandates from the Memorandum and Articles of Association of such companies (which normally have the power to do virtually everything as long as it is permitted under its constitutive documents), the mandate of a board of directors of a Government Owned Enterprise is VERY NARROWLY CIRCUMSCRIBED. The board of directors of a Government Owned Enterprise can only discharge the SPECIFIC MANDATES outlined in section 18 of the Government Owned Enterprises Act and NO OTHER.
10) THAT " Appointing Advocates to represent the Government Owned Enterprise in court " is not included as part of the mandate of the board in section 18 aforesaid. It follows logically therefore that that is a mandate that belong EXCLUSIVELY to the management of the Enterprise (and NOT the board).
11) THAT section 22(6)(a) of the Government Owned Enterprises Act provides that it is the CEO of a government owned enterprise who is responsible for the "day to day management " of the enterprise and NOT the board.
12) THAT appointment of advocates to represent the enterprise in court is part of the "day to day management" of the enterprise, and is therefore the EXCLUSIVE MANDATE of the CEO.
13) THAT the CEO therefore properly, legally and procedurally appointed us to represent the 1st and 2nd Respondent.
14) THAT the CEO is aware that it is Ms. Robbai who instigated the institution of these proceedings and thereafter furnished the petitioners with all the information and materials that have been produced herein. That the CEO is also aware that Robbai is working very closely with the petitioners and intends to illegally and irregularly frustrate and defeat the interests of the 1st and 2nd Respondents in these proceedings by supporting the petitioner's case.
15) THAT that is the reason why the CEO appointed an independent firm of advocates to represent the 1st and 2nd Respondents in these proceedings.
16) THAT for the foregoing reasons, it is follows that the Application dated 8th September, 2026 by Robai Musilivi Advocate is misplaced and ill advised and the same ought to be struck out with costs.
Decision
6. The parties filed written submissions which the court perused and considered.
7. Issue for determination
a) Whether the law firm of Rachier &Amollo LLP, legal representative of the 1st and 2nd respondents, is lawful.
b) Whether the applicant is entitled to the orders sought
The law
8. Order 9 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules,
9. Sections 7 and 34, sections 3A & 63 (e) of the Civil Procedure Act,
10. Sections 11, 12, and 79 of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012.
11. The Government Owned Enterprises Act
Whether the law firm of Rachier &Amollo LLP, legal representative of the 1st and 2nd respondents, is lawful.
12. The facts are as outlined above. The applicant is the 1st and 2nd respondents, and they seek an order that –
‘THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to strike out the Memorandum of Appearance dated 1" September 2026, the Grounds of Opposition, the Notice of Motion, and all pleadings or documents filed by the firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP purporting to act for or represent the 1" Respondent (The Board of Directors) and the 2nd Respondent (National Oil Corporation of Kenya Limited).
THAT the firm of M/S Rachier & Amollo LLP be barred and restrained from acting, appearing, or taking any steps in these proceedings on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Respondents.’
13. On 1st September 2026, the interested party appointed the law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP to represent him in the matter and further filed a notice of change alleging to have been appointed to represent the 1st and 2nd respondents.
14. The law firm then proceeded to file grounds of opposition of even date of 1st September 2026 on behalf of the 1st and 2nd respondents and the interested party.
15. Further, the law firm filed an application dated 1st September 2026 purporting to act for the respondents and sought to discharge the conservatory orders issued by the duty judge, Justice Abuodha, on 25th August 2026 suspending extension of the acting capacity as CEO of the interested party. The interested party swore an affidavit stating he was authorised to support the application by the respondents.
16. The law firm in response to the instant application, annexed a letter dated 1st September 2026 authored by the interested party to it as follows-
‘The National Oil Corporation of Kenya Limited (the Corporation) and its Board of Directors have been sued in NAIROBI EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT PETITION NO. E256 OF. 2026 - MESHACK GWARO -V- THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, NATIONAL OIL CORPORATION OF KENYA & 3 OTHERS wherein certain adverse orders have been issued against the Corporation. The matter is coming up in court tomorrow, 2nd September 2026. The Corporation therefore instructs you to immediately take over the conduct of the said case and protect its interests. Keep us posted on all developments relating to that matter.’’
17. The foregoing is the background of the instant application of which the respondents deny having instructed the law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP to represent them in the proceedings and relying on the board resolution that the corporation secretary was to act for them.
18. There are two appointments before the court. One by the 1st respondent, the board of directors of the 2nd respondent, vide a board resolution of 31st August 2026 appointing the Corporation Secretary to represent the respondents in the suit. A subsequent appointment by the interested party dated 1st September appointing the law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP to represent the respondents, where a notice of change of advocates was filed on the same date of 1st September 2026.
19. The law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP urged that the board is not like that of a company. Counsel for the firm contended as follows:-‘ THAT unlike the board of directors of other companies that derive their mandates from the Memorandum and Articles of Association of such companies (which normally have the power to do virtually everything as long as it is permitted under its constitutive documents), the mandate of a board of directors of a Government Owned Enterprise is VERY NARROWLY CIRCUMSCRIBED. The board of directors of a Government Owned Enterprise can only discharge the specific mandates outlined in section 18 of the government owned enterprises act and no other.
20. The law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP submitted that- ‘’appointing Advocates to represent the Government Owned Enterprise in court " is not included as part of the mandate of the board in section 18 aforesaid. It follows logically therefore that that is a mandate that belong EXCLUSIVELY to the management of the Enterprise (and NOT the board). THAT section 22(6)(a) of the Government Owned Enterprises Act provides that it is the CEO of a government owned enterprise who is responsible for the "day to day management " of the enterprise and NOT the board.’
21. Section 18 of the Government Owned Enterprises Act provides for the role of the Board as follows-
‘The Board of a Government Owned Enterprise shall be responsible for—
(a)the appointment and removal of the Chief Executive Officer;
(b)the determination of the terms and conditions of employment of the Government Owned Enterprise staff, taking into consideration all relevant factors, including industry dynamics and the sustainability of the Government Owned Enterprise, subject to such guidelines as the Cabinet Secretary may issue;
(c)setting of the Government Owned Enterprise strategic direction and approval of strategic plans;
(d)the approval of annual budgets and the related funding for a Government Owned Enterprise level;
(e)setting key performance indicators for the Chief Executive Officer and top-level management;
(f)the establishment of risk governance and risk management systems and processes, including setting the risk appetite for the business of the Government Owned Enterprise, taking into consideration shareholder risk preference;
(g)establishing and overseeing internal control systems and their continuous testing for efficiency and effectiveness;
(h)performance evaluation of the Chief Executive Officer and top-level management;(i)entering into performance contracts with the National Treasury;
(j)putting in place systems and processes to ensure compliance with all legal and regulatory requirements and frameworks;
(k)putting in place succession management framework and business continuity plan comprising—
(i)nomination processes to identify candidates for consideration by the Cabinet Secretary for appointment to the Board; and
(ii)succession plans for the Chief Executive Officer and other critical positions within management ranks of the Government Owned Enterprise; and
(l)establishment and implementation of a Board self-evaluation system.’
22. Board meetings are provided for in section 19 of the Act as follows –
‘19. Board meetings
(1)The Board of a Government Owned Enterprise shall meet—(a)at least once in every three months; and(b)at other times that the Board considers necessary for the efficient management of the business and affairs of the Government Owned Enterprise.’
23. Section 22 provides for the role of the Chief Executive Officer of the 2nd Respondent as follows-
‘6)A Chief Executive Officer shall—
(a)be responsible to the Board of the Government Owned Enterprise for the day-to-day management of the affairs of the Government Owned Enterprise; and
(b)perform such other functions as the Board may direct.’’
24. The petitioner submitted –in Nang'ole v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company, Petition E138 of 2022 [2023] KEELRC 2716 (KLR), the Court recognised the Board of Directors as the policy-making body of a company or State Corporation responsible for providing strategic direction. It requires no gainsaying that the Board of Directors is the policymaking body of a company or State Corporation such as the Respondent and provides the strategic direction. Its decisions ought to be available for perusal and verifiable by courts of law whenever they are relied upon by parties.
25. Conversely, respondent submitted that Nang’ole v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company, Petition E138 of 2022 [2023] KEELRC 2716 (KLR), does not establish that the Board of a Government Owned Enterprise has an exclusive statutory power to appoint advocates to represent the Enterprise. The question must be determined by the legal framework applicable to the particular entity and the authority vested in the person who issued the instructions. In the present case, that framework is the Government Owned Enterprises Act, 2025, and the Applicant has not demonstrated any provision therein that invalidates the instructions issued by the Acting Chief Executive Officer.
26. The court finds it is a no-brainer that the CEO of the 2nd respondent is an appointee of the Board and may be directed by the Board under section 22 of the Government Owned Enterprises Act. Section 19 of the same Act provides-
‘b)at other times that the Board considers necessary for the efficient management of the business and affairs of the Government Owned Enterprise’
27. I find the instant petition challenging the acting tenure of the interested party is an issue under the affairs of the 1st respondent. The acting CEO (as he then was) is a subordinate of the Board and cannot overturn a resolution of the Board. I am persuaded by the authority in Nang'ole v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company, Petition E138 of 2022 [2023] KEELRC 2716 (KLR), where the Court recognised the Board of Directors as the policy-making body of a company or State Corporation responsible for providing strategic direction-
"It requires no gainsaying that the board of directors is the policymaking body of a company or state corporation such as the Respondent and provides the strategic direction. Its decisions ought to be available for perusal and verifiable by courts of law whenever they are relied upon by parties."
28. The Government Owned Enterprises Act defines A “Government Owned Enterprise” as a company which—
‘(a)is a legal person under the ownership and control of the national government;
(b)the national government or national government entity is a shareholder with more than fifty percent of the share capital of the company;
(c)has been assigned financial and operational powers to carry on a business activity;
(d)as its main business, supplies goods or services in accordance with ordinary commercial principles; and
(e)is financed wholly or substantially from sources that do not require annual appropriation by National Assembly, or imposition of a tax, levy or other charge under legislation.’
29. The 1st respondent's role under section 18 of the Government Owned Enterprises Act included –
‘setting of the Government Owned Enterprise strategic direction and approval of strategic plans;’’
30. The decision in Nang'ole v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company recognised the strategic direction as one of the functions of the board.
31. The Government Owned Enterprises Act has recognised the 2nd respondent as a company. I find the purported letter of 1st September 2026 by the interested party purporting to overturn the decision of the Board as irregular, null and void. The Board has the mandate under section 19 of the Government Owned Enterprises Act to sit and consider any agenda necessary for the efficient management of the business and affairs of the Government Owned Enterprise. The Board did that, faced with a suit on the status of the employment of the interested party, and appointed its corporation secretary to represent in the suit vide a resolution. The decision was legal.
Disposition
32. In the upshot, the court holds that the appointment by the interested party of the law firm of Rachier Amollo LLP, vide letter of 1st September 2026, is illegal and void. The notice of change of advocates and all pleadings filed by the law firm on the alleged behalf of the 1st and 2nd respondents are deemed to have been filed without the instructions of counsel and are expunged from the record. The board resolution appointing the corporation secretary to represent the 1st and 2nd respondents in the suit is upheld.
33. Costs of the application to the applicant in the cause.
34. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
COURT ASSISTANT: OTIENO
PETITIONER- BUNDI
RESPONDENT- ROBAI
INTERESTED PARTY- AMIMO