REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E079 OF 2025
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
GOLDEN LION INTERNATIONAL LIMITED ……………………………..…… APPELLANT
VERSUS
RICHARD KIPKEMOI KORIR ……………………………………..……… 1ST RESPONDENT
KENNETH KIMUTAI TONUI ……………………………………………… 2ND RESPONDENT
NGETICH DOMINIC …………………………………..…………………… 3RD RESPONDENT
REUBEN CHERUIYOT SIGEI ……………………………………..……… 4TH RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the Judgment of Hon. L. B. Koech (Mrs.), Principal Magistrate, delivered on 30th October, 2023 at the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Nairobi, Milimani Commercial Courts, in CMELRC No. E1443 of 2021: Richard Kipkemoi Korir & 3 Others v Golden Lion International Limited)
JUDGMENT
This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 18th March, 2025 filed out of time with the leave of this court granted on 26th February, 2025. It arises from a judgment delivered on 30th October, 2023 in Milimani CMELRC No. E1443 of 2021.
The Respondents, drivers and a turn boy in the Appellant’s transport department, were declared redundant on 26th June, 2019. The trial court found the redundancy lawful and fair, declined compensation but awarded each of them severance pay, in a total of Kshs.495,248.50 with costs and interest.
The appeal comes out as thus;
1. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in unprocedurally and irregularly altering, varying, overturning and unusual toppling of a judgment of court issued on 30th October 2023 in the presence of all parties in very unclear circumstances.
2. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by reaching a wrong decision in Law and fact contrary to the weight of evidence before her.
3. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in Law and fact in failing to consider the fact that the claimants both in their oral evidence and submissions, admitted of remittance & payment of NSSF, PAYE & NHIF as indicated in the Respondent’s / claimants list of documents, their pay slips and by dint of Section 35 (6) (a) & (d), the awarding of the severance pay was erroneous, wrong and in contravention with Employment Act.
4. THAT the Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact in failing to consider and mis-appreciating the law, evidence, pleadings and submissions by the Appellant and the fact that severance pay could not be awarded to the Respondent / claimants as they were members of a pension scheme and the appellant was remitting the NSSF deductions thereby the honourable trial magistrate arrived at a wrong conclusion of Law without providing adequate reasons.
5. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in Law and practice in failing to consider all the surrounding facts, taking judicial notice and events that occurred and necessitated the termination of the Respondents / Claimants and the evidence presented during trial and in effect the learned trial magistrate reached at the wrong decision.
6. THAT the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in Law and in fact by misdirecting herself and acting on a wrong principal of Law in determining the case before her and in result reached an irregular manifestly exaggerated and an exorbitant award / compensation which is biased, unjust and an inconsistent decision.
The Appellant prays for orders thus;
a) This Appeal be allowed and the Learned Trial Magistrate’s judgment and Order granted on 30th October 2023 be set aside and quashed and be substituted by this Honourable Court’s Orders.
b) This Honourable Court do adjudicate and determine the appeal and arrive at a just Judgment in light of the evidence on record.
c) That the costs of this Appeal and proceedings be awarded to the Appellants.
It is the Appellant’s case and submission that the judgment pronounced virtually on 30th October, 2023 dismissed the claim with costs. Some two months later, it says, a decree issued showing that the Respondents had succeeded, without notice to either party. The Appellant further submits that the Respondents themselves first lodged an appeal in ELRC Appeal No. E232 of 2023, which they later withdrew. It calls the change an intentional alteration and says it has complained to the Office of the Judiciary Ombudsman. It invites this court, under Article 165 (6) and (7) of the Constitution to call for the virtual recording and order a fresh hearing.
On the merits, the Appellant submits that the Respondents were paid salary, leave, house allowance and notice pay, and that PAYE, NSSF and NHIF were remitted for them. It says it also paid each of them fifteen days’ salary at the end of every year as service pay, as shown in its payroll muster rolls.
Severance pay on top of this, it submits, amounts to thirty days’ pay for each year of service and is double compensation, the more so where the redundancy was itself found lawful and fair.
The Respondents’ case and submission is that no evidence has been placed before this court of any alteration of the judgment. Allegations of procedural impropriety must be strictly proved, and the record shows a judgment duly delivered. They further submit that the trial court considered the evidence of both sides, that severance pay is a statutory entitlement on redundancy which membership of the NSSF does not bar, and that service pay is not severance pay. They pray that the appeal be dismissed with costs.
After a considered look and scrutiny of the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;
1. Whether the judgment of the trial court was irregularly altered after its delivery on 30th October, 2023.
2. Whether the trial court erred in awarding the Respondents severance pay.
3. Whether the sums awarded are justified in the circumstances.
4. Who should bear the costs of the appeal.
This being a first appeal, this court is under a duty to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence on record and to draw its own conclusions, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses testify. This is the pronouncement in the celebrated authority of Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others [1968] EA 123.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the judgment of the trial court was irregularly altered after its delivery on 30th October, 2023. This complaint is grave. It is, in substance, that a judicial officer pronounced one judgment and signed another. Such a charge calls for cogent proof. However, there is none on this record. The Record of Appeal, compiled by the Appellant itself, carries one judgment only. It is signed, dated 30th October, 2023 and certified a true copy of the original on 10th December, 2025. The certified proceedings carry no note of a dismissal. The judgment records the Appellant as absent at delivery, and the court then granted a thirty days’ stay of execution. This order would serve no purpose on a claim that had been dismissed.
No affidavit was filed on what was pronounced. No recording or transcript is before this court and no application was made to adduce additional evidence. What counsel says in written submissions is not evidence. The Appellant’s letter of 10th January, 2024 describes the judgment as one of dismissal. That shows the Appellant’s understanding of events. It does not prove them. The judgment on record is, moreover, consistent within itself, its reasoning running from a lawful redundancy to an award of severance pay and no more.
The supervisory jurisdiction now invoked was not moved by any application. The Appellant elected to come by way of appeal. The complaint against the judicial officer lies before the body mandated to inquire into it, where the Appellant says it already is. Ground 1 therefore fails.
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in awarding the Respondents severance pay. The finding that the redundancy was lawful and fair went in the Appellant’s favour and there is no cross-appeal. That finding stands, and ground 5, which goes to the reason for the termination, takes the appeal no further. Section 40 (1) (g) of the Employment Act, 2007 requires an employer to pay an employee declared redundant severance pay of not less than fifteen days’ pay for each completed year of service. It is a condition of a lawful redundancy, not a discretionary award.
Section 35 (6) of the Act, on which the Appellant relies, excludes members of the National Social Security Fund or of a pension scheme from service pay under section 35 (5). It says nothing of severance pay. Section 40 carries no such exclusion. Remittance of NSSF, PAYE and NHIF is therefore no answer to the claim. Grounds 3 and 4 fail.
The muster rolls show an annual item described as service pay. It was, however, paid during the subsistence of the employment and as part of the Respondents’ yearly earnings. Severance pay does not accrue until redundancy and cannot be discharged in advance by a payment made each year under another name and for another purpose. The Appellant did not plead payment of severance or any set-off. Its pleaded case was that the Respondents were not entitled to severance pay at all. Neither the termination letters nor the final pay slips for June, 2019 offer severance pay. Its witness put the matter beyond doubt. In cross-examination Mr. Mutinda stated, they were not paid severance pay… The pay-slip does not indicate severance pay. In re-examination he added, we were not to pay them severance after we paid service pay.
An employer who elects to pay a benefit that the law did not oblige it to pay cannot later rename it to meet one that the law does. The trial court was right to hold that service pay is not severance pay. Ground 2 fails.
The 3rd issue for determination is whether the sums awarded are justified in the circumstances. The Appellant’s submissions on section 49 of the Act and on twelve months’ compensation do not arise. No compensation was awarded. Severance pay is a matter of computation, and the trial court applied the statutory formula to salaries that were not in dispute and to years of service, 8, 9, 4 and 9, that accord with the pleaded dates of employment.
The computation nonetheless bears an arithmetic error. For the 4th Respondent, Kshs.33,544 x 15/30 x 9 years is Kshs.150,948.00, not Kshs.159,948.00 as entered. The award is overstated by Kshs.9,000.00 and is therefore so adjusted.
For the 1st Respondent, Kshs.35,221 x 15/30 x 8 years is Kshs.140,884.00 against Kshs.140,844.00 entered. There is no cross-appeal and that figure is left undisturbed. Ground 6 succeeds to this limited extent only.
On the 4th issue, costs. Costs are in the discretion of the court. The appeal has substantially failed and has succeeded only on a slip of computation. However, the costs of the appeal are rightly, in the entire circumstances awarded to the Respondent.
I therefore allow the appeal in part and order as follows;
(i) The severance pay awarded to the 4th Respondent be and is hereby reduced from Kshs.159,948.00 to Kshs.150,948.00.
(ii) The appeal is otherwise dismissed and the judgment of the trial court delivered on 30th October, 2023 in CMELRC No. E1443 of 2021 is upheld.
(iii) The award of the trial court shall now read thus;
1st Respondent – severance pay……………………………………….Kshs.140,844.00
2nd Respondent – severance pay………………………………………Kshs.158,494.50
3rd Respondent – severance pay……………………………………….Kshs.35,962.00
4th Respondent – severance pay……………………………………….Kshs.150,948.00
TOTAL………………………………………………………………..Kshs.486,248.50
(iv) The orders of the trial court on costs of the suit and on interest stand and remain undisturbed.
(v) The costs of this Appeal shall be borne by the Appellant.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Mwangi instructed by M. P. Mwangi & Company Advocates for the Appellant.
2. Miss Malombo instructed by Charles Gomba & Company Advocates for the Respondents.