Employment law

Gogong v Teachers Service Commission [2026] KEELRC 14970 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Constitutional Petition E155 of 2025
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Petitioner was a teacher employed by the Respondent. Aggrieved by the employer's administrative actions, the Petitioner alleged a violation of his constitutional rights in a Petition dated 8th August 2025 and sought the following relief-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The Petitioner identified the following issues for determination in his submissions dated 3rd September 2026:

Paragraph 25 →

Reasoning passage

The petitioner has set out with reasonable precision his complaints, the provisions of the Constitution said to be infringed and the manner of infringement. I find no alternative mechanisms for the resolution of the allegations have been pleaded as stated by the Court of Appeal in Speaker of the National Assembly v Karume [1992] KECA 42 (KLR) that – ‘where there is a clear procedure for the redress of any particular grievance…

Paragraph 36 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E155 OF 2025

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010 ARTICLES 10, 22, 23 (1) & (3),

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE CONTRAVENTION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS AS ENSHRINED UNDER ARTICLES 10,19, 20, 28, 33, 47, 48 & 236 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

AND

IN THE MATIER OF SECTION 11 OF THE TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION ACT 2012

AND

IN THE MATTER OF RULE 79(1), 83 (1), (2), (3) AND 120(4) OF THE TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION CODE OF REGULATION

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE ENFORCEMENT OF RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS UNDER CHAPTER FOUR ARTICLES 22 AND

23(1) AND (3) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA

BETWEEN

HOSEA LOROT GOGONG ……………….………………………………......................................... PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

TEACHERS SERVICE COMMISSION……….……………………..….…………………………..RESPONDENT

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. The Petitioner was a teacher employed by the Respondent. Aggrieved by the employer's administrative actions, the Petitioner alleged a violation of his constitutional rights in a Petition dated 8th August 2025 and sought the following relief-

a) A Declaration that the Respondent has violated the Petitioner's rights under Articles 27, 28, 41 and 47 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

b) A Declaration that the Respondent's failure and/or refusal to confirm the Petitioner as a substantive Headteacher, despite having served in that capacity for a period exceeding six (6) years, is unlawful, unreasonable, discriminatory, and in contravention of the principles of fair labour practices and administrative justice.

c) An order of Mandamus compelling the Respondent to forthwith confirm the Petitioner as a substantive Headteacher and to effect his promotion from Job Group C2 to Job Group C5 or such other commensurate grade with all attendant benefits.

d) An order of Mandamus compelling the Respondent to compute and pay to the Petitioner all salary arrears, allowances and entitlements accruing to the position of Headteacher from the date the Petitioner first undertook acting responsibilities to the date of compliance with this Order.

e) An Order directing the Respondent to consider the Petitioner for further promotion in line with his academic qualifications, length of service, performance record, and administrative experience.

f) General damages for the psychological suffering, reputational harm and professional frustration suffered by the Petitioner as a result of the Respondent's inaction.

g) Interest on (d) and (f) above at court rates from the date of accrual until payment in full.

h) Costs of this Petition.

2. The Petition was filed alongside the Petitioner’s Supporting Affidavit sworn on 8th August 2025, with the bundle of documents in support of the Petition attached.

3. In response to the Petition, the Respondent filed a Preliminary Objection dated 4th February 2026; and a Replying Affidavit sworn by ANTONINA LENTOIJONI on 4th February 2026.

4. To counter the responses, the Petitioner filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 4th July 2026.

The Petitioner’s case in summary

5. The Petitioner’s case is that he is a duly trained and registered teacher under Registration Number TSC/502523 issued by the Respondent, and that he has served in several administrative positions. The Petitioner avers that vide a letter dated 27th January 2011, the Respondent appointed him as Deputy Headteacher at Koputiro Primary School, where he served between February 2011 and 2012. Following a successful application for promotion, the Respondent vide a letter dated 1st July 2013 appointed the Petitioner as Headteacher of Kalapata Primary School where he served from 2013 to July 2015. The appointment as Headteacher was confirmed with effect from 29th December 2013.

6. It is stated that on 28th August 2014, with a view to advancing himself academically and in pursuit of professional growth, the Petitioner applied for and was granted study leave vide a letter dated 15th July 2015 to undertake a Masters (MA) in Kiswahili at Laikipia University for a period of two years from 1st August 2015 to 31st July 2017. Upon conclusion of his studies, he resumed duty in November 2017 and was posted to Kakuma Arid Zone Primary School as a teacher with the said deployment being termed as temporary. In 2018, the Petitioner states that he was transferred to Lochwaakwaan Primary School as Acting Headteacher, a position the Respondent again communicated would be temporary. In 2020, he was posted to Lomokamar Primary School in the same capacity, and then later as Acting Headteacher at Nariamawoi Primary School.

7. The Petitioner’s grievance is that he has served as Acting Headteacher across three different institutions for an uninterrupted period of six (6) years, yet the Respondent has failed, refused, and/or neglected to confirm him into a substantive Headteacher position. As Acting Headteacher, he is remunerated at the level of a classroom teacher, without recognition or remuneration commensurate with his administrative responsibilities and long-standing service. The Petitioner states that he appeared, on 14th December 2020, before a panel convened in Eldoret by the Respondent for an interview for the Head Teacher position but he heard nothing back. He further states that he has written several letters to the Respondent highlighting the prolonged acting status and stagnation in career progression, but has only received one response through a letter dated 29th September 2020 where the Respondent claimed that he was not captured as an administrator as the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) was already in effect by the time he resumed duty post-study leave.

8. It is the Petitioner’s case that he is deserving of appointment to the substantive Headteacher position, as he has increased school enrolment, for instance from 12 to over 200 learners at Lochwaakwaan Primary School; he has facilitated the registration of three (3) previously unregistered public primary schools, i.e. Lochwaakwaan, Lomokamar, and Kalapata Primary Schools; he is presently engaged in securing the registration of a fourth institution, namely Nariamawoi Primary School, within his current station of deployment; he has undertaken the application for and procurement of Integrated Personnel Payroll Database (IPPD) codes; he has secured Free Primary Education (FPE) funds; he has lobbied for and secured additional TSC teacher postings; and he has drafted and submitted proposals that led to infrastructure development. He states that he has also steered learners to excellence in co-curricular activities, including participation in competitions up to the provincial level. All his achievements have been made despite extremely challenging conditions, including harsh geographical terrain, prevailing insecurity, inadequate communication infrastructure, and widespread poverty.

9. The Petitioner complains that several junior teachers, including individuals who he previously supervised in his capacity as Headteacher, have since been elevated to Job Group C5, whereas he remains stagnated in Job Group C2, a disparity that has occasioned public humiliation, professional marginalization and considerable personal distress. This is especially so as the Petitioner is not being paid any acting allowance, special duty allowance or other remuneration commensurate with his duties.

Respondent’s case in brief

10. The Respondent opposes the Petition for lack of specificity and particularity, thereby failing to meet the test of constitutional pleadings espoused in the Anarita Karimi vs. Republic (No.1) (1979) 1 KLR 15 and Mumo Matemu vs. Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance, Civil Appeal No.290 of 2012 (2013) eKLR cases. Additionally, they invoke the doctrine of Constitutional avoidance, stating that the Petition does not raise any cause of action anchored in the Constitution, with the subject matter pertaining to contractual grievances within the ambit of statutory law, specifically the Employment Act. The Respondent also prays for dismissal on the basis that the Petition is time-barred and contravenes Section 89 of the Employment Act, as the cause of action accrued in the year 2017.

11. In response to the substantive issues raised in the Petition, the Respondent avers that the Petitioner has come to Court with unclean hands, and is guilty of material non-disclosure and deliberate distortion of facts with the intention to mislead the Court, since he has withheld from the Court the fact that at the material time that he was deployed as a Headteacher, the position of Headteacher was not a substantive post with compensating remuneration but a deployment position where any teacher could be deployed to serve, subject to satisfactory performance.

12. The Respondent states that it is established under Article 237 (1) of the Constitution and some of its functions are to register trained teachers, to recruit and employ trained teachers, to assign teachers in its service to teach in various public schools; to promote and transfer teachers; to exercise disciplinary control over teachers; and to terminate the employment of teachers. The mandate of the Respondent is operationalized under Section 11 of the Teachers Service Commission Act Cap 212 of the Laws of Kenya. They further admit that they are bound by the national values and principles of governance under Article 10 of the Constitution and the values and principles of public service under Article 232 of the Constitution.

13. The Respondent contextualizes the dispute between them and the Petitioner by stating that since the inception of the Respondent Commission in 1967 up to 30th June 2017 when the first Collective Bargaining Agreement was signed between it and teacher unions, all administrative positions in the teaching service specifically Senior Teacher, Deputy Head Teacher and Head Teacher were deployment positions. At the time, teacher's career progression in terms of grades were not informed by the positions they held, and as such, all primary school teachers could rise from Job Group G to Job Group N, which was the highest Job Group in Primary School, regardless of whether the teacher was a classroom teacher or Headteacher. They explain that teachers who were deployed as Head Teachers or Deputy Head Teacher were paid allowances for the period they served and such service was premised on performance of duty failure to which such a teacher would be deployed back to perform his/her contractual duty which is teaching.

14. Within this context, the Respondent contends that the contract that existed between the Commission and the Petitioner was that of a teacher whose core function was to carry out teaching duties. They confirm that at the time of the employment, and prior to the conversion of teacher's job grades, the Petitioner was in Job Group G which was the lowest cadre at the time. The Headship or Deputyship was a tour or additional duty and responsibility that attracted an allowance but was conditional on performance.

15. After the execution of the first CBA between the Respondent and the teachers’ unions on 1st July 2017, there was a re-calibration of teachers grades to conform to the job worth of every teacher. The Respondent then formulated the Policy on Appointment and Deployment of Institutional Administrators, 2017, to manage the processes of placing teachers into positions of administration at the respective learning institutions. The result of executing the CBA and enacting the Policy was that all administrative posts in the teaching service became substantive appointments with remuneration benefits in terms of salary. In particular, appointment to Headship attracted a special salary package in recognition of the job descriptions for the grade, which made it extremely competitive. The Commission has since applied the principles of fair competition and merit as the basis of appointment, which involves advertisement of the vacant positions through various modes; transparent shortlisting of candidates; interviews and

selection based on available vacancies and budgetary provisions. The Respondent contends that the 2017 Policy was not in existence when the Petitioner’s purported cause of action accrued.

16. While they admit that the Petitioner, vide a letter dated 27ᵗʰ January 2011 was directed to serve as a Deputy Head teacher Koputiro Primary School, and as Headteacher, Kalapata Primary School vide a letter dated 1ˢᵗ July 2013, they emphasize that the positions were deployments, rather than promotions or substantive appointments. There was no change in the Petitioner's remuneration to signify any promotion as alleged. They stress that the deployments were made prior to the execution of the 2017 CBA that brought in force the Policy on Appointment and Deployment of Institutional Administrators, 2017. The policy position obtaining at the time was that the positions were deployment positions which only attracted a token benefit namely responsibility allowance.

17. Being aware of the policy position at the time, the Petitioner vide his letter dated 18th April 2014 applied for promotion from Job Group G (the lowest job grade in the teaching service at the time) to Job Group K.

18. The Respondent agrees that the Petitioner was granted study leave with effect from 1st August 2015 to 31st July 2017, whereupon the Respondent deployed an alternative teacher to fill in the void left by the Petitioner, there being no automatic administrative security for the position held in light of the absence of Policy criteria at the time. As such, according to the Respondent, the Petitioner was obligated to apply to the Commission for posting upon expiry of the study leave pursuant to the provisions of Regulation 124(1) of the Code of Regulations for Teachers. The Respondent avers that teachers previously deployed to undertake administrative roles who were not substantively appointed at the time of policy change, were obligated to re-apply and satisfy the policy position obtaining at the time.

19. The Respondent concedes that after the Petitioner returned from study leave, he was directed to report to the TSC County Director, Turkana County for posting. The Petitioner was subsequently posted to Kakuma Arid Zone Primary School vide the letter dated 18th October 2017. Following the implementation of the CBA 2017, all teachers not holding administrative Positions as at 1st July 2017, including the Petitioner, were designated as assistant teachers for purposes of computing the teacher's workload and deployed as such. The posting of the Petitioner as a classroom teacher therefore did not in any way vary his term of employment, since his previous Head Teacher position was not substantive at the time the Petitioner proceeded for study leave.

20. After the 2017 CBA and the Respondent’s 2017 Policy were adopted, the Commission put in force the Career Progression Guidelines for Teaches (CPG), 2018 that replaced the Schemes of Service for Teachers, and formulated a Manual for implementation of the job evaluation recommendations. In the implementation of the new policy direction as herein above, the Commission undertook a conversion exercise of the teaches job grades to put each teacher in the right job group/grade. Consequently, the Commission converted the Petitioners grade, appointing him as Primary Teacher II, Job Grade B5 with effect from 1st July 2017. In accordance with the Respondent’s Career Progression Guidelines, the Petitioner's Grade B5 does not make him eligible to be substantively appointed to the position for Headteacher.

21. Since the position of an institutional head such as a Principal or Headteacher had become substantive, meaning that one had to apply and be competitively recruited, the consequence was that failure to perform would lead to dismissal and not re-deployment to perform normal teaching/classroom roles. However, noting the biting shortage of teachers in the region the Petitioner is serving, the Commission vide the letter dated 12ᵗʰ September 2018 issued the Petitioner with a letter for temporary deployment as acting Headteacher for Lochwaakwaan Primary School.

22. The Respondent states that in appreciating the implementation and effect of the Career Progression Guidelines for Teachers, it promoted the Petitioner under the common establishment (common-cadre) promotions to the next grade being lob Grade C1. Pursuant to the provisions of the CPG, any further promotions for the Petitioner, i.e from Grade C1 onwards are subject to competition, merit and availability of budgetary allocation by the National Treasury. They state that the Petitioner is aware of the Guidelines and applied for promotion to the next grade being Job Grade C2, where he emerged successful after undergoing competitive interview. The Petitioner was consequently appointed as Senior Teacher II Job Grade C2. Accordingly, it is abundantly clear that the Respondents was legally mandated to deploy the Petitioner in such capacity as the Commission deemed appropriate to safeguard the learners' right to free and compulsory basic education and promote the children’s best interest.

23. The Respondent therefore denies violating the Petitioner’s rights or acting in an unlawful manner and urges the Court to refrain from interfering with the Constitutional and statutory duty of the employer, and the contract between the parties.

DETERMINATION

24. Following directions by the Court that it would determine the Petition through written submissions, both parties filed.

Issues for determination

25. The Petitioner identified the following issues for determination in his submissions dated 3rd September 2026:

i. Whether the Respondent's failure to confirm the Petitioner to a substantive position as a head-teacher violated Articles 10,19,20,27 ,28,41,47 and 236 of the Constitution of Kenya.

ii. Whether the Respondent's failure to confirm the Petitioner to a substantive position as a head-teacher violated Section 11(d) (e) of the Teachers Service Commission Act and Regulations 79(1), 83(1) (2) (3) and 119(1) of the Teachers Service Code of Regulations for teachers, 2015.

iii. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the orders/reliefs sought under the Petition.

26. Conversely, in their submissions dated 7th August 2026, the Respondent distilled the following issues for determination:

i. Whether the Petition satisfies the constitutional pleading threshold.

ii. Whether the Commission acted within its constitutional and statutory mandate in posting and deploying the Petitioner following his return from study leave.

iii. Whether the Petitioner has established violation of any of the Constitutional provisions.

iv. Whether the Petition is statute-barred.

v. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.

27. The court, vide a ruling delivered on the 15th May 2026, decided that the issue of constitutional threshold and whether the claim was statute-barred would be decided on merit.

28. The court, on perusal of the pleadings and submissions by the parties, discerned the issues for determination in the petition to be-

i. Whether the Petition satisfies the constitutional pleading threshold.

ii. Whether the Petition is statute-barred.

iii. Whether the Respondent's failure to confirm the Petitioner to a substantive position as a head-teacher violated Articles 10,19,20,27 ,28,41,47 and 236 of the Constitution of Kenya.

iv. Remedies

The law

29. Articles 10,19,20,27,28,41,47 and 236 of the Constitution of Kenya.

30. Section 89 of the Employment Act-

‘89. Limitations

Notwithstanding the provisions of section 4(1) of the Limitation of Actions Act (Cap. 22), no civil action or proceedings based or arising out of this Act or a contract of service in general shall lie or be instituted unless it is commenced within three years next after the act, neglect or default complained or in the case of continuing injury or damage within twelve months next after the cessation thereof.’

31. Section 11(e) of the Teachers Service Commission Act –

‘(e)facilitate career progression and professional development for teachers in the teaching service including the appointment of head teachers and principals;’

Whether the Petition satisfies the constitutional pleading threshold.

32. The respondent raised a preliminary objection dated 4th February 2026 and raised 2 points of law-

a) The Petition lacks specificity and particularity hence does not meet the test of constitutional pleadings espoused in the Anarita Karimi vs. Republic (No.1) (1979) 1 KLR 15 and Mumo Matemu vs. Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance, Civil Appeal No.290 of 2012 (2013) eKLR cases.

b) The Petition has not raised any cause of action anchored in the Constitution. The subject matter pertains to contractual grievances within the ambits of statutory law (Employment Act) disguised as a Constitutional Petition. The court to exercise the Doctrine of Constitutional Avoidance and dismiss the Petition.

33. In support of the issues, the respondent submitted that the grievance is on the implementation of the policy on appointment and deployment of institutional administrators, the career progression guidelines and job evaluation process that led to abandoning the 2017 policy / practice of deployment of teachers to head teachers based on performance and not rank or competitive recruitment. That it was on the basis of the 2017 reforms that the petitioner was deployed as a classroom teacher post-study leave. That he had not challenged the constitutionality of the policies or the career guidelines but was aggrieved on how they affected him individually. That the petition concerns the manner in which the Commission exercised its power, which is governed by statute. The respondent it was a case of constitutional avoidance and relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in Communications Commission of Kenya and 5 others v Royal media services ltd and 5 others (2014)e KLR

34. Conversely, the petitioner denied this was a case of constitutional avoidance and the petition challenged prolonged administrative action, differential treatment, failure to implement statutory relations and failure of the respondent to accord fair administrative action and related the allegations to article 41 on fair labour rights, Article 47 on fair administrative action, Article 27 on equality and Article 236 on protection of public officers.

35. On perusal of the petition, I was persuaded it met the constitutional threshold. It was held in Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] KEHC 30 (KLR) paragraph 5

‘ c). We would, however, again stress that if a person is seeking redress from the High Court on a matter which involves a reference to the Constitution, it is important (if only to ensure that justice is done to his case) that he should set out with a reasonable degree of precision that of which he complains, the provisions said to be infringed, and the manner in which they are alleged to be infringed.’

36. The petitioner has set out with reasonable precision his complaints, the provisions of the Constitution said to be infringed and the manner of infringement. I find no alternative mechanisms for the resolution of the allegations have been pleaded as stated by the Court of Appeal in Speaker of the National Assembly v Karume [1992] KECA 42 (KLR) that – ‘where there is a clear procedure for the redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament, that procedure should be strictly followed.’

The petitioner is held to be in the right forum.

Whether the Petition is statute-barred.

37. The preliminary objection was that - The Petition herein being premised on an alleged cause of action accruing in the year 2017, the court lacks jurisdiction to entertain such cause of action for being time-barred and contrary to the provisions of Section 89 of the Employment Act.

38. On the preliminary objection, the petitioner responded that the facts had not been ascertained and required scrutiny of the court on merit to determine if he met the threshold of a constitutional petition and whether he had a valid cause of action. He stated his cause was of continuing injury, thus not time barred.

39. Section 89 of the Employment states-

‘89. Limitations

Notwithstanding the provisions of section 4(1) of the Limitation of Actions Act (Cap. 22), no civil action or proceedings based or arising out of this Act or a contract of service in general shall lie or be instituted unless it is commenced within three years next after the act, neglect or default complained or in the case of continuing injury or damage within twelve months next after the cessation thereof.’

40. The teacher/petitioner is in the employment of the respondent and has been placed on acting as Head teacher without acting allowance pay since 2018. The injury continues. I find this is a case of continuing injury.

Whether the Respondent's failure to confirm the Petitioner to a substantive position as a head-teacher violated Articles 10, 19, 20, 27, 28, 41, 47, and 236 of the Constitution of Kenya.

41. The Petitioner is a teacher employed by the Respondent. He alleges unfair labour practice arising from prolonged acting as Head Teacher and failure to be confirmed to a substantive position. The background to the grievance is that, vide a letter dated 1st July 2015, the Petitioner was appointed as Head Teacher of Kalpata Primary School and served in that position until July 2015. Previously, he served as Deputy Head Teacher from 27th January 2011.

42. The appointment as Head Teacher was confirmed with effect from 29th December 2013. (HLQ-4 is the letter of confirmation).

43. The petitioner applied and was granted study leave vide letter dated 15th July 2015 to undertake Masters – Kiswahili at Laikipia University for a period of 2 years (HLGS is the letter of study leave).

44. On completion of study leave, he resumed duty in November 2017 and was posted by the Respondent to Kakuma Arid Zone Primary School as a teacher, a deployment described as temporary. In 2018, he was transferred to Lochwaakwaan Primary School as acting Head Teacher, a position indicated as temporary by the Respondent. In 2020, he was posted to Lomokamar Primary School in the same capacity and is currently serving as acting Head Teacher at Naria Mawoi Primary School. These are 6 years of acting.

45. On 14th December 2020, the petitioner says he appeared before a panel convened by the Respondent in Eldoret for an interview. The panel heard his grievances and promised to escalate his issues, but he never received any communication. He wrote repeatedly about the prolonged acting and received only one response dated 29th September 2020, in which the Respondent claimed he was not captured as an administration officer because the CBA was already in effect when he resumed duty after study leave. He sent demand letters through his advocate and seeks substantive appointment as Head Teacher, promotion to the appropriate job group, payment of salary arrears in this position, and compensation for the prolonged period of acting, with fair treatment. (see supporting affidavit of petitioner dated 8th August 2025).

46. The deponent stated that since 1967 up to 30th June 2017, when the first CBA was signed between it and the Unions, all administrative positions in the teaching service, specifically senior teachers, Deputy Head Teacher and Head Teacher, were deployment positions. Prior to 2017, teachers' career progression in terms of grades was not informed by their positions held, and all primary school teachers could rise from job group G to N, the highest for primary school teachers, regardless of whether they were classroom teachers or Head Teachers.

47. Teachers deployed as Deputy Head Teacher or Head Teachers were paid allowances and such service was premised on performance, failing which they returned to the contractual job of teaching. That the petitioner had a contract as a teacher and was at Job Group G, which is the lowest. The letter of employment was annexed dated 16th July 2009 – confirmed on 21st April 2011. That Headship was a tour of additional duty which attracted allowance but consideration to performance.

48. In 2017, jointly with Salaries Review Commission (SRC), a comprehensive job evaluation was conducted, effective from 1st July 2017. It signed its first CBA with the Teachers Union, transforming the teaching service. The Commission formulated a policy for the appointment and deployment of institutional administration in 2017 to manage the process of placing teachers in administrative positions at learning institutions. Under the CBA, administrative positions became substantive appointments with remuneration in terms of salary. Appointments became competitive, vide advertisements.

49. That the Petitioner was aware of the practice of obtaining before 2017. He applied for promotion on 18th April 2014 from job group G to K (AL – 5). That after study leave approval, another teacher was deployed to fill the void left. On resumption, he had to apply for repositioning. (Regulation 124 (1) COA).

50. That all teachers previously deployed to administrative positions had to reapply and satisfy the policy position requirements at the time. That he was posted to Kakuma Arid 2020 Primary School.

51. In the vide letter dated 12th September 2018, he was temporarily deployed to perform the duties of Head Teacher in an acting capacity at Lodi Waa Kwan Primary School (AL -1). The deponent states that the commission converted the petitioner’s grade and appointed him as Primary Teacher II, Job Grade B5, effective 1st July 2017. The court noted this as the lowest position in primary schools for teachers and termed it the entry grade, yet he had served since 2009.

52. The deponent stated that Grade B5 does not make him eligible for substantive approval as a head teacher. The Respondent, vide letter dated 14th April 2021, informed the petitioner that he could not be re-designated as head teacher because he was on study leave and posted as a P1 Teacher after study leave. The letter also stated that he was re-deployed as head teacher on 12th September 2018 after the July 2017 CBA. The court did not understand the meaning of the words "he was re-deployed as head teacher in 2018", taking into account the Respondent's position of doing away with non-competitive appointments of head teachers.

53. The respondent states that the petitioner applied for promotion to Grade C2, was successful in a competitive interview, and was appointed as a senior teacher II C2 under a letter dated 6th July 2021. The court examined the career progression guidelines for teachers 2018 (AL – 9) and established that the promotion was competitive. It further found that the position of Head Teacher was at scale 10, was competitive, and that, to be appointed, a teacher had to have served as Deputy Head Teacher II TSC Grade 9 for a minimum of 3 years.

54. The Petitioner hinges his case on the 2017 policy, which was established, was not based on grade, and any teacher could be appointed. Indeed, he was appointed as Head Teacher in 2017, having been confirmed as a teacher in 2011.

55. The court noted at page 101 of the Career Progression Guidelines for Teacher 2018 the job group of the petitioner as at 2017 of Group H converted to CI, primary teacher I, Head teacher is CI.

56. Having analysed the facts, I make the following findings-

(1) That the Petitioner was not qualified to be Head Teacher, post 2017 CBA and new career progression guidelines. That the position is competitive and he does not qualify.

(2) That the appointment as Head Teacher previously (prior to 2017)was not competitive and was not based on grade and thus no legitimate expectation can be founded that he ought to be automatically appointed Head Teacher under the new career progression guidelines of 2018 where the position of Headmaster is based on grade progression and is competitive.

(3) The Petitioner’s contract all along was that of a teacher and not Head master, and the policy was changed under the CBA to make the Head Teacher position competitive.

57. Whether prolonged acting as Head Teacher is illegal and unconstitutional? The court has, on numerous occasions, held that prolonged acting is an illegal and unfair labour practice. The Equal Work, Equal Pay policy is violated by prolonged acting. The Respondent cannot have its cake and eat it. It alleges that the petitioner is not qualified to be Head Teacher, yet continually deploys him as acting Head Teacher. The court cannot countenance this unfair practice. The prolonged acting is held unconstitutional under Article 41 on fair labour practice.

58. The court finds the Petitioner is entitled to compensation for the unfair labour practice by being paid acting allowance for the entire period he has been deployed as acting Head Teacher from 12th September 2018 (AL – 7) under the 2018 career progression guidelines.

59. The court holds the payment of acting allowances in arrears to be enough to vindicate violation of his rights. The court finds that Article 232 requires competitive, merit-based promotion and thus has no authority to order promotion based on prolonged acting.

60. The Petitioner is awarded costs of the petition since his labour rights have been violated for a prolonged period.

Remedies

61. The court declares that the Respondent's act of placing the Petitioner on a prolonged period of acting as Head Teacher, since 12th September 2018, is unconstitutional, violates labour rights, and is illegal. The court grants an order of mandamus compelling the Respondent to pay the Petitioner acting allowance in arrears for the entire period he has acted as Head Teacher, that is, since 12th September 2018, within 60 months.

62. The Respondent to bear costs of the petition.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF

C/A Otieno

Petitioner- Nyakoe

Respondent – Jusa h/b Mulaku

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder