Background
Whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E449 OF 2022
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
MARGARET ADEKE EJAKAIT ……………………………………….…… CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KENYA REVENUE AUTHORITY ……………………………………… RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
This matter came to court by way of a Statement of Claim dated 24th May, 2022. It does not disclose any issue in dispute on its face.
The Respondent in a Memorandum of Response dated 26th September, 2022 denies the claim in its entirety and prays that it be dismissed with costs.
The Claimant in a Reply to Statement of Response dated 10th October, 2024 reiterates their claim and prays that it be awarded as prayed.
The Claimant’s case is that she joined the Respondent as a Graduate Trainee on 21st January, 2002 and was confirmed on permanent and pensionable terms with effect from 22nd January, 2004. As Compliance Manager, South of Nairobi Station, she reviewed the file of a taxpayer, Scripture Mission East Africa. An assessment of Kshs. 56,317,015 issued on 18th December, 2014 was revised to Kshs. 12,302,962 by a demand notice dated 11th June, 2015. The Station Manager, Mr. T. M. Okumu, signed it. She says her role was to review and forward the notices to him.
On 16th September, 2019, some four years later, the Respondent issued her a show cause letter on three charges of negligence of duty. She replied on 8th October, 2019. She was invited to a disciplinary hearing by a letter dated 18th October, 2019, the day of the hearing. She says the panel noted that her documents were uncertified and undertook to verify them. She heard nothing for eleven months. On 11th September, 2020 she was dismissed with three months’ salary in lieu of notice. Her appeal of 9th October, 2020 was dismissed on 30th October, 2020 for raising no new grounds.
The Claimant avers that the termination of her employment by the Respondent was unfair. The reasons were not valid, she did not approve the notices, and the Station Manager who did was not disciplined. She says she was denied a fair hearing and that the process took a year. She seeks twelve months’ compensation of Kshs. 3,408,000.00 being Kshs. 284,000.00 a month. She also seeks Kshs. 2,000,000.00 for discrimination, Kshs. 500,000.00 for breach of her rights and legitimate expectation, a certificate of service, interest and costs. In buttressing her case, she relies on the authority of David Wanjau Muhoro v Ol Pejeta Ranching Limited [2014] eKLR, among other authorities.
She prays as follows;
a) A declaration that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unlawful, unfair and illegal for want of substantive justification and procedural fairness.
b) A declaration that the Respondent’s action amounted to discrimination ad against the Claimant and in violation of Section 5 of the Employment Act as read together with Article 27 of the Constitution.
c) Compensation for unlawful and unfair termination of employment equivalent to 12 months’ pay as particularized under paragraph 25 hereinabove.
d) Damages for breach of the Claimant’s right to freedom from discrimination guaranteed under Article 27 of the Constitution.
e) Damages for breach of the Claimant’s right to fair labour practice guaranteed under Article 41 of the Constitution.
f) Damages for breach of the Claimants right to fair administrative action guaranteed by Article 47 pf the Constitution of Kenya.
g) Damages for breach of the Claimant’s legitimate and reasonable expectation.
h) Interests at court rates.
i) Costs of the suit
The Respondent’s case is that the termination was lawful and fair. Its investigator, Mr. Peter Murithi Moffat, compiled a report on 7th June, 2018 on the Claimant’s dealings with the taxpayer. It says it allowed her twenty-seven days to answer the show cause letter and gave her the investigation report. It says a first invitation to a hearing on 16th October, 2019 was postponed at her request to 18th October, 2019. It says management considered her representations and found them unacceptable.
The Respondent’s further case is that her documents were uncertified and her explanation on VAT was a misrepresentation, amounting to gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(c) and (g) of the Employment Act, 2007. They again aver that she remained on full pay throughout and was paid three months’ salary in lieu of notice. It says each officer in a disciplinary process is judged on the role played. It relies on Section 14 of the Kenya Revenue Authority Act on the personal responsibility of employees for negligent acts. It denies discrimination and any breach of her rights, and asks that the suit be dismissed with costs.
The Respondent filed witness statements by Mr. Moffat and Mr. Frankline Kiogora, both dated 7th October, 2022, and by Ms. Roseline Mamo, dated 10th June, 2025. It filed no documents. On 11th June, 2025 the court directed that the matter be disposed of by written submissions on the pleadings and documents on record. The Claimant filed submissions dated 8th July, 2025 and the Respondent dated 1st August, 2025. No witness was heard, so the witness statements were not tested by cross-examination.
The issues for determination therefore are;
1. Whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment.
2. Whether the termination was carried out in accordance with fair procedure.
3. Whether the Claimant was discriminated against, or is entitled to damages for breach of her constitutional rights and legitimate expectation.
4. What reliefs the Claimant is entitled to, and who should bear the costs.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment. Under Sections 43(1) and 45(2) of the Employment Act, 2007 the Respondent must prove the reason and it must be valid and fair. The termination letter of 11th September, 2020 gave two grounds of negligence of duty. First, that she forwarded the reviewed demand notices to the Station Manager without ascertaining the basis of the downward revision. Second, that she misrepresented the VAT position of the taxpayer. These are the reasons the Respondent must prove.
The Respondent’s witnesses and their letter of 4th March, 2021 speak of fraudulent manipulation of a tax ledger leading to a loss of Kshs. 7.8 million. The Claimant was never charged with that. An employer cannot justify a termination on an allegation it did not put to the employee. This court decides only the charges laid.
On the first ground, the Respondent filed no documents. The investigation report, the minutes of the hearing and the compliance files are not before this court. Its three witness statements recite the charges and say management found them confirmed. None says what the basis of the revision was, why it was lacking, or what the Claimant should have done to ascertain it. A conclusion is not proof of the facts on which it rests.
The Claimant gave a documented account. The first assessment was an estimate because the taxpayer had not supplied a breakdown of the benefits. The revision followed documents supplied on objection, including a letter of 2nd October, 2014 from the Norwegian Lutheran Mission. The revised notice issued over the Station Manager’s signature. The Respondent does not say any of this is false. Its own submissions say she merely forwarded the notice to her superior. It has not shown that she had authority to approve it, or a duty to re-verify the reviewing officer’s work.
The termination letter also held that her documents were inconsequential because the tax agent had not certified them. That is a point of form. The documents were not said to be false, and on her account the panel undertook to verify them and did not. Section 14 of the Kenya Revenue Authority Act speaks to personal liability. It does not relieve the Respondent of proving negligence. The only loss quantified, Kshs. 7.8 million, is attributed by its own investigator to the ledger manipulation for which she was not charged.
On the second ground, the termination letter identifies no provision that obliged a compliance manager to recommend compounding. The only compounding provision in the papers is the one the Claimant quotes, which says the Commissioner “may” compound an offence. She explained that she and the Station Manager considered compounding and decided against it. The Respondent has not shown that this was careless or caused any loss. The revised demand also assessed VAT of Kshs. 1,986,514, which sits poorly with the alleged misrepresentation.
This court finds that the Respondent has not proved the reasons for the termination. The termination was substantively unfair under Sections 43(1) and 45(2)(a) and (b) of the Employment Act, 2007.
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was carried out in accordance with fair procedure. Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 requires the employer to explain to the employee the reason it is considering termination, in the presence of a colleague of her choice, and to hear and consider her representations. Section 45(2)(c) makes fair procedure a condition of fairness. In the authority of David Wanjau Muhoro v Ol Pejeta Ranching Limited [2014] eKLR, at paragraph 177, the court held that The Employee must be given the documents the Employer intends to rely on at the hearing, as well as other documents the Employee may request for.
Some things were done properly. The show cause letter set out three specific charges and the Claimant was allowed more time to reply. She replied fully on 8th October, 2019. This court finds no unfairness at that stage.
The notice of the hearing is another matter. The only invitation on record is dated 18th October, 2019, the day of the hearing. The Respondent says an earlier invitation of 8th October, 2019 for a hearing on 16th October, 2019 was received on 9th October, 2019 and that the hearing was moved at the Claimant’s request. It produced neither the invitation, the acknowledgement nor the request. They were in its custody. A pleading and near identical witness statements do not prove them.
The decisive failing is the verification. The Claimant says the panel noted that her documents were uncertified and undertook to verify them. The Respondent denies this, but it holds the minutes of the hearing and did not produce them. This court infers that the minutes would not assist it. The termination letter itself rests on the very point that her documents were uncertified, which supports her account.
She waited eleven months for a check that was never done. She was then dismissed on the ground that her documents were inconsequential for want of certification. She was not told the check had not been done and had no chance to certify the documents before the decision. That is not fair procedure.
The appeal did not cure this. She obtained certified copies, but the appeal was dismissed in a few lines for raising no new grounds. The delay of a year against the Respondent’s own six month target is unexplained, although she remained on full pay. This court makes no finding on malice, or on whether her colleague was allowed to speak, as the record of the hearing is not before it. The termination was procedurally unfair, and the Respondent has not discharged its burden under Section 45(2)(c).
The 3rd issue for determination is whether the Claimant was discriminated against, or is entitled to damages for breach of her constitutional rights and legitimate expectation. Section 5(7) of the Employment Act, 2007 puts the burden on the employer once discrimination is alleged, but the Claimant must first identify this. She names no ground under Section 5(3) or Article 27 on which she was treated differently. Her complaint is that the Station Manager was not disciplined. He is said to have approved the notices while she forwarded them. Different treatment of an officer in a different role is not discrimination. The claim fails.
The claims under Articles 41 and 47 arise from the same facts as the unfair termination, for which Section 49 of the Employment Act, 2007 provides the remedy. Further general damages would compensate the same wrong twice. The sums of Kshs. 2,000,000.00 and Kshs. 500,000.00 appear for the first time in submissions. The legitimate expectation claim also fails. The Respondent made no promise that she would not be dismissed. What she could expect was a valid reason and a fair procedure, which this court has dealt with. The claims for separate damages fail.
The 4th issue for determination is the appropriate relief and costs. Having found the termination unfair in substance and procedure, the Claimant is entitled to a declaration to that effect. She does not seek reinstatement. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, 2007 allows compensation of up to twelve months’ gross salary. Her gross monthly salary of Kshs. 284,000.00 is consistent with the final dues of Kshs. 852,000.00 the Respondent says it paid, which is three months’ salary.
Having regard to Section 49(4), the Claimant served for over eighteen years, from 21st January, 2002 to 11th September, 2020, and the record shows no earlier discipline. The termination was unfair on both counts and she waited eleven months on a cheque never done. Against that, she was the reviewing officer on the revised notices and her documents were uncertified when first produced. That counts for something, though not so so much. She was also paid three months’ salary in lieu of notice. Nine months’ gross salary, which is Kshs. 2,556,000.00 is just and proportionate.
The Respondent says any further payment would unjustly enrich the Claimant at the taxpayers’ expense. Parliament has set the remedy, and a public employer is bound by Section 49 like everybody else. The Claimant says no certificate of service was issued and the Respondent says it was. Section 51 entitles her to one and she may ask for it. No order is made on it.
This has been a case of mixed outcome. In the exercise of the discretion under Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, each party shall bear its own costs.
On these premises, I am inclined to partially allow the claim and order as follows:
i) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair for want of a valid and fair reason and fair procedure.
ii) Nine (9) months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination of employment ……………………………………………Kshs. 2,556,000.00
iii) The sum awarded in (ii) above shall accrue interest at court rates from the date of this judgment until payment in full.
iv) The prayers for a declaration of discrimination, damages under Articles 27, 41 and 47 of the Constitution and for damages for breach of legitimate expectation be and are hereby dismissed.
v) Each party shall bear its own costs of the claim.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Aringa instructed by Aringa & Company Advocates for the Claimant.
2. Mr. Shijenje instructed by Shijenje Johnson Advocate for the Respondent.