Employment law

Edible Oil Products Ltd & another v Moseti & 11 others [2026] KEELRC 14983 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Appeal E167 of 2023
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law in arriving at the entire decision against the weight of the evidence on record.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NO. E167 OF 2023

(CONSOLIDATED WITH ELRC APPEAL NO. E165 OF 2023)

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

EDIBLE OIL PRODUCTS LIMITED 1ST APPELLANT

READY CONSULTANCY CO. LIMITED 2ND APPELLANT

VERSUS

JOSPHAT MORARA MOSETI & 11 OTHERS RESPONDENTS

(Being an appeal from the Judgment of Hon. G. M. Gitonga, Principal Magistrate, delivered on 9th August 2023 at the Chief Magistrate’s Court, Milimani Commercial Courts, in CMEL Cause No. 136 of 2018: Josphat Morara Moseti & 11 Others v Edible Oil Products Limited, Ready Consultancy Co. Limited & Islam Munir.)

JUDGMENT

This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 28th August, 2023 and filed in court on 7th September, 2023. It arises from a Judgment and Decree delivered on 9th August, 2023 in CMEL Cause No. 136 of 2018 at the Chief Magistrate’s Court, Milimani Commercial Courts. The appeal is consolidated with Appeal No. E165 of 2023, lodged by Ready Consultancy Co. Limited as Appellant against the same judgment with E167 is the lead file.

The Respondents in this appeal were the claimants in the cause before the trial court. They are twelve in number.

The grounds in the 1st Appellant’s Memorandum of Appeal come out as follows;

1. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law in arriving at the entire decision against the weight of the evidence on record.

2. The Learned Magistrate failed to consider and/or ignored the appellant’s submissions on record and hence came to a wrong conclusion in deciding the claim in favor of the Respondent herein.

3. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact by failing to appreciate and comprehend the submissions and documentary evidence produced by the Appellant.

4. In all the circumstances of the case, the findings of the learned Judge are insupportable in Law or on the basis of the evidence adduced.

5. The Learned trial Magistrate overall in handling of the cause and awarding the Respondent herein was prejudicial and extremely punitive to the Appellant and further perpetuated injustice contrary to public policy in such instance.

REASONS WHEREFORE:- The Appellant prays that this honorable court do set aside the entire lower court Judgment and/or interfere with the said Judgement dated 9th August, 2023 to the extent that it does not meet the end of justice:-

By a Statement of Claim dated 6th August, 2018 the Respondents, as claimants, sued Edible Oil Products Limited (Edible), Ready Consultancy Co. Limited (Ready) and Mr. Islam Munir, the managing director of Edible oil aforesaid. They pleaded that each of them commenced work at the factory of Edible between 2010 and 2013, as an operator assistant or in packaging, at a monthly wage of Kshs 20,815. They further pleaded that they held no written contracts and received no payslips, leave, or NSSF or NHIF cover, and that they worked more than 72 hours weekly in place of 45. They stated that, following an NSSF raid in April 2018, they were issued with letters describing them as employees of Ready, whereupon they registered with NSSF.

According to the Respondents, they were thereafter barred from accessing the premises on 3rd May 2018, on the instructions of Mr. Munir, without notice or hearing. They sought a declaration of breach of Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution, damages as tabulated, reference letters, costs and interest. The tabulated damages totalled Kshs 6,215,499.00 Edible and Mr. Munir denied that the Respondents were their employees. They averred that Edible had engaged Ready as an independent contractor to supply labour, that they possessed no authority to pay, hire or dismiss the Respondents, and that Ready had admitted the Respondents to be its employees.

The position of Ready, for what it matters, was different. It pleaded that it is a labour outsourcing company which supplies workers to other businesses as the need arises, and that it has no work of its own. It pleaded daily employment, with earnings accumulated and paid weekly, and alleged that, on 17th May 2018, the Respondents failed to present NSSF cards and assaulted its supervisor, Mr. Ronald Ruvuga.

At the hearing, Mr. Josphat Morara Moseti (CW1) testified for the Respondents on 27th June, 2022. Edible called its human resource manager, Mr. Bethuel Mugaka Omaga (RW1) and Mr. Munir (RW2) on 30th August, 2022. Ready called its human resource manager, Mr. Bernard Agilla (DW3), on 20th March, 2023 who testified that the Respondents were casual employees paid daily and not entitled to notice, overtime or leave. The trial court delivered its judgment on 9th August, 2023. It found that the Respondents were employees of Edible and Ready, that their casual employment had converted into regular employment and further that their employment was unfairly terminated. It held Edible and Ready jointly and severally liable, found Mr. Munir not personally liable, and awarded Kshs 6,215,499.00 together with costs and interest.

Aggrieved by that decision, Edible lodged the present appeal. For ease of reference, Edible is referred to as the 1st Appellant and Ready as the 2nd Appellant. The Record of Appeal was filed on 21st November, 2025 and the appeals were canvassed by way of written submissions. By reason of the consolidation, the court has considered the written submissions of the parties in the lead file, namely Edible and the Respondents. The decree against Ready is joint and several with that against Edible and rests on the same findings. A determination of the lead file therefore governs and binds both appeals.

It is the 1st Appellant’s case and submission that the trial court relied solely upon the testimony of the Respondents. It contends that the trial court disregarded the letters, the NHIF introduction letters and the service contracts which, in its view, identify Ready as the employer. It further submits that the burden of proof lay upon the Respondents to establish employment by Edible, and that Ready had accepted liability.

The Respondents’ case and submission is that the impugned judgment ought to be upheld. They rely on section 37 of the Employment Act, 2007 and on decisions concerning the conversion of casual employment. They state that they served a notice to produce the payment records, and they urge the court to uphold the entire award of Kshs 6,215,499.00 with costs and interest.

The issues for determination as follows;

1. Whether the Respondents were employees of Edible, Ready or both, and whether the trial court rightly held them jointly and severally liable.

2. Whether the Respondents’ casual employment converted into term employment under section 37 of the Employment Act, 2007.

3. Whether the termination of the Respondents’ employment was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.

4. Whether the awards of compensation, notice pay, gratuity, overtime and leave pay should stand.

5. Who should bear the costs of the appeal.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the Respondents were employees of Edible, Ready or both, and whether the trial court rightly held them jointly and severally liable. Edible contends that Ready alone employed the Respondents, as an independent contractor. At trial, Ready maintained that the Respondents were its casual employees, engaged on behalf of Edible while the Respondents contend that both entities employed them. The reasoning of the trial court on the point is difficult to follow, and the evidence is therefore re-evaluated afresh.

The starting point is section 2 of the Employment Act, 2007 which defines an employer as a person who has entered into a contract of service to employ an individual and extends the definition to that of agent, foreman, manager or factor of that person. It follows that the label which the parties assign to the arrangement is not determinative. The substance of the relationship is indeed the controlling and critical factor for consideration. Viewed in that light, the documents emanating from Ready identify it as an employer. Its Memorandum in Reply describes Ready as the employer of the claimants and its letters of early May 2018 to NHIF describe each Respondent as a casual employee of our company. Mr. Agilla further testified that Ready paid the Respondents. The court therefore finds that Ready was an employer of the Respondents.

This finding however, does not exhaust the inquiry. The evidence also bears upon the role of Edible in this game or circus. Mr. Agilla also testified that Ready recruited the Respondents on behalf of Edible and was used to supply the number of workers that Edible required. Such conduct is characteristic of an agent, and by the definition in section 2, the principal of an agent is the employer. On the evidence of Ready itself, Edible was accordingly an employer as well.

The evidence of the witnesses of Edible is to the same effect. Mr. Omaga first stated that the Respondents never worked for Edible, but thereafter stated that they were working for Edible and that its records reflected both companies. Mr. Munir conceded that the Respondents had worked at Edible since 2013 although he denied supervising or paying them. On the testimony of both appellants’ witnesses, therefore, the Respondents served at Edible for not less than five years prior to May, 2018.

The service contracts in the record corroborate that conclusion. Under them, Edible provided the working area, reserved the right to reject or remove any worker and subjected the workers to its security searches. Edible further funded the wages by paying Ready daily or weekly for that purpose, in addition to a commission of Kshs 25 or Kshs 30 per worker.

Edible relies on the service contracts, which contain a clause providing that no worker shall acquire a legal claim against it. That clause is of no avail. The Respondents were not parties to the contracts and an undertaking between two companies cannot divest statutory rights from workers who never assented to it. Edible further contends that the trial court disregarded its letters of 11th July, 2018. Those letters were authored after the dispute had arisen, so they state a position and are not evidence, and they were in any event contradicted by Mr. Omaga.

In considering the contention of Edible that it merely engaged an independent contractor, the court is guided by the decision in Masai Rolling Mills Ltd v Ongaki & another (Appeal E155 of 2022) [2025] KEELRC 510 (KLR). In that case, Masai Rolling Mills Limited, which had outsourced the work to a contractor, was held not to be the employer of the worker, because the outsourcing agreement predated his engagement and the contractor paid both his wages and his NSSF contributions. That conclusion followed an examination of who controlled the work, where it was performed, whether the workers were integrated into the business, and whether their service was continuous.

The present case is variously distinguishable. Ready, by its own pleading, had no work of its own and merely supplied labour to others, while the Respondents worked on the premises of Edible, under its rules and within its production process, for years. Moreover, Mr. Agilla conceded that the Respondents were not registered with NHIF or NSSF until 2018, although the contracts made Ready responsible for those remittances.

As regards Ready, the trial judgment does not state clearly whether Ready was found to be an employer. Upon re-evaluation of the evidence, however, the court is satisfied that Ready was an employer of the Respondents, and the decree against it is therefore supportable. It is unnecessary to determine the precise date on which each Respondent commenced service. The commencement dates alleged for 2010 to 2012 rest solely on the Respondents’ own assertion, and the registers on which the trial court relied are not part of the record. It suffices that the witnesses of both appellants placed the Respondents at Edible from 2013, which gives each Respondent not less than five years of service before May 2018. Accordingly, the court finds that Edible and Ready were each an employer of the Respondents, Edible as principal and Ready as the contracting and paying employer. The finding of joint and several liability is therefore upheld.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the Respondents’ casual employment converted into term employment under section 37 of the Employment Act, 2007. Section 2 of the Act defines a casual employee as a person whose terms provide for payment at the end of each day and who is not engaged for longer than 24 hours at a time. Ready pleaded, however, that the earnings of the Respondents were accumulated and paid weekly, which is inconsistent with payment at the end of each day under a daily engagement. That inconsistency is reinforced by the surrounding facts. The Respondents held no written contracts and worked continuously on the production line of Edible for years, while Edible and Ready entered into annual service contracts in several of those years. Mr. Agilla likewise testified that the Respondents were engaged from 2013 and that no written contracts existed.

Even if the Respondents were to be treated as casual employees, section 37(1) would apply. It provides that a casual employee who works continuously for the equivalent of not less than one month is deemed to be employed on monthly wages, to which section 35(1)(c) applies, and section 37(3) entitles such an employee, after two months of continuous work, to the terms and conditions of service available to an ordinary employee under the Act. The service of the Respondents far exceeded that threshold, so their employment converted, by operation of law, into monthly-paid employment, and the casual designation cannot defeat that consequence. Both appellants must accordingly be treated as employers of employees entitled to the full protection of the Act. As to the wage, the trial court adopted the pleaded sum of Kshs 20,815.00 per month. The appellants tendered no payroll records to controvert it, and Mr. Munir stated that Edible kept none, so the court adopts that figure and upholds the finding that the casual employment converted under section 37.

The 3rd issue for determination is whether the termination of the Respondents’ employment was wrongful, unfair and unlawful. The Respondents assert that they were barred from the premises on 3rd May, 2018 while Ready places the disturbance on 16th and 17th May, 2018. The union representing the Respondents wrote to Ready on 21st May, 2018 complaining of the unlawful termination of the workers. The precise date cannot be fixed from the record, but it falls between 3rd and 21st May, 2018 and nothing turns on it.

Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007, places upon an employee alleging unfair termination the burden of establishing that an unfair termination occurred, whereupon the employer must justify the termination. Mr. Moseti testified that no notice or hearing preceded his removal, and the union’s letter states that the workers had been terminated. Together with the concessions of Mr. Agilla, that evidence discharged the initial burden of the Respondents, and the burden shifted to the appellants.

The governing provisions come out thus: section 43 obliges the employer to prove the reasons for termination, section 45 renders a termination unfair where there is no valid reason or where a fair procedure was not followed, and section 41 requires notification of the grounds and a hearing before termination for misconduct. Section 41(2) applies even to summary dismissal under section 44(3) or (4), so that gross misconduct does not dispense with a hearing. In that regard, Mr. Agilla conceded that no show-cause letter or warning was issued and that the Respondents were not contacted regarding the events of 17th May, 2018.

The reason advanced by Ready was an alleged assault upon its supervisor and that reason was not proved. Mr. Ruvuga did not testify, and his statement and annexures RR-1 to RR-5, which include a police complaint and medical documents, are not in the record. Mr. Moseti, for his part, denied any assault. Ready’s own papers are, moreover, inconsistent on the allegation, its reply referring to 11 Respondents while its supervisor’s statement names all 12. A police complaint does not prove the assault, and no outcome of any police inquiry was placed before the court.

Ready also relied on its policy that workers register with NSSF. Its contracts with Edible, however, made Ready responsible for NSSF remittances, and after years of service the absence of an NSSF card could not justify removal without a hearing. Accordingly, the termination was effected without notice, without a hearing and without a proved reason, contrary to sections 41, 43 and 45. Responsibility for it attaches, connects and relates to both appellants as employers, and the finding of unfair termination is upheld.

The 4th issue for determination is whether the awards of compensation, notice pay, gratuity, overtime and leave pay should stand, and who should bear the costs of the appeal. The trial court awarded each head as claimed. The submissions of Edible do not address quantum specifically, but its grounds of appeal challenge the weight of the evidence and the punitive character of the award, which places the awards before the court for re-evaluation. Each head is therefore considered in turn.

Compensation is governed by section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, 2007, which permits an award of up to twelve months’ gross wages, and section 49(4) enumerates the factors to be weighed, including the length of service, the conduct of the employer and of the employee, and mitigation. The trial court awarded the maximum of twelve months, being Kshs 249,780.00 without assigning reasons. In Ol Pejeta Ranching Ltd v Muhoro (CA 42 of 2015) [2017] KECA 329 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that the maximum award requires reasons and substituted six months where the trial judge had given none, (no reasons.) This standard is applicable and similarly applied in the present case.

The Respondents served for between five and eight years, were removed without a hearing, and for years were retained as casuals without statutory cover. Conversely, no evidence of mitigation was led, and nothing demonstrates malice or bad faith on the part of the employers of a kind that would warrant the maximum. Upon that balance, twelve months is excessive, and the court awards eight months’ wages to each Respondent, being Kshs 166,520.00 Notice pay follows from section 37(1), which applies section 35(1)(c) to the converted contract, and from section 36, which provides for payment in lieu of notice. No notice was given, and the court allows one month’s wages, Kshs 20,815.00 to each Respondent.

The Respondents also claimed gratuity, the figures approximating fifteen days’ pay for each year of service. The statutory entitlement is service pay under section 35(5), but section 35(6)(d) excludes its application to a member of NSSF. The claim itself states that the Respondents registered with NSSF after the raid of April, 2018 and before they were barred, so on their own case they were members of NSSF at termination. The failure of the employers to register them earlier may found a distinct claim, but none was pleaded or proved, and the award of service pay is accordingly set aside.

Overtime was pleaded at more than 72 hours weekly against 45, whereas the demand letter of the Respondents referred to 48 hours. No record of hours was produced, the claim furnished no day-by-day or week-by-week basis, and Mr. Agilla testified that night shifts were paid at a fixed rate. A party claiming overtime must present a defensible and credible basis for its computation as was observed in KUDHEIHA v Charles Waithaka Goko t/a Apple Bees Pub and Restaurant [2013] KEELRC 440 (KLR). The Respondents state that they served a notice to produce records, but that notice is not in the record, and no application for an adverse inference was made at trial. The award of overtime is accordingly set aside.

Leave stands on a different footing. The trial court awarded three months’ wages to every Respondent irrespective of length of service, which cannot be sustained. Section 28(1)(a) confers 21 working days after each twelve consecutive months, section 28(1)(b) confers leave pro rata on termination, and section 28(4) requires leave to be taken within 18 months of the end of the leave-earning period. The appellants produced no leave records, which section 74(1)(f) obliges an employer to keep, and no leave was granted. By section 37(3), the Respondents were entitled to leave as ordinary employees, and their reliance on section 40(e) is misplaced, since section 40 governs redundancy. In the absence of records, the leave-earning period of each Respondent cannot be fixed. The court therefore allows leave for the two most recent leave years, being 42 working days, computed at one twenty-sixth of the monthly wage per working day, which yields Kshs 33,624.23 for each Respondent.

Each Respondent accordingly receives Kshs 166,520.00 as compensation, Kshs 20,815.00 as notice pay and Kshs 33,624.23 as leave pay, a total of Kshs 220,959.23 and the total for the twelve Respondents is Kshs 2,651,510.76. The appeal of Edible therefore fails on liability and succeeds in part on quantum. Since the decree is joint and several, the reduced sums bind both appellants, and the appeal of Ready succeeds to the same extent. As to interest, the trial court ordered interest at court rates until payment in full. That order is retained and applies to the sums awarded in this judgment.

Turning to costs, no ground attacks the order of the trial court, which is accordingly left undisturbed. As regards this appeal, both sides have succeeded in part. Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act empowers the court to make such order on costs as it considers just and on this premises and circumstances each party shall tear its costs of the appeal.

I am therefore inclined to partially allow the appeals and order as follows;

(i) The finding of the trial court that the Respondents were employees of both appellants, that their casual employment converted into term employment under section 37 of the Employment Act, 2007, and that their employment was unfairly terminated be and is hereby upheld.

(ii) The awards of the trial court are set aside and substituted with the following awards to each of the twelve Respondents:

Compensation (8 months’ wages)…………………………….Kshs 166,520.00

Notice pay (1 month’s wages)…………………………………Kshs 20,815.00

Leave pay (42 working days)…………………………………..Kshs 33,624.23

Total of the award per Respondent………………….……..Kshs 220,959.23

Grand total of the award for the Respondents…………Ksh2,651,510.76.

(iii) The grand total payable to the twelve Respondents is Kshs 2,651,510.76, for which the 1st and 2nd Appellants are jointly and severally liable.

(iv) The awards of gratuity and overtime are set aside.

(v) The sums awarded in order (ii) shall attract interest at court rates, as ordered by the trial court.

(vi) The order of the trial court on costs goes undisturbed.

(vii) Each party shall bear its own costs of this appeal.

Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mr. Kamau instructed by Aming’a, Opiyo, Masese & Co. Advocates for the 1st Appellant.

2. Miss Akinyi instructed by Kuloba Wasike & Co. Advocates for the Respondents.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder