Background
The petitioner, vide petition dated 12th July 2021 filed before the High Court and transferred to this court on account of jurisdiction vide ruling of Justice Mrima dated 27th January 2022, sought the following orders –
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The petitioner, vide petition dated 12th July 2021 filed before the High Court and transferred to this court on account of jurisdiction vide ruling of Justice Mrima dated 27th January 2022, sought the following orders –
Paragraph 1 →The court discerned the singular issue for determination to be –
Paragraph 9 →It is apparent that section 48 of the Employment Act allows an official of an employer organisation who is an advocate to represent a party, in this case the employer, but outlaws other advocates who may represent employees. I find the section discriminatory, as it allows employers to be represented by an advocate but excludes employees from legal representation, contrary to the principles of natural justice and the equal application…
Paragraph 18 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
ELRC PETITION NO. 27 OF 2022
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLES 2(1), 2(3), 2(4), 2(5), 3(1), 22(1), 25(C), 156(6), 159(2)(D), 165(3)(B) & 165(3)(D)(I) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION OF THE RIGHTS
AND
FUNDERMENTAL FREEDOMS UNDER ARTICLES 25(c) & 50(2)(g) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 48 OF THE EMPLOYMENT ACT NO. 11 OF 2007 LAWS OF KENYA
BETWEEN
CONSTANTINE JOSEPH ADVOCATES LLP……………………….................................................PETITIONER
AND
THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL..........................................................................RESPONDENT
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, vide petition dated 12th July 2021 filed before the High Court and transferred to this court on account of jurisdiction vide ruling of Justice Mrima dated 27th January 2022, sought the following orders –
a. A declaration that Section 48 of the Employment Act is unconstitutional for threatening the right to a fair hearing guaranteed by Articles 25(c) and 50(2)(g) of the Constitution.
b. The costs of this petition are granted to the Petitioner: and
c. Any other relief that this Honourable Court deems fit to grant.
Grounds of the Petition
2. The Constitution provides that the right to a fair hearing shall not be limited, and the State shall ensure access to justice for all persons.
3. The Constitution also provides that every person has the right to a fair trial, which includes the right to choose, and be represented by, an advocate: and
4. That all laws in force immediately before the Constitution's effective date will continue to be in force and shall be interpreted with the alterations, qualifications, and exceptions necessary to bring them into conformity with the Constitution.
5. This being said, Section 48 of the Employment Act provides that in any complaint made under Section 47(of the Employment Act), no advocate shall represent a party in the proceedings before a labour officer.
6. Essentially, what Section 48 of the Employment Act does is to deny a person their Constitutional right to a fair hearing. It is the Petitioner's humble petition therefore, that Section 48 of the Employment Act is a threat to a person's right to a fair hearing.
7. The petition was not opposed.
DETERMINATION
8. The court directed that submissions be filed. No party filed.
9. The court discerned the singular issue for determination to be –
Whether section 48 of the Employment Act is unconstitutional for threatening the right to a fair hearing guaranteed under 50(2) (g) of the Constitution.
The law.
10. Article 50(1) and (2)(g) of the Constitution provides-
‘(1)Every person has the right to have any dispute that can be resolved by the application of law decided in a fair and public hearing before a court or, if appropriate, another independent and impartial tribunal or body.
(2)Every accused person has the right to a fair trial, which includes the right-
(g)to choose, and be represented by, an advocate, and to be informed of this right promptly;’
11. Section 48 of the Employment Act provides for representation before the labour officer as follows-
‘In any complaint made under section 47, no advocate shall represent a party in the proceedings before a labour officer, but any party may be assisted or represented by an official of a trade union or an official of an employer's organisation notwithstanding the fact that the official is an advocate.’
12. Section 47 of the Employment Act provides for jurisdiction of labour officer as follows-
‘47. Complaint of summary dismissal and unfair termination
(1)Where an employee has been summarily dismissed or his employer has unfairly terminated his employment without justification, the employee may, within three months of the date of dismissal, present a complaint to a labour officer and the complaint shall be dealt with as a complaint lodged under section 86.
(2)A labour officer who is presented with a claim under this section shall, after affording every opportunity to both the employee and the employer to state their case, recommend to the parties what in his opinion would be the best means of settling the dispute in accordance with the provisions section 49.
(3)The right of the employee to present a complaint under this section shall be in addition to his right to complain to the Employment and Labour Relations Court on the same issue and to the right to complain of any other infringement of his statutory rights.
(4)The right of an employee to make a complaint under this section shall be in addition to any right an employee may enjoy under a collective agreement.
(5)For any complaint of unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal the burden of proving that an unfair termination of employment or wrongful dismissal has occurred shall rest on the employee, while the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination of employment or wrongful dismissal shall rest on the employer.
(6)No employee whose services have been terminated or who has been summarily dismissed during a probationary contract shall make a complaint under this section.’
13. The labour officer exercises statutory mandate under section 86 of the Employment Act to wit-
‘86. Complaint and jurisdiction in cases of dispute between employers and employees
(1)Subject to the provisions of this Act whenever—
(a)an employer or employee neglects or refuses to fulfill a contract of service; or
(b)any question, difference or dispute arises as to the rights or liabilities of either party; or
(c)touching any misconduct, neglect or ill treatment of either party or any injury to the person or property of either party, under any contract of service, the aggrieved party may complain to the labour officer or lodge a complaint or suit in the Employment and Labour Relations Court.’
14. Article 25 of the Constitution provides for Fundamental Rights and freedoms that may not be limited-
‘Despite any other provision in this Constitution, the following rights and fundamental freedoms shall not be limited—…;(c)the right to a fair trial; ‘
15. The court has jurisdiction to determine the petition as held by the Supreme Court in Kenya Tea Growers Association & 2 others v National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees & 13 others [2024] KESC 3 (KLR)
‘There was nothing in the Constitution, the ELRC Act, or indeed the decision in the Karisa Chengo case to suggest that in exercising its jurisdiction over disputes emanating from employment and labour relations, the ELRC was precluded from determining the constitutional validity of a statute. That was especially so if the statute in question lay at the center of the dispute. What it could not do, was to sit as if it were the High Court under article 165 of the Constitution and declare a statute unconstitutional in circumstances where the dispute in question had nothing or little to do with employment and labour relations within the context of the ELRC Act.’
Decision
16. The right to a fair trial under article 50 cannot be limited as per article 25 of the Constitution. The labour officer in exercise of statutory duty under section 86 of the Employment Act, is performing an administrative action under article 47 of the Constitution, to wit-
(1)Every person has the right to administrative action that is expeditious, efficient, lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair….’
17. Procedural fairness includes the right to fair hearing. Section 48 of the Employment Act reads-
‘In any complaint made under section 47, no advocate shall represent a party in the proceedings before a labour officer, but any party may be assisted or represented by an official of a trade union or an official of an employer's organisation notwithstanding the fact that the official is an advocate.’
18. It is apparent that section 48 of the Employment Act allows an official of an employer organisation who is an advocate to represent a party, in this case the employer, but outlaws other advocates who may represent employees. I find the section discriminatory, as it allows employers to be represented by an advocate but excludes employees from legal representation, contrary to the principles of natural justice and the equal application of the law. To the extent that section 48 of the Employment Act disallows advocates to represent parties and at same time allows representation by an official of an employer's organisation notwithstanding the fact that the official is an advocate, the provision is inconsistent with provisions of article 50(1) (2)(g) and article 47 of the Constitution. The provision violates the basic tenets of natural justice of equal treatment of parties. It is the finding of the court that the limitation of the right to legal representation before an external administrative process by the labour officer under section 48 of the Employment Act , is not compliant with the provisions of article 24 of the Constitution, to wit-
(1)A right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights shall not be limited except by law, and then only to the extent that the limitation is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom, taking into account all relevant factors, including—
(a)the nature of the right or fundamental freedom;
(b)the importance of the purpose of the limitation;
(c)the nature and extent of the limitation;
(d)the need to ensure that the enjoyment of rights and fundamental freedoms by any individual does not prejudice the rights and fundamental freedoms of others; and
(e)the relation between the limitation and its purpose and whether there are less restrictive means to achieve the purpose.’
19. The court takes judicial notice that section 48 of the Employment Act came into force in 2007, way before the promulgation of the Constitution. The limitation of the right was not justified and serves no purpose, given that the advocates, who are officials of the employers' organisation, can represent the employer before the same labour officer, to the exclusion of the employee's right to be represented by an advocate. The provision violates the right of parties not to be discriminated against. Article 27(1) of the Constitution states-
(1)Every person is equal before the law and has the right to equal protection and equal benefit of the law.’
20. Under section 48, the parties are not equal before the law, as only the employer is allowed to have an advocate before the labour officer.
21. The court holds that the limitation of legal representation under section 48 of the Employment Act is not reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom.
Disposition
22. The court declares the limitation of legal representation under section 48 of the Employment Act, of excluding advocates from appearing for workers and allowing advocates for employer organisations only, before the labour officer, performing administrative duties under section 86 of the Employment Act, is unjustified and inconsistent with Article 27 and Article 50(2)g).
23. A declaration is hereby issued that Section 48 of the Employment Act is unconstitutional for threatening the right to a fair hearing guaranteed by Article 50(2)(g) of the Constitution.
24. The court, taking into account the nature of the petition, makes no order as to costs in the petition.
25. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Petitioner- absent
Respondent - absent