Background
The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact in finding that the Claimant was not unlawfully terminated from employment without a notice to show cause.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact in finding that the Claimant was not unlawfully terminated from employment without a notice to show cause.
Paragraph 1 →Whether the magistrate erred on unfair termination, compensation, underpayment, leave allowance and January 2023 salary; and whether further relief and appeal costs were due. The Employment and Labour Relations Court in Asuma v Levs Trading Co. Ltd t/a House…
The appellant said he was employed in 2019 and, while on leave, was called back on 24 January 2023, questioned over workplace theft, told to go home, and never recalled or paid January salary. He claimed unfair termination, underpayment, leave allowance,…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E301 OF 2025
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
REMJIUS CHEMASI ASUMA…………………………………………… APPELLANT
VERSUS
LEVS TRADING CO. LTD T/A HOUSE OF LEATHER……………… RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the Judgment of Hon. E. Riany, Principal Magistrate, delivered on 30th July 2025 at Milimani in Milimani Chief Magistrate’s Court MCELRC Cause No. E642 of 2023: Remjius Chemasi Asuma v Levs Trading Co. Ltd t/a House of Leather)
JUDGMENT
This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 28th August, 2025. It arises from a judgment delivered on 30th July, 2025 in Milimani Chief Magistrate’s Court MCELRC Cause No. E642 of 2023.
The grounds of appeal are as follows;
1. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact in finding that the Claimant was not unlawfully terminated from employment without a notice to show cause.
2. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law in making findings that the Respondent was not underpaid without taking into account the regulations of wages bill presented by the appellant as exhibits.
3. The Learned Magistrate acted on the wrong principles of law by not considering issues raised by the appellant and not controverted by the respondent while arriving at her findings.
4. The Learned Magistrate erred in not sufficiently taking into account the evidence presented to her in totality and in particular the evidence presented on behalf of the Appellant.
5. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact in delivering a judgment that was against the weight of the evidence presented by the Appellant.
6. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact in disregarding the Appellant’s case thereby reaching a finding that is against the rule of law and natural justice.
The genesis of this matter and the Appellant’s case is that the Appellant raised a Statement of Claim dated 6th April, 2023. He pleaded that the Respondent employed him in 2019 as a shop attendant on a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 17,000.00. He pleaded that on 24th January, 2023 the Respondent called him from leave, told him to go home and wait for a phone call, and never allowed him back to work or paid his january salary.
He sought a declaration that the termination was unlawful, unprocedural and irregular. He claimed Kshs. 246,000.00 for unfair termination, underpayment of Kshs. 54,099.50 for January, 2019 to June, 2022 and Kshs. 28,142.40 for July, 2022 to February, 2023 leave allowance of Kshs. 20,517.80, notice pay of Kshs. 20,517.80 and January, 2023 salary of Kshs. 20,517.80. The total was Kshs. 389,795.30. He also sought a certificate of service, interest and costs.
The Respondent filed a Statement of Response dated 24th May, 2023. They said the Appellant was a general worker and was properly paid, and that it never terminated him. Again, they averred that an internal audit in January, 2023 uncovered forged receipts at its Ridgeways outlet, that the Appellant was implicated, and that he failed to appear for a disciplinary process and stopped reporting to work.
The matter was heard inter partes on 9th July, 2025. The Appellant testified and called no other witness. The Respondent called Patrick Mutune, its National Sales Manager. The trial court delivered its judgment on 30th July, 2025. It found that the Respondent failed to comply with section 41 of the Employment Act and that the Appellant was unfairly terminated, but also contributed to the situation. It declined compensation under section 49(4)(k). It dismissed the claims for underpayment, leave allowance and January, 2023 salary. The court awarded one month’s salary in lieu of notice of Kshs. 17,000.00 and ordered a certificate of service within 30 days. It also awarded the Appellant costs and interest.
The Record of Appeal was filed on 28th January, 2026 and a Supplementary Record of Appeal on 29th March, 2026. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions, the Appellant’s dated 30th March, 2026 and the Respondent’s filed on 21st April, 2026.
The Memorandum of Appeal appeals against the whole of the judgment and contains no separate prayers. In his submissions the Appellant asks that the appeal be allowed with costs.
It is the Appellant’s case and submission that he was employed in 2019 as a shop attendant at Kshs. 17,000.00 a month. He says that on 24th January, 2023 he was called back from leave, questioned about a theft at the workplace, and told to go home and wait for further communication and that he was never recalled.
The Appellant further submits that no notice to show cause or warning letter was ever served on him, as the Respondent’s witness admitted in cross-examination and that the Respondent adduced no evidence of any attempt to call him back. He relies on Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] eKLR for the two limbs of fairness, and on Ronald Nyambu Daudi v Tornado Carriers Limited [2019] KEELRC 2150 (KLR) for the rule that an employer alleging desertion must show efforts to reach out to the employee. It is his further case that the trial court contradicted itself by pronouncing that he was not unfairly terminated while finding that he contributed to the breakdown of the employment relationship.
On the issue of underpayment, the Appellant submits that the Regulation of Wages (General) (Amendment) Order, 2018 set the basic monthly wage of a shop attendant at Kshs. 18,319.50 and that the 2022 Order set that of a cashier at Kshs. 20,517.80. He says the Respondent paid only Kshs. 17,000.00 and never disputed the claim. He adds that the Respondent’s own witness statement confirmed that he was a cashier. He argues that the trial court misread his letter of employment, which says a sales person or any other duty as may be required by the management, because the word or leaves room for other duties such as cashiering.
The Respondent’s case and submission is that the Appellant was employed as a sales person by a letter of employment dated 7th December, 2019 on a gross salary of Kshs. 13,000.00. They posit that an internal audit in January, 2023 revealed suspicious transactions, that the Appellant was among the employees involved in a theft syndicate, and that police interrogated him at Muthaiga Police Station.
The Appellant was invited to appear before its disciplinary committee but failed to show up. It submits that under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007 the burden of proving unfair termination rests on the Appellant, and that his claim that he was told not to report to work is a bare allegation. It says he waived his right to a hearing by his own conduct.
On underpayment, it submits that the Appellant produced no document showing he was a cashier or was redeployed to that role, and relies on his letter of employment. It says the claims for leave allowance and January salary were unproved, because it produced his payslip and a statement of NSSF remittances. It asks for costs under section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act and for the appeal to be dismissed.
After a considered look and scrutiny of the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;
1. Whether the trial court erred in its findings on the termination of the Appellant’s employment.
2. Whether the trial court erred in declining to award compensation.
3. Whether the Appellant proved that he was underpaid.
4. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the claims for leave allowance and for the January 2023 salary.
5. Whether the Appellant is entitled to any further relief and who should bear the costs of the appeal.
This being a first appeal, this court is under a duty to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence on record and to draw its own conclusions, bearing in mind that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses testify, as is in the authority of Selle and Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123.
Grounds 3 to 6 are general complaints about how the trial court evaluated the evidence. They have no separate content and I deal with them under the issues.
Ground 3 says the trial court ignored matters the Respondent did not controvert. The record does not bear that out. The Statement of Response denied paragraphs 3 to 10 of the claim, denied the claim for unpaid leave, and put the Appellant to strict proof – see page 41 of the record.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in its findings on the termination of the Appellant’s employment. Ground 1 faults the trial court for finding that the Appellant was not unlawfully terminated. The judgment does not say that. At page 66 the trial court found that the Respondent failed to comply with section 41 of the Employment Act. At page 67 it found that the Appellant was unfairly terminated, but also contributed to the situation.
The Appellant avers that the trial court contradicted itself between pages 60 and 67. Page 60 of the Supplementary Record is not part of the judgment. It is part of the Respondent’s written submissions in the trial court, and the proposition the Appellant attributes to the trial court appears at paragraph 22 of those submissions. The judgment contains no such pronouncement.
The finding that the termination was unfair is therefore in the Appellant’s favour. The Respondent did not cross-appeal, yet its submissions argue that the termination was not unlawful. Because this is a first appeal, I have examined the evidence afresh on that question.
Section 45(2) of the Employment Act makes a termination unfair if the employer fails to prove a valid and fair reason and a fair procedure. Under section 47(5) the employee must show that an unfair termination occurred, and the burden of justifying the grounds rests on the employer.
The Respondent’s position is that it never terminated the Appellant and that he absconded. That is a plea of desertion, and an employer must prove it. It must show what it did to reach the employee and to tell him that action on that ground was under consideration, as in the authority of Ronald Nyambu Daudi v Tornado Carriers Limited [2019] KEELRC 2150 (KLR), at paragraph 10.
The Respondent gave no evidence of reaching out. Its Statement of Response says the Appellant was summoned on 20th January, 2023 interdicted pending investigations, told to return after 14 days for a formal disciplinary process, and failed to appear (page 41). It produced no letter, message or call record, and called no witness who made the call or sent the message.
Its only witness, Mr. Mutune, said in cross-examination: No charges have been preferred against claimant. He has since absconded duty. There has been no final communication or any Notice to Show Cause, see page 73. His witness statement says the Appellant was further summoned” to a disciplinary process but “has since failed to show up, page 45. It gives no date and no manner of summons.
The Respondent’s submissions speak of an admission that the Appellant failed to show up after being invited to a hearing. There is no evidence of such in the proceedings. In cross-examination the Appellant said he never went back to work because he was told verbally not to come back - page 73. That is not an admission that he was invited to a hearing.
The Respondent’s account is also inconsistent on dates. Its Statement of Response says the Appellant was summoned on 20th January, 2023 (page 41). Its witness says 6th February, 2023 (page 45). The Appellant pleaded 24th January, 2023. Nothing in the Respondent’s evidence reconciles these dates.
The Respondent also gave no proof of the reason it alleges. Section 43 of the Act requires an employer to prove the reason for termination. It alleged that the Appellant colluded with cashiers to forge receipts, but produced no audit report, no forged receipts, no police report and no charge sheet. Its list of documents contains only the letter of employment, a payslip and the Appellant’s police statement, see page 46.
On its pleadings the Appellant avers that the Respondent interdicted the Appellant and told him to return after 14 days. An interdiction is a step taken by the employer. An employee who stays away because he has been sent away is not absent without leave. There is no evidence that the Respondent then wrote to him, heard him, or ended the interdiction. The Respondent submits that it could have dismissed the Appellant summarily under section 44(4)(a) and (g). It did not, and its pleaded case is that it did not dismiss him at all. A ground not invoked at the time cannot justify what the employer says it never did. In any event section 41 still required it to explain the allegation and hear him.
The Respondent also says the Appellant waived his right to a hearing by staying away. Waiver presupposes that a hearing was offered, and the Respondent did not prove that it was. It is right that criminal and disciplinary processes are separate, but that cuts both ways. It could not rely on the police inquiry in place of its own process, and it held none. I find that the Respondent did not prove desertion, did not prove a valid reason, and did not pursue a fair procedure in terminating the employment of the Appellant. The termination was unfair under section 45(2). The trial court reached the same conclusion and this court hereby affirms it.
This court does not make any finding on whether the Appellant took part in the alleged fraud. The Respondent did not prove it, and the outcome of this appeal does not depend on it. Ground 1 fails to the extent that it alleges error in the finding on termination.
The 2nd issue for determination whether the trial court erred in declining to award compensation. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, 2007 allows compensation of up to twelve months’ gross salary for unfair termination. Section 49(4) lists the factors the court must weigh, including at paragraph (k) any conduct of the employee which to any extent caused or contributed to the termination. The trial court relied on that factor to decline compensation. Compensation is a matter of discretion. An appellate court interferes only where the trial court acted on a wrong principle, ignored a relevant matter, considered an irrelevant one, or was plainly wrong, as in Mbogo and Another v Shah [1968] EA 93.
The Appellant’s submissions do not engage with section 49(4)(k). They argue that the Respondent did not prove efforts to recall him. That goes to whether the termination was fair, which the trial court decided in his favour. It does not show error in weighing his own conduct.
Both sets of submissions misstate the judgment here. The Respondent quotes a passage that includes the words following the initial phone calls. The Appellant says the trial court found that he did not communicate in writing. Neither phrase is in the judgment. What the trial court found, at page 67, is that the Appellant failed to make reasonable efforts to communicate with the Respondent after his interrogation. Reliance is made on the judgment as certified. That finding is supported by the evidence. The Appellant pleaded that on 24th January, 2023 he was called from leave, questioned and told to go home. His police statement, which the Respondent produced, places the events on 20th January, 2023: he was at work packing goods, was sent back to his place of work after questioning, and was arrested at about 4.00 pm with several colleagues (pages 50 and 51).
The Appellant did not tell the trial court when he was released from custody. He did not say that he went back to the workplace, wrote, called, or sent anyone on his behalf. On the contrary he only said that he never went back because he was told verbally not to, page 73 and he named no one and no date.
The Appellant’s witness statement names the people who told him to go home but places that conversation on 24th January, 2023 - page 7. In cross-examination he again gave 24th January, 2023 as the day he came from leave and was arrested, page 73. His police statement describes the same events on 20th January, 2023 - pages 50 and 51. The only demand he produced is a letter dated 6th March, 2023 – see also page 39. It is written for Ms Faith Nyanchera Nyambaga, a cashier on a gross salary of Kshs. 19,800.00. It is not a demand on his behalf and cannot be treated as an effort by him to communicate. The record discloses no communication from him to the Respondent between January, 2023 and the claim dated 6th April, 2023.
The trial court was entitled on that evidence to find that the Appellant made no reasonable effort to communicate with the Respondent. That finding is not plainly wrong. That conduct contributed to the circumstances in which the employment ended without a hearing, which is what paragraph (k) is about. The other factors do not assist him. He did not plead or seek reinstatement, and gave no evidence of his wishes, of any effort to find other work, or of any loss beyond the claim itself. Section 49(4)(l) makes failure to mitigate a relevant factor and there is no evidence on it either way.
This court has considered whether nil compensation is too harsh, given that the Respondent proved neither a reason nor a procedure. Section 49(4) does not make the employer’s failings the only consideration. The trial court also marked those failings by awarding notice pay, although the Respondent said it had not terminated the Appellant at all. The Respondent has not challenged that award. I find no basis to disturb the decision to decline compensation. The Appellant’s complaint on this head fails.
The 3rd issue for determination is whether the Appellant proved that he was underpaid. A claim for underpayment is a claim for the difference between what the employee was paid and what the Regulation of Wages Orders required. Section 107 of the Evidence Act puts the burden of proving the facts on the party who asserts them. The Appellant had to prove the category of work he did, the rate for that category, and what he was paid. His pleaded case was that he was a shop attendant pages 1 and 7. He applied the shop assistant rate of Kshs. 18,319.50 under item 6 of the 2018 Order - page 32 and Kshs. 20,517.80 under item 6 of the 2022 Order at page 37. He says he was paid Kshs. 17,000.00 and the Respondent’s payslip agrees, page 49.
The Respondent denied that he was a shop assistant. Its Statement of Response says he was a general worker, page 41 and its witness says the same - page 44. The letter of employment, which the Appellant does not dispute, describes the job as a sales person or any other duty as may be required by the management - page 47. The claim was contested, so ground 3 cannot succeed on the footing that it was not.
The Appellant’s evidence does not establish that he was a shop assistant. He told the trial court: I was not employed as a packer but line attendant then moved to packer, page 73. His police statement says he started in 2019 selling stationery and has been a packer since 2020, see page 50. On his account he was a packer when the dispute arose, and he gave no evidence of what a shop assistant does.
On appeal he changes his case. He says he was a cashier and that the 2022 Order fixes the cashier’s rate at Kshs. 20,517.80. That was never pleaded. It also contradicts his own exhibits. Kshs. 20,517.80 is the figure for item 6 of the 2022 Schedule, which lists a shop assistant (page 37). His extract of the 2022 Order ends at item 10, page 38 and omits the cashier entry. In the 2018 Schedule the cashier is item 11, at Kshs. 30,627.45 - page 33.
A party is bound by his pleadings and the Appellant cannot recover as a cashier at the appeal stage. In any case the Respondent’s witness statement does not say he was a cashier. It says he was a general worker, page 44 and its references to cashiers at paragraphs 5 and 6 are to other employees with whom it says he colluded. The submission that the Respondent confirmed he was a cashier is not borne out. The argument on the word or in the letter of employment does not carry his case. The letter allows the Respondent to assign other duties. That says what the Respondent could require. It does not prove what the Appellant actually did, and the burden of proving that he worked as a shop assistant stayed with him.
The trial court said it accepts the contractual designation. That was imprecise, since the letter does not designate him a shop assistant. But the result was right. The claim failed because the Appellant did not prove the category on which it depended.
The Respondent argues that as a general worker his pay of Kshs. 17,000.00 exceeded the 2022 minimum of Kshs. 15,201.65 in item 1 of the Schedule, see page 35. That figure is a basic wage exclusive of housing allowance. No housing allowance claim was pleaded and I make no finding on it. The claim before the trial court was for the shop assistant rate and it was not proved.
The computation also rests on a start date the evidence does not support. The Appellant claims underpayment from January, 2019 but his letter of employment is dated 7th December, 2019 - page 47 and the Respondent’s witness gives the same date, page 44. His NSSF statement records 26th June 2019, page 11. The 2022 Order also came into operation on 1st May, 2022 not in July 2022 as the claim assumes - page 34.
I find that the Appellant did not prove that he was entitled to the shop assistant rate, and so did not prove underpayment. The trial court was right to dismiss the claim. Ground 2 therefore fails.
The 4th issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in dismissing the claims for leave allowance and for the January, 2023 salary. The Appellant’s submissions say nothing about the dismissal of the claims for leave allowance and January, 2023 salary. The appeal is however against the whole Judgment and the Respondent has answered both heads, so I deal with them briefly.
The leave claim is for a leave allowance of Kshs. 20,517.80 for 2023. The Appellant pointed to no term of his contract and no provision of the Employment Act, 2007 that gives a leave allowance of a month’s pay. He pleaded and proved no accrued and untaken leave days. His own evidence is that he was on leave when the Respondent called him - page 7. The trial court rightly found the claim unsubstantiated.
The January salary stands differently. The trial court dismissed that claim because the Respondent produced a payslip and a statement of remittance of funds to NSSF, which demonstrate payment of the Claimant’s salary and because these records were not rebutted by the Claimant - page 68. Both statements are open to question on the record.
The Appellant did rebut the point. In his pleading, his witness statement and his evidence he said he was not paid his salary for January, 2023 - pages 1, 7 and 73.
A pay advice slip is the employer’s own statement of what is due and what is deducted. It does not prove that money reached the employee. This one shows gross pay of Kshs. 17,000.00 and net pay of Kshs. 16,200.00 - page 49. The NSSF statement shows a contribution of Kshs. 400.00 for January, 2023 - page 11. That records a statutory remittance, not payment of net pay.
Payment of wages is a fact especially within the employer’s knowledge. Section 112 of the Evidence Act places the burden of proving such a fact on the party who holds that knowledge. The Respondent paid its staff by bank transfer, and the Appellant’s 2022 statement shows monthly credits described as SAL LEVS TRADING COMPANY LIMITE - pages 12 to 29. It produced no bank record for January, 2023 and its witness did not say that the January salary was paid. The Appellant’s bank statement stops at 31st December, 2022 – see page 29 so it does not help him either. But the burden on this fact lay on the Respondent, and the documents it relied on do not discharge it.
The Respondent has never said that the January, 2023 salary was not due. Its case is that it was paid. This court finds that payment was not proved. The trial court misapprehended what the payslip and NSSF statement show and overlooked that the Appellant had denied receipt. I set aside the dismissal of that claim.
The Appellant claimed Kshs. 20,517.80 on the shop assistant rate, and that rate has failed. The Respondent’s own payslip puts his gross pay for January, 2023 at Kshs. 17,000.00. I award that sum. It is noted, for accuracy that the Respondent’s submissions say the trial court awarded Kshs. 19,800.00 in lieu of notice. The certified judgment awards Kshs. 17,000.00 - page 68. I have had regard to the judgment itself, and not to either party’s characterisation of it.
The 5th issue for determination is whether the Appellant is entitled to any further relief and who should bear the costs of the appeal. The appeal succeeds on one point only, the claim for January, 2023 salary. It fails on termination, compensation, underpayment and leave allowance. The award of notice pay, the order for a certificate of service and the order for costs in the trial court are not challenged by the Respondent and are undisturbed. The trial court awarded costs plus interest without stating the rate or the date from which interest runs. To avoid doubt, interest on the sums awarded shall run at court rates from 30th July, 2025 the date of the trial court’s judgment, until payment in full.
On the costs of this appeal, section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act aforecited gives this court discretion to make such orders as to costs as it considers just. The Respondent’s reliance on section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act is misplaced. The appeal succeeded in part as the alleged fraud was not proved. Each party shall bear its own costs of the appeal.
I am therefore inclined to partially allow the appeal and order as follows;
(i) The dismissal of the claim for salary for January, 2023 is set aside.
(ii) The award of salary in lieu of notice made by the trial court is upheld.
(iii) The Appellant is therefore awarded relief thus:
Salary in lieu of notice…………………………………….…..Kshs. 17,000.00
Salary for January 2023…………………………………….….Kshs. 17,000.00
Total of award………………………………………..………Kshs. 34,000.00
(iv) The remainder of the Judgment delivered on 30th July 2025 in Milimani MCELRC Cause No. E642 of 2023 is upheld, including the dismissal of the claims for compensation, underpayment and leave allowance, the order for a certificate of service within 30 days and also the order for costs in the trial court.
(v) The sums awarded in order (iii) above shall carry interest at court rates from 30th July, 2025 until payment in full.
(vi) Each party shall bear their costs of the appeal.
Delivered, dated and signed this 30th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Misiga instructed by Misiga & Company Advocates for the Appellant.
2. Miss Kemunto instructed by Eno & Associates Advocates for the Respondent.