Employment law

Anyoma & 6 others v Principal Secretary, Ministry of Health & another [2026] KEELRC 14960 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Judicial Review Application E002 of 2026
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Ex parte Applicants are judgment holders against the 1st Respondent. The Decree remains unsatisfied. Pursuant to leave of the court issued on 13 January 2026, vide an application dated 20 January 2026, by way of notice of motion under Order 53 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules and section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, the ex parte applicants seek for an Order of Mandamus compelling the 1st Respondent to satisfy a lawful…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The court noted that both parties addressed the issue of whether the respondents could be compelled to settle the decretal sum before the funds were budgeted and approved by the Treasury and whether the application was merited.

Paragraph 9 →

Reasoning passage

The respondent raised a defence of lack of budgetary allocation. I find nothing in the law that requires a budgetary allocation before enforcement to satisfy the decree under section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act. The respondent's position is mistaken, as what is before the court is an application for enforcement, not a contempt of court proceeding. The order of mandamus is available to enforce the duty of the accounting officer…

Paragraph 32 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Principal Secretary, Ministry of Health could be compelled by mandamus to satisfy a Government decree before funds were budgeted and approved by the National Treasury; and whether the judicial review application was meritorious.

Material facts

The seven ex parte applicants held an unsatisfied decree arising from ELRC Petition No. E041 of 2023. The underlying judgment of 20 November 2023 declared the respondent’s conduct unconstitutional and awarded each applicant Kshs. 565,640, plus interest and…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

JUDICIAL REVIEW DIVISION AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E002 OF 2026

DR. ONSARE M. ANYONA & 6 OTHERS………………………………………………EX-PARTE APPLICANTS

VERSUS

THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HEALTH............................................... 1ST RESPONDENT

AND

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL...............................................................INTERESTED PARTY

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. The Ex parte Applicants are judgment holders against the 1st Respondent. The Decree remains unsatisfied. Pursuant to leave of the court issued on 13 January 2026, vide an application dated 20 January 2026, by way of notice of motion under Order 53 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules and section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, the ex parte applicants seek for an Order of Mandamus compelling the 1st Respondent to satisfy a lawful decree arising from ELRC Petition No. E041 of 2023, Dr. Onsare M. Anyona & 6 Others - vs- Ministry of Health & 2 Others. They also seek costs of the application.

2. The judicial review application was accompanied by a statement of facts dated 20th January 2026 and an affidavit verifying the facts of even date, in which the ex parte applicants annexed documents in support of the application.

3. The Respondent subsequently filed Grounds of Opposition dated 9th March 2026, contending that payment could not be made because the decretal amount had not been included in the current budget cycle and would be considered in the next financial year, 2026/2027.

The Ex Parte Applicants’ case

4. Judgment in Dr. Onsare M. Anyona & 6 Others -vs- Ministry of Health & 2 Others was delivered on 20th November 2023 by Hon. Justice Byram Ongaya (as he then was). The Court declared the Respondent's conduct unconstitutional and awarded each Applicant a sum of Kshs. 565,640 together with interest and costs.

5. Following the Judgment, a Decree was extracted, and a Certificate of Order Against Government was issued on 29th September 2025, certifying the amount payable as Kshs.5,180,760.09, inclusive of interest and taxed costs (annexures OMA-1, OMA-2 and OMA-3, respectively).

6. The Ex Parte Applicants served the Ministry of Health, the Attorney General and relevant Government offices on 5th October 2025. Despite service and subsequent follow-ups, payment was not made, compelling the Applicants to institute these proceedings on 20th January 2026. (Annexure OMA-4 were the affidavits of service)

Response

7. The 1st Respondent, through the Office of the Attorney General, subsequently filed Grounds of Opposition dated 9th March 2026, contending that payment could not be made because the decretal amount had not been included in the current budget cycle and would be considered in the next financial year. The respondent did not contest the decree but stated that they are bound to ensure that any disbursement of public funds follows the mandatory appropriation process.

DETERMINATION

8. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions. Both parties complied.

9. The court noted that both parties addressed the issue of whether the respondents could be compelled to settle the decretal sum before the funds were budgeted and approved by the Treasury and whether the application was merited.

10. The court discerned there were 2 issues for determination in the judicial review application -

a) Whether the respondents can be compelled to settle the decretal sum before the funds are budgeted for and approved by the Treasury

b) Whether the application is meritorious.

The law.

11. Section 53 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules

12. Section 21 (1 and 2) of the Government Proceedings Act

13. Order 29 (1 and 2) of the Civil Procedure Rules

Whether the respondents can be compelled to settle the decretal sum before the funds are budgeted for and approved by the Treasury

14. The respondents do not dispute the Decree but raise a defence of lack of budget appropriation. They submit as follows-

15. The Respondents submit that payment of decretal sums by Government Ministries, Departments and Agencies is governed by the Constitution, the Public Finance Management Act, No. 18 of 2012, and the Government Proceedings Act, Cap. 40. Consequently, the Respondents cannot lawfully settle the decretal sum unless the funds have been appropriated by Parliament and released through the National Treasury.

16. Section 12 of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012 (PFM) mandates the National Treasury to manage the budget process and ensure all expenditure is within approved estimates-

"The National Treasury shall have the following functions, in addition to those in subsection (1)-

(a)promote transparency, effective management and accountability with regard to public finances in the national government;

(b)ensure proper management and control of, and accounting for the finances of the government and its entities in order to promote the efficient and effective use of budgetary resources;

(c)co-ordinate the preparation of annual appropriation accounts and other statutory financial reports by the national government and its entities;

(d)prepare annual estimates of revenue of the national government, and co-ordinate the preparation of the budget of the national government;"

17. Section 39 of the PFM Act requires that budget estimates be submitted to Parliament and approved before any commitment or expenditure-

"The National Assembly shall consider and pass the Finance Bill, with or without amendments, in time for it to be presented for assent by 30th June each year. (4) Any recommendations made by the relevant committee of the National Assembly or resolution passed by the National Assembly on revenue matters shall-(a)ensure that the total amount of revenue raised is consistent with the approved fiscal framework."

18. Section 40 of the PFM Act is categorical: -

"No public money shall be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund or any public fund except in accordance with an appropriation by Parliament."

19. Section 44 of the PFM Act further provides that reallocation of funds can only be done with approval of the National Treasury and, where necessary, Parliament, with a supplementary budget in support of money spent under Article 223 of the Constitution.

‘(2) After Parliament has approved spending under subsection (1), an Appropriation Bill shall be introduced for the appropriation of the money spent."

20. Therefore, the Respondent have no legal power to withdraw or pay the decretal sum in the absence of such appropriation.

21. The Respondent contended that the decretal sum has not been factored in the Current Financial Year Budget. It was also not included in the Supplementary Estimates for this Financial Year 2025/2026, the Ministry has already initiated internal processes to have the amount captured in the FY 2026/2027 budget estimates for onward approval by the National Treasury and Parliament. This is not refusal to pay. It is compliance with mandatory fiscal discipline. Kenyan courts will not issue orders that are impossible to comply with or that would require a party to act illegally. The Respondents distinguish between willful disobedience and legal incapacity. The Applicant seeks coercive orders premised on alleged contempt. However, contempt cannot lie where compliance is legally impossible.

22. The Respondent further submitted that Article 201(b) of the Constitution requires prudent use of public money-

"The public finance system shall promote an equitable society, and in particular-(i)the burden of taxation shall be shared fairly;

(ii) revenue raised nationally shall be shared equitably among national and county governments; and

(iii)expenditure shall promote the equitable development of the country, including by making special provision for marginalized groups and areas;"

23. The Respondent submitted that paying outside the budget would violate this constitutional principle and expose accounting officers to surcharge under Section 205 of the PFM Act.15. The Respondents therefore urge the Court to find that there is no contempt, but rather a need for reasonable time to comply once funds are appropriated. They have demonstrated good faith by engaging the National Treasury to have the amount programmed in FY 2026/2027. Filing these Grounds of Opposition was intended to explain the procedural constraints. This negates any allegation of bad faith. The Court's role in such circumstances is supervisory, to set timelines for compliance, not to punish.

24. Conversely, the ex parte applicants submitted that it is not disputed that Judgment was delivered on 20th November 2023 in favour of the Applicants. Equally, it is not disputed that a Decree was extracted, costs were taxed, and a Certificate of Order Against Government was issued and served in compliance with Section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act. The Respondent has also not alleged that the Judgment has been appealed, stayed, varied or set aside. Accordingly, the Decree remains valid, binding and enforceable.

25. The Respondent's opposition rests entirely on the proposition that settlement depends upon budgetary allocation and Treasury processes. With respect, that position cannot stand in law. Government administrative arrangements cannot supersede a court decree nor can internal financial procedures operate to suspend judicial authority. Once a Certificate of Order Against Government is issued and served, a public duty crystallises upon the accounting officer concerned. The Principal Secretary, as the Ministry's accounting officer, bears a statutory obligation to facilitate the settlement of lawful obligations against the Ministry. That obligation is mandatory, not optional.

26. The ex parte applicants relied on the case of Republic vs. Permanent Secretary, Ministry of State for Provincial Administration and Internal Security Exparte Fredrick Manoah Egunza [2012] eKLR as quoted in Republic v Attorney General & Principal Secretary, Ministry of Education ex parte Samuel Ndungu Wainaina (Miscellaneous Civil Application 366 of 2013) [2017] KEHC 8928 (KLR) (Judicial Review) (28 June 2017) (Ruling) where the court held as follows:-

"The only requirement which serves as a condition precedent to the satisfaction or enforcement of decrees for money issued against the Government is found in Section 21(1) and (2) of the Government Proceedings Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act) which provides that payment will be based on a certificate of costs obtained by the successful litigant from the court issuing the decree which should be served on the Hon Attorney General. The certificate of order against the Government should be issued by the court after expiration of 21 days after entry of judgment. Once the certificate of order against the Government is served on the Hon Attorney General, Section 21(3) imposes a statutory duty on the accounting officer concerned to pay the sums specified in the said order to the person entitled or to his advocate together with any interest lawfully accruing thereon."

Decision

27. The ex parte applicants seek an Order of Mandamus to enforce the Judgment in Dr Onsare M. Anyona & 6 Others -vs- Ministry of Health & 2 Others, delivered on 20th November 2023 by the Hon. Justice Byram Ongaya (as he then was). The Court declared the Respondent's conduct unconstitutional and awarded each Applicant Kshs. 565,640, together with interest and costs.

28. Following the Judgment, a Decree was extracted and a Certificate of Order Against Government was issued on 29th September 2025, certifying the amount payable as Kshs.5,180,760.09, inclusive of interest and taxed costs (annexures OMA-1, OMA-2 and OMA-3, respectively). The Decree and Certificate Against Government are not contested. The defence is based on a lack of budgetary allocation.

29. It is not disputed that the decree is against the Government and that it has not been satisfied. How is the ex parte applicant to realise the fruits of the judgment? Execution by attachment of property cannot be issued against the Government. The procedure for enforcing the decree is provided for under section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, to wit –

‘ 21. Satisfaction of orders against the Government

(1)Where in any civil proceedings by or against the Government, or in proceedings in connection with any arbitration in which the Government is a party, any order (including an order for costs) is made by any court in favour of any person against the Government, or against a Government department, or against an officer of the Government as such, the proper officer of the court shall, on an application in that behalf made by or on behalf of that person at any time after the expiration of twenty-one days from the date of the order or, in case the order provides for the payment of costs and the costs require to be taxed, at any time after the costs have been taxed, whichever is the later, issue to that person a certificate in the prescribed form containing particulars of the order:

Provided that, if the court so directs, a separate certificate shall be issued with respect to the costs (if any) ordered to be paid to the applicant.

(2)A copy of any certificate issued under this section may be served by the person in whose favour the order is made upon the Attorney-General.

(3)If the order provides for the payment of any money by way of damages or otherwise, or of any costs, the certificate shall state the amount so payable, and the Accounting Officer for the Government department concerned shall, subject as hereinafter provided, pay to the person entitled or to his advocate the amount appearing by the certificate to be due to him together with interest, if any, lawfully due thereon:

Provided that the court by which any such order as aforesaid is made or any court to which an appeal against the order lies may direct that, pending an appeal or otherwise, payment of the whole of any amount so payable, or any part thereof, shall be suspended, and if the certificate has not been issued may order any such direction to be inserted therein.

(4)Save as aforesaid, no execution or attachment or process in the nature thereof shall be issued out of any such court for enforcing payment by the Government of any such money or costs as aforesaid, and no person shall be individually liable under any order for the payment by the Government, or any Government department, or any officer of the Government as such, of any money or costs.’

30. The court noted there is no order of stay of execution. Order21 Rule 3 (above) is categorical that on being issued with a certificate against the Government, the accounting officer for the Government concerned, the 1st respondent herein, shall pay to the person entitled or his advocate the amount appearing by the certificate to be due to him together with interest, if any, lawful and due.

31. The ex parte applicants have complied with and served the certificate of order against the Government under section 21(1) of the Government Proceedings Act and Order 29 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The certificate was dated 29th September 2025 (OMA-2). Service of the same was undisputed.

32. The respondent raised a defence of lack of budgetary allocation. I find nothing in the law that requires a budgetary allocation before enforcement to satisfy the decree under section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act. The respondent's position is mistaken, as what is before the court is an application for enforcement, not a contempt of court proceeding. The order of mandamus is available to enforce the duty of the accounting officer to comply with the certificate of order against government. In defining the scope of the Order of Mandamus, the Court of Appeal in Kenya National Examination Council v Republic; GGN & 9 others (Ex parte) [1997] KECA 58 (KLR) stated-

‘24. The next issue we must deal with is this: What is the scope and efficacy of an Order of Mandamus? Once again we turn to Halsbury’s Law of England, 4th Edition Volume 1 at page 111 from paragraph 89. That learned treatise says:-“The order must command no more than the party against whom the application is made is legally bound to perform. Where a general duty is imposed, a mandamus cannot require it to be done at once. Where a statute, which imposes a duty leaves discretion as to the mode of performing the duty in the hands of the party on whom the obligation is laid, a mandamus cannot command the duty in question to be carried out in a specific way.’

33. The ex parte applicants, like all other litigants, are entitled to realise the fruits of his judgment. They have complied with the lawful procedure under the Government Proceedings Act, section 21. The court has an obligation to issue the remedy of an order of Mandamus. The defence of budgetary allocations cannot lie to defeat the order sought of Mandamus to compel compliance with the judgment of the court/ I was persuaded by the decision relied on by the ex parte applicants in Republic vs. Permanent Secretary, Ministry of State for Provincial Administration and Internal Security Exparte Fredrick Manoah Egunza [2012] eKLR as quoted in Republic v Attorney General & Principal Secretary, Ministry of Education ex parte Samuel Ndungu Wainaina (Miscellaneous Civil Application 366 of 2013) [2017] KEHC 8928 (KLR) (Judicial Review) (28 June 2017) (Ruling) the court held as follows:

"The only requirement which serves as a condition precedent to the satisfaction or enforcement of decrees for money issued against the Government is found in Section 21(1) and (2) of the Government Proceedings Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act) which provides that payment will be based on a certificate of costs obtained by the successful litigant from the court issuing the decree which should be served on the Hon Attorney General. ‘

Whether the application is meritorious

34. Following my finding of compliance with section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, I return in the positive that the ex parte applicants are entitled to an order of mandamus to compel compliance by the respondent with the certificate of order against the Government dated 29th September 2025.

Disposition

35. The judicial review application dated 21st January 2026 is allowed.

36. The court is pleased to issue an order of Mandamus compelling the Principal Secretary, Ministry of Health, the 1st Respondent, being the accounting officer of the Ministry, to satisfy the decretal sum of Kshs. 5,180,750.09 together with any further interest lawfully accruing thereon pursuant to the judgment of the court delivered on the 20th November 2023. The ex parte applicants are awarded costs of the application.

37. It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

exparte Applicant: Mwariri

Respondent: Kioko.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder