REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS
COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI
APPEAL NO. E069 OF 2024
FRANCIS MUSYOKI KIMEU…...……………..…...…………APPELLANT
VERSUS
CREATIVE CONSOLIDATED SYSTEMS LTD...................RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the judgment and decree of Hon. Linda Mumassabba (PM) in Nairobi Milimani MCELRC No. 865 of 2022 delivered on 14th February 2024)
JUDGMENT
1. The Appellant instituted this suit against the Respondent before the Magistrate’s Court at Milimani alleging unlawful termination of employment. He sought Kshs. 63,744.25 comprising one months’ salary in lieu of notice and severance pay. He also sought leave pay, interest on the above sums at 25% per annum from the date of termination of employment until payment in full, a certificate of service and costs of the suit. His case was that he had been engaged by the Respondent as a steward on 1st September 2015 and served continuously until 31st August 2021, when his employment was unlawfully terminated. He further contended that at the time of termination, he earned a monthly salary of Kshs. 14,165.50.
2. The Respondent opposed the claim through a Response to Memorandum of Claim dated 12th April 2023. Its case was that the Appellant’s employment did not terminate unlawfully but came to an end by effluxion of time. The Respondent averred that the Appellant had initially been engaged on a fixed-term contract which was due to expire on 31st August 2021, and that he was consequently issued with a one-month notice of termination on 31st July 2021. It further averred that on 31st August 2021, the Appellant was issued with a fresh one-month fixed-term contract, expressly stated to be non-renewable. The Appellant accepted the contract and served under its terms until it lapsed by effluxion of time. On that basis, the Respondent urged the Trial Court to dismiss the claim, contending that it was an attempt by the Appellant to unfairly derive benefits from the Respondent.
3. Upon considering the pleadings, evidence and submissions, the Trial Magistrate, in a judgment dated 14th February 2024, found that the Appellant’s employment had come to an end by effluxion of time. The Trial Magistrate nevertheless found merit in the claim for accrued leave and awarded the Appellant Kshs. 8,027.11. He also directed the Respondent to issue the Appellant with a certificate of service. Aggrieved by that decision, the Appellant lodged the present appeal through a Memorandum of Appeal dated 14th March 2024, raising the following grounds:
(1) That the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in failing to award him costs of the claim even after finding part of the claim meritorious yet costs always follow the event.
(2) That the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in failing to award him leave days earned but not paid yet the burden to prove that leave days earned by the Claimant were paid rested with the Respondent which burden was never discharged.
(3) That the Learned Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to award him all the prayers in the Statement of Claim dated 28th April, 2022 notwithstanding the fact that the claim was proved on a balance of probability as by law required.
(4) That the Learned trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to appreciate the facts of the case, the evidence adduced in support of the claim and the applicable law and thus arrived at a wrong decision.
4. On the basis of these grounds, the Appellant urges this Court to allow the appeal and grant the reliefs sought in the claim before the Trial Court. Alternatively, he urges this Court to make its own findings on the appeal. He also seeks the costs of the appeal.
5. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions. Although the parties were directed on 8th May 2026 to file their respective submissions, only the Appellant complied with the directions. The only document filed by the Respondent is a Replying Affidavit sworn by its Counsel, apparently in opposition to the Memorandum of Appeal. A replying affidavit is not a recognised mode of responding to an appeal. Nevertheless, the substance of the Respondent’s position, as discernible from that affidavit, is that the judgment of the Trial Court was sound and ought not to be disturbed.
Appellant’s Submissions
6. In support of the appeal, the Appellant identifies four issues for determination, namely:
(a) Whether the Trial Magistrate erred in finding that his employment terminated by effluxion of time;
(b) Whether the Trial Magistrate erred in dismissing his claim for unfair and unlawful termination;
(c) Whether the Trial Magistrate erred in failing to award the leave dues claimed; and
(d) Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in failing to award costs.
7. On the first issue, the Appellant submits that the finding that his employment terminated by effluxion of time was unsupported by evidence. He points out that the alleged fixed-term contract was not produced and that the Respondent did not call any witness to establish its existence or terms. He further submits that the termination notice dated 31st July 2021 merely referred to the contract but did not, of itself, establish its existence, terms or duration. The Appellant therefore contends that the Respondent failed to discharge the burden imposed by section 10(7) of the Employment Act, which places upon an employer the burden of proving or disproving an alleged term of employment where the written contract is not produced. In the circumstances, he submits that the Trial Magistrate erred in relying on Registered Trustees of the Presbyterian Church of East Africa & another v Ruth Gathoni Ngotho-Kariuki [2017] eKLR, which concerned an established fixed-term contract whose terms were not in dispute, unlike the present case where the contract was not produced.
8. On the second issue, the Appellant submits that the Trial Magistrate erred in finding that the Respondent had discharged the burden imposed by sections 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act despite the Respondent having neither called a witness nor produced documentary evidence in support of its defence. Relying on CMC Aviation Ltd v Mohammed Noor [2018] eKLR, he submits that pleadings unsupported by evidence remain mere statements. He also relies on Naima Khamis v Oxford University Press (E.A.) Ltd [2017] eKLR, in which the Court of Appeal held that termination of employment is unfair where an employer fails to establish a valid reason for termination or adhere to fair procedure.
9. With regard to compliance with sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, the Appellant submits that there was no evidence that he was informed of any allegations against him, invited to a disciplinary hearing, informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague to the hearing, or afforded an opportunity to make representations before his employment was terminated. Relying on Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR, he submits that compliance with section 41 is mandatory and that the Respondent failed to demonstrate compliance with the prescribed procedural safeguards. He therefore maintains that the Trial Magistrate erred in failing to find that the termination was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
10. On the issue of leave dues, the Appellant submits that the Trial Magistrate erred in limiting the award to Kshs 8,027.11, particularly in view of the Respondent’s failure to produce employment records as required under section 74 of the Employment Act. He therefore asserts that the Court reached its decision on the basis of unproven records.
11. On costs, the Appellant submits that he ought to have been awarded costs having been compelled to institute proceedings and incur legal expenses in order to vindicate his rights. He further points out that the Respondent did not call any witness to substantiate its defence. He therefore urges the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour and award him the costs of both the proceedings before the Trial Court and the present appeal. Accordingly, he urges the Court to allow the appeal.
Disposition
12. This being a first appeal, I am obliged to evaluate and examine the record before the Magistrates' Court and the evidence presented before that Court in order to arrive at my own conclusion. This principle of law was enunciated in the celebrated case of Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123 where the Court of Appeal outlined the duties of a first appellate court as follows:
"I accept counsel for the respondent's proposition that this court is not bound necessarily to accept the findings of fact by the court below. An appeal to this court is by way of retrial and the principles upon which this court acts in such an appeal are well settled. Briefly put they are that this court must reconsider the evidence, evaluate it itself and draw its own conclusions though it should always bear in mind that it has neither seen nor heard the witnesses and should make due allowance in this respect."
[Emphasis supplied]
13. Having properly warned myself that I neither saw nor heard the Appellant testify in trial, I have duly evaluated the evidence presented in the Trial Court, and which evidence and documents in support thereof, are before this Court and I have come to the following determination.
14. The appeal before me was apparently opposed by the Respondent. I say so because the only document filed by the Respondent is a Replying Affidavit sworn by its Counsel, ostensibly in opposition to the Memorandum of Appeal. A replying affidavit is not a recognised mode of responding to an appeal. Nevertheless, the substance of the Respondent’s position, as discernible from that affidavit, is that the judgment of the Trial Court was sound and ought not to be disturbed.
15. In cases where termination of employment is an issue, various sections come into play. These are principally sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act as well as sections 10 and 74 where the issue of contract of employment and employment records are concerned. In this case, the employer denied the contract was terminated asserting the same ended by effluxion of time. Despite these assertions in the defence filed, no contract was exhibited and as such there was no evidence led to prove there was determination of the contract of employment by effluxion of time. The Appellant had sued seeking payment of one month’s notice and severance pay. Severance pay is due where termination occurs on account of redundancy under section 40 of the Employment Act. In the case before the Learned Magistrate, the issue of redundancy did not arise and the circumstances of this case did not speak to any declaration of redundancy. In my considered opinion, there was no basis for an award of any relief for severance pay.
16. The Appellant had been engaged as a steward and he earned Kshs. 14,165.50 at the material time. He had sought one month’s salary in lieu of notice. The Appellant also sought interest at 25% per annum on the sums claimed. The statutory default interest rate applied in Kenya is between 6% and 12%. Where a contract provides for a rate of interest that is above the statutory minima, there is basis for an award of such a high rate of interest. However, commercial rates of interest do not ordinarily apply to contracts of employment. In this case, there was no justification for claiming a commercial rate of interest and there was no basis for any award of interest beyond the rate of 12% per annum.
17. As regards, the mode and manner of termination of the contract, the employ of the Appellant herein was terminated by the Respondent without due regard to procedure in terms of section 41 of the Employment Act and for that he would be entitled to a modest sum of Kshs. 28,331/- being 2 months salary as compensation for unlawful termination of employment. The Appellant will also have the sum awarded by the Trial Court being Kshs. 8,027.11 being accrued leave. The Appellant will also have costs of the suit before the Magistrate’s Court as well as on this Appeal.
18. In the final result the judgment and decree of the Learned Magistrate are set aside and the same substituted with a Judgment in favour of the Appellant as follows:
a. Kshs. 28,331/- being 2 months salary as compensation for unlawful termination of employment.
b. Kshs. 8,027.11 being accrued leave
c. Costs of the suit before the Magistrate’s Court as well as on this Appeal.
d. Interest on the sums in (a) and (b) above at court rates from the date of this Judgment till payment in full.
It is so ordered.
Dated and delivered at Kisumu this 3rd day of November 2026
Nzioki wa Makau, MCIArb.
JUDGE