Employment law

Garfield Promotions Ltd v Manji [2026] KEELRC 14942 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E346 of 2024
Judgment date
3 November 2026
Judge(s)
Nzioki wa Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

In a judgment delivered on 13th September 2024, the Learned Trial Magistrate found that the Respondent had been constructively dismissed as a result of the Appellant's failure to pay her salary from May to October 2019, which culminated in her resignation on 14th October 2019. The court consequently awarded the Respondent the following reliefs:

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS

COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI

APPEAL NO. E346 OF 2024

GARFIELD PROMOTIONS LIMITED.……………..…...……APPELLANT

VERSUS

EDDAH WAMBUI MANJI……….…...………….................RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal from the judgment and decree of Hon. B. M Cheloti (PM) in Nairobi Milimani MCELRC No. E537 of 2022 delivered on 13th September 2024)

JUDGMENT

1. In a judgment delivered on 13th September 2024, the Learned Trial Magistrate found that the Respondent had been constructively dismissed as a result of the Appellant's failure to pay her salary from May to October 2019, which culminated in her resignation on 14th October 2019. The court consequently awarded the Respondent the following reliefs:

(a) Kshs. 50,000/- for a dishonoured cheque issued in settlement of the matter;

(b) Kshs. 360,000/-, being the equivalent of twelve months' salary as compensation for unlawful termination;

(c) Kshs. 189,000/- in unpaid salary for May – October 2019;

(d) Kshs. 90,000/- gratuity; and

(e) Kshs. 126,000/- for untaken leave/unpaid leave days.

2. The Appellant was dissatisfied and it lodged a Memorandum of Appeal dated 3rd December 2024 contending that:

(i) The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact by accepting uncorroborated evidence by the Respondent in arriving at the decision that the Respondent was employed by the Appellant Company for the period alleged in her Statement of Claim.

(ii) The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact by awarding the Respondent reliefs founded on allegations that were unsupported by evidence contrary to the Evidence Act and rules of evidence.

(iii) The Learned Magistrate erred in law and in fact by arriving at the fact that the Respondent was unfairly terminated despite the Respondent's own communication stating that she was resigning her position.

(iv) The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law by failing to appreciate that the Respondent's evidence did not rise to the limit of dispatching the burden of proof as it ought to in order to place the evidentiary burden on the Appellant.

(v) The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and in law by considering issues of evidence that had no bearing to the actual suit as was filed by the Respondent as against the Appellant and therefore arriving at the disputed conclusion.

3. On the strength of these grounds, the Appellant urges this Court to allow the appeal, set aside the judgment of the Trial Court, and substitute it with an order dismissing the Respondent's suit with costs. The Appellant further seeks costs of both the appeal and the proceedings before the Trial Court.

4. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Appellant's Submissions

5. In support of the appeal the Appellant identified the following issues which according to it were dispositive of the appeal:

(1) Whether the Respondent sufficiently proved an employer-employee relationship;

(2) Whether the Respondent was constructively dismissed;

(3) Whether the Respondent is entitled to the reliefs awarded by the Trial Court.

6. On the first issue, the Appellant submits that the Trial Magistrate erred in relying solely on a bank statement for the month of July 2018 as proof of employment. It contends that the burden of proving the existence of an employment relationship lay with the Respondent. In support of that proposition, the Appellant relies on the case of Josephine M. Ndungu & others v Plan International Inc. [2019] KEELRC 663 (KLR) and Zamzam Wholesalers Limited v Otieno [2024] KEELRC 13453 (KLR), in which the court affirmed that, under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, the burden of proving unfair termination rests with the employee.

7. On the issue of constructive dismissal, the Appellant submits that the Respondent's continued service without seeking judicial intervention demonstrated that the working environment was not intolerable. It asserts that the Respondent voluntarily resigned for reasons unrelated to her employment and had acquiesced in the prevailing working conditions.

8. On entitlement to the reliefs sought, the Appellant submits that the Respondent failed to discharge her burden of proof, hence she is not entitled to any of the remedies granted by the trial court. Reliance is placed on Joseph Ogembo Mose v Lochab Company Bros Company Ltd [2019] KEELRC 1096 (KLR), where the court declined to award damages after finding that the claimant had failed to establish the existence of an employer–employee relationship.

Respondent's Submissions

9. On her part the Respondent identifies the following issues for determination:

(a) Whether the appeal is merited; and

(b) Who should bear costs of the appeal.

10. As a preliminary issue, the Respondent submits that the appeal is incompetent for failure to include the decree appealed from in the Record of Appeal, contrary to Order 42 Rule 13(4)(f) of the Civil Procedure Rules. In support of that contention, she relies on Bwana Mohamed Bwana v Silvano Buko Bonaya & 2 others [2015] eKLR, where the Supreme Court held that an appeal filed without the requisite record is incompetent and deprives the appellate court of jurisdiction to determine the factual and legal controversies raised therein.

11. On the merits, the Respondent reiterates that her resignation on 14th October 2019 was occasioned by the Appellant's persistent failure to pay her salary, which created an intolerable and hostile working environment. On the existence of an employer–employee relationship, she submits that the Appellant failed to adduce any evidence disproving that relationship. She relies on Palace Investments Ltd v Geoffrey Kariuki Mwenda & another [2015] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that proof on a balance of probabilities requires a party to establish that its version of events is more probable than not. She also cites Miller v Minister of Pensions [1947] 2 All ER 372, which held that a fact is proved where it is shown to be more probable than not, as well as sections 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, which place the burden of proving a fact on the party who asserts it. The Respondent further contends that the Appellant's assertion that she voluntarily resigned is inconsistent with its simultaneous denial of the existence of an employment relationship, and therefore amounts to approbation and reprobation. She accordingly urges the Court to dismiss the appeal with costs.

Disposition

12. On appeal, a Court has to analyse the evidence noting it did not hear the parties and make allowance for that. In the case of Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123 and restated in the case of Kenya Ports Authority v Kuston (Kenya) Limited [2009] 2 EA 212 the Court of Appeal rendered itself as follows:

"On a first appeal from the High Court, the Court of Appeal should reconsider the evidence, evaluate it itself and draw its own conclusions though it should always bear in mind that it has neither seen nor heard the witnesses and should make due allowance in that respect. Secondly that the responsibility of the court is to rule on the evidence on record and not to introduce extraneous matters not dealt with by the parties in the evidence."

[Underline for emphasis]

13. It is trite that the responsibility of this Court is to rule on the evidence on record and not to introduce extraneous matters that were not dealt with by the parties in the evidence they presented before the Learned Magistrate at the Nairobi Milimani Chief Magistrates Court. Having properly warned myself that I neither saw nor heard the Appellant nor the Respondent testify in trial, I have carefully evaluated the evidence the parties presented in the Trial Court, and which evidence and documents in support thereof, are before this Court and I have come to the following determination.

14. The Appellant herein disavows the existence of the relationship of employee-employer. Simultaneously, there is an assertion that the Respondent acquiesced to the situation then obtaining and voluntarily resigned for reasons unrelated to her employment. The Appellant asserts the Respondent's continued service without seeking judicial intervention demonstrated that the working environment was not intolerable.

15. The fallacy of the arguments placed before the Court on appeal are evident in the dichotomy between an assertion there is no employment relationship and the argument that the termination of the employment was not for the reasons stated by the Respondent and as found by the Learned Trial Magistrate. In my considered view, the two are incompatible as they are antithesis of each other. One cannot resign from employment with another if there was no employment relationship in the first place. I reject the argument that there was no employment relationship established.

16. The Appellant preferred an appeal against the judgment and decree of the Learned Magistrate made in Nairobi Milimani MCELRC No. E537 of 2022 delivered on 13th September 2024 but curiously did not include a copy of the decree issued therein. That seems to be an error that would otherwise incapacitate the appeal before me. Under the Employment & Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024, there is no express provision on the consequences for the failure to include of the copy of the decree appealed from. This may therefore seem to suggest that failure to include the decree is not fatal to the appeal as the Rules of the Court provide for a memorandum of appeal which shall be accompanied by a record of appeal comprising a certified copy of pleadings, the proceedings, any documentary evidence relied on, and the judgment, ruling, decision, order, decree or award appealed against. It does not avail of a similar position as Order 42 Rule 13(4)(f) of the Civil Procedure Rules.

17. The Court has evaluated the evidence adduced before the Learned Magistrate and ascertains that there was consideration of the elements of what constitutes constructive dismissal. In the case of Coca Cola East & Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] KECA 394 (KLR) the Court of Appeal held as follows from paragraph 29 et seq.:

29. What is the key element and test to determine if constructive dismissal has taken place? The factual circumstances giving rise to constructive dismissal are varied. The key element in the definition of constructive dismissal is that the employee must have been entitled or have the right to leave without notice because of the employer's conduct. Entitled to leave has two interpretations which gives rise to the test to be applied. The first interpretation is that the employee could leave when the employer's behavior towards him was so unreasonable that he could not be expected to stay - this is the unreasonable test. The second interpretation is that the employer's conduct is so grave that it constituted a repudiatory breach of the contract of employment - this is the contractual test. The contractual test is narrower than the reasonable test. The dicta in Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd. v Sharp [1978] ICR 222 adopts the contractual approach test and we are persuaded that the test is narrow, precise and appropriate to prevent manipulation or overstretching the concept of constructive dismissal. For this reason, we affirm and adopt the contractual test approach. This means that whenever an employee alleges constructive dismissal, a court must evaluate if the conduct of the employer was such as to constitute a repudiatory breach of the contract of employment. Whether a particular breach of contract is repudiatory is one of mixed fact and law. (See Pedersen v Camden London Borough Council [1981] ICR 674). The criterion for evaluating the employers conduct is objective; the employer's conduct does not have to be intentional or in bad faith before it can be repudiatory (See Office v Roberts (1980) IRLR 347). The employee must be able to show that he left in response to the employer's conduct (i.e. causal link must be shown, i.e. the test is causation). In the case of Jones v F. Sirl & son (Furnishers) Ltd. [1997] IRLR 493, it was held that there can still be constructive dismissal if the employee waits to leave until he has found another job to go to. The employee must leave because of the breach but the breach need not be the sole cause so long as it is the effective cause. (See Walker v Josiah Wedgwood & Sons. Ltd. [1978] IRLR 105). The criterion to determine if constructive dismissal has taken place is repudiatory breach of contract through conduct of the employer. The burden of proof lies with the employee. The employer's conduct must be such as when viewed objectively, it amounts to a repudiatory and fundamental breach of the contractual obligations. (See Wooder v Wimpey [1980] 1 WLR 277; see also Malik and Mahmud v Bank of Credit and Commerce International [1998] AC 20). If the employee makes it clear that he or she is working under protest, he/she is not to be taken to have waived the right to terminate the contract under constructive dismissal. We adopt the dicta in the above cited persuasive judicial decisions as establishing relevant principles in constructive dismissal.

30. The legal principles relevant to determining constructive dismissal include the following:

a. What are the fundamental or essential terms of the contract of employment?

b. Is there a repudiatory breach of the fundamental terms of the contract through conduct of the employer?

c. The conduct of the employer must be a fundamental or significant breach going to the root of the contract of employment or which shows that the employer no longer intends to be bound by one or more of the essential terms of the contract.

d. An objective test is to be applied in evaluating the employer's conduct.

e. There must be a causal link between the employer's conduct and the reason for employee terminating the contract i.e. causation must be proved.

f. An employee may leave with or without notice so long as the employer's conduct is the effective reason for termination.

g. The employee must not have accepted, waived, acquiesced or conducted himself to be estopped from asserting the repudiatory breach;

h. The employee must within a reasonable time terminate the employment relationship pursuant to the breach.

h. The burden to prove repudiatory breach or constructive dismissal is on the employee.

18. The question that was addressed by the Learned Magistrate in relation to the decision by the Respondent to terminate her services with the Appellant is within the prism of repudiatory breach of contract. The Appellant conducted itself in such a manner as to indicate it no longer wanted to be bound by the contract between it and the Respondent. By persistently refusing to pay a salary to the Respondent, the Appellant did not wish to remain in the relationship of employer-employee as the said refusal amounted to repudiation of the contract. The Appellant created the intolerable conditions featured in the case of Coca Cola v Maria Kagai Ligaga (supra) compelling the Respondent to resign as she did. The Respondent was entitled to the reliefs obtained before the Learned Magistrate and I therefore find no reason to disturb any of the determinations made in the case. The appeal before me is devoid of merit and is accordingly dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

It is so ordered.

Dated and delivered at Kisumu this 3rd day of November 2026

Nzioki wa Makau, MCIArb.

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder