Background
For determination is the Claimant’s Memorandum of Claim dated 26th April, 2024, where he seeks the following orders against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
For determination is the Claimant’s Memorandum of Claim dated 26th April, 2024, where he seeks the following orders against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →The issues for determination are:
Paragraph 58 →In conclusion, I enter Judgment in favour of the Claimant as follows: -
Paragraph 89 →On the claims for violation of constitutional rights and mental and psychological torture, the Court finds that the Claimant has not demonstrated any independent constitutional violation warranting a separate award of damages.
Paragraph 85 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E534 OF 2024
JAMES MWANGI WATHUGE.................................................CLAIMANT
VERSUS
ODEX CHEMICALS LIMITED..............................................RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. For determination is the Claimant’s Memorandum of Claim dated 26th April, 2024, where he seeks the following orders against the Respondent:-
a. A Declaration that the Respondent’s conduct of terminating the Claimant’s employment on account of alleged failure to meet set targets was in breach of the Constitution, Employment Act, in breach of the principles of natural justice and amounted to unfair and unlawful termination.
b. Damages for unfair and unlawful termination from employment equivalent to twelve (12) months’ salary totaling to Kshs.3,240,000.00 with interest thereon at court rates from the date of filing this Suit until payment thereof in full.
c. Damages for violations of the Claimant’s rights under the Constitution and Section 5 (2) and 5 (3) (b) of the Employment Act, 2007. The same to be assessed and awarded by this Honourable Court.
d. Damages for mental and psychological torture caused by the conduct of the Respondent. The same to be assessed and awarded by this Honourable Court.
e. One month’s salary in lieu of notice of Kshs. 270,000.00
f. Service pay at 15% for every year worked from 15th August, 2022 to 31st August, 2023.
g. Costs of the suit plus interest thereon from the date of filing Suit until payment in full.
2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 7th August, 2024 and subsequently filed a Response to the Memorandum of Claim dated 29th August, 2024. The Respondent also filed a witness statement dated 29th August, 2024, and a List and Bundle of Documents of even date.
3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 15th December, 2025, when the Claimant, James Mwangi Wathuge, testified as CW1, adopted his witness statement dated 26th April, 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced his list and bundle of documents of even date as Exhibits Nos. 1 and 2.
4. The Respondent’s case was heard on 27th April, 2026, when the Respondent called one witness, Margaret Mutua, its Human Resource and Administration Officer, who testified as RW1, adopted her witness statement dated 29th August, 2024, and produced the Respondent’s documents as Respondent’s Exhibits Nos. 1-7.
5. Submissions were received from both parties.
The Claimant’s Case.
6. The Claimant avers that he was initially employed by the Respondent on 15th August, 2022 under a one year contract running until 31st August, 2023, in the position of ERP and ICT Manager. He avers further that he worked diligently and to the satisfaction of the Respondent during the said period.
7. The Claimant states that following the lapse of his initial contract and on account of his exemplary performance, the Respondent offered him a new appointment as a Retail and ERP Support Manager commencing on 18th September, 2023. He avers that he executed the appointment letter on 1st September, 2023.
8. It is his case that on or about 14th March, 2024, he was invited to attend a meeting with the directors which was presented to him as a performance review meeting. He contends that the meeting was instead used to inform him that his employment was being terminated due to what the Respondent described as a decline in business.
9. The Claimant maintains that the termination was unlawful and unfair and that it was disguised as a termination on account of poor performance and failure to meet set targets. He contends that the Respondent failed to notify him of the specific shortcomings in his performance, failed to conduct meaningful consultation with him and failed to accord him an opportunity to be heard in accordance with the principles of natural justice.
10. The Claimant further states that he was not given an opportunity to attend the meeting with a colleague or representative of his choice, and maintains that he did not commit any wrongdoing during his employment and that the Respondent’s allegation that he failed to meet the set targets was part of a scheme to terminate his employment unlawfully.
11. He therefore contends that the Respondent violated his rights under Article 27 of the Constitution and Sections 5(2) and 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007, and that he suffered loss, damage and mental anguish as a result of the termination.
12. He testified that he attended a virtual meeting with the Respondent on 13th March, 2024, which was communicated to him as a performance review meeting. He stated that he was notified of the meeting two days beforehand and was given a document setting out the subject of the review.
13. It is his testimony that the document stipulated a monthly target of Kshs.2.5 million, which he had not achieved by the time of the review. He explained that he was engaging several prospective clients and referred to page 18 of the Respondent’s bundle, which contained a list of the clients he had approached. He stated that he was awaiting purchase orders and was also waiting to sign a contract with Clean Shelf.
14. The Claimant further testified that the meeting did not proceed according to the agenda communicated to him as he was informed that his employment was being terminated. He stated that the meeting lasted approximately three minutes, and that he had worked for the Respondent from 15th August, 2022 to 14th March, 2024.
15. On cross-examination, the Claimant confirmed that his initial contract was a six month probationary contract commencing on 18th September, 2023, and was due to expire on 18th March, 2024 unless extended. He admitted that his contract was terminated on 14th March, 2024 during the probationary period.
16. He confirmed that he previously held the position of ERP Manager in 2022 before being appointed as Retail and ERP Support Manager in 2023.
17. The Claimant admitted that he signed the termination notice contained in the Respondent’s bundle. He confirmed that the notice stated the reason was poor performance following an evaluation conducted on 14th March, 2024, in which his performance was found to have remained unsatisfactory despite support. He acknowledged that the termination was based on performance and not declining business.
18. He explained that his role as ERP Support Manager involved overseeing the implementation of the newly acquired ERP system, training employees, stock-taking and generating reports. He acknowledged that he has not led evidence to demonstrate that he had met his sales targets or that sales had improved. He also testified that the uncollected amount stood at 70%, customer growth was minimal, and no new product lines were introduced.
19. The Claimant also confirmed that the signature on the full and final settlement document was his.
20. On re-examination, the Claimant stated that he did not have clarity on which of the two positions he held was senior and maintained that the additional role was given to him on account of his performance.
21. He stated that he did not undergo any meeting to review his performance, and maintained that the targets could have been achieved had the prospective customers been successfully onboarded and the turnover improved.
22. Regarding the full and final settlement document, the Claimant stated that its contents were not explained to him before he signed it. He maintains that he signed the document to enable him to receive his dues, and not to waive any liability against the Respondent.
23. It is his prayer that the Court allow his claim.
The Claimant’s submissions
24. It is the Claimant’s submission that although Section 42 of the Employment Act provides for termination of probationary contracts, the employer is still required to observe the procedural safeguards under Section 41 of the Act. He relied on Kibuchi & 6 Others v Mount Kenya University; Attorney General (Interested Party) [2021] KEELRC 2310 (KLR), where the Court held that Section 42(1) of the Employment Act was unconstitutional to the extent that it excluded employees serving under probationary contracts from the procedural protections under Section 41, and was inconsistent with Articles 24, 41 and 47 of the Constitution.
25. He submits that the Respondent had previously employed him for one year and that his subsequent appointment as Retail and ERP Support Manager did not justify treating him as a completely new employee requiring probation, particularly considering his prior service with the Respondent.
26. On whether the termination was unfair, the Claimant relied on Section 45(2) of the Employment Act, which requires an employer to establish that the reason for termination was valid and fair and that the termination was undertaken in accordance with fair procedure.
27. It is his submission that where an employer intends to terminate an employee on account of poor performance, the employee must be informed of the alleged shortcomings, given an opportunity to respond and afforded a reasonable period to improve. He relied on National Bank of Kenya v Mutonya [2019] KECA 404 (KLR), where the court addressed the obligation of an employer to explain the reasons for the contemplated termination to an employee, permit the employee to be accompanied by a fellow employee or shop-floor union representative of their choice, and hear and consider the employee’s representations.
28. Further, the Claimant cited Grace Kaverenge Kendeli v Laborex Kenya Limited [2013] KEELRC 699 (KLR), for the holding that once poor performance is identified, the employer should point out the employee’s shortcomings and allow a reasonable period, suggested in that decision to be two to three months, for improvement.
29. Applying the above authorities, the Claimant submitted that he was only invited to a meeting described as a performance review, without sufficient time to prepare, and that the meeting proceeded to terminate his employment without giving him an opportunity to be heard in the presence of a representative of his choice.
The Respondent’s Case
30. The Respondent states that the Claimant’s employment was terminated on account of poor performance and inability to meet the set and agreed targets, and not due to a decline in business as he alleges.
31. The Respondent further states that the Claimant was initially employed under a contract commencing on 15th August, 2022 and ending on 31st August, 2023 in the position of ERP and ICT Manager. It further avers that the Claimant was subsequently appointed under a probationary contract commencing on 18th September, 2023 and running until 18th March, 2024.
32. The Respondent contends that the second contract was a six month probationary appointment offered to the Claimant following unsatisfactory performance in his previous position as an opportunity to give him a lifeline within the organization. It maintains that the new appointment was in a different position, namely Retail and ERP Support Manager, and was subject to a performance review to the satisfaction of the Respondent before confirmation.
33. The Respondent states that the Claimant’s confirmation in employment was conditional upon satisfactory performance and that upon evaluation, he failed to meet the required targets. It therefore maintains that the termination was undertaken in accordance with the terms of the probationary contract and the Employment Act, 2007.
34. The Respondent further denies that the Claimant was ambushed or denied an opportunity to be heard. It contends that the meeting held on 14th March, 2024 was a performance review contemplated by the probationary contract and that the Claimant was given an opportunity to explain his performance shortcomings, but his explanations were found unsatisfactory.
35. The Respondent further denies the Claimant’s allegation that it violated his constitutional rights and the allegations of loss, damage and mental anguish.
36. RW1 testified that the Claimant was lawfully terminated while serving under a probationary contract, and that the reason for termination was poor performance.
37. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that the Claimant had previously served as ERP and ICT Manager and was later appointed as Retail and ERP Support Manager. She acknowledged that the former position was senior to the latter and that the latter appointment amounted to a demotion.
38. She maintained that the Claimant had not performed well as ERP Manager. She confirmed that the Respondent conducted a review of the Claimant’s performance in his previous position, but admitted that the report on that review was not before the Court.
39. RW1 confirmed that the Claimant was terminated on 14th March, 2024 during the performance review meeting. She stated that he was invited to the meeting through a calendar invitation sent on 10th March, 2024, for the review scheduled on 14th March, 2024. She admitted that the calendar invitation was not produced before the Court.
40. She confirmed that the Claimant’s monthly sales target was Kshs. 2.5 million and explained that any over achievement in one month did not spill over to the following month. She stated that the Claimant’s overall performance assessment result was 42%.
41. RW1 confirmed that the notice of termination of employment is dated 14th March, 2024, and that the Claimant’s clearance form was also dated 14th March, 2024. She further confirmed that the Claimant was not accompanied by a representative during the review meeting and that his employment was terminated on the same day.
42. On re-examination, RW1 stated that the Claimant was not allowed to attend the meeting with a representative because it was not a disciplinary hearing, but a performance review. She explained that the Respondent used basic questions, efficiency, and sales targets to arrive at the overall performance assessment of 42%.
43. She reiterated that the decision to terminate the Claimant’s employment was based on poor performance.
44. The Respondent finally urges the court to dismiss the Claimant’s claim.
The Respondent’s Submissions
45. The Respondent submits that it has discharged its burden under Section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007, by demonstrating that the reason for termination was poor performance, which it genuinely believed to exist at the time of the termination.
46. The Respondent further submits that the Claimant’s overall sales achievement during the period was 17.2% against the monthly target of Kshs. 2.5 million, while the overall performance assessment was 42%. It argued that the Claimant did not produce documentary evidence, such as sales reports, client proposals or contracts, to demonstrate that he had met the targets or rebut the Respondent’s performance records.
47. In support of its position on the assessment of poor performance, the Respondent relied on Hot Point Appliances Limited v Ogutu (2025) KEELRC 1650 (KLR), for the proposition that an employer should have clear performance targets and should take measures to assist an employee to improve, including placing the employee on a Performance Improvement Plan where appropriate.
48. On the question of probation, the Respondent also relied on Kibuchi & 6 Others v Mount Kenya University; Attorney General (Interested Party) [2021] KEELRC 2310 (KLR).
49. It acknowledged that probationary employees are entitled to procedural protection under Section 41 of the Employment Act, but submitted that the nature and scope of the hearing should be proportionate to the employee's probationary status and distinguished from a formal disciplinary hearing.
50. The Respondent submits that the Claimant’s probationary appointment was in a different role from his previous fixed-term position. It submits further that the probationary contract was intended to assess his suitability for confirmation in the new position and that it was not obliged to extend the probationary period indefinitely or provide extensive training where the Claimant had failed to meet the targets during the six month period.
51. It is the Respondent’s submission that the meeting held on 14th March, 2024, was a performance review meeting contemplated under Clause 7(a) of the probationary appointment letter. It maintains that the Claimant was invited to the meeting, informed of his performance shortcomings, shown his sales figures and given an opportunity to explain his performance, but his explanations were found unsatisfactory.
52. The Respondent denies that the meeting was a disciplinary hearing and contends that the law did not require the same nature and scope of procedure for a performance appraisal as that applicable to disciplinary proceedings. It maintains that the Claimant was afforded a hearing commensurate with his probationary status and that the Respondent complied with the requirements of Section 41 of the Employment Act.
53. On compensation for unfair termination, the Respondent submitted that an award under Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act is discretionary and only available where termination is found to be unfair. It argued that the Claimant’s probationary contract expressly provided for a six month probationary period, and that an award of twelve months’ salary would amount to rewriting the contract.
54. On notice pay, the Respondent submitted that Clause 7(a) of the probationary appointment letter and Section 42(4) of the Employment Act entitled either party to terminate a probationary contract by giving at least seven days’ notice or payment of seven days’ wages in lieu of notice. It contends that the Claimant was paid one week’s salary in lieu of notice, and that the one month notice period under Clause 7(b) applied only after confirmation, which did not occur.
55. On service pay, the Respondent relied on Sections 35(5) and 35(6)(d) of the Employment Act to submit that the Claimant was not entitled to service pay because he was a member of the National Social Security Fund (NSSF), and was also provided with a pension scheme under the appointment letter.
56. With respect to the claims for constitutional violations and mental anguish, the Respondent submitted that the claims were duplicative of the unfair termination claim and were unsupported by medical evidence or proof of an independent constitutional violation. It argued that the Employment Act provides adequate remedies for unfair termination.
57. The Respondent therefore urged the Court to find that it has established a valid reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment, that it had followed a fair procedure, and that the Claimant was not entitled to the declaration and monetary awards sought.
Analysis and Determination
58. The issues for determination are:
i. Whether the Claimant’s termination was fair and lawful.
ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought.
Whether the termination was fair and lawful
59. It is not disputed that the Claimant was initially employed by the Respondent as an ERP and ICT Manager under a fixed-term contract commencing on 15th August, 2022. It is further agreed that he was subsequently appointed as Retail and ERP Support Manager under a six month probationary contract commencing on 18th September, 2023.
60. The Respondent's witness (RW1) admitted that the latter position was a demotion from the Claimant's previous position, and further explained that the new appointment was intended to give the Claimant another opportunity following unsatisfactory performance in his previous role.
61. It is now settled that employees on probationary contracts are entitled to procedural fairness similar to those who are substantively employed. It then follows that although the Claimant's subsequent appointment was on probation, that status did not exempt the Respondent from the obligation to observe procedural fairness. In Kibuchi & 6 Others v Mount Kenya University; Attorney General (Interested Party) [2021] KEELRC 2310 (KLR), the Court declared Section 42(1) of the Employment Act unconstitutional to the extent that it excluded employees serving under probationary contracts from the procedural protections afforded by Section 41 of the Act.
62. Accordingly, the Respondent was required to explain to the Claimant the grounds upon which his termination was contemplated and accord him a reasonable opportunity to make representations before reaching its decision to terminate his services.
63. Further, Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act place a duty on the Respondent/employer to establish that the reason for termination was valid, fair, and justified. Poor performance no doubt constitutes a valid reason for termination, but an employer must demonstrate that the employee was made aware of the applicable performance standards, the shortcomings identified and the measures taken to facilitate improvement.
64. The Claimant herein acknowledged on cross-examination that his monthly sales target was Kshs.2.5 million, and that he had not attained this target as at the time he was terminated. The Respondent's evidence, however, raises concerns on the fairness of the assessment process. RW1 admitted that the Claimant was not placed on a Performance Improvement Plan, that the performance assessment report relating to his previous position was not produced, and that the meeting invitation was also not produced. More importantly, the Claimant was terminated on the very day of the performance review.
65. In the circumstances of this case, the Court is not persuaded that merely inviting the Claimant to a performance review meeting and asking him questions about his performance constituted compliance with the statutory requirements of procedural fairness. The meeting was effectively a termination meeting, given that the termination letter and clearance documentation were prepared on the same date.
66. Further, the Claimant was neither given a reasonable opportunity to address the identified shortcomings nor allowed an opportunity to make representations in the company of an employee of his choice.
67. In Rabin Patrick Opwaka & Agnes Nduta Njenga v National Bank of Kenya [2019] KEELRC 478 (KLR), the Court emphasized that the existence of a performance improvement plan does not dispense with the employer's obligation to accord an employee a hearing before termination.
68. The Court is also guided by the decision in Grace Kaverenge Kendeli v Laborex Kenya Limited [2013] KEELRC 699 (KLR), which underscores the importance of identifying performance shortcomings and allowing an employee reasonable time to improve. Further, although the law does not prescribe a universal period for every performance improvement process, the employee must be afforded a genuine and reasonable opportunity to improve.
69. It is also my view that the Respondent's reliance on the Claimant's failure to achieve the stipulated targets does not, on its own, establish that the termination was procedurally fair.
70. Further, the Court is alive to the employer's right to set performance targets and assess an employee against them, but the assessment must be objective, transparent and accompanied by a fair opportunity for the employee to respond and improve. The Respondent evidently failed to demonstrate that this was done.
71. The Court therefore finds that, notwithstanding the Claimant's probationary status and the evidence of unsatisfactory performance, the Respondent failed to comply with the requirements of procedural fairness under Section 41 of the Employment Act.
72. The Claimant’s termination was therefore unfair and unlawful.
73. On the reasons for the termination, the Claimant admitted that he had not achieved the monthly sales targets and further acknowledged that customer growth was minimal, that the uncollected amount stood at 70%, and that no new product lines were introduced during the period under review.
74. The Court, in light of the foregoing, accepts that the Respondent had a genuine performance concern, and thus finds that it has demonstrated that the Claimant's performance was below the stipulated expectations.
75. I accordingly find and hold that the Claimant’s termination was substantively fair.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought
76. Having found the termination unfair, the Claimant is entitled to compensation under Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act.
77. I note that the Claimant had served the Respondent for approximately one year and seven months, and his performance was admittedly below expectations, thus contributing to his eventual termination.
78. Taking the foregoing into consideration, I deem an award equivalent to two (2) months' salary, amounting to Kshs.540,000, sufficient compensation for the unfair termination, and which is hereby awarded.
79. On the claim for one month's salary in lieu of notice, Section 42(4) of the Employment Act provides for seven days' notice or payment of the seven days' wages in lieu of notice for termination occurring during the probationary period.
80. The parties agree that the Claimant was terminated during the probationary period of his contract, and is therefore entitled to 7 days' notice or pay in lieu thereof.
81. The Respondent maintains that it paid him one week's salary in lieu of notice, hence the claim for Kshs.270,000.00 is not merited, and the Claimant’s claim in respect of notice therefore fails.
82. On service pay, Section 35(6)(d) of the Employment Act expressly excludes employees who are members of the National Social Security Fund from entitlement to service pay under Section 35(5). In Kens Metal Limited v Shikanga (Civil Appeal 139 of 2018) [2022] KECA 561 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the statutory exclusion of NSSF members from payment of service pay.
83. The Claimant has not controverted the Respondent’s assertion that he was contributing to NSSF, and his employment contract further provides for his inclusion in the Respondent's staff pension scheme.
84. This claim therefore fails and is dismissed.
85. On the claims for violation of constitutional rights and mental and psychological torture, the Court finds that the Claimant has not demonstrated any independent constitutional violation warranting a separate award of damages.
86. The unfairness established herein has adequately been addressed through the remedies under Section 49 of the Employment Act.
87. These claims are therefore devoid of merit and are declined.
88. The Court is also not persuaded that the Claimant's signature on the full and final settlement document, without more, extinguished his right to challenge the fairness of the termination.
89. In conclusion, I enter Judgment in favour of the Claimant as follows: -
a) A declaration that the termination of the Claimant's employment was procedurally unfair and unlawful.
b) That the Claimant is awarded Compensation equivalent to two months' salary for the unfair termination at Kshs.540,000.00.
c) The Respondent shall bear the costs of the suit.
d) Interest shall accrue on (b) above at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full.
90. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Wafula h/b for Mr. Owino for the Claimant
Mr. Victor Olao present for the Respondent
Ms. Esther - C/A