Employment law

Apex Vision Limited v Mutiso & 3 others [2026] KEELRC 14919 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E163 of 2022
Judgment date
3 November 2026
Judge(s)
Nzioki wa Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Respondents instituted this suit before the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Milimani Nairobi via a Statement of Claim dated 22nd February 2019, alleging unfair termination of employment. They contended that they had been employed on diverse dates between 1st August 2010 and 8th August 2010, in various capacities and at different salaries, as evinced by their respective payslips. They further averred that they served diligently until…

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS

COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI

APPEAL NO. E163 OF 2022

APEX VISION LIMITED………..………………...……………APPELLANT

VERSUS

CAROLINE MUTISO.…………...…………....................1ST RESPONDENT

MILDRED ROBINA OSEBE NYANGERI…….………2ND RESPONDENT

GLADYS WANGARI…………...………………………3RD RESPONDENT

ESTHER WANGUI MUTURI…………………………..4TH RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal from the judgment and decree of Hon. E Wanjala (PM) in Nairobi CMELRC No. 262 of 2019 delivered on 26th August 2022)

JUDGMENT

1. The Respondents instituted this suit before the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Milimani Nairobi via a Statement of Claim dated 22nd February 2019, alleging unfair termination of employment. They contended that they had been employed on diverse dates between 1st August 2010 and 8th August 2010, in various capacities and at different salaries, as evinced by their respective payslips. They further averred that they served diligently until the 5th June 2018 when their employment was summarily terminated. Their case was that the 1st Respondent having worked on 30th and 31st May 2018, proceeded on her off days till 4th June 2018. On reporting back on 6th June 2018, the Respondents contended that the 1st Respondent sought clarification on the fate of the Respondents employment following the expiry of Appellant’s contract with Telkom Kenya. She was informed that henceforth the Respondents would be reporting to the Appellant’s headquarters. However, on 11th June 2018, she was surprised to receive a termination letter on the ground of abscondment from duty. The 2nd, 3rd and 4th Respondents were similarly issued with termination letters dated the same day, also citing abscondment. The Respondents asserted that their termination was procedurally and substantively unfair, as they had not absconded from duty. They further contended that they had not been paid overtime or compensated for accrued leave days. Consequently, they sought a total of Kshs. 2,836,305.60 in damages and terminal dues.

2. In opposition to the claim, the Appellant filed a Reply to Claim dated 31st May 2019. It contended that the Respondents had been lawfully terminated for abscondment and for proceeding to work for its main competitor without informing it. The Appellant consequently averred that it was entitled to invoke clause 13 of the Respondents’ employment contracts, which provided for summary dismissal in cases of absenteeism.

3. Upon considering the pleadings and evidence, the Trial Magistrate found that the Respondents’ employment had been unlawfully and unfairly terminated. The Court found no evidence that they had absented themselves from work or joined the Appellant’s competitors. It consequently awarded the following reliefs: Kshs. 304,584/- to the 1st Respondent, comprising one month’s salary in lieu of notice and seven months’ compensation; Kshs. 473,903/- to the 2nd Respondent, comprising one month’s salary in lieu of notice and seven months’ compensation; Kshs. 288,600/- to the 3rd Respondent, comprising one month’s salary in lieu of notice and seven months’ compensation; and Kshs. 283,500/- to the 4th Respondent, comprising one month’s salary in lieu of notice and five months’ compensation. The Trial Magistrate also directed the Appellant to issue each of the Respondents with a certificate of service.

4. Aggrieved by the entire judgment, the Appellant lodged the present appeal through a Memorandum of Appeal dated 22nd September 2022. The appeal is founded on eight grounds, in which the Appellant contends that:

(1) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to properly construe the terms and conditions contained in the Respondents’ contracts of service dated 24th April 2015.

(2) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact when she failed to consider that the Appellant was denied a fair hearing, in gross violation of its constitutional right to fair hearing when it proceeded with trial in the absence of the Appellant, due to no fault of its own, on a mere mis-diarization of the said hearing date by its Advocates on record, which mistake should not have been visited on the Appellant and in spite of an oral application and/or request being made on the subsequent Hearing date.

(3) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact when she failed to make a finding that on a true and correct construction of the subject contracts of service, the same expressly provided that the employment of the Respondents could be determined by either party only on the conditions set out in the termination clause provided in the said contracts.

(4) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact when she failed, contrary to the overwhelming evidence led, to make a finding that the Appellant had terminated the said service contracts on the grounds of absconding their duties for an extended period without due cause and that the same constituted grounds for summary dismissal per the said contracts of service and in accordance with Employment Laws of the Republic of Kenya. Further, failed to consider that evidence was indeed led demonstrating that the Respondents had in truth gone ahead to join the direct competitor of the Appellant.

(5) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact when she failed to appreciate and make a finding that the termination of the service for the Respondents was indeed lawful and procedural.

(6) The Learned trial Magistrate failed to pronounce herself over whether or not on the oral application of the Appellant's counsel on record, an application to seeking orders with the effect of re-calling the witnesses of the Respondents who had testified in the absence of the Appellant, merely only on the basis of there not being a written application to the same effect wholly overlooking the overriding objective of the Honourable Court to expeditiously handle matters before it without undue regard to technicalities thereof.

(7) The Learned Trial Magistrate erred both in law and fact when she failed to appreciate and/or consider at all, the submissions of the Appellant which relied on overwhelming evidence in support of its Defence.

(8) The Learned Trial Magistrate failed in going ahead to grant award to the respondents despite overwhelming evidence and failing to appreciate both the grounds adduced herein and the circumstances surrounding the lawful termination of contract of the Respondents.

5. On the strength of the foregoing grounds, the Appellant urges this Court to re-appraise the evidence on record and order a retrial of the claim to afford it an opportunity to present its defence. It further prays that the appeal be allowed, that it be awarded the costs of the appeal, and that the Court make such further orders as it may deem appropriate.

6. Although the Court issued directions on the filing of written submissions on 8th May 2026, neither party filed submissions.

Disposition

7. This being a first appeal, I am enjoined to evaluate and examine the record before the Magistrates’ Court and the evidence presented before it in order to arrive at my own conclusion. This principle of law was enunciated in the celebrated case of Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd [1968] EA 123 where the Court of Appeal outlined the duties of a first appellate court as follows:

"I accept counsel for the respondent's proposition that this court is not is not bound necessarily to accept the findings of fact by the court below. An appeal to this court is by way of retrial and the principles upon which this court acts in such an appeal are well settled. Briefly put they are that this court must reconsider the evidence, evaluate it itself and draw its own conclusions though it should always bear in mind that it has neither seen nor heard the witnesses and should make due allowance in this respect."

[Emphasis supplied]

8. Having properly warned myself that I neither saw nor heard the Appellant nor the Respondent testify in trial, I have come to the following determination. I have duly evaluated the evidence they presented in the Trial Court, and which evidence and documents in support thereof, are before this Court.

9. Upon perusal of the material before the Trial Court, and upon an analysis of the material before the Learned Magistrate, I discern no error that would entitle the Court to interfere with the determination made by the Trial Court. The Appeal is in essence an appeal against the findings of the Learned Magistrate which were made on proper analysis of the facts and the law.

10. The unsurprising thing is that the Appellant did not appear at the trial and attacks the decision alleging its right to fair trial were abridged thereby. A party that absents themselves from attending the hearing of a case cannot tun around and accuse the Court of failing to give it a hearing. Failure to appear in Court in the present circumstances cannot be placed at the feet of the Court. It is apparent even at the appellate stage, the Appellant is indolent. No submissions were filed despite directions to file these. As at the time of penning the Judgment there was nothing to this end and as such the Court returns the appeal is devoid of merit as there is no cogent challenge to the findings of the Court. The Appeal is accordingly for dismissal. Appeal dismissed with no order as to costs since the Respondents did not bother to file submissions either.

It is so ordered.

Dated and delivered at Kisumu this 3rd day of November 2026

Nzioki wa Makau, MCIArb.

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder