Employment law

David v Parklane Construction Company Limited [2026] KEELRC 14918 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E240 of 2024
Judgment date
3 November 2026
Judge(s)
Nzioki wa Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Appellant instituted this suit via an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 19th December 2019, alleging unlawful dismissal from employment and non-payment of terminal dues. His case was that on 14th November 2018, he was summarily dismissed by one Richard Mwinzi for reporting to work late. He attributed his lateness to a disruption of public transport occasioned by a police crackdown on that day.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS

COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI

APPEAL NO. E240 OF 2024

NEXIES MWANDUKA DAVID...……………..……...………APPELLANT

VERSUS

PARKLANE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED....RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal from the judgment and decree of Hon. L.B Koech, (SPM) in Nairobi Milimani MCELRC No. 834 of 2019 delivered on 19th July 2024)

JUDGMENT

1. The Appellant instituted this suit via an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 19th December 2019, alleging unlawful dismissal from employment and non-payment of terminal dues. His case was that on 14th November 2018, he was summarily dismissed by one Richard Mwinzi for reporting to work late. He attributed his lateness to a disruption of public transport occasioned by a police crackdown on that day.

2. The Respondent opposed the claim through a Response to the Memorandum of Claim dated 21st May 2021. Its position was that the Appellant had been employed by Mr. Richard Mwinzi, whom the Respondent had subcontracted to undertake construction works around Athi River. The Respondent maintained that it had paid Mr. Richard Mwinzi a total of Kshs. 5,560,970.95 for the works and had no responsibility for the workers engaged by him. It therefore denied any knowledge or liability in respect of the Appellant’s alleged terminal dues.

3. At the hearing, however, the Appellant maintained that Richard Mwinzi was not his employer but merely a co-worker who acted as his supervisor. The Respondent’s witness, Mr. Juresh Bhudija, on the other hand, testified that Mr. Richard Mwinzi would raise quotations for the works he undertook, following which the Respondent would make the requisite payments.

4. In her judgment delivered on 19th July 2024, the Trial Magistrate dismissed the Appellant’s claim with costs. The Court found that the Appellant had failed to establish an employer-employee relationship between himself and the Respondent. Instead, upon evaluating the evidence before it, the Trial Magistrate found that Mr. Richard Mwinzi had been subcontracted by the Respondent to undertake works on its behalf and was therefore responsible for the workers he engaged.

5. Aggrieved by that decision, the Appellant lodged a Memorandum of Appeal dated 19th August 2024, raising the following grounds:

(i) That the Learned Trial Magistrate erred in fact and law in reaching a judgment wholly against the weight of evidence and particularly in finding that the Claimant had in suing the Respondent sued a wrong party, not his employer.

(ii) That having so held, the learned Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact by failing to assess the awards, if any, that were due to the Claimant in respect of his claim.

6. On the basis of the foregoing grounds, the Appellant urges this Court to set aside the judgment of the Trial Court, find the Respondent liable for his unlawful dismissal, and allow the claim as prayed in the Amended Memorandum of Claim. He further seeks the costs of both the appeal and the proceedings before the Trial Court. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Appellant’s Submissions

7. In support of the appeal, the Appellant identifies two issues for determination, namely:

(a) Whether the Trial Magistrate erred in finding that he was not employed by the Respondent; and,

(b) Whether he is entitled to the reliefs sought in the Amended Memorandum of Claim.

8. On the first issue, the Appellant submits that there was no evidence demonstrating that Mr. Richard Mwinzi had been subcontracted by the Respondent. He contends that, in the absence of a subcontracting agreement, there was no basis upon which the Trial Magistrate could properly conclude that Mr. Richard Mwinzi was an independent contractor. Conversely, the Appellant maintains that Mr. Richard Mwinzi was an employee of the Respondent who performed supervisory duties. In support of this contention, he points to the fact that he worked at the Respondent’s premises, used the Respondent’s equipment, worked within hours controlled by the Respondent, and that Mr. Richard Mwinzi merely followed up on the payment of salaries. He asserts that these circumstances demonstrate the existence of an employment relationship when considered against the economic reality test. The Appellant further submits that the duties performed by Richard Mwinzi bore all the hallmarks of those of a supervisor. He relies on Burlington Industries, Inc. v Ellerth, 524 U.S. 742 (1998), for the proposition that a supervisor is an agent of the employer, thereby rendering the employer liable for the supervisor’s unlawful acts. He also invokes section 2 of the Employment Act, which defines an employer to include a foreman or manager. Further reliance is placed on the testimony of CW2, who stated that the Respondent was their employer, as well as the decision in Wasilwa v Judicial Service Commission; Kenya Union of Domestic, Hotels, Educational Institutions, Hospitals and Allied Workers & 3 others (Interested Parties) (Petition E237 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 1071 (KLR), where the Court found the respondent to be a putative employer in the absence of evidence to the contrary. The Appellant consequently asserts that the Respondent ought either to have called Mr. Richard Mwinzi as a witness or joined him to the proceedings so as to clarify the nature of his relationship with the parties. He therefore maintains that the Trial Magistrate erred in finding that he was not an employee of the Respondent.

9. As regards the reliefs sought, the Appellant submits that the same ought to be granted as pleaded in the Amended Memorandum of Claim on the basis that his termination from employment was unlawful.

Respondent’s Submissions

10. The Respondent, on its part, maintains that no employer-employee relationship existed between it and the Appellant. It submits that the Appellant failed to discharge the burden of establishing such relationship, as required by section 107(1) of the Evidence Act. It relies on Anne Wambui Ndiritu v Joseph Kiprono Ropkoi & another [2005] 1 EA 334, where it was stated:

“As a general proposition under section 107(1) of the Evidence Act, cap 80, the legal burden of proof lied upon the party who invokes the aid of the law and substantially asserts the affirmative of the issue. There is however the evidential burden that is cast upon any party the burden of proving any particular fact which he desires the court to believe in its existence. That is captured in sections 109 and 112 of the Act.”

11. The Respondent further relies on the testimony of RW1, who stated that Mr. Richard Mwinzi was an independent contractor responsible for recruiting, supervising and remunerating the workers engaged in the works he had been contracted to undertake. It also draws attention to the Appellant’s own testimony that he was supervised and remunerated by Mr. Richard Mwinzi and that it was Mr. Richard Mwinzi who ultimately terminated his employment.

12. In view of the foregoing, the Respondent submits that the claim was fatally defective in view of the wrong party being sued. Consequently, it urges the Court to uphold the Trial Court’s finding and dismiss the appeal with costs.

Disposition

13. The Appellant was employed at a worksite the Respondent served. It is apparent from the record that the Appellant was engaged for a period of time and his pay was channelled through Mr. Richard Mwinzi who had been subcontracted by the Respondent to undertake the works at Doshi. In my considered view, having failed to close the gaps in his testimony and not availing anything other than the demand letters, the Appellant was on a backfoot and could not dislodge the defence of the Respondent. Having taken note that the suit was dismissed with costs by the Learned Magistrate though there was basis to dismiss it without an order for costs, I uphold the dismissal but vacate the order for costs. Appeal dismissed with no order as to costs.

It is so ordered.

Dated and delivered at Kisumu this 3rd day of November 2026

Nzioki wa Makau, MCIArb.

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder