Employment law

Warui v Public Service Commission & 2 others [2026] KEELRC 14975 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Petition E224 of 2026
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbarũ

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

A declaration that the Constitution binds the Public Service Commission and may exercise only those powers expressly conferred upon it under the Constitution and written law;

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC PETITION NO. E224 OF 2026

JAMES MUNGAI WARUI …………………………….…………PETITIONER

VERSUS

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION……………..……….1ST RESPONDENT

SALARIES AND REMUNERATION

COMMISSION…………………………………………….2ND RESPONDENT

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL..……...3RD RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

The Petitioner is seeking the following orders:

1. A declaration that the Constitution binds the Public Service Commission and may exercise only those powers expressly conferred upon it under the Constitution and written law;

2. A declaration that the Office of Inspector-General (Corporations) is a statutory office established by Parliament under the State Corporations Act, whose legal character, statutory functions and essential indent cannot be altered through administrative action;

3. A declaration that the Public Service Commission has no constitutional or statutory authority to amend, redefine, diminish or otherwise alter the statutory functions of the Office of Inspector General (Corporations) through a recruitment advertisement or other administrative instrument;

4. A declaration that the Public Service Commission acted ultra vires Articles 2, 10, 47, 73, 94, 230, 232 and 234 of the Constitution in publishing Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5 May 2026 and on its website in the manner complained of in this Petition;

5. A declaration that any alteration of the remuneration framework, benefits or allowances attached to the office of the Inspector General (Corporations) other than in accordance with Article 230 of the Constitution is unconstitutional, null and void;

6. A declaration that the impugned Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5 May 2026 and on the 1st respondent’s website is inconsistent with the Constitution and State Corporations Act, Cap 446 to the extent that it purports to alter the statutory tenure, functions, remuneration framework or other legal indent of the office;

7. An order of certiorari bringing into this Court for the purpose of being quashed Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5 May 2026 and on the 1st respondent’s website, together with all decisions, actions and processes undertaken pursuant thereto, together with all decisions, actions and processes undertaken pursuant thereto, to the extent that they are inconsistent with the Constitution and the State Corporations Act;

8. An order of prohibition prohibiting the 1st respondent, whether by itself, its officers, servants, agents or any other person acting under its authority, from proceeding with recruitment, shortlisting, interviewing, selection, recommendation, appointment or implementation of Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 in its present form;

9. An order of Mandamus directing that any future recruitment to the office of Inspector-General (Corporations) shall be undertaken strictly in accordance with the Constitution, the State Corporations Act, the Public Service Commission Act, the applicable Scheme of Service, and the Constitutional mandate of the Salaries and Remuneration Commission;

10. A permanent injunction restraining the 1st Respondent from administratively altering the statutory functions, legal indent, tenure or remuneration framework of the Office of Inspector General (Corporations) except pursuant to lawful constitutional and statutory authority;

11. A declaration that any appointment made pursuant to an unconstitutional recruitment process is liable to be invalidated by this Honourable Court;

12. An order directing each Respondent to bear and comply with its respective constitutional mandate in accordance with the Constitution and the applicable statutes; and

13. Costs of this Petition together with interest thereon.

The Petitioner is an advocate of the High Court of Kenya, a career public officer, and brings the Petition in his own interest and in the public interest pursuant to Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution, protection of the rule of law and preservation of the institutional integrity of a statutory office established by Parliament.

The 1st Respondent is the Public Service Commission (PSC), an independent constitutional commission established under Article 233 of the Constitution and charged with the functions set out under Article 234. It is responsible for publishing Vacancy Advertisement No. 109 of 2026, appearing in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5 May 2026 on its website, the subject of this petition.

The 2nd Respondent is the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC), an independent constitutional commission established under Article 230 of the Constitution with the exclusive constitutional mandate to set and regularly review the remuneration and benefits of all state officers and to advise the national and county governments on the remuneration and benefits of all other public officers.

The 3rd Respondent is the principal legal adviser to the Government under Article 156 of the Constitution and is joined because the Petition raises substantial questions touching on the exercise of State authority and interpretation of the Constitution.

The Petition is that on or about 5th May, 2026, the 1st respondent published Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5th May, 2026 and on its website inviting applications for appointment to the Office of Inspector General (Corporations). The impugned advertisement materially departed from the statutory and historical architecture of the office in several fundamental respects.

The advertisement converted what had consistently been maintained as a permanent and pensionable statutory public office into a fixed five-year contractual office without any statutory amendment authorizing such transaction.

The advertisement omitted or materially altered statutory functions conferred upon the Office under the State Corporations Act, thereby diminishing the statutory oversight framework enacted by Parliament.

The Petition is that the advertisement introduced a remuneration and benefits framework inconsistent with the existing remuneration structure attached to the office without any disclosed advice or review by the 2nd Respondent as constitutionally required under Article 230. The cumulative effect of those alterations fundamentally changed the legal identity, institutional independence, tenure security and statutory character of the Office established by Parliament.

The impugned advertisement ceased to be a mere recruitment instrument and instead became an administrative instrument purporting to redesign a statutory office established by legislation.

The Petition is that the foregoing violates Articles 2 and 3 on the Constitutional supremacy and the duty to uphold the constitution, Article 10 on the national values and principles of governance, Article 94 by the usurpation of Parliament’s legislative authority, Article 234 by acting beyond constitutional mandate, Article 230 by the unconstitutional interference with the constitutional mandate of the Salaries and Renumeration Commission, Articles 27 and 47 on the Equality, Fair Administrative Action and Procedural Fairness, Articles 73 and 232 on the integrity, accountability and values of public service.

The Petition is that the State Corporations Act is the primary legislation governing the establishment, supervision and administration of State Corporations in Kenya. Under Section 18 of the Act, the Office of Inspector–General (Corporations) is an institutional mechanism for ensuring lawful administration, financial accountability, and effective oversight within corporations, and it confers powers and functions, including powers of inspection, inquiry, and surcharge, as provided under the Act. These functions form part of the legal identity of the Office and cannot be omitted, diminished or modified through administrative instruments.

The Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 materially departs from the statutory architecture established under the State Corporations Act by altering the Office’s legal identity and omitting statutory functions expressly conferred by Parliament and, in so doing, acted in a manner inconsistent with the express provisions of the State Corporations Act. The Commission also violated the Public Service Commission Act in exceeding its statutory mandate by purporting to redesign statutory offices, as well as Article 47 of the Constitution and the Fair Administration Act.

The Petition is that officers serving within the Inspectorate of State Corporations, and indeed the public generally, have a legitimate expectation that statutory offices will continue to exist under the legislative framework enacted by Parliament unless lawfully amended. The unilateral transformation of the Office through an administrative advertisement defeats those legitimate expectations without legal authority.

The present petition challenges the constitutional validity of Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 as an administrative instrument alleged to exceed the constitutional authority of the Public Service Commission, which is fundamentally different from other proceedings concerning the Petitioner’s employment relationship and previous recruitment processes relating to the Office of Inspector-General (Corporations), which principally concerned personal employment grievances and recruitment decisions affecting the Petitioner.

The Petitioner also supports the Petition with an affidavit. He avers that the challenged advertisement seeks to materially alter and depart from the subsisting provisions regarding the historical architecture of the Office of Inspector-General (Corporations). The respondents, in essence, have converted the office into a fixed-term contract and omitted material statutory oversight functions conferred under the State Corporations Act and Legal Notice No. 93 of 2004. The remuneration and benefits attached to the office have been changed without justification and fundamentally alter the legal intent of a statutory office established by Parliament.

The petitioner avers that these alterations exceed the constitutional and statutory mandate of the 1st respondent and raise substantial constitutional questions concerning the interpretation of fundamental rights and freedoms.

The petitioner avers that he is aware of proceedings in ELRC Judicial Review Application No. E012 of 2026 involving his employment-related grievances. The petition herein is distinct and different from the other proceedings. Whereas the Judicial Review proceedings concern employment grievances and administrative decisions affecting his public service career, the petition challenges the constitutional validity of Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 and the constitutional authority of the 1st Respondent to alter the legal character, functions, tenure and remuneration framework of a statutory office established by Parliament.

In reply, the 1st Respondent Commission, through the affidavit of its Chief Executive Officer/ Secretary, Paul Famba, avers that the Commission on 5th May, 2026 advertised the position of Inspector General (Corporations) in compliance with Article 232 (1) (g) of the Constitution as read together with section 10 of the Public Service (Values and Principles) Act. The advertisement complied with section 37 of the Public Service Commission Act.

The Petitioner had moved this Court in Nairobi ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026, in which he is the Applicant, vide an application dated 5th May, 2026 seeking orders that the advertisement of the position of Inspector General (State Corporations) in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 be suspended pending the hearing and determination of the suit and the Public Service Commission be directed to consider confirming him to the position having regard to his long service and acting appointment.

The Commission proceeded to shortlist candidates for the interview, including the Petitioner, after this Court did not grant a stay order in Nairobi ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026 stopping the PSC from proceeding with the recruitment process for the position of Inspector General (State Corporations). After the recruitment process for the position of Inspector General (State Corporations) was finalised, Mr Sang Kipkemei was appointed with effect from 15th July, 2026.

The fact that the Office of the Inspector-General is established under the State Corporations Act, Cap 446 does not mean it is not a Public Office as envisaged under Article 260 of the Constitution. It thus falls within the mandate of the PSC. For this reason, the PSC appointed the Petitioner as Acting Inspector-General. The State Corporations Act was enacted in 1986, and when the Constitution was promulgated in 2010, all offices, including the Office of the Inspector-General (Corporations), fell within the Commission's mandate pursuant to section 7(2) of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution.

The 1st respondent avers that Article 234(2) (g) of the Constitution gives the PSC the power to review and make recommendations to the national government on conditions of service, code of conduct, and qualifications of officers in the public service. Under section 53 of the Public Service Commission Act, the Commission may, on its own initiative or upon request by any authorized officer, recommend to the Cabinet Secretary conditions of service relating to the Public Service.

Mr. Famba avers that no statute sets the terms of service for the position of Inspector General (Corporations) as permanent and pensionable. The Commission lawfully advertised the position of Inspector General (State Corporations) with a five-year contract term of service as per section 14.0 of the Delegation Instrument on the Exercise of Human Resource Powers and Functions in the Public Service Ref. No. PSC/SEC/93/37/VOL. VI/31 dated 14 December 2022, issued to all authorized officers, including the Principal Administrative Secretary, Office of the Chief of Staff and Head of the Public Service.

The functions of the Office of Inspector General (Corporations) are set out under section 18 of the State Corporations Act, Cap 446, and the advertisement sets out only the duties and responsibilities of the office holder; it does not remove the functions of the office, which are clearly stated in the Act. The salary attached to the position is the salary attached to the position of Civil Servants Grade (CSG)-4 and the benefits attached to the Job Grade. The Commission did not introduce a different remuneration and benefits structure.

Mr. Famba avers that once it receives an indent from the authorized officer, it reviews it and, before approving it, is guided by parity of treatment of public officers and the legitimate expectations of the public officers concerned.

The constitutional mandate of the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC) has not been implicated, as the salary assigned to the position is as advised by SRC for the mainstream Public Service for Job Grade CSG-4.

The Petitioner in the Supplementary Affidavit deposes that the Delegation Instrument on the Exercise of Human Resource Powers and Functions in the Public Service, by giving a directive to authorized officers that all appointments on CSG 5 and above shall be on contract, is in contravention of section 45 (2) (a) of the Public Service Act, which limits employment on contract terms to only those offices created by the Commission and does not include those under the Authority of the Commission. The section does not apply to the Office of the Inspector-General (Corporations), as it is a statutory office established by Parliament, not by the Commission. The letter of appointment referred to in the 1st Respondent’s replying affidavit is incomplete, as an important part of it has been blacked out in an effort by the 1st Respondent to hide material facts from the scrutiny of this Honourable Court.

The Petitioner avers that in the Nairobi ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026, he was seeking orders to suspend the advertisement No.109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations ), that the Public Service Commission be directed to consider confirming him to the position of Inspector-General (Corporations) and further that the Public Service Commission be directed to consider confirming him to the position of Inspector-General (Corporations). His case is for the preservation of his legitimate expectation of being promoted to the position. In this Petition, he challenges the constitutionality and legality of the instrument and process by which the 1st Respondent purported to recruit to, and thereby alter the character, terms, and framework of the statutory Office of the Inspector-General (Corporations). The two petitions therefore raise distinct issues for determination.

The authorized officer, Executive Office of the President, requested the 1st Respondent to advertise the position of Inspector General (Corporations) on permanent and pensionable terms in accordance with Section 33(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. The 1st Respondent has not provided any reasons/justifications for departing from this request.

None of the other authorized Officers in the Ministries/state departments whose vacant positions were similarly advertised on the 1st Respondent’s website alongside Advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for the Inspector (Corporations) adhered to Section 14. This is because, of the ninety-nine (99) promotional vacancies advertised, only Advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations) states a five (5)-year contract, renewable once, subject to satisfactory performance.

Advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations) states a five (5) - year contract, renewable once, subject to satisfactory performance. Likewise, there were twenty-one (21) vacancies at Job Grade CSG-5 with permanent and pensionable terms of service, and none were on a contractual basis.

The Petitioner avers that the 1st Respondent has proffered no reason why it did not act on the indent sent to it on 20 April 2023 by the Permanent Secretary and the then authorized Officer, State Department for Performance and Delivery Management, Office of the Prime Cabinet Secretary.

In reviewing the subsequent indent sent to it on 1st December, 2025 by the authorized officer, the 1st Respondent breached section 55 of the Public Service Commission Act by altering the term, thereby discriminating against the office from other similar offices in the civil service that are designated as Job Grade CSG-4. It arbitrarily alters the remuneration structure without input from relevant stakeholders, such as the Salaries and Remuneration Commission. This curtails the legitimate expectations of inspectors of state corporations currently serving on permanent and pensionable terms of service who could not apply for the job, though advertised as a promotional appointment, because they did not want to serve on the new contractual terms with reduced allowances and benefits.

The Petitioner avers that on 27th May, 2026, soon after the closure of advertisement No. 109 of 2026 but before further processing of the recruitment, he wrote to the 1st Respondent highlighting the anomalies in the advertisement and seeking clarification, but regrettably received no response.

On the petition, the petitioner submitted that regarding the issue of alleged res judicata and parallel proceedings, the doctrine of res judicata is statutory and its constituent elements must all be established. In Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission v Kiai and 5 others [2017] KECA 477 (KLR), the court held that the ingredients of res judicata are conjunctive. The former suit must concern the same direct and substantial issue; involve the same parties or parties claiming under them. The present petition consequently ought not to be struck out merely because the other proceedings concern the petitioner’s employment history or aspects of the recruitment exercise. The respondents must demonstrate actual identity of the issue, cause of action, parties and final determination. Mere overlap in factual background does not satisfy Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act.

The Petitioner submitted that Parliament, under Section 18 of the State Corporations Act, did not merely create a generic administrative position that could be freely redesigned through an internal human resource instrument. The Statutory architecture is therefore important. The question before the Court is not simply whether the 1st Respondent had authority to recruit a public officer. It is whether the 1st Respondent could lawfully determine that the statutory office created by section 18 should henceforth be advertised in a form which materially differs from the statutory framework.

The Petitioner submitted that section 234 of the Constitution whilst conferring powers upon the Commission including powers in the public service qualifies the relevant power by providing that PSC exercise its function subject to the Constitution and legislation as held in Githongo & Another v State Corporations Advisory Committee &Another; Public Service Commission & 2others (Interested Parties) [2025] KEHC 18054 (KLR) where the court considered that the meaning of the phrase ‘subject to this constitution and legislation in Article 234 requires PSC, in discharging its constitutional mandate, to act in conformity with the Constitution and legislation.

The principle is directly applicable in this case. The 1st Respondent’s constitutional authority under Article 234 cannot be read in isolation from section 18 of the State Corporations Act, and sections 33 and 45 of the Public Service Commissions Act. Where Parliament has created an office and prescribed its statutory functions, an administrative instrument cannot be used to achieve what in substance would amount to an amendment of statute. The petitioner argues that section 45 of the Public Service Commission Act limits the PSC's powers to appoint public officers on contract to only those offices it has established. Further, under section 33(1), the Commission’s authority under subsection (1) is to be exercised at the request of the authorized officer of the public body to which the appointment needs to be made, and the 1st Respondent has not proffered any reason for contravening this provision.

On the alteration of the remuneration and benefits associated with the office of Inspector General (Corporations), the petitioner submitted that the issue is whether a public body can materially alter the remuneration and benefits applicable to a public office without demonstrating compliance with the constitutional and statutory framework governing remuneration. The Petitioner relies on Matindi v Salaries & Remuneration Commission and Another [2026] KEHC 755 (KLR), where the court considered the constitutional architecture surrounding SRC’s remuneration mandate, to argue that the question is one of institutional legality and constitutional process, rather than whether SRC possesses an unrestricted veto over recruitment.

The Petitioner cited Commission for the Implementation of the Constitution v Parliament of Kenya & 5 others [2013] e KLR, holding that every constitutional Commission and public body remains subject to constitutional and statutory limitations, and the same principle applies to PSC. Article 234 does not create a parallel universe in which the Commission’s decisions are insulated from legislation.

The Petitioner contends that this Court has the power to nullify the impugned administrative act, and that the fact that recruitment has progressed and persons have been shortlisted, interviewed, and an officer appointed to the office of Inspector General (Corporations), cannot retrospectively cure a foundational illegality.

The respondents have not filed written submissions.

Determination

On the petition, the affidavits and written submissions, the issues for determination are:

a) Whether the Petition is sub judice before the Nairobi ELRC, Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026.

b) Whether the 1st Respondent’s powers under Article 234 of the Constitution are subject to the statutory framework governing the office of Inspector General (Corporations).

c) Whether the advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations) unlawfully alters the statutory character, functions or other essential indents of the office.

d) Whether the remedies sought should be issued.

e) Who should pay costs.

The issue of the Petition being sub judice appears in paragraphs 14-17 of the Commission's Replying Affidavit.

The 1st Respondent contends that the Petitioner moved this Court in Nairobi ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026 in which he is the Applicant seeking orders that the advertisement of the position of Inspector General (State Corporations) in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 be suspended pending the hearing and determination of the suit and the PSC be directed to consider confirming the applicant in the position having regard to his long service and acting appointment. The Court initially issued conservatory orders pending delivery of the ruling. The Court thereafter ruled that it would not issue the interim orders sought, except that the main motion would be heard on a priority basis.

The Court delivered a ruling on 11th June, 2026. The applicant filed an application dated 5th July, 2026 seeking review of those orders. The Petitioner has now appealed this ruling on review in Civil Appeal No. 319 of 2026.

Regarding sub judice, Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act provides:

“No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceeding in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed.”

In Thiba Min. Hydro Co Ltd v Josphat Karu Ndwiga [2013] KEHC 2017 (KLR), the court held that the form in which the suit is framed does not determine whether it is sub judice. Rather, the substance of the suit, as reflected in the pleadings in both cases, does. Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act states:

“No Court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceeding in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed.”

A party that seeks to invoke the sub judice rule must therefore establish:

a) there is more than one suit over the same subject matter;

b) one suit was instituted before the other;

c) both suits are pending before courts of competent jurisdiction; and

d) The suits are between the same parties or their representatives.

In Mwangi v NCBA Bank Kenya Plc & another [2026] KEHC 13901 (KLR), the court held that the sub judice rules exist to address duplication and piecemeal litigation. The sub judice rule prevents this, and a party cannot sidestep it simply by adding or substituting parties.

In SK v NSK [2026] KEHC 8070 (KLR), the Court held:

“I am convinced that this Court cannot determine the issues raised in this Miscellaneous Cause and decide whether to allow or decline the prayers sought in these proceedings without delving into the issues pending in Eldoret High Court Family Civil Appeal No. E071 of 2023, which was already in existence between the same parties long before this Cause was filed. I am also convinced that if the prayers sought in this Miscellaneous Cause are granted, they will directly affect the Appeal. The two matters are therefore intertwined and joined at the hip.”

The test is therefore whether this court can determine the issues raised in this case and allow or decline the prayers sought in these proceedings without delving into the issues pending in NRB ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026, and whether, if the prayers sought are granted in that case, they will affect the instant petition. The Petitioner’s submission is mainly on res judicata, and that no direct and substantial issue has previously been determined.

In the Petition, the petitioner challenges the constitutionality and legality of the instrument and process by which the 1st Respondent advertised recruitment for the position of Inspector General (Corporations) by altering the character, terms, and framework of the statutory requirements for the office.

General (Corporations) by altering the character, terms and framework of the statutory requirements for the office. With regard to the proceedings in the Nairobi ELRC Judicial Review No. E012 of 2026, as the applicant, the petitioner seeks orders to suspend Advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations), because the PSC should be directed to consider confirming him to the position of Inspector-General (Corporations). His case is for the preservation of his legitimate expectation of being promoted to the position.

Viewed objectively, each suit has its own separate and distinct substantive issues. The two suits therefore raise distinct issues for determination. Nairobi JR No. E012 of 2026, the substantial issue is the propriety of the Vacancy Advertisement No. 109 of 2026 appearing in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026. The petition herein challenges the constitutionality and legality of the instrument applied for the position.

The rule of sub judice does not apply.

In this case, the constitutional mandate of the PSC is outlined under Article 234(2) of the Constitution, including:

(2) The Commission shall—

(a) subject to this Constitution and legislation––

(i) establish and abolish offices in the public service; and

(ii) appoint persons to hold or act in those offices, and to confirm appointments;

In this petition, these functions are relevant as the petitioner sets out a case that the PSC has exceeded its constitutional and statutory mandates by changing and converting the position of Inspector General (Corporations) from the statutory architecture by converting the office from permanent and pensionable terms to fixed contract terms, altering the statutory oversight functions, altering the remuneration framework and changing the legal indent of a statutory office established by Parliament.
The core provisions are the establishment or abolition of office and the appointment of persons to hold public office.

Under the Public Service Commission Act, the PSC's powers to establish and abolish offices, or to appoint persons to hold or act in those positions, should be anchored in the Constitution and the Public Service Commission Act. Section 33 of the PSC Act does not grant the PSC these functions. They are regulated to the extent that a request must be initiated from the authorized officer of the public body to which the appointment needs to be made:

33. Commission’s authority to appoint

(1)The Commission shall have such powers as may be necessary to discharge its functions under Article 234(2) (a) (ii) of the Constitution.

(2)The Commission's authority under subsection (1) shall be exercised at the request of the authorised officer of the public body to which the appointment needs to be made.

The PSC therefore cannot act suo moto. There must be a request, the need and justification for any change or review with regard to a public office. Acting without a request is both unconstitutional and unlawful. Such would be acting ultra vires. In Katiba Institute v Attorney General & 2 others; Ndii & 20 others (Interested Parties) [2026] KEHC 258 (KLR), the court held that under section 27 of the Public Service Commission Act, the authorized officer must make a requisition, a request. The requisition must be a written request to establish an office, based on a comprehensive workload analysis, indicating financial implications and including a verification statement; none of which, as the petitioner asserts, was issued under the provisions of the States Corporations Act.

Fundamentally, section 27(2) of the Public Service Commission Act requires a written statement verifying that all these conditions have been met. In this case, the changes the PSC made to the challenged advertisement for the position of Inspector-General (Corporations) are fundamentally different from the line agency's request.

Under the State Corporations Act, section 18 regulates the position of Inspector-General (Corporations). The Act regulates this office. Its operations are statutory. Any changes must therefore emanate from a request by the authorized officer of the public body to which the change is to be made.

In this case, the position of Inspector-General (Corporations) is placed at the executive office of the President. The initiator of the request for any change should be from this office in terms of section 4 of the State Corporations Act.

It is not contested that the authorized officer, Executive Office of the President, requested the 1st Respondent to advertise the position of Inspector General (Corporations) on permanent and pensionable terms in accordance with Section 33(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. The 1st Respondent has not provided any reasons for the alterations to the fixed-term contract or justification for departing from this request with different terms and conditions.

The application of the Delegation Instrument on the Exercise of Human Resource Powers and Functions in the Public Service Ref. No. PSC/SEC/93/37/VOL. VI/31 dated 14th December, 2022, issued to all authorized officers, including the Principal Administrative Secretary, Office of the Chief of Staff and Head of the Public Service, and cannot be applied outside the PSC's constitutional or legal mandate. Such an instrument can only extrapolate what is constitutional and lawful. The position of Inspector General (Corporations) is regulated by law; a subsidiary instrument cannot change its terms and conditions. To do so would negate the essence of section 18 of the State Corporations Act and its provisions.

Indeed, in the Replying Affidavit of Mr. Famba for the 1st respondent, paragraph 25 confirms that the position of Inspector General (Corporations) is governed by section 18 of the State Corporations Act. A review of the terms and conditions thereof cannot be undertaken through the Delegation Instrument. What is set out under the law cannot be negated outside the law.

Under paragraph 27 of the Replying Affidavit, Mr. Famba admits that the PSC received an indent from the authorizing officer but the changes made were justified under section 55 of the Public Service Commission Act for factors such as ensuring parity of treatment, the human resource needs of the public service, the legitimate expectation of the public officers concerned, and, fundamentally, the need to eliminate unfair competition among public bodies.

However, where the authorized officer submitted the indent, the PSC has no justification for a variation. None is demonstrated in this regard. Reverting to the authorizing officer as the initiator was necessary before applying the changes as herein done.

As correctly submitted by the petitioner, of all the positions advertised by the 1st respondent in May 2026, only advertisement No. 109 of 2026 for Inspector General (Corporations) was changed, with a review of terms from permanent and pensionable to fixed-term contract. In response to the 1st respondent, Mr. Famba has not attached any evidence of a request initiated by the authorized officer seeking a review, the need, or the justification.

Indeed, in the authorized Officer's request dated 20th April, 2023, the advertisement for the position of Inspector General (Corporations) was to be permanent and pensionable. The duties and responsibilities were outlined to conform to section 18 of the State Corporations Act.

Any review of a public position should be based on the requirements set out in section 55 of the PSC Act. Any review of qualifications initiated by the PSC must be justified, as the overriding objective is to have such review initiated by the authorized officer under section 33 of the PSC Act. Singling out one position among several others as advertised contradicts the constitutional principles outlined in articles 10, 27, and 232 of the Constitution. This requires all persons to be treated fairly, without discrimination, and for the application of high professional standards in addressing the public service. A recruitment process should afford all persons adequate and equal opportunities for appointment. For the PSC to act contrary to the authorizing officer's request without justification is unconstitutional and unlawful.

Therefore, under the constitutional mandate of the PSC under Article 234 of the Constitution, the statutory office created by Section 18 of the State Corporations Act should henceforth be advertised in conformity with the constitutive law.

The advertisement under Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 25th May, 2026 materially differs from the statutory framework. This is unconstitutional and unlawful. It cannot stand for being invalid.

The orders sought to invalidate the advertisement and the attendant actions therefrom are justified. Accordingly, the advertisement is hereby quashed, along with all consequential actions taken thereunder by the respondents. As the basis is unconstitutional and unlawful, any action taken pursuant to the advertisement is invalid. The advertisements cannot be applied to justify any recruitment to the position of Inspector General (Corporations).

Regarding the mandate of the SRC, Article 230(4) (a) of the Constitution mandates the SRC to set and regularly review the remuneration and benefits of all State officers. A public officer appointed under an advertisement by the PSC holds a public office, and remuneration undoubtedly affects the public compensation bill. Article 230(5) requires the SRC to consider fiscal sustainability. In Muthuuri & 4 others v Attorney General & 2 others [2023] KESC 52 (KLR), the Court held that the SRC's advice on the remuneration of public officers is mandatory. The court emphasized:

“Whereas Article 230(4) (b) integrates the SRC in the determination of matters relating to the remuneration and benefits of public officers, this provision must be read alongside other provisions of the Constitution which confer power on some of the Chapter Fifteen commissions to review and make recommendations on the conditions of service of public officers under them. For instance, article 234(2)(g) empowers the Public Service Commission (PSC) to “review and make recommendations to the national government in respect of conditions of service, code of conduct and qualifications of officers in the public service” except state offices, an office of high commissioner, ambassador or other diplomatic or consular representative of the Republic.”

The PSC cannot therefore proceed to determine the remuneration of the office of the Inspector General (Corporations) without the advice of the SRC. Its role is mandatory and must be obtained before taking any action that requires that advice. The advice is binding in terms of article 259(11) of the Constitution, which directs:

“If a function or power conferred on a person under this Constitution is exercisable by the person only on the advice or recommendation, with the approval or consent of, or on consultation with, another person, the function may be performed, or the power exercised only on that advice, recommendation, with that approval or consent, or after that consultation, except to the extent that this Constitution provides otherwise.”

This position is reiterated in Teachers Service Commission v Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT) & 3 others [2015] KEELRC 863 (KLR), where the court held that no valid salary or benefit of a state or public officer shall ensue from a process that ignores the role of SRC. The advice by SRC under article 230(4) (b) of the Constitution is binding, and SRC has a role to play in collective bargaining agreements on matters relating to remuneration and benefits of public officers, including teachers.

In this case, the SRC's advice was necessary before the PSC could change the advertised position. No advice was obtained. The PSC has no mandate under the Constitution or the law to make changes to remuneration for the office of Inspector General (Corporations).

On the reliefs sought, the PSC, being bound under the Constitution to exercise its powers constitutionally and lawfully, as analyzed above, in undertaking the recruitment for the position of Office of Inspector-General (Corporation), erred in going outside the request by the authorized officer in the Vacancy Detriment No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5th May, 2026. The State Corporations Act regulates such a position, and the Delegation Instrument cannot change its legal character, statutory functions, or essential intent. Such changes are unlawful. Constitutional validity of Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 and the constitutional authority to make alterations lacking the same is null and void.

Because the changes to the office under section 18 of the State Corporations Act are invalid, the alterations to the remuneration framework, benefits, or allowances attached to the office of the Inspector General (Corporations), as requested by the authorizing officer in a request dated 20th April, 2023, are contrary to Article 230 of the Constitution. Without the necessary approvals and the advice of the 2nd respondent, as the constitutional commission authorized to review remuneration for such office, the 1st respondent's alterations are unconstitutional, null, and void. The orders of certiorari quashing Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5th May, 2026 together with all decisions, actions and processes undertaken pursuant thereto, together with all decisions, actions and processes undertaken pursuant thereto, to the extent that they are inconsistent with the Constitution and the State Corporations Act, are hereby justified.

Taking into account the ruling herein delivered on 11th June 2026 directing parties to hear the main suit and no interim orders issued, the orders of Mandamus sought by the petitioner seeking directions that any future recruitment to the office of Inspector-General (Corporations) be undertaken strictly in accordance with the Constitution, the State Corporations Act, the Public Service Commission Act, the applicable Scheme of Service, and the Constitutional mandate of the Salaries and Remuneration Commission, on the findings above, the 1st respondent shall fill the position accordingly.

The petition is successful; costs are justified.

Accordingly, the petition is with merit, and the following orders are hereby issued:

a) A declaration that the 1st respondent, in recruiting for the position of Office of Inspector-General (Corporations), acted outside its constitutional and legal mandate and the same is null and void.

b) Vacancy Advertisement No. 109/2026 published in MyGov Issue No. 42/2025-2026 dated 5th May, 2026, together with all decisions, actions and processes undertaken pursuant thereto, is hereby quashed.

c) Recruitment to the office of Inspector-General (Corporations) shall be undertaken in accordance with the Constitution, the State Corporations Act and based on the request from the authorizing officer.

d) The petitioner is awarded costs.

Delivered in open court at Nairobi this 5th day of November 2026

M. MBARŨ

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder