Background
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th September 2020, the Claimant sued the respondent for unfair and unlawful termination of his employment and prayed for the following reliefs:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th September 2020, the Claimant sued the respondent for unfair and unlawful termination of his employment and prayed for the following reliefs:
Paragraph 1 →The Court finds that the Respondent had a genuine belief that the Claimant had failed to ensure that the suspicious bags were physically searched before being allowed to proceed to the check-in counters. This belief was based on the investigation report, the CCTV footage and the Claimant's own statement. The Respondent's belief was objectively supported by the evidence on record.
Paragraph 65 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT
NAIROBI
(O N Makau J on 5th November 2026)
CAUSE NO. E561 OF 2020
ROMANUS OKETCH OGUTU ….……..…………………………....CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KENYA AIRPORTS AUTHORITY …………………………..…..RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 16th September 2020, the Claimant sued the respondent for unfair and unlawful termination of his employment and prayed for the following reliefs:
a) An order of reinstatement of the Claimant's employment and contract of service with all benefits.
b) In the alternative, damages as follows:
i. Payment of 3 months' salary in lieu of notice at Kshs.120,643.70 per month, totaling Kshs. 361,931.10.
ii. Leave days of 34 days on a prorate basis at Kshs.186,449.40.
iii. Salary as from 9th August 2018 until 5th August 2020 when the appeal was found to be inadmissible, at Kshs.2,895,448.80.
iv. General damages of 12 months' salary at Kshs.1,447,724.40.
Total: Kshs. 4,864,134.60.
c) A certificate of service.
d) Costs of the claim.
e) Interest on (c) and (h) above at court rates from the date of filing this claim until payment in full.
2. The Respondent filed a Memorandum of Defence dated 31st March 2021, admitting that it employed the Claimant from 2nd February 2004 until 9th August 2018 when it dismissed him on 9th August 2018 for misconduct. However, it denied the alleged unlawful termination and prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.
3. The Claimant filed a Reply to the Memorandum of Defence dated 6th April 2021, joining issue with the Respondent and reiterating his claim. Thereafter the suit went to full hearing.
Evidence
4. The Claimant testified as CW1. He adopted his witness statement dated 16th September 2020 as his evidence in chief and produced his list and bundle of documents dated 16th September 2020 as exhibits 1to 23.
5. In brief, he stated that he lives and does small business in Siaya. He further stated that he worked for respondent for 14 years from 2nd February 2004 until 9th August 2018, when the Respondent unlawfully, unprocedurally, unfairly and without justification terminated his contract of service. He was employed on permanent and pensionable terms as a Security Supervisor (Grade S5).
6. He testified that on 13th June 2018, he received a letter from the Respondent to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against him for an incident that took place on the morning of 25th April 2018. The allegations were that he had illegally facilitated entry of miraa/khat into the passenger terminal in disregard of the Managing Director's circular dated 8th March 2018 on the prohibition of transportation of miraa through the passenger terminal.
7. He responded to the show cause letter vide his letter dated 14th June 2018, in which he indicated that he was not aware of the allegations raised. He also referred his manager to his statement recorded on 3rd May 2018 on the incident.
8. On 5th July 2018, he was invited to appear before the disciplinary committee on 13th July 2018 but he was not given any other document. He was accompanied to the hearing by Vitalis Luseka, his fellow Security Supervisor. He was then shown a video clip which showed bags stuck on the X-ray machine conveyor belt at a screening point.
9. He explained the operations at the screening point: there is an X-ray machine, together with a monitor and a walk-through metal detector. Each of these machines is monitored by employees of the Respondent. The staff includes the bag searcher, the X-ray monitor, and the line monitor. The bag searcher's responsibility is to search bags that are identified by the X-ray monitor to contain suspicious contents only. The X-ray monitor staff has the responsibility of interpreting images of prohibited items in the passenger bags. The line monitor is to do physical searches on passengers who trigger the alarm in the walk-through metal detector. The Security Supervisor's role is the general control of the screening points and ensuring screening standards are adhered to. The Security Supervisor is in charge of supervising between 1 to 5 screening points and 1 to 15 members of staff in one single terminal.
10. The video clip also showed signs of a conversation between him and the X-ray monitor staff. It also showed him talking to the bag searcher and it showed the bag searcher removing the bags from the conveyor belt. The same clip showed him leaving the screening point to another screening point. It later showed him coming back and when he arrived, it showed him engaged in a conversation with a female passenger and directing her to where the trolleys were. It then showed the lady passenger picking her bags and leaving. It further showed him going to the information checker at the entry door of the terminal and then the video clip ended.
11. After viewing the clip, the members of the disciplinary committee raised questions on what was happening during the period of the recording. He then explained that on the material day, he went to the screening point and found the X-ray conveyor belt was full of bags which had jammed up. He made an enquiry from the X-ray monitor about what was causing the snarl-up and she responded that some bags needed to be physically searched while others were waiting for the owners to pick them. He engaged the bag searcher and instructed him to remove the bags that the owners had not picked and put them aside to await the owners to collect them.
12. Thereafter, he was called to deal with another issue of a misplaced laptop at another screening point. After solving the issue, he came back and found that the bags he had instructed the bag searcher to place aside had not been picked by the passengers. He enquired to know the owners. A lady passenger showed up and indicated that she was the owner. He talked to the lady trying to enquire where she had been and she told him that she was going through security procedures. He advised her to take a trolley and pick her bags and she left towards the check-in counters and he left and went to the entrance of the terminal to check on the passenger queue that had formed outside as it was raining. This was the explanation he gave for the video clip.
13. He testified that his accuser was not called to testify before the disciplinary committee, and the investigation report was not given to him. He contended that there was no evidence of the miraa/khat produced and he was not given any witness statement written against him. Also, no witness was called to testify against him and he was not allowed to cross-examine the investigator despite request by the colleague who accompanied him to the hearing. He contended that the committee indicated that they normally do not call witnesses for cross-examination during disciplinary hearing.
14. After the hearing he was advised that they would deliberate and notify him of the outcome. On 9th August 2018, he received a letter of termination of services from the Managing Director. To date, he is not aware of the findings of the Disciplinary Committee or even their recommendation.
15. Subsequently, he lodged an appeal against the termination of service to the Managing Director, pursuant to Clause N.12 of the Kenya Airports Authority Human Resources Manual. His appeal raised pertinent issues of law and sufficient grounds. Under the provisions of Clause N.12(1) of the Kenya Airports Authority Human Resources Manual, an appeal ought to be heard within 21 days but his appeal was neglected and disregarded.
16. Respondent took 6 months without considering his appeal and the claimant wrote a reminder which prompted them and the appeal was heard before the appeals committee. Thereafter 8 months passed without a verdict and he wrote a reminder to the respondent asking for a decision but no response came until after another 6 months when he received a letter dated 10th July 2020 from the Acting Managing Director informing him that the appeal was inadmissible.
17. He lodged another appeal on 28th July 2020 and on 5th August 2020, he got a letter from the Human Resource Manager in which again informed him that his appeal was inadmissible.
18. He explained how the operation procedures at the screening point are done. He stated that the X-ray Monitor is the person with the responsibility of identifying any bag containing suspicious/prohibited items or contents and she does not need permission from the Security Supervisor to declare any bag suspect. She is also the one who instructs the Bag Searcher on which bags to search and which ones not to. She does not need to get any instructions from the supervisor to give the instructions.
19. The Bag Searcher, on the other hand, once instructed by the Screen Monitor to search a bag, it is mandatory that he should search the bag and if the Supervisor interferes, then he should report such interference to the next immediate person in charge.
20. The claimant stated that, on the material day, no notice of miraa was brought to his attention and even if it was ever brought to his attention, he did not have any authority to instruct any of the employees at the screening point to let it go.
21. He stated that he was aggrieved with the way his employment was terminated including how the disciplinary committee of the Respondent handled the disciplinary proceedings and the subsequent appeals.
22. He averred that the termination was unlawful because it was effected without a valid reason contrary to Section 35(4)(b) of the Employment Act and the Authority's Standard Operating Procedures; the reasons were not proved as required by Section 43; and that the allegations against him were not substantiated; that he was denied a fair hearing since he was neither furnished with his accusers' statements nor allowed to cross-examine witnesses.
23. He further averred that the Respondent did not follow the prescribed hearing procedures including his appeal and as such the termination was not in accordance with justice and equity. He was also not paid salary in lieu of notice and terminal benefits, including the unexpired portion of his contract.
24. On cross-examination, he confirmed that he did not clear with the employer after the termination. He contended that the termination letter dated 9th August 2018 stated that he would be paid three months’ salary in lieu of notice. He contended that other employees were paid the same notice pay but he had no evidence that they did not clear.
25. He admitted that he was given a show cause letter and he responded. He asked for statements from the DC but he didn’t receive any. He contended that the report used to accuse him was also not availed to him despite making a verbal request for the same. He admitted that in his statement at page 2, he made reference to a CCTV clip played at the disciplinary hearing. He admitted that the Bag Searcher was to search specific bags. He contended that he did not know the Bag Searcher. He further contended that he was not aware of the contents of the bags or the specific bags that needed to be physically searched.
26. On re-examination, the claimant stated that the Bag Searcher knew what to do and as he did not need to do her work. He confirmed that he was the overall overseer of trained officers under him. He maintained that he did not know which bags were to be searched. He asked for the statement and report verbally.
27. He reiterated that his claim for 3 months' notice pay was based on the termination letter. He contended that he failed to clear because he was not convinced with the Respondent's procedure.
28. On 5th February 2026, the Claimant was recalled for further cross-examination and confirmed that he did clearance with the respondent by taking his clearance form to all departments and to his bank, KCB Kariobangi, where he had a loan. He contended that the bank informed him that all his accounts were dormant except the loan account and promised it would communicate directly with the employer. He confirmed that he never took any letter from the bank to the Respondent.
29. He confirmed that a letter dated 26th November 2024 from KCB (page 10 of the Respondent's further documents) indicated an outstanding loan of Kshs. 3,192,336.05 but the Respondent did not pay despite his agreement that his terminal dues, which are set out in the termination letter, be remitted to his KCB account.
30. The Respondent called its Manager, Employee Relations, s Jacinta Wafubwa, as RW1. She adopted her witness statement dated 1st April 2021 as her evidence in chief and produced 13 documents from the lists dated 31st March 2025 and 10th February 2025 as exhibits D1–D13.
31. In brief, her testimony was that she was stationed at the Head Office in Nairobi, charged with employee relations, staff affairs and implementation of human resource policies and was familiar with the case, having sat on the appeals committee that recommended upholding the Claimant's termination. Her testimony was based on eyewitness accounts, personal knowledge of the Respondent's policies, practices and operations and the documents in the Claimant's personnel file.
32. She stated that the Respondent appointed the Claimant as a Security Supervisor and posted him at Jomo Kenyatta International Airport to supervise the screening of passengers, their luggage and baggage at the passenger terminal. She further stated that the Claimant was issued with a job description requiring him to ensure compliance with security procedures, standards and regulations through supervision of senior security wardens and security wardens.
33. She contended that, through a memo dated 8th March 2018, the respondent cautioned staff against transferring, facilitating or participating in the handling of miraa (khat) through passenger terminal. On 25th April 2018, the Respondent received a report from JKIA's baggage handling system (BHS) personnel that passenger bags containing miraa, contrary to the said directive, had been intercepted. BHS is a multi-layered security system that conducts secondary screening of checked-in baggage to detect prohibited items that may compromise the safety and security of aircraft and passengers.
34. She stated that, the Claimant was required to explain how the bags containing miraa successfully passed screening and in his statement, he explained that the bags were to be searched by SW Peter Musa. He further stated that, he engaged passenger to where she was while the bags were lying there, and told him that she going through security check procedures. He then showed her where the trolleys were and directed her to collect her bags and proceed to the check-in counters.
35. RW1 contended that the said statements by the claimant demonstrated that he knew the bags had been marked for physical search but failed to ensure that the bags were searched before directing her to proceed to check-in.
36. Following the Claimant's statement, an investigation was conducted as to how the miraa had passed the screening point at Terminal 1A, and upon review of CCTV footage of luggage passing through Terminal 1A at all material times, it was established that:
a) The bags were screened by a security warden named Susan Ngugi, who, upon screening them, found them suspicious and marked them for physical search.
b) One Peter Musa, who was the bag searcher at Terminal 1A, removed the bags from the search table and placed them aside for purposes of conducting a physical search.
c) Once the owner of the bags presented herself for the search, the Claimant, who was supervising security at Terminal 1A, was seen talking to her, after which he allowed the bags to proceed to check-in at the baggage handling system without physical search.
37. RW1 stated that the investigation established that the Claimant released the suspicious bags marked for physical search without ensuring the search was conducted as per the security standard operating procedures. The report further recommended that disciplinary action be taken against employees adversely mentioned for violation of various of the Respondent's policies, including the Claimant.
38. She contended that the report established the claimant had violated Clause N4(1)(a) of the Respondent's HR Manual, which provides that disciplinary action will be taken against employees who neglect, disregard and without sufficient reason fail to comply with an order, regulation, standing order, or departmental instruction. According, the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter for illegally facilitating miraa into the passenger terminal, contrary to the memo dated 8th March 2018.
39. The show cause letter stated that he had violated Clause N4(1)(a) of the Respondent's HR Manual and Clause 41.0(i) of the Collective Bargaining Agreement, which makes failure to comply with an order, regulation or standing departmental instructions an offence. He responded by reiterating the contents of his statement.
40. RW1 further stated that the claimant’s response was found unsatisfactory and by another letter dated 5th July 2018 he was invited to a disciplinary hearing and informed of his right to representation. The disciplinary committee met on 13th July 2018, and the Claimant attended and he was given an opportunity to defend himself. In the end the panel found him culpable of illegal facilitation of miraa and recommended his termination, which was communicated to him by letter dated 9th August 2018.
41. The Claimant appealed and an appeals committee was constituted on 13th February 2019. She confirmed that she attended hearing of the appeal and the claimant was given an opportunity to challenge the termination. In the end the committee upheld the termination.
42. RW1 stated that she saw the CCTV footage where the Claimant's complicity and/or willful neglect was apparent. The contended that the claimant breached the respondent’s policies either willfully or negligently and therefore the reason for the termination was valid and related to his conduct within the meaning of section 45(2)(a)& (b) of the Employment Act.
43. Finally, she stated that the procedure followed before terminating claimant’s employment was fair and faulted him for failing to clear with the Respondent and instead chose to file the present suit. Therefore she prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.
44. On cross-examination, she stated that she was a HR officer in 2018 when the incidence occurred. She further testified that, after receiving the investigation report, the HR Manager initiated the disciplinary process against the Claimant. She reiterated that she sat in the claimant’s appeal against the termination.
45. She confirmed that Appendix 2 (Investigations Report) page 4 of the respondent’s bundle, finding 2 was that Susan was supervising X-ray while the Claimant was the Supervisor and not the bag searcher. She also confirmed that Appendix 7, page 11, the Claimant told the Bag Searcher to push bags ahead because the queue was building up.
46. She further confirmed that on Page 12 Susan Ngugi said that there was no Bag Searcher and that she informed the Supervisor; and on Page 13 she repeated that there was no Bag Searcher but the Supervisor.
47. RW1 confirmed that the investigation was done by Mr. Newton Kithuka and he also attended the disciplinary hearing to show the pictures and clarify any issues. She contended that an appeal by an employee takes about 3 months, but there is no fixed time. She admitted that the appeal herein was heard on 18th February 2019 while the termination was done in August 2018.
48. In re-examination, RW1 stated that, as a standard operating procedure (SOP), a bag search requires the presence of the passenger, the Bag Searcher and the Supervisor. She reiterated that she never attended the disciplinary hearing but the appeal hearing. She also reiterated that her evidence was based on records in her office.
49. After the hearing counsel for both parties filed written submissions urging the court to find in their client’s favour.
Issues for Determination and analysis
50. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced, and the written submissions filed by both parties, it is a fact that the claimant was employed by the respondent under a contract of service from 2nd February 2004 to 9th August 2018 when the respondent terminated the contract. The following issues fall for determination:
a) Whether the termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair and unlawful.
b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Unfair termination
51. Section 45 (2) of the Employment Act provides that:
“(2)A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove—
(a) that the reason for the termination is valid;
(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason—
(i) related to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility; or
(ii) based on the operational requirements of the employer; and
that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure.”
52. The above law has its roots from the International Labour Organization convention 158 on termination of employment specifically Article 4 and 7 which I have copied below:
“Article 4 – the employment of a worker shall not be terminated unless there is a valid reason for such termination connected with the capacity or conduct or the operational requirement requirements of the undertaking, establishment or service.
Article 7 – The employment of a worker shall not be terminated for reason related to the worker’s conduct or performance before he is provided an opportunity to defend himself against the allegations made, unless the employer cannot be expected to provide this opportunity.”
53. The key factors to consider in determining whether a termination is lawful are substantial fairness and procedural fairness. The former refers to the validity of the reason or reasons upon which the termination is grounded while the latter entails the steps followed before making the decision to terminate including the fair opportunities availed to the employee to defend himself/herself.
Substantive Fairness
54. The termination letter dated 9th August 2018 cited the reason for the termination as “illegal facilitation of miraa at the JKIA Terminal 1A. The termination took effect on the same date. The burden of proof of the reason of termination lies with the employer and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of Section 45.
55. In the instant case, the Respondent alleged that the Claimant facilitated the passage of miraa through JKIA passenger Terminal 1A on 25th April 2018, in violation of the Managing Director's circular dated 8th March 2018, Clause N4(1)(a) of the Respondent's HR Manual, and Clause 41.0(i) of the Collective Bargaining Agreement.
56. The Claimant denied the allegations and stated that on the material day, he was supervising five passenger screening points at Terminal 1A, and all the points had Bag Searchers whose responsibility was to search bags. The Claimant contended that he was unaware of the specific bags marked for searching and maintained that the Screen Monitor and the Bag Searcher were responsible for that task.
57. The Claimant contended that his role was to ensure efficient and timely movement of passengers and luggage and to clear the backlog of bags at the screening point. He contended that while clearing the screening point, the Claimant was not aware that the Bag Searcher had not done his work, and neither was he alerted as to any suspicious bags or bags yet to be searched.
58. The Claimant further testified that the operation procedures at the screening point are that it is the responsibility of the X-ray monitor person to identify any bag containing suspicious/prohibited items or contents. She does not need permission from the Security Supervisor to declare any bag suspicious. She is also the one who instructs the bag searcher on which bags to search and which ones not to. The bag searcher, once instructed by the screen monitor to search a bag, it is mandatory that he should search the bag.
59. He contended that the bag Searcher was free report to the next immediate person in charge, if the Supervisor interfered. He maintained that the material day, no notice of intercepted miraa was brought to his attention, and even if it was ever brought to his attention, he did not have any authority to instruct any of the employees at the screening point to let it go.
60. RW1, testified that the investigation established that the bags were screened by Susan Ngugi, who found them suspicious and marked them for physical search. Peter Musa, the bag searcher, removed the bags from the search table and placed them aside for physical search once the owner of the bags presented herself for the search. When she did, the Claimant was seen talking to her, after which he allowed the bags to proceed to check-in without physical search.
61. The Claimant was the supervisor and not the bag searcher. Susan Ngugi told the investigator that there was no bag searcher and therefore she informed the supervisor. The Respondent produced the investigation report, the minutes of the disciplinary hearing and the appeals committee report as exhibits to support its case.
62. The Court has considered the evidence on record and finds that the Claimant was the supervisor and not the bag searcher. However, he admitted in his statement recorded on 3rd May 2018 that he was aware that the belt was full and that there were some bags which were to be searched by the bag searcher, SW Peter Musa. He also admitted that he engaged the female passenger and enquired where she had been. He then showed her where the trolleys were and asked her to pick her bags and proceed to the check-in counters.
63. The Claimant's own statement therefore places him at the scene and demonstrates that he was aware that the bags had been marked for physical search. As the supervising officer on duty, it was incumbent upon him to ensure that the requisite security procedures were carried out, including confirming that the marked bags were physically searched before being allowed to proceed to the check-in counters.
64. The Claimant's actions constituted a breach of security procedures and amounted to gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(c) of the Employment Act which entitles an employer to dismiss an employee if;
“(c) an employee willfully neglects to perform work which it was his duty to perform, or if he carelessly and improperly performs any work which from its nature it was his duty, under his contract, to have performed carefully and properly.”
65. The Court finds that the Respondent had a genuine belief that the Claimant had failed to ensure that the suspicious bags were physically searched before being allowed to proceed to the check-in counters. This belief was based on the investigation report, the CCTV footage and the Claimant's own statement. The Respondent's belief was objectively supported by the evidence on record.
66. The Court is therefore satisfied that the Respondent has proved on a balance of probabilities that there was a valid and fair reason for the termination of the Claimant's employment, namely, the illegal facilitation of miraa at JKIA Terminal 1A. He did so when he failed to ensure that the suspicious bags marked for physical search were searched before being allowed to proceed to the check-in counters. The said default amounted to a breach of the Respondent's security procedures and standard operating procedures.
Procedural fairness
67. Section 41 of the Employment Act sets out the following mandatory disciplinary procedure:-
“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.
(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”
68. The above provision places a heavy burden on the employer to ensure that the employee is accorded a fair hearing before termination of his employment. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR the Court of Appeal held as follows:-
“Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass muster:
(i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee;
(ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination;
(iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination is made;
(iv) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee.”
69. In the instant case, the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter dated 13th June 2018, which he responded to vide his letter dated 14th June 2018. He was invited to a disciplinary hearing on 13th July 2018 via a letter dated 5th July 2018, which letter informed him of his right to representation. He attended the disciplinary hearing accompanied by Vitalis Luseka, his fellow Security Supervisor. He was shown a video clip and given an opportunity to explain what was happening. He made his representations.
70. The Claimant's complaint is that he was not furnished with witness statements or the investigation report, his accusers were not called, and he was denied the right to cross-examine witnesses. However, the Respondent contended that disciplinary process is not like a criminal court where employees must be given statements by their accusers and a chance to cross-examine witnesses.
71. Having considered the facts of the case, I am satisfied that the respondent followed a fair procedure before terminating the services of the claimant on 9th August 2018. The claimant was served with a show letter framing the charges and he responded in writing. Thereafter he was taken through a hearing process fashioned along the mandatory procedure under Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007.
72. However, fair procedure goes beyond the decision by the Disciplinary Committee to include the communication of the decision, issuance of certificate of service, payment of dues and appeal process.
73. The claimant adduced evidence to prove that he lodged his appeal on time but the respondent delayed determination beyond the 21 days provided by Clause N.12 of the Kenya Airports Authority Human Resources Manual. The appeal was filed on 16th August 2018 and was heard by the appeals committee on 13th February 2019 after the claimant served a reminder. Thereafter the decision of appeals committee was not communicated to the Claimant until 10th July 2020, after he wrote another reminder to the respondent.
74. The delay in finalizing the claimant’s appeal was almost two years after it was lodged. A delay of that period was unreasonable considering that the respondent’s HR Manual provided for 21 days. The respondent violated its own HR Manual and by so doing exposed the claimant to financial difficulties and anxiety as highlighted above. Procedural fairness does not end with the decision of the disciplinary hearing unless the employee does not file an appeal.
75. Where an employee lodges an appeal, the employer is bound by his HR Policies and procedures manual and Collective Bargaining Agreement (if any) to act fairly. He cannot place the employee in suspense for an unreasonably long time. The employer has a duty to finalize the process in order for the employee to know his fate and begin his sojourn of hunting for a new job.
76. In this case, the delay in concluding the appeal was unreasonable and the respondent did not explain the same. Consequently, I find that, although the respondent followed a fair procedure at the initial hearing, it thereafter breached its own HR Manual by unreasonably delaying the appeal process for almost two years, when the appeal ought to have been disposed of within 21 days. Accordingly, I hold that the termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair within the meaning of Section 45(2)(c), (4)(b) and (5)of the Employment Act, 2007 since viewed as a whole, it was not done in accordance with equity and justice. As noted above the respondent failed to accord the claimant a fair hearing on his appeal. It is trite law that justice delayed is justice denied.
Reliefs
77. The Claimant prayed for reinstatement to his position as Security Supervisor with full benefits. However, Section 12(3)(viii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act provides that the Court may make an order for reinstatement of any employee within three years of dismissal. The Claimant was dismissed on 9th August 2018. The period of separation is now over seven years. The prayer for reinstatement cannot therefore issue.
78. However, there is an alternative prayer of compensatory damages for unfair termination under section 49 of the Employment Act. Considering the claimant’s long service of 14 years and also the fact that he contributed to the termination through misconduct, I award him three-months gross salary, being Kshs.361,931.10, as compensation for the unfair termination due to the unreasonable delay by the employer in determining his appeal.
79. The Claimant prayed for payment of 3 months' salary in lieu of notice at Kshs. 120,643.70 per month, totaling Kshs. 361,931.10. The termination letter dated 9th August 2018 indicated that the Claimant was entitled to three (3) months' salary pay in lieu of notice. The Respondent did not produce any evidence to show that this amount was paid. The RW1, confirmed on cross-examination that the Respondent had not paid the Claimant's terminal dues. Therefore, I award the said Kshs.361,931.10.
80. The Claimant prayed for leave days of 34 days on a prorate basis at Kshs. 186,449.40. The Respondent submitted that no evidence was led to prove the Claimant's entitlement to compensation under this head. The termination letter dated 9th August 2018 indicated that the Claimant was entitled to leave days earned but not utilized up to 9th August 2018. The Claimant prayed for 34 leave days but no particulars were pleaded and no documentary evidence was adduced to prove the exact number of leave days accrued. Consequently, I decline the claim for accrued leave.
81. The Claimant prayed for Kshs. 2,895,448.80 being salary as from 9th August 2018 until 5th August 2020, when the appeal was found to be inadmissible. The Claimant's argument is that during the pendency of the appeal, he was still an employee of the Respondent and is therefore entitled to be paid a salary.
82. The Respondent submitted that the Claimant is not entitled to any compensation under this head since salary is only paid to compensate for services rendered and not for unjust enrichment.
83. Section 17 of the Employment Act, 2007 provides that wages are earned for work done. The Claimant did not render any services to the Respondent after 9th August 2018. The pendency of an appeal does not, in itself, entitle an employee to salary for services not rendered. He was supposed to mitigate losses unless the employer made him stick around the work place.
84. Since he did not show that he was required to remain in suspension during the pendency of the appeal, the claim for salary from 9th August 2018 until 5th August 2020 is declined.
85. The Claimant prayed for a certificate of service and I find that he is entitled to the same under section 51(1) of the Employment Act, 2007. The Respondent averred that the certificate of service is available for collection subject to the claimant completing clearance process.
86. The Court ordered the claimant to do the clearance during the pendency of the hearing and he produced a copy of Clearance Form signed by various departments on 5th August 2024. Consequently, I order the Respondent to issue the Claimant with a certificate of service forthwith.
87. As regards the prayer for costs of the claim, Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act provides that costs shall follow the event. The claimant has succeeded in his suit and therefore he is entitled to costs.
Conclusion
88. I have found that the termination of the claimant’s contract was unfair because the employer unreasonably delayed the claimant’s appeal. I have further found that the claimant is entitled to some the reliefs sought in his suit. Consequently, I enter judgment for the claimant as follows:
(a) Notice Kshs.361,931.10.
(b) Compensation Kshs.361,931.10.
Total Kshs.723,862.20
(c) Certificate of service
(d) Costs and interest at court rates from the date of the judgment.
(e) The award of damages is subject to statutory deductions.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
ONESMUS MAKAU
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ambani for Claimant
Okelo for Ouma for Respondent