Background
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 15th July, 2024, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.M Kivuti delivered on 8th April, 2023 on grounds inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 15th July, 2024, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.M Kivuti delivered on 8th April, 2023 on grounds inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →The ELRC in several cases has always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court refers to the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others. The court therefore takes the view that in as much as the Appellant had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove that termination occurred, the trial court ought to…
Paragraph 12 →In conclusion this court disagrees with the trial court decision and finds that the Appellant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally unfair and unjustified.
Paragraph 20 →The Respondent further alleged that they issued the Appellant with a notice of payment of salary in lieu of notice on 6th August 2018 after realizing that the Appellant had absconded duties. This court notes that the show cause letter is dated 9th July, 2018 which had the allegations of deviating the designated route for the Appellant’s own selfish gains. The Appellant alleged that he was barred from accessing the Respondent’s premises…
Paragraph 9 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
APPEALS DIVISION
APPEAL NO. E200 OF 2024
JEREMIAH MUTINDA MAINGA…………..…………….. APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
STEEL STRUCTURES LIMITED………..…………...…. RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Honourable D.M Kivuti delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in CMEL No. 159 of 2019 on 8th April,2023.)
JUDGMENT
(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)
1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 15th July, 2024, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.M Kivuti delivered on 8th April, 2023 on grounds inter alia: -
i. The Learned Magistrate erred in law by failing to take in to account and appreciating the substantive issues of law raised by the Appellant’s counsel during the hearing of the main suit and in the submissions, authorities and other documents on record.
ii. The Learned Magistrate erred in law in finding that the Respondent did discharge its burden of proof.
iii. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in finding that the Appellant’s suit lacked merit and was not sustainable.
iv. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in finding that the Appellant authored his own misfortune and that the Respondents conduct was faultless.
v. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in finding that the Respondent followed due process in terminating the Appellant’s employment.
vi. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law by failing to appreciate that the cross-examination of the Respondent’s witness disclosed factual discrepancies as far as establishing fair termination was concerned.
vii. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in finding that the conduct of the Appellant was sufficient to warrant a summary dismissal.
viii. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law by misapprehending the evidence tendered by the Appellant and arriving at erroneous findings on the issue of whether the Appellant was denied entry to the work place or whether he absconded from duty.
ix. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law by arriving at a decision that was not based on the pleadings and evidence on record.
x. In all the circumstances of the case, the Learned Magistrate failed to render justice to the Appellant and to uphold the rule of law.
2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed with costs of this appeal and that of subordinate court and the judgment delivered on 26th April, 2023 be set aside and or quashed while the Appellant’s claim as prayed in the memorandum of claim dated 5th February, 2019 be allowed.
3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.
APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS
4. The Appellant’s Advocates Mbuthia Kinyanjui and Company Advocates filed written submissions dated 20th February, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On ground 1 of the Appeal counsel submitted that the learned magistrate overlooked key legal issues raised in the hearing and submissions including the requirements for fair termination under section 41, 43,45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act. That no fair hearing was accorded, no evidence of misconduct was tendered and the Respondent’s actions amounted to constructive dismissal followed by contradictory absconding claim.
ii. Counsel submitted that during the proceedings the Appellant testified to being denied entry on 6th July, 2018 which was uncontroverted. That the Respondent’s witness admitted that no standard operating procedure for hearings existed and no hearing occurred yet the judgment summarily held the termination was fair without addressing these discrepancies or the cited authorities on fair hearing.
iii. Further it was submitted that the Magistrate failed to appreciate the evidentiary burden shift under section 47(5) where the employer must justify termination. That the Respondent produced no tracking data, witness from the transport manager or proof of selfish gains. That the omission rendered the judgment flawed as courts must consider all the evidence and authorities on record.
iv. On ground 2 counsel relied on section 47(5) on respective burden of proof that the employer must justify the grounds of termination. That the Respondent alleged deviation for selfish gains but failed to justify this ground. That the trial court found the Respondent met its burden based on the show cause letter alone ignoring the contradictory 6th August, 2018 letter accusing absconding. That the letter implied reinstatement or withdrawal of dismissal undermining the misconduct claim as apparently evidenced by the letter dated 9th July,2018 where the former letter shifted the cause of termination from misconduct to absconding which shows the termination was not justified in the first place.
v. Counsel relied on the case of Kenfreight (E.A) Limited V Benson K. Nguti (2016) eKLR where the court shunned away from unsubstantiated claims and the case of Stanley Omwoyo Onchweri v Board of Management Nakuru YMCA Secondary School (2015) eKLR and Dikson Matingi v DB Schenker Limited (2016) eKLR on employer making efforts to reach absconding employee and notifying them that they are considering termination on account of absconding duty.
vi. It was submitted that the Respondent also produced a letter dated 6th August, 2018 which stated that the Appellant’s last day of work as July, 06 2018 hence there was no way the Appellant would be said to have absconded duties if the Respondent captured his last day of work.
vii. On ground 3 counsel submitted that the suit hinged on unfair termination as per section 45(2) of the Employment Act which requires a valid reason and fair procedure. That the Appellant’s uncontroverted evidence of denial of entry established constructive dismissal followed by unfair summary dismissal without a hearing.
viii. It was submitted that the trial court dismissed the suit as unsustainable yet ignored the Respondent’ failure to prove misconduct or follow procedure. That the Appellant’s claim for remedies was sustainable per section 49(1) of the Act including 7 years’ service. Counsel submitted that the error warrants reversal while relying on the case of Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission (2013) KEELRC 386(KLR) where unsubstantiated dismissals were deemed unfair.
ix. On ground 4 counsel submitted that the judgment blamed the Appellant for authoring his own misfortune by not responding to the show cause which ignored the evidence that he was already denied entry rendering response futile. That the Respondent’s conduct of denial of entry, no hearing, contradictory letters was fault ridden.
x. On ground 5 counsel relied on section 41 of the Employment Act on fair hearing that the Respondent admitted that no hearing occurred, relied on written response only which fell short of due process. That the show cause letter was served post denial of entry and no investigations followed backed by anyone in the Respondent’s company not even he transport manager.
xi. On ground 6 counsel submitted that the cross examination revealed discrepancies of no standard operating procedures for hearings, no transport manager involvement, no tracking evidence and contradiction between dismissal for misconduct and absconding letter. That the trial court failed to appreciate these in evaluation of evidence. That discrepancies in employer’s testimony or documentation at trial ought to be ruled in favor of an employee as they undermine employer’s credibility.
xii. On ground 7 counsel submitted that for termination to pass fairness test there must not only have the substantive test but procedural test as well while relying on the case of Omondi & 9 Others v Brava Food Industries Ltd & Another (2025) KEELRC 1378(KLR) and another on this assertion. That no evidence proved deviation for selfish gains. The alleged conduct was unproven and summary dismissal under section 44(4) requires gross misconduct with fair procedure which was absent in this case.
xiii. On ground 8 counsel submitted that the Appellant’s evidence of denial of entry on 6th July, 2018 was uncontroverted yet the magistrate misapprehended it as absconding. That the magistrate ought not to have placed that burden of proving the denial on the employee because it was simply not logical.
xiv. On ground 9 counsel submitted that the decision ignored pleadings and evidence basing it on unproven assertions. That before the trial court could make a finding that the Appellant had discharged his burden of proof on a balance of probabilities the rule is that whoever alleges must prove and such evidence ought to be consistent with his pleadings. Reliance was placed on the case of Antony Francis Wareham t/a AF Wareham & 2 Others v Kenya Post Office Savings Bank (2004) KECA 166 (KLR)
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
5. The Respondent’s Advocates Atuti & Associates Advocates filed written submissions dated 12th June, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On the issue of whether the trial court overlooked key legal issues raised in the hearing and submissions including requirements for fair termination under section 41, 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act counsel submitted that the same was farfetched and misleading. That the Appellant was granted opportunity under section 41 of the Act when he was issued with show cause letter but he instead opted to desert employment and terminating employment contract without notice.
ii. On the allegation that the trial court erred in finding that the Respondent did discharge its burden of proof counsel relied on section 47(5) of the Employment Act which require the employer to justify grounds of termination. That apart from the Appellant claiming he was unfairly terminated he never produced evidence to substantiate the manner in which the termination was effected.
iii. Counsel submitted that the Respondent in rebuttal alleged desertion of employment and produced notice to show cause and the demand letter for payment of salary in lieu of notice to back its allegation. That in the face of this rebuttal the Appellant ought to have refuted the allegations of desertion by way of evidence which he did not.
iv. Counsel relied on among others the case of Erastus Onyango v Manoa Malenya(2015) eKLR to submit that the appellate court will hardly interfere with conclusion made by trial court after weighing the credibility of the witnesses in cases where there is a conflict of primary facts between witnesses and where credibility of the witnesses is crucial.
v. Counsel submitted that the trial magistrate made correct finding based on the evidence adduced and the appeal had no basis. That the Respondent discharged its duty under the provisions of section 41 of the Act by demonstrating efforts made to give the Appellant opportunity to plead his case and further to demand for payment of salary on account of termination of employment. That the appeal was an afterthought after the trial court properly determined the issues when litigation must come to an end the appeal seeks to keep parties longer in court. That the appeal should be dismissed with costs to the Respondent.
DETERMINATION
6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by both parties herein and proceeds to analyse them while appreciating the role of this court as first appellate court is to re-evaluate the evidence tendered at trial court and reach its own determination while placing reliance on the case of Gitobu Imanyara & 2 others v Attorney General [2016] eKLR, among others.
7. In this case, the Judgment of the trial court was a declaration that the Claimant’s claim was dismissed for being not sustainable. That the Appellant deserted workplace which led to summary dismissal hence he authored his own misfortunes as the employer was not expected to do much. The Appellant aggrieved by the judgment appeals the whole of the Judgment raising 10 grounds in his memorandum of appeal which this court will condense in to two main issues namely: -
i. Whether the trial court erred by finding that the Appellant deserted duties; he was to blame for his own misfortunes hence fairly terminated by the Respondent
ii. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe Whether the trial court erred by not awarding the Appellant his reliefs sought in the claim
Whether the trial court erred by finding that the Appellant deserted duties; he was to blame for his own misfortunes hence fairly terminated by the Respondent
8. It was not in dispute that the Appellant was employed by the Respondent as a driver on 26th September, 2011 until July, 2018 but the parties differ on how employment ended. Whereas the Appellant alleged that he was denied entry to the premises on 6th July, 2018 and the show cause letter issued after he was denied entry and the allegations of deviating from the designated route for his selfish gains made thereafter. The Respondent alleges that after the Appellant was issued with show cause letter on allegations of deviating from the designated route for his selfish gains he failed to respond to the show cause letter and deserted place of work.
9. The Respondent further alleged that they issued the Appellant with a notice of payment of salary in lieu of notice on 6th August 2018 after realizing that the Appellant had absconded duties. This court notes that the show cause letter is dated 9th July, 2018 which had the allegations of deviating the designated route for the Appellant’s own selfish gains. The Appellant alleged that he was barred from accessing the Respondent’s premises on 6th July, 2018. The letter requesting the Appellant to make payment for notice period of two months dated 6th August, 2018 confirms that the last day the Appellant worked was on 6th July, 2018. This means that by the time the Respondent issued the show cause letter the Appellant was no longer working for them.
10. In any case the Respondent never produced any evidence of the Appellant receiving the show cause letter. The same was not signed by the Appellant to confirm receipt or the Respondent never produced any muster rolls or attendance sheets to show that by the time the Appellant allegedly issued with the show cause letter he was present and absconded thereafter.
11. The Respondent as the custodian of employment records is required under section 74 of the Employment Act to illustrate that indeed the Appellant stopped working once he was issued with show cause letter. The trial court on the other hand found that the Appellant absconded duties, he was to blame for his own misfortunes and the Respondent was expected not to do much.
12. The ELRC in several cases has always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court refers to the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others. The court therefore takes the view that in as much as the Appellant had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove that termination occurred, the trial court ought to have evaluated the circumstances under which the alleged termination occurred, in this case the issue of absconding as alleged by the respondent and the Appellant’s claim that he was denied entry to his workplace.
13. The Respondent alleged that the Appellant absconded duties after he was issued with show cause letter. Under Section 44(4) (a) of the Employment Act, absconding duty by an employee constitutes gross misconduct and renders an employee liable for summary dismissal. The Respondent relied on the defence of desertion that the Appellant had no intention of returning to the place of work. Proof of desertion has been considered in several cases by ELRC including the case of Stanley Omwoyo Onchweri v Board of Management Nakuru YMCA Secondary School [2015] eKLR, where the court held that:-
18. Desertion can only take place where an employee leaves employment with the intention of not returning or formulating such intention not to return after leaving. Such intention may be demonstrated by showing absence of communication from the employee, duration of absence, impact of the absence and nature of employee’s duties.
14. The Respondent claims desertion/absconding of duty after the Appellant was issued with show cause letter while the Appellant alleged that he was barred from accessing the Respondent’s premises on 6th July, 2018. The Respondent confirmed that the last day the Appellant worked was on 6th July, 2018 in its letter dated 6th August, 2018. There was no proof of the Appellant receiving the said letter since he was no longer working for the Respondent as seen above.
15. The Respondent never showed any efforts of contacting the Appellant if at all he absconded duties and it never clarified when the Appellant absconded duties. In addition, if the Appellant absconded duties the Respondent did not demonstrate that it commenced any disciplinary action against the Respondent under Section 41 of the Employment Act after he allegedly failed to report on duty. The only letter of 6th August, 2018 of payment of notice in lieu notice worked against the respondent’s case by confirming the Appellant’s word that his last day of work was on 6th July,2018 and by the time the show cause was issued he was not at work.
16. It was held in the case of Richard Kiplimo Koech Vs Yuko Supermarket Ltd [2015] eKLR that absconding duty is an act of misconduct on the part of the employee, in which case the requirements of Section 41 of the Employment Act obtain. Further in the case of Joseph Nzioka v Smart Coatings Limited [2017] eKLR Nduma J. observed that:_
“Dismissal on account of absconding must be preceded by evidence showing that reasonable attempt was made to contact the employer concerned and that a show cause letter was issued to such employee calling upon such employee to show cause why his services should not be terminated on account of absconding duties.”
17. The Respondent had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to justify the grounds of termination in this case absconding of work since the claims of deviating from designated route for selfish gains was never proved by the Respondent when in the first place the Appellant never received the said show cause letter and no evidence was led on those allegations. The Respondent did not issue any show cause letter to the Appellant on the allegations of absconding duties.
18. This court therefore finds that the Respondent failed to justify the grounds of allegation of absconding of duties by the appellant. The trial court therefore erred in this regard and this sets aside the findings.
19. Concerning procedural fairness as provided for under section 41 of the Employment Act this court notes that the same was never adhered to as the Respondent, as illustrated above, never satisfactorily proved serving the show cause letter on the Appellant. The Respondent confirmed that there were no hearing guidelines in its organization and the Appellant was never heard. In that respect, the court is guided by the holding in the case of Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Meru North Farmers Sacco Limited [2014] eKLR that: -
Section 41 of the Employment Act is couched in mandatory terms. Where an employer fails to follow these mandatory provisions, whatever outcome of the process is bound to be unfair as the affected employee has not been accorded a hearing in the presence of their union representative.
20. In conclusion this court disagrees with the trial court decision and finds that the Appellant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally unfair and unjustified.
Whether the trial court erred by not awarding the Appellant his reliefs sought
21. The trial court after finding that the Appellant absconded duties did not analyse the prayers sought since it termed it as summary dismissal. This court having reached a different conclusion from the trial court will proceed to assess compensation due to the appellant.
22. On the claim for 12 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination, this court having found that the Appellant was unfairly terminated, is entitled to the compensation under Section 49(1) (c)of the Employment Act. The court however notes that the award of compensation under this section is discretionary but guided by considerations set out under Section 49(4) of the Employment Act.
23. The court appreciates the fact that the Appellant had served the Respondent for around 7 years, he had a clean disciplinary record and that the termination of his service was unfair in the circumstances, 8 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination will be considered adequate in the circumstances.
24. The award of one-month salary in lieu of notice was also justified after finding the Respondent was unfairly terminated without notice as provided for under section 35 of the Employment Act as well as the employment contract. The Appellant was also entitled to the salary for the 5 days worked in July 2018 since he was barred from entering the Respondent’s offices on 6th July, 2018.
25. On the claim for leave pay the same is a special damage which has to be specifically pleaded and proved. The Appellant only prayed for the same on pro rata basis without guiding the court on how much leave he was entitled to. Parties are bound by their own pleadings and this court will not allow a prayer which is not properly pleaded and proved.
26. On the issue of service pay which was only pleaded in the appeal this court notes that the same was not pleaded in trial court and in any case the Appellant from the attached payslip, was a member of NSSF hence he fell under exceptions under section 35(6) (d) of the Employment Act.
27. The Appellant is entitled to certificate of service as provided for under section 51 of the Employment Act if the same has not yet being issued.
28. In the upshot the Appeal is found merited and is hereby allowed with costs to the Appellant as follows.
a. 8 Months compensation for unfair termination…. 66,974.46/= x 8 = Kshs 535,795.68/=
b. Notice pay……..Kshs 66,974.46/=
c. Salary for days worked in July 2018…Kshs11,162.41/=
d. Unpaid leave………...NIL
e. TOTAL KSHS 613,932.55/=. The award shall be subject to taxes and statutory deductions but shall attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full.
29. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 5th day of November 2026
Delivered virtually this 5th day of November 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-ELRC-Mombasa