REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. 267 OF 2014
PETER KIMEU & 130 OTHERS…………...…..........................CLAIMANTS
VERSUS
MANG HOTEL……………………………………………..1ST RESPONDENT
TIMOTHY KINUTHIA ……………………….…………..2ND RESPONDENT
AND
FELISTERS MUCHERA GITHURA…………………………....1ST OBJECTOR
PETER NG’ANG’A NGAHU……………………………….2ND OBJECTOR
MANG CITY HOTEL LTD…………………………………....3RD OBJECTOR
RULING
1. This ruling relates to the Objectors’ Notice of Motion application dated 26th February, 2026, made pursuant to Order 22 Rules 51(1) & 52 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Rule 72 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024. The Objector/Applicants seek the following reliefs: -
i. Spent
ii. Spent
iii. Spent
iv. THAT the Proclamation dated 23rd February, 2026 on the properties of the Objectors be lifted.
v. THAT cost of this Application be paid by the Claimants and Vin Auctioneers jointly and severally.
2. The application is supported by grounds on the face thereof and the affidavit sworn by Felisters Muchera Githura, on 26th February, 2026. The crux of the Motion is that the Claimants obtained Judgment in this matter against the Respondents on 19th June, 2015, together with costs of the suit.
3. The Objectors aver that they were not parties to the proceedings and have no known relationship with either the Claimants or the Respondents herein. They state that the Claimants instructed Vin Auctioneers to execute the decree in this matter.
4. The Objectors further contend that the auctioneers in execution of the subject decree, unlawfully proclaimed their movable assets without justification. They state that the proclamation notice dated 23rd February, 2026 lapsed on 2nd March, 2026, necessitating urgent intervention to prevent irreparable loss, including closure of their business.
5. They maintain that they are tenants occupying three floors of Mang Hotel under a lease dated 1st September, 2023, and that the 3rd Objector is a separate legal entity incorporated nine years after the suit was filed.
6. It is the Objectors’ assertion that their business has no connection with the Claimants or Respondents. They further aver that they were neither in occupation nor using the premises as at 19th June, 2015.
7. Accordingly, the Objectors seek the lifting and setting aside of the proclamation notice.
8. The Claimants opposed the Motion vide a Replying affidavit sworn by PETER KIMEU MOSE on 10th March, 2026.
9. The deponent avers, on behalf of his Co-Claimant, that he has read and understood the application dated 26th February, 2026, and that he has recognized the movable assets listed in Vin Auctioneers’ proclamation dated 23rd February, 2026 as the same property previously used by the 1st Applicant during his employment.
10. The Claimants/Respondents further contend that the proclaimed assets were previously used by Mang Cafe Limited, whose directors are allegedly the same as those of Mang Hotel Limited. He argues that the Objectors should produce purchase receipts to prove ownership of the proclaimed goods.
11. The Claimant further contends that the assets have always remained in the hotel and have been used in its operations by successive tenants, adding that they are old and in fair condition.
12. He therefore seeks dismissal of the application with costs.
13. Parties canvassed the motion by way of written submissions which have been duly considered.
Analysis and Determination.
14. The singular issue for determination is whether the Objectors have established a sufficient legal and factual basis to warrant the lifting of the proclamation and stay of execution on the ground that the proclaimed movable assets belong to them and not to the Judgment Debtors.
15. The purpose of objector proceedings is to protect third parties from having their property wrongfully attached to satisfy another person's decree. They are not intended to reopen or challenge the merits of the judgment.
16. The central question herein is whether the Objectors have demonstrated a legal or equitable interest in the proclaimed assets sufficient to establish that the property is not liable to attachment in execution of the decree against the Respondents. In Arun C. Sharma v Ashana Raikundalia T/A A. Raikundalia & Co. Advocates & 4 others [2014] KEHC 1412 (KLR), the Court affirmed that the burden of establishing a legal or equitable interest in attached property rests with the Objector.
17. . The same position was reiterated in Chai Trading Co. Limited v Muli Mwanzia & 2 others [2019] KEHC 9028 (KLR), and applied by this Court in Josephat Randa Nyatieno v Vyas Hauliers Limited; Dhimahi Transport Limited (Objector) [2021] KEELRC 2028 (KLR), where the Court held that an Objector must demonstrate a definite interest in the specific proclaimed property through cogent evidence.
18. Applying these principles, the Objectors rely principally on their status as tenants of Mang Hotel under a lease agreement dated 1st September, 2023 and the separate incorporation of the 3rd Objector.
19. The documents produced indeed establish their occupation of the premises and the 3rd Objector's separate legal personality, but they do not, without more, establish ownership of the specific movable assets proclaimed by the auctioneers.
20. Further, the Objectors have not demonstrated, through purchase receipts, invoices, an asset register, a schedule of property acquired by them, or other credible documentary evidence, that the proclaimed goods belong to them.
21. Additionally, the fact that the 3rd Objector was incorporated after the institution of the suit herein, and the Objectors were not parties to the proceedings, does not, in my view, resolve the question of ownership.
22. The Claimants, on their part, contend that the proclaimed goods were previously used by the 1st Applicant during his employment and subsequently by Mang Cafe Limited, whose directors are allegedly the same as those of Mang Hotel Limited. They further assert that the goods have remained in the hotel and have been used in its operations by successive tenants.
23. This evidence, in my view, raises a legitimate question regarding the ownership and history of the goods, but the Claimants have also not independently demonstrated that the assets belong to the Judgment Debtors.
24. Although I am mindful that the proclamation was made at premises currently occupied by the Objectors under a lease, the Objectors cannot obtain the release of the goods merely by demonstrating that they occupy the premises where the goods are situated. They were obliged to establish their own legal or equitable interest in the proclaimed property, which they did not.
25. In Josephat Randa Nyatieno v Vyas Hauliers Limited (supra), the Court demonstrated that objection proceedings may succeed in respect of particular items where ownership is established, without necessarily stopping execution against all the proclaimed property. That approach underscores the need for evidence identifying the Objectors’ interest in each item sought to be released.
26. I therefore find that the Objectors have established their occupation of the premises, but have not sufficiently demonstrated ownership or another legal or equitable interest in the proclaimed movable assets, and their apprehension of business disruption and financial loss cannot substitute for the evidential burden imposed by Order 22 Rule 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
27. In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Objectors have not established sufficient grounds for lifting the proclamation dated 23rd February, 2026 or staying execution of the decree herein.
28. Consequently, the application dated 26th February, 2026 is dismissed with no orders on costs.
29. Orders accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Njiru present for the Claimants
Mr. Karwanda present for the Objectors
Ms. Esther- C/A