Employment law

Kenya Engineering Workers Union v Universal Engineering Systems Ltd [2026] KEELRC 15004 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E033 of 2024
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This judgment relates to the Claimant union’s Memorandum of Claim dated 17th January, 2024, where it seeks the following remedies against the Respondent:

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Universal Engineering Systems Ltd breached Clause 42 of the registered collective bargaining agreement (CBA) dated 10 December 2021 by failing to provide the agreed transport allowance, and whether Kenya Engineering Workers Union was entitled to…

Material facts

The parties had a valid registered CBA. Clause 42 required the employer to give transport to employees assigned work outside its office or workshop premises within Nairobi, at the minimum bus fare agreed by the parties. The respondent said that, after…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E033 OF 2024

KENYA ENGINEERING WORKERS UNION........................... CLAIMANT

VERSUS

UNIVERSAL ENGINEERING SYSTEMS LIMITED..................RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction.

1. This judgment relates to the Claimant union’s Memorandum of Claim dated 17th January, 2024, where it seeks the following remedies against the Respondent:

a. THAT, the action of the Respondent before the Honourable Court, be found null & void and bad faith.

b. THAT, the Respondent be compelled to respect the Collective Bargaining Agreement between parties and implement the C.B.A without further delay.

2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 8th April, 2024 and filed a Response to the Memorandum of Claim dated 9th September, 2024, a witness statement of Sameen Alam dated 9th September, 2024, and later amended the witness statement of Rachael Linah Musili, which is dated 5th September, 2024.

3. The matter was disposed of by way of documentary evidence, and both parties filed their respective submissions.

The Claimant’s Case.

4. The Claimant’s case is that the dispute herein arose from the parties’ CBA, dated 10th December, 2021, which the Claimant states was signed and registered. The Claimant further states that the Respondent’s refusal to implement Clause 42 of the CBA breached the agreement and abused the parties’ collectively negotiated terms.

5. The Claimant avers that the Respondent’s refusal to implement Clause 42, relating to transport allowance, and to pay the arrears resulted in a trade dispute, which it reported to the Minister on 27th January, 2023.

6. The Claimant further stated that Ms. Rhama was appointed as conciliator on 16th February, 2023, but following her transfer, the parties had to await the appointment of another conciliator. The Claimant states that it subsequently sought the reappointment of a conciliator, and Ms. Victoria Olesi was appointed to conciliate the dispute.

7. The Claimant contends that the Respondent’s refusal to implement the CBA was contrary to Article 41 of the Constitution, which guarantees fair labour practices, and that the refusal violated Sections 57 and 60 of the Labour Relations Act, 2007.

8. It maintains that the CBA was a binding agreement that both parties were required to honour and that the Respondent could not unilaterally decline to implement its provisions.

9. The Claimant seeks orders declaring the Respondent’s conduct null and void and compelling the Respondent to respect and implement the CBA without further delay.

The Claimant’s Submissions

10. The Claimant submits that the parties had a duly signed Recognition Agreement and a similarly registered CBA, and that the Respondent’s refusal to implement Clause 42 was contrary to the Labour Relations Act, 2007.

11. It is its submission that the terms of a CBA having been jointly negotiated and agreed upon were binding on both parties and ought to be respected in the interest of fair labour practice under Article 41 of the Constitution.

12. The Claimant submits further that the Respondent’s reliance on the financial difficulties occasioned by the COVID-19 pandemic did not justify its refusal to implement the CBA. It argues that the Respondent’s refusal to honour the agreed terms amounted to an abuse of the CBA and a violation of employees’ rights.

13. It further invited the Court to involve CPMU to provide an economic report to assist the Court in determining the dispute.

The Respondent’s Case

14. The Respondent’s case is that the parties herein had indeed entered into a CBA dated 10th December, 2021, which provided for bus fare allowance for employees working within Nairobi, but outside the Respondent’s business premises.

15. The Respondent maintains that it has been providing transport to its employees in accordance with the CBA until it encountered financial difficulties following the COVID-19 pandemic.

16. The Respondent further avers that the financial difficulties persisted and forced it to release a substantial number of employees because it could no longer afford to retain them. It maintains that the Claimant was aware of the Respondent’s financial position.

17. It is its position that by a letter dated 31st October, 2022, it notified the Claimant of its inability to continue paying for employee transportation in the manner previously contemplated under the CBA. Nevertheless, the Respondent asserts that it continued providing transport through company vehicles to ensure that employees could move between work sites whenever required.

18. The Respondent further states that the communication regarding the financial difficulties and the transport arrangements was conveyed to its employees.

19. The Respondent contends that the Claimant’s claim amounts to double compensation and unjust enrichment because the Respondent incurred expenses in transporting the employees between sites.

20. The Respondent avers that the claim is an abuse of the Court process, and prays that the Memorandum of Claim be dismissed with costs.

The Respondent’s Submissions

21. The Respondent acknowledged the existence of the CBA, but maintains that it did not breach its obligations because it continued providing transport to employees despite the financial challenges it is facing.

22. The Respondent submits that the Claimant has not demonstrated by credible evidence that it failed to discharge a specific obligation imposed by the CBA, arguing that the Claimant could not rely on a general allegation of non-payment without identifying the employees affected, the specific months or payment periods in question, the applicable rates, the amounts allegedly due, and the computation of the claimed arrears.

23. It further submits that the Court ought not to issue a blanket order requiring implementation of the transport allowance provisions without first establishing the nature and extent of the alleged breach.

24. On the burden of proof, the Respondent sought to rely on Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act to argue that the party asserting a fact must prove it. It cited Muriungi Kanoru Jeremiah v Stephen Ungu M’Mwirabua [2015] KEHC 1315 (KLR), on the burden resting upon the party alleging that a debt or obligation remains unpaid.

25. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant has failed to discharge that burden.

26. It is the Respondent’s further submission that the existence of financial difficulties did not, by itself, establish a breach of the CBA, particularly where it continued providing transport to employees. It denies any violation of constitutional rights and argues that any relief granted ought to correspond to a specific breach proved by evidence. It contends that the claim was unsubstantiated and urged the Court to dismiss it with costs.

27. On costs, the Respondent relied on Morgan Air Cargo Limited v Everest Enterprises Limited [2014] KEHC 8693 (KLR), to submit that the Court should consider the conduct of the parties, the circumstances leading to the institution and termination of the proceedings, the stage at which the proceedings were concluded, and the need to promote reconciliation between disputing parties.

28. It ultimately urged the Court to dismiss the claim with costs.

Analysis and Determination

29. The issues for determination are:

i. Whether the Respondent breached Clause 42 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) dated 10th December, 2021, by failing to provide the agreed transport allowance; and

ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

30. The existence of a valid CBA between the parties herein is not disputed. Article 41(5) of the Constitution protects the right of employers, trade unions and employers’ organizations to engage in collective bargaining. Further, Sections 57 and 60 of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, provide the statutory framework governing collective agreements and their binding effect.

31. The Respondent’s position is that it was providing transport to its employees in accordance with the CBA until it encountered financial difficulties following the COVID-19 pandemic. It further asserts that the financial difficulties persisted, forcing it to release a substantial number of employees because it could no longer afford to retain them, and that the Claimant was aware of its financial position.

32. A party, in my view, cannot unilaterally disregard an applicable CBA merely because its financial circumstances have deteriorated. Financial difficulties may explain the Respondent’s conduct, but do not, without more, vary or extinguish its contractual obligations.

33. In Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Meru North Farmers Sacco Limited [2014] KEELRC 813 (KLR), the Court considered the obligations arising from the employment relationship and the need to establish the relevant contractual terms.

34. The general principle is that parties are bound by the agreements they make, and the Court must enforce the applicable terms where a breach is established. The Respondent’s letter dated 31st October, 2022, notifying the Claimant of its financial difficulties could not, by itself, amend the CBA or relieve the Respondent of its obligations.

35. Further, Section 59(5) of the Labour Relations Act, specifically makes a CBA enforceable upon registration by the Court and effective from the date agreed upon by the parties. Section 59(1) & (3) further provides that the agreement binds the parties and that its terms are incorporated into the contracts of employment of the employees covered by it.

36. In light of the foregoing, the decisive question is the precise obligation imposed by Clause 42, and whether it required payment of a transport allowance or permitted the Respondent to discharge that obligation by providing transport through company vehicles.

37. Clause 42 of the CBA between the parties herein states thus: -

“BUS FARE ALLOWANCE

The employer shall give for transport to all employees assigned work outside the employee office or workshop premises within Nairobi as per the minimum fare provided in the bus fare agreed upon by the parties.”

38. Although the above caption of the CBA between the parties is not very clear, I would interpret it as saying that the employer is obliged to provide transport or pay a transport allowance to every employee assigned to perform work outside the employer’s office or workshop premises within Nairobi, calculated at the minimum fare agreed upon by the parties.

39. In my view, the Respondent’s assertion that it incurred expenses transporting employees between work sites and its assertion that it incurred financial difficulties following the COVID-19 pandemic do not satisfy Clause 42, and do not justify unilateral variation of the CBA. In Shankar Electronics Limited v Amalgamated Union of Kenya Metal Workers [2026] KEELRC 2052 (KLR), the Court reaffirmed that financial hardship does not authorize an employer to unilaterally alter terms governed by a CBA.

40. I thus reach the conclusion that the Respondent breached clause 42 of the parties’ CBA.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought

41. The Claimant seeks a declaration that the Respondent’s conduct is unlawful and an order compelling implementation of Clause 42.

42. The evidence before the Court does not establish the precise amounts outstanding on account of the bus fare allowance claimed, nor are the employees affected identified, as well as the periods affected.

43. Although the Respondent cannot escape its obligations under the CBA, the Court cannot issue a monetary award without an evidential basis. In Kenya Union of Journalists and Allied Workers v Nation Media Group Limited & Another [2013] KEELRC 397 (KLR), the Court affirmed the binding nature of a CBA, but emphasized the need for sufficient evidence that the employees concerned were denied the benefits claimed.

44. In the circumstances, I conclude that the CBA is binding upon the parties and that the Respondent’s financial difficulties did not, of themselves, entitle it to suspend or unilaterally vary Clause 42 of the CBA. However, in the absence of sufficient evidence establishing the arrears due, the Claimant has not laid a proper basis for a quantified monetary award.

45. Accordingly, I enter judgment in the following terms:-

a) A declaration is hereby issued that the parties herein are bound by the registered CBA dated 10th December, 2021.

b) That the Respondent is directed to forthwith comply with Clause 42 of the said CBA.

c) That the prayer for payment of transport allowance arrears is declined for want of sufficient particulars and proof of the amounts due.

d) Each party shall bear its own costs, in the interest of harmonious labour relations.

46. Judgment of the Court.

47. Top of Form

48. Bottom of Form

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Araka present for the Claimant

Ms. Msavakwa present for the Respondent

Ms. Esther - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder