Employment law

Kariuki v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2026] KEELRC 14996 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E280 of 2024
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the court is a plaint dated 12th September, 2000 and amended on 16th October, 2023, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Employment and Labour Relations Court had jurisdiction over the employment and pension aspects of the dispute; whether the deceased’s termination before retirement was lawful; whether he was entitled to pension benefits under the Staff Pension…

Material facts

Josephat Kemenju Kariuki, now deceased, was employed by National Bank of Kenya Limited from 15 February 1971 and rose to Branch Manager. A 3 February 1999 notice anticipated retirement in June 1999, but the Bank placed him on compulsory leave and terminated…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E280 OF 2024

JOSEPHAT KARIUKI………………………………………..……..CLAIMANT

VERSUS

NATIONAL BANK OF KENYA LIMITED……………………RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. Before the court is a plaint dated 12th September, 2000 and amended on 16th October, 2023, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-

a. A declaration that Mr. Josephat Kemenju Kariuki (now deceased) the Plaintiff retired as per the Retirement Notice dated 3/2/99 and the subsequent termination dated 3/3/99 is null and void and of no consequence or effect in law.

b. An order that the Plaintiff be paid Mr. Josephat Kemenju Kariuki’s (now deceased) his retirement Benefits and Pension in terms of the Defendant’s staff Pension fund regulations as at February 1999 by the Defendant forthwith.

c. The Defendant do off-set any sums due in respect of Mr. Josphat Kemenju Kariuki’s (now deceased) the Plaintiffs loan facilities as at February 1999 from his the Plaintiffs Retirement benefits and pension package and the balance thereto be remitted to the Plaintiff.

d. Interest on the balance between prayers (b) and (c) above at Commercial Rates and/or Prevailing Treasury Bills rates.

e. Costs of this suit and interest thereon.

f. Such further or other relief as the Court deems fit and just to grant

2. The Respondent entered an appearance and filed a statement of defence dated 16th October, 2000.

3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 3rd July, 2014 and 29th November, 2016 when PW1, Agnes Muthoni Kariuki, testified and adopted her witness statement dated 13th February, 2013 and produced the Claimant's documents.

4. The Respondent’s case was heard on 10th December, 2025 when James M. Kamau, its Head of Compensation and Benefits within the Human Resources Department, testified as RW1. He adopted his substituted witness statement dated 2nd December, 2024 as his evidence in chief. He also produced the Respondent’s documents, which were admitted as the Respondent’s Exhibits Nos. 1-52.

5. Upon conclusion of the hearing, both parties filed their submissions.

The Claimant’s Case

6. The Claimant’s case is that the deceased, Josephat Kemenju Kariuki, was employed by the Respondent Bank on 15th February, 1971 as a bank clerk and worked for the Bank for approximately 28 years and six months, rising through the ranks to the position of Branch Manager. It is averred that the Claimant was employed on permanent and pensionable terms and was governed by the Bank’s terms and conditions of service, the applicable Collective Agreement and the Bank’s Staff Pension Fund Rules.

7. The Claimant states that on 3rd February, 1999, while the deceased was serving as a Branch Manager in Meru, the Respondent issued him with a retirement notice informing him that he was due to retire with effect from 30th June, 1999, upon attaining the age of 55 years. She maintains that the deceased was therefore entitled to his retirement benefits and pension in accordance with the Respondent’s Staff Pension Fund Regulations.

8. The Claimant states that after receiving the retirement notice, the deceased requested to proceed on his retirement leave as he had accumulated over 200 days of leave. She avers that the Respondent acceded to the request and that, on or about 10th February, 1999, the deceased was instructed to hand over his duties to his Assistant, one Mr. Faustin Paul Mwangi and to complete the handover by 12.00 noon on the same day. She avers that the handover exercise was completed at approximately 2.00 p.m.

9. The Claimant contends that immediately after the handover, the Respondent served the deceased with a letter dated 10th February, 1999 alleging that he had borrowed money from one Father Hilary Wambugu of Nyeri approximately three years earlier, and that he was required to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against him and was directed to respond by 10.00 a.m. on 11th February, 1999.

10. The Claimant avers that the deceased responded to the allegations on 12th February, 1999, explaining that he had already handed over his duties and was unable to access the Respondent’s internal systems to prepare his response within the stipulated time. She avers that the Claimant consequently travelled from Meru to the Respondent’s Head Office in Nairobi to deliver his response.

11. The Claimant further avers that while the deceased was on retirement leave, he received a letter dated 3rd March, 1999 purporting to terminate his employment, which decision he appealed against on 6th March, 1999, but the Respondent did not respond to the appeal.

12. The Claimant maintains that the purported termination was irregular, unlawful, wrongful, null and void because the deceased had already proceeded on retirement leave and had handed over his duties to his assistant. She further contends that the allegations against him were previously raised in 1995, investigated and dealt with by the Respondent’s management and the matter was concluded without any basis for disciplinary action.

13. The Claimant states that in 1995 the deceased had obtained financing from the Respondent Bank and secured against two properties, namely L.R. No. KABARU/BLOCK 2/MATHINA/442 and L.R. No. NGURUBI/NDIUNI/565. She maintains that the facilities attracted staff interest rates and that upon retirement, any outstanding loan balances were to be offset against the deceased’s retirement benefits and pension and the balance paid to him.

14. The Claimant further states that instead of calculating and paying the deceased’s retirement benefits, the Respondent converted the loan facility into a commercial facility attracting interest at 30% without his consent, approval or notice. She maintains that the conversion was unlawful and that, at the time, the deceased’s retirement benefits exceeded the outstanding loan balances.

15. The Claimant further states that the deceased made several requests to the Respondent for a breakdown of his accounts and the payment transactions affecting his facilities. In particular, she refers to correspondence dated 14th October, 1999, the deceased’s response dated 6th November, 1999, a letter dated 4th January, 2000, and further correspondence in January and February 2000 concerning an amount of Kshs.235,552.95 which the Respondent described as an irregular overdraft.

16. The Claimant contends that the deceased was entitled to retirement benefits and pension amounting to over Kshs. 6,000,000/= for the period of service rendered to the Respondent. She maintains that even if the deceased owed the Respondent any money under the loan facilities, the outstanding amounts ought to have been deducted from his retirement benefits with the balance remitted to him.

17. The Claimant also alleges that the Respondent withheld the deceased’s personal documents including the title deeds to the two charged properties and subsequently advertised and sold one of the properties. She contends that the sale was irregular particularly in light of the injunction proceedings relating to the property and seeks the return of the proceeds realised from the sale of L.R. No. KABARU/BLOCK 2/MATHINA/442.

18. The Claimant therefore maintains that the deceased was unlawfully terminated and denied his full retirement benefits and pension which had accrued following his long service with the Respondent.

19. The Claimant called Agnes Muthoni Kariuki, who testified as PW1. During the proceedings of 3rd July, 2014, she stated that she was the deceased’s wife and had been granted a Power of Attorney by him. She adopted her witness statement as her evidence in chief and explained that she was testifying from documents and correspondence exchanged between the deceased and the Respondent as well as facts personally known to her as his wife.

20. On the retirement benefits, PW1 referred to the actuarial report prepared by Mr. Leslie Olando Akumu. She testified that as at 1st Jun,e 1999, the deceased’s retirement benefits amounted to Kshs. 5,451,936/=. She stated that the Respondent credited his account with Kshs. 485,982.70 on 2nd June, 1999 leaving a balance of Kshs. 4,965,953.30 as reflected in the actuarial report.

21. PW1 also testified regarding the deceased’s charged properties. She referred to L.R. No. NGURUBI/NDIUNI/565 and L.R. No. KABARU/BLOCK 2/MATHINA/442 stating that the latter property was sold and a new title issued as L.R. No. KABARU/BLOCK II/MATHIMA/8481. She stated that there has been an injunction in Court and that she did not know how the sale had proceeded despite the injunction.

22. On cross-examination by Mr. Nyugugi, PW1 confirmed that she was aware of the claim and was in possession of documents exchanged between the deceased and the Respondent Bank. She confirmed that the deceased was employed by the Bank vide an appointment letter dated 15th February, 1971 which was contained at pages 4 -5 of the Respondent’s bundle.

23. She acknowledged that the deceased’s employment benefits were subject to the Bank’s general rules and conditions of service. She referred to the terms of the employment letter, including the provision prohibiting employees from lending or borrowing money from another institution without authority and the provision that employment could be terminated upon one month’s notice.

24. PW1 confirmed that the deceased was given a house loan of Kshs. 750,000/= and other facilities including a consumable durable car loan and a small personal loan which amounted to Kshs. 1,158,601/=. She stated that the loan was repayable at Kshs. 10,416.60 over a period of 72 months and that commercial interest rates would apply upon an employee leaving the Bank.

25. She was referred to the deceased’s staff account statement which showed that as at 27th February, 1999 the account was in debit to the tune of Kshs.1,426,685.30. She also confirmed the existence of a letter dated 9th September, 1999 directing the deceased to proceed on compulsory leave and a letter dated 10th February, 1999 relating to allegations of unauthorized borrowing from bank clients.

26. PW1 confirmed that the deceased was terminated on 3rd March, 1999 before attaining the retirement age of 55 years. She was also referred to a memorandum at page 93 of the Respondent’s bundle showing a computation of the deceased’s terminal dues at Kshs. 1,211,735.50.

27. She further referred to the deceased’s statement of account which reflected a credit of Kshs. 1,432,770.85. She stated that a bank statement printed on 30th June, 1999 relating to the deceased’s account after termination reflected a credit of Kshs.429,110.70 as pension benefits. She testified that the same amount was confirmed in a complaint made to the Retirement Benefits Authority.

28. PW1 acknowledged that the Respondent had written to the Retirement Benefits Authority vide a letter dated 2nd February, 2003 and that the Authority did not pursue the matter further. She also referred to a bank statement showing that as at 30th December, 1999 the deceased’s account had a debit balance of Kshs. 235,592/=.

29. She further acknowledged that the deceased had obtained loans from the Respondent and that the Bank was entitled to recover any amounts due under the loan facilities. She confirmed that the properties were charged to the Bank and that the Bank still held the title documents with no discharge having been issued in the deceased’s favour. She also acknowledged that the Respondent had disposed of one of the properties.

30. During the further proceedings recorded on 29th November, 2016, PW1 confirmed the deceased’s appointment as a bank clerk under the letter dated 15th February 1971. She was referred to paragraph 5 of the appointment letter which prohibited the lending or borrowing of money from another institution. She also confirmed the loan facilities granted to the deceased and the applicable repayment terms.

31. PW1 also confirmed that the deceased’s title deeds remained with the Bank and that she has not received a discharge in respect of the charged properties. She acknowledged that the Bank had disposed of one of the properties and stated that she had not written to the Respondent complaining about the disposal.

32. On re-examination, PW1 stated that the deceased was terminated on 3rd March, 1999 as reflected at page 26 of the Claimant’s List of Documents and that he was informed of the same on 9th April 1999.

33. She reiterated that the allegations involving Father Hilary Wambugu originated in February 1995, and that the deceased had responded to the relevant letter on 12th February, 1999. She referred to a letter dated 18th March, 1999 from the Respondent to Rev. Father Hilary Wambugu in which the Bank described the matter as private and advised the parties to settle it out of Court.

34. PW1 stated that she did not understand why the Bank terminated the deceased’s employment when it had subsequently treated the dispute involving Father Hilary Wambugu as a private matter. She further maintained that the deceased was terminated when he was approximately three months short of attaining the retirement age of 55 years, and that he was eligible for pension.

35. She also referred to paragraph 14 of the Respondent’s pension benefits provisions, concerning the normal pension age, and maintained that the deceased has not been paid his full retirement benefits because of the alleged debt to Father Hilary Wambugu which had already been dealt with.

36. It is her prayer that the Claimant’s claim be allowed.

The Claimant’s submissions

37. On the issue of termination, the Claimant submits that the deceased’s employment was governed by the repealed Employment Act, Cap. 226 particularly Sections 5(4)(b) and 17. It is further submitted that the deceased had already received a retirement notice, proceeded on retirement leave and handed over his duties before the Respondent purported to terminate his employment on 3rd March, 1999.

38. It is the Claimant’s further submission that the allegations against the deceased were raised and dealt with earlier, and that he was not subjected to a fair disciplinary process. Counsel contends that the Respondent failed to comply with the statutory procedure under Section 5(4)(b) and violated the principles of natural justice, particularly the right to be heard.

39. In support of the right to a fair hearing, Counsel relied on Onyango Oyoo v Attorney General [1986–1989] EA 456, as cited in James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR), and Ridge v Baldwin [1963] All ER 66 as referred to in AAAS v RRE [2023] KEHC 20607 (KLR). These authorities were relied upon for the principle that a person should not be condemned unheard and that decisions affecting a person's rights must be reached through a fair process.

40. On pension entitlement, Counsel submitted that pension is an accrued right in the nature of property which cannot be withheld or forfeited once it has vested. Counsel also relied on the Income Tax Rules (Retirement Benefits Rules) 1994, the Retirement Benefits Act, 1997, and the Retirement Benefits (Occupational Retirement Benefits Schemes) Regulations 2000 particularly the provisions on vesting of pension benefits.

41. It was argued that the deceased, having served the Respondent for approximately 28 years and six months had fully acquired his pension entitlement which could not be forfeited on account of alleged misconduct.

42. On the computation of pension, Counsel submitted that the applicable formula was provided under Section 10 of the Respondent’s Pension Fund Trust Deed.

The Respondent’s Case

43. The Respondent denies the Claimant’s allegations and maintains that the deceased’s employment was lawfully terminated in accordance with the terms of his employment. The Respondent states that the deceased was its employee, but avers that it discharged him pursuant to the terms and conditions governing his employment. The Respondent further maintains that it reserved the right to summarily dismiss the Claimant.

44. The Respondent contends that the deceased’s services were terminated on account of gross misconduct arising from his involvement in borrowing money from the Bank’s customers, an act which allegedly caused embarrassment and pecuniary loss to the Bank. It maintains that it brought the disciplinary matter to the deceased’s attention before termination and that his conduct amounted to a breach of his employment contract.

45. The Respondent states that it issued the deceased with a termination letter and maintains that the termination was justified by his conduct. It further avers that upon termination, the loan facility started attracting commercial interest rates in accordance with the applicable mortgage contract.

46. Regarding the deceased’s terminal dues and pension, the Respondent maintains that the terminal benefits were properly calculated and set off against the deceased’s outstanding liabilities. It avers that after the set-off, the deceased remained indebted to the Bank in the sum of Kshs.151,929.15 as at 14th April, 2000, which continued to attract interest.

47. The Respondent further maintains that it supplied the deceased with accurate and regular statements of account.

48. The Respondent avers that it intends to exercise its statutory power of sale over the charged properties on account of the deceased’s failure to service the loan facilities and the resulting arrears.

49. The Respondent denies that the deceased was entitled to the reliefs sought and pray that the suit be dismissed with costs.

50. RW1 testified that the deceased was employed by the Respondent on 15th February 1971 and was due to retire on 1st June 1999 upon attaining the age of 55 years. He stated that the Bank issued the deceased with a retirement notice dated 3rd February, 1999, but subsequently placed him on compulsory leave on 9th February, 1999 after allegations of gross misconduct arose.

51. He maintained that the deceased was terminated on 3rd March, 1999 on account of gross mismanagement of the Meru Branch and gross pecuniary embarrassment to the Bank. He explained that the allegations arose from the deceased’s alleged borrowing of money from the Bank’s customers contrary to the terms governing his employment.

52. RW1 further testified that the deceased was paid Kshs. 485,984.69, being his pension contributions together with interest, less applicable taxes, but was not entitled to the employer’s contributions under the pension scheme rules. He stated that the Respondent had also calculated the deceased’s terminal dues and set them off against the outstanding loan facilities.

53. He maintained that the deceased still owed the Respondent money arising from the loan facilities advanced to him during his employment.

54. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that he has worked for the Respondent for approximately 24 years and was familiar with the Bank’s pension policy, Trust Deed and Rules.

55. He confirmed that the deceased was appointed on 15th February 1971 and that the Respondent issued him with a retirement notice dated 3rd February, 1999 indicating that his retirement would take effect on 1st June, 1999. He acknowledged that the deceased served the Respondent for approximately 28 years.

56. RW1 stated that he was not aware that the deceased had requested to proceed on terminal leave. He confirmed however, that the Respondent had instructed the deceased to hand over his duties and proceed on compulsory leave pending investigations. He stated that compulsory leave was not a termination, but a measure taken to facilitate investigations.

57. He further confirmed that the Respondent received complaints from members of the public alleging that the deceased owed them approximately Kshs. 400,000/=. However, he admitted that the letter containing the complaint and the report by the members of the public were not before the Court. He also indicated that a show cause letter was not issued although a letter placing the deceased on compulsory leave was issued on 9th February, 1999.

58. RW1 confirmed that the termination letter dated 3rd March, 1999 was authored by the Deputy General Manager, Administration. He stated that the reasons for termination were gross mismanagement of the Meru Branch and gross pecuniary embarrassment to the Bank, which had resulted in the Bank losing confidence in the deceased. He further confirmed that the termination took effect immediately and that the deceased had already left the Meru Branch and was on compulsory leave.

59. He acknowledged that the Human Resource Manual was not produced before the Court, although he stated that it contained provisions relating to gross pecuniary embarrassment. He further maintained that the deceased had borrowed money from Bank customers, and that the persons who had complained were customers of the Respondent.

60. On the pension and loan facilities, RW1 stated that the deceased had obtained loans from the Respondent in 1995 which were not been fully settled and which continued to attract interest. He confirmed that the Bank still held the title documents to the properties pending full settlement of the loan. He however stated that he could not confirm whether legal charges had been registered over the two properties.

61. RW1 also admitted that the Respondent did not file a counterclaim in respect of the alleged outstanding loan and that no separate suit had been filed concerning the loan or the alleged gross pecuniary embarrassment.

62. RW1 confirmed that the deceased was granted loan facilities by the Respondent and that he continued to owe the Bank in respect of those facilities. He referred to a document dated 24th July, 1995, which was authorized by the Bank’s Assistant Manager, and confirmed that the loan was advanced for the purchase of a house and was secured against properties in Nyeri and Embu.

63. RW1 further confirmed that the loan was repayable over 72 months. He maintained that the deceased had borrowed money from Father Hilary Wambugu and other customers, including Barnabas Nderitu, D.K. Kabanda and Henry Muriuki, and that the complaints had caused pecuniary embarrassment to the Bank.

64. He also confirmed that the deceased’s terminal dues were computed at Kshs.1,211,735.50 which was applied towards the outstanding amount owed to the Respondent. He stated that the deceased remained indebted to the Bank in the sum of Kshs. 271,441.65, which has not been recovered and continues to attract interest.

65. On re-examination, RW1 reiterated that the deceased was terminated before his anticipated retirement date on account of gross misconduct arising from allegations that he had borrowed money from the Bank’s customers. He maintained that the deceased’s appointment letter required him to live within his salary and prohibited conduct that breached the Bank’s rules.

66. RW1 further stated that the Respondent had received complaints from Bank customers regarding money allegedly borrowed by the deceased. He maintained that the deceased was asked to respond to the allegations involving Father Hilary Wambugu, but he denied borrowing the money.

67. He reiterated that the deceased was paid his terminal dues and that the Bank had applied the amount towards the outstanding loan facilities. He maintained that the loan remained unpaid and continued to accrue interest.

The Respondent’s Submissions

68. On the termination, the Respondent submitted that the deceased’s employment was terminated on 3rd March, 1999 following allegations of gross mismanagement and gross pecuniary embarrassment arising from borrowing money from the Bank’s customers contrary to the terms of his employment.

69. Counsel argued that the retirement notice dated 3rd February, 1999 did not prevent the Bank from taking disciplinary action before the anticipated retirement date. The Respondent further submits that the deceased was placed on compulsory leave, informed of the allegations and given an opportunity to respond before termination.

70. On pension entitlement, the Respondent submitted that the deceased’s benefits were governed by the applicable Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules, particularly Clause 6 on normal retirement age and Rule 14(c) on forfeiture of pension in cases of gross negligence or fraud against the Bank.

71. It submits further that the deceased’s employment ended on 3rd March, 1999 before his anticipated retirement date of 1st June, 1999, and that his entitlement had to be assessed according to the circumstances of that cessation of employment. Counsel distinguished the deceased’s own pension contributions from the additional employer funded pension benefit claimed.

72. The Respondent maintains that the deceased received Kshs.429,110.70 representing his own contributions and that the Claimant has not established entitlement to the additional pension claimed.

73. The Respondent further submitted that the Income Tax (Retirement Benefits) Rules, 1994 had to be read alongside the specific pension scheme rules, and that the Retirement Benefits (Occupational Retirement Benefits Schemes) Regulations, 2000 could not apply retrospectively to the deceased’s employment which had ended in March, 1999.

74. On jurisdiction, the Respondent argued that disputes concerning the computation of pension benefits should first be referred to the statutory dispute resolution mechanism under the Retirement Benefits Act, Cap. 197 particularly Section 46(1). It relied on Mumba & 7 others (sued on their own behalf and on behalf of predecessors and or successors in title in their capacities as the Registered Trustees of Kenya Ports Authority Pensions Scheme) v Munyao & 148 others (suing on their own behalf and on behalf of the plaintiffs and other members/beneficiaries of the Kenya Ports Authority Pensions Scheme) [2019] KESC 83 (KLR) and the aforementioned Magaha decision submitting that pension computation falls within the mandate of the statutory pension authorities in the first instance.

75. In conclusion, the Respondent urged the Court to find that the deceased’s termination was lawful, that the Claimant has not established entitlement to the additional employer funded pension benefits claimed and that the Court should decline to undertake the initial computation of the pension.

76. It finally prays for dismissal of the suit with costs.

Analysis and Determination

77. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced, the parties’ submissions and the applicable law, the following issues arise for determination:-

i. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the dispute concerning the deceased's retirement and pension benefits.

ii. Whether the Respondent lawfully terminated the deceased's employment before his anticipated retirement date.

iii. Whether the deceased was entitled to retirement benefits under the Respondent's Staff Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules.

iv. Whether the Respondent was entitled to apply the deceased's terminal dues and pension benefits towards settlement of his outstanding loan facilities.

v. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the dispute concerning the deceased's retirement and pension benefits

78. The Respondent has challenged the Court's jurisdiction to undertake the computation of pension benefits, relying on Section 46(1) of the Retirement Benefits Act and the Supreme Court’s decision in Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 Others v Maurice Munyao & 148 Others [2019] KESC 83 (KLR).

79. The starting point is that jurisdiction is everything, and a court must satisfy itself that it has jurisdiction before proceeding to determine a dispute. This principle was established in the now famous case of Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S" v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KECA 48 (KLR) .

80. The jurisdictional question, however, requires a distinction between a dispute concerning the computation or administration of pension benefits under a retirement benefits scheme and a claim arising from an employer-employee relationship, including the lawfulness of termination and its consequences for pension entitlement.

81. The Claimant's case is not confined to challenging the arithmetics of a pension computation, but it also challenges the Respondent's decision to terminate the deceased's employment shortly before his anticipated retirement, the consequent treatment of his pension entitlement, and the application of his terminal dues towards outstanding loan facilities.

82. In the premise, I hold that this court has jurisdiction to determine this matter.

Whether the Respondent lawfully terminated the deceased's employment before his anticipated retirement date

83. It is not disputed that the deceased was employed by the Respondent on 15th February, 1971 and that he served for approximately 28 years. It is also not disputed that on 3rd February, 1999, the Respondent issued him with a retirement notice indicating that he would retire upon attaining the age of 55 years in June of that year.

84. The Respondent confirmed placing the deceased on compulsory leave and subsequently issued him a termination letter dated 3rd March, 1999, citing gross mismanagement of the Meru Branch and gross pecuniary embarrassment arising from allegations that he had borrowed money from the Bank's customers.

85. For starters, the Claimant’s termination occurred in March 1999; hence, the applicable employment law is the law then in force, which is the repealed Employment Act, Cap. 226, together with the deceased's contract of employment and the applicable principles of common law.

86. The Claimant relied on David Oloo Onyango v Attorney-General [1987] KECA 56 (KLR) for the principle that a person should not be condemned unheard. The principle is equally reflected in Ridge v Baldwin [1964] AC 40, where the House of Lords affirmed the importance of observing the rules of natural justice when a decision affects a person's rights.

87. The Court is also alive to the fact that an employer is entitled to take disciplinary action against an employee who commits misconduct, even where the employee is approaching retirement. The issuance of a retirement notice does not therefore, by itself, immunize an employee against disciplinary action before the effective retirement date.

88. The employer must, however, demonstrate that the disciplinary action was based on genuine and established grounds, and was undertaken in accordance with the applicable contractual and legal requirements.

89. RW1 testified that the deceased was terminated on account of gross mismanagement and gross pecuniary embarrassment arising from borrowing money from the Bank's customers. However, he admitted that the complaints allegedly made by the customers, and the report forming the basis of the allegations, were not produced in evidence, and neither were the alleged complainants called to testify.

90. Further, although the Respondent maintains that the deceased was given an opportunity to respond to the allegations, RW1 admitted that no formal show-cause letter was issued. This evidence is inconsistent with the Claimant's account and the letter dated 10th February, 1999, which required the deceased to explain the allegations concerning Father Hilary Wambugu. Even assuming the letter constituted an opportunity to show cause, no satisfactory evidence shows how or whether the Respondent considered the deceased's response or how it arrived at its decision to terminate his employment.

91. Additionally, the Respondent did not produce its Human Resource Manual, which RW1 claimed contained provisions relating to gross pecuniary embarrassment; hence, the Court is not able to establish the precise disciplinary provisions that were applicable to the deceased or whether the Respondent complied with them.

92. Further, the Respondent's subsequent correspondence dated 18th March, 1999, in which it described the dispute involving Father Hilary Wambugu as a private matter and advised the parties to settle it out on their own, raises further questions on the seriousness of the allegations forming the basis of the Claimant’s termination just before his retirement.

93. The Court also notes that the allegations reportedly originated in 1995, yet the Respondent did not satisfactorily explain why the matter was revived in February 1999, shortly after issuing the deceased with a retirement notice. Further, although the timing alone does not establish bad faith, it called for a cogent explanation from the Respondent.

94. In my view, the Respondent, having relied on misconduct as justification for the termination, bore the burden to place sufficient evidence before the Court to establish the factual foundation of that decision, which it failed to discharge. Further, the evidence produced did not demonstrate that the Respondent undertook a fair disciplinary process before terminating the deceased's employment.

95. In the premise, I find the Claimant’s termination unjustified by the evidence presented, and thus contrary to the applicable principles of natural justice and the deceased's contractual rights.

96. Accordingly, I find and hold that the Claimant’s termination was wrongful and unlawful.

Whether the deceased was entitled to retirement benefits under the Staff Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules

97. The Claimant contends that the deceased had served the Respondent for approximately 28 years and six months and had consequently acquired pension rights which could not be forfeited merely because his employment was terminated on allegations of misconduct.

98. The Respondent, on the other hand, maintains that the deceased was not entitled to the employer funded portion of the pension because his employment ended before the normal retirement age. It further relies on Clause 6 and Rule 14(c) of the Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules, particularly the provision relating to forfeiture of pension in cases of gross negligence or fraud against the Bank.

99. It is my opinion that pension entitlement is governed by the applicable pension scheme's Trust Deed and Rules, and the mere fact that an employee has served for a considerable period does not necessarily entitle him to every component of the pension benefits irrespective of the conditions prescribed by the scheme.

100. Equally, an employer cannot rely on an allegation of misconduct to forfeit pension benefits without demonstrating that the applicable scheme rules permit such forfeiture and that the circumstances contemplated by those rules have been established.

101. The deceased alleged misconduct was not satisfactorily established through evidence, and therefore, even if Rule 14(c) permits pension benefits forfeiture in the circumstances described by the Respondent, the evidential basis for invoking that provision has not been established.

102. The Court further notes that the Retirement Benefits (Occupational Retirement Benefits Schemes) Regulations, 2000 cannot be applied retrospectively to determine rights arising from the termination of employment in March 1999.

103. The upshot, therefore, is that the Respondent has not established a lawful basis for forfeiting the deceased's pension entitlement on account of the alleged misconduct.

Whether the Respondent was entitled to set off the deceased's terminal dues and pension benefits against the outstanding loan facilities

104. The evidence establishes that the deceased obtained loan facilities from the Respondent, including a house loan and other personal facilities. PW1 acknowledged that the loans remained outstanding and that the Bank was entitled to recover the amounts lawfully due under the facilities.

105. The dispute concerns the Respondent's treatment of those facilities after the deceased's employment ended.

106. The Claimant contends that the outstanding loan balances ought to have been deducted from the deceased's retirement benefits, with the balance remitted to him. She further challenges the conversion of the staff loan facilities into commercial facilities attracting interest at 30%.

107. The Respondent maintains that the conversion was undertaken in accordance with the applicable mortgage arrangements and that the deceased remained indebted even after the application of his terminal dues.

108. The Court notes that RW1 gave inconsistent figures concerning the outstanding indebtedness. At one point, he referred to Kshs.151,929.15, while elsewhere he stated that the outstanding amount was Kshs.271,441.65. The statements and computations referred to by the parties also disclose differing balances. Further, RW1 admitted that the Respondent did not file a counterclaim in respect of the outstanding loan facilities.

109. The Court therefore finds that the Respondent was entitled to recover the deceased's outstanding loan obligations under the applicable loan agreements, but was not entitled to apply arbitrary charges or unsubstantiated balances against his terminal and pension benefits, especially having found the termination unlawful.

Whether the Court has jurisdiction to determine the pension computation

110. The Respondent submitted that the dispute concerning the computation of pension benefits ought to have been referred to the Retirement Benefits Authority under Section 46(1) of the Retirement Benefits Act. In Albert Chaurembo Mumba & 7 Others v Maurice Munyao & 148 Others [2019] KESC 83 (KLR), the Supreme Court held that the dispute resolution mechanism established under Sections 46, 47 and 48 of the Retirement Benefits Act must be exhausted before recourse is made to the courts. The Court affirmed that the Chief Executive Officer of the Retirement Benefits Authority has original jurisdiction over disputes falling within Section 46, with an appeal lying to the Retirement Benefits Appeals Tribunal.

111. The foregoing decision is important, but it must be applied in the context of the dispute before this Court. The Supreme Court was dealing with a dispute between pension scheme beneficiaries and the trustees of a pension scheme.

112. The distinction was subsequently illustrated in Sarah Mang'oli v Kenya Medical Research Institute & Another [2020] KEELRC 595 (KLR), where the Employment and Labour Relations Court distinguished a dispute arising from an employer's failure to fulfil its employment obligations from one arising from the administration of a pension scheme. The Court held that a claim concerning an employer's failure to remit pension contributions was properly within its employment jurisdiction.

113. In the present case, the Claimant challenges the Respondent's conduct as the employer, particularly the termination of employment and its consequences for the deceased's contractual pension entitlement. In my view, this aspect of the dispute falls within this Court's jurisdiction.

114. I am, however, alive to the fact that the Claimant seeks an initial determination of the precise pension benefits payable under the Staff Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules, which question falls within the statutory dispute-resolution framework under Section 46 of the Retirement Benefits Act, as it concerns the administration of the scheme by its manager, administrator, custodian or trustees.

115. Further, the evidence that the Claimant previously lodged a complaint with the Retirement Benefits Authority does not establish that the Authority made a determination on the merits. Indeed, PW1 acknowledged that the Authority did not pursue the matter further.

116. I therefore find that this Court has jurisdiction to determine the employment dispute, but the initial computation and determination of benefits under the pension scheme must be undertaken through the statutory mechanism prescribed by the Retirement Benefits Act.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought

117. Having found that the Claimant’s termination was wrongful and unlawful, the deceased's entitlement must be assessed on the basis that the Respondent has not established lawful justification for terminating his employment on 3rd March, 1999, and the forfeiture of part of his pension entitlement.

118. To start with, an order for immediate payment of Kshs.5,451,936, without reconciliation against the applicable Trust Deed and Rules as suggested by the claimant, would in my view be premature. The appropriate course is to establish the pension benefits under the applicable scheme rules, credit amounts already paid, and deduct only properly established contractual liabilities.

119. As regards the charged properties, the Claimant's evidence concerning the alleged irregular sale of L.R. No. KABARU/BLOCK 2/MATHINA/442 raises issues concerning the exercise of the Respondent's statutory power of sale. However, the reliefs expressly sought in the amended plaint do not include a specific order setting aside the sale, reconveying the property or refunding its proceeds.

120. Parties, as always, are bound by their pleadings, and the Court cannot grant substantive relief beyond the pleadings.

121. Accordingly, the Court will confine its determination to the reliefs properly sought in the amended plaint.

122. In the final analysis, I proceed to determine the Claimant’s Claim as follows:-

a) A declaration that the termination of the deceased's employment was wrongful and unlawful.

b) A declaration that the Respondent shall not rely on the said termination as a lawful basis for forfeiting the deceased's pension entitlement.

c) That the Retirement Benefits Authority is hereby ordered to determine the precise pension benefits payable to the Claimant under the Respondent’s Staff Pension Fund Trust Deed and Rules, not later than 60 days from the date of this Judgment.

d) The Respondent shall offset any sums due in respect of the Claimant’s loan facilities as at February 1999 from his Retirement benefits and pension package and the balance thereto remitted to the Claimant

e) The Respondent shall bear the costs of the suit.

123. Orders accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Ms. Ouma present for the Claimant

N/A for the Respondent

Ms. Esther - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder