Employment law

Karenju v Tns Rms East Africa [2026] KEELRC 15008 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 639 of 2017
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
Onesmus Makau

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The facts of this case are fairly straight forward. The Claimant was employed by Scanad Tanzania Limited under fixed term contract from 1st February 2012 to 31st January 2014. The contract was then extended upto 31st August 2016. His position was Senior Country Field Manager and his gross monthly salary was Tshs.2,506,950 and later went upto Tshs.2,955,589.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Upon expiry of the said contract term, Scanad Tanzania Limited never renewed it and his work permit expired. Respondent offered the Claimant a fixed term contract of six months from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017 to serve in the same capacity and terms as in the earlier company. However, effort to secure a work permit for the claimant yielded nothing and the Claimant started receiving calls from unknown people threatening him…

Paragraph 2 →

Reasoning passage

RW1 produced several emails but none of them forwarded the termination letter and the Certificate of Service to the Claimant. No other form of evidence was adduced to prove service of the said termination notice, like a delivery book, courier service certificate or even certificate of postage. In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Claimant’s contract was not prematurely terminated on account of redundancy on 31st January 2017…

Paragraph 24 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT

NAIROBI

(O N Makau J on 5th November 2026)

CAUSE NO. 639 OF 2017

WILSON KARENJU ………..………………………………………….... CLAIMANT

VERSUS

TNS RMS EAST AFRICA …………….…..................................... RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. The facts of this case are fairly straight forward. The Claimant was employed by Scanad Tanzania Limited under fixed term contract from 1st February 2012 to 31st January 2014. The contract was then extended upto 31st August 2016. His position was Senior Country Field Manager and his gross monthly salary was Tshs.2,506,950 and later went upto Tshs.2,955,589.

2. Upon expiry of the said contract term, Scanad Tanzania Limited never renewed it and his work permit expired. Respondent offered the Claimant a fixed term contract of six months from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017 to serve in the same capacity and terms as in the earlier company. However, effort to secure a work permit for the claimant yielded nothing and the Claimant started receiving calls from unknown people threatening him for working in Tanzania without a work permit. As a result, the Claimant was repatriated to work at Nairobi Office from November 2016 while the employer followed up the issue of work permit. The respondent was also forced to pay USD600 as penalty for the days the Claimant had remained in Tanzania without work permit. The respondent paid his accommodation cost for November 2016 and thereafter he assumed the costs of his residence.

3. As fate would have it, the Claimant was served with a notice of intention to terminate his job on account redundancy since it had been impacted by a restructuring which had been going on. The employer also served the area Labour Officer with a notice of intended redundancy. Subsequently, the Claimant among other affected employees were invited to interview for the vacant positions in the new structure but the Claimant withdrew from the same and as such his contract was terminated on the 31st January 2017 on account of redundancy.

4. After the termination, the Claimant’s terminal dues were not paid because there was a dispute over some money for business expenses advanced to him by the respondent that he had not accounted for. Accordingly, a reconciliation was required but allegedly the Claimant failed to co-operate by producing supporting documents.

5. The Claimant filed a Memorandum of Claim dated 3rd April 2017, seeking the following reliefs:

a) A declaration that the Respondent’s refusal to pay the Claimant’s salary and allowances in the course of employment and performance of duties is unfair, unlawful and unconstitutional.

b) An order compelling the Respondent to pay the claimant his earned salary and allowances for the months of December 2016, January 2017, February 2017, March 2017 and a BGS project training refund all amounting Tshs.8,685,814.9 equivalent of Kshs.754,726 and thereafter continue paying progressive salary and allowances and travel and accommodation allowance of Kshs.840,000 making a total of Kshs.2,583,141.70 and allocate him duties and responsibilities.

c) In the alternative to (b) above, the Respondent be ordered to pay the Claimant his terminal dues calculated up to age of retirement of 60 years amounting to kshs.26,604,781.

d) General damages.

e) Certificate of Service to be issued within 14 days of the judgment.

f) Costs and interest of this suit at Court rates.

g) Any other or further relief which the court may deem fit, just and expedient to grant.

6. The Respondent filed a Statement of Response dated 4th July 2022 after amicable negotiations yielded no settlement. It averred that the Claimant was not its employee upto 31st August 2016 as he was employed by Scanad Tanzania Limited, an independent legal entity incorporated in Tanzania. It further averred that it offered the Claimant a six-month contract from 1st September 2016 to 28th February, 2017 but it terminated the same on account of redundancy on 31st January 2017. However, it denied any wrong doing in the termination and prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.

7. The Claimant filed a Reply to the Response dated 29th January 2024 joining issues with the respondent and denied having been served with termination letter dated 31st January 2017 until he filed the suit. Therefore, he maintained his averments in his Memorandum of Claim.

Evidence

8. The Claimant testified as CW1 and adopted his witness statement dated 3rd April 2017 as his evidence in chief. He further produced 5 documents as exhibits to support his case. In brief, he confirmed that he was employed as Country Field Manager Tanzania by Scanad Tanzania Limited under a fixed term contract which had been extended to 31st August 2016. After the expiry of the contract term, his work permit also lapsed.

9. He testified that the Respondent then gave him a contract of six months instead of two years required for one to get work permit and therefore, the work permit was not given. As a result, he started receiving phone calls from anonymous persons and the immigration harassing him for lack of a work permit.

10. He further testified that the Respondent repatriated him to work in its Nairobi Office while processing of his work permit was being done. The Respondent paid for his accommodation for the month of November 2016 and stopped. He stated that in July 2016, the employer gave notice of intention to restructure. He never received any termination letter and he continued reporting to the Nairobi Office until 1st April 2017 when he stopped because no work was being allocated to him.

11. On cross examination, he admitted that his fixed term contract with Scanad ended on 31st August 2016 and then the Respondent employed him for six months from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017. He further admitted that his work permit was pegged on his earlier contract with Scanad which expired and an Agent called Itima was engaged to assist in getting him a new work permit. He stated that he was reporting to the Human Resource Manager, Gloria Akinyi Mwangi who told him that Tanzania was hostile to Kenyans applying for work permits. He denied that allegation contending that though he is a Kenyan, he resides in Tanzania with his family.

12. He admitted that a notice of intended redundancy dated 6th December was issued to Labour Officer and thereafter, there were interviews to fill an East Africa position but he never participated. He denied receipt of the termination notice dated 13th December 2016 and maintained that he continued reporting to work until April 2017.

13. He admitted that he attended conciliation meeting on 28th February and 8th march 2017 over the money he had received for business expenses but failed to avail supporting evidence. He could not recall receiving any money in January 2017. He could also not recall how much he received as final dues but admitted that he received a lump sum payment without particulars. However, he admitted that he was being deducted NSSF in Tanzania as shown in his payslips but denied being paid house allowance.

14. The Respondent’s Senior Human Resource Administrator, East and French West Africa, Yvonne Murugu testified as RW1. She adopted her written statement dated 4th July 2024 as her evidence in chief. She also produce 15 documents as exhibits to support the defence case. In brief, she explained that the respondent is a member of KANTAR GROUP offering research services. It shares common services in Human Resource, Operations, Finance and IT with a Sister Company, Millward Brown and they trade as KANTAR GROUP. Scanad Tanzania Limited is an independent legal entity incorporated in Tanzania.

15. She testified that the Claimant’s contract of employment with Scanad Tanzania Limited ended on 31st August 2016 and his work permit expired. The Respondent then employed the Claimant for six months from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017 to work in Tanzania as a Field Manager. The respondent hoped to get a work permit for the Claimant and engaged an Agent in Tanzania, Itima Abel to pursue the same. Meanwhile, the Claimant reported threats from persons pretending to be Immigration officials over his stay without a permit.

16. On 5th October 2016, the respondent asked the Claimant to move to Kenya for his safety pending the procurement of the work permit. It also paid USD 600 as penalty for Claimant’s stay without permit. Despite much effort, the work permit was not given due to stringent requirements under Tanzanian law. The Company repatriation policy, was clarified to the Claimant by the respondent’s Gloria Akinyi Mwangi that only one month accommodation would be provided to him, being November 2016.

17. RW1 testified that from July to October 2016, KANTAR GROUP underwent a major restructuring and the Claimant was served with notice of possible termination dated 6th December 2016. A similar notice was served on the Labour Officer. A consultation window was presented to him whereby he was invited for interview for one of the four positions of Field Management in Kenya but he declined. As a result, he was served with a termination notice dated 13th January 2017 informing him that his last working day would be 31st January 2017. The letter also notified of the terminal benefits being salary upto 31st January 2017, salary in lieu of notice and accrued leave. The dues were processed but not paid to the Claimant because he refused to attend the offices for clearance as required.

18. She testified that the Claimant was paid all his salary for September, October and November 2016. She denied the claim of Kshs.321,819 BGS training because it was not verified, using documents. Besides, she contended that the Claimant owed Kshs.425,000 that was advanced to him in august 2016 for field activities but failed to account for the same.

19. She denied that the Claimant continued working until March 2017, and reiterated that his contract was terminated on 31st January 2017. She denied the claim for travel expenses contending that the Claimant never made any business travel. She contended that the respondent acted fairly and prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.

20. On cross examination, she maintained that the only time the respondent employed the Claimant was when it offered him six months contract from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017. She reiterated that the Claimant exited on account of redundancy on 31st January 2017. She reiterated that the Claimant was paid salary for September, October and November 2016 but not for December and January. He was also not paid his terminal dues because he was advanced Kshs.321,000 for PTS training and a further Kshs.425,000 for project work expenses but failed to avail documents to support the expenditure alleging that he lost the receipts. He was invited to do clearance and reconciliation in order to have his dues paid but he failed to attend.

21. After the hearing, the parties filed written submissions but they failed to do so in time before the trial Judge was promoted to the Court of Appeal. As a result, the file was re-allocated to me and the parties agreed that I should write the judgment.

Issues for determination and Analysis

22. I have carefully considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions presented by the two sides. It is clear to my mind that the Claimant was employed by the respondent on a fixed term contract of six months from 1st September 2016 to 28th February 2017. His basic salary was Tshs.2,506,950 per month subject to taxes and other statutory deductions. He was entitled to leave allowance of 2% of his annual basic salary. He was also entitled to medical health cover. The following issues fall for determination:

a) Whether the contract was terminated on 31st January 2017 or any other date thereafter.

b) Whether the termination was unfair and unlawful.

c) Whether reliefs sought should be granted.

Date of termination

23. The Claimant alleged that he continued reporting to the office until 1st April 2017 when he decided to stop because he was not being assigned any work. However, RW1 contended that the Claimant’s contract was terminated on 31st January 2017 vide a notice of termination dated 13th December 2016. The Claimant denied receipt of the said termination notice and maintained that he continued reporting to work until 1st April 2017 when he stopped going to the Office.

24. RW1 produced several emails but none of them forwarded the termination letter and the Certificate of Service to the Claimant. No other form of evidence was adduced to prove service of the said termination notice, like a delivery book, courier service certificate or even certificate of postage. In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Claimant’s contract was not prematurely terminated on account of redundancy on 31st January 2017 but on a later date. That date was not 1st April 2017 but 28th February 2017 when it lapsed automatically by effluxion of time as agreed between the parties in their contract. I say so because all the email correspondences before 28th February 2017 were through his official email address but thereafter, all email correspondences were through his personal email address.

Unfair termination

25. In view of the foregoing conclusion, I find that the alleged unfair and unlawful termination did not arise as the contract lapsed after its term ended on 28th February 2017. This view is corroborated by the fact that the first mention of the “termination of the contract” was in the respondent’s email dated 28th February 2017 at 4.51 p.m. sent through his personal email address.

Reliefs

26. In view of the foregoing finding that the contract lapsed automatically, the claim based on unfair termination falls on its face. That leaves only the claim for salary for December 2016 to February 2017 which I award him. The appointment letter provided for Tshs.2,955,589 per month subject to statutory deductions. Therefore, for the said three months, I award Tshs.2,955,589 x 3 = Tsh.8,866,767 less statutory deduction.

27. The respondent alleged that there was cash advances given to the claimant for training and business expenses which he failed to account for. However, no counterclaim was lodged against the claimant in this suit. Besides, the Claimant denied the same and no evidence was adduced to prove the allegation. Consequently, I find and hold that the alleged debt of Kshs.321,000 and Kshs.425,000 have not been sought and established against the claimant.

Conclusion

28. I have found that Claimant’s contract of employment expired automatically by effluxion of time on 28th February 2017. For that reason, I have found that the claim founded on unfair termination has no legs to stand on. I further found that the Claimant is entitled to salary for December 2016 to February 2017 against which there is no counterclaim filed by the respondent. Consequently, I enter judgment for the Claimant against the respondent on the following terms:

a) Unpaid salary…………………….. Tshs.8,866,767.

b) The award is subject to tax only.

c) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit plus interest at court rate from the date of filing the suit until payment in full.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

ONESMUS MAKAU

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mageto for Claimant

Cheruiyot for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder