Employment law

East Africa Spectre Limited v Kiarie [2026] KEELRC 14997 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E202 of 2024
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 20th July, 2024, the Appellant appeals against part of the judgment of Honourable R. Oganyo delivered on 24th June, 2024 on grounds inter alia that:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Regarding procedural fairness, it was held in the case of Walter Ogal Anuro -vs- Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR that for termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for termination but also procedural fairness. The issue of the substantive fairness has not been challenged hence this court will only deal with the issue of procedural fairness as the ground in this…

Paragraph 16 →

Reasoning passage

In this case, the Respondent alleged that the hearing was predetermined to terminate his services. The accusations were communicated to the Respondent following which he was accorded ample time to respond and was in fact heard before a decision to dismiss him was made, the accusations were clear on the willfully tampering with equipment in the factory, participating in receiving kickbacks with a supplier and insubordination. Even…

Paragraph 19 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

APPEALS DIVISION

APPEAL NO. E202 OF 2024

EAST AFRICA SPECTRE LIMITED............................................APPELLANT

-VERSUS-

PETER MBURU KIARIE............................................................RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment and decree of Honourable R.Aganyo delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in CMELRC No. E1124 of 2020 on 24th June, 2024)

JUDGMENT

(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)

1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 20th July, 2024, the Appellant appeals against part of the judgment of Honourable R. Oganyo delivered on 24th June, 2024 on grounds inter alia that:

i. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in considering the issue of procedure of termination of the Claimant's termination, while the same had not been contested in the Claimant's pleadings.

ii. The Learned trial magistrate erred in law, and in fact, in her analysis of the evidence before the court by arriving at conflicting conclusions on the question of procedural fairness of the Appellant's termination of the Respondent's employment, on the one end, reaching a finding that the process was fair, and on the other end, arriving at a contrary position, without explaining the basis of the conflict of the findings, yet the same was not contested in the Claimant's pleadings, at all, and proceeded to award damages by way of compensation on the same, when there was unchallenged evidence before the court which confirmed that Respondent was properly undertaken through the correct and appropriate procedure of fairness before a decision to terminate his services was communicated to him.

iii. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in finding that the Respondent had not followed due process in terminating the Claimant.

iv. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in by failing to state with clarity which procedure the Respondent did not adhere to in order to warrant termination of the Claimant unprocedural.

v. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in finding that the Claimant was entitled to salary in lieu of notice when the Claimant had been rightfully so summarily dismissed.

vi. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in failing to make a pronouncement on the Respondent's Counter-claim.

vii. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact in awarding the Claimant one month's salary in lieu of notice at Kshs. 44, 721.40, compensation for unfair termination at Kshs.134, 164.20 and costs and interest of the suit at court rates.

2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed with costs in the trial court and this appeal and the whole judgment and resultant decree of the Chief Magistrate's Court at Nairobi delivered by the Honourable R. Aganyo on the 24th Day of June,2024 against the Appellant herein be set aside and substituted with an order dismissing the Respondent's suit against Appellant.

3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.

APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS

4. The Appellant’s Advocates D. Otieno and Company Advocates filed written submissions dated 8th June, 2026 and submitted among others that:-

i. On the issue of whether the trial court erred in finding that the termination was procedurally unfair counsel submitted that the Respondent did not plead that the termination was procedurally unfair. A perusal of his Memorandum of Claim reveals that his claim was solely anchored on alleged wrongful and unlawful termination for want of valid reason, not on lack of fair procedure. Further, a perusal of the brief submissions filed by the Claimant, paragraph 7 expressly speaks to having the Respondent prove that there were substantive reasons for terminating the Claimant.

ii. It was submitted for the Appellant that the trial court’s finding that the termination was procedurally unfair was therefore outside the pleadings and in contravention of well-established principles of civil litigation. A court must confine itself to the issues framed by the pleadings. Procedure was never contested. Reliance was placed on the case of Galaxy Paints Co. Ltd v Falcon Guards Ltd [2000] eKLR on this assertion that issues for determination flow from the pleadings. Further reliance was placed on the case of IEBC & another v Stephen Mutinda Mule & 3 others [2014] eKLR in which the Court of Appeal agreed wholly with the Appellant’s submission that courts should not base decisions on unpleaded issues and parties are bound by their pleadings.

iii. Counsel submitted that by entertaining and upholding a claim not pleaded, the trial court denied the Appellant a fair opportunity to respond and defend itself against that claim. Nonetheless, the Appellant went ahead to show that indeed the termination was procedurally and substantively fair as per the requirement of sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act.

iv. Counsel relied on section 43 of the Employment Act on the proof for reasons of termination and the case of Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Co. Limited [2013] eKLR on the employer observing procedural fairness under section 41 of the Employment Act.

v. It was submitted that the question is whether the employer followed the above procedure. From the List and Bundle of documents produced by the Appellant at page 35 of the Record of Appeal

a. The Appellant issued the Respondent with a show-cause letter dated 25th November 2019 informing the Respondent of the charges against him and allowing him 72 hours to respond.

b. The Respondent responded to the Show cause vide letter dated 28th November 2019.

c. the Appellant issued a disciplinary hearing invitation vide letter dated 2nd December 2019.

d. the Appellant conducted the hearing on 4th December 2019 of which minutes were taken. The Respondent confirmed that he attended the disciplinary hearing on the said date during cross examination as indicated in the proceedings.

e. the Appellant issued a dismissal letter dated 11th December 2019.

vi. Counsel submitted that the trial court acknowledged that the Appellant issued a show-cause letter, received a response, issued a disciplinary hearing invitation, conducted the disciplinary hearing and issued a summary dismissal letter. Despite these uncontested facts, the court found that the Appellant had not accorded the Respondent procedural fairness. The Appellant submits that it followed the due process as elaborated in the case of Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Co. Limited (supra) above.

vii. On the issue of whether the trial court erred in awarding one month's pay in lieu of notice despite summary dismissal counsel submitted that the Respondent was summarily dismissed pursuant to Section 44 of the Employment Act for gross misconduct. Under Section 44(1) and (4), summary dismissal entitles an employer to dismiss without notice.

viii. It was submitted that in the instant suit, the reason for the summary dismissal of the Respondent is captured in the summary dismissal letter dated 11th December 2019 which states as follows:-

‘At the disciplinary hearing, the following allegations were found proved: That you being the electrical technician for East Africa Spectre Limited failed to adhere to our Code of Conduct policy as well as our occupational and health policy.

You willingly tampered with Company equipment in the factory on the 18th November 2019.

There was no breakdown and no KPLC power surge as you stated in your show cause response letter dated 28th November 2018. The standard capacitor starting contactor testing procedure was not followed. The management trainee Felix Njue was exposed to danger during working hours.’

ix. It was submitted that the Respondent attended the disciplinary hearing on 4th December 2019 and called Mr. Erastus Ateng as his witness, minutes of which appear at 52-57 of the Record of Appeal. The disciplinary hearing committee concluded that he was to be removed from his position in the company. The Respondent was then issued the summary dismissal letter dated 11th December 2019. There was valid reason for summary dismissal and due procedure was followed. From the foregoing, the Respondent having been summarily dismissed was not entitled to notice pay and the award of the same by the trial court contradicts Section 44 of the Employment Act and should be set aside.

x. On the issue of whether the award of three months' compensation was justified counsel submitted that it reiterates its submissions above and states that the termination of the Respondent was both procedurally and substantively fair. Therefore, no compensation was due to the Respondent. The trial court acknowledged that the Respondent:

⎯ Had received prior disciplinary warnings.

⎯ Engaged in acts that directly led to his dismissal.

⎯ Was culpable in suspicious damage to machinery.

⎯ Was found to have breached protocol and safety standards.

xi. It was submitted that in light of these findings, the trial court ought not to have rewarded the Respondent who contributed to his own dismissal by awarding any compensation, having committed gross misconduct, breached safety protocols, endangered the life a trainee, caused machinery damage and caused immense financial loss to the Appellant. Reliance was placed on the case of Jacob Juma Makokha v Radar Security (K) Limited 2018 KEELRC 2577(KLR) where court appreciates the loss of confidence and trust between the employee and employer due to actions of employee and awarding such an employee would be to award gross misconduct.

xii. On the issue of whether the trial court erred by failing to determine the Appellant’s counter-claim counsel submitted that the failure of the trial court to determine its counter-claim amounts to a denial of fair hearing and as such occasioned a miscarriage of justice. The Appellant’s counterclaim sought compensation for losses occasioned by the Claimant's deliberate damage to the Respondent's machinery and equipment. The Respondent adduced evidence demonstrating that the Claimant damaged the equipment on various occasions, necessitating the procurement and installation of replacement parts. The trial court failed to address it entirely, rendering the judgment incomplete and legally deficient.

xiii. It was submitted that in support of its claim, the Appellant produced receipts marked as Respondent's Exhibits 13, 15, 17 and 19 evidencing the replacement of damaged parts on 3rd July 2019, 29th July 2019, 27th September 2019 and 18th November 2019 at a cumulative cost of Kshs. 306,472.00. The Appellant's evidence was that the damage occurred on the aforesaid dates while the maintenance engineer was away on leave and that the Respondent was directly involved in procuring and collecting the replacement parts, in some instances at exaggerated prices.

xiv. Counsel further submitted that the Appellant further adduced evidence showing that the damage caused to the equipment resulted in a cumulative production downtime of sixty-eight (68) hours. As a consequence, the Appellant suffered loss of production valued at Kshs. 5,820,072.00. The foregoing was demonstrated through the report produced as Respondent's Exhibit 34. The Appellant's evidence regarding the damage to the equipment, the cost of replacement and the resultant production losses was not challenged by the Respondent. The Respondent did not tender any evidence to controvert the receipts produced, the production-loss report or the testimony of the Appellant's witnesses.

xv. It was submitted that further, the Appellant specifically pleaded the losses suffered and strictly proved the same through documentary evidence. It is trite law that special damages must not only be specifically pleaded but must also be strictly proved. The Respondent has satisfied both requirements. In the circumstances, the Appellant proved its counterclaim on a balance of probabilities and is entitled to the reliefs sought therein together with costs and interest.

xvi. Counsel submitted that from the foregoing, the learned Magistrate neither allowed nor dismissed the counter-claim and did not evaluate the evidence tendered in support thereof. Consequently, the judgment was incomplete.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

5. The Respondent’s Advocates Namada & Co. Advocates filed written submissions dated 3rd July, 2026 and submitted among others that:-

i. Counsel submitted on the role of this court as the first appellate court while relying on the case of Selle & Another vs Associated Motor Boat Co. ltd & others [1968) EA 123. That however, as noted in Mbae (Suing as the Legal Representative of the Estate of Koome Mbae) v Kinya [20241 KEHC 2285 (KLR), it is not incumbent upon this Court to interfere or set aside the trial Court's findings.

ii. On the issue of whether the learned Magistrate erred for finding that the Respondent's dismissal from employment was procedurally unfair counsel submitted that the Appellant contends that the Respondent did not plead that the termination was procedurally unfair. The Appellant's argument is legally untenable and ought to be rejected. The issues for determination on the Memorandum of claim by the Respondent are clear. It expressly indicated the same as unfair/unlawful dismissal and payment of damages for unfair/unlawful dismissal.

iii. It was submitted that once unfair/unlawful dismissal was pleaded, the trial court was obliged to interrogate whether the Appellant had complied with all the statutory requirements governing termination of employment, namely both substantive and procedural fairness. That procedural fairness is not an independent or separate cause of action requiring separate pleading. Rather, it constitutes one of the essential legal ingredients that the court must examine whenever a claim for unfair termination is before it.

iv. It was submitted that consequently, once the Respondent pleaded unfair and unlawful dismissal, the issue of procedural fairness automatically became a question for determination by the trial court in applying the provisions of Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act.

v. Counsel submitted that the law is settled that pleadings should not be construed in a narrow or technical manner. While relying on Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution 2010, and the overriding objective of civil litigation, that courts are enjoined to administer substantive justice without undue regard to technicalities. Where parties have adduced evidence on an issue and addressed it in submissions, the court is entitled to determine that issue notwithstanding that it may not have been pleaded with meticulous particularity.

vi. It was submitted that the learned trial magistrate applied the mandatory provisions of Sections 41, 43 and 45 (5) (a) of the Employment Act to the facts presented before the trial court. The finding that the Respondent's termination was procedurally unfair was therefore neither outside the pleadings nor an introduction of a new cause of action. It was an inevitable legal conclusion arising from the pleaded claim for unfair termination and the evidence adduced by both parties.

vii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant's argument seeks to artificially separate procedural fairness from the statutory concept of unfair termination, contrary to the Employment Act and the binding jurisprudence of the superior courts. Such an interpretation would defeat the protective purpose of the Employment Act, which requires the court to evaluate both the reason for termination and the procedure adopted before determining whether a dismissal is fair.

viii. It was submitted that accordingly, this court is respectfully urged to find that the trial Magistrate correctly addressed all the statutory ingredients of unfair termination and that the finding on procedural unfairness was properly founded in both the pleadings and the evidence. It is now trite that for any termination from employment of any employee, the same has to satisfy a two-pronged test of substantive justification and procedural fairness. Reliance was placed on the case of Walter Ogal Anuro vs Teachers Service Commission [2013) eKLR on this assertion.

ix. That any employer must satisfy both the substantive and procedural fairness. Failure to meet either of the two requirements render the termination/dismissal unfair under the Employment Act. Procedural justification is outlined under section 45 of the Employment Act.

x. It was submitted that in the instant case, the reasons put forth for the Respondent’s termination are as stated in the Appellant's alleged dismissal letter dated 11th December 2019. The letter categorically puts that the Respondent had failed to adhere to the Appellant’s Code of Conduct Policy as well as the Occupational Health and Safety policy, he willfully tampered with the company equipment in the factory on the 18th November 2019, and participated in receiving kickbacks with supplier.

xi. Counsel submitted that for one to breach any code of conduct, the said code of conduct must be in existence. The Appellant never availed any code of conduct policy addressed in the two show cause letters and the dismissal letter and the exact sections that the Respondent had breached. No proof that the Respondent was ever taken through or ever issued a copy of the code of conduct while responding to the allegations levied against him.

xii. Reliance was placed on Article 47 of the Constitution 2010, which outlines the right to fair administrative action that is expeditious, efficient, lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair. The Respondent was accused of receiving kickbacks from suppliers. The Appellant never ever called the said supplier during the disciplinary hearing.

xiii. It was submitted secondly, that the report being relied upon was done by one of the employee who used to work with the Respondent. Mr. David Mwenda RWI produced the report which was relied upon by the Appellant in dismissing the Respondent from employment. The said witness was an employee who worked closely with the Respondent, how does he then again become the available investigator in the investigation processes over the charges levied against the Respondent?

xiv. Counsel submitted that the said report does not in any way mention that the Respondent was ever interrogated or called upon before the report was made the subject matter of the case at the disciplinary hearing. This is clearly a conflict of interest where a colleague is used to investigate his fellow colleague when he was equally personally involved in the events resulting to the Respondent’s dismissal.

xv. It was submitted that in the instant case, there was no fair internal investigations by the Appellant prior to the dismissal. There was no indication of any independent technical report or whether the Respondent was ever involved in the investigation process which arrived at a report relied upon by the Appellant. Reliance was placed on Section 41 of the Employment Act on fair hearing processes and section 45 of the Employment Act on what amounts to unfair termination.

xvi. Counsel also relied on the case of Janet Nyandiko vs Kewa Commercial Bank Limited (2017] eKLR, where the court condensed the cited provisions while finding that for the termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness.

xvii. Counsel submitted that this was a case where the Appellant had already made up their mind in ensuring that the Respondent is out of their employment. There was no involvement of the Respondent in the entire process that resulted to a dismissal. If indeed the Appellants were genuine enough on the substantive and procedure fairness, why were they reluctant in allowing the Respondent a chance to appeal their decision?

xviii. It was submitted that the summary dismissal letter dated 11th December 2019 clearly stated that the arrangements apply with immediate effect with no clause allowing the Respondent to appeal the Appellant's decision, which was against Article 47 and 50 of the Constitution 2010 and against the fair procedure as outlined under section 45 (5) (a) of the Employment Act.

xix. It was submitted that the trial court had opportunity of seeing the demure of the witnesses during the examination in chief and cross- examination which this court does not. It's on the above stated that the trial court held that the Appellant had faulted the laid down procedure. Procedural fairness process, does not only involve issuance of show cause letters and the invitation to the disciplinary hearing, the essential part is that what happens before the issuance of the show cause letter, during the disciplinary hearing and before the issuance of the summary dismissal.

xx. On the issue of whether the learned Magistrate erred for awarding the Respondent damages counsel submitted that flowing from the unlawful termination, the trial court had the discretion pursuant to section 50 of the Employment Act to award the Respondent any or all of the remedies under section 49 of the Employment Act. The awards tend to vary from case to case based on the peculiar circumstances of each case.

xxi. It was submitted that in the instant case, the Respondent had served the Appellant for at least five years. That, was fairer especially on the part of the Appellant for its unlawful, unfair and malicious dismissal of the Respondent. Be as it may, this court’s discretion on award of compensatory of damages is directed by the provisions of section 49 of the Employment Act, and in particular section 49(4)(a)-(f).

xxii. It was submitted that the Respondent’s dismissal being unlawful and unfair, and the circumstances in which the termination took place, an award of one month in lieu of notice and damages of three months’ pay for unfair termination was awarded on the discretion of the trial court, that it ought to be interfered upwards. The Respondent had worked for the Appellant for more than five years and reasonably expected to work even more but for the malicious and unfair dismissal by the Appellant.

xxiii. Counsel submitted that the learned magistrate did not err nor misappropriate the facts and the evidence before her. Neither did she misapply the law. This Appeal is entirely bereft of merit, it is vexatious, an abuse of the court and is one for dismissal. This is a 2020 matter for which the Respondent should be enjoying the fruits of his judgement.

DETERMINATION

6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by the both parties herein and proceeds to analyse them while appreciating the role of this court as the appellate court, to re-evaluate the evidence tendered at trial court and reach its own determination while placing reliance on the holding of Court of Appeal for East Africa in Peters –vs- Sunday Post Limited [1958] EA 424 among others. In this case, the judgment of the trial court was that judgment was entered in favour of the Respondent against the Appellant with costs while finding that the termination was unfair in terms of procedure and awarded the respondent compensation for unfair termination at three months’ salary of Kshs 134,164.20/= and Notice pay of Kshs 44,721.40/=. The Appellant appealed the judgment fronting 7 grounds of appeal which this court will frame in to two issues which are:-

i. Whether the trial court erred by finding that Respondents’ termination of employment was procedurally unfair and unlawful.

ii. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe Whether the trial Magistrate erred in awarding the Respondent his terminal dues and whether the Appellant’s counterclaim is merited.

Whether the trial court erred by finding that Respondents’ termination of employment was procedurally unfair

12. It is not in dispute that the Respondent was employed by the Appellant as an Electrical Technician on 16th June 2014 and he worked up to 11th December, 2019 when he was dismissed from employment. Whereas the Respondent alleged that on 18th November, 2019 there was a power upsurge as a result of a default in KPLC transmission which led to destruction and loss to the Appellant and for which he was erroneously summarily dismissed, the Appellant’s case was that it terminated the services of the Respondent due to vandalism of its property due to negligence performance of duties.

13. The Appellant raised an issue that the Respondent did not plead in the memorandum of claim that his termination was procedurally unfair and so the trial court erred in its finding that there was a failure on procedural fairness when the same was not pleaded. This court appreciates that a party is bound by their pleadings. In respect to the essence of pleadings, the Supreme Court of Kenya in its ruling on inter alia scrutiny in the case of Raila Amolo Odinga & Another vs. IEBC & 2 others (2017) eKLR found and held as follows in an election petition: -

“In absence of pleadings, evidence if any, produced by the parties, cannot be considered. It is also a settled legal proposition that no party should be permitted to travel beyond its pleadings and parties are bound to take all necessary and material facts in support of the case set up by them. Pleadings ensure that each side is fully alive to the questions that are likely to be raised and they may have an opportunity of placing the relevant evidence before the court for its consideration. The issues arise only when a material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by one party and denied by the other party. Therefore, it is neither desirable nor permissible for a court to frame an issue not arising on the pleadings…...’”

14. The court has perused the Memorandum of Claim dated 7th October 2020. The Respondent’s case as stated was that the Appellant accused the Respondent of tampering with the company equipment. The Appellant then invoked a predetermined disciplinary process against the Respondent. The Appellant eventually terminated the services of the Respondent unfairly, unlawfully and without any justification and against the principles of natural justice.

15. From the above, it cannot be said that the Respondent did not plead procedural unfairness. The Respondent pleaded and the trial court did not depart from the pleadings. The Respondent clearly challenged the procedure adopted in his dismissal. The court properly assessed the probity of the said procedure. That is what resulted to the finding of lack of procedural fairness. It was not mandatory that a party must use the phrase procedural or unprocedural fairness for it to be said to be pleaded.

16. Regarding procedural fairness, it was held in the case of Walter Ogal Anuro -vs- Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR that for termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for termination but also procedural fairness. The issue of the substantive fairness has not been challenged hence this court will only deal with the issue of procedural fairness as the ground in this appeal.

17. The Court of Appeal in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority v Menginya Salim Murgani [2010] eKLR observed thus;

“there is ample authority that decision making bodies other than courts and bodies whose procedure are laid down by statute are masters of their own procedures. Provided they achieve the degree of fairness appropriate to their task. It is for them to decide how they will proceed.”

18. The trial court found that the reason for termination was fair but the procedure was unfair. According to the Appellant, this was a contradictory finding. To this court, there was no contradiction. The Appellant having a valid reason to terminate the services of the Respondent did not grant him a fair termination process. The Employment Act at section 45 takes a two pronged approach in determining unfair termination. That is to say, a termination will be deemed unfair if it is established that the reasons for termination have not been proved or are those prohibited under section 46 of the Act and or the process of termination did not accord to the procedure provided for under section 43 of the Act or egregious breach of administrative fairness and rules of natural justice. An employer may have a valid and justifiable reason to terminate an employee’s service but miss out or abuse the procedure for termination as prescribed by law. This will constitute an unfair termination notwithstanding the validity of reasons for the termination

19. In this case, the Respondent alleged that the hearing was predetermined to terminate his services. The accusations were communicated to the Respondent following which he was accorded ample time to respond and was in fact heard before a decision to dismiss him was made, the accusations were clear on the willfully tampering with equipment in the factory, participating in receiving kickbacks with a supplier and insubordination. Even though the hearing took a narrow view centred on negligence leading to destruction of capacitors and contactors the court finds that the Appellant tried to the best of its standards to follow the procedural fairness. Whereas the Respondent alleged that there was no external investigation report and that he was investigated by the fellow employee no prejudice was established to have been suffered by him. The Respondent was previously warned of his conduct, and he contributed to his dismissal. This court notes that the conduct need not be a near forensic examination of the hearing which took place. The Court therefore takes the view that the Respondent was accorded a fair hearing with a colleague of his choice. In this respect ,the court is guided by the Court of Appeal sentiments in Civil Appeal No 66A of 2017, Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019) eKLR where it was stated as follows:

“…It is improper for a court to expect that an employer would have to undertake a near forensic examination of the facts and seek proof beyond reasonable doubt as in a criminal trial before it can take appropriate action subject to the requirements of procedural fairness that are statutorily required. The standard of proof is on a balance of probability, not beyond reasonable doubt, and all the employer is required to prove are the reasons that it "genuinely believed to exist," causing it to terminate the employee's services…"

20. This court therefore disagrees with the trial court that the procedure was unfair as it did not expect the Appellant to conduct a near forensic hearing. As long as the reason was justified and the Appellant tried to comply with section 41 of the Employment Act on the fair hearing then the Appellant discharged its duty. There was no procedural unfairness therefore.

Whether the trial Magistrate erred in awarding the Respondent his terminal dues and whether the Appellant’s counterclaim is merited.

21. This court having overturned the trial court finding that the procedural fairness was not breached, the finding on unfair termination and consequential orders by the trial court naturally becomes displaced and are hereby set aside.

22. On the Appellant’s counterclaim although they produced receipts, the same being special damages ought to have been specifically proved and attributed to the Respondent. There was no demand letter issued to the Respondent during the pendency of his employment since the replacement of spare parts happened severally even before the dismissal of the Respondent. The dismissal letter did not raise any amount to be paid by the Respondent. It is after the Respondent filed the claim when the counterclaim was raised. To this court this was just but an afterthought and the same was raised too late. The court therefore disallows the same even though the trial court did not deal with the counterclaim the same is not merited.

23. In the upshot the Appeal partially succeeds by overturning the trial court findings that the appellant did not accord the respondent procedural fairness while terminating his service and substituting therewith an order that the procedure was fair and accorded with the provisions of section 45 of the Act.

24. Appellant’s counterclaim is disallowed for lack of merit and sufficient proof as required by law.

25. Each party to bear their cost of the appeal.

26. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 5th day of November2026

Delivered virtually this 5th day of November 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-Appeals Division

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder