Background
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 28th October, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.O Mbeja, SPM delivered on 2nd October, 2025 on grounds inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 28th October, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.O Mbeja, SPM delivered on 2nd October, 2025 on grounds inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
APPEALS DIVISION
APPEAL NO. E371 OF 2025
BOBMIL INDUSTRIES LIMITED…………..…………….. APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
BONIFACE WANGURU KORI………..………...…. 1ST RESPONDENT
DANREE MULTIHANDLING
SERVICES LIMITED…………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Honourable D.O Mbeja, SPM delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in MCELRC No. E385 of 2024 on 2nd October,2025)
JUDGMENT
(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)
1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 28th October, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the Judgment of Honourable D.O Mbeja, SPM delivered on 2nd October, 2025 on grounds inter alia: -
i. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact and misunderstood the nature of the claim by rendering judgment based on assumptions and opinions not supported by evidence.
ii. The Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact by failing to consider that there was an employment contract between the Respondents that the Appellant was not party to.
iii. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in failing to consider that the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent had a sub contract agreement dated 24th March 2021 by which the 2nd Respondent was responsible for making all terminal benefits to casual labourers who were its employees including the 1st Respondent.
iv. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in failing to appreciate the admission by the 1st Respondent that the Appellant was not his employer and so could not have contravened Section 45 of the Employment Act.
v. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in awarding the 1st Respondent an excessive award of 6 months’ salary as well as one-month salary in lieu of notice in contravention of Section 49(1) of the Employment Act.
vi. The Learned Magistrate erred in fact and law in finding unfair termination against the Appellant despite the contrary evidence.
2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed and the Judgment delivered on 2nd October, 2025 be set aside with an order dismissing the claim against the Appellant.
3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.
APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS
4. The Appellant’s Advocates Macharia-Mwangi & Njeru Advocates filed written submissions dated 20th May, 2026 submitted among others that:-
i. It was submitted that the crux of this Appeal can be summed up in the words of Ndolo J in Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Mwana Black Smith Limited [2013) eKLR, that employment relationship has serious implications on the parties and the courts must satisfy it exists while the Claimant must prove it exists. Counsel also relied on the case of Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co Ltd & Others [1968) EA 123 on the duty of the first appellate court.
ii. On the issue of whether the trial court erred in finding that there was no dispute on who was the 1st Respondent's employer - Grounds of appeal 1, 2, 3 & 4 it was submitted that this appeal challenges the position taken by the trial court by misconstruing on employer-employee relationship between the parties.
iii. Counsel firstly, submitted that the assertion that the issue of employment was not in dispute is a misconception of the factual issue, is ill-construed and at the very least did very little in the way of analyzing the evidence presented. That the Appellant in its pleadings and the hearing before the trial court at all times disputed that the 1st Respondent was not its employee.
iv. Counsel submitted that the 1st Respondent was never an employee of the Appellant and the trial court failed to make a determination on the issue of employer- employee relationship. Reliance was placed on clause 10 of the subcontract agreement between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent in which it was stated that the subcontractor shall assume all legal responsibilities as an employer of the casual laborers.
v. That the right provision on definition of employee and employer was section 2 of the Employment Act and not section 45 as stated by the trial court. That what was before the trial court was an issue of outsourcing of labour. The 1st Respondent was an employee of the 2nd Respondent who was deployed to work at the Appellant premises.
vi. It was submitted that this court in Christine Adot Lopeyio vs Wycliffe Mwathi Pere [2013] eKLR considering a similar issue spelt out various tests to determine the nature of an employer-employee relationship in a contract of service. Further it was submitted that there existed a triangular relationship in labour outsourcing agreements which the trial court ignored. Reliance was placed on the case of Mekubo v Vivo Energy Kenya Limited [2025] eKLR where it was submitted that in triangular model of employment contract, the owner of the work does not directly employ the worker and the 1st Respondent herein was not direct employee of the Appellant.
vii. Further reliance was placed on Abyssinia Iron & Steel Limited v Kenya Engineering Workers Union (2016) eKLR where it was submitted that the 1st Respondent was not under management and control of the Appellant. A closer scrutiny of the facts present reveals that the 1st Respondent herein was an employee of the 2nd Respondent. He was recruited, engaged, and managed by the 2nd Respondent under various contracts of employment. At no time was the employment contract issued by the Appellant, nor was there any direct contract of service between the 1st Respondent and the Appellant.
viii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant only engaged the 2nd Respondent through a subcontract. As per the subcontract agreement dated 24th March 2021, the 2nd Respondent was to provide outsourced casual labour. The key obligations such as recruitment, payment of salaries, statutory remittances, and overall supervision of the 1st Respondent were expressly placed on the 2nd Respondent.
ix. It was submitted further, that the Appellant exercised no control or supervision over the 1st Respondent as to give rise to an implied employment relationship. During the hearing the 1st Respondent herein admitted that he was an employee of the 2nd Respondent. He further admitted that he had entered a contract of employment with the 2nd Respondent. He further admitted that the NSSF payment were made by his employer the 2nd Respondent. In addition, he admitted that the 2nd Respondent used to pay his salary.
x. It was submitted that in totality therefore, the evidence adduced at the trial court can only point to one conclusion; that the 1st Respondent was fully integrated into the employment structure of the 2nd Respondent and there is no evidence that the Appellant assumed any employer obligations toward them.
xi. On the issue of whether the 1st Respondent was an employee of the Appellant herein- Grounds of Appeal 5 & 10 it was submitted that the trial court failed to consider the admission by the 1st Respondent that he was employed by the 2nd Respondent. As a matter of fact, the 1st Respondent relied on his witness statement and relied on his list of documents among them the employment contract dated 20/02/2024 and duly signed by the 1st and 2nd Respondent which at clause 1 it provided that the 1st Respondent was to be an employee of the 2nd Respondent.
xii. It was submitted that at cross examination the 1st Respondent conceded that indeed the contract of employment was between the 2nd Respondent and himself as per the contract of employment and made reference to the employment form. That the 1st Respondent admitted that his NSSF was paid for by his employer the 2nd Respondent. This fact is uncontroverted. It was the 2nd Respondent who issued the 1st Respondent with a warning letter and the one who paid him. Reliance was placed inter alia on Moses Njuki Ngethe v Ministry of Interior and Coordination of National Government & 2 Others (2012) KEELRC 627 while submitting that the trial court position that there was no dispute who the 1st Respondent’s employer was amounted to mistrial.
xiii. It was submitted that it is good law that where a trial judge fails to direct themselves as to the evidence, an appellate court is duty bound to upset such a finding. Counsel urged this court to set aside the judgement of the trial court as was set out by the Court of Appeal in Mwangi & another v Wambugu [1984] KECA 13 (KLR).
xiv. On the issue of whether the Appellant terminated the 1st Respondent-Grounds of Appeal 6, 9 & 11 it was submitted that the very concept of dismissal or termination presupposes the existence of a valid employment contract. If no contract of service exists, there is nothing to terminate. That a party could not dismiss a Claimant who was not its employee. That the existence of an employment relationship between the parties is a prerequisite in employment claims. Counsel relied on Aaron Safari Mutinda v Abe-Tee (E.A) Limited [2017) KEELRC 747 (KLR) on this assertion.
xv. On the issue of whether the court erred in making an awards against the Appellant -Grounds of Appeal 7 & 8 it was submitted that it was established law that liability for employment benefits arises primarily from the existence of an employer-employee relationship. That as there was no employer employee relationship, no terminal dues could be founded against the Appellant. Reliance was placed inter alia on Kaiga v Das (ELRC Cause No. E002 of 2023) (2023) eKLR and ELRC Cause No. E981 of 2023 Emmanuel Kulecho Bushuru v Danree Multihandler Services Ltd and Bobmill Industries Limited (2025) eKLR.
xvi. Counsel also urged the Court to be guided by the case of Everret Aviation Ltd v Kenya Revenue Authority [2013] eKLR, in which the Court of Appeal stressed the need to direct claims and reliefs only against parties with legal or contractual obligations to the Claimant.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
5. The 1st Respondent’s Advocates A.K Wahome & Co. Advocates filed written submissions dated 4th June, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On the issue of whether the Claimant was an employee of the Appellant it was submitted that the 1st Respondent worked for the Appellant and it was the Appellant who paid his salary as per the bank statements produced in evidence. The Appellant is the one who controlled how the 1st Respondent did his job, and gave the 1st Respondent work hours, schedules and evaluated his work.
ii. It was submitted that the lower court did not make a mistake in determining that there was an employee and employer relationship between them, as there is no doubt that the Respondent was working for the Appellant, evidence shows that the Appellant was paying a salary, and the Respondent was working at the Appellant's premises under the Appellant's terms. Reliance was placed on the case of Lwanga v Nation Media Group Limited (2024) eKLR where it was submitted for the 1st Respondent that there was an employer-employee relationship between the 1st Respondent and the Appellant. That the only reason the Appellant is denying that the 1st Respondent was its employee is to avoid paying the benefits that are due to the 1st Respondent. The 2nd Respondent has ceased to exist, and it was only used by the Appellant as a vehicle to avoid paying benefits due to employees and to avoid other legal liabilities that may arise during the employment of its workers.
iii. On the issue of whether the Claimant employment was unfairly terminated it was the submission of the 1st Respondent that he was unfairly terminated from employment as he was given a new contract to sign which reduced his benefits.
iv. It was submitted that the employment laws are very clear that if an employer imposes a salary or benefit cut without employee consent, it constitutes an unlawful pay cut and a fundamental breach of employment contract, which entitles the employee to demand full contractual salary or the employee can claim constructive dismissal. The 1st Respondent had no choice but to leave his job and file suit against the Appellant for unlawful termination.
v. It was submitted that the 1st Respondent was entitled to the benefits that the trial court awarded.
DETERMINATION
6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by the both parties herein and observes that the role of this court as the first appellate court is to re-analyse and re-evaluate the evidence in the trial court and arrive at its own decision while placing reliance on the case of Gitobu Imanyara & 2 others v Attorney General [2016] eKLR among others.
7. In this case, the judgment of the trial court found that the 1st Respondent was unfairly terminated by the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent jointly and awarded the 1st Respondent terminal dues jointly and severally against the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent. The crux of the Appellant’s appeal to this court is that it is the 2nd Respondent who was the employer of the 1st Respondent and not the Appellant. This leads to the main issue as to who between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent was the employer of the 1st Respondent before the court can deal with the rest of the issues.
Whether the trial court erred by finding employee-employer relationship between the 1st Respondent and the Appellant
8. It was pleaded in the Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 17th June 2024 that on or about June 2012, the Appellant herein and the 2nd Respondent employed the 1st Respondent as a worker operating machinery at a salary of Ksh. 30,000/= per month until December, 2023 when they altered his terms of employment and he left in protest of the terms hence unfair termination.
9. The 2nd Respondent herein filed its Response dated 22nd March 2024 and admitted employing the 1st Respondent. On the other hand, the Appellant filed its Response dated 17th September 2024 and denied being the employer of the 1st Respondent while maintaining that it was the 2nd Respondent who was the employer of the 1st Respondent.
10. The 1st Respondent had the duty to prove on a balance of probability who his employer was. This could be expected to be by tendering evidence of an employment contract or evidence that he was engaged and paid under an arrangement that would be interpreted to mean an employment contract. This court is awake to Section 107(1) of the Evidence Act, which provides that:
“Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.”
11. This was the position in Anne Wambui Ndiritu vs Joseph Kiprono Ropkoi & Another [2005] 1 EA 334, in which the Court of Appeal held that:
“As a general proposition under section 107(1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 80, the legal burden of proof lies upon the party who invokes the aid of the law and substantially asserts the affirmative of the issue. There is however the evidential burden that is cast upon any party the burden of proving any particular fact which he desires the Court to believe in its existence which is capture
12. The jurisdiction of the Employment and Labour Relations court as far as employment matters are concerned is limited by the existence of an employment relationship as defined in law and the court must always satisfy itself on this account before proceeding any further. In this respect the court relies on the case of Casmir Nyankuru Nyaberi v Mwakikar Agencies Limited (2016) eKLR where the court held that:
“…This court is fully aware that it is the responsibility of an employer to document the employment relationship and in certain respects, the burden of proving or disproving a term of employment shifts to the employer. This does not however release the Claimant from the burden of proving their case. Even in cases where an employment contract is oral in nature, the Claimant must still adduce some evidence whether documentary or viva voce to corroborate their word. More importantly, where an employee believes that the employer has in its possession some documents that would support the case of the employee, that employee is obligated to serve a production notice…”
13. The burden of proof in civil cases is on a balance of probability. Lord Denning J. in Miller vs Minister of Pensions (1947) 2 ALL ER 372, discussing that burden of proof held that that degree is well settled. It must carry a reasonable degree of probability, but not so high as is required in a criminal case.
14. The court has perused the testimony and evidence of the 1st Respondent in the trial court. In his testimony in cross examination, it was the case of the 1st Respondent that his contract of employment was with the 2nd Respondent. He was deployed to work for the Appellant but the 2nd Respondent paid him. On his part, the witness of the Appellant testified that the Appellant never paid the 1st Respondent salary directly. There was a sub contract agreement between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent. Invoices were issued between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent.
15. On the re-evaluation of the evidence produced in the trial court, the court is unable to find basis for the finding by the trial court that the Appellant jointly with the 2nd Respondent employed the 1st Respondent. This court notes that the employment contract produced by the 1st Respondent shows he was employed by the 2nd Respondent. The bank statement which runs from June 2023 to January, 2024 he was paid by the 2nd Respondent.
16. A clear scrutiny shows that although the subcontractor agreement was officially entered in to in March 2021 the same arrangement existed as early as 2011 as the personal employment form between the 1st and 2nd Respondents was dated 2011 and the invoices between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent date back to 2019. This therefore meant the 1st Respondent was all along an employee of the 2nd Respondent whose obligations were taken over by Dannryy Logistics Limited on March 2021.
17. Further the NSSF statement showed the 2nd Respondent as the employer as well as the subcontracting employment clause 1.3 the 2nd Respondent was the employer, clause 2.18 the 2nd Respondent was to indemnify the Appellant of all claims and clause 10 the 2nd Respondent was not an employee or agent of the Appellant. All this evidence leads to the conclusion that the 1st Respondent was never an employee of the Appellant but the 2nd Respondent who also issued a warning letter dated 23rd March, 2020 to the 1st Respondent as its employee.
18. Whereas the 1st Respondent pleaded that he was employed by both the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent, the evidence produced demonstrated that the 1st Respondent was employed and paid by the 2nd Respondent. There ought to have been established an employer-employee relationship against both the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent per the 1st Respondent’s pleadings. In the case of Samuel Wambugu Ndirangu v 2NK Sacco Society Limited [2019] eKLR, the Court spelt out the ingredients necessary to determine the existence of an employer-employee relationship as follows:
“A review of the elements above reveals that in order for a positive determination of the existence of an employer-employee relationship there must be the selection and engagement of the employee (the hire after either a restricted or open interview process), proof of payment of wages, the power of dismissal and finally, the power to control the employee’s conduct.
19. The relationship between the 1st Respondent and the Appellant was strictly based on the existence of the relationship between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent. There was no direct contract between the Appellant and the 1st Respondent. In Industrial Court of Kenya Cause Number 684 of 2011- Child Welfare Society of Kenya v. Margaret Bwire and Isiolo Children’s Home- Isiolo County, the Court stated as follows:
“an employer- employee relationship exists, where an Employee agrees to work for an Employer, full time or part-time, for a specified period or indeterminate period of time, in return for wages or salary. The Employer has the right to decide where, when and how the work is to be done. There are four factors [at common law] in determining the presence of an employment relationship: control; ownership of the tools of work; the chance of profit or risk of loss; and integration.’’
20. Further, the contract herein was clearly a contract of service. Under Section 2 of the Employment Act, 2007, ‘contract of service’ is a necessary ingredient in the definition of ‘employer’. Further, Section 2 of the Employment Act defines an employee as:-
“a person employed for wages or a salary and includes an apprentice and indentured learner”
21. In the case of Charles Juma Oleng v M/S Auto Garage Ltd & another [2014] KEELRC 1170 (KLR) the court elaborated the difference between the contract of service and contract for service as follows: -
“11. In most cited authorities in this regard from various jurisdictions, several tests have been applied to distinguish between what comprise ‘employment’ as against what constitutes ‘service’ in case of contracts of service as contrasted with contracts for service. They include the following:
The control test whereby a servant is a person who is subject to the command of the master as to the manner in which he or she shall do the work.
The integration test in which the worker is subjected to the rules and procedures of the employer rather than personal command. The employee is part of the business and his or her work is primarily part of the business.
The test of economic or business reality which takes into account whether the worker is in business on his or her own account, as an entrepreneur, or works for another person, the employer, who takes the ultimate risk of loss or chance of profit.
Mutuality of obligation in which the parties make commitments to maintain the employment relationship over a period of time. That a contract of service entails service in return for wages, and, secondly, mutual promises for future performance. The arrangement creates a sense of stability between the parties. The challenge is that where there is absence of mutual promises for stable future performance, the worker thereby ceases to be classified as an employee as may be the case for casual workers.
12. These tests are however not to be seen exclusively by themselves as they only serve as a guide based on the facts of each case. They are however a good guide to the issues as in this case”.
22. Based on this definition, the 1st Respondent was solely under the control of the 2nd Respondent in relation to his work. The court cannot find any way in which the Appellant could terminate the services of the 1st Respondent. If the 2nd Respondent did not advocate for better terms or against reduction of the salary payable to the 1st Respondent, by that fact alone, the 2nd Respondent could not be said to have ceased to be an employer of the 1st Respondent.
23. Therefore, without an employment relationship between the Appellant and the 1st Respondent, the trial court was wrong in apportioning liability for unfair termination of employment of the 1st Respondent between the Appellant and the 2nd Respondent. This court therefore sets aside judgment against the Appellant. The judgment will stand solely against the 2nd Respondent.
24. In the upshot the court makes the following orders:
a) The appeal is merited and is allowed.
b) Judgment of the lower court dated 2nd December 2025 as against the Appellant is set aside.
c) The Claim against the Appellant is dismissed with costs.
d) For the avoidance of doubt, 2nd Respondent shall solely bear the Judgment.
e) The Appellant shall have costs of this Appeal.
25. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 6th day of November, 2026
Delivered virtually this 6th day of November, 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-Appeals Division.