Employment law

Thinji v Samchi Group Ltd [2026] KEELRC 15062 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E841 of 2024
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before the Court is a Statement of Claim dated 2nd October, 2024, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent: -

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E841 OF 2024

GILBERT THINJI ................................................................... CLAIMANT

VERSUS

SAMCHI GROUP LIMITED ................................................RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction.

1. Before the Court is a Statement of Claim dated 2nd October, 2024, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent: -

(a) A declaration that the Respondent’s termination of the Claimant’s services was unlawful, procedurally improper, and constituted unfair dismissal.

(b) A declaration that the Respondent’s treatment of the Claimant from 10th February, 2024 until the termination of his services on 1st August, 2024 breached his Constitutional Rights under Article 41 and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.

(c) General Damages for Breach of the Claimant’s Rights under Article 41 and 50 of the Constitution.

(d) Salary for the Month of July 2024 – Ksh 150,000

(e) One month’s pay in lieu of notice – Ksh 150,000

(f) Payment for unutilized leave days – Ksh 80,000

(g) General damages for unfair dismissal (150,000 X 12 months) – Ksh 1,800,000.

(h) Certificate of service.

(i) Costs of this suit.

(j) Interest on (c-g) and (i) above at court rates.

(k) Any other relief that this Honourable Court may deem fit to grant.

2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 25th October, 2024 and subsequently filed a Response to the Statement of Claim dated 11th November, 2024 together with a Counterclaim against the Claimant. It also filed a List and Bundle of Documents dated 11th November, 2024, and Witness Statements by Williamson Moses and Edmond Vincent, both dated 12th November, 2024. The witness statement of Williamson Moses was later expunged from the court record.

3. The Claimant subsequently filed a Reply to the Defence and Defence to Counterclaim dated 15th December, 2024 and filed on 14th January, 2025. The Claimant also filed a supplementary Witness Statement and supplementary List and Bundle of Documents dated 15th December, 2024.

4. The Claimant’s case was heard on 30th September, 2025, when the Claimant testified as CW1. He adopted his Witness Statement dated 2nd October, 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced his List and Bundle of Documents of even date, which were admitted as Claimant’s Exhibits Nos. 1-13.

5. He further adopted his supplementary Witness Statement dated 15th December, 2024 as his evidence and produced his supplementary List and Bundle of Documents of even date, which were admitted as Claimant’s Exhibits Nos. 14 -16.

6. The Respondent’s case was heard on 29th April 2026, when Edmond Vincent Ogot testified as RW1. He adopted his witness statement dated 12th November, 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced his list and bundle of documents, which were admitted as Exhibits 1-6 and Exhibit 8. The Respondent’s witness statement by Williamson Moses was subsequently expunged from the record.

7. Both parties filed written submissions.

The Claimant’s Case

8. The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent on or about 4th April, 2023 as the General Manager of its business known as After 40 Hotel at a monthly salary of Kshs.150,000/=. He states that he performed his duties diligently and faithfully without any complaints of misconduct or incompetence until 2024, when the Respondent allegedly began taking steps to terminate his services without lawful justification.

9. The Claimant avers that on 10th February, 2024, the Respondent issued him with a show cause letter alleging gross misconduct, wilful neglect and careless performance of his duties. He states that the allegations related to local purchase orders allegedly made without proper approvals, hiking of prices for items purchased from a particular hardware, failure to raise requisitions through the required system, failure to involve Heads of Departments in repairs and purchases, and use of external repair services without involving the Respondent’s maintenance personnel.

10. The Claimant states that he responded to the allegations through a letter dated 12th February, 2024, explaining his position and disputing the allegations. He contends that the Respondent did not respond to his explanations but instead issued him with a second show cause letter dated 26th June, 2024, alleging underperformance and setting out further complaints, namely failure to achieve set targets, ineffective team management, challenges in the housekeeping department, lack of staff motivation, and absenteeism.

11. The Claimant avers that he responded to the second show cause letter on 28th June, 2024, and thereafter, through a letter dated 9th July, 2024, the Respondent raised further concerns and required him to prepare a business improvement plan and strategy. He states that he complied by preparing and submitting the requested plan through his letter dated 18th July, 2024, which contained thirteen action points intended to address the concerns raised by the Respondent.

12. The Claimant maintains that despite complying with the Respondent’s demands, his employment was summarily terminated through a letter dated 1st August, 2024. He avers that the dismissal letter cited alleged underperformance, gross misconduct, and issuing a fake receipt to a client following a payment. He contends that the allegation concerning the fake receipt and receipt of money was never included in the earlier show cause letters, and he was not given an opportunity to respond to those allegations or subjected to a disciplinary hearing before the termination.

13. The Claimant denies issuing a fake receipt or receiving money from the Respondent’s client, Mr. Ayubu. He maintains that he was never summoned by the police or any other lawful authority in connection with the allegations. He further contends that the Respondent’s investigations and allegations were intended to create a basis for terminating his employment after his responses to the earlier allegations did not result in his dismissal.

14. The Claimant also avers that the Respondent failed to pay his outstanding dues following the termination. He particularized the amounts claimed as Kshs. 150,000/= being unpaid salary for July 2024, Kshs. 150,000/= being one month’s salary in lieu of notice and Kshs. 80,000/= for unutilized leave days. He maintains that the termination was unfair and unlawful and that it violated his rights under Articles 41 and 50 of the Constitution and the Employment Act.

15. In his Reply to the Defence, the Claimant denies that he was issued with a show cause letter concerning the alleged stealing of money or issuance of fake documents.

16. The Claimant further denies the allegations of poor performance and maintains that the Respondent failed to provide him with an opportunity to improve his performance. He reiterated that the termination was procedurally and substantively unfair.

17. In his Defence to the Respondent’s Counterclaim, he denies receiving Kshs. 102,000/= or any other amount from the Respondent’s client and denies issuing fake receipts or breaching his employment contract. He prayed that the Respondent’s Response and Counterclaim be struck out and judgment entered as prayed in the Statement of Claim.

18. The Claimant testified that his office was situated on the first floor and not at the hotel reception. He stated that although the hotel maintained a visitors’ attendance book at reception, he was never shown any entry indicating that someone had visited him to deliver money. He also denied deleting emails, stating that the emails were protected on the Respondent’s server.

19. He further pointed out that Michael Kimemia, who had allegedly been implicated alongside him, continued working for the Respondent and even served as a General Manager. He explained that procurement requisitions and sourcing of additional labour fell within the responsibilities of Esther Kamau, the Procurement Manager.

20. On cross-examination, CW1 confirmed that he received and acknowledged the show cause letter dated 10th February, 2024 and the second show cause letter dated 26th June, 2024. He also confirmed that he responded to both letters, but could not confirm whether he achieved the set targets.

21. He was referred to invoices at page 30 of the Respondent’s bundle and acknowledged that the kitchen mixer appeared in two invoices and that duty waste also appeared twice. He maintained that he did not personally know Mr. Ayubu and had no knowledge of why anyone would claim to have paid him. He denied receiving Kshs. 102,000/=, issuing a receipt for that amount or using the Respondent’s rubber stamp to stamp any receipt. He further stated that it was never reported to him that Kshs. 102,000/= was missing.

22. CW1 acknowledged that the issue of hiking prices and double charging was brought to his attention and accepted that as General Manager, he was responsible for ensuring that the right procedures were followed. He also confirmed that, in his response to the show cause letter, he stated that methods were not always by the book and that some decisions were made directly by the CEO. He further acknowledged that a monthly management report indicated that price hiking had been confirmed.

23. He stated that he was not given performance indicators or a job description. He confirmed that there were discussions on a Kshs. 12 million target, but acknowledged that he did not achieve the target. He explained that his response contained a breakdown of the achievements. He also confirmed that the issue of a defective mattress in Room No. 801 was raised and that it fell within his responsibilities as General Manager.

24. On re-examination, CW1 reiterated that he was not issued with a show-cause letter concerning the alleged issuance of fake receipts or receipt of Kshs. 102,000/=. He maintained that the show cause letters concerned failure to achieve targets and that forgery and issuance of a receipt were not among the allegations put to him.

25. He stated that he was asked to respond to concerns relating to tender strategy and improvement and did so on 18th July, 2024 by preparing a business improvement strategy. He maintained that none of the proposals in the strategy were implemented. He further testified that there was no evidence that the alleged receipt was issued to him or that he collected the money.

26. CW1 also stated that he has produced evidence showing that the Respondent’s revenues increased after he joined the company. He maintained that he raised the issue of price hiking with the CEO and instructed the Finance Manager to investigate, but the Finance Manager produced no report to show that he was responsible for the price increases. He explained that he relied on reports from Heads of Departments when preparing his management reports.

27. Regarding the screenshot allegedly linking him to Mr. Ayubu, he stated that it did not contain a telephone number but only a name similar to that of Ayubu. He further stated that the CEO knew of the outstanding debt and that he had brought it to her attention.

The Claimant’s Submissions

28. On procedural fairness, the Claimant submits that the Respondent failed to comply with Section 41 of the Employment Act as he was not informed of the allegation concerning the issuance of a fake receipt and receipt of Kshs. 102,000/=, nor was he given an opportunity to respond to those allegations before termination. He further submits that the earlier show cause letters concerned procurement irregularities and underperformance and did not contain the allegations upon which the summary dismissal was ultimately based.

29. It is the Claimant’s submission that the Respondent did not provide the Claimant with the investigation report before termination, thereby denying him an opportunity to understand and respond to the evidence relied upon against him. He sought to rely on Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Company Ltd [2013] KEELRC 920 (KLR), on the requirements of a fair disciplinary process, including disclosure of the allegations and material relied upon and the opportunity to make representations.

30. On substantive fairness, the Claimant submits that the Respondent has failed to establish a valid and fair reason for termination as required under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act. It was argued that the investigation report relied upon by the Respondent was undated and unsigned and did not sufficiently establish that the Claimant received Kshs.102,200/= from the client, issued a fake receipt, or deleted emails. Counsel pointed to the investigator’s admissions during cross-examination, including the absence of a statement from the Claimant in the report, the absence of CCTV verification, lack of evidence identifying the person who allegedly delivered the money, and the absence of a forensic report or police occurrence book.

31. The Claimant relied on Lockwood Girls High School v Wasike [2024] KECA 360 (KLR), in support of the principles governing substantive and procedural fairness in termination of employment.

32. On the alleged violation of constitutional rights, Counsel relied on Articles 27, 41, 47, 50 and 236 of the Constitution, to submit that the Respondent’s conduct amounted to unfair labour practices and denial of fair administrative action and a fair hearing.

33. Regarding remedies, Counsel submitted that the Claimant was entitled to Kshs. 150,000/= being salary for July, 2024, Kshs. 150,000/= being one month’s salary in lieu of notice, and Kshs. 80,000/= for unutilized leave days.

34. It is the Claimant’s submission that his employment contract provided for one month’s notice and that he had 11 outstanding leave days as at 5th March, 2024, with the claimed leave payment calculated at Kshs. 80,000/=.

The Respondent’s Case.

35. The Respondent denies the Claimant’s allegations of unlawful and unfair termination. It states that the Claimant was employed as the General Manager of After 40 Hotel, but maintains that his employment commenced on 14th April, 2023, and was lawfully terminated on 1st August, 2024, on the grounds of gross misconduct, underperformance, and issuance of fake receipts.

36. The Respondent denies that the Claimant worked diligently and faithfully, maintaining that investigations had revealed gross misconduct and poor performance. It contends that it issued the Claimant with a show cause letter and gave him sufficient time to respond, but that the allegations raised against him were substantiated by the investigation reports and were not satisfactorily addressed in his responses.

37. The Respondent further states that the Claimant failed to achieve set targets, managed the team ineffectively, had challenges in the housekeeping department, failed to motivate staff and was frequently absent from work. It maintains that the Claimant was given several opportunities to improve his performance but failed to do so, leaving the Respondent with no option but to terminate his employment.

38. It therefore contends that the dismissal was justified and that the necessary procedural requirements were followed.

39. The Respondent further states that the Claimant breached his employment contract by causing disrepute to the company and defrauding it of Kshs. 102,200/=, being money paid directly to him by one of the Respondent’s clients. It maintains that the Claimant received the money without following the company’s procedures and failed to remit it to the Respondent.

40. In its Counterclaim, the Respondent states that the Claimant received Kshs. 102,000/= directly from one of its clients after raising an invoice and issuing a fake receipt, but failed to surrender the money to the Respondent.

41. The Respondent therefore urges the Court to enter judgment against the Claimant for Kshs. 102,000/= being the monies allegedly received from its client, together with costs of the suit and those of the counterclaim.

42. RW1 identified himself as a private investigator and stated that he was the lead investigator in the matter. He testified that he was commissioned to investigate allegations of hiking prices in the purchase of repair materials, misuse of petty cash, and stealing of Kshs. 102,200/= at After 40 Hotel.

43. RW1 testified that his investigations established that the Claimant and two other employees hiked prices of items purchased from hardware suppliers and that the price differences were being pocketed by the Claimant and the other employees.

44. On cross-examination, RW1 confirmed that although he interviewed the Claimant in relation to the alleged theft of Kshs. 102,200/=, the Claimant’s statement was not included in the investigation report.

45. RW1 further admitted that the person who allegedly contacted Mr. Ayubu and the person who allegedly delivered the money were not named in the report. He stated that Mr. Ayubu had indicated that he sent someone with the money, but the report did not identify that person or indicate that Mr. Ayubu was in Tanzania at the material time. He confirmed that the hotel had an M-Pesa payment channel, a reception visitors’ book and CCTV cameras, but admitted that he did not check the visitors’ book or CCTV footage to establish whether the alleged person visited the Claimant.

46. RW1 further testified that the alleged forgery of the receipt was reported to the police, but admitted that the investigation report did not contain an OB number, the occurrence book has not been produced, and there was no forensic report demonstrating that the receipt was forged. He also admitted that he has no proof that the police investigation had progressed.

47. He confirmed that the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter concerning underperformance, but admitted that the allegation of issuing a fake receipt and theft was not included in that show cause letter. He further admitted that he has no minutes of a disciplinary hearing, no evidence that emails were deleted, no ICT expert to testify, and no server logs showing that emails were deleted.

48. RW1 also admitted that he has no evidence showing that Kshs. 102,200/= was paid into the Claimant’s M-Pesa or bank account. He stated that the Claimant’s name did not appear in the investigation report, although the names of two other persons under investigation appeared at page 20. He confirmed that the services of the other two persons were not terminated and that Michael Kimemia continued working for the Respondent as a General Manager at Samchi Telecoms.

49. On re-examination, RW1 stated that the investigation did not require ICT expertise apart from accessing the server. He confirmed that the Claimant has produced the show cause letters and maintained that the receipt for Kshs. 102,200/= allegedly issued to Mr. Ayubu was before the Court.

The Respondent’s Submissions

50. On substantive justification, the Respondent submits that it had valid and fair reasons to terminate the Claimant’s employment under Sections 43, 44 and 45 of the Employment Act.

51. It is its submission that investigations established that the Claimant received Kshs. 102,000/= directly from Mr. Ayubu of African Heritage Safaris, a client of the hotel, issued a fake receipt, failed to remit the money, concealed the transaction, moved the invoice from the debtors’ list to accounts receivable, and deleted email correspondence with the assistance of an IT officer.

52. The Respondent submits that the conduct amounted to gross misconduct under Section 44(4)(g) of the Employment Act and destroyed the trust necessary for continuation of the employment relationship.

53. The Respondent further submits that the investigations revealed procurement irregularities between 16th May, 2023 and 19th December, 2023, including local purchase orders made without approvals, hiking of prices, failure to raise requisitions through the required system, failure to involve Heads of Departments and use of external repair services without involving the company’s maintenance personnel.

54. It submits further that the Claimant, as General Manager, was responsible for ensuring compliance with the company’s procedures. It relied on the Claimant’s December 2023 Monthly Management Report, which allegedly recorded that cost hiking of materials by outside contractors was confirmed and the Claimant’s admission that methods were not always by the book.

55. On underperformance and absenteeism, it submits that the Claimant was issued with a show cause letter dated 26th June, 2024, setting out concerns relating to failure to achieve targets, ineffective team management, housekeeping challenges, lack of staff motivation and absenteeism.

56. The Respondent argued that the Claimant’s response dated 28th June, 2024, was unsatisfactory and that his performance remained wanting despite opportunities to improve. It sought to rely on Kenfreight (E.A) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] KECA 409 (KLR) on poor performance as a valid ground for termination where deficiencies are demonstrated and an employee is given an opportunity to respond and improve.

57. It is the Respondent’s submission that it complied with Section 41 of the Employment Act by issuing show cause letters, giving the Claimant an opportunity to respond, considering his written explanations and conducting investigations before making the decision to terminate his employment.

58. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant’s dismissal was lawful and proportionate, having regard to the allegations of dishonesty, procurement irregularities, underperformance and absenteeism.

59. On the Counterclaim, the Respondent submitted that it has established on a balance of probabilities that the Claimant received Kshs. 102,000/= from the hotel’s client and failed to remit the amount to the Respondent.

60. The Respondent finally urges the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s claim with costs and enter judgment for the Respondent on the Counterclaim for Kshs. 102,000/= together with interest and costs.

Analysis and Determination

61. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced, and the rival submissions, the issues arising for determination are: -

i. Whether the Claimant’s termination from employment was substantively and procedurally fair.

ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.

iii. Whether the Respondent has proved its Counterclaim for Kshs.102,000/=.

Whether the Claimant’s termination from employment was substantively and procedurally fair

62. Termination of employment is deemed procedurally and substantively fair, where the employer adheres to the mandatory provisions of Sections 41, 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007. Under Section 43, an employer bears the burden of proving the reason for the termination, while Section 45 requires the employer to show that the reason was valid and fair and that the termination was carried out in accordance with fair procedure pursuant to Section 41 of the Act.

63. The Respondent herein relied on three principal grounds for the Claimant’s termination, namely, procurement irregularities, underperformance, and the alleged theft of Kshs.102,000/= through issuance of a fraudulent receipt.

64. On the procurement irregularities, the Claimant acknowledged that concerns relating to price hiking and double charging were brought to his attention as the entities’ General Manager. He also admitted that, as General Manager, he was responsible for ensuring compliance with the Respondent's operational procedures, and acknowledged that his December 2023 management report indicated that price hiking was confirmed, and that some operational methods were not always conducted by the book.

65. These admissions are relevant in assessing whether the Respondent had a reasonable basis for questioning the Claimant's performance and discharge of his managerial responsibilities. However, procurement irregularities alone do not establish that the Claimant personally engaged in fraud or dishonesty. The Respondent was required to demonstrate the Claimant's individual responsibility and the connection between the established irregularities and the decision to terminate his employment.

66. On underperformance, the Claimant acknowledged that a Kshs.12 million target was indeed discussed and that he did not achieve the target. He, however, maintained that he was not issued with performance indicators or a job description, and that he submitted a business improvement strategy in response to the Respondent's concerns.

67. The law recognizes poor performance as a potentially valid reason for termination, but an employer must demonstrate the shortcomings complained of, the standards against which performance was assessed and the measures taken to give the employee a reasonable opportunity to improve. Issuing a show-cause letter alone does not, in my view, establish underperformance.

68. In Machira v Mugo Waweru and Associates [2012] KEIC 1 (KLR), the court cited with approval the case of Kenya Science Research International Technical and Allied Workers Union (KSRITAWU) Vs Stanley Kinyanjui and Magnate Ventures Ltd (Industrial Court Cause No. 273 of 2010) for the holding that;

“The proper procedure once poor performance of an employee is noted is to point out the shortcomings to the employee and give the employee an opportunity to improve over a reasonable length of time. In our view 2-3 months would be reasonable.”

69. The Respondent was thus required to demonstrate not merely that the Claimant failed to meet its expectations, but that the alleged deficiencies were objectively established and that the Claimant was afforded a fair opportunity to address them.

70. On the alleged receipt of Kshs.102,000/= from a hotel client and issuance of a fraudulent receipt, the Respondent's investigator admitted that there was no evidence showing that the money was paid into the Claimant's M-Pesa or bank account. Further, the person allegedly sent to deliver the money was not identified, the visitors' book and CCTV footage were not examined, and no forensic report was produced in support of the allegation of forgery.

71. The court further notes that the investigation report did not contain the Claimant's statement, despite the investigator confirming that he had interviewed him. No evidence was also led on the alleged deletion of emails, including server logs.

72. These omissions, in my view, materially weaken the Respondent's assertion that the Claimant personally received and misappropriated the money. In Arthi Highway Developers Limited v West End Butchery Limited & 6 others [2015] KECA 816 (KLR), the Court of Appeal reiterated that allegations of fraud must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved to a standard higher than the ordinary balance of probabilities, though not beyond reasonable doubt. Similarly, in R.G. Patel v Lalji Makanji [1957] EA 314, the Court held that allegations of fraud require strict proof.

73. Although the present proceedings concern employment and the applicable standard under Section 43 is the employer's reasonable belief in the existence of a valid reason, the seriousness of an allegation of theft and forgery requires cogent evidential support. The Respondent's investigation, as presented before this Court, falls short of that requirement.

74. I therefore find that the Respondent did not sufficiently establish that the Claimant personally received the alleged Kshs.102,000/=, issued a fraudulent receipt or deleted company emails.

75. On whether the Respondent adhered to the tenets of fair process, Section 41 of the Employment Act requires an employer, before terminating employment on grounds of misconduct or poor performance, to explain to the employee the reasons for the contemplated termination and afford the employee an opportunity to make representations in the presence of another employee or shop floor union representative of his choice.

76. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Tanui [2019] KECA 489 (KLR), the Court of Appeal emphasized that Section 41 prescribes the minimum standards of procedural fairness, including notification of the allegations, an opportunity to respond and consideration of the employee's representations.

77. It is not disputed that the Claimant was issued with show cause letters dated 10th February, 2024 and 26th June, 2024, and that he responded to both letters. He asserted that he was subsequently required to prepare a business improvement strategy, which he submitted on 18th July, 2024.

78. It is evident from the court record that the termination letter dated 1st August, 2024 also relied on the allegations that the Claimant received money from a client and that he issued a fake receipt. The court record further shows that these allegations were not in either of the show cause letters.

79. Further, RW1 expressly admitted that the allegations of theft and issuance of a fake receipt were not included in the show cause letters and that he had no minutes of a disciplinary hearing.

80. The Respondent cannot rely on allegations that were introduced at the point of termination without first bringing them to the Claimant's attention and allowing him an opportunity to respond. Further, the fact that the Claimant responded to the earlier allegations of procurement irregularities and underperformance did not dispense with the obligation to notify him of the separate and substantially more serious allegations of theft and forgery.

81. I therefore find and hold that the Respondent violated Section 41 of the Employment Act by relying on allegations of theft and forgery that were not put to the Claimant before termination.

82. Further, although the Claimant was given an opportunity to respond to the performance-related concerns, the Respondent did not demonstrate that it undertook a fair and objective assessment of his performance or afforded him a properly structured opportunity to improve before termination.

83. The submission of a business improvement strategy on 18th July, 2024, followed by termination barely two weeks later, without evidence of an evaluation of the proposed measures, raises further doubt as to whether the Respondent genuinely considered the Claimant's explanations.

84. In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Claimant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally unfair.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought

85. Having found that the Claimant’s termination from service was unfair, I now proceed to consider the individual remedies sought.

(a) Salary for July, 2024

86. The Claimant sought payment of his July 2024 salary. The employment relationship subsisted until 1st August, 2024, and the Respondent has not demonstrated that the salary for July 2024 was paid.

87. Under Section 18(4) of the Employment Act, an employer is required to pay an employee all remuneration earned up to the date of termination.

88. I therefore find that the Claimant is entitled to Kshs.150,000/= being salary for July 2024.

(b) One month's salary in lieu of notice

89. The Claimant's employment was summarily terminated on 1st August, 2024. Having found that the termination was unfair, and there being no demonstrated justification for withholding notice pay, the Claimant is entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice in accordance with Section 36 of the Employment Act, and the terms of his employment contract.

90. I thus award him Kshs.150,000/= under this head.

(c) Unutilized leave days.

91. Section 28 of the Employment Act provides for annual leave of not less than 21 working days with full pay after every 12 consecutive months of service.

92. The Claimant produced a leave application form dated 5th March, 2024, indicating an outstanding leave balance of 11 days. The Respondent did not sufficiently demonstrate that the outstanding leave was subsequently taken or paid for. It further did not controvert the amount payable for the 11 days.

93. I therefore find that the Claimant is entitled to payment for the accrued and unutilized leave days in the sum of Kshs.80,000/= .

(d) Compensation for unfair termination

94. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act empowers the Court to award compensation not exceeding 12 months' gross wages for unfair termination.

95. In determining the appropriate compensation, the Court is guided by the considerations under Section 49(4), including the employee's length of service, the circumstances surrounding the termination, the employee's reasonable expectation of continued employment and the opportunities available to the employee to secure comparable employment.

96. In Kenfreight (E.A) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] KECA 409 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the statutory framework governing remedies for unfair termination.

97. The Claimant served the Respondent from April 2023 until August 2024, a period of approximately 16 months. The court further notes that the Respondent raised legitimate operational and performance concerns against the Claimant. Balancing these considerations, I find an award of four (4) months' gross salary sufficient compensation for the unfair termination.

98. Accordingly, I award the Claimant Kshs.600,000/= as compensation for the unfair termination.

(e) General damages for violation of constitutional rights

99. The Claimant seeks additional general damages for the alleged violation of Articles 41 and 50 of the Constitution. Article 41 guarantees fair labour practices, while Article 50 principally guarantees the right to a fair hearing before a court or, where appropriate, an independent and impartial tribunal or body.

100. Sections 41 and 45 of the Employment Act give effect to the right to fair labour practices in the employment relationship. Having already found that the Respondent's conduct amounted to unfair termination and awarded compensation under Section 49 of the Employment Act, I will not make a further award of general damages for the same employment related wrong without proof of a distinct constitutional violation and resulting injury.

101. The claim is thus declined.

(f) Certificate of service

102. Under Section 51 of the Employment Act, an employer is obligated to issue a certificate of service upon termination of an employee's employment.

103. The Respondent is therefore directed to issue the Claimant with a certificate of service within 14 days of this judgment.

Whether the Respondent has proved its Counterclaim for Kshs.102,000/=

104. The Respondent counterclaimed for Kshs.102,000/=, alleging that the Claimant received the money directly from its client, Mr. Ayubu, issued a fraudulent receipt and failed to remit the money to the hotel.

105. The burden of proving the Counterclaim rests with the Respondent under Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act.

106. Although the Respondent engaged a private investigator, the evidence presented was materially deficient. The investigator admitted that he had no evidence demonstrating that the money was paid into the Claimant's account or that the Claimant personally received it. The person said to have delivered the money was also not identified, and neither was the CCTV footage nor the visitors' register examined.

107. Further, no forensic evidence was produced to establish that the receipt presented was forged. Similarly, the investigation report did not contain the Claimant's statement, and no evidence demonstrated that the alleged emails were deleted.

108. It is also significant that RW1 admitted that the Claimant's name did not appear in the investigation report, notwithstanding the serious allegations made against him.

109. I therefore conclude that the Respondent has not produced sufficiently cogent evidence linking the Claimant to the alleged receipt, collection or misappropriation of the money.

110. The Counterclaim for Kshs.102,000/= is consequently dismissed.

111. I accordingly enter judgment for the Claimant against the Respondent in the following terms: -

a) A declaration that the termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair and unlawful.

b) That the Respondent shall pay the Claimant: -

i. Kshs.150,000/= being unpaid salary for July 2024.

ii. Kshs.150,000/= being one month's salary in lieu of notice.

iii. Kshs.80,000/= being payment for accrued and unutilized leave days.

iv. Kshs.600,000/= being compensation equivalent to four months' gross salary for the unfair termination.

c) An order directing the Respondent to issue the Claimant with a certificate of service within 14 days of this Judgment.

d) The Respondent's Counterclaim is dismissed with no orders on costs.

e) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit.

f) Interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Kibiku present for the Claimant

Ms. Njeru h/b for Mr. Gicheha for the Respondent

Ms. Esther - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder