Background
The parties to the action had an employment relationship which the Respondent terminated on 6th February 2025 or thereabouts. The Claimant has instituted this case to challenge the legality of the aforesaid decision.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The parties to the action had an employment relationship which the Respondent terminated on 6th February 2025 or thereabouts. The Claimant has instituted this case to challenge the legality of the aforesaid decision.
Paragraph 1 →Having regard to the principle articulated in the aforesaid case law, I am reluctant to expunge the report in question from the court record on account of the alleged confidentiality clause. That said, I acknowledge the legitimacy of the Respondent’s contention that minors should be protected from undue exposure including through judicial proceedings. As such, whilst I decline the request to expunge the impugned report from the court…
Paragraph 35 →Having regard to the foregoing, the court is convinced that the contract between the parties had more connection to Kenya than the United States of America. As such, the Kenyan law and courts are best suited to adjudicate on disputes arising therefrom. Based on this, I find that this court has jurisdiction over the instant dispute.
Paragraph 29 →Whether the Employment and Labour Relations Court had jurisdiction over an employment dispute arising from an international assignment; whether the Child Abuse Investigation Report-2024 should be struck out or redacted for confidentiality and protection of a…
Thomas John Tauras challenged the Respondent’s termination of his employment on or about 6 February 2025. The Respondent maintained that the employment contract was concluded in the United States, identified the Claimant’s home country as the United States,…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO E1012 OF 2025
THOMAS JOHN TAURAS….…………………...….……...…... CLAIMANT
VERSUS
CHURCH WORLD SERVICE AFRICA.........................….... RESPONDENT
RULING
Background
1. The parties to the action had an employment relationship which the Respondent terminated on 6th February 2025 or thereabouts. The Claimant has instituted this case to challenge the legality of the aforesaid decision.
2. Upon being served with the Statement of Claim, the Respondent entered appearance in the cause and filed the application dated 24th November 2025 seeking the following orders: -
a) Spent.
b) Spent.
c) Spent.
d) That the confidential and sensitive exhibits attached to the Statement of Claim specifically the Child Abuse Investigation Report-2024 and the internal procurement evaluation documents marked as exhibits 4,5,6,8 and 9 be struck out, expunged from the court record or heavily redacted to protect the identity of the minor named therein and the Respondent’s confidential commercial data and trade secrets.
e) That the court determines whether it has jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
f) Spent.
g) That the Statement of Claim dated 9th October 2025 be struck out for want of jurisdiction.
h) That costs of the application be provided for.
3. The application is based on the grounds appearing on the face thereof. It is also supported by the affidavit and supplementary affidavit of one Jacqueline Burns.
4. The Respondent asserts that the employment contract between the parties was concluded in the United States of America. It further contends that the contract specifically acknowledged the Claimant’s home country as the United States of America with Kenya only recognized as the host country.
5. The Respondent asserts that the contract described the Claimant’s engagement as an international assignment. It further contends that it (the contract) specifically required the Claimant to waive his right to claim benefits under the contract based on local laws.
6. In the premises the Respondent avers that the applicable law to the dispute between the parties is the law of the United States of America. As such, it contends that Kenyan courts have no jurisdiction over the suit and that this case was improperly filed before this court and should be struck out.
7. The Respondent further contends that the Claimant has presented to court a confidential report which discloses information on a minor. It contends that such disclosure violates the privacy of the minor. As such, it prays that the report should either be expunged from the court record or redacted to protect the minor.
8. The Respondent also alleges that the Claimant has exhibited procurement records which are confidential in nature. It avers that this disclosure is likely to injure its trade secrets. Consequently, it prays that the aforesaid records should be expunged from the court record.
9. The Claimant has opposed the application. He contends that although the Respondent signed the contract between the parties in the United States of America, he signed the contract in Kenya where he was residing and working even before he joined the Respondent.
10. The Claimant further states that the contract between the parties was performed in Kenya where the Respondent has a permanent office. He also contends that the purported breach of the contract allegedly occurred in Kenya. As such, he contends that all the witnesses to the alleged breach are resident in Kenya.
11. The Claimant further contends that the contract between them neither provides that the applicable law would be the law of the United States of America nor ousts the application of Kenyan law to disputes arising therefrom. In the premises, he contends that Kenyan law is the most appropriate law to be applied to resolve the dispute between them.
12. The Claimant further states that the Respondent, in any event, unconditionally entered appearance to the cause thus waiving any objections to the court’s jurisdiction to entertain the dispute. As such, he contends that the instant objection to the court’s jurisdiction is misguided.
13. The Claimant contends that he lawfully obtained the Child Abuse Investigation Report which the Respondent seeks to expunge from the record. As such, he asserts that the report is no longer confidential as asserted by the defense.
14. The Claimant further asserts that the report evinces attempts by the Respondent to cover up an illegality relating to sexual abuse of a minor. He contends that his resistance to these attempts is the reason why the Respondent terminated his services. As such, he contends that the report is relevant to the action and should not be expunged as this will only aid the Respondent to conceal its improper actions.
15. The Claimant avers that the procurement data which the Respondent asks the court to expunge from the court record is not confidential in nature. He further contends that the information does not contain the Respondent’s trade secrets to warrant its exclusion from the court record on this account.
Analysis
16. The legal position is that parties to a contract which is concluded or is intended to be performed across different jurisdictions enjoy the freedom of choosing the law which will be applied to resolve disputes which may arise from the contract. Equally, they enjoy the freedom of choosing the sit or venue for resolution of such disputes.
17. Where the parties have chosen the law that will apply to the contract and the venue where they will resolve disputes arising from the contract, the court is obligated to give meaning to this election. As such, it (the court) will not impose on them a law or venue for dispute resolution which they did not agree on.
18. However, where the parties have not agreed on the applicable law or venue for dispute resolution, the court is dutybound to address these two issues in order to determine whether to assume jurisdiction over a dispute arising from the contract. The parameters which the court should consider whilst discharging this function are now well settled.
19. In the case of Wainaina v IPAS [2018] KEELRC 2065 (KLR), the court, whilst speaking to the matter, stated as follows: -
‘’The parties herein though entering into an international contract of employment did not expressly provide for the Court which would have jurisdiction in case of conflict or on allegations of breach of contract.
In such an instant, there are factors a Court ought to consider before assuming jurisdiction. These connecting or dominant factors equally apply (overlap) when assigning choice of law where there was no express or tacit agreement and they include locus contractus, locus solutionis, domicile and nationality of the parties (see Forsyth, Private International Law, third edition, page 288).
The Court is expected to weigh up these features in a qualitative rather than quantitative basis. The Court should also have regard to whether any judgment it renders would be effective and capable of being enforced.’’
20. Speaking to the same issue in the case of Kamurasi v Absa Bank Kenya PLC & another [2023] KEELRC 3229 (KLR), the court stated as follows: -
‘’Ordinarily, disputes stemming from implementation of a contract should be resolved using the law of the State in which the contract was made (lex loci contractus). This is because at the time of contracting, the parties are presumed to have intended that the laws of the State in which the contract was made will be applied to resolve any disputes that may arise during its implementation.
However, it is also possible that parties to a contract that is entered into in one jurisdiction may intend that it (the contract) be performed in another jurisdiction. In such case, they may elect the law of the State in which the contract is to be performed as the law that will be applied to resolve disputes that may arise from the contract (lex loci solutionis).
In some instances, the court may consider an individual’s nationality in deciding the law that is to be applied to resolve a civil dispute that involves him irrespective of his current residence (lex patriae). This is of particular importance in instances that involve personal law disputes such as divorce and inheritance.
Yet, the court may also consider one’s domicile in deciding the choice of law to resolve an inter-jurisdictional civil dispute that is before it (lex domicilii). An individual’s domicile must be his permanent domicile. It is acquired by birth, choice or operation of law.
The above principles are of importance when parties to an inter-jurisdictional contract have not chosen the forum and law for resolution of disputes that may arise from it. Where the parties have chosen the law and forum for resolution of the disputes, the court will give primacy to their choice (Dorcas Kemunto Wainaina v IPAS [2018] eKLR).’’
21. The Respondent contends that the employment contract between the parties provides that the law which is applicable to it (the contract) is the law of the United States of America. As such, it (the Respondent) urges the court to find that it has no jurisdiction over the case.
22. The court has perused the contract and it is apparent that it does not speak to the law which is to be applied to it or the venue for resolution of any dispute that may arise therefrom. The parties to the contract neither agreed on the law nor the forum for adjudication of any disputes that may arise from the contract. As such, the Respondent’s contention that the contract provides for the applicable law as the law of the United States of America is incorrect.
23. The foresaid being the case, the court has to determine whether it should assume jurisdiction over the instant dispute. In doing so, the court has to apply the principles alluded to above.
24. Although the Respondent alleges that the contract was executed in the United States of America, the Claimant asserts that he executed it (the contract) in Kenya. As such, there is no agreement regarding whether the contract was executed wholly in the United States of America or partially in Kenya.
25. That notwithstanding, the contract shows that the Respondent engaged the Claimant as its Regional Representative, Nairobi, Kenya. As a matter of fact, the Claimant has stated under oath that he was attached to and executed his duties at the Respondent’s Nairobi office in Kenya. The Respondent did not controvert this contention either in its supplementary affidavit or otherwise. As such, the court is convinced that the contract between the parties was principally performed in Kenya.
26. The Claimant has stated under oath that the contract was allegedly breached in Kenya. He further states that the procurement process which led to the decision to terminate his services was undertaken in Kenya. Therefore, he contends that the witnesses that are likely to be called over the dispute are in Kenya. The Respondent has equally not controverted these assertions under oath.
27. Importantly, the contract stipulates that the Claimant’s host country was to be Kenya. This is an acknowledgement that the Claimant was to be hosted in Kenya for purposes of performing his duties under the contract. This further fortifies the reality that the contract was performed in Kenya.
28. The contract also stipulated that the Claimant was to abide by and be bound by the laws of the host country (Kenya). This can only be understood to imply that his dealings in the country, including his employment, were subject to the laws of the host country.
29. Having regard to the foregoing, the court is convinced that the contract between the parties had more connection to Kenya than the United States of America. As such, the Kenyan law and courts are best suited to adjudicate on disputes arising therefrom. Based on this, I find that this court has jurisdiction over the instant dispute.
30. Resolving a similar objection in the case of Kamurasi v Absa Bank Kenya PLC & another (supra), the court observed as follows: -
‘’As indicated earlier, the Claimant contends that although the purported contract was allegedly entered into in Uganda, he was posted to Nairobi Kenya to render services under it. Therefore, the locus solutionis for the contract was Kenya.
Applying the lex loci solutionis principle, I arrive at the conclusion that I have jurisdiction to adjudicate on the dispute between the two parties (Claimant and 2nd Respondent) for the reasons that: the alleged contract was performed in Kenya; the alleged breach happened in Kenya; and the Claimant was resident in Kenya at the time that the cause of action allegedly arose. Thus, the most suitable law for addressing the dispute between the two parties (Claimant and 2nd Respondent) is the law of Kenya. As well, the most suitable forum for adjudicating over the purported dispute is Kenya.’’
31. The Respondent contends that because the contract describes the Claimant’s engagement as an international assignment, this court should decline jurisdiction over it. With respect, I do not agree. The aforesaid description of the Claimant’s engagement is not one of the elements which the court is to consider whilst deciding the law to be applied to cross jurisdictional contracts.
32. The Respondent has also objected to placement on record of the Child Abuse Investigation Report-2024 in its raw form on two grounds namely: that the report is confidential; and that the report relates to a minor whose privacy should be protected.
33. Regarding whether the report should be rejected on the ground of confidentiality, case law suggests that a party to litigation is not entitled to wave the confidentiality shield in order to prevent disclosure of information which is meant to prove commission of an illegal or criminal act. Speaking to this in the case of Jacobs v KwaZulu-Natal Treasury (DA7/20) [2021] ZALAC 50; [2022] 3 BLLR 269 (LAC); (2022) 43 ILJ 1286 (LAC) (9 December 2021), the South African Labour Appeal court stated as follows: -
‘’It is, also, my view that an employer may not invoke a confidential agreement to conceal wrong doings in the workplace and an employee who has signed a confidentiality agreement does not require the permission of his or her employer to reveal wrongdoings in the workplace if required to do so in legal proceedings. If permission is to be obtained first, any dishonest conduct will never see the light of day.’’
34. In the instant case, I understand the Claimant to be stating that the impugned report discloses sexual abuse of a minor which he resisted resulting in the Respondent’s decision to terminate his services. He contends that the report lays bare the motivation for the decision to illegally terminate his services.
35. Having regard to the principle articulated in the aforesaid case law, I am reluctant to expunge the report in question from the court record on account of the alleged confidentiality clause. That said, I acknowledge the legitimacy of the Respondent’s contention that minors should be protected from undue exposure including through judicial proceedings. As such, whilst I decline the request to expunge the impugned report from the court record, I direct the Claimant to redact the minor’s and the minor’s parents’ names from the report within 21 days of this order.
36. The Respondent has also sought for the expunging of the procurement data belonging to it from the court file on the ground that the data is confidential and contains its (the Respondent’s) trade secrets. However, it (the Respondent) has not presented cogent evidence to demonstrate that the data in question is either confidential or contains trade secrets.
37. But even if it were to be demonstrated that the impugned data was accessed in violation of a confidentiality obligation imposed on the Claimant, the court will not exclude the information from the record unless the Respondent demonstrates that its introduction in evidence will prejudice the fairness of the trial process or will be detrimental to the administration of justice (see Njenga v Dib Bank Kenya Limited [2023] KEELRC 1549 (KLR)). The affidavit evidence which the Respondent has placed on record does not cogently speak to this requirement. That being the case, the court rejects the request to strike out the aforesaid procurement data.
Conclusion
38. After evaluating the affidavit evidence against the applicable law, the court makes the following findings and attendant orders: -
a) The court finds that it has jurisdiction to entertain the instant suit.
b) As such, it declines the request to strike out the case for want of jurisdiction.
c) The court declines to strike out the Child Abuse Investigation Report on account of the report being confidential.
d) However, it directs the Claimant to redact the minor’s and the minor’s parents’ names from the report within 21 days of this order.
e) The court declines to expunge the procurement data from the court file on account of the said data comprising the Respondent’s trade secrets.
f) Costs of the application dated 24th November 2025 to be in the cause.
Dated, signed and delivered on the 12th day of November, 2026
B. O. M. MANANI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
……………. for the Claimant
……………. for the Respondent
ORDER
In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.
B. O. M MANANI