Employment law

Opetu v Benforce Security Services Ltd [2026] KEELRC 15059 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 405 of 2018
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Claimant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th November, 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 148 and 787 of the Companies Act (Act No. 17 of 2015), Sections 1A, lB, 3A and 34 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap 21 Laws of Kenya, and Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2020, where the Applicant seeks orders that: -

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the premise, I find it premature to impose personal liability on the Respondent’s directors before their examination has been undertaken.

Paragraph 46 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 405 OF 2018

 

WILLIAM LAURENCE OPETU..............................................CLAIMANT

VERSUS

BENFORCE SECURITY SERVICES LTD……………………..RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Claimant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th November, 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 148 and 787 of the Companies Act (Act No. 17 of 2015), Sections 1A, lB, 3A and 34 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap 21 Laws of Kenya, and Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2020, where the Applicant seeks orders that: -

i. THAT Anne Claire Khaimia and Benard Absalom Sanya being the Directors of BENFORCE SECURITY LIMITED the Judgment Debtor herein be examined personally as to the assets and finances of the BENFORCE SECURITY LIMITED.

ii. THAT upon such examination, the veil of incorporation of the Respondent be lifted and the Directors Anne Claire Khaimia and Benard Absalom Sanya be made personally liable and be ordered to settle the decretal sum Kshs.142,751.30 with interest thereof from 14th day of February, 2025 jointly and severally until payment in full, now totaling to: -

a) Decretal amount as at 14th February 2025…………....Kshs. 142,751.30

b) Costs of suit taxed at……………………...Ksh.67,375.00

c) Add accrued interest from 14/02/2025 to 24/11/2025 being Kshs. 142,751,312x12/100x9 months & (10) days…………………………..……..Kshs.13,320,097.00

Total Outstanding Amount………………....….…..Kshs.223,446.397.00

iii. THAT the said directors Anne Claire Khaimia and Benard Absalom Sanya do immediately settle the said decretal sum of Kshs.142,751.30 with interest thereof from 14th day of February, 2025.

iv. THAT in default of the said directors complying with the above orders, they be imprisoned and committed to civil jail for a period not exceeding six (6) months and their personal assets be attached to settle the outstanding decretal amount

v. THAT costs of the Application be provided.

2. The application is supported by grounds on the face thereof and the affidavit sworn by William Laurence Opetu, the Claimant/Applicant, on 24th November, 2025.

3. The Applicant avers that judgment was delivered in this matter on 14th February, 2025 in its favour for Kshs.142,751.30/=, together with costs and interest, and that despite service of the decree, the Respondent has failed or refused to settle the decretal amount.

4. The Applicant therefore seeks to have the Respondent’s Directors, Anne Claire Khairnia and Benard Absalom Sanya, summoned to attend court for examination on the Respondent’s assets and means of satisfying the decree.

5. It further urges the Court to lift the corporate veil and hold the Directors personally liable, alleging that they are concealing the company’s offices, assets and resources to evade execution of the decree.

6. The Respondent opposed the motion vide a Replying affidavit sworn by Bernard Absalom Sanya on 22nd January, 2026.

7. The Respondent’s Director denies knowledge of an entity known as Benforece Security Limited, as cited in the application, asserting that he operates a separate legal entity known as Benforce Security Services Limited. Further, without prejudice to that objection, he contends that even if the application relates to his company, it is misconceived, premature, legally untenable and an abuse of the court process, and should be dismissed with costs.

8. The Respondent contends that it was never served with the pleadings, hearing notices or any court process leading to the hearing and entry of the impugned judgment. It asserts that it did not participate in the proceedings and was thereby prejudiced and denied its constitutional right to a fair hearing under Article 50 of the Constitution.

9. It further maintains that no proper affidavit of service has been produced to demonstrate that service was effected before the hearing and delivery of the judgment.

10. The Respondent contends that, in the absence of proper service, the judgment and all consequential proceedings, including the present application, are irregular and unsustainable. It further argues that the Applicant has prematurely sought to summon its Directors for examination without first demonstrating that lawful execution proceedings against the company have been undertaken and exhausted.

11. It maintains that the examination of Directors is not intended to be punitive or coercive, nor a fishing expedition, but must be preceded by strict compliance with the prescribed execution procedures and due process.

12. The Respondent further contends that the Applicant has not demonstrated that warrants of attachment and sale were issued and returned unsatisfied, or that the company wilfully refused to settle the decretal sum despite notice and an opportunity to do so.

13. It argues that no legal or factual basis has been established for lifting the corporate veil or summoning its Directors personally, as the company is a separate legal entity and no fraud, misrepresentation or improper conduct has been pleaded or proved.

14. The Respondent challenges the application for targeting Directors of an entity whose correct legal identity, service and liability have not been established. It maintains that the issues of non-service and denial of a fair hearing must first be addressed and reserves the right to seek the setting aside of the judgment and consequential orders.

15. It therefore finally urges the Court to dismiss the application with costs.

16. In a further affidavit sworn by NAMADA SIMONI, counsel for the Applicant on 7th June, 2026, the Applicant/Claimant contends that the Judgment Debtor was correctly identified throughout the proceedings as Benforce Security Services Limited, and that the different name appearing in the application dated 24th November, 2025, was merely a typographical error. It asserts that the Claimant was employed by the Judgment Debtor from July 2015 until his unfair dismissal in November 2017.

17. The Applicant argues that following the failure by the Judgment Debtor to honour a demand for payment of terminal dues, the Claimant instituted the suit on 21st March, 2018, and the Summons and the Memorandum of Claim dated 7th March, 2018, were subsequently served upon the Judgment Debtor at its business premises at Jampark Plaza, Ngong Road, Nairobi, on 30th April, 2018.

18. The Applicant states that the Judgment Debtor was repeatedly served with mention notices for hearings scheduled on 10th December, 2018 and 26th March, 2019, but failed to attend court. He avers that, on 30th May, 2019, the Court directed that summons be reissued and served afresh, and that the fresh summons and Memorandum of Claim were served on the Judgment Debtor on 30th August, 2019 and received by its Director, Mr. Benerd Sanya.

19. The Applicant further states that its advocates came on record for the Decree Holder on 20th June, 2023, following the filing of a Notice of Change of Advocates dated 8th June, 2023.

20. The Applicant states that, following the Court’s directions of 28th January, 2020, it requested fresh summons on 23rd June 2023, which were issued on 25th July, 2023 and served upon the Judgment Debtor on 11th October, 2025. He states that the matter was subsequently scheduled for hearing on 10th November, 2023, but did not proceed due to the Judgment Debtor’s non-attendance.

21. The Applicant further avers the Judgment Debtor was also served with subsequent mention and hearing notices, including for the pre-trial mention of 29th November, 2023 and the hearing scheduled for 2nd July, 2024, which were again received by its Director, Mr. Benerd. He states that on 2nd July, 2024, the suit was dismissed for non-attendance, but was subsequently reinstated upon an oral application by the Claimant’s counsel. The Applicant further states that notice of the next hearing date was served upon the Judgment Debtor on 7th August, 2024.

22. The Applicant states that, on 30th October, 2024, the matter proceeded as an undefended cause after the Judgment Debtor failed to enter appearance or file a defence despite repeated service of court documents, and that Judgment was subsequently delivered in favour of the Claimant on 14th February, 2025, following which execution commenced.

23. The Applicant maintains that the Judgment Debtor was aware of the proceedings from their inception and that its Director’s claim of having learnt of the suit only upon encountering the application to lift the corporate veil is false and intended to frustrate execution. He contends that summons and pleadings were duly served at the Judgment Debtor’s established business premises and personally received by its Director, Mr. Bernard Absalom.

24. The Applicant therefore maintains that the judgment was regularly obtained and that the allegations of non-service are unfounded.

25. The Applicant contends that litigation must come to an end and that the Judgment Debtor, having deliberately ignored court proceedings, should not be rewarded with discretionary relief. It maintains that the Judgment Debtor was indolent and undeserving of the orders sought.

26. The Applicant therefore urges the Court to allow its application dated 24th November, 2025 as prayed, with costs.

27. Parties’ submissions have been duly considered.

Analysis and Determination.

28. I have considered the application, the affidavits filed in support and opposition thereto, and the rival submissions. The issues arising for determination are: -

i. Whether the application is properly brought against the named Judgment Debtor and whether the judgment was regularly obtained.

ii. Whether the Directors of the Judgment Debtor should be examined.

iii. Whether the circumstances justify lifting the corporate veil and holding the Directors personally liable for the decretal sum.

iv. Whether the Applicant is entitled to the other consequential orders sought.

Whether the application is properly brought against the named Judgment Debtor and whether the judgment was regularly obtained

29. On the identity of the Respondent, the Claimant/Applicant has clarified in his further affidavit that the Judgment Debtor was correctly identified throughout the proceedings as Benforce Security Services Limited, and that the different name appearing in the application dated 24th November, 2025, was merely a typographical error.

30. This fact is evident from the court record, and it is therefore clear to the court that the Judgment debtor/Respondent herein is properly identified.

31. On whether the judgment was regularly obtained, the Respondent herein disputes service of summons and the subsequent court processes, alleging that it was denied an opportunity to be heard.

32. The Applicant, on the other hand, has given a chronological account of the proceedings and produced affidavits of service which it contends demonstrate that the Judgment Debtor was repeatedly served at its business premises, and that some of the documents were personally received by its Director, Bernard Absalom Sanya.

33. The Applicant has further produced affidavits of service relating to the initial summons, the fresh summons and the subsequent hearing notices in respect of the suit herein. Of particular significance is the assertion that the Judgment Debtor's Director, Bernard Absalom Sanya, personally received the fresh summons and the Memorandum of Claim on 30th August, 2019. The Applicant has also referred to subsequent service of hearing and mention notices, some of which were again said to have been received by the same Director.

34. From the Applicant's account of service, together with the subsequent hearing notices said to have been received by the Judgment Debtor's Director, the Respondent cannot challenge the regularity of the judgment merely by asserting that it was unaware of the suit. It is indeed evident that it was aware of the proceedings from the inception.

35. Moreover, the Respondent retained the right to challenge the judgment through an appropriate application, and cannot do so under the present execution proceedings, and I thus find his position devoid of merit.

Whether the Directors of the Judgment Debtor should be examined

36. Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that where a decree is for payment of money, the decree-holder may apply for an order that the judgment-debtor, an officer of a corporate judgment-debtor or any other person be orally examined concerning debts owed to the judgment-debtor and the property or means available to satisfy the decree. In Wakhungu v Milembe Investment Plc & Another (Commercial Appeal E344 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 8746 (KLR), the High Court affirmed that examination under Order 22 Rule 35 is intended to facilitate post judgment discovery and is investigative rather than punitive. The Court held that directors may properly be summoned to disclose the company's assets, liabilities and means of satisfying a decree. It further emphasized that examination should ordinarily precede a determination on whether the corporate veil should be lifted.

37. The Respondent's argument that warrants of attachment and sale must first be issued and returned unsatisfied before its Directors can be examined is not supported by the wording of Order 22 Rule 35. The provision does not expressly prescribe exhaustion of all other execution methods as a precondition. What is necessary is an existing money decree which remains unsatisfied and a proper basis for seeking information concerning the judgment-debtor's assets and means.

38. The Applicant herein has demonstrated that judgment was entered against the Respondent for Kshs.142,751.30, together with costs and interest, and that the decretal amount remains unpaid, while the Respondent has not demonstrated that it has settled the decree or disclosed any concrete arrangement for doing so.

39. I therefore find merit in the prayer for examination of the Judgment Debtor/Respondent’s Directors under Order 22 Rule 35.

Whether the circumstances justify lifting the corporate veil and holding the Directors personally liable for the decretal sum

40. The next question is whether the Directors should, at this stage, be made personally liable for the decretal sum.

41. The starting point is the principle of separate corporate personality established in Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 and recognized under Section 19 of the Companies Act, 2015. Upon incorporation, a company becomes a body corporate distinct from its members and directors.

42. The Court of Appeal reaffirmed this principle in Riccatti Business College of East Africa Limited v Kyanzavi Farmers Company Limited [2016] KECA 763 (KLR), observing that lifting the corporate veil is an exceptional jurisdiction which must be exercised only where special circumstances justify disregarding the company's separate legal personality.

43. In Victor Mabachi & another v Nurtun Bates Limited [2013] KECA 204 (KLR), the Court of Appeal similarly upheld the principle that directors and shareholders are not ordinarily liable for the obligations of a company merely by reason of their positions within it, and that personal liability must be founded on an established legal basis.

44. Guided by the foregoing precedents, the mere fact that a company has failed to satisfy a decree, is financially distressed or has proved difficult to trace for purposes of execution does not justify lifting its corporate veil. Evidence must connect the directors to fraudulent or improper conduct, or show that the corporate structure is being abused to defeat legitimate legal obligations.

45. The Applicant herein contends that the Directors have concealed the company's offices, assets and resources to frustrate execution. However, no specific evidence has been presented demonstrating that the Directors transferred, diverted or appropriated the company's assets for their personal benefit, or deliberately used the corporate structure to defeat the decree.

46. In the premise, I find it premature to impose personal liability on the Respondent’s directors before their examination has been undertaken.

47. Accordingly, I make the following orders: -

a) That the prayer for examination of the Directors, Anne Claire Khaimia and Benard Absalom Sanya, is allowed.

b) That the said Directors shall attend Court for examination concerning the Judgment Debtor's assets, liabilities, bank accounts, and other means of satisfying the decree herein.

c) That the prayer for lifting the corporate veil and imposing personal liability upon the Directors is declined.

d) The prayers for attachment of the Directors' personal assets and their committal to civil jail are declined.

e) I make no orders on costs.

48. Orders of the Court.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Mwanyambu h/b for Mr. Namada for the Claimant/Applicant

N/A for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S - C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder